Loggerhead Tools, LLC v. Sears Holdings Corporation

Filing 457

MOTION by Plaintiff Loggerhead Tools, LLC for judgment , Award of Prejudgment and Post-Judgment Interest and Costs, and Identification of the Applicable Schedule for LoggerHead's Motion for Attorney's Fees and Nontaxable Expenses (Attachments: # 1 Memorandum, # 2 Declaration of Christopher Bokhart, # 3 Exhibit A to Declaration of Christopher Bokhart, # 4 Trial Exhibit, # 5 Exhibit A - Proposed Order)(Skiermont, Paul)

Download PDF
LoggerHead Tools, LLC v. Sears Holdings Corp. and Apex Tool Group Case No. 12-cv-09033 DTX 130 Highly Confidential --Attorneys' Eyes Only exhibitsticker.com Produced in Native Format APEX0018943 #35358 Period 201208 201209 201209 201209 201209 201209 201209 201210 201210 201210 201211 201211 201211 SHIPDATE 8/22/2014 9/2/2012 9/2/2012 9/2/2012 9/9/2012 9/22/2012 9/23/2012 10/6/2012 10/14/2012 10/21/2012 10/28/2012 10/28/2012 11/6/2012 #35359 Period SHIPDATE 201208 201209 201209 201209 201209 201209 201209 201210 201210 201210 201211 201211 201211 8/22/2014 9/2/2012 9/2/2012 9/8/2012 9/9/2012 9/22/2012 9/23/2012 10/6/2012 10/14/2012 10/21/2012 10/28/2012 10/28/2012 11/6/2012 P.O UZ4308 UZ4308/10/11/12 UZ4308/10/11/12 UZ4308/10/11/12 UZ4308/10/11/12 UZ4308/10/11/12 UZ4308/10/11/12 UZ4308/10/11/12 UZ4308/10/11/12 UZ4308/10/11/12 UZ4308/10/11/12 UZ4308/10/11/12 703513 P.O UZ4308 UZ4308/10/11/12 UZ4308/10/11/12 UZ4308/10/11/12 UZ4308/10/11/12 UZ4308/10/11/12 UZ4308/10/11/12 UZ4308/10/11/12 UZ4308/10/11/12 UZ4308/10/11/12 UZ4308/10/11/12 UZ4308/10/11/12 703513 DESCRIPTION MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN CUST ITEM 35358 35358 35358 35358 35358 35358 35358 35358 35358 35358 35358 35358 35358 Q'TY UNTPRICE 10,836 $9.00 1,440 $9.00 6,576 $9.00 1,440 $9.00 7,992 $9.00 $9.00 4,176 4,176 $9.00 16,008 $9.00 6,000 $9.00 10,008 $9.00 6,024 $9.00 6,912 $9.00 360 $9.00 AMOUNT $97,524.00 $12,960.00 $59,184.00 $12,960.00 $71,928.00 $37,584.00 $37,584.00 $144,072.00 $54,000.00 $90,072.00 $54,216.00 $62,208.00 $3,240.00 DESCRIPTION MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN CUST ITEM 35359 35359 35359 35359 35359 35359 35359 35359 35359 35359 35359 35359 35359 Q'TY UNTPRICE 21,672 $10.00 26,688 $10.00 4,512 $10.00 4,512 $10.00 18,816 $10.00 13,344 $10.00 13,320 $10.00 50,016 $10.00 13,992 $10.00 36,024 $10.00 47,184 $10.00 25,008 $10.00 360 $10.00 AMOUNT $216,720.00 $266,880.00 $45,120.00 $45,120.00 $188,160.00 $133,440.00 $133,200.00 $500,160.00 $139,920.00 $360,240.00 $471,840.00 $250,080.00 $3,600.00 Chanel Sears Sears Sears Sears Sears Sears Sears Sears Sears Sears Sears Sears International Sears Sears Sears Sears Sears Sears Sears Sears Sears Sears Sears Sears International Jan Jan Jan Jan Feb Feb Feb Feb Mar Mar Mar Mar Apr Apr Apr Apr Units Shipped Jul May Jun May Extended Amount Jun Jul Aug Sept $97,524.00 $232,200.00 Units Shipped Jul Aug 10,836 Aug 21,672 Sept 25,800 Sept 81,192 Oct 32,016 Nov 13,296 Oct Nov $288,144.00 $119,664.00 May Jun Oct 100,032 Nov 72,552 May Extended Amount Jun Jul Aug Sept Oct Nov $216,720.00 $811,920.00 $1,000,320.00 $725,520.00 Dec Total Unit 81,948 Dec Total $$ $737,532.00 Dec Total Unit 275,448 Dec Total $$ $2,754,480.00 Channel Sears Sears Hometown International Total: Total Q'ty 81,588 0 360 81,948 Amount $734,292.00 Channel Sears Sears Hometown International Total: Total Q'ty Amount 275,088 $2,750,880.00 0 360 $3,600.00 275,448 $2,754,480.00 $3,240.00 $737,532.00 May 4,608 Units Shipped Jun Jul 744 Aug Mar Apr May $1,082.40 $69,057.12 $41,564.16 Extended Amount Jun Jul $6,710.88 Aug #35358 Period SHIPDATE P.O 201301 1/20/2013 TE0396 201303 2/26/2013 85288 201304 4/14/2013 TF5891/UZ5879 201304 4/20/2013 89166 201305 5/12/2013 TF6404 201307 6/30/2013 TF6790 201309 9/2/2013 UZ6791 201309 9/15/2013 UZ6794 201309 9/15/2013 UZ7425 201309 8/29/2014 UZ9932 201310 10/20/2013 UZ6797 201310 10/16/2013 104866 201310 10/25/2013 TF8626 ITEM SB35358 SB35358 SB35358 SB35358 SB35358 SB35358 SB35358 SB35358 SB35358 SB35359 SB35358 SB35358 SB35358 DESCRIPTION MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN CUST ITEM 35358 35358 35358 35358 35358 35358 35358 35358 35358 35359 35358 35358 35358 Q'TY 1,512 120 7,464 192 4,608 744 4,440 32,256 1,824 9,852 32,232 192 5,280 UNTPRICE $9.02 $9.02 $9.02 $9.02 $9.02 $9.02 $9.02 $9.02 $9.02 $9.02 $9.02 $9.02 $9.02 AMOUNT $13,638.24 $1,082.40 $67,325.28 $1,731.84 $41,564.16 $6,710.88 $40,048.80 $290,949.12 $16,452.48 $88,865.04 $290,732.64 $1,731.84 $47,625.60 Chanel Sears International Sears International Sears Sears Sears - Hometown Sears Sears Sears - Display Sears International Sears Jan 1,512 Feb Jan $13,638.24 Feb Mar 120 Apr 7,656 Sept 48,372 Oct 37,704 Nov Dec Total Unit 100,716 Sept Oct $436,315.44 $340,090.08 Nov Dec Total $$ $908,458.32 Channel Sears Sears Hometown International Total: Total Q'ty 95,772 4,440 504 100,716 Amount $863,863.44 $40,048.80 $4,546.08 $908,458.32 Channel Sears Sears Hometown International Kmart Ace Total Q'ty 254,024 1,896 696 15,696 23,016 295,328 Amount $2,545,320.48 $18,997.92 $6,877.92 $156,865.92 $230,620.32 $2,958,682.56 #35359 Period SHIPDATE P.O 201301 1/20/2013 TE0396 201303 2/26/2013 85288 201303 3/17/2013 B95ZV 201303 3/24/2013 VTDNA 201304 4/14/2013 TF5891/UZ5879 201304 4/20/2013 89166 201305 5/12/2013 B96A6 201305 5/12/2013 TF6404 201306 5/26/2013 TF6404 201306 6/10/2013 VTEF6 201307 6/30/2013 TF6790 201307 7/14/2013 VTET3 201308 8/4/2013 VTF50 201308 8/12/2013 WC9K5/WC9KM 201308 8/14/2013 WC9K5/WC9KM 201308 8/14/2013 101337 201309 9/2/2013 UZ6791 201309 9/2/2013 VTFEU 201309 9/15/2013 UZ6794 201309 9/15/2013 UZ7425 201309 8/29/2014 UZ6632 201309 8/29/2014 UZ8032 201310 10/20/2013 UZ6797 201310 10/5/2013 VTFSF 201312 108333 201312 VTGKD ITEM SB35359 SB35359 SB35359 SB35359 SB35359 SB35359 SB35359 SB35359 SB35359 SB35359 SB35359 SB35359 SB35359 SB35359 SB35359 SB35359 SB35359 SB35359 SB35359 SB35359 SB35359 SB35360 SB35359 SB35359 SB35359 SB35359 DESCRIPTION MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN CUST ITEM 35359 35359 35359 35359 35359 35359 35359 35359 35359 35359 35359 35359 35359 35359 35359 35359 35359 35359 35359 35359 35359 35360 35359 35359 35359 35359 Q'TY 4,008 120 2,160 792 7,752 192 504 6,240 6,216 816 2,712 816 4,992 9,240 13,776 192 1,896 2,400 96,816 13,200 19,704 5,600 91,776 2,400 192 816 UNTPRICE $10.02 $10.02 $10.02 $10.02 $10.02 $10.02 $10.02 $10.02 $10.02 $10.02 $10.02 $10.02 $10.02 $10.02 $10.02 $10.02 $10.02 $10.02 $10.02 $10.02 $10.02 $10.02 $10.02 $10.02 $9.52 $9.52 AMOUNT Chanel Sears International Kmart Kmart Sears International Kmart Sears Sears Kmart Sears Kmart Kmart Ace-Direct Ace-Direct International Sears - Hometown Kmart Sears Sears Sears - Display Sears - Display Sears kmart $1,827.84 International $7,768.32 kmart $40,160.16 $1,202.40 $21,643.20 $7,935.84 $77,675.04 $1,923.84 $5,050.08 $62,524.80 $62,284.32 $8,176.32 $27,174.24 $8,176.32 $50,019.84 $92,584.80 $138,035.52 $1,923.84 $18,997.92 $24,048.00 $970,096.32 $132,264.00 $197,434.08 $56,112.00 $919,595.52 $24,048.00 Jan 4,008 Feb Jan $40,160.16 Feb Mar 3,072 Apr 7,944 May 6,744 Units Shipped Jun Jul 7,032 3,528 Aug 28,200 Sept 139,616 Oct 94,176 Extended Amount Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sept Oct $30,781.44 $79,598.88 $67,574.88 $70,460.64 $35,350.56 $282,564.00 $1,398,952.32 $943,643.52 Nov Nov Dec 1,008 Total Unit 295,328 Dec Total $$ $9,596.16 $2,958,682.56 May Units Shipped Jun Jul 192 Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec Total Unit 384 May Extended Amount Jun Jul $1,645.44 Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec Total $$ $3,290.88 #35358 SHIPDATE P.O DESCRIPTION 201404 4/24/2014 00121560 MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN 201407 6/28/2014 00131451 MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN CUST ITEM 35358 35359 Q'TY 192 192 UNTPRICE $8.57 $8.57 AMOUNT Chanel Jan Feb Mar Jan Period Feb Mar $1,645.44 International $1,645.44 International Apr 192 Apr $1,645.44 #35359 Period SHIPDATE P.O 201403 3/23/2014 F82CV 201403 3/24/2014 F82CV 201404 41735 VTHPF 201404 41753 00121560 201406 41793 VTJ8P 201407 41821 VTJNZ 201407 41835 VTJWH 201409 41877 UZ2512 201409 41891 VTKLG 201409 41905 VTKTH 201411 41940 UZ2872 201411 41949 VTL1J 201412 41979 VTLLG DESCRIPTION CUST ITEM MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WRENCH 8 MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WRENCH 8 MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WRENCH 8 MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WRENCH 8 MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WRENCH 8 MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WRENCH 8 MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WRENCH 8 MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WRENCH 8 MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WRENCH 8 35359 35359 35359 35359 35359 35359 35359 35359 35359 35359 35359 35359 35359 Q'TY 1,800 1,200 600 192 600 600 600 1032 1608 2016 216 3000 408 UNTPRICE $9.52 $9.52 9.52 9.52 9.52 9.52 9.52 9.75 9.75 9.75 9.75 9.75 9.75 AMOUNT $17,136.00 $11,424.00 $5,712.00 $1,827.84 $5,712.00 $5,712.00 $5,712.00 $10,062.00 $15,678.00 $19,656.00 $2,106.00 $29,250.00 $3,978.00 Chanel Ace-direct Ace-direct Kmart International kmart kmart kmart ACE KMART KMART ACE KMART KMART Jan Feb Jan Feb Mar 3,000 Apr 792 Mar Apr $28,560.00 $7,539.84 May May Units Shipped Jun Jul 600 1,200 Extended Amount Jun Jul $5,712.00 $11,424.00 Aug Aug Sept 4,656 Sept $45,396.00 Oct Oct Nov 3,216 Dec 408 Total Unit 13,872 Nov Dec Total $$ $31,356.00 $3,978.00 $133,965.84 Channel Sears Sears Hometown International Kmart Ace Total: Total Q'ty Channel Sears Sears Hometown International Kmart Ace Total: Total Q'ty 384 384 Amount $1,645.44 $1,645.44 Amount 192 $1,827.84 9432 $91,410.00 4,248 $40,728.00 13,872 $133,965.84 Jan Feb Mar 408 Apr May Units Shipped Jun Jul Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec Total Unit 408 Jan Feb Mar $3,582.24 Apr May Extended Amount Jun Jul Aug Sept Oct Nov Dec Total $$ $3,582.24 #35358 Period SHIPDATE P.O DESCRIPTION CUST ITEM 201503 2/26/2015 1570-35-15MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WRENCH 6 35358 Q'TY 408 UNTPRICE $8.78 AMOUNT Chanel $3,582.24 OSH May Units Shipped Jun Jul Aug Sept Oct 312 May Extended Amount Jun Jul Aug Sept Oct #35359 Period 201501 201501 201502 201503 201511 SHIPDATE 1/15/2015 1/18/2015 2/15/2015 2/26/2015 10/28/2015 P.O DESCRIPTION B0W77 MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN UZ4058 MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN VTMRW MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WREN 1570-35-15MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WRENCH 8 VTQP1 MAX AXESS ADJUSTABLE WRENCH 8 CUST ITEM 35359 35359 35359 35359 35359 Q'TY 720 240 600 408 312 UNTPRICE $9.75 $9.75 $9.75 $9.75 $ $9.26 AMOUNT $7,020.00 $2,340.00 $5,850.00 3,978.00 $2,889.12 Chanel KMART Sears-IND KMART OSH KMART Jan 960 Feb 600 Jan Feb $7,020.00 $8,190.00 Mar 408 Mar $3,978.00 Apr Apr Nov Nov $2,889.12 Dec Total Unit 2,280 Dec Total $$ $22,077.12 Channel Sears Sears Hometown International Kmart Ace OSH Total: Total Q'ty Channel Sears Sears Hometown International Kmart Ace OSH Total: Total Q'ty 408 408 1632 240 408 2,280 Amount $3,582.24 $3,582.24 Amount $15,759.12 $2,340.00 $3,978.00 $22,077.12 Summary 2012 6 Inch Max Axess Locking Wrench 8 Inch Max Axess Locking Wrench PTS $9.00 $10.00 Margin Total Shipped 46.89% 81,948 48.00% 275,448 Total Cost $391,711.44 $1,432,329.60 Total PTS Margin $$ $737,532.00 $345,820.56 $1,322,150.40 $2,754,480.00 $1,667,970.96 6 Inch Max Axess Locking Wrench 8 Inch Max Axess Locking Wrench 8 Inch Max Axess Locking Wrench Cost $4.68 $5.10 $5.10 PTS $9.02 $10.02 $9.52 Margin Total Shipped 48.12% 100,716 49.10% 294,320 46.43% 1,008 Total Cost $471,350.88 $1,501,032.00 $5,140.80 Total PTS Margin $$ $908,458.32 $437,107.44 $2,949,086.40 $1,448,054.40 $9,596.16 $4,455.36 $1,889,617.20 6 Inch Max Axess Locking Wrench 8 Inch Max Axess Locking Wrench 8 Inch Max Axess Locking Wrench 35358 35359 Cost $4.78 $5.20 Cost $4.68 $5.10 $5.10 PTS $8.57 $9.52 $9.75 Margin Total Shipped 45.39% 384 46.43% 5,592 47.69% 8,280 Total Cost $1,797.12 $28,519.20 $42,228.00 6 Inch Max Axess Locking Wrench 8 Inch Max Axess Locking Wrench 8 Inch Max Axess Locking Wrench Cost $4.68 $5.10 $5.10 PTS $8.78 $9.75 $9.26 Margin Total Shipped 46.70% 408 47.69% 1,968 44.92% 312 Total Cost $1,909.44 $10,036.80 $1,591.20 Total PTS Margin $$ $3,290.88 $1,493.76 $53,235.84 $24,716.64 $80,730.00 $38,502.00 $64,712.40 Total PTS Margin $$ $3,582.24 $1,672.80 $19,188.00 $9,151.20 $2,889.12 $1,297.92 $12,121.92 Total Shipped 183,456 586,928 Total Cost $866,768.88 $3,020,877.60 2013 35358 35359 35359 2014 35358 35359 35359 2015 35358 35359 35359 2012 - 2015 Oct 35358 35359 6 Inch Max Axess Locking Wrench 8 Inch Max Axess Locking Wrench 2012 35358 Channel Sears Sears Hometown International OSH Total: Total Q'ty 81,588 0 360 81,948 2013 Amount $734,292.00 $3,240.00 $737,532.00 2012 35359 Channel Sears Sears Hometown International Kmart Ace OSH Total: Total Q'ty Amount 275,088 $2,750,880.00 0 360 $3,600.00 275,448 $2,754,480.00 Total Q'ty 95,772 4,440 504 100,716 Amount $863,863.44 $40,048.80 $4,546.08 $908,458.32 2014 Total Q'ty 295,328 $2,958,682.56 2015 Amount 384 384 2013 Total Q'ty Amount 254,024 $2,545,320.48 1,896 $18,997.92 696 $6,877.92 15,696 $156,865.92 23,016 $230,620.32 Total PTS Margin $$ $1,652,863.44 $786,094.56 $5,869,205.52 $2,848,327.92 $3,634,422.48 Total Q'ty $3,290.88 $3,290.88 $408.00 $408.00 2014 Total Q'ty 2012 - 2015 Oct Amount Grand Total Unit Grand Total $$ 177,360 $1,598,155.44 4,440 $40,048.80 1,248 $11,076.96 $3,582.24 408 $3,582.24 $3,582.24 183,456 $1,652,863.44 2015 Amount 192 9,432 4,248 $1,827.84 $91,410.00 $40,728.00 13,872 $133,965.84 Total Q'ty 1,632 240 408 2,280 Amount $15,759.12 $2,340.00 $3,978.00 $22,077.12 2012 - 2015 Oct Grand Total Unit Grand Total $$ 529,112 $5,296,200.48 1,896 $18,997.92 1,248 $12,305.76 26,760 $264,035.04 $273,688.32 27,504 408 $3,978.00 586,928 5,869,205.5

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?