Richerme et al v. Trumbull Insurance Co.

Filing 14

MOTION by Defendant Trumbull Insurance Co. for judgment , MOTION by Defendant Trumbull Insurance Co. for judgment on the pleadings (Sliwinski, Mark)

I T HEU N I ED S T A T ES DI T R I CO U R T
N
T
S
CT
FO R T HEN O R T HER N DI T R I O FI L I O I
S
CT
L N S
EA S T ER N DI S I N
VI O
EDW AR D R I
CHER M Ea KAR EN R I
nd
CHER M E, )
)
P l i fs
antif ,
)
)
v
.
)
)
T R U M BU L L I S U R AN CECO M P AN Y,
N
)
)
Def
enda
nt,
)
)
)
)
T R U M BU L L I S U R AN CECO M P AN Y,
N
)
)
CounterP l i f,
- antif
)
)
v
.
)
)
EDW AR D R I
CHER M Ea KAR EN R I
nd
CHER M E, )
)
CounterDef
- enda .
nts
)

CaeN o. 2018 c
s
:
v01286

T R U M BU L L I S U R A N CECO M P A N Y’S M O T I N FO R J DGM EN T O N T HEP L EA DI GS
N
O
U
N
NO W

CO M ES

Def
enda
nt/CounterP l i f, T R U M BU L L
- antif

I S U R AN CE CO M P AN Y
N

( T r bul ) by i a neys iha .Dufy a M akJ lw i kiofW is s osow i
“ um l , ts ttor
”
M c elJ
f nd r .S i ns
lonElerM
k tzEdel a
m n
& Dik L L P , her
c er
eby m ov
esthi
sHonor bl Cour f J
ae
t or udgm ent on the P l di
ea ngson i
ts

Counter l i a on P l i fs
cam nd
antif /CounterDef
- enda ’,Edw ad R iher e ( Edw ad” )a Kaen
nts
r c m “
r
nd r
R iher e ( Kaen” )( ol tiel the “ R iher es) Com pl i pur ua to Fed.R .Ci.P .12( )
c m “ r
c l v y,
ec
c m ” ,
ant
s nt
v
c
f the r s
or
eaons s f th i T r bul s
et or
n
um l
’s uppor ng M em or ndum
ti
a
c
ontem por neous her i
a
l
y
ew th.

2481639v.1

of L a , fl
w
i
ed

W HER EFO R E,f l
oralofthe f egoi r s ,T r bul es tf l r
or ng eaons um lr pec ul eques
y
tstha thi
t s
Cour a ts oti f udgm enton the P l di , i ng T r bul es R iher es
tgr nti M
on orJ
ea ngs fndi
um low the c m no
duty to def
end ori
ndem niy, r bul d not br c the r ev nt i ur nc pol y,T r bul
f T um ldi
ea h
el a ns a e i
c
um l
di not a t i ba f i a a ad T r bul uc othera f therr i sthi
d
c n d ath, nd w r um ls h
nd ur
el
efa sCour deem s
t
j ta equi bl i l nga w ad ofc ts
us nd
ta e,ncudi na r
os .
Da
ted: Aprl 2018
i25,

R es tf l s i
pec ul ubm tted,
y
T R U M BU L L I S U R AN CECO M P AN Y
N
By: /s iha J
/M c el .Dufy
f
O neofI Attor
ts
neys

M iha J
c el .Dufy ( iha . f w i onelerc )
f m c eldufy@ l
s s . om
M akJ l i k ( ak sw i k@ w i onelerc )
r .S i nsi m r . l nsi l
w
i
s s . om
W i onElerM osow i
l
s
s
k tzEdel a Dik L P
m n& c erL
55 W es onr tr
tM
oeS eet- ui
S te3800
Chia I 60603
c go,L
(
312)7040550
(
312)7041522 ( a
f x)
Fim ID.# 16741
r .

2481639v.1

CER T I CA T EO FS ER VI
FI
CE
Iher c tiy tha
eby er f
ton Aprl25,
i
2018, ec onial fl the aor ad doc ent( )w i the
Iel tr c l i
y ed
f esi
um
s th
Cl koftheCour i
er
tus
ngtheECFs tem w hihw i s notiia onofs hfl
ys
c l end
l
fc ti
uc ingtoal r es
i
lpati of
r or i thi c s by oper ti ofthe Cour el tr cfl s tem a
ec d n s ae
a on
t’s ec oni ing ys
i
nd/orU . .M al P ati
S
i
. r es
m a a c s s ingthr
y c es thi fl
i
oughtheCour s tem .
t’s ys
Cor i M c ght
nel
us Kni
S ta ey A.Ki nger
nl
tzi
M c ght& Ki nger L L C
Kni
tzi ,
117 N or efer onS tr S ui
thJ f s
eet, te301
Chia Il s
c go,lnoi 60661
i
nea@ m k a yer . om
l
pl w s
c
s n@ m k a yer . om
ta
pl w s
c
/s iha J Dufy____
/M c el . f

2481639v.1