Craft et al v. Health Care Service Corporation

Filing 186

MEMORANDUM Opinion and Order signed by the Honorable Virginia M. Kendall on 10/26/2018. Plaintiffs' Motion to Modify Administration of Settlement 175 is granted. The Settlement Administrator shall have 45 days from the date of this Order to fu rther attempt to complete distributions to the Settlement Class Members who received but did not cash the checks made payable to them. On the conclusion of the 45-day period, the Settlement Administrator shall resume the schedule and procedures under the Plan of Allocation (Dkt. 148 -6) to distribute the Residual Settlement Fund. Status hearing set for 11/13/2018 is reset for 1/11/2019 at 9:00 AM. Mailed notice(lk, )


´$6,5(³  IR WF$ \WLUXFH6 HPRFQ, WQHPHULWH5 HH\ROSP( HKW RW WQDXVUXS VHLUDL FLIHQHE GQD
VWQDSLFLWUDS QDOS HFQDUXVQL KWODHK RW GHZR VHLWXG VWL IR QRLWDORLY QL VUHWQHF WQHPWDHUW ODLWQHGLVHU QL
VVHQO OL ODWQHP IR WQHPWDHUW URI HJDUHYRF HFQDUXVQL ULHKW IR HSRFV HKW JQLWFLUWVHU \E VHFLWFDUS ODJHO O L
GQD \URWDQL PLUFVLG QL GHJDJQH &6&+ WQDGQHIH' HJHOOD VII LWQLDO3 WLXV QRLWFD VVDOF ULHKW Q,
'1825*.&$%

GHWQDUJ VL QRLWR0 ¶VI ILWQLDO3
VQRVDHU JQLZROORI HKW UR)  WN' HQLOGDHG QRLWXELUWVLG HKW IR QRLVQHW[H \DG D JQLNHHV
HQL OGDH' QRLWXELUWVL' JQLGQHW[( \E WQHPHOWWH6 IR QRLWDUWVL QL PG$ \ILGR0 RW QRLWR0 D GHOL I
VI ILWQLDO3   UHEPHWSH6 Q2 UHWIDHUHKW QRRV QDJHE VVDO& HKW RW GQX) WQHPHOWWH6 WH1 HKW IR
QRLWXELUWVL'  WN' VVDO& WQHPHOWWH6 HKW IR I ODKHE QR VHLWUDS HKW \E RWQL GHUHWQH WQHPHHUJ$
WQHPHOWWH6 HKW JQLYRUSSD WQHPJGX- GQD UHGU2 ODQL) D GHUHWQH WUXR& HKW   \UDXUEH) Q2
 WN' &6&+ WQDGQHIH' WVQLDJD   \OX- QR WLXV QRLWFD VVDOF VLKW GHO LI VI ILWQLDO3
5('52 '1$ 12,1,32 08'1$520(0

O ODGQH. 0 DL QLJUL9 QR+
 & 

WQDGQHIH'
12,7$52352&
(&,95(6 (5$& +7/$(+
Y

VIILWQLDO3

GHWDXWLV \OUDO L PLV VUHKWR O OD IR I ODKHE
QR GQD IODKHE QZR ULHKW QR +&678$3
/ 1$<5% WQHUDS GQD GQHLUI W[HQ
UHK \E URQLP D (2' <5$0 +&678$3
/ 1$<5% 7)$5& $ +7(%$=,/(
WQHUDS GQD GQHLUI W[HQ UHK \E URQL P
D (2' (1$- 7)$5& $ +7(%$=,/(

12,6,9,' 15(76$(
6,21,//, )2 7&,576,' 15(+7521 (+7 52)
7582& 7&,576,' 6(7$76 '(7,18 (+7 1,



O DYRUSS$ ODQL) HKW HWDG HKW QR GQX) WQHPHOWWH6 WH1 HKW JQL \ OSLWOXP \E GHQLPUHWHG HE O ODKV³ HUDKV
V¶UHEPH0 KFD(  WD G, QRLWDFRO O$ IR QDO3 HKW QL GHGLYRUS DOXPURI D RW JQLGURFFD GHWDOXFODF
VD ´V\D' WQHPWDHU7 GHWVXMG$ UHKVLK QR GHVDE GQX) WQHPHOWWH6 WH1 HKW IR HUDKV D HYLHFHU
O O LZ³ UHEPH0 VVDO& WQHPHOWWH6 JQLWDS LFLWUD3 KFDH QRLWDFRO O$ IR QDO3 HKW RW JQLGURFF$
 WN' HH6 UHEPH0 KFDH RW VNFHKF
JQLWXELUWVLG URI HOXGHKFV GQD HUXGHFRUS D VHGLYRUS GQD GHWDOXFODF HE RW VL HUDKV V¶UHEPH0 KFDH
ZRK KWURI VWHV QRLWDFROO$ IR QDO3 HK7  WD   WD  VWN' ´VUHEPH0 VVDO& WQHPHOWWH6
JQLWDSLFLWUD3³ VVDO& WQHPHOWWH6 HKW IR WXR WSR WRQ GLG RKZ VUHEPH0 VVDO& OOD RW FWH VHHI VWVRF
VH[DW QLDWUHF VVHO   GQX) WQHPHOWWH6 WH1 HKW IR QRLWXELUWVLG HKW URI QRLWDFRO O$ IR QDO3 D
VHWDURSURFQL WQHPHHUJ$ HK7   WD  URWDUWVL QLPG$ WQHPHOWWH6 VD &// QRLWDUWVL QL PG$
O KD' GHWQLRSSD GQD 

IR GQX) WQHPHOWWH6 D GHKVLOEDWVH WQHPHHUJ$ WQHPHOWWH6

GHYRUSSD HK7  WN' HFLGXMHUS KWLZ QRLWFD HKW JQLVVL PVLG GQD WQHPHHUJ$ WQHPHOWWH6
HKW JQLYRUSSD WQHPJGX- GQD UHGU2 ODQL) D GHXVVL WUXR& HKW   \UDXUEH) Q2
 WD  WN' WQHPHOWWH6 HKW IR WXR GHWSR VUHEPH0 VVDO& WQHPHOWWH6 R1  WN' WXR WSR
RW \WLQXWURSSR GQD WQHPHOWWHV GHVRSRUS HKW IR HFLWR1 VODXGL YLGQL HVHKW GHGLYRUS GQD DWDG &6&+
KJXRUKW VUHEPH0 VVDO& WQHPHOWWH6 GHL ILWQHGL VHLWUDS HK7  WN' VVHQO O L ODWQHP IR WQHPWDHUW
O DLWQHGLVHU IR HJDUHYRF URI VQRLVXOF[H QDOS QR GHVDE &6&+ \E GHLQHG P LDOF ULHKW GDK GQD UHWQHF
WQHPWDHUW ODLWQHGLVHU D QL VVHQO OL ODWQHP IR WQHPWDHUW URI P LDOF D GHWWL PEXV &6&+ \E GHUXVQL
URGQD GHUHWVL QLPGD QDOS VWL IHQHE HUDIOHZ HH \ROSPH GHQUHYRJ$6,5( QD IR VHLUDLFL IHQHE UR
QL VWQDSLFLWUDS HUHZ   \OX- UHWID RKZ VODXGLYLGQL IR I ODKHE QR WQHPHOWWH6 QRLWF$ VVDO& HKW
JQLYRUSSD \ O LUDQL P LOHUS UHGU2 QD GHUHWQH WUXR& HKW   UHEPHWSH6 Q2  QL VQRLVVXFVLG
WQHPHOWWHV GHUHWQH VHLWUDS HK7

 WN'

$6,5( RWQL GHWDURSURFQL VD ´WF$ \WLUD3³ HKW

 IR WF$ \WLXT( QRLWFLGG$ GQD \WLUD3 KWODH+ ODWQH0 LFLQHPR' HWH3 GQD HQRWVOOH: OXD3 HKW GQD


QR HFQDLO O$ ODQRLWD1 RW UHGQLDPHU HKW HWXELUWVLG O OLZ URWDUWVL QL PG$
WQHPHOWWH6 HKW QHKW VVHO UR  VL GQX) WQHPHOWWH6 ODXGLVH5 HKW I, 
\ OHYLWDQUHWOD UR VUHEPH0 JQLWDSLFLWUD3
H OELVVHFF$ OOD URI V\D' WQHPWDHU7 GHWVXMG$ HKW IR PXV HKW  V\D'
WQHPWDHU7 GHWVXMG$ V¶UHEPH0 HKW QRLWFDUI JQLZROORI HKW \E GQX)
WQHPHOWWH6 ODXGLVH5 HKW IR WQXRPD HKW JQL \ OSLWOXP \E GHQLPUHWHG
HE OODKV UHEPH0 JQLWDSLFLWUD3 HO ELVVHFF$ KFDH RW GHWXELUWVLG HUDKV
HKW HUHKZ ´VUH EPH0 JQLWDSLFLWUD3 HOELVVHFF$³ GHWHOSPRF HUHZ
VQRLWXELUWVLG PRKZ URI VUHEPH0 VVDO& WQHPHOWWH6 JQLWDSLFLWUD3
HVRKW RW UHGQLDPHU HKW DWDU RUS HWXELUWVLG O OLZ URWDUWVL QL PG$
WQHPHOWWH6 HKW QHKW  VGHHF[H GQX) WQHPHOWWH6 ODXGLVH5 HKW I, 
VZROORI VD ´GQX)
WQHPHOWWH6 ODXGLVH5³ HKW GHULS[H VDK NFHKF QRLWXELUWVLG HKW JQLKVDF
URI GRLUHS HPLW HKW HVXDFHE GHWHOSPRF QHHE WRQ HYDK WDKW VQRLWXELUWVLG
\ QD IR WQXRPD HKW GQD + KSDUJDUD3 RW WQDXVUXS HGLVD WHV QHHE
HYDK WDKW VQRLWXELUWV LG \QD IR WQXRPD HKW HGXOFQL OODKV KFLKZ VH[DW
GHWFHS[H URGQD VWVRF HYLWDUWVL QLPGD HOEDQRVDHU URI HYUHVHU D VVHO
GQX) WQHPHOWWH6 WH1 HKW IR UHGQLDPHU HKW HWXELUWVLG UHWIDHUHKW V\DG 
QLKWLZ O OLZ URWDUWVLQ L PG$ WQHPHOWWH6 HKW ´HWD' QRLWHOSPR&³ HKW +
KSDUJDUDS QL RW GHUUHIHU VQRLWXELUWVLG O OD IR HGLVD JQLWWHV UR QRLWHOSPRF
HKW LL UR WQHPJGX- OD QL) UHWID V\DG  L UHKWLH IR UHLOUDH HKW W$ ,
HUDKV V¶UHEPH0 VVDO& WQHPHOWWH6 JQLWDSLFLWUD3
WDKW HGLVD WHV GQD WVHXTHU WQHP\DS SRWV D HXVVL O OLZ URWDUWVL QL PG$
WQHPHOWWH6 HKW QHKW JQL OLDP UHWID V\DG  WVDHO WD URI GHQUXWHUQX GQD
GHKVDFQX VQLDPHU NFHKF \QD I, HGLVD WHV UR GHWHOSPRF UHKWLH QHHE HYDK
VQRLWXELUWVLG O OD OLWQX HGLVD WHV HE O ODKV HUDKV V¶UHEPH0 VVDO& WQHPHOWWH6
JQLWDSLFLWUD3 HKW QHKW GQX) WQHPHOWWH6 WH1 HKW IR HUDKV V¶UHEPHP
WDKW IR QRLWXELUWVLG HKW HWHOSPRF RW HO ELVVRS \ OEDQRVDHU WRQ VL WL UHEPH0
VVDO& WQHPHOWWH6 JQLWDSLFLWUD3 D RW QRLWXELUWVLG D HNDP RW VWSPHWWD
RZW WVDHO WD UHWID WDKW VHQLPUHWHG URWDUWVL QLPG$ WQHPHOWWH6 HKW I, +
OXIVVHFFXVQX VDZ WSPHWWD QD PRKZ URI VUHEPH0
VVDO& WQHPHOWWH6 JQLWDSLFLWUD3 \QD URI QRLWDPURIQL VVHUGGD HWDGRW
SX GQLI RW WSPHWWD RW OHVQXRF ¶VHLWUD3 HKW KWLZ NURZ O O LZ GQD VUHEPH0
VVDO& WQHPHOWWH6 JQLWDSLFLWUD3 RW O LDP GHL ILWUHF \E VNFHKF HWXELUWVLG
RW VWSPHWWD RZW WVDHO WD HNDP O OLZ URWDUWVL QLPG$ WQHPHOWWH6 HK7 *
VUHEPH0 VVDO& WQHPHOWWH6 JQLWDSLFLWUD3
RW VNFHKF HKW JQLWXELUWVLG URI HOXGHKFV JQLZROORI HKW VHGLYRUS QHKW QRLWDFRO O$ IR QDO3 HK7
± WD G, ´VUHEPH0 JQLWDSLFLWUD3 OOD URI V\D' WQHPWDHU7 GHWVXMG$ HKW IR PXV HKW
 V\D' WQHPWDHU7 GHWVXMG$ V¶UHEPH0 HKW QRLWFDUI JQLZROORI HKW \E @  \UDXUEH)> UHGU2


GHPURIQL QRLWDUWVL QL PG$ OKD' VNFHKF HOEDUHY LOHGQX UR GHKVDFQX OOD QR WVHXTHU WQHP\DSSRWV D
JQLXVVL URI HQLOGDHG \DG HKW   WVXJX$ Q2  WD  WN'   \D0 QR QRLWDFRO O$
IR QDO3 HKW QL GHGLYRUS HOXGHKFV HKW UHS VNFHKF IR QRLWXELUWVLG HKW GHWDLWLQL QRLWDUWVL QL PG$
OKD'  WN' VUHEPH0 JQLWDSLFLWUD3  \OHWDP L[RUSSD GHGXOFQL WVL/ VVDO& WQHPHOWWH6
ODQL) HK7  WD  WN'   KFUD0 VDZ WQHPHOWWH6 IR HWD' HYLWFHII( HK7
 WD  WN'
WQHPHHUJ$ VLKW IR VPUHW HKW JQLFURIQH IR HVRSUXS HKW URI
WQHPHOWWH6 HKW GQD QRLWF$ VHLWUD3 HKW UHYR QRLWFLGVLUXM QLDWHU OOLZ WUXR&
HKW WDKW HHUJD GQD HJGHOZRQNFD VHLWUD3 HK7 QRLWFLGVLUX- IR QRLWQHWH5 
WQHPHHUJ$ WQHPHOWWH6
 WD  WN'
WQHPHOWWH6 HKW URGQD WQHPJGX- GQD UHGU2 ODYRUSS$ ODQL) VLKW IR
VPUHW HKW HFURIQH RW \UDVVHFHQ \GHPHU HOEDWLXTH UR ODJHO HWDLUSRUSSD \QD
UHGUR \DP WUXR& HK7 IRHUHKW VQRLVLYRUS HVDHOHU HKW HGXOFQL WQHPHHUJ$
WQHPHOWWH6 HKW GQD UHGU2 VLKW IR QRLWDUWVL QLPGD GQD WQHPHFURIQH
GQD GQX) WQHPHOWWH6 HKW IR QRLWLVRSVLG WQHPHHUJ$ WQHPHOWWH6
HKW IR QRLWDWQHPHOS PL RW GUDJHU KWLZ VUHEPH0 VVDO& WQHPHOWWH6
GQD URWDUWVL QLPG$ WQHPHOWWH6 HKW VHLWUD3 OOD UHYR QRLWFLGVLUXM
JQLXQLWQRF HYLVXOF[H QLDWHU OOLZ WUXR& VLKW \DZ \QD QL WQHPJGXGQD UHGU2 ODYRUSS$ ODQL) VLKW IR \WL ODQLI HKW JQLWFHIID WXRKWL: 
12,7&,'6,58-

WQHPJGX- GQD UHGU2 ODQL)
WUXR& HKW \E QRLWFLGVLUXM IR QRLWDYUHVHU VVHUS[H QD HGXOFQL
WQHPHHUJ$ WQHPHOWWH6 HKW GQD WQHPJGX- GQD UHGU2 ODQL) HKW KWRE \ OODQL)  WD  WN'
´WVHUHWQLQLVURVVHFFXV ULHKW UR WQHPHHUJ$ VLKW GHWXFH[H RKZ VQRVUH3 HKW \E GHQJLV JQLWLUZ D \E
WSHF[H GHYLDZ HE VQRLVLYRUS VWL IR \QD \DP URQ GHGQHPD UR GHL ILGRP HE WRQ \DP WQHPHHUJ$³ HKW
VHWDWV WDKW HVXDOF ´WQHPGQHP$ UR QRLWDF L ILGR0³ D VHGXOFQL RVOD WQHPHHUJ$ WQHPHOWWH6 HK7
 WD G,

$9 QRWJQLOU$  HWLX6 HYLU' [DIULD) 1  VVHQOO, ODWQH0

WUXR& HKW HVXDFH%


\UDVVHFHQ VL WQHPWVXMGD RQ QRLWR0 ¶VIILWQLDO3 VWQDUJ
\UDVVHFHQ IL VUHEPH0 ODQRLWLGGD HVHKW URI VWQHPWVXMGD \UDVVHFHQ \QD HNDP QDF WUXR& HKW WVXUW

\HKW WDKW \OQR GHWDWV WUXR& HKW HUR IHE JQLUDHK D WD WXE VIHLUE ULHKW GHWWLPEXV VHLWUDS HKW HFQLV QRLWDUWVLQLPG$ OKD'
GHWFDWQR F HYDK WDKW VUHEPH0 ODQRLWLGGD RZW HKW RW GUDJHU KWLZ QRLWLVRS RQ QHNDW HYDK VWQDGQHIH' Q  WD  WN'
VNFHKF ULHKW IR VWLVRSHG HKW JQLWHOSPRF QL HFQDWVLVVD URI VUHEPHP HHUKW HVHKW KWLZ JQLNURZ QRLWDUWVLQLPG$ OKD' RW
WFH MER WRQ RG \HKW WDKW QRLWR0 ¶VIILWQLDO3 RW HVQRSVH5 ULHKW QL GHWDWV VWQDGQHIH' GHOLI VDZ QRLWR0 ¶VIILWQLDO3 HPLW HKW
WD QRLWDUWVLQLPG$ OKD' GHWFDWQRF GDK NFHKF UHK UR VLK I R HFQDXVVLHU JQLNHHV VUHEPH0 VVDO& HYLI HKW IR HHUKW \OQ2



 WN' WQHPJGX- GQD UHGU2 ODQ L) HKW RW QRLWDFL ILGRP ODPURI JQLULXTHU WQHPHHUJ$
HKW IR VPUHW HKW RW HJQDKF HYLWQDWVEXV D VHWXWLWVQRF QRLVQHW[H \DG HKW JQLXJUD HHUJDVLG
VWQDGQHIH'  WN' WQHPHHUJ$ HKW RW VWQHPWVXMGD KFXV HNDP RW UHZRS HOEDWLXTH V¶WUXR&
HKW GQD WQHPHHUJ$ WQHPHOWWH6 HKW GQD WQHPJGX- GQD UHGU2 ODQL) HKW QL GHYUHVHU VD QRLWFLGVLUXM
JQLXQLWQRF V¶WUXR& HKW QLKWLZ VL WKJXRV QRLVQHW[H \DG HKW WDKW HXJUD VI ILWQLDO3
6,6</$1$

 WN' QRLWDFLILGRP KFXV VHGXOFHUS
\ OVVHUS[H WQHPHHUJ$ WQHPHOWWH6 HKW JQLXJUD WKJXRV QRLVQHW[H \DG HKW RW WFHMER WXE HQLOGDHG 
WVXJX$ HKW HFQLV QRLWDUWVL QLPG$ OKD' GHWFDWQRF HYDK WDKW VUHEPH0 JQLWDSLFLWUD3 HKW RW GHXVVLHU
HE RW VNFHKF JQLZROOD RW WFHMER WRQ RG VWQDGQHIH' G, JQLVVHFRUS ODQRLWLGGD VLKW HWHOSPRF RW
V \DG  NHHV VII LWQLDO3 \ O ODFL ILFHS6 G, VNFHKF GHKVDFQX WXE HOEDUHYL OHG  HKW IR QRLWXELUWVLG
HKW HWHOSPRF RW WSPHWWD UHKWUXI HQR QRLWDUWVLQ L PG$ OKD' ZROOD RW HOXGHKFV QRLWXELUWVLG HKW RW
´WQHPWVXMGD WVHGRP³ D NHHV VII LWQLDO3 QRLWR0 HKW Q,  WN'   UHEPHWSH6 QR HQLOGDH'
QRLWXELUWVL' JQLGQHW[( \E WQHPHOWWH6 IR QRLWDUWVL QL PG$ \ ILGR0 RW QRLWR0 ULHKW GHO LI VI ILWQLDO3
  UHEPHWSH6 VDZ QRLWXELUWVLG GQXRUGQRFHV HKW JQLWDLWLQL URI HQLOGDHG \DG HK7
G, GHXVVLHU HE NFHKF HKW WDKW JQLWVHXTHU HQLOGDHG  WVXJX$ HKW UHWID QRLWDUWVL QL PG$
O KD' GHWFDWQRF UHEPH0 JQLWDSLFLWUD3 HYLWFHSVHU HKW VNFHKF GHKVDFQX WXE HOEDUHYLOHG  HKW
IR HYLI UR)  WD G,  \OHWDPL[RUSSD JQLODWRW VNFHKF GHKVDFQX WXE HOEDUHYLOHG  GQD
 \OHWDPL[RUSSD JQLODWRW VNFHKF HOEDUH YLOHGQX  GHQLDPHU VNFHKF  WDKW OHVQXR& VVDO&



Y OKR3 ´ZDO WFDUWQRF IR VHOSLFQLUS \E GHQUHYRJ VL WQHPHFURIQH VWL GQD WFDUWQRF D VL WQHPHHUJD
WQHPHOWWHV $³ UL& KW   G)  UHJHW6 IR OOL9 Y NULNZ H1 RVOD HHV ´VLRQLOO,
IR HWDW6 HKW IR VZDO HKW RW JQLGURFFD GHWHUSUHWQL GQD \E GHQUHYRJ HE O ODKV WQHPHHUJ$ VLKW
IR VQRLWLGQRF GQD VPUHW O O$³  WD  WN' ZDO VLRQL OO, VHLOSSD WUXR& HKW WQHPHHUJ$ HKW IR
VPUHW HKW JQLFURIQH Q, GHGGD VLVDKSPH ´WQHPHHUJ$ VLKW IR VPUHW HKW JQLFURIQH IR VHVRSUXS

HKW URI    QRLWFLGVLUXM QLDWHU O OLZ WUXR& HK@7>³  WN' GHGGD VLVDKSPH ´WQHPHOWWH6
HKW URGQD WQHPJGX- GQD UHGU2 ODYRUSS$ ODQL) VLKW IR VPUHW HKW HFURIQH RW \UDVVHFHQ \GHPHU
HOEDWLXTH UR ODJHO HWDLUSRUSSD \QD UHGUR \DP WUXR& HK7³  WN' HH6 WQHPHHUJ$ WQHPHOWWH6
HKW GQD UHGU2 HKW IR VPUHW HKW \E GHWL P L O \OWLF L OS[H VL WL GHUHWWHIQX WRQ VL WQHPHHUJ$ WQHPHOWWH6
HKW GQD WQHPJGX- GQD UHGU2 ODQL) HKW QL WUXR& HKW \E GHYUHVHU QRLWFLGVLUXM HKW UHYHZR+
´GHOWLWQH
HUD VUHEPHP VVDOF GHGLFHG VDK WL KFLKZ RW IH L OHU HKW \DS RW    HVLPRUS D HYRUSSD RW \ OHUHP
WRQ GQD GHWHOSPRF VL VHYRUSSD WL WQHPHOWWHV \QD WDKW HHV RW VUHEPHP VVDOF RW \WXG D VDK WUXRF
WFLUWVLG HKW QRLWFD VVDOF D Q,³  UL& KW   G)  QRLWDJLWL/ WVXUWLWQ$ UHQLDWQR&

GHWDJXUUR& HU Q, JH RVOD HHV  UL& KW   G)  QDYLOOX6 Y \GDU% JQLWRXT G,
GHOWLWQH HUD \HKW KFLKZ RW IHL OHU HKW HYLHFHU VUH EPHP VVDOF HUXVQH RW UHGUR QL ´WL KWLZ HFQDL OSPRF
HWDGQDP RW UHZRS HKW HYDK \ OLUDVVHFHQ @WQHPHHUJD WQHPHOWWHV D> RW WQDXVUXS WQHPJGXM UHWQH
RKZ VWUXRF WFLUWVL@'>³  UL& KW   G)  WVL' NUD3 RJDFLK& Y UHGQD[HO$
´VUHEPHP VVDOF IR VWVHUHWQL HKW WFHWRUS RW  3 YL& 5 GH) RW WQDXVUXS \WL O L ELVQRSVHU VWL KWLZ
WQHWVLVQRF VL QRLWFLGVLUXM IR QRLWQHWHU WLFL OS[H V¶WUXRF WFLUWVLG HK7³  WD  WN' ´WQHPHHUJ$
WQHPHOWWH6 HKW GQD UHGU2 @ODQL) HKW> IR QRLWDUWVL QLPGD GQD WQHPHFURIQH GQD GQX) WQHPHOWWH6
HKW IR QRLWLVRSVLG WQHPHHUJ$ HKW IR QRLWDWQHPHOSPL³ RW WQHPHOWWH6 HKW IR ODYRUSSD GQD WQHPJGXM
O DQLI GQR\HE QRLWFLGVLUXM GHYUHVHU \ OVVHUS[H WUXR& HKW WQHPJGX- GQD UHGU2 ODQL) HKW Q,



VUHZRS WQHUHKQL GQD HOEDWLXTH HYDK RVOD VWUXR& WQHPHHUJ$ HKW QL GHGLYRUS \ OWLFLOS[H WDKW GQR\HE
VGQXI IR QRLWXELUWVLG HKW UHYR UHZRS RQ VDK WUXR& HKW WDKW UHYHZRK \DV RW WRQ VL WDK7
VI ILWQLDO3 HKW \E GHWVHXTHU QRLWDFRO O$ IR
QDO3 HKW RW QRLWDFL ILGRP HKW WQDUJ RW WQHPHHUJ$ HKW GQD UHGU2 HKW KJXRUKW GHQLDWHU QRLWFLGVLUXM HKW
UHGQX \WLURKWXD RQ VDK WUXR& HKW HURIHUHK7 QRLWDFL ILGRP GHVRSRUS HKW RW HVLZUHKWR UR JQLWLUZ
GHQJLV D QL GHHUJD WRQ HYDK VHLWUDS HK7 QRLWDF L ILGRP IR VQDHP UHKWR \QD HWDOSPHWQRF QRLWDFRO O$
IR QDO3 HKW URQ UHGU2 HKW UHKWLH1  WD  WN' VHLWUDS HKW \E GHQJLV JQLWLUZ D \E WSHF[H
GHGQHPD UR GHL ILGRP HE WRQ \DP WL WDKW VHWDWV \ OWLFLOS[H WQHPHHUJ$ HKW HURPUHKWUX) QRLVQHW[H
GHWVHXTHU V¶I ILWQLDO3 JQL \QHG \EHUHKW QDO3 HKW RW JQLGURFFD GHHFRUS QRLWXELUWVLG GQXRUGQRFHV HKW
WDKW UHGUR RW WUXR& HKW HULXTHU GOXRZ WQHPHHUJ$ HKW IR VPUHW HKW JQLFURIQH HURIHUHK7 HPRF VDK
QRLWXELUWVLG GQXRUGQRFHV HKW JQLWDLWLQL URI HQLOGDHG \DG HK7 QRLWXELUWVLG GQXRUGQRFHV HKW
IR WUDS D HPRFHE HQL OGDHG \DG HKW IR VD GHKVDFQX HUHZ \HKW HVXDFHE HGLVD WHV VNFHKF OOD WDKW
VHULXTHU QDO3 HK7 GHVVDS \OUDHOF VDK QRLWXELUWVLG GQXRUWVULI HKW JQLWXELUWVLG URI HQL OGDHG HKW GQD
VUHEPH0 JQLWDSLFLWUD3 RW VNFHKF IR QRLWXELUWVLG HKW URI HOXGHKFV UDHOF D VHKVLOEDWVH WQHPHHUJ$
WQHPHOWWH6 HKW RWQL GHWDURSURFQL VD QRLWDFROO$ IR QDO3 HKW IR HJDXJQDO QLDOS HK7
 WD
G(1  UHKJOOD* JQLWRXT G, ´VUHKWR HKW IR WKJLO QL WUDS KFDH JQLZHLY HORKZ D VD³ WFDUWQRF
HKW HXUWVQRF GQD ´WQHWQL ¶VHLWUDS HKW IR QRLWDFLGQL WVHE HKW VL JQLQDHP \UDQLGUR GQD QLDOS VWL QHYLJ
HJDXJQDO HKW VD HQROD WFDUWQRF @HKW> IR HJDXJQDO HKW RW NRRO³ WVULI WVXP WUXRF HK7  OO, 
 G(1  WUDQH/ Y UHKJDOOD* JQLWRXT  UL& KW   G)  FQ, ( UH]DH% Y

R& HNR&

WKJL/ VD* VHOSRH3 ´VHLWUDS HKW IR WQHWQL HKW RW WFHIIH HYLJ RW VL WFDUWQRF D JQLXUWVQRF

QL HYLWFHMER \UDPLUSµ V¶WUXRF HKW ZDO VLRQL OO, UHGQ8³

WQHPHHUJD WQHPHOWWHV D JQLXUWVQRF

QHKZ ZDO HWDWV VHLOSSD WUXR& HK7 UL& KW   G)  FQ, VHQLOUL$ GHWLQ8



WFLUWVLG HK7 
WD G, GHOORUWQRF QLHUHKW GHWDURSURFQL HQL OGDHG JQL O L I \DG HKW GQD WQHPHHUJ$
WQHPHOWWH6 ¶VHLWUDS HKW HVXDFHE UHZRS HOEDWLXTH VWL UHGQX VP LDOF GHO LIHWDO HKW IR \QD UHGLVQRF
WRQ GOXRKV WUXR& HKW JQLXJUD QRLWRP HKW GHVRSSR VWQDGQHIH' G, WQHPHHUJD ¶VHLWUDS HKW UHGQX
WQHP\DS URI GHLI L ODXT VP LDOF  JQL QLDPHU HKW UHKWHKZ UHYHZRK UDHOFQX VDZ W, 
WD G, GHVVDS
H QLOGDHG HKW UHWID QRRV GHYRUSSDHUS HUHZ PRKZ IR WVRP VUHEPHP VVDOF WQHUUXF \E GHO LI HUHZ 
VP LDOF GHO LIHWDO  HKW I2 
WD  /:  GHYRUSSD QHHE GDK WQHPHHUJD WQHPHOWWHV
VVDOF ¶VHLWUDS HKW UHWID VP LDOF GHO LIHWDO  ZROOD RW WUXR& HKW GHYRP VII LWQLDO3 NFXEHR5

VUDH6 HU Q, Q, QRLWLVRS VLKW WURSSXV RW NFXEHR5 VUDH6 HU Q, QR \ OLUDP LUS \ OHU VIILWQLDO3 VNHHV
WL WQHPWVXMGD JQL OXGHKFV HKW HNDP RW QRLWFLGVLUXM HOEDWLXTH VDK WUXR& HKW HXJUD VI ILWQLDO3
´VQRVUHS GHWVHUHWQL WXE GHPDQQX WFHWRUS RW \WXG GQD UHZRS
WQHUHKQL HKW VDK GQXI WVXUW D IR QRLWXELUWVLG HKW JQLVLYUHSXV WUXRF D WDKW HFQXRQQD RW ZDO OHYRQ WRQ
VL W, VUHZRS \WLXTH ODQRLWLGDUW VWL VQLDWHU WUXRF HKW GHWXELUWVLG \ OODXWFD VL WQHPHOWWHV HKW \E GHWDHUF
GQXI HKW OLWQ8³  UL& G   G)  HWUR0D/ Y VWQHL= RVOD HHV GHWWLPR QRLWDWRXT
  UD0 OO, '1 
WD  /:   &  R1 JLWL/ EDL/ GRU3 UHKVD:

JQLGDR/WQRU) R&

NFXEHR5 VUDH6 HU Q, JH HH6 ´GHWXELUWVLG \ OODXWFD VL @GQXI WQHPHOWWHV>

HKW OLWQX HXQLWQRF³ VUHEPHP VVDOF GHPDQQX WFHWRUS RW \WXG \UDLFXGLI GQD VUHZRS WQHUHKQL V¶WUXR&
HKW QRLWFLGVLUXM IR QRLWQHWHU WLFL OS[H VWL HNL/  UL& KW   G)  NQD% O¶WD1

ODLFLIHQH% Y VGORQ\H5 JQLWRXT ´¶VHLUDLFXGL I IR VHULXTHU ZDO HKW WDKW HUDF IR \WXG KJLK HKW RWµ
WFHMEXV ¶VVDOF HKW IR \UDLFXGLIµ HKW VD WFD GOXRKV VWUXRF WFLUWVL@'>³  UL& KW  G) 
R& VYUH6 GHWDOH5 OHYDU7 VVHUS[( P$ Y QDPIXD.    68  HH/ Y \UUHEVQD+
JQLWLF ´QLJLUR QL HOEDWLXTH @VL> HUXGHFRUS QRLWFD VVDOF HK@7>³  UL& KW   G) 
GQDIOH+ Y SUR& WKJLU:VVLWUX& HH6 GHWHOSPRF QHHE HYDK QRSX GHHUJD VD WQHPHOWWHV HKW IR VPUHW
HKW OLWQX VVDOF HKW IR VUHEPHP GHWVHUHWQL WXE GHPDQQX HKW WFHWRUS RW \WXG \UDLFXGLI D VD OOHZ VD

HWDO D VD QRLWLVRS UDO LPLV D QL HUD NFHKF QRLWXELUWVLG GQXRUWVULI ULHKW GHKVDF WRQ HYDK WXE GHYLHFHU
RKZ VUHEPH0 VVDO& HKW \ OODQRLWLGG$ VUHEPH P VVDOF JQL \ I LODXT HKW JQRPD GQXI WQHPHOWWHV HWLQL I
HKW IR QRLWDFROOD HKW VHVDF GHWLFHYRED HKW QL VWUXRF JQLWDYLWRP HXVVL HPDV HKW RW HVLU HYLJ VNFHKF
GHKVDFQX WXE HOEDUHYLOHG HKW WXE VP LDOF GHO LIHWDO HYORYQL WRQ VHRG WVHXTHU ¶VI ILWQLDO3
HVLZUHKWR
H OEDWLXTHQL HE GOXRZ WOXVHU HUHKZ WQHPHHUJD WQHPHOWWHV HKW QL HVXDOF QRLVUHYHUQRQ HWLSVHG UHZRS
HOEDWLXTH V¶WUXRF RW WQDXVUXS VGQXI IR QRLVUHYHU JQLWWLPUHS  UL& G  G)  HOE$

Y UHKFHH% JH RVOD HHV ´ HOX5 RW WQDXVUXS VQRLWFD VVDOF JQLHHVUHYR QL QRLWFQXI V¶WUXRF HKW IR
ZHLY ZRUUDQ³ ´GHWQDUUDZQX³ QD VD VPUHW WQHPHHUJD WQHPHOWWHV RW HFQHUHKGD WFLUWV V¶WUXRF WFLUWVLG
JQLWFHMHU  WD G)  VWQHL= JH HH6 WQHPHHUJD ¶VHLWUDS HKW IR VPUHW HKW \E GHVROFHURI
VDZ WKJXRV IHLOHU HKW HUHKZ QHYH GHWWLPR QRLWDWRXT ´VQRVUHS GHWVHUHWQL WXE GHPDQQX
WFHWRUS RW \WXG GQD UHZRS WQHUHKQL GQD \WL O LELVQRSVHU V¶WUXRF HKW VL UHYHZRK JQLFQDODE VLKW
RW ODUJHWQ,    VUHEPHP VVDOF JQLYLUUDHWDO RW HXG QRLWDUHGLVQRF HKW GQD QRLWXELUWVLG WQHPHOWWHV
WQHLGHS[H IR VODRJ HKW JQLFQDODE VL VUHZRS HOEDWLXTH @V¶WUXRF HKW> IR HVX \UDPLUS $³  UL& G
  G)  JLWL/ EDL/ VGRU3 ZHUF6 HQR% FLGHSRKWU2 HU Q, JH HHV HPDV HKW GOHK HYDK
VWUXRF HWDOOHSSD UHKW2  WD G)  SUR& WKJLU:VVLWUX& VVDOF WQHPHOWWHV HKW IR VUHEPHP
HKW WFHWRUS RW \WXG VWL GQD ´VWQDQLDOSPRF JQLWHSPRF JQRPD GQXI HWDXTHGDQL QD @JQL>WDFRO OD³
IR ´QRLWFQXI HOEDWLXTH ODQRLWLGDUW³ V¶WUXRF HKW KWLZ WQHWVLVQRF VL UHZRS KFX6

 UL&

KW   G)  GRUO( Y VQUX% VWQDP LDOF ZHQ HKW URYDI HFQDODE QR VHLWLXTH HKW HUHKZ
\OQR WXE VP LDOF HWDO IR JQL OLI HKW WLPUHS RW UHZRS HOEDWLXTH ULHKW QLKWLZ QRLWHUFVLG HYDK VWQHPHHUJD
WQHPHOWWHV VVDOF JQLHHVUHYR VWUXRF WDKW GH]LQJRFHU VDK WLXFUL& KWQHYH6 HKW GHHGQ,

G, VP LDOF HWDOWXEGLODY  HKW RW GUDJHU KWLZ WVDHO WD \WLURKWXD HOEDWLXTH
V¶WUXR& HKW UHGQX KFDRUSSD WQHLQHO HURP D GHWQDUUDZ HVDF HKW QL VWFDI HKW JQLGQLI GHHUJDVLG WUXRF



QRLWVHXT \QD GHVLDU UHEPH0 VVDO& RQ GRLUHS HFLWR1 HKW JQLUXG QRLWDUWVL QL PG$ OKD' GQD OHVQXR&
VVDO& GHWFDWQRF VUHEPH0 VVDO& IR VQH]RG KJXRKWOD GHHGQ, GUDZD QRLWXELUWVLG GQXRUGQRFHV D
URI ODLWQHWRS HKW QR QHYH UR HQL OGDHG \DG HKW QR VVDO& WQHPHOWWH6 HKW IR WXR WSR RW WRQ QRLVLFHG
UHK UR VLK GHVDE UHEPH0 VVDO& \QD \ OHNLOQX \ OKJLK VL WL \ OODQRLWLGG$ V\DG  QHHE HQLOGDHG HKW
GDK GHKFDHU QHHE HYDK WRQ GOXRZ WQHPHHUJ$ HKW WDKW UR QRVDHU UDOXFLWUDS \QD URI HQLOGDHG JQLKVDF
NFHKF HKW VD V\DG  HVRKF VHLWUDS HKW VWVHJJXV VIHLUE ¶VHLWUDS HKW UR GURFHU HKW QL JQLKWR1 
W& SS$ OO,   G(1  UDJG( Y DPVLD+ JQLWRXT  UL& KW   G) 

SUR& GQDOGRR: OW$ QDHF2 Y &// RLWQD]\%

GORKQU$ DGO( ´WL WXRKWLZ HGDP QHHE HYDK WRQ

GOXRZ WFDUWQRF HKW WDKW HFQDWURSPL KFXV IR GQD HUXWDQ D KFXV IR³ WFDUWQRF D IR QRLVLYRUS ODLWQHVVH
QD VL PUHW ODLUHWDP D ZDO VLRQL OO, UHGQ8 ´Q LDJUDE HKW IR WUDS ODUJHWQL QD V@DZ> HQLOGDHG @> HKW
WDKW «WQHPHOWWH6 HKW IR VPUHW HKW GQD    GURFHU HKW IR ZHLYHU D PRUI HGXOFQRF WRQ³ GOXRF WUXRF
HKW HUHKZ VP LDOF GHO LIHWDO JQLWWLPUHS  <1'(   SSX6 )  JLWL/ FH6 HLGG(

\]DU& HU Q, JH RVOD HHV 
WD  /:  WQHPHHUJ$ ¶VHLWUDS HKW HJQDKF \ O ODLUHWDP
WRQ OOLZ QRLVQHW[H GHWVHXTHU HKW WDKW VGQLI WUXR& HKW NFXEHR5 VUDH6 HU Q, QL VD RVO$
GHWW LPR QRLWDWRXT ´WQDPLDOF JQLYUHVHG D \E \UHYRFHU
HGXOFHUS RW VD GLJLU RV HE WRQ WVXP HOSLFQLUS VLKW IR QRLWDFLOSSD GHWDQLPUHW HE WVXP UHWWDP HKW
WQLRS HPRV WD GQD ODLWQHVVH VL HWDG IIRWXF D GQXI WQHPHOWWHV QRLWFD VVDOF HJUDO D IR QRLWXELUWVLG HKW
QL WDKW QRLWVHXT RQ VL HUHKW HO LK:³  WD G)  FLGHSRKWU2 HU Q, JH HH6 GHOWLWQH HUD \HKW
KFLKZ RW VGQXI HKW HYLHFHU RW \WLQXWURSSR OOD VVL P O OLZ VUHEPH0 VVDO& HVHKW QRLWQHYUHWQL WUXR&
WXRKWL: WQHPHOWWHV HKW QL JQLWDSLFLWUDS URI HQ LOGDHG ULHKW GHVVLP HYDK \HKW WQDP LDOF JQL O LIHWDO D
HNLO HURIHUHK7 O LDP HKW QL GHYLHFHU NFHKF HKW KVDF RW VL WQHPHOWWHV HKW QL HWDSLFLWUDS RW GHULXTHU
QRLWFD \OQR GQD WVULI HK7 WQHPHHUJ$ HKW UHGQX QRLWXELUWVLG UHK UR VLK HYLHFHU RW NURZUHSDS
\ QD UR P LDOF D WLPEXV RW GHULXTHU UHYH VDZ UHEPH0 VVDO& JQLWDSLFLWUD3 RQ HUH+ WQDP LDOF JQL OL I



WRQ HYDK RKZ VUHEPH0 VVDO&  JQL QLDPHU HKW VGQDVXRKW IR VQHW UR VGQDVXRKW HKW QDKW VVHO UDI WXE
WQXRPD ODLYLUW D VQDHP RQ \E²UHEPH0 VVDO& UHS  \ OHWDPL[RUSSD ODQRLWLGGD QD RW VWQXRPD
VLKW HUH+ NFHKF D GHKVDF WDKW VUHEPH0 JQLWDSLFLWUD3 UHKWR HKW JQRPD GHGLYLG HE RW QRLWXELUWVLG
GQXRUGQRFHV D KJXRUKW GUDZD ODQRLWLGGD QD IR \WLOLELVVRS HKW \OQR VHVLPRUS W,

WQXRPD

WDKW GQR\HE QRLWXELUWVLG \QD UHEPH0 VVDO& \QD HHWQDUDXJ WRQ VHRG WQHPHHUJ$ HK7 WQXRPD
GHHWQDUDXJ VLKW GHYLHFHU HYDK VUHEPH0 VVDO& J QL QLDPHU  HKW WXE OOD HWDG R7 NFHKF QRLWXELUWVLG
GQXRUWVUL I D JQLKVDF GQD JQLYLHFHU VUHEPH0 JQLWDSLFLWUD3 OOD URI VWQXRFFD WDKW GQX) WQHPHOWWH6
WH1 HKW IR QRLWFDUI D RW ODXTH QRLWXELUWVLG GQXRUWVULI D \OQR UHEPH0 VVDO& KFDH VHHWQDUDXJ
QRLWDFRO O$ IR QDO3 HK7 QRLWXELUWVLG GQXRUGQRFHV D KJXRUKW GUDZD \QD GHHWQDUDXJ VL UHEPH0
VVDO& RQ WX% QRLWXELUWVLG GQXRUGQRFHV HKW \ OQR \DOHG O OLZ QRLWDFL ILGRP HK7 VNFHKF QRLWXELUWVLG
GQXRUWVULI ULHKW GHKVDF \GDHUOD HYDK WDKW VUH EPH0 JQLWDSLFLWUD3 RW \DOHG OXIPUDK \QD HVXDF
WRQ O O LZ QRLVQHW[H \DG HKW HVLZHNL/ GHSSDF VL GQX) WQHPHOWWH6 HKW HFQLV HVDF HKW QL WQLRS
VLKW WD HUXVRS[H UHKWUXI RQ HFDI RKZ VWQDGQHIH' HFLGXMHUS WRQ O OLZ QRLVQHW[H \DG HK7
HWDLUSRUSSD VL WQHPHHUJD
WQHPHOWWHV VVDOF IR QRLWDFL ILGRP UHKWHKZ HQL PUHWHG RW VURWFDI HVHKW JQL \OSSD  UL& &'
  G)  VQRLWF$ VVDO& WVXUWLWQ$ VQLPDWL9 HU Q, JH RVOD HHV    68
 SLKV¶3 GW/ VFRVV$ NFLZVQXU% Y R& VYUH6 YQ, UHHQRL3 JQLWLF 
WD  /: 
NFXEHR5 VUDH6 HU Q, KWLDI GRRJ QL GHWFD VIILWQLDO3 UHKWHKZ GQD \DOHG URI QRVDHU HKW VJQLGHHFRUS
ODLFLGXM QR WFDSP L ODLWQHWRS VWL GQD \DOHG HKW IR KWJQHO HKW VWQDGQHIH' RW HFLGXMHUS IR UHJQDG
HKW JQLGXOFQL VURWFDI ODUHYHV VUHGLVQRF WUXR& HKW VHLWLXTH HKW JQLFQDODE Q, QRLVQHW[H \DG
GHWVHXTHU HKW UHGLVQRF RW \WLURKWXD HOEDWLXTH VWL QLKWLZ VL WL WDKW VGQLI WUXR& HKW HURIHUHK7
 WD  WN' HH6 QRLWXELUWVLG KFXV IR JQ L PLW UR WQXRPD HKW UR GHQLPUHWHG HE GOXRZ WL ZRK
UXFFR GOXRZ QRLWXELUWVLG GQXRUGQRFHV D UHKWHKZ VVHFRUS QRLWXELUWVLG GQXRUGQRFHV HKW WXRED



IR VQHW VHVDF HPRV QL GQD VGQDVXRKW URI HUD VNFHKF HVHKW HVXDFH%  ˆ WD  WN' GHUHYLOHG
WFDI QL HUHZ VNFHKF GHKVDFQX WXE HOEDUHYLOHG HKW QRLWDUWVLQL PG$ OKD' RW JQLGURFFD GQRFH6
NFHKF HKW KVDF UR HYLHFHU RW HUXO LDI ULHKW RW GHWXELUWQRF HYDK GOXRF WDKW VHXVVL KWODHK ODWQHP
VXRLUHV KWLZ HOJJXUWV RW HXQLWQRF \DP GQD QRLWDOXSRS HOEDUHQOXY D IR WUDS \OWQHUHKQL HUD VODXGL YLGQL
HVHKW VVDO& VLKW IR VUHEPHP VD WVUL) \DOHG \DG URQLP VLKW VWQDUUDZ GQD HOEDVXF[H VL VNFHKF
ULHKW KVDF RW HUXO LDI ¶VUHEPH0 VVDO&  HKW HYHLOHE RW QRVDHU VDK WUXR& HKW \ O ODQRLWLGG$
WQHPHOWWHV HKW IR \WL ODQLI HKW \DOHG
\ OODLWQDWVEXV GOXRZ WDKW ´VUHEPHP VVDOF HYLWFHSVRUS \ OQR³ \E VP LDOF ´@GH>WVHWQRF \OVXRURJLY³
VXVUHY VUHEPHP VVDOF GHQLDWUHFVD \E VP LDOF GHVRSSRQX IR JQL O LIHWDO QHHZWHE JQL KVLXJQLWVLG 
WD G)  VQUX% QRLWDUWVL QLPGD WQHPHOWWHV HKW RW QRLWSXUVLG ODP L QLP QDKW HURP HULXTHU GOXRZ
V P LDOF HKW JQLVVHFRUS GQD VVHQLGUDW ULHKW URI QRLWDQDOS[H RQ GHGLYRUS GDK VWQDP LDOF QZRQNQX
VDZ VP LDOF HKW IR \WLGL ODY HUHKZ VPLDOF GHO LIHWDO  JQLWWLPUHS URYDI WRQ GLG VHLWLXTH  
WD
 /:  NFXEHR5 VUDH6 HU Q, NFHKF HKW KVDF GQD HXVVLHU RW VL VVHFRUS QRLWXELUWVLG HKW
HWHOSPRF RW WIHO SHWV \OQR HK7 GUDZD WDKW HYLHFHU RW NURZUHSDS UHKWR UR PLDOF \QD WLPEXV RW VGHHQ
V ODXGL YLGQL HVHKW IR HQRQ GQD GHWDOXFODF QHHE \GDHUOD VDK KFDH RW GHZR GUDZD HK7 QRLWXELUWVLG
D URI \ IL ODXT VNFHKF GHKVDFQX WXE HOEDUHYLOHG KWLZ VUHEPH0 VVDO&  HKW QRLWVHXT RQ VL
HUHK7 QRLWDFRO O$ IR QDO3 GQD WQHPHHUJ$ HKW QL URI GHWQXRFFD \OWLFL OS[H HUHZ VNFHKF GHKVDFQX WXE
HOEDUHYL OHG HK7 ODP L QLP HE O OLZ QRLWXELUWVLG GQXRUGQRFHV \QD RW \DOHG HKW HURPUHKWUX)
´VWQDP LDOF
\ OHPLW \E \UHYRFHU QL QRLWFXGHU HOXFVL QLP D \ OQR QL WOXVHU GOXRZ³ RV JQLRG HUHKZ VP LDOF GHOL I
HWDO HYLI JQLZROOD  WD G)  VWQHL= JH HH6 QRLWXELUWVLG GHHWQDUDXJ V¶UHEPH0 VVDO& \QD

HFXGHU WRQ OO LZ QRLVQHW[H HKW GHQLDOS[H \GDHUOD VD VVHOGUDJH5 GHWWLPUHS VL QRLVQHW[H HKW IL QLDJ
RW GQDWV WQHPWDHUW KWODHK ODWQHP ULHKW URI HJDUHYRF GHLQHG RVOD HUHZ RKZ WXE NFHKF D GHKVDF WH\



HJGX- WFLUWVL' VHWDW6 GHWLQ8
O ODGQH. 0 DL QLJUL9 QR+
BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB

  UHERWF2 HWD'

GQX) WQHPHOWWH6 ODXGLVH5 HKW HWXELUWVLG RW  WN' QRLWDFRO O$ IR QDO3 HKW UHGQX VHUXGHFRUS
GQD HOXGHKFV HKW HPXVHU O ODKV URWDUWVL QLPG$ WQHPHOWWH6 HKW GRLUHS \DG HKW IR QRLVXOFQRF HKW
Q2 PHKW RW HOED\DS HGDP VNFHKF HKW KVDF WRQ GLG WXE GHYLHFHU RKZ VUHEPH0 VVDO& WQHPHOWWH6
HKW RW VQRLWXELUWVLG HWHOSPRF RW WSPHWWD UHKWUXI RW UHGU2 VLKW IR HWDG HKW PRUI V\DG  HYDK
O ODKV URWDUWVL QL PG$ WQHPHOWWH6 HK7 GHWQDUJ VL  WN' HQL OGDH' QRLWXELUWVL' JQLGQHW[( \E
WQHPHOWWH6 IR QRLWDUWVL QL PG$ \ ILGR0 RW QRLWR0 ¶VI ILWQLDO3 HYRED KWURI WHV VQRVDHU HKW UR)
12,68/&12&

VNFHKF GHKVDFQX WXE HOEDUHYLOHG HKW IR QRLWXELUWVLG HWHOSPRF RW
Q RLVQHW[H \DG HKW JQLWWLPUHS URYDI VHLWLXTH HKW HFQDODE Q2 QRLVQHW[H HKW JQLWVHXTHU QL KWLDI
GRRJ QL GHWFD HYDK VI ILWQLDO3 WDKW HWXSVLG WRQ RG VWQDGQHIH' GQD VGQLI WUXR& HKW \ O ODQL)
G, WQXRFFD NQDE D RW VVHFFD IR NFDO GQD UHEPHP
\ O L PDI D IR KWDHG VHVXRSV QHHZWHE QRLWDFLQXPPRFVLP D NFHKF HKW IR ODYLUUD HWDO HOSPD[H URI
GHYLHFHU VNFHKF HKW GHKVDF JQLYDK WRQ URI VQRVDHU HOEDL ILWVXM HUD HGHFQRF VWQDGQHIH' WDKZ KWLZ
GUDZURI HPRF HYDK VNFHKF GHKVDFQX KWLZ VUHE PH0 VVDO&  HKW IR HYLI WFDI Q,  ˆ WD GL HH6
O LDP HKW QL GHYLUUD WL QHKZ NFHKF HKW GHNRROUHYR UR WVRO UHKWLH GQD JQLPRFKWURI VDZ NFHKF D ZRQN
WRQ GLG ODXGL YLGQL HKW GHUUXFFR GHWURSHU \GDHUOD UHEPH0 VVDO& HQR VD \ OHNLO HURP VL W, NFHKF
HKW KVDF WRQ \ OODQRLWQHWQL GQD HFLWRQ GOXRZ ODXGL YLGQL RQ VHPXVVD WUXR& HKW VUDOORG IR VGQDVXRKW