Boudreaux et al v. Harrell et al

Filing 4

ORDER DISMISSING APPEAL/CASE. This case is closed. Signed by Judge Dudley H. Bowen on 1/14/15. (cmr)

:iiiirif$AL

l:"r'--D
u . ' - . , r : ' ti l C i r j 0 U R ;

IN THE T'NITED STATES DISTRICT COT'RT FOR T H E
SOUTHERNDISTRICT Or. GEORGIA
Z0i5 itr
JAil
DT'BLIN DIVISION

]IY,

,:rtnr;$ffi

SARALAND, LLL P,

IN RE:

tr:n kr,-nt- r-\' Nl-'

1?-?n113

Debtor.

for

T O D D B O U D R E A U XT r u s t e e
,
Sar:aland, LLLP,

cv 314-L48
Plaintiff,
/A.i\Tarcrri/

Nlrrmhor

i n

B a n k r u p t c y C o ur L : I 3 * 0 3 0 0 5 )

vs.
LISTER HARRELL; N]KK] HARRELL
a,/ k,/a NIKKI MINCEY d,/b,/a
ANd
PLANTATIONMANAGEMENT,
INC. /
PLANTAT]ONMANAGEMENT,
Defendant s

ORDER

On December 3,2014,
^.
uI

^^^^-l
dppYdr

States

-la6

ih

, rrn ^ . a c - lr y - rrrrv
i
u r{lr r'

Mr. Lister
na

nracaodinn
I/!uLEEufrrv

l-hF

29,

Mr. Harre-l.l's

zv

t.)

t

nf

a noL-ice
t-ha

Ihe
--!
dtt\)

request

Notace

ot

*^^!*-1.^l
LlLrar
J\c!,4
P\,J

to

proceed in

AnnarI
h^^^mh^r

ic

The appeal

r^ralI -reasonecl

a.rrrt,q

Rankrltnr-.\r

2013). )

Recommendation of November 18, 2A!4,

'

fjled

rThi

ia-l

Bankruptcv Court.

No. 13-03005 (S.D. Ga. Apr.
F-nm

r u
q ^ rvr ro! rJcur!r.ryr

W. Harrell

is

taken

RFnnrf

a"]d

whlch reconrnends denial- of
forma pauperis.'

(Bankr,

r]rIo^
.and einnad
nn
lv.il,6mh6r
?7
^n1/1 .
ir
iq
fhcrpF/1rF
timal\/

1

n^-

Nl^

QA \

Thc

:nna:l

urifho'l-

canti

onad

rraf f ey

itc.nini.n

:c

oF

be

ranrriqira

rha

denied

in

fOrma

Doc. No. 99. )
3pa

fiIinrr

for

dismissed

CourL adopted the

and

(Bankr.

sLatus ro Mr. Harre.Il.
ne\/'r'enf

must

on December 9, 2014, this

Fcr-nnneni'lar i ^n

and

pauperis

f l^rs

FirsL,

two reasons.
pFn^ri

in

ih'ic

Thus,

^nr\o:

l

nrrst

be dlsmissed.
qannn.'l
^^

^ ri ^+-i

rrrnoc

nf

fodcral

^r

^^,,,1

rnno,al

e

frnm

rhe

intar'l^.irl-^r\r

l -l - U . S . C .
with

orders

R.enkrrrnf

l-eave of

fl^:f
the

encis the
to

court

A flnal

Ii-ioation
do but

as

a1l

(citation

^-A^r

an

Adams v.

United

f l^e
d:re:

nriqnn

^nfh-ri-iFs

faLhef

States,

\mailhnv

{"llnrler
ic
l-he

8002(c) (1)

hUL

nrienner
F^.

(effecLive

28

j-h.^

1339,

d:-p

r-lol i rrare
:
,r\.
mrir;-^

nf

court

Fulton,

for
111

Ihe Report and
is

not

.r.lar.

r ^ ' if h

nal-il-inn
nr
nrhar
e^^
]lSO
Fed.
R.

Dec. 1, 2074) .

S

is "one

a f inal^n.l

1341. (11ti Cir.
filinn

n
r v l rr lJ^

See qenerallv

fn re

appeals

(2)

U.S.C.

and Ieaves nofhino

inte.r-IO.r.j- .r\/

113 E.3d

rrrlF'

na
p s .r i

S '

interfocutory

in

om-iLLed).

Harrelf

i.-..1^-a--

timo

other

judgment. "

Recommendation from which Mr.
^v

tha

order in a bankruptcy

its

-irrdamanr.
- . ,. * : . . . - . . .

fin:l

described

on the meri!s

1 9 9 1)

ll\

i On OVe.r three

P. 8001(b) & 8003.

execute

E.3d 92, 93 (11'r' Cir.

i UriSdiCt
J

radrr rir j
- r u u u n r n |d

(3)

and

158(a) (3) and Eed. R. Bankr.
28 U.S.C. S 158(a).

n!
vr

court,

i rris,lir-tinn,

in 28 U.S.C. S 158(a) (1);

n !_L <
fi r rc r o :u ri fnr n y
r

S 1121(d) ;

hA:Js
II

.-r., r-^rrrl-.

as described

rnna:lc

inrted

COUTIS Of

t h i c C o r r r lL- oI rt l] r u
U ]

and decrees,

orders,

under

COUTtS aIe

rha

Mr.

1999)
,-.,rrrt

filina

ln

Bankr.

P.

has not

Harrell
moljon
.^rr-f
uvul

ma\/ "trF^f

oifher

crr

.rrarf

he

'_lpnrr

e.i

fror

-h^..!

+l-r+

(2\
\-/

n!
vf

/-

\

.\'/Fr

^..]Fr

ic

bankruptcy

federaf

r6v^6^r

L^vryLrv.raf

courts

llnnn

record

and

8004(d) .

P.

and

the

appeal
Notice

r

district

*..

/-.\nl-r^l

l r l r ln ig h ^

^ round

resorr

Congress'

;^-^r

/

final

r.ltry.r i ^h

Harrel,f

leave

hr,r^u > L
+
r
'

^
oF
I

-aw

reso_Lucion

of

Of
the

of the

interlocutory

Tnc. v.

Lewis,

519

(
to S 1.292 b) requests would

design

^-^^^

f he

difference

termination

Caterpillar

to

h-.t-.
Pdr Ly

^ , u^e .s L l o ^ r
i n
q, -

affow

Lhe

which governs

l
ri ^r^ 9

for

immadiat.e

uses

court's

dPPcdl

shoufd

courts

courc

S 1292(b),

f rnn

:a'

interlocucory

^isLrict

advance the ultimate

a firm

cl e .on<i

and denies Mr.

Bankr.

]eave

wherher feave to

lV\\

j-ha

sparingly.

hardLy comport with
^,., f^r

e

/?\

U.S. 61, 14 11996) ("Routine

-^,.i

12q)

crrhcf ^nt

^n.l

District
appeals

€

:

issue woufd materiallv
litigation.

28 U.S.C.

nraaanf

./^'rr.f q

i.r.,nd

in

|ndar

whi r-h l-hare

nninrnr

fof

to granL discretionary

r r . r - j -r . r - \ / a n n F a l s

c
J

+l"u
La^

\4/

a motion

thc

{ h^

forth

set

r l norl
unJ p u s r

vvv!

oF

however, che district

R.

consider

efrenfith

whether

r ' 1 i. r - - e l - i o n a - r z i n r F r l
c

^"

Fed.

a hankr'-^F^

same standard

.^l,rf

r

iI

rhc

on

In decermining
:nneals o

anna:l

a

on December 3, 2014.

of Appeaf fifed

evyEqr

n€

Even if

fi-Le such appeal.

noL f -iled,

Court will

this

Accordingly,

n.\1-i.o

tha

.lranj-

qLo'rld

to

leave co appeal is

for
:LLq]

L

leave

sought

to

reserve

^-allv

gsrrs!u

!r),

inrerlocucory

r e f u r arif n . i r d _ \ j
r eL
r
r

f.r

!J!

lL-_h e

judgment rufe.").
' laa ^^.1rl-

to

^-ercises

_its discretion

appeaf because he has not met

rhe srandard

for

- hi s

a- rearlv

c.rr-t

- L1r! v v.YrL.l r L
^
s1

it-s ^donfion

appeaf be DISMISSED.
pendlnq

and aff

affi

y

,

Lw

LJ

rrecl

-rrrrcr

rha

motions

oct,Lory appeal.

Renort

Arnnrdinnlrr

The Cl-erk is

ORDERENTEREDac
Qattua,L

inLerf

a discretionary

and

In fact,

Recommendation

I T I S O R D E R E DL h a t

directed

to CLOSE the

case,

are DENIED AS MOOT.
Augusta,

Georgia,

Lhe

this

.

UNITED STAT S D I S T R I C T J U