Amgen Inc. v. F. Hoffmann-LaRoche LTD et al

Filing 534

DECLARATION re #532 Memorandum in Support of Motion, #531 MOTION for Summary Judgment That Dr. Lin's Asserted Claims are Definite, Adequately Described and Enabled BY RENEE DUBORD BROWN by Amgen Inc.. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit Ex. 1#2 Exhibit Ex. 2 - 1#3 Exhibit Ex. 2-2#4 Exhibit Ex. 2-3#5 Exhibit Ex. 2-4#6 Exhibit Ex. 3-1#7 Exhibit Exhibit 3-2#8 Exhibit Ex. 3-3#9 Exhibit Ex. 4-1#10 Exhibit Ex. 4-2#11 Exhibit Ex. 4-3#12 Exhibit Ex. 5-1#13 Exhibit Ex. 5-2#14 Exhibit Ex. 5-3#15 Exhibit Ex. 5-4#16 Exhibit Ex. 6-1#17 Exhibit Ex. 6-2#18 Exhibit Ex. 6-3#19 Exhibit Ex. 6-4#20 Exhibit Ex. 6-5#21 Exhibit Ex. 7#22 Exhibit Ex. 8#23 Exhibit Ex. 9#24 Exhibit Ex. 10#25 Exhibit Ex. 11#26 Exhibit Ex. 12#27 Exhibit Ex. 13#28 Exhibit Ex. 14#29 Exhibit Ex. 14#30 Exhibit Ex. 16#31 Exhibit Ex. 17#32 Exhibit Ex. 18#33 Exhibit Ex. 19#34 Exhibit Ex. 20#35 Exhibit Ex. 21#36 Exhibit Ex. 22#37 Exhibit Ex. 23#38 Exhibit Ex. 24#39 Exhibit Ex. 25)(Gottfried, Michael)

Download PDF

Amgen Inc. v. F. Hoffmann-LaRoche LTD et al Doc. 534 Att. 28 Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-29 Filed 06/20/2007 Page 1 of 10 EXHIBIT 14 Dockets.Justia.com 10131200 CTI-MA LAITNEDIFNOC 464661 A .llI .�ttartS d �ur�')hq791 .�ocikC .t�t�. �t�. ��.� �.O ot st�.ea�r tm� �.eeddA 67612LH s�G yb tr� n� �uS .dridnat.� sa dna iro*taraperp $*hT .noitartlif teS no dnab lagirtemmy�, .e1$ni� sah osla tI .dnab �of dc�u �lsni$ a de ,vuh,� .�tafluslycclcud muilCm fo egitserp �ht ni Hp ta dna .q dna 6 HO ta $isc'mhporl�lc le| cd,mal)reay�op yb Iatrgtam siht fo sisylanA ".noitariiperP ��nerefc.P lanoitanretnI eht fo yttvttea eht desab ,mttorp S m/U 004.07 (o ycne�I dah ,r�cffub etahpsohp Mm! htiw nmu]�c etltapalyxordyh morf dctute kope-,( n�,tcarP *'.la te ekaytM yb debirc.�ed neeb sah �pe erup fo nuiti�rapcrp ehT ni��porh�yrE "Jo noimc6�ruP SOOHTEM DNA S.2AIRETAM .derusaem eb nac op� mures fo sievci �sserped dna lamron ,dohtem siht htiW namuh fo U 300.0-200.0 tceted ot hsuone evitisnes dna cificeps si iaht yass�on -ummioidar a '[o Incmpolev�d eht no trQDl�r ew ,elcitra siht nI .yticificeps :�isiuqcr eht evah ton did suht dna erup ylbartsnomed �on erew taht dnsu erew snoiter�pcrp enomroh hcihw ni *'*upc ro.[ syassa cigolonummi fo stroper n�eb evah erehT .slairetam edurc ni tneserp srotibihni c�icepsnon yb dclceTta netfo cra tub �eipm�s upe deifirup ot elbacilppa yllereneB era sdohtem esehT s*' .debircsed neeb evah desu era seuqinhcet erutluc liec hcihw ni sdehtem yassa �vitisn� lareveS �nomrob �lt ro slevel lamronbus ro imnron fo noitanimreted elpmis eht timrep seod tub ,Jmnron evoba ylba'�disnoc srelit mures "/o noitceted eht rof tneiciffus si ytivitisnes '/o eersed sihT ?U tuoba ,doht�m tar detsa'[ eht hti.w dna 'U 30.0 luoba fo muminim a tceted yllaosu nac eno ,kpma�c ro'[ ,dohtem esumtI cirohtelp eht htiw �evitisn�sni ylevitaler era dna ,noisicerp kcal ,ylts�c era ,cSiceps hsuohtla ,sdohtem y�su lamina.elohW .tnedive neeb S noI sah )ope( nitcioporhlyre ro.[ yassa c6�xls dna eviksncs ylhsih ,esicerp ,elbailer a rof DEEN EH eneguE �r� doowrehS .B m�k. y8 niteioporhtyrE rof yassaonummioidaR A Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-29 Filed 06/20/2007 Page 2 of 10 20131200 CTI-MA LAITNEDIFNOC 564661 A ht�w ,-ATDE M 10.0 ,�K M t0.O �u txim mu� �m� � �t�i � 1� � �ist� �ut y� hc� .4.7 � ta ,nimubla .� eta�bp M �20.0 � oni� t�id � ni �4 ta �ad 4 tor euq�hceT yas�ummioidaR �t � �tai�d �ats �t � �� na � �t era .�tar� ��fcR l�ta�MI �t � �l�ma � htn�-� ni �niU� �t� y�i�a �]lv �t � ro )I�a �ram � �tiv ni( ,��h ni �a�i eF� � ln�a � .)'erum� t�ma ta � ) yb �w�lof ,kw mf m�ta �O oI �ze �a �mms( � �n�eru�m �yt t sae b �t� tar dts�f ht trcw �v sy� oviv �i �T .e[� � �ill�i eht � � .�e � �n�s dradnats dcnimret� si �z�tnys nlbol�meh � m�a �t dna .e�m� eht htiw .y� �v ni � �tZv ni eht �t�ucni era �utl� ni sllcc worram � t� .�t� �tiv ni �t nI derus�m saw �lpm� mur� �a stcartxe eussit �t ni tn� � �itca yll� fo �cI �T ya�;aoiB .� .�zcJ�M [o � ytl�evmU .dimh� I��K .rD m�f ifi$ s �w )ni�y1$ dica .[-a( �um�ro namuh eruP .gnidnif s�s�p htiw tnem�rga ni saw hcihw .y�a tar �azs oviv evitcani sa� tub .�sa 11�C �rram uht ni �tivitca ci� ll�f �later �r� �talai�d ehT htiw .).oM ,s�L .tS ..oC l�imchC amsiS( �inimar�n �u�-�ra$a � )emyzne � U 4.0[ lm 80 � saw �laisA niar � mf ,� Hp ,et�a M ,0 ni � =v�an � � �l�u�i yb ,�mt�V ,laI�H �IcM layoR ,h�R I�M � etutb�I llaH �ilE �s �laW mraf lnitllumit�y� 11� I nul eruP ,tinU hcr�R �aC ,�uB ynOtnA .rO � [[� �k �rf � Ma �R �ciM �lfo �w �g�ta �iT LlI ,�hC �hC � yli�vin� �H m� lan� dna y�l� �I �f �is� �w � noruH selpmaS fo noi�erP y�miu�a $nifa�t � � �I retfa � 8 n�s �w �nJ �t� �al �t :taht kw 2 uw 8nialb �iht �t �a ,jni� saw �ni �t� a �ni �ami� retfa kw 2 �i� � a �a �ni� �t �tfa kw 6 �v18 � �� Z � �w �b� :�u uw ku� $niwb�f � .t� hcuot �mnimda laniter �t � �ni imdsuni �luM .)�jni �t�( � �tu Lnavujda s'�F � �u�v 1� ni ht� �Ribu� )erUJni ffm�( �t a uw � �itlfs � �hw �aI�Z weN elam 4 ni � �w � ot �itnA n�ita:inummI otni �t � ni �w .m�p pE �al-l"� nim�la �ta�i �n� ytivi�d� i�tini ytivi�t �;�s � .mu� � �t � htiw �/iC� �2�$1 �r nw pE �aL .O.7 Hp ta ot �ls law �r � .yilaitneu� �a �ew ).llI �th[�H �nilrA ..�C m�emA .iC� 0 fo .laiv� �t oT .ln� �t� �ila�a� � ).llI .�fk�R ..oC l�C �( "lmw�" �id .).III .d�fk�R ..oC l�im�C .�fm�h� fo I, 02 fo sliaw �hI o(� �ta� .nmtani� smar�rc�m ytf�F nmmrp � k�S dna rek�F yb �ir� doht�n �ht dewo14cf eW" .oitanidoioidaR Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-29 Filed 06/20/2007 Page 3 of 10 30131200 CTI-MA LAITNEDIFNOC 664661 A yl�vital{r �ht fo �u� �a �ht�m siht htiw $nikro� fo �ae eht fo ht� ,�htem nego�l eht ot $nid�ca �tani�i ?lenituor saw �e ehT fo Ft�tca�umml no gnil.ffo �hteM eht fo tceffE .)i elbaT( �o saw tibb� ronod ch� �o t�amch �t �a m� eht ni �itna fo r�if �t nccwt� �italcrroc .)2 .8�( 3-A orehitna �( �S:� ot A29� mur,itna �f �15:1 morf ,03 � � tn� a 8 niv� ,�Jtulid lanif �t ,)8ni�lb �iht( noit�jni h�f �t.�A .)I .l�( 6� � � tn� a gniris �1:I � �tulid l�lf a ta 2-A m�tna htiw ,)lni� �( pE � �i�jni �iht eht retfa yli�itamard �r �tU e� .0.4 � � a � ,I-A m�tna htiw �i� ,�.51 fo hsih a morf �gn� � :I � �ulid lanif a ta dnu� tn�r� eht :wol erew �d ret� � �t �t�a �ibb� tnere�id ni nctit �itnA tsrif eht �a �it�inummi �t yb �nim�t� namuh �tani� �t � � m� t� �t � sa ot �ibb� r�f llA �i�azinummI ,noitar�e� �u noruh �t y�itna � ytic� � �SER .0� � � ,llid �ff� � � �1� eh[ n� �ufnl� � �ut � � llA � �t htiw �aw �ut/� 1� � �mun :� �I tI mm l'mr � t� �t �im.led o� )�r� .7911 etahp� � � �t ni dtulid �I �d �t� dif� �t e� � �t �f �I �s �e � � �I �a ,� delebal-lU' fo d� GOl ,mI�c�Lna detulid iij OOt (o �CF YA�SAONUMMIOIOAR Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-29 Filed 06/20/2007 Page 4 of 10 40131200 CTI-MA LAITNEDIFNOC 764661 A 82 001.6 :� 24 �3 AZ.96G 2966 000.8 :I ooo.al:l �?� � drihT morF � ni�myre fo 9elsia .1 e�l�T rof :d�u erew �noitaraperp recart tnereffid hguoht neve ,�lbicuderper etiuq evah sevruc dradnat, ehT .ope fo Um 5 I-OI fo noitidda oht yb decalpsid saw r�:�art eht fo tnecrep ytfiF .mte fo U 002--001 dna )ni�torp fo gp 21 yletamixorppa( neewteb detacol yltnetsi,noc saw muresitna �iht rof sevruc tnemecalpsid Um dradnats eht fo noitrop raenil ehT .)2-A mur�itna� noitulid 000.01:I a ta de*u saw tibbar "ro gnideelb dnoce� eht morf deniatbo muresitna .seidut� $niwollof eht nI ytilibicudorpeR dna "oivi�it.neS yassaonummioidaR 5.31 htiw recart del�l�I -rctnuH-n�tioB eht fo tnemecalpsid lauqe na dna dradnals �:1e fo Um 41 htiw recart dei�bal-nc�odoI eht fo tn�mecalpsid %05 dewohs sevruc 8 nidnib evititepmoc morf gnidnetxe noitrop ta�ni1 eht ,lauqe ehT .)3 .giF( ope fo Um 002 ot erew sevruc owt eht fo sepols ehT .desu erew noitulid OQ0.O1 :I a ts Z-A mur,itna dna dradn.ms ope erup eht :ylsuoenatlumis deraperp erew sevruc dradnats ehT .eudiser cinoipo�plynehpyxordyh-p.|�-'-� eht htiw nietorp eht fo �luor� o�ima setalyca hcihw ,).mM .notsoB ,raelcuN dnal$nE w�N( retse adiminiccusyxordyh.V/dica cinoiporp )lynehpyxordyh-4(.3 detanidoi htiw detcaer saw nietorp eht ,dehtoot rettal eht nI .�reeart sa |nivres "Pncgaer retnuH-notioB eht yb dna dohtem neBodol eht yb delehal ope htiw �evru� tnemecalpsid fo nos -irapmoc yb deiduts saw ope fo ytivitcaeronummi eht no noitanidoi fo tceffe ehT .ope eht sniatnoc taet esahp suoeuqa eht fo ffo snitt�ip yb detanimret ylid,r si noitcaer eht .laiv eht fo llaw eht |nit ,oc .m�of dilos ni si tnadixo eht esuaceB .snoitidnoc �IE3SAWO .I�C DNA Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-29 Filed 06/20/2007 Page 5 of 10 50131200 CTI-MA LAITNEDIFNOC 864661 A Q�4OOlO� 0� 0� OS Ot SO esuom erehw dna cirohtelp lanoitnevnoc eht dna AIR n�wt� n�irapmoc a ,elbisac� ,y�aonummioidar eht ni �[�t erew selpm� mur� namuh lare� -eca�sid eht �* .� .)4 �w .)6 .B iF lellarap erew dna �* ��roh eht fo mrof d eht �' .pE-a rof �uc tn�ecalpsid eht taht dnuof �� .�e-� �vit� �[ani�i dna 2-A y�itna B nisu yB .)5 .$iF( �c namuh ekil yli�i�ummi �vah� �ipm� mur� eht ni lairetam �[ taht lnit�BBus �e R� �[ � �u�p =�uc eht oi lellar� �cw �niatbo �uc mcm �m� mur� namuh fo �nuoma �nisaercni nehW 2-A mur�tn, oI �e-ls�' � I ni�ib eht htiw �[�moc �R( .RSC( ro�,t I ndalumds-yn� 11� lnul �u� m� n�uh �i�yli owt h�iw y� �t fo yti�i�s � �a di�um�ro �t �t�t eW nire�kty�E �f yn�:A fo yr�i�S .�2.81 � n�ta�av � tne� a htiw .Um 8.9 m�'�H� �-5 a re� �rav sah tni� t�ecalpsid � � eht �m� y� .) � t iF" � !o � qllmtmt l'�*ffI Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-29 Filed 06/20/2007 Page 6 of 10 60131200 CTI-MA LAITNEDIFNOC 964661 A �mUm OO$ OO� O� 0$ gniwohs -�cyl� �* revew� .�rga ton od yeh� :"2 loh�la" �llac noi�ar� eh: rof tpecxe ,yassa llec worram :h� yb �n�mrct�d �ht h�iw llew ylriaf :�ga AIR yb derus�m �divizca ehT .snoilaraperp �e �ifirup yllaitr� ro ro stc�txe �c ro sy�sa � elbatius �nd �1� tn� ew .3 elbaT nI tah: .y�ib yb [� naht �hgih hcum eh� ,) IB �a 3J( �id laner cinorhc h�iw smed� owt ni )E( �a ;y�b � �a AIR yb �intbo �eld n�wl� �e� =lban�r a �w ereht .)R �a ,4J ,2W ,IW .IH �M( �sac xis ni )D( :erusaem reilf rewol eht dah ,cir�ena saw �w ,2M tneit� morf m� .�y�a raF � �lpm� eht 8noma )C( :eSn� l�ron eht ni �e elbat�ted dah ,arev aimeht �id �w ,2J �neit� morf m� )B( ;AIR yb �rus�m � lamron fo retil ope �lt )A( taht dewohs )2 elbaT( stluser ehT .edam saw m-r�s Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-29 Filed 06/20/2007 Page 7 of 10 70131200 CTI-MA LAITN�IDIFNOC 074661 A 62.0 7.2 1�.0 �o� � �c 9.2 0.�.2 0.2g 0.� 0.�,2 0.� 0.47 �k �R � 3 2 � � 0.202 4.63 0.�2 0.43 081 8.21 491 8,96 7.8� � 3eAHP �.�d4IP '� eht Jyllne� erom �tr�cr � sA .�nc�oh � ot nwohs lon saw tu� �c ni �hcir� ylbaredisnoc s�w lairetam 8nihu.r ch� ;recart �hl su �i d�u dn; �htem ciSol�ummi yb noitar�=rp �= n� dcifir� 'ai�ruG .l�ir=�am dcI�al eht sa dn� nelonummi eht sa ht� � nitei�orhtyre erupmi �ac� .chi� eeew s�hmm eht �e namuh tor sy�ummioidar polevcdm detpmett� ylsuoi�p dah �aSit�vni h�uohhA .cifi�s dn� cvi�n� si [eht �assaon t �te�d ot � �ttim� �h �e namuh er� Fo �hiibaliava e� -umm�id� .nitcaio� ro( ".la t� 8 nucL yb � t�t � r�imis si 8ni� bhT .ym� yb n�t AIR yb ytivi�a mI �f � .�uwoh �t, revil l�e� eht fo � eht ni .y� oviv ni mtit rehiih �hs �tem �utl� �rram dna AIR eht ht� .larcnc$ ni .�m t�r dets�'I eht yb dnuof ytiv;tca eht htiw .)'Y !ohocla"--es� e�o ni �ecxe( �.O 1.0 e�.O �.0 20.0 61,0 88,Q �1 � �00.0 20.0 010.0 e30.O 020.O Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-29 Filed 06/20/2007 Page 8 of 10 80131200 CTI-MA LAITNEDIFNOC 174661 A yll�i�ioib taht gnitcidni sa �htcm erutluc ll� worram �t yb dna �IR yb dnuo� �etit rehgih eh� terpretni ylevitatnet eW .snoitcar� edurc �o syas�o evitatitnauq tn�erp sti ni �ilppa � �nn� .�e �o �etit mures �o ztn�erus�m ro� �u � n� ti hg�htla .AIR �t taht w�s � �aT ni �tne�rp atad ehT .noit�mr� le� yb �e m�f elbarap� tnen�moc evitcae�ummi rellams a �niatnoc 3J elpm� taht �F evah ew ,stnemir�xe �animilerp .dc�ircv � na� noitseggus a hcus cro� .revewoh �cn si noitamuhni erom :ytivitcu cigoloi� on � elttil evah taht secnat�us evi�aeronummi ta .m� eht ni ,e�rp �t ot eud � yam gnidn� sihT .yacsib ia�izne�oc � yb dn�� taht naht regral hcum yrev saw �IR yb denimreted relit eht .IB dna �J �ncit� nI .noit -artn�noc rewol a dah tneitap cirhpena na dna .sn�r� la�on m� zr� ni dnuo� taht naht ret�erg yltnacifingis noitartnecnoc �� na dah zix�yh ot yradnoces aimena htiw tneitap A .y�s�nummioidar yb dnuo� �e �o resir eht dna rc�id lacinilc eht neewteb noitalerroc o saw erehT )�( .)2 elbaT( �c �vitc�ronummi tnuomo eht dna .ecim cirohtelp ni denimreted sa ,ytivitca �oloib neewt� tnemeerga �g ylban�acr saw ereht ,se�mas em� ro� )B( -)Y -8�( �e namuh erup hliw dnuo� taht ot icllar� �uc tnemecalpsid �cu�p m� namuh stn�a �nis�rcnI )�( :�e d�dni si y�s�nummioidar yb mur� namuh �t�ted ecnatMus eht taht �itaterpretni eht str�pus ecnedi� gniwollo� ehT .�u �w �c namuh ot m�izna na nehw �e namuh Fo noitazilartuen sa sa ton saw �c p�hs �o noitazilartuen taht �w�s ohw � .nnamlhaM dna yel�h� [o tr�er a mrifn� y�itna yb gnidnib no y�tar�al ruo ni �iduts yran -imilerP .)3 elbaT( y�aonummioidm yb dna y�ib yb �uo� �c �o �nu�a n�wt� �id eht yb �t�gus si sihT .y�itna eht htiw ytivitcaer ot �r htiw �lpm� eni� dna namuh �t n�wt� e�ereWid tn�6ingis yam �eht ,r�woH ,�i�s !�e� ot nomm� si taht ezis �Bitna �in� � �pa suht y�itna � .r�t namuh eht �aMs[d dna 2-� � namuhnon dna namuh ht� �r� nitei�orht�E orehitna htiw stc�r rof .)6 .�iF( �omroh evitan eht �f dnuoF taht ot lellar� si �laisa �uc recalpsid eht taht gni� r� yb dna ai�aO yb nw�s saw sihT .�c ytivi�onummi eht retla �n �d �udi�r �ca cilais fo la�mer ,ylralimiS .)� .giF( �ni� tnemecalpsid �5 l�itnedi yllaitn� wohs �a icllar� era ,re�woh ,�oit�e� �e �l�al yltnerc�id owt �ht htiw dnuoF �uc tnem�alpsid �t ;)� �hsilbupnu( ytivi�a �loib �lu� ,�htem retnu�-notl� eht yb �uorg onima �r[ �t no � ,�htem neB�I eht �o �m yb �e �o �udi�r cni�ry� eht � eni�i � noituzit�uS .ytivitca ci�ummi sti ro� �n ton si �c �o ytivitca ci�loib tcatnI .11� tegrat a htiw noitcaretni sti rof deriu�r �e � etis evitca eht tsniaga �t�rid � ton yam �i�itna ralucitr� �ehz taht �ggus sihT .�htem erutluc worram ortiv ni eh� yb dc� neh� �efo ytivitca eh� ezilartuen t� did )2-�( m�h �iduts tnemecalpsid eht ni �u mur ,itna � .)I elbaT� slir�t�meh ralimis h�iw s[ibbar mor� emac ,retit �oI a d�h hcih� .A2966 dna .re�i� gnidnib hgih a dah hcihw .3-� ar�itna ,elpmaxe roF .tibbar ronod eht fo �ir�ch eh� dna rccar� dnib ot muresi�n� eht �o ytic�ac eh� n�w� noitalerroc on dnuo� ew .snoitar�erp edurc ot �sn�r ni d�iar erew taht �e ot �r�itna iare� htiW .recart eh[ sa ope sih hLiw dnuof dah ch taht erup "to �su eht yb detanimile n�:�l evah dohtem suoiverp Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-29 Filed 06/20/2007 Page 9 of 10 90131200 CTI-MA LAITq�LDIFNOC 2/"4661 A 671,761 � .2791 ,e� II �iM .S� hliw �IS :� �lhsM .CJ � .02 )� ni( m�myS �lh -�B .nitc�orhly� � ym�numm�idaR :E �G .BJ �w�S .FJ a�aG .91 8791 .8261-9161:301 mehC �T :E �791 .I namuh reEsiF �B .�i[�htwe n�uh � �t� r�a�dl� ,HKC I�K ,T �ayiM .0I � �61 �M ni� b� J .�i�htyre y�s�numm�r a � �t� :WJ �eR ,�P nolr� .JJ �ru�e.I 9 m( .BA -lm� y�ummio�ar dna y�ib n�wt� piEsnm� siweL n,c�orh[yr= � �it�i�A :EF hgu�borT .FL ydurG'O .DR cBn�I .� :SC l�i� .MS ll�uR .CF I n�L .81 .3�2-8�1:252 �C � :D �I�=M ,J �irMamaC .WA �OG ni ,nitci�thl�e amsalp namuh yass�nummioidar ehT :FJ aicraG .7 -?t �uB .71 3�91 .93�-925:331 pp .]?qI .dnullu41-htre� -�e� I nltllyca �ini� l�S� a Ot �tivi� clfi�s hlih m sniem� 2�1 .�l�E �t�a� .�H �ral�ul�-noN .III traP �a cviluOit�vnI ni ;)s�( SR wol�Y ,AS n�r� ni ,nttm� �3�1 �M �B -�h�� diB yhsa �tlv ni nA �H �aW .� .orti� 4?91 y�mmI :A � .RC �M .51 �4�42 �C �O J .� n� ni �lec �r� � �is �lwd� .O euli�aL-,illaG .B5 �tn�K .4 8791 .�8�:301 � [lN�ililm �ht � ta or.v ni �it�or�lyre � y�a �kiS .FJ �ailE ,E �sa�loG .3 � � .�i� n�aJ .L �i�hl�e kaz� I �il�ln� 8791 .?�:08 nummoC �R lyhpoiO meh�iB .liru�ylI .��.411 .�m�hc y�n� I htiw etln� �mem nie� :rJ CJ �S .JP �I.F .21 7791 �?-lJ?:�3 OHW lt� -mtni �"1 :RD �I�G .OL .LW �irF .2 m�hBuB .MP nroC .tI yb cim�ty�yl� �m �m ni nit;�lorhtyre ya.aoiB :RD m�hlnaB .MP �ctuC .I SECNEREFER noluG nylevE dal deirF .W .�:i ot .syt,�l,oib eht "io cmo�, |nimro'irxI ro't eW dna =nalsi.l lscinh�t "m'i rendraG ettennA ot lur�tar| TN EMGICE.�VON (ICA .dohtem a hcus s nike�s yltnerruc era eW .ope "fo noitanoitc,'-r't eht gnirotinom "io esoprup eht evre� lliw dohtem ortiv ni rehtien ,smrof owt eseht neewttb $nihsiugnitsid rof dnuof �b nac dohl�m a litnU ,ortiv ni sllec ni evitca dna evitcacronummi htob si hcihw ,o)le olaisa evitcani yllaci$oloib htiw detanimatnoc yllaitnat�us si ope evitan evitca 9$ NITE�'YRE �O.r VA�SAONUMM�OI)�III Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-29 Filed 06/20/2007 Page 10 of 10

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.

Why Is My Information Online?