Harrell et al v. Harrell et al

Filing 14

ORDER DISMISSING APPEAL/CASE. This case is closed. Signed by Judge Dudley H. Bowen on 1/13/15. (cmr)

'L!
.5

r Ir_. Li
t_

'tr- ' : l S J , i
' ' !l;iict-c0uR
lV.

IN TITE IJNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE
SoUTHERN DTSTRXCT OF GEORGTA
28]5iAll13
DT'BIIN DIVISION

P

:,LLi{

IN RE:

l r l Y r l T J aG I

SARALAND, LLLP,
*

Rr

n lz r,,^t

.-!r

N^

1)

30113

-

Debtor.

Trustee
TODD BOUDREAUX,
Saral-and, LLLP,

for

cv 314-131
Plaintiff,
Number in
Court:13-03005)

/ A.'lrra r c 2 r\/
F..nLrrrhf.\,

LISTER HARRELL; NIKKI HARREII
a/k/ a NIKKT MINCEY d,/b,/a
ANd
PLANTATIONMANAGEMENT;
]NC. ,
PLANTATIONMANAGEMENT,
Defendant s .

ORDER

nn

W.

nFr-e'rhpr

nf

^ ,V
g i_, L ^ -E r r

dismissal

LErl

of

Harrell

had

"Motion

for

1

20,1A.

morjon

Harrell's

artn/.linl-manf

wcr>

q

in
rL v
.\

na!/
puj

to

Extension

The motions
dated
December 7,
December IA, 20L4.

of

in

f ha

fil-ed

Time. "1

thc

Annpl

r-\z enna:l

r au y J i- ! L u r o r i
- crr

f i

.receipt

of

a

t'Motion

to

qir.r'a

and

Faa

rhis

€ilinn
-hc

for

u:rrgll
ar

f 2ra

Order,

Produce"

(Doc. No. 7,)

rpr-e ir.pr-l

T.r cter

Mr

l i nn

to

are contained in a
2014.
The Clerk

I ant

pauperis

forma

hankrrrnf

Prior

be

rienr ad

Corrrt

fhjs

c h e a p p e a - l.
caused

s

proceed

Lo

r-ortnqel
^d
u ^ \y, --

fhi

and a

Obviously,

r . r hi n r r
f i 1 inr

Mr.

ig
9n

Mr.

had not

Harrell

had the

these motions.;

fi-Iinq

of

benefit

Court/ s Order prior

the

Answer and Amend Nolice

to

"Motions

six

of

and Continue, "

to

to

v.ii.-s

Answer and Amend

l-o Sl-tv anrl Fo- Eneroen.\/ Tnirrnction

Adrrersa rv

Proceed jnoq-//

to Object

to Compensation & Proceed I!'P."

The
Iil

iners/rnfions

..r'rt
lvu!

anneAls

ir

in

nrcac

iha

Mr.

i h

- q y n j - e + iv o n
e a

whether

hi <

nf

l-hc

Lhat

should
.^,
vvu

^f

?
J /\

his

r

fnr

e

iaa

' FL ,

r-!rt-

!

n^f

1n

nt-<

rrnr--ont-

Mr

lL U
-^

on-Ly one
clel jneate

H:rrel

in

I

or

farma

eaolze

on how ro

.]^-i^^-l-^
uerr9rraL

r^16,,-^l

nattnari

e

fnrm<

-^-.
--^^^6Ai
PruLccuflr9D.

h:hlzr,'^t--..
PLLy

/ \
1/

"communjcations" invo-Iving the r.rusLees and the bankruptcy
filed
and unfiled
court;
5) aff
" c o m m u n i c a ti o n s " f r o m M r .
the
bankruptcy
court;
Harrel,l
to
and 6)
alf
evidence
crrnnnrl-inn

Harrelf
Lr-

l-he

h-enkrrrnrnrr

.'.\rrrl-

seeks an extension

-6^^-r

(Doc. No. 7.)

in-r'--ri...]

fhp

'c

nr,,larc

of time to
f:itrrro

>nrl

nrnaoor'li

correct

i-.r

n:ir

nn<

Mr

the defects
r-ho

lng

rhla

Court

this

instructions

?)
^f

i c

bOth.

h .
r r^ut wr

:nna.al.

r r n d a r l r r* ,
- --- '

rho

r-learlV

in

2n1 A

I)

alia,

havc heen

may contain

chorrlrl

ho

filinos
,and

^r..1-

recent

cases and discrict

a^rrrt

be made either

i
, l n
r - n l U, r. u iq r-r i Y

lL ' r : u ,e' . .u ! r p
n J ri

s

filings

and

Da.aml'rar

inter

rannr.t

i nne'

l- hi
'Thi

nrrml'rar

of,
: Ir /eu
u ^ n Ia - a l r

in

a/-\rrrl-

Fi li nn

h J
r ,ira

flrai

r-:epc

R^nkrrr^F^',

"production"

inct

rrhl-

r-:qa

fil-i-ng

I F...i qf ^tac

^-^.-^"tl,!vrcuuLs
n^.ti^h<

ei

'\Mn-j6n

:nrl

"

Harrefl's

ar.cnrdi n.rI '/- -ha

direcLed

and

the

Tn

ir^

is

Mr.

-^nl inn.

if<
l-.\

that

Amend aff

(Doc. No. 13.)

h,ankrrnj-.\/ court

R:nLrrrnir-\/

Harre-lf

/ q ra q a
v - v

rhe

rrn

notes

and to

r-^ rncF-

mrrl-inle

]isr

uvvuq

L

rlnnlzotaut

Ilnr

first

Court

Annoinr

t.\

to

to Answer and Amend

Motions

"M(r1i or
-

'tMotions

Appeals, "

"Motion

j-nclude

to

motions,

to Produce, " "Motion

Answer and Amend Motions
Extend

of a filing,

The Courr is also in receipt

dated December 1"3, 2014, which contains

to

fitinn

foa

of

the

has f.iled

Mr. Harrell
in

the

^^.r-+c
anlrr

^€

I imrrorl

h:c

urr!1,

i , , r Ii v v * .e lv ri v r. r i , , r
a
n

descr j.bed in
inr-reeeirrr

as

P.

order

in

r^i

t-.r-i

^h

Mr

nr,4ar

^ni

r

Office
ni

er-'i

Mr.

l.l.a

^F

hJ\ /
v

a^,,rt-

orders

nothing

1 r-h! F
v r

:I Far
u n/ n g u !'

rrnr'{or

28

I11

Undef

fhe

appeals
U.S,C.

With

and

R.

Fed.

q)

do but

q?

ll

of

Bankr.
A

final

Lit.igation

the

to

S

leave

S 158 (a) .

ends

courL

?d

11

orders
(3)

chat

tr

fr.m

inter-Iocutory

U.S.C.

the

rha

i <

ic

n;rrcina

c^^h

f ha

If

filing
prrlc

Eadar:l

fourteen
Mr.

Rrn

n^rhi

I'l

rra,er

on
j-ts

execute

Ith

r"ir

1gq?I

hrrr]<hi

CourL,
Ci

rrrri

he may not

I

R:nlzrrrbi-^rr

days of

HarreLl

_

a^rrrt

motion
pr^.adrrra

on

.\n

l-ha

^f

nzrl-

hc

- nor-gun
a-lprlrt

the United

appeal

ent.ry of

continues

n

i

r ^ ir I I

1.h:n

rrnrirro

al'Ahih

:nna:l

Cnrrrr

nn

an appropriate
nf

of

1rr1ni-.(,f

Bankruptcy

foreh?arned that
also

lAef

qie1- .c

i co

f n^t

musL do so within

8002

(2)

npri.,ls

"one

anncalq

Court

a-)^-^

S 158(a)

for

IIni l-F.l

nrrnr

rhd

without

RuIe

is

court

Uniced States

the

Harre-LI is

1

28 U.S.C,

are

this

courr/

of

: n f e r ' l o . r r ] 1o t - v
-

Frr'l tnn

r }n/ F ! r n!:Ln h
n vq !
q

of

timF

nr:nri

']'ho

issr

fha

See senerallv

ra

l].rrall'e

tolerated.
a^hal

i , -u- u ^ -ra r E - - L r ,
l 9 ' ^{ rt
J

however,

il_a,4\

anl- oro.ls

q}JFL

l

^-

l-rznee

S 158 (a) (1);

in

and leaves
T.

three

other

a bankruptcy

'/

ilr.]^nahr

a'l

& 8003.

merits

the

/31

described

8001{b)

€:

I I )

rFcjuai n/r

an.r

As a district

nrror

28 U,S.c.

nr

11r1 /,,1\'

.

j
a ^ J -r r f
uv
!.

cou.rt s ,

Federal

ir.ris6lj6li6n.

_l u!

Rai - , t^z! r , , n u F L U ^ , /
1! n
r\

court,

December 20L4.

of

month

court

13 appeals in this

an additional

e

States

Ahha.

l<

inter.Iocutory
for

leave

to

:n.'l

ha

Ann?

the

subject

orde.r,

the

current

path,

h.rl-

i ^,r1a

rl

IJqlLreufs!!

\7

r ^ r il - h . \ r r l -

f ha

but not

Now, in

sanctions

of

Lhe instant

d.ismiss Mr. Harrell's

-raLhe-ran incerlocutory
6iva

i-

-L>

t-^

^^+

fila

fiI^n

ltuL

'\.,rrFn-

to

he

this

Accordingly.

qhnrrl ri lre rrranrerl

...lAtArmininn

standard

-h^,.,
sll()w

t2\

nf

rl-,-r
LllclL

.\/F.

r yl fn i nr vi r r. ' n
v
lr

'
Harre]l'

l -h e

he

be levied,

i.r

filing

l- nf

'laa\.,4

m eutyr
-L.

-

R.

c
J

is
The

a

Bankr.

:eCOId

and

L

/'-haid^-

motion

foI

8003 (c) .

P.

Ieave

soughc

r o : n n o r-P c d
uv
al l

riII

thaL

whether

tha

tine.

has not

fnr

cli rect

Eed.

cf rcrdf

inn

Court

or judgment, buc

HarreI]

r-arrrr

nr

the

this

order

m^f

wi.Ll consider

r,rhather

forth

set

rli snretionarv
/--\rrrtc

d fi JcLt-r
u

^

f .r anncel

f ro'n a hankrrrn-r-\/

anne:ls
qIJyUgr'

m:rr

to

the

appeal

NOLice

OI

on November 79, 20L4,

Appeal filed
rh

if

filed,"

Court
on

Frran

lL-Lh o
ru

a

I c:\/e

anne:l

will

appeal,

appeal at

and Mr.

order';

r n nrc ' a lo t
qpl c

h^'.r^r,6r

-.\

r,rho-har
I oarre

<rrnh

ha

rvv,

Y

Order from which he appeals is not a fjnal

'I

toa

I i nrr

filing.

consideracion
to

constrained

ci

A

to the reEurn of any appellate

fimited

without

ro Mr. Harre]l

.f

and appropriate

deemedan abusive fi-Ier
including

n^\/manf

i/'\

..^rrrf .

in

28

/1\
\-L/

whir:h
mnnn

'.l'he

l q

i-h^

lln.lar

^r.lar

there
.c,r.rt e

fhc

€

1?q2

a

er.l

e.-rat

1292 (b) ,

from

distric!

Ban J<rupt cy
Order
s Motion to Extend n6..l

. hc

rnnarl

^n

, , - / 1 n l - r n l I iL f a t t r u
n

qrrhci-an1-rAl
l? )

,r:ound

'nrrcrl

iSte

appealed
r-^

rr|i

n..^-

nI ' r 1- - -a r-l - - - .-, --- ro r ,y

COUIT USeS Lhe SattLe

S

/h\

r

i nn:

distfiCt

U.S.C.

nraaFntc
pruJUrJLJ

iq

.li

Annealq

i-\te-l.\.uforv
annoa

.1r:nf

ih^

for

to

n:rt-\.

inn

the
hUSt

nf

difference

resof

rl lh h a u
Pvr r

governs

couTtS

d4 +F e L r
\ ri rJl

from
-^

which

ution

denies
I .
L

of

Mr.

1--.

of
Ehe

would materially

issue
'Ii'i.rrf

inn

rrurvuetvrr.

nisrri.l-

snarinolv-

(1996)

("Rourine

^r'\mnr-\/- wi -h

resort

rey.Fr11-ronal,

r:aqeq

courcs a firm

final

!^ret/ervrrq!

I yt vn r^ n
v
r

f ^

. ql !r r a r - n n s i . l c r a v

srandard for

1292{b)

requests

rFsFr\re

,rcner:l

l\r

i nf e-l

61-

woufd

ocuf

rpt-Airi-o

Il.S.

hard-Iy

ra\/ j Aw fol

o-v

for

74

fhe

fada;pL

rhe

ion -

Cnrrrr

e;g;gises

diScretion

its

leave to appeaf because he has nor mer the

a discretionary

ORDERED that

IS

S

the

b.nkr||nl-/-\r

q1g

l ewis-

of

judgment rule."),

and denies Mr. Harrell

IT

to

u'hi le

rz

lnn

terminatj-on

inf e-lo.rIorv

affow

ll:r

.Jesi.rn

C . rn o r e! <v c et
v
vvr y

uvrLLPv!

should

courts
a^f.rr:,i

annc,ils

uftimate

advance the

the

-interfocutory
appea.L be

appeal.

DISMISSED.

Accordingly,
The

Cl-erk

:-s

p e n d i n g m o t i o n s ATC DENIED AS

direcr-ed ro cLoSE the case, and aIl
MOOT.4
ORDER ENTERED
January,

-^^.-i\rsrrr-9_Le,

7| r, ^f
n L ,. ^ g,u D L a / r

crL

fhia

2015.

UN]TED STA

4
.Ar n y ua :r
yn q

I

On Decenber 19, 2AIA, Mr.
l-.\

tha
q

ftonamhar
faa

in^^

for

hr-

Mr

\

f-i rr-nif
.lirF.t
Tha

ina

N^iiao

order

/finn

Harre.l-f fifed

r-.\rrrt

nf

Anno.el

rhe
aF

nrvhanl-

Annor'l

q

Nl.rq

AnnnrAinnlrr

nnrino
hi

L

nf
e

.annaal
^f

rrrc

1n

in

.:nna:l

mntinn

f^

r^.'rrnsFl

ere

Fha

of
t-ha

f +lri n nr r r Y
!i
l-.',

and motion

this
ie

i n.r

rnnnmnrnian

BecaUSe

)

had not been entered
c

a Notice

q

forma pauperis

leave to appeaf in

Ll:rrollf

imnrnnar

h

^rAar
R

..\Inqc

nf

judgment or
^.\i

?n1A
l\l^

a motion
^nn.i

Ela\/anl-

ISTRICT JUDG

a

case at
^ramairrra

n r a n !a! a A
v ! s

in

Lo

f inal

that
rn^
far^a

l J !

nartr',a-i

c

an,,l

n".\f i,rn

i-.\

annninf

DENIED

AS

MOOT.