Sprint Communications Company LP v. Vonage Holdings Corp., et al
Filing
320
OBJECTION(S) to 286 Witness List, 285 Exhibit List by Vonage America, Inc., Vonage Holdings Corp.. (Campbell, Terrence)
<![CDATA[
Sprint Communications Company LP v. Vonage Holdings Corp., et al
Doc. 320
Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL
Document 320
Filed 08/22/2007
Page 1 of 27
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF KANSAS __________________________________________ ) SPRINT COMMUNICATIONS COMPANY, L.P., ) ) Plaintiff, ) ) Case No. 05-2433-JWL v. ) ) VONAGE HOLDINGS CORP. AND ) VONAGE AMERICA, INC., ) Defendants. ) __________________________________________) VONAGE'S OBJECTIONS TO SPRINT'S WITNESS AND EXHIBIT LIST Pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 26 and 32 and the Final Pretrial Order (Doc. 207) entered in this matter, Defendants Vonage Holdings Corp. and Vonage America, Inc. (collectively "Vonage"), respectfully submit the following objections to Plaintiff Sprint Communications Company L.P.'s ("Sprint") designations of trial witnesses and exhibits. Vonage expressly reserves all objections under Fed. R. Civ. P. 402 and 403 pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(a)(3). Reserving its objections under Fed. R. Evid. (FRE) 402-403, as permitted by Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(a)(3), Vonage makes the following objections: GENERAL OBJECTION Vonage generally objects to each and every exhibit listed by Sprint to the extent addressed by a Motion in Limine filed by Vonage. Vonage also objects to each and every exhibit listed by Sprint that was not produced pursuant to discovery requests.
Dockets.Justia.com
Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL
Document 320
Filed 08/22/2007
Page 2 of 27
EXHIBITS Vonage's objections to the exhibits identified by Sprint are set forth in Exhibit A. Vonage reserves the right to object to any exhibits identified by Sprint at a later date. TRIAL WITNESSES Vonage objects to any individual's testimony from the Verizon v. Vonage matter for the reasons set forth in Vonage's pending Motions in Limine. Vonage also objects to the inclusion of Don Lewis and Terry Yake on Sprint's Witness list, as Sprint refused to provide these individuals for deposition, asserting health issues and assuring Vonage that these individuals would not be called at trial. Vonage has no objection to the identification of Sprint's other witnesses, subject to Vonage's objections to the proferred deposition testimony of the individuals cited in Sprint's Witness List. Vonage reserves the right to object to specific portions of testimony from individuals cited in Sprint's Witness List.
Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL
Document 320
Filed 08/22/2007
Page 3 of 27
August 22, 2007
Respectfully submitted, _/s/ Terrence J. Campbell Terrence J. Campbell - 18377 Catherine C. Theisen - 22360 BARBER EMERSON, L.C. 1211 Massachusetts Street P.O. Box 667 Lawrence, KS 66044 (785) 843-6600 (785) 843-8405 Facsimile _/s/ Helesa Lahey Patrick D. McPherson Barry Golob Donald R. McPhail Patrick C. Muldoon Helesa K. Lahey Duane Morris LLP 1667 K Street N.W. Washington, DC 20006-1608 202-776-7800 Attorneys for Defendants/Counterclaim Plaintiffs Vonage Holdings Corp. and Vonage America, Inc.
Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL
Document 320
Filed 08/22/2007
Page 4 of 27
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify on August 22, 2007, that a copy of VONAGE'S OBJECTIONS TO SPRINT'S WITNESS AND EXHIBIT LIST was e-filed and served via the Court's electronic filing system: B. Trent Webb Adam P. Seitz Eric A. Buresh Shook, Hardy & Bacon LLP 2555 Grand Boulevard Kansas City, MO 64108-2613 bwebb@shb.com aseitz@shb.com eburesh@shb.com Attorneys for Plaintiff Sprint Communications Company L.P.
_/s/ Helesa Lahey Attorney for Defendants
Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL
Document 320
Filed 08/22/2007
Page 5 of 27
EXHIBIT A
Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL
Document 320
Filed 08/22/2007
Page 6 of 27
Exhibit No. 21.
Description Newsletter Memorializing Joe Christie
Objection No. Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403
22.
Photos of Christie
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-402
23.
"The Definition of Easy"
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403
24.
Email from Timothy Smith to Jeffrey Citron and Louis Mamakos re: stopping the bleeding (2/23/06)
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403
25.
Emails between Louis Mamakos Hearsay, FRE 801-802. and Sylvain Abitol re: Our patents Foundation, may solve your 911 situation Authentication FRE 901. (12/5/05) FRE 401-403 FRE 406
Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL
Document 320
Filed 08/22/2007
Page 7 of 27
Exhibit No. 26.
Description Emails between Jeff Citron, Michael Morris and Louis Mamokos re: please call me-Michael Morris (5/16/06 AND 6/3/06)
Objection No. Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403
27.
Emails between Louis Mamakos and Greg Lightnerre: UltraDNS Introduction (12/2/05)
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403 FRE 406
28.
Emails between Louis Mamakos, Brian Dworkin, and Ed Mulligan re: XO Communications (5/5/06)
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403
29.
Emails between John Paolillo, Rohan Dwarka, Chris Stummer and Joseph Malcom re: Pine Bluff Circuit E911 (1/11/06)
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403 FRE 406 Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403 FRE 406
30.
Emails between John Paolillo, Rohan Dwarka, Chris Stummer and Joseph Malcom re: Pine Bluff Circuit E911 (1/11/06)
31.
Emails between John Paolillo, Rohan Dwarka, Chris Stummer and Joseph Malcom, Nicholas DeLuca and Marek Niemiec re: plz help
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403 FRE 406
Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL
Document 320
Filed 08/22/2007
Page 8 of 27
Exhibit No. 32.
Description Email forwarding Wall Street Journal article titled "Vonage Faces User Complaints as IPO Looms" (5/18/06)
Objection No. Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403 Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403
33.
Vonage Presentations
34.
Vonage Presentations
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403
35.
Vonage Presentations
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403
40.
Vonage Facilities Powerpoint
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403
45.
Draft Executive Summary (5/7/2005)
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403
51.
Email from Niraj Shah to Jeffrey Citron, Mike Snyder, John Rego, Johathan Turnbull, Gerrit Parker and Bret Varsov (5/17/06) Email from John Rego to Brooke Schultz (2/14/06)
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403 Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403
52.
Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL
Document 320
Filed 08/22/2007
Page 9 of 27
Exhibit No. 63.
Description Bonanza Project Detailed Requirements Statement (6/4/97)
Objection No. Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403, FRE 106
79.
http://www.sprint.com/companyin fo/history/, "Milestone Events making Sprint History: 18991989"
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403 Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403 Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403
83- 86
Emails between Mike Hughes, Barry Golob, Masoud Kamali, and David Heckadon (11/08/06), (09/01/06), and (08/30/06) Citron Deposition Exhibits #20 and 21
118 and 119
125.
Dwarkha Deposition Exhibit #1
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901.
126.
Dwarkha Deposition Exhibit #2
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901.
127.
Dwarkha Deposition Exhibit #3
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901.
128. 130.
Dwarkha Deposition Exhibit #4 Eisen Deposition Exhibit #1
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403
131.
Eisen Deposition Exhibit #2
Hearsay, FRE 801-802.
Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL
Document 320
Filed 08/22/2007
Page 10 of 27
Exhibit No.
Description
Objection No. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403
132.
Eisen Deposition Exhibit #3
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403
133.
Eisen Deposition Exhibit #4
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403
134.
Eisen Deposition Exhibit #5
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403
135.
Eisen Deposition Exhibit #6
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403
136.
Eisen Deposition Exhibit #7
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403
137.
Eisen Deposition Exhibit #8
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403
138.
Gorrepati Deposition Exhibit #2
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901.FRE 401-403 FRE 602
Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL
Document 320
Filed 08/22/2007
Page 11 of 27
Exhibit No. 141.
Description Holder Deposition Exhibit #10
Objection No. Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403.
142.
Holder Deposition Exhibit #13
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403. FRE 602.
143.
Holder Deposition Exhibit #14
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403. FRE 602.
144.
Holder Deposition Exhibit #15
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403. FRE 602.
145.
Holder Deposition Exhibit #17
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403. FRE 106
146.
Mamakos Deposition Exhibit #1
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901.FRE 401-403
147.
Mamakos Deposition Exhibit #2
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901.FRE 401-403 FRE 106. FRE 602
148.
Mamakos Deposition Exhibit #3
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901.
Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL
Document 320
Filed 08/22/2007
Page 12 of 27
Exhibit No.
Description
Objection No. FRE 401-403
149.
Mamakos Deposition Exhibit #4
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403 Subject to Motion in Limine
150.
Mamakos Deposition Exhibit #5
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403 FRE 602
151.
Mamakos Deposition Exhibit #8
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901.FRE 401-403 FRE 106
152.
Mamakos Deposition Exhibit #11
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403
153.
Mamakos Deposition Exhibit #12
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403 FRE 602
154.
Mamakos Deposition Exhibit #13
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901.FRE 401-403 FRE 602
155.
Mamakos Deposition Exhibit #14
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE
Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL
Document 320
Filed 08/22/2007
Page 13 of 27
Exhibit No.
Description
Objection No. 901.FRE 401-403 FRE 602
156.
Mamakos Deposition Exhibit #15
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901.FRE 401-403 FRE 602
157.
Mamakos Deposition Exhibit #16
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901.FRE 401-403 FRE 602
158.
Mamakos Deposition Exhibit #17
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901.FRE 401-403 FRE 602
159.
Mamakos Deposition Exhibit #18
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901.FRE 401-403
160.
Mamakos Deposition Exhibit #19
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901.FRE 401-403
161.
Mamakos Deposition Exhibit #20
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901.FRE 401-403 FRE 602
164.
Martinez Deposition Exhibit #2
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901.
Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL
Document 320
Filed 08/22/2007
Page 14 of 27
Exhibit No.
Description
Objection No. FRE 401-403 FRE 106
165.
Martinez Deposition Exhibit #3
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901.FRE 401-403 FRE 602
166.
Martinez Deposition Exhibit #8
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901.FRE 401-403 FRE 602
167.
Martinez Deposition Exhibit #9
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901.FRE 401-403
168.
Martinez Deposition Exhibit #10
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403
169.
Martinez Deposition Exhibit #11
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901.FRE 401-403 Subject to Motion in Limine. Attorney Client Privileged
170.
Martinez Deposition Exhibit #12
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901.FRE 401-403 Subject to Motion in Limine. Attorney Client Privileged
Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL
Document 320
Filed 08/22/2007
Page 15 of 27
Exhibit No. 171.
Description Miron Deposition Exhibit #2
Objection No. Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403 FRE 602
172.
Martinez Deposition Exhibit #3
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403 FRE 602
174.
Mulligan Deposition Exhibit #2
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403.
175.
Mulligan Deposition Exhibit #3
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403.
176.
Mulligan Deposition Exhibit #4
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403.
177.
Mulligan Deposition Exhibit #5
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403.
178.
Mulligan Deposition Exhibit #6
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403.
179.
Mulligan Deposition Exhibit #7
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation,
Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL
Document 320
Filed 08/22/2007
Page 16 of 27
Exhibit No.
Description
Objection No. Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403.
180.
Mulligan Deposition Exhibit #8
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403.
181.
Mulligan Deposition Exhibit #9
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403.
182.
Mulligan Deposition Exhibit #10
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403.
183.
Mulligan Deposition Exhibit #11
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403.
184.
Mulligan Deposition Exhibit #12
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403.
185.
Mulligan Deposition Exhibit #13
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403.
186.
Mulligan Deposition Exhibit #14
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403.
Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL
Document 320
Filed 08/22/2007
Page 17 of 27
Exhibit No. 187.
Description Mulligan Deposition Exhibit #15
Objection No. Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403.
188.
Mulligan Deposition Exhibit #16
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403.
189.
Mulligan Deposition Exhibit #17
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403.
192.
Rego Deposition Exhibit #5
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403. Also, Subject to Motion Limine
193.
Rego Deposition Exhibit #6
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403.
195.
Rego Deposition Exhibit #8
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403.
196.
Rego Deposition Exhibit #9
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403.
197.
Rego Deposition Exhibit #10
Hearsay, FRE 801-802.
Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL
Document 320
Filed 08/22/2007
Page 18 of 27
Exhibit No.
Description
Objection No. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403..
198.
Rego Deposition Exhibit #11
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403.
200.
Rego Deposition Exhibit #13
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403.
201.
Rego Deposition Exhibit #14
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403.
202.
Rego Deposition Exhibit #15
Withdrawn. Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403.
203.
Rego Deposition Exhibit #16
Withdrawn. Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403.
204.
Rego Deposition Exhibit #17
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403.
205.
Rego Deposition Exhibit #18
Withdrawn. Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901.
Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL
Document 320
Filed 08/22/2007
Page 19 of 27
Exhibit No.
Description
Objection No. FRE 401-403..
206.
Rego Deposition Exhibit #19
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403.
207.
Rego Deposition Exhibit #20
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403.
208.
Rego Deposition Exhibit #21
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403.
209.
Rego Deposition Exhibit #24
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403.
210.
Rego Deposition Exhibit #26
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403.
211.
Rego Deposition Exhibit #28
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403.
212.
Rego Deposition Exhibit #29
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403.
213.
Rego Deposition Exhibit #29A
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation,
Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL
Document 320
Filed 08/22/2007
Page 20 of 27
Exhibit No.
Description
Objection No. Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403.
214.
Rego Deposition Exhibit #30
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403. Also, subject to Motion in Limine.
215.
Rego Deposition Exhibit #31
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403.
216.
Setter Deposition (3/27/07) Exhibit #8
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403
228.
Wu Deposition Exhibit #1
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403. FRE 602.
229.
Wu Deposition Exhibit #2
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403. FRE 602.
230.
Wu Deposition Exhibit #3
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403. FRE 602.
232.
Wu Deposition Exhibit #6
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901.
Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL
Document 320
Filed 08/22/2007
Page 21 of 27
Exhibit No.
Description
Objection No. FRE 401-403.
233.
Wu Deposition Exhibit #7
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403.
234.
Wu Deposition Exhibit #8
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403.
235.
Wu Deposition Exhibit #9
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403.
236.
Wu Deposition Exhibit #10
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403.
237.
Wu Deposition Exhibit #11
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403.
238.
Wu Deposition Exhibit #13
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403.
239.
Wu Deposition Exhibit #14
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403.
247.
Halpern Deposition Exhibit #8
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation,
Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL
Document 320
Filed 08/22/2007
Page 22 of 27
Exhibit No.
Description
Objection No. Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403
248.
Halpern Deposition Exhibit #9
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403
251.
Halpern Deposition Exhibit #12
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901.FRE 401-403 Subject to Motion in Limine.
252.
Halpern Deposition Exhibit #13
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403 Subject to Motion in Limine.
253.
Kaplan Deposition Exhibit #1
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403 FRE 602
254.
Kaplan Deposition Exhibit #2
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403 FRE 602
258.
Koperda Deposition Exhibit #1
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403
259.
Koperda Deposition Exhibit #2
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901.
Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL
Document 320
Filed 08/22/2007
Page 23 of 27
Exhibit No.
Description
Objection No. FRE 401-403
275. 281.
Strickland Deposition Exhibit #2 Strickland Deposition Exhibit #8
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. FRE 401-403. FRE 106. Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403. FRE 602. FRE 106.
283.
Strickland Deposition Exhibit #11
Hearsay, FRE 801-803. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403. Also, subject to Motion in Limine.
284.
Strickland Deposition Exhibit #13
Hearsay, FRE 801-803. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403. FRE 602.
290.
Strickland Deposition Exhibit #21
Hearsay, FRE 801-803. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403. FRE 602
295.
Vonage 2008 Valuation Materials Presented by Deutsche Bank (June 2005)
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403 FRE 406
296.
Email from Citron re: Retention Reports
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901.
Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL
Document 320
Filed 08/22/2007
Page 24 of 27
Exhibit No.
Description
Objection No. FRE 401-403 FRE 406
297.
Email from Eisen re: Churn Topline
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403 FRE 406
298-300
Customer Emails re: Poor Service
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403 FRE 406
301-303
3i Valuation of Vonage; NEA's projections of Vonage's profitability; Bain Capital's projections of Vonage's profitability
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403 FRE 406
342.
Ebay Inc. 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2005
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403
344.
Telecommunications Industry Association's "TIA 2006 Telecommunications Market Review & Forecast" (website) Various Vonage Press Releases
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901.
347-353
Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL
Document 320
Filed 08/22/2007
Page 25 of 27
Exhibit No. 358.
Description http://cedmagazine.com/index.asp ?layout=articlePrint& articleID=CA6335969 - Sprint's Embarq starts new independent life" (May 18, 2006)
Objection No. Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403
361.
http://www.intertangent.com/0233 46/Articles_and_News/1413.html - "History of VoIP"
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403
362.
http://www.webconsult.com/1800. html - "Telecom History: The 1800s (Early History and the Great Fervor"), a website's history of telecom http://about.skype.com/2005/09/eb ay_to_acquire_skype.html - "eBay to Acquire Skype" (September 12, 2005)
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403 Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403 Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403 FRE 406 FRE 106
363.
364.
UBS Global Communications and Technology Conference Presentation (November 15, 2006)
367-368
Securities Filings of Third-Parties
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403
379.
"Broadband Cable: Next Steps," Address of William E. Kennard,
Hearsay, FRE 801-802.
Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL
Document 320
Filed 08/22/2007
Page 26 of 27
Exhibit No.
Description Chairman of the FCC (December 16, 1999)
Objection No. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403 FRE 602
384.
"Ramping Up to VoIP," Hearsay, FRE 801-802. TelephonyOnline, a Penton Media, Foundation, Inc., abusiness to business media Authentication FRE 901. company, dated March 11, 2002 FRE 401-403 "ADSL to spur VoIP use," VNU Business Publications, dated march 4, 2002 Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403
386.
390.
Email from Ronald Prague, Synchronoss to Robert Reckers, SHB STI Porting Data dated February 26, 2007
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403 Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403
391.
STI-Vonage Port-Ins from Sprint
392.
STI-weekly reports for 10/14/2006 to 12/22/2006
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403
399.
The Sprint Nextel Review, 1Q, 2007
Objection because exhibit has not been provided, despite request; Vonage reserves the right to object after reviewing the
Case 2:05-cv-02433-JWL
Document 320
Filed 08/22/2007
Page 27 of 27
Exhibit No.
Description
Objection No. document.
401.
Letter from B. Trent Webb to Loren Schecter on July 20, 2005
Hearsay, FRE 801-802. Foundation, Authentication FRE 901. FRE 401-403
402.
Copy of CD enclosed with July 20, Foundation, 2005 Letter Authentication FRE 901.
]]>
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?
