Bingham v. Owens et al

Filing 96

ORDER granting 73 Motion for Summary Judgment; adopting 92 Report and Recommendations. Final judgment shall be entered in favor of the defendants and this civil action closed. Signed by Judge Dudley H. Bowen on 1/4/13. (cmr)

O IGINAL
R
DISrRICr.ou*tu.S.
srArEs
rN LrNrrED
rHE
o,&h\FProu*,

illv
oF
FoRTHEsourHERNDT'TRICT GEoRGIA Aiiili-i:liA

-q
t0uJAll P ] q-l

DUBLIN DIVISION

CLERI{

RANDALL BINGHAM.
Plaintiff,

1
cv 31 -019
JOSEMORALES, et al.,
Defendants.

ORDER

After a careful, de novo review of the frle, the Court concurswith the Magistrate
to
havebeenfiled (doc.no. 94). On
Judge'sReportand Recommendation, which objections
recommended Defendants'motion summary
November30,2012,the Magistrate
Judge
that
for
judgment concerning Plaintiffs claims of deliberate indifference related to the prison
barbershopand laundry seruicebe granted,and that this casebe closed. (Seedoc. no. 92.)
to
Plaintiff devotes majority of his objections asserling inconectly that he is entitledto
the
judgment that he not be required to shaveusing barbershop
a declaratory
equipment,and
otherwisesimply restates claimsthat the MagistrateJudgehasalreadyaddressed raises
the
or
new claims that arenot relatedto the instantcase. (Seeeenerallvid.) Critically, he doesnot
that warants a deviationfrom the MagistrateJudge's
offer any new informationor evidence
recommendation.
Thus,Plaintiff s objectionsareOVERRULED. Accordingly,the Report
of
and Recommendation the MagistrateJudgeis ADOPTED as the opinion of the Court.

judgment is GRANTED (doc. no. 73), a final
Therefore,Defendants'motion for summary
and
iudsment shall be ENTERED in favor of Defendants, this civil action is CLOSED.

,/*)

b4-

2ol 3 ,

"Lttq
SO ORDERED this /ryd:ay of feeemben4*2.

at Aug

DISTRICT
JUDG