Toffoloni v. LFP Publishing Group, LLC

Filing 211

Second MOTION to Amend 187 Pretrial Order by LFP Publishing Group, LLC. (Bauer, S.)

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF GEORGIA
MAUREEN TOFFOLONI,
as Administrator and Personal
Representative of the ESTATE
OF NANCY E. BENOIT,

)
)
)
)
)
Plaintiff,
)
)
vs.
)
)
LFP PUBLISHING GROUP, LLC, )
d/b/a Hustler Magazine.
)
)
Defendant.
)

CASE NO. 1:08-cv-00421-TWT

SECOND MOTION TO AMEND THE PRETRIAL ORDER
Defendant LFP Publishing Group, LLC hereby moves to amend the Pretrial
Order [D.I. 187] to withdraw one exhibit, and identify three additional exhibits
LFP may use at trial.
An updated schedule of exhibits Defendant may use at trial is submitted
herewith. Copies of each identified exhibit have been delivered to Plaintiff.
Defendant hereby withdraws its former Exhibit 16 (Composite Otten Ex. 9).
Defendant also seeks to supplement its exhibit list with the following
materials:
1

33.

Transcript of February 8, 2008 Hearing on Plaintiff’s Motion for
Temporary Restraining Order Before Hon. Thomas W. Thrash;

34.

January 25, 2008 Letter from Paul J. Cambria, Jr. to Richard Decker;

35.

January 29, 2008 Letter from Richard Decker to Paul J. Cambria, Jr.;

36.

January 30, 2008 Letter from Paul J. Cambria, Jr. to Richard Decker.

Plaintiff is aware of and has had copies of each of these exhibits since at
least February 2008, and will not be prejudiced by their late addition to
Defendant’s exhibit list.
A proposed Order is submitted herewith for the Court’s convenience.
WHEREFORE, Defendant prays that this Court inquire into and sustain this
motion, and enter an Order amending the pretrial order, D.I. 187, to reflect the
changes to Defendant’s anticipated exhibit list as described above and attached
hereto at Exhibit A.

2

Respectfully submitted this 31st day of May 2011.

/s/ S. Derek Bauer
James C. Rawls
Georgia Bar No. 596050
Barry J. Armstrong
Georgia Bar No. 022055
S. Derek Bauer
Georgia Bar No. 042537
Darrell J. Solomon
Georgia Bar No. 305922
McKENNA LONG & ALDRIDGE LLP
303 Peachtree Street, NE, Suite 5300
Atlanta, Georgia 30308
[phone]
[phone] (facsimile)
Pro hac vice:
Paul J. Cambria, Jr.
Jeffrey Reina
William M. Feigenbaum
LIPSITZ GREEN SCIME CAMBRIA
LLP
42 Delaware Avenue, Suite 120
Buffalo, New York 14202-3924
[phone]
[phone] (facsimile)
Attorneys for LFP Publishing Group,
LLC
3

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
This is to certify that I have this day filed the within and foregoing
SECOND MOTION TO AMEND PRETRIAL ORDER via the CM/ECF system
which will automatically send notification to Plaintiff’s attorneys of record, who
are participants in the CM/ECF system.
This 31st day of May 2011.
/s/ S. Derek Bauer
S. Derek Bauer

4

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF GEORGIA
MAUREEN TOFFOLONI,
as Administrator and Personal
Representative of the ESTATE
OF NANCY E. BENOIT,

)
)
)
)
)
Plaintiff,
)
)
vs.
)
)
LFP PUBLISHING GROUP, LLC, )
d/b/a Hustler Magazine.
)
)
Defendant.
)

CASE NO. 1:08-cv-00421-TWT

ORDER
Before the court is Defendant’s Second Motion to Amend the Pretrial Order.
Upon consideration of Defendant’s motion, the Court grants the motion and
ORDERS that the Pretrial Order [D.I. 187] is hereby amended to reflect the
changes to Defendant’s exhibit list described in Attachment A hereto.
So ORDERED this

day of ____ 2011.

Hon. Thomas W. Thrash, Jr.
United States District Judge
5

ATTACHMENT A
Defendant’s list of documentary and physical evidence
1

03/2006

Hustler Magazine, March 2006 (cover and article excerpt
only)

2

12/2007

Hustler Magazine, Holiday 2007 (cover and article excerpt only)
(LFP 0016)

3

01/2008

Hustler Magazine, January 2008 (cover and article excerpt only)
(LFP 0017)

4

03/2008

Hustler Magazine, March 2008 (cover and article excerpt only)
(LFP 0019)

5

Representative Entertainment Media Exhibit

6

10/03/08

Dismissal Order Issued by Hon. Thomas W. Thrash, Docket
Index 13

7

03/2008

LFP Content and Pagination Report (LFP 134)

8

03/2008

LFP Internal Compliance Report (LFP 0035)

9

03/2008

LFP March 2008 Geographic Circulation Analysis

10

05/1983

Sports Review Wrestling, May 1983 (Otten Ex. 2)

11

Photo of Nancy Benoit used on the cover of The Grapevine
(Otten Ex. 3)

12

Advertisement featuring Fallen Angel photographs (Otten Ex. 5)

13

“Fallen Angel” photographs (Otten Ex. 6)

14

Edited Advertisement featuring Fallen Angel photographs
(Otten Ex. 7)
6

15

Nancy Benoit photographs taken from the Internet (Otten Ex. 8)

16

07/11/07

Email from Mark Samansky to LFP (LFP 0073 - 0074)

17

01/22/96

Independent Contractor Agreement between Nancy Benoit and
World Championship Wrestling, Inc. (UWC 005 - 016)

18

01/16/08

Letter from Richard P. Decker to LFP Internet Group, LFP
Video Group, and LFP Publishing Group

19

Sales figures (LFP 0099)

20

Operating Statement (LFP 0105)

21

Operating Statement (LFP 0106)

22

Operating Statement (LFP 0107)

23

Operating Statement (LFP 0108)

24

Operating Statement (LFP 0109)

25

Operating Statement (LFP 0110)

26

Operating Statement (LFP 0111)

27

Operating Statement (LFP 0112)

28

Balance Sheets (2006-2009) (LFP 0133)

29

Certified copy of the opinion and judgment in Toffoloni v. LFP
Publishing Group, LLC, 572 F.3d 1201 (11th Cir. 2009)

30

03/29/11

Letter from Donna Hahner to Maureen Toffoloni

31

04/01/11

Letter from Richard Decker to Donna Hahner with enclosures

32

05/20/11

Issue of Entertainment Weekly magazine
7

33

02/08/08

Transcript of February 8, 2008 Hearing on Plaintiff’s Motion for
Temporary Restraining Order Before Hon. Thomas W. Thrash

34

01/25/08

Letter from Paul J. Cambria, Jr. to Richard P. Decker

35

01/29/08

Letter from Richard P. Decker to Paul J. Cambria, Jr.

36

01/30/08

Letter from Paul J. Cambria, Jr. to Richard P. Decker

ATLANTA:5307901.1

8