Mays Gillon v. University of Illinois Health & Science Systems et al

Filing 55

MEMORANDUM Opinion and Order signed by the Honorable Virginia M. Kendall on 7/30/2018. The Court denies Defendants' Motion to Dismiss 45 . Mailed notice(lk, )


 Q,  ˆ WD G, WVL ODLFHS6 HVUX1 HQL/ &&,3 IR QRLWLVRS WQHQDPUHS HKW RW GHULK VDZ QRO OL*
 Q, ± ˆ WD G, HFLII2 HFUXRVH5 JQLVUX1 V¶GUDR% HKW KJXRKW ´HVUX1 [HO)³ D VD GUDR% HKW
\E GH\ROSPH VDZ QDFLUHP$ QDFLUI$ QD QRO O L*  RW  PRU)  ˆ WD  WN' ´PHWV\6
V LRQL OO, IR \WLVUHYLQ8 HKW IR \GRE JQLQUHYRJ³ HKW VL GUDR% HK7  UL& KW   G)
 WQHPD&F0 Y ]HULPD5QRUHGOD& HH6 VV L PVL' RW QRLWR0 ¶VWQDGQHIH' IR VHVRSUXS URI HXUW
HE RW GHPXVVD GQD WQLDOSPR& GHGQHP$ GQRFH6 V¶QRO O L* QL GHJHOOD HUD VWFDI JQLZROORI HK7
'1825*.&$%

GHLQHG VL QRLWR0 ¶VWQDGQHIH' ZROHE KWURI WHV VQRVDHU HKW UR) HJGXM GHQJLVUHGQX
HKW RW GHQJLVVDHU VDZ WLXV HKW GHIHLUE \ O OXI VDZ QRLWR0 HKW UHWI$  WN' E HUXGHFRU3
O L YL& IR HOX5 ODUHGH) RW WQDXVUXS VVL PVLG RW GHYRP HYDK QLDJD VWQDGQHIH'  WN' WQLDOSPR&
GHGQHP$ GQRFH6 D GHO LI QRO OL*  WN' HY( W6 HJGX- \E GHVVL PVLG VDZ WQLDOSPR& GHGQHP$
WVUL) UHK UHWI$  † &68  GQD THV WH H † &68  GHGQHPD VD  IR WF$ VWKJL5
O LYL& HKW IR ,,9 HOWL7 IR QRLWDORLY QL HFDU UHK QR GHVDE QRLWDQL PLUFVLG WQHP \ROSPH GHJHOOD URI
´VWQDGQHIH'³ \ OHYLWFHOORF HONL2 HQDL' URVLYUHSXV UHK GQD ´GUDR%³ HKW VLRQL OO, IR \WLVUHYLQ8
HKW IR VHHWVXU7 IR GUDR% HKW WVQLDJD WLXV VLKW GHO LI QRO OL* V\D0 5 \HOUHYH% I ILWQLDO3
5('52 '1$ 12,1,32 08'1$520(0

O ODGQH. 0 DL QLJUL9 QR+
 &  R1

VWQDGQHIH'
(/.,2 (1$,'
GQD 6,21,//, )2 <7,65(9,18
([phone] '5$2%
Y
I ILWQLDO3
12//,* 6<$0 5 </5(9(%

12,6,9,' 15(76$(
6,21,//, )2 7&,576,' 15(+7521 (+7 52)
7582& 7&,576,' 6(7$76 '(7,18 (+7 1,



R7  UL& KW   G)  RJDFLK& IR \WL& Y NDLEX. JQLWRXT  WD G) 
]HULPD5QRUHGOD& ´¶I ILWQLDOS HKW IR URYDI QL VHFQHUHIQL HOEDQRVDHU O OD ZDUG GQD WQLDOSPRF HKW QL
VWFDI GHGDHOSO OHZ HKW IR OOD HXUW VD @V>WSHFFDµ³ WUXR& HKW E HOX5 UHGQX VVL PVLG RW QRLWRP D
IR VHVRSUXS UR) WQLDOSPRF HKW IR \FQH L FLI IXV ODJHO HKW VHJQHO ODKF QRLWRP E HOX5 $
'5$'1$76 /$*(/

  WD G,
´QRLWDQL P LUFVLG KVLORED RW WQDGQHIH' JQLULXTHU³ QRLWFQXMQL WQHQDPUHS D GQD VHJDPDG HYLWLQXS
VHJDPDG \URWDVQHSPRF QL  VNHHV QRO O L*  WN' HONL2 WVQLDJD P LDOF  † D  GQD
GUDR% HKW WVQLDJD P LDOF ,,9 HOWL7 D  VWQXRF RZW VQLDWQRF WQLDOSPR& GHGQHP$ GQRFH6 V¶QRO OL*
 WN' UHWWHO HXV RW WKJLU D GHYLHFHU HKV  KFUD0 QL HFDU UHK IR HVXDFHE QRLWDWRU GQD
VHLWXG HVUX1 HJUDK& UHK PRUI GHYRPHU QHHE GDK HKV WDKW JQL QLDOSPRF QRLVVL PPR& \WLQXWURSS2
WQHP\ROSP( ODXT( HKW KWLZ QRLWDQL P LUFVLG IR HJUDKF D GHO LI QRO OL*  UHEPHFH' Q,
VWFDI UHKWR ZHI
VHJHO OD QRO OL*  ˆ WD G, GHWRPHG VDZ HKV WDKW VHJHOOD RVOD QRO OL*  ˆ WD G, ´JQLQLDUW GQD
QRLWDWRU VHLWXG HVUX1 HJUDK& PRUI GHGXOF[H WRQ HUHZ VQDFLUHP$ QDFLUI$QRQ GHWDXWLV \ OUDO L PLV³
WDKW VHJHOOD QRO O L* VHQLO HPDV HVHKW JQRO$ ± ˆˆ WD G, VWURSHU HFQDPURIUHS HWDXTHGD UHK
HWLSVHG HFDU UHK IR WQXRFFD QR VDZ ODYRPHU UHK WDKW GQD VHLWXG HVUX1 HJUDK& PRUI GHYRPHU HVUXQ
\ OQR HKW VDZ HKV WDKW VHJHOOD QROOL*  ˆ WD G, VHLWLYLWFD HVHKW PRUI QRO O L* HGXOF[H RW QRLVLFHG HKW
HGDP HONL2 \ O ODFLILFHS6  ˆ WD G, VHLWLQXWURSSR ODQRLWRPRUS GQD \DS IR VVRO UHK QL JQLWOXVHU
VHLWLQXWURSSR JQLQLDUW GQD ´QRLWDWRU GQD VHLWXG HVUX1 HJUDK&³ PRUI IILWQLDO3 HGXOF[H RW QDJHE
VWQDGQHIH'  IR JQLUS6 HKW QL WDKW VHJHOOD QROOL*  ˆ WD G, ODWLSVR+ RJDFLK& WD VLRQL OO, IR
\WLVUHYLQ8 HKW WD ED/ \JRORUHWQHRUWVD* HKW IR URWFHUL' WQDWVLVV$ HKW VDZ RKZ HONL2 IR QRL VLYUHSXV
HKW UHGQX GHNURZ HKV QRLWLVRS VLKW Q,  ˆ WD G, HVUX1 \JRORUHWQHRUWVD* D HPDFHE QRO OL*



QRLJLOHU URORF HFDU V¶ODXGL YLGQL KFXV IR HVXDFHE WQHP\ROSPH IR VHJHO LYLUS UR VQRLWLGQRF VPUHW
QRLWDVQHSPRF VLK RW WFHSVHU KWLZ ODXGLYLGQL \QD WVQLDJD HWDQL PLUFVLG RW HVLZUHKWR UR ODXGL YLGQL
\QD HJUDKFVLG RW UR HULK RW HVXIHU UR OLDI RW³ UH\ROSPH QD URI OXIZDOQX WL VHNDP ,,9 HOWL7
GUDR% HKW WVQLDJ$ PLDO& ,,9 HOWL7 , WQXR&

,

 WD  WN' \UHYRFVLG RW GHHFRUS RW HVDF HKW ZROOD
WRQ GOXRKV WDKW ´VWQHPHOH ¶VP LDOF HKW IR QRLWDWLFHU VHQRE HUDE³ QD QDKW HURP JQLKW\QD GHWQHVHUS
WRQ VDK QRO OL* WDKW HXJUD VWQDGQHIH' VL WDK7  WD  WN' ´QRLWDQL P LUFVLG ODLFDU URI HOEDL O
HUD VWQDGQHIH' WDKW HFQHUHIQL HKW ZDUG \ OEDQRVDHU RW WUXRF D ZROOD WDKW VWFDI KJXRQH GDHOS WRQ
VDK @QRO OL*> WDKW³ HXJUD VWQDGQHIH' WQLDOSPR& GHGQHP$ GQRFH6 HKW VVL PVLG RW JQLYRP Q,
12,668&6,'


UL& KW   G)  RJDFLK& IR \WL& Y VQLNW$ HH6 HORKZ D VD \WL O L ELVXDOS VWL VHVVHVVD GQD
WQLDOSPRF HKW VGDHU WUXR& HK7 GHWWLPR QRLWDWLF  UL& KW   G)  FQ, VUHLKWRO&
NQD% $ VR- Y DWVDPD&

´QRLVXOFQRF GQD VOHEDO QDKW HURP VHULXTHU IHLOHU RW @WQHP>HOWLWQH

@UHK> IR VGQXRUJ HKW HGLYRUS RW QRLWDJLOER V¶I ILWQLDOS³ D QRLWLGGD Q,    68
 ODET, Y WIRUFKV$ ´HFL IIXV WRQ RG VWQHPHWDWV \URVXOFQRF HUHP \E GHWURSSXV QRLWFD IR HVXDF
D IR VWQHPHOH HKW IR VODWLFHU HUDEGDHUK7³  UL& KW   G)  \W& NRR& IR WUXR&
WLXFUL& HKW IR HJGX- IHLK& HKW IR HFLII2 Y LUX+ ´VWVHU WL KFLKZ QRSX VGQXRUJ HKW GQD VL P LDOF

HKW WDKZ IR HFLWRQ ULDI WQDGQHIHG HKW HYLJ WVXP WQLDOSPRF HKW WXE \UDVVHFHQQX HUD VWFDI FL I LFHS6³
 UL& KW   G)  FQ, VYUH6 KWODH+ DUWQHFQR& Y &2(( JQLWRXT 
UL& KW   G)  KWX$ \DZKJL+ OOR7 HWDW6 OO, Y QDUKFR& ´¶OHYHO HYLWDOXFHSV D HYRED
\ WL O LELVVRS WDKW JQLVLDU IHLOHU RW WKJLU D VDK IILWQ LDOS HKW WDKW WVHJJXV \ O ELVXDOSµ³ HXUW VD QHNDW QHKZ
KFLKZ VWFDI HJHOOD WVXP WQLDOSPRF V¶II LWQLDOS D E HOX5 UHGQX VVLPVLG RW QRLWRP D HYLYUXV



QRLWDJHOOD
HPDV  ˆ WD GL RVOD HHV  ˆ WD G, QRLWDWRU HVUX1 HJUDK& HKW PRUI GHYRPHU HVUXQ \OQR HKW VDZ
HKV WDKW VHJHOOD RVOD HK6 QRLWDJHO OD HPDV  ˆ WD GL RVOD HHV  ˆ WD  WN' ´QRLWDFXGH GQD
HFQHLUHS[H HJGHOZRQN VD KFXV VHWXELUWWD QL QR O OL* RW UDO L PLV HUHZ VHVUXQ HVHKW GQD JQLQLDUW GQD
QRLWDWRU VHLWXG HVUX1 HJUDK& PRUI GHGXOF[H WRQ HUHZ VQDFLUHP$ QDFLUI$QRQ GHWDXWLV \ OUDO L PLV
WDKW QL HFDU UHK RW HXG QRO O L* GHGXOF[H VWQDGQHIH'³ WDKW VHJHOOD WQLDOSPR& GHGQHP$ GQRFH6
HKW WQHYH \QD Q, VQRLWDJHOOD ZHQ HYLWDFLOSXG VHPLWHPRV WKJLH JQLGGD WQDYHOHU VD WQLDOSPR&
GHGQHP$ GQRFH6 UHK GHO L I QROOL* WOXVHU D V$ G, HFDU UHK RW QRLWFD WQHP \ROSPH HVUHYGD GHJHOOD
HKW JQLWFHQQRF QL VDZ UHYHZRK WURKV O OHI HKV HUHK:  WD  WN' VHLWLQXWURSSR ODQRLWRPRUS
GQD \DS IR VVRO D QL GHWOXVHU WDKW JQLQLDUW PRUI JQLGXOF[H JQLHE GQD VHLWXG HVUX1 HJUDK& GHQJLVVD
JQLHE WRQ \E QRLWFD WQHP \ROSPH HVUHYGD QD GHUHIIXV HKV WDKW GQD HVUXQ D VD GHL I LODXT VDZ HKV WDKW
QDFLUHP$ QDFLUI$ VL HKV WDKW GHJHO OD \ OWQHLFL I IXV GDK QRO OL* WDKW GOHK \OVXRLYHUS WUXR& HK7
   68  DPHUR6 Y ]FLZHLNUHLZ6 ´WQHPHULXTHU JQLGDHOS
D WRQ GUDGQDWV \UDLWQHGLYH QD WL HVXDFHE HVDF HLFDI DPLUS D GDHOS³ RW GHULXTHU WRQ VL QRO OL* WDKW VL
VQDHP VLKW WDK:  WD G)  LUX+ HH6 HJDWV WQHPJGXM \UDPPXV HKW WD ´WHHP \OWQHXTHVEXV
WVXP I ILWQLDOS D QHGUXE \UDLWQHGLYH HKW PRUI WQHUHI ILG HVUXRF IR HUD VHVDF ,,9 HOWL7 QL VGUDGQDWV
JQLGDHOS³ HKW \ OODFLILFHS6  UL& KW   G)  SVQDU7 GH0 5&6 Y HWD7 HQR
´JQLGQDPHGQX³ QD WFDI QL VL GUDGQDWV JQLGDHOS ,,9 HOWL7 HK7  UL& KW   G) 
R&

HUHH' Y QDZR*F0 JQLWLF  UL& KW   G)  SU* QL) 6

: Y RQLWUD0

´\ OEDURYDI HURP GHWDHUW HUHZ VVDOF GHWFHWRUS HKW QL WRQ VQRVUHS GHWDXWLV \ OUDO L PLV  GQD QRLWFD
WQHP \ROSPH HVUHYGD QD GHUHIIXV HK@V>  QRLWLVRS URI GHLOSSD HKW URI GHL I LODXT VDZ HK@V> 
VVDOF GHWFHWRUS D IR UHEPHP VL HK@V> ³ VWQHPHOH JQLZROORI HKW ZRKV WVXP QRO OL* ,,9 HOWL7
IR QRLWDORLY D URI P LDOF D HWDWV RW UHGUR Q, DH † $&68  ´QLJLUR ODQRLWDQ UR [HV



HUD VP LDOF WQHP \ROSPH QRLWDQLP LUFVLG HFDU  † GQD ,,9 HOWL7  UL& KW   G)
 HWLK: Y VUHJGR5 HH6 OLDI ,, WQXR& IR ODVV LPVLG IR URYDI QL VWQHPXJUD HWDFL OSXG ¶VWQDGQHIH'
GHOS \OWQHLFL IIXV VL GUDR% HKW WVQLDJD P LDOF ,,9 HOWL7 V¶QRO OL* WDKW VHGXOFQRF WUXR& HKW HVXDFHE
WX%  WD  WN' , WQXR& IR ODVVLPVLG IR URYDI QL GHWUHVVD \HKW VGQXRUJ HPDV HKW QR GHVVL PVLG
HE GOXRKV ,, WQXR& WDKW HFQHWQHV HOJQLV D QL HXJUD VWQDGQHIH' \WLFDSDF ODXGL YLGQL UHK QL HONL2
WQDGQHIH' WVQLDJD  † &68  UHGQX QRLWDQLP LUFVLG IR P LDOF D VJQLUE RVOD I ILWQLDO3
HONL2 WQDGQHIH' WVQLDJ$ PLDO&  † &68  ,, WQXR&

,,

GHLQHG VL , WQXR& VVL PVLG RW QRLWRP ¶VWQDGQHIH'  WD
 WN' HJDWV VLKW WD GHUHGLVQRF \OHWDLUSRUSSD WRQ VL QDFLUHP$ QDFLUI$ VL HVUX1 HJUDK& HKW VD
VHYUHV \OWQHUUXF RKZ ODXGL YLGQL HKW HVXDFHE QRLWDQL PLUFVLG HFDU URI P LDOF D HWDWV WRQQDF QRO OL* WDKW
WQHPXJUD ¶VWQDGQHIH' WQLRS ODQLI D V$ ´@UHGQHJ UR HFDU UHK> IR VLVDE HKW QR I ILWQLDOS HKW WVQLDJD
QRLWFD WQHP \ROSPH HVUHYGD GHL ILFHSV D GHWXWLWVQL UH\ROSPH HKW WDKW UHYD \OQR GHHQ QRLWDQL PLUFVLG
@UHGQHJ UR HFDU> JQLJHOOD WQLDOSPRF D³  UL& KW   G)  NUD3 HVRUOH0
IR OOL9 Y VLDODYD/ RVOD HHV VVL PVLG RW QRLWRP E HOX5 D HYLYUXV RW WQHLFL I IXV VL ´HFDU

\ P IR HVXDFHE ERM D URI QZRG GHQUXW VDZ ,³ ´\ O ODUHQHJ HWLXT³ VHWDWV WDKW QRLWDJHO OD QD  UL&
KW   G)  WGLPKF6 Y WWHQQH% HH6 HFDU UHK IR WQXRFFD QR UHK WVQLDJD GHWDQL PLUFVLG
GUDR% HKW WDKW VHJHO OD \OHWDXTHGD WQLDOSPR& GHGQHP$ GQRFH6 V¶QRO O L* \ OJQLGURFF$
 UL& KW   G)  FQ, VYUH6 KWODH+ DUWQHFQR& Y &2(( ´PLDOF HKW RW
HFQDWURSP L ODFLWLUF UDHOF IR GQD HGLYRUS RW \VDH KWRE VL WDKW QRLWDPURIQL UHKWUXI RQ VL HUHKW HFDU UHK
IR VLVDE HKW QR VL WL WDKW GHL ILUDOF VDK QRLWDQLPLUFVLG ODJHO O L JQLJHO OD II LWQLDOS D HFQ@2>³ VWFDI HVHKW
GHJHO OD VDK QRO OL*  UL& KW ±  G)  $1 NQDELWL& Y QRVQDZ6 HH6 QHKZ
GQD PRKZ \E GHUUXFFR VNQLKW HK WDKW QRLWDQL P LUFVLG IR HS\W HKW HJHO OD \OQR GHHQ QRLWDQL PLUFVLG
WQHP \ROSPH JQLJHOOD I ILWQLDOS D VGUDGQDWV JQLGDHOSHFLWRQ ODUHGHI JQL O LDYHUS UHGQX QLDJ$



HJGX- WFLUWVL' VHWDW6 GHWLQ8
O ODGQH. 0 DL QLJUL9 QR+
BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB

  \OX- HWD'

\UHYRFVLG RW GHHFRUS O OLZ VP LDOF V¶QRO OL* 
WN' VVL PVL' RW QRLWR0 ¶VWQDGQHIH' VHLQHG WUXR& HKW HYRED KWURI WHV VQRVDHU HKW UR)
12,68/&12&

VHYLYUXV WL ,, WQXR& VVLPVLG RW VGQXRUJ UHKWR
\ QD IR HFQHVED HKW Q,  WD G)  VLDODYD/ RVOD HHV VGUDGQDWV HPDV HKW UHGQX GH]\ ODQD