Khalidi, LLC v. The Paper Tigers, Inc.

Filing 4

ORDER directing the Defendant to file within 14 days from the date of this order an amended notice of removal. (Compliance due by 12/5/2017.) Signed by Judge William T. Moore, Jr on 11/21/17. (wwp)

IN

THE IJNITED STAIES DISTRICT
COURT EOR
THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF GEORGIA
SAVA}TNAH DIVISION

R A M S E Y H A L I D I, L L C , a G e o r g i a
K
i 1 1 r . r
L r m 1 L e o rl 1. a^o^r. _ r Ll y. ,

T I -.1 !^,.

/-^

LUmpany,

Plaintiff,

c A S E N O . C v4 7 1 - 2 3 4

V.

T H E P A P E RT I G E R S , I N C , a n
TlI

innic

U. S. DISTBICT
COUFT
South6rnDlstrlctot Ga,
Filsd in Otfice

a^r^^r.ii.\n

Defendant

ll

,,

_

ll l2r roll

ORDER
Before
1. )

However,

notice

of

rl'versil-

v

The
bears

lha

l . \ F j -w e e r

partv

invokino

S 1332;
LOB2
of

Bonner v. Citv
(en banc),
1981)
lL a
v

insufficient
i6c

Removaf.

contained

to

estabflsh

a^-^F.]in^lr/

days

removal that

AlAn-^r-ar

dcci
'

this

Court's

adequacely pLeading

Ray v.
(5ch

ci tizenship

t.In

n-e.F/ianj-

of

alfegations

fout'teen
of

Notice

in

(Doc.
the

complete

ra.^..1rht

from
l-ists

the
the

date

jS

of

thls

citizenship

of

s members.

8.2C, 1081,
diversity

Defendant's

^.rf

within

file

Lhe burden of

28 U.S.C.

^rr^-

are

an amended notice

Pfaintiff'

ts!!vr

is

jurisdictional

the

removal

DIRECTED to
order

Court

the

Bird

Cir.

r

upon

("The
Lhe

l , r r i c-r. l-i .n , - - l O n
.J-

c o m p - L e L ed i v e r s i t y .

Son Asset

Ig15)

is

r.{irr-rcirrr

Rea-Iizatj-on Co.,
burden

parEy

of

invoking

See
519

pleading
federal

of Pric ha{d , 66L 8.2d L206, 1-209 (11rh cir.
Circu it
the
El
th
adopted as bind ing
si_6n5
6f
thle f o r m e r F i f t h C i r c u i t
handed down
1987.

l
l
l

l
l
l

irrrrsrlict
n.arl- \/

ion.

a lsn

-irrriqdiar

anllinn

Grcanq

1020,

F.3d

the

MHp

h^s

srrff

citizenships

no member of
delendants
r

L }r

Tr

of

r

above,

/-^q6-

is

lhe

of
in

of

the ir
^-rr

i^-

noti6e

of

LLC.

the
the

rhis

r e m o v a - Lw i t n i n
members

SLate
StaLe

of

fou rteen
of

wiLh

is

to

is

Lheir

CO

insufficient

days from the

date

for

comp]ete

1082.
include

a list

cjtizenships,

of

states

that
under

pri nc;pa-1 place
1 ql 3.)

esLablish
file

ion thaL

and exisrinq

its

(Doc.

Ramsey

Court

J iabi IiLy

allegat

merel y

organized
wiLh

31 4

,

na+ hOCL

estdblishing

DInECTED to

Plaintiff

r'

IjmiLed

general

notice

ofl Ceorgia."

Ls noL sufficienl
Defendant

the

al

The

Georgja

r

nrnnar

removal does not

members, along

a

l-ist

Ray, 519 F.2d at

PAILIEJ.

tl^F

tLo

citizen

bu rden

lS

I

;

members of

Georgia

/ \ \ --r!.!' / \
\

un.l-linnc

^d

Furrhermore,' the
a

of

The E-leventh Circuit

a.l..lreeci

a Georgia Corporarjon

Accordingly,

afI

a-Il

t-h6

L:urrpdrry

S^u

2004).

Lhat

,its members are citizens.

COmCaSt

i n

E^r

'

/

l irr-h - ll il - "
- -i -y

c ri L - i z c -r s' D ri rn P
u jr
4 l h r

Ramsey Khalidi,

"Plajncifi

business

rL rtl'E
p

ih^

individual

laws

r,.-i -

pvnl

LLC is

hU t r r a a n
J o

PLainti if

the

Cir.

car ry

ro

1- is
h

Lhe

V,

of

an

'

which any of

(11th

j

//\

n r l 1v . !\ 4
v

I i m i l a -r -" -i

jn

Id_ aL IA22.

company."

rrirrorcif

:

L.P.

hee-

ir-icnrlv

.\f

rerrrer] -

rhal

nrnnerlrr

F 4

inn

102I-22

AnnFa's

a'lane

hrrrr]o*]

eve-ry staLe

of

ciLizen

is

c..lir:t ion

irrri

f ha

|''a:-s

rlir;oreitrr

nf

an,^l i'

af

As discussed

compLece diversiry.
an amended notice
of

Khaf j-di

this

order

LLC

and

of

Iisting
their

ni

+ -i z a n

All

ch i ne

other

deadlines

in

this

case

wiff

remain

rrnr-hrnnari

so oRDERED
"nr"rZ/!'o^

.'

^f

l\r^r/6ml^' av

1n1'l

W I L L ] A M T . M O O RT J R .
E
U N I T E D S T A T E SD I S T R ] C T C O U R T
SOUTHERN ISTRICT OF GEORGIA
D

' The Courl

wil I

not

accept

Ar.\r

e-ar.la...l
a^^r,.-

n.rr
l

r nc

-11^-^+.1

6f

removal

that

ny racfuaI
r
a-L egar ron
ni anoma:
I
contained
in
an ear]ier
fi ) ing , or
o f f e r s o n - ly :
amendment. Defendant's
amend d notice
e
of remova.l should be a
qi anc]-el nnc
f'1i^.r
tharind nendenfI rr r-nnra irs
the f actua.l
all
prr^ i- i^h<
:l l
n _ -q _
_A ..' o _q ; _ l r y
co
estabfish
diversity
between
the
i n--rn^r.atoa

h\/

3