Amgen Inc. v. F. Hoffmann-LaRoche LTD et al

Filing 534

DECLARATION re #532 Memorandum in Support of Motion, #531 MOTION for Summary Judgment That Dr. Lin's Asserted Claims are Definite, Adequately Described and Enabled BY RENEE DUBORD BROWN by Amgen Inc.. (Attachments: #1 Exhibit Ex. 1#2 Exhibit Ex. 2 - 1#3 Exhibit Ex. 2-2#4 Exhibit Ex. 2-3#5 Exhibit Ex. 2-4#6 Exhibit Ex. 3-1#7 Exhibit Exhibit 3-2#8 Exhibit Ex. 3-3#9 Exhibit Ex. 4-1#10 Exhibit Ex. 4-2#11 Exhibit Ex. 4-3#12 Exhibit Ex. 5-1#13 Exhibit Ex. 5-2#14 Exhibit Ex. 5-3#15 Exhibit Ex. 5-4#16 Exhibit Ex. 6-1#17 Exhibit Ex. 6-2#18 Exhibit Ex. 6-3#19 Exhibit Ex. 6-4#20 Exhibit Ex. 6-5#21 Exhibit Ex. 7#22 Exhibit Ex. 8#23 Exhibit Ex. 9#24 Exhibit Ex. 10#25 Exhibit Ex. 11#26 Exhibit Ex. 12#27 Exhibit Ex. 13#28 Exhibit Ex. 14#29 Exhibit Ex. 14#30 Exhibit Ex. 16#31 Exhibit Ex. 17#32 Exhibit Ex. 18#33 Exhibit Ex. 19#34 Exhibit Ex. 20#35 Exhibit Ex. 21#36 Exhibit Ex. 22#37 Exhibit Ex. 23#38 Exhibit Ex. 24#39 Exhibit Ex. 25)(Gottfried, Michael)

Amgen Inc. v. F. Hoffmann-LaRoche LTD et al

Doc. 534 Att. 29

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 534-30

Filed 06/20/2007

Page 1 of 9

EXHIBIT 15

Dockets.Justia.com

I

egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008

ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL

8077

.ON

.R.S.C

,retlaP

nalA

yrraH

:yb detropeR

).redro evitcetorp eht htiw ecnadrocca ni tpircsnart eht taert esaelP dednem·
eritne
.redrO

evitcetorP

sa

eht fo )c(5 noitceS rep laitnedifnoc detangised si

tpircsnart sihT(
7002

,8

ENUJ

AINROFILAC
.D.M

,ALLOJ AL
FO NOITISOPED

,SILYAG

.D

NILKNARF

DEPATOEDIV

LAITNEDIFNOC

.stnadnefeD

,noitaroproC
yesreJ weN a ,.CNI ,EHCOR ,ynapmoC AL-NNAMFFOH dna namreG a ,HbmG SCITSONGAID ,ynapmoC ssiwS a EHCOR ,EHCOR AL-NNAMFFOH .F
oV

,.DTL YGW-73221-VC-50
.oN

noitcA

liviC

,ffitnialP
,.CNI

,NEGMA

ypoC deifitreC
70021816

STTESUHCASSAM FO
TRUOC TCIRTSID

TCIRTSID
DETINU

SETATS

LAITNEDIFNOC
.D nilknarF

,.D.M ,silyaG
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 534-30

Filed 06/20/2007

Page 2 of 9

172

egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008 ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL

32:85:41 91:85:41 61:85:41 61:85:41
01:85:41 80:85:41 60:85:41 50:85:41
dna dluow

?OPE

fo

stnuoma

tnereffid

ecudorp selpmas
.Q

52 42 32

tnetanrepus H-1141 ruoy fo
taht
tcerroc

tnereffid

ti

si

oS

:RETRAC

.SM

YB

22 12 02

?elbarapmoc yeht
riafnu
na

erew

yas

ot

noitseuq
oS

s'ti

kniht I
eht
ta

.elpmas
semit

emas

dnes

t'ndid
I

91

tnereffid

,eveileb

81
71

30:85:41
95:75:41 75:75:41 65:75:41 55:75:41

,sbal

htob

htiw
dah I fo

spihsnoitaler gnikrow
:SSENTIW
EHT

tnereffid

61
51
41

.troper sih

epocs

eht

dnoyeB

.noitalucepS .noitcejbO
erew

:GNIMELF

.RM

31
?tnereffid

45:75:41
35:75:41 35:75:41

21
ii

yeht

woh

llacer

uoy

oD

.Q
:RETRAC
.SM YB

0I
9 8 7

25:75:41
05:75:41 84:75:41

.llacer

I

sa

,sbal
dna

tnereffid

owt
emas

ni
eht
ew

deyassa

ti

evah

tnemirepxe
ew

mrofrep

t'ndid

64:75:41
54:75:41 24:75:41 14:75:41 14:75:41

t'ndid
na

esuac'

,noitseuq
EHT

6 5
4

riafnu

s'tI

:SSENTIW

.eugaV

.noitcejbO
ralimis
evah

:GNIMELF

.RM

3
?stluser

2
1

93:75:41

yeht

did

dnA

70021816

LAITNEDIFNOC .D nilknarF ,.D.M ,silyaG

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 534-30

Filed 06/20/2007

Page 3 of 9

272

egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008

ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL

61:95:41
61:95:41

uoy

tnemom

a

dias

uoY

.Q
:RETRAC .SM YB

52 42

70:95:41 50:95:41
30:95:41

.syassa

tnereffid
na

gnirapmoc
ot

32
22 12 O2

siht
neeb

no

noinipo
ev'I fo

edivorp
eht

deksa

ton

:SSENTIW

EHT

85:85:41
75:85:41 65:85:41 55:85:41 45:85:41

.troper sih

epocs

dnoyeB
sllaC
.RM

.noitaluceps .noitcejbO
,naem

rof

91 81
?"tnereffid

:GNIMELF

71

woh"

uoy

od

tahW

.Q
:RETRAC .SM
YB

61
51 41 31 21
ii

45:85:41
25:85:41 05:85:41 84:85:41 74:85:41 54:85:41 34:85:41 14:85:41 93:85:41 93:85:41 83:85:41 73:85:41 62:85:41 eht
dluow woh
no .erew

selpmas

eht

tnereffid
EHT

sdneped

tI

:SSENTIW

.noitaluceps

rof

sllaC

.troper sih fo epocs eht dnoyeB

.noitcejbO
?OPE

:GNIMELF
stnuoma

.RM

0I

fo

tnereffid
ruoy
sI

ecudorp

9 8
7

tnetanrepus
taht

H-1141

fo

selpmas
.Q

tnereffid

tcerroc

ti

:RETRAC

.SM

YB

6
5 4

.noitseuq
taeper esaelP
:SSENTIW EHT

.noitaluceps
.troper sih
fo epocs

rof

sllaC

3 2
1

62:85:41 52:85:41

eht

dnoyeB
.RM

.noitcejbO
LAITNEDIFNOC

:GNIMELF

70021816

.D nilknarF

,.D.M ,silyaG
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 534-30

Filed 06/20/2007

Page 4 of 9

372

egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008

ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL

00:00:51 95:95:41 55:95:41 45:95:41 35:95:41 25:95:41 15:95:41 74:95:41
54:95:41 fo
na

.yassaonummi
a saw

na

saw

ti

tnereffid

52

ti

wenk

tsuj
eht
no

I

42

.yassa
evah

fo

dradnats

noinipo

32 22 12 02

t'nod I
epocs

:SSENTIW

EHT

.troper sih fo

eht

dnoyeB
.RM

.noitcejbO
elbaiv ti
a

:GNIMELF

?ytivitca
dohtem si
AIR

eht eht diD

rof

gnitset
atad

91 81 71

esuaceb

etarucca

saw

emussa

uoy

.Q
:RETRAC .SM
YB

54:95:41 14:95:41 83:95:41 73:95:41 63:95:41
53:95:41 .atad
etarucca
saw

61 51

ti

taht dna

demussa

dna

atad

eht

deniatbo I

,syassa
EHT

eht

41 31
21 II

mrofrep

t'ndid I epocs

:SSENTIW

.troper sih fo

eht
rof

dnoyeB
sllaC .meht

.noitaluceps
ro

43:95:41

0I

13:95:41
92:95:41

yfirev

meht
eh

kcehc si

t'ndid
eh

eH

.meht

9 8
7

deviecer
.drocer
.tnemucod

dias

llA

82:95:41
62:95:41

eht
eht

seziretcarahcsiM

seziretcarahcsiM
:GNIMELF
?tcerroc .RM

6
5
meht

52:95:41 42:95:41

.noitcejbO
uoy evah
tcerroc

;elbailer
tset AIR

dnif
.rD

4

12:95:41
02:95:41 81:95:41
no

t'ndid

fi

stluser t'ndluow dna

s'eirgE
gnorw

3
2 1

deiler fi
em

uoy oga

taht-tnemom
a

m'I

deifitset

70021816

LAITNEDIFNOC .D nilknarF ,.D.M ,silyaG

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 534-30

Filed 06/20/2007

Page 5 of 9

472

egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008

ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL

94:00:51 94:00:51

eht

terpretni

uoy

dluoC

.Q
:RETRAC .SM YB

52
42

54:00:51
44:00:51 24:00:51 04:00:51 93:00:51 73:00:51 73:00:51 43:00:51 13:00:51
72:00:51 uoy eht
etats

.em

evag
nac

ehs

taht

stluser
EHT

eht

32 22 12 O2 91 81

ylno

I

:SSENTIW

.ynomitset sih
.tnemucod
eht

seziretcarahcsiM seziretcarahcsiM
epocs eht

.troper

sih

fo

dnoyeB
.RM

.noitcejbO
gnitset
AIR

:GNIMELF

?ytivitca
rof dohtem

71 61 51 41

elbailer
na

a

saw

dohtem t'ndid

eht

taht

gnidnatsrednu
stluser

evah

fi
a

troper
sa

trepxe ruoy ni

noinipo
.rD

ruoy

fo

52:00:51 12:00:51

sisab

s'eirgE
uoy

stluser

31
21

eht

no

yler

dluoW

.Q
:RETRAC .SM
YB

02:00:51
61:00:51 41:00:51 21:00:51 01:00:51 90:00:51 90:00:51 70:00:51 50:00:51
a

ii 0i 9 8
7

.noitseuq
eht

taeper

esaelP epocs

:SSENTIW

EHT

.troper sih fo

eht

dnoyeB

.lacitehtopyh etelpmocnI .noitaluceps .noitcejbO
?ytivitca
saw

rof

sllaC
.RM

6 5 4 3 2
.SM YB

:GNIMELF

eht

rof

gnitset
na

fo

dohtem elbailer
t'ndid
uoy

ti

gnidnatsrednu
eht
no

evah

fi

40:00:51 00:00:51

stluser
,

yler

uoy

dluoW

.Q
:RETRAC

1

LAITNEDIFNOC 70021816
,D nilknarF

,.D.M ,silyaG
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 534-30

Filed 06/20/2007

Page 6 of 9

572

egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008 ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL

52
63:10:51 43:10:51 33:10:51 23:10:51 13:10:51 03:10:51 92:10:51
82:10:51
mret

.sAIR

fo

ycarucca
ot

42

eht
neeb

no

noinipo
ev'I

na

mrof

deksa

32
22
12

ton

:SSENTIW

EHT

".ytivitca"
eht
ot
sa

eugaV .troper

O2
91

trepxe sih

fo

epocs

eht

dnoyeB
deksA
.RM

81
71 61

.derewsna

dna

52:10:51 42:10:51
02:10:51

.noitcejbO

:GNIMELF

?ytivitca gninimreted
dohtem
AIR

51 41

fo

dohtem uoy

elbailer
oD

a

eb

ot

81:10:51 30:10:51

eht

redisnoc

.Q

31
21
ii

.yrotanalpxe-fles
era

20:10:51
10:10:51 95:00:51 95:00:51 75:00:51 75:00:51 65:00:51 45:00:51 25:00:51 05:00:51
.nac

srebmun
.ot

ehT m'I
I

elba

0I
.A

.nac

9 8
7 6
.SM
YB

?naC
.nac

.Q
.A

I

?tonnac

uoY

.Q
:RETRAC

5
4 3

I

:SSENTIW

EHT

.troper sih fo

epocs

eht

dnoyeB
.RM

.noitcejbO

:GNIMELF

2
?stluser

05:00:51
LAITNEDIFNOC
70021816
.D nilknarF ,.D.M

1

,silyaG
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 534-30

Filed 06/20/2007

Page 7 of 9

672

egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008

ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL

21:20:51 90:20:51 70:20:51 60:20:51 50:20:51

eht

dedulcni I

:SSENTIW

EHT

52
42

.derewsna
.tnemucod eht

dna

deksA

seziretcarahcsiM
:GNIMELF
.RM

32 22
?OPE

.noitcejbO
llec siht

decudorp
ruoy

12

40:20:51
10:20:51
rof

enil atad

H-1141
no

eht
uoy

taht diD

noinipo
.Q
:RETRAC

O2 91

yler

10:20:51 00:20:51 85:10:51 45:10:51 45:10:51
35:10:51
ot

.SM

YB

81 71

tnes

saw

taht
m'I

atad

eht

gnillacer
EHT

61 51 41 31 21
ii

ylno .ynomitset
sih

:SSENTIW

seziretcarahcsiM

.troper sih fo epocs eht dnoyeB .eugaV

25:10:51
15:10:51 05:10:51

.noitcejbO
.lesnuoC

,ssentiw

0i

94:10:51 74:10:51 54:10:51
44:10:51 24:10:51

siht

daelsim

ot

gniyrt potS .gnihtyna
no

9
8
7

gniyler

s'eh

yas
eh

t'ndid

eH

.atad
s'eH

siht

deviecer

gniyas ylno

6
5
4

.ynomitset

sih

seziretcarahcsiM
:GNIMELF

04:10:51 93:10:51 83:10:51 73:10:51
atad

.noitcejbO

.RM

?tcerroc

;troper

trepxe ruoy ni
.Q
:RETRAC .SM YB

3 2
1

eht

no

gniyler er'uoy

tuB

70021816

LAITNEDIFNOC .D nilknarF ,.D,M ,silyaG

Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 534-30

Filed 06/20/2007

Page 8 of 9

772

egaP
1 .txE 8663.845.008

ecivreS dlroW etoNeviL

85:20:51

.ti
I

s'tahT
.oN

:GNIMELF :SSENTIW ?srewsna

.RM EHT

52 42
ruoy

65:20:51
45:20:51 35:20:51
15:20:51
ot

suoiverp
evaH

32
22

dda

ot

gnihtyna
.rewsna

uoy

sih
emas

ekil

t'nod

uoy

12 O2 91

05:20:51 84:20:51
84:20:51 74:20:51 74:20:51 54:20:51
no

esuaceb

noitseuq
uoY

eht

mih
.RM

gniksa

peek

t'nac

:GNIMELF

.ssentiw
rof

eht

81 71 61
51

yfitset

t'noD

:RETRAC

.SM

.gnihtyna

gniyler
ot

saw

eh

yas

t'ndid

eH

54:20:51
44:20:51 14:20:51 93:20:51 83=20:51 73:20:51 53:20:51

.mih

41

dedivorp

saw

ti
uoy

esuaceb

atad
eH

eht

31
21
II

dedulcni

tsuj

eh

dlot

.derewsna

dna

deksA

.ynomitset

sih

seziretcarahcsiM

0i
9 8
rof
uoy

.troper sih fo epocs eht dnoyeB

.noitcejbO
?ytivitca
dohtem fi
atad eb

:GNIMELF

.RM

23:20:51
03:20:51 72:20:51

lacigolonummi gninimreted
a

7

elbailer
siht
dluow

eb

ot

AIR

dootsrednu yas
ot

6 5
4

edulcni
uoy

ylno d'uoy
dluow
dnA

riaf

02:20:51 02:20:51 61:20:51 31:20:51

ti

.Q
:RETRAC
.SM YB

3 2
1

.atad eht

evitca
atad

yllacigoloib
evitcaeronummi

troppus

ot

LAITNEDIFNOC
70021816
.D nilknarF ,.D.M

,silyaG
Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY

Document 534-30

Filed 06/20/2007

Page 9 of 9