Amgen Inc. v. F. Hoffmann-LaRoche LTD et al

Filing 534

DECLARATION re 532 Memorandum in Support of Motion, 531 MOTION for Summary Judgment That Dr. Lin's Asserted Claims are Definite, Adequately Described and Enabled BY RENEE DUBORD BROWN by Amgen Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit Ex. 1# 2 Exhibit Ex. 2 - 1# 3 Exhibit Ex. 2-2# 4 Exhibit Ex. 2-3# 5 Exhibit Ex. 2-4# 6 Exhibit Ex. 3-1# 7 Exhibit Exhibit 3-2# 8 Exhibit Ex. 3-3# 9 Exhibit Ex. 4-1# 10 Exhibit Ex. 4-2# 11 Exhibit Ex. 4-3# 12 Exhibit Ex. 5-1# 13 Exhibit Ex. 5-2# 14 Exhibit Ex. 5-3# 15 Exhibit Ex. 5-4# 16 Exhibit Ex. 6-1# 17 Exhibit Ex. 6-2# 18 Exhibit Ex. 6-3# 19 Exhibit Ex. 6-4# 20 Exhibit Ex. 6-5# 21 Exhibit Ex. 7# 22 Exhibit Ex. 8# 23 Exhibit Ex. 9# 24 Exhibit Ex. 10# 25 Exhibit Ex. 11# 26 Exhibit Ex. 12# 27 Exhibit Ex. 13# 28 Exhibit Ex. 14# 29 Exhibit Ex. 14# 30 Exhibit Ex. 16# 31 Exhibit Ex. 17# 32 Exhibit Ex. 18# 33 Exhibit Ex. 19# 34 Exhibit Ex. 20# 35 Exhibit Ex. 21# 36 Exhibit Ex. 22# 37 Exhibit Ex. 23# 38 Exhibit Ex. 24# 39 Exhibit Ex. 25)(Gottfried, Michael)

Download PDF
Amgen Inc. v. F. Hoffmann-LaRoche LTD et al Doc. 534 Att. 31 Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-32 Filed 06/20/2007 Page 1 of 22 EXHIBIT 17 Dockets.Justia.com pmt.8F65sw .snoitcejbo fo eseht fo reviaw a sa tca yam niereh noitamrofni noisivorp on dna ,noitcejbo siht ot tcejbus eb llahs niereh srewsna llA .egelivirp elbacilppa eht rehto yna ro/dna enirtcod tcudorp krow yenrotta eht ,egelivirp tneilc-yenrotta yb detcetorp noitamrofni skees ti tnetxe eht ot yrotagorretni yreve dna hcae ot tcejbo sa era stnadnefeD era .yrotagorretni dna era eht ot elbacilppa snoitcejbO eht ot lareneG rehto yna fo reviaw eb ot deveileb a deurtsnoc eb ot ton yrotagorretni cificeps elbacilppa ylralucitrap esoht yeht esuaceb era dedivorp snoitcejbO lareneG cificeps ,yrotagorretni cificeps ot esnopser ni detic snoitcejbO lareneG cificeps tnetxe eht oT .niereht eb llahs dna sesnopser 'stnadnefeD fo lla ot htrof tes ylluf fi sa esnopser hcae ni detaroprocni ylppa snoitcejbo lareneg gniwollof ehT SNOITCEJBO LARENEG .)51-1 .soN( seirotagorretnI dna fo teS tsriF )"negmA"( eht ekam s'.cnI negmA ffitnialP ot sesnopser snoitcejbo latnemelppus rehtruf gniwollof )"ehcoR" ylevitcelloc( .cnI ehcoR aL-nnamffoH dna ,HbmG scitsongaiD ehcoR ,.dtL ehcoR aL-nnamffoH .F stnadnefeD )51-1 .SON( STNADNEFED OT SEIROTAGORRETNI FO TES TSRIF S'.CNI NEGMA FFITNIALP OT SNOITCEJBO DNA SESNOPSER LATNEMELPPUS DRIHT 'STNADNEFED .stnadnefeD DETCADER YGW 73221-50 :.oN noitcA liviC ,noitaroproC yesreJ weN a ,.CNI EHCOR AL-NNAMFFOH dna ynapmoC namreG a ,HbmG SCITSONGAID EHCOR ,ynapmoC EHCOR AL-NNAMFFOH .F ssiwS a ,DTL ,ffitnialP ,.CNI NEGMA STTESUHCASSAM FO TCIRTSID TRUOC TCIRTSID SETATS DETINU LAIRETAM DNI/ALB REDRO EVITCETORP OT TNAUSRUP LAITNEDIFNOC SSECCA DETCIRTSER SNIATNOC Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-32 Filed 06/20/2007 Page 2 of 22 67 90174413 ot tcejbo osla stnadnefeD .ytinummi tcudorp-krow ro egelivirp tneilc-yenrotta siht ot eht yb detcetorp noitamrofni rof sllac ti taht tnetxe eht ot .daorb yrotagorretni sa tcejbo stnadnefeD ,revoeroM ylrevo dna suougibma ,eugav yludnu yrotagorretni siht ot tcejbo stnadnefeD :ESNOPSER ecnatsbus dna erutan eht tsom .noitamrofni ro egdelwonk s'nosrep hcus hcae fo gnitats ,yrotagorretni siht fo rettam tcejbus eht gnidrager elbaegdelwonk ,lesnuoc naht rehto ,ehcoR htiw detailiffa slaudividni eerht eht )e( dna ;noitamrofni ro hcus hcae fo ecnatsbus dna erutan eht gnidulcni yrotagorretni siht ot esnopser s'eheoR gnidrager detlusnoc saw ro noitamrofni dehsinruf ohw ,lesnuoc naht rehto ,nosrep hcae )d( egdelwonk s'nosrep ;dilavni si mialc a taht noitnetnoc hcae fo troppus ni yler uoy hcihw nopu atad ro/dna ,tnemirepxe ,tset yreve ,)s(noitnetnoc ruoy troppus ot gnidnet sesu cilbup ro ,egdelwonk roirp ,ynomitset ,stnemucod gnidulcni ,noitnetnoc hcae fo troppus ni yler uoy hcihw no ecnedive lla )c( lla tcejbus ;snoitnevni demialc eht fo emit eht ta sniatrep tius-ni-stnetap eht fo rettam eht hcihw ot tra eht ni lliks yranidro gnivah nosrep a fo lliks fo level eht )b( no uoy hcihw sdnuorg lautcaf dna lagel eht ;dilavni si mialc hcus taht dnetnoc ,sisab noitatimil-yb-noitatimil a no )a( :yfitnedi ,dilavni si mialcretnuoC htneT tius-ni-stnetap s'negmA uoy taht ro sesnefeD evitanrrL'ffA htxiS dna htfiF ruoy ni dnetnoc fo mialc hcae rof mrof trahc mialc ni ,yletarapeS 9 .ON YROTAGORRETNI DETCADER Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-32 Filed 06/20/2007 Page 3 of 22 77 90174413 yb demialc sa ,OPE evitca yllacigoloib gnikam rof ssecorp eht dna tnetap 800' eht fo eneg OPE eht taht detats sa yllacirogetac negmA ,sgnideecorp evitca emas esoht nI .tius-ni-stnetap eht ni demialc nietorpocylg yllacigoloib ro eht gnitalosi saw neht dna sllec tsoh ni eneg taht gnisserpxe eneg OPE fo ssecorp eht ni evitnevni levon gnihton ecno ereht tnetap 800' eht ni demialc sa eht detalosi dah rekrow delliks eht ecnerefretni taht ,iaguhC dna etutitsnI sciteneG htiw sgnideecorp gnirud OTP fo slaeppA elbailer tnetaP fo draoB eht decnivnoc ot ydaerla negmA gnisu nietorp OPE .OPE fo eht sserpxe nac seititnauq ecudorp ygolonhcet AND tnanibmocer taht sllec tsoh nailammam :snoitairav suoivbo ronim htiw noitnevni taht etartsnomed dna elgnis a ylno dessessop negmA -ni-stnetap ot ,rotnevni elgnis dna noitacificeps OPE emas eht erahs lla tius sserpxe eht dna tnetap 800' ehT .nietorp detalysocylg dna evitca yllacigoloib sllec eseht sa gniwolla sa rennam a ni ecneuqes AND siht htiw demrofsnart sllec tsoh nailammam ecneuqes AND detalosi eht .oN tnetaP .S.U llew OPE gnidocne ,sgniht rehto gnoma ,smialc tnetap revo 800' ehT elbuod .)"tnetap 800' eht"( 800,307,4 rof dilavni era deripxe won s'negmA gnitnetap epyt-ssensuoivbo tius-ni-stnetap gnitnetaP eht fo smialc detressa eht fo llA 101 noitceS rednu gnitnetaP elbuoD noitnevnI emaS dna sa elbuoD epyT-ssensuoivbO era .A .swollof tes dnopser stnadnefeD ,ecnerefer yb niereh detaroprocni hcihw evoba htrof snoitcejbO lareneG dna snoitcejbO cificepS .yrevocsid gnirud eseht fo reviaw tuohtiw dna ot ecruos tcejbuS tpiecer yna morf slairetam tnaveler fo ot nopu emit yna ta esnopser siht tnemelppus ro yfidom thgir no eht evreser stnadnefeD a .7002 ,2 lirpA litnu smialc eseht gniraeh namkraM tcepxe ton seod truoC eht dna deurtsnoc neeb ton evah tius-ni-stnetap eht fo smialc detressa ehT ot .ynomitset trepxe rof sllac dna erutamerp si ti esuaceb yrotagorretni siht .truoC eht tcejbo osla stnadnefeD sa yb desopmi timil yrotagorretni 04 eht fo sesoprup rof hcus negmA siht tsniaga detnuoc eb dluohs dna seirotagorretni elpitlum setutitsnoc ti esuaceb yrotagorretni LAIRETAM DNI/ALB REDRO EVITCETORP OT TNAUSRUP LAITNEDIFNOC SSECCA DETCIRTSER SNIATNOC Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-32 Filed 06/20/2007 Page 4 of 22 87 90174413 .noitagitil ngierof ni sa llew sa ,tius-ni-stnetap ytitnedi eht eht fo noitucesorp eht gnirud smialc nietorp negmA eht dna smialc AND eht neewteb emas gnidrager stnemetats ralimis edam osla .noitnevni eht erew yeht esuaceb rettam ton did siht ,tnetap 800' eht fo sllec tsoh dna ecneuqes AND eht devlovni noitagitil eht dna ,OPE detalysocylg evitca yllacigoloib neve fo noitcudorp eht ot detcerid saw gnideecorp 790,201 ylppa eht fo tnuoc eht hguoht taht deugra negmA 'struoc eseht fo .sgnideecorp egatnavda ecnerefretni eht ot dluohs ti taht gniniatniam yb sgnilur koot negmA ,eroferehT .dI .etutitsnI sciteneG erofeb tnetap 800' eht fo sllec tsoh dna secneuqes AND demialc eht tnevni ot tsrif eht neeb dah negmA taht dnuof tiucriC laredeF eht dna sttesuhcassaM fo tcirtsiD eht .cnI ,negmAnI .)1991 .riC .deF( 0021 d2.F 729 ,.smrahP iaguhC .v ,negmA eht ni seussi ytidilav dna ytiroirp gnidrager tiucriC laredeF eht dna truoC tcirtsiD eht fo sgnidnif tpoda dluohs draoB eht taht deugra negmA ,ecnerefretni 790,201 eht gniruD .editpepylop detalysocylg eht gnitalosi .5 dna ytivitca lacigoloib deticer eht tceffe ot OPE namuh larutan fo noitalysocylg eht fo evitacilpud yltneiciffus rennam a ni editpepylop eht gnitalysocylg .4 ,editpepylop a otni ANRm eht gnitalsnart .3 ,ANRm ot AND eht gnibircsnart .2 ,setycoluciter dna sllec doolb der gnisaercni fo seitreporp lacigoloib oviv ni eht evah ot OPE namuh fo evitacilpud yltneiciffus editpepylop a gnidocne AND htiw demrofsnart sllec nailammam gniworg .1 fo spets gnisirpmoc editpepylop detalysocylg yllacigoloib oviv ni na fo noitaraperp eht rof ssecorp A evitca :tius-ni-stnetap fo stnemele laitnesse eht lla a srevoc eht fo smialc detressa eht dna ,swollof sa saw 790,201 .oN ecnerefretnI ot tnuoC ehT fo .niteioporhtyre namuh gnidocne yllaitnesse gnitsisnoc ecneuqes AND detalosi ot lacitnedi si dna erew ecneuqes AND dna deifirup A :tnetap 800' eht fo 2 mialc ot tnuoC ehT ,swollof sa saw 690,201 .oN ecnerefretnI .noitnevni emas eht ot detcerid 790,201 dna 690,201 .soN ecnerefretnI ot stnuoC eht taht detats negmA ,sgnideecorP ecnerefretnI eseht gnirud ,ralucitrap nI .62-52 ta 19/92/7 detad eht rof feirB eeS ".noitnevni emas ,790,201 .oN ecnerefretnI ,niL ytraP roineS eht eht fo snoitatsefinam tnereffid ylno era" ,tius-ni-stnetap LAIRETAM DNlJALB REDRO EVITCETORP OT TNAUSRUP LAITNEDIFNOC SSECCA DETCIRTSER SNIATNOC Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-32 Filed 06/20/2007 Page 5 of 22 97 90174413 hcstirF eeS .niL .rD ton dna ,gnillamS .rD dna enworB .rD yb desivrepus dna detcerid saw sllec tsoh nailammam ni eneg OPE eht fo noisserpxe .soN ot gnitaler negmA ecnerefretnI ta enod krow eht fo lla taht decudda saw ti ,790,201 dna 690,201 sgnideecorP gnirud ,yllacificepS .611 dna 0(201 §§ .C.S.U 53 rednu noitavired dna pihsrotnevni eriuqer fo kcal rof dilavni eb dluow smialc detressa esoht smialc detressa eht taht seugra dna noitnetnoc siht neht ,noitubirtnoc evitnevni etarapes seined negmA taht tnetxe eht oT .tius-ni-stnetap eht fo smialc detressa eht suoivbo redner 800' eht fo smialc llec tsoh dna AND eht taht deniatniam evah stnadnefeD 611 dna ,evoba detats fO kcaL sA .B )f(201 snoitceS rednU noitavireD dna pihsrotnevnI .)1991 .riC .deF( 0021 d2.F 729 12 ,.smrahPiaguhC hcstirF .v .cnl ,negmAdna ,)2991 .ppA .taP .fretnI & .ppA .taP .dB( .v 7371 d2 .Q.P.S.U ,niL .v ,)1991 .soN .fretnI & .dB( 1371 d2.Q.P.S.U nac 12 ,niL hcstirF ,790,201 dna 690,201 yrotsiH eliF ecnerefretnI ta dnuof eb noitnetnoc siht gnitroppus ecnedivE eht dessorc si .)".ylppa enil taht erehW ton seod 121 noitceS fo ecnetnes driht eht fo noitibihorp deniatniam eb tnemeriuqer noitcirtser eht detpmorp taht 'snoitnevni tcnitsid .riC dna tnednepedni' neewteb noitacramed fo enil eht taht seriuqer ecnanosnoC"( .)1991 ta d3.F 943 .deF( 9751 ,9651 d2.F 539 ,.cnl ,nocitpO .v .cnI ,.shceT lobmyS ;1831 .v ,aveneG ;)4002 .riC eeS .deF( 8431 ,3431 d3.F 163 ,.hceT .proC hcraeseR ecnanosnoc .oC bbiuqS sreyM-lotsirB stnemeriuqer noitcirtser eht htiw niatniam ton did negmA ,revoeroM .tnetap eht saerehw 800' eht emaceb taht lanoisivid noitacilppa eht fO snoitaunitnoc morf deussi a tius-ni-stnetap 121 noitceS snoitacilppa morf deussi stnetap ot robrah efas sedivorp ,sgniht rehto gnoma esuaceb 121 § .C.S.U 53 rednu kcatta gnitnetap elbuod siht morf dedleihs ton si negmA ,yltnatropmI eht fo smialc detressa won .tius-ni-stnetap eht etadilavni 800' eht fo smialc eht taht gniyned morf deppotse yllaiciduj eht fo si negmA ,tluser ot a sA .tifeneb saw elbignat a deviecer dna a sa tius-ni-stnetap noitucesorp eht htiw deecorp dewolla negmA ,tluser dna noitisop s'negmA htiw deerga draoB tnetaP ehT LAIRETAM DNI/ALB REDRO EVITCETORP OT TNAUSRUP LAITNEDIFNOC SSECCA DETCIRTSER SNIATNOC Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-32 Filed 06/20/2007 Page 6 of 22 08 a 90174413 morf detalosi niteioporhtyre namuh revo tcudorp demialc eht ot ro ecruos a ytilibatnetap refnoc ton dluow detats tiucriC laredeF eht hcihw noitatimil ssecorp si "erutluc ni nworg sllec nailammam morf deifirup si niteioporhtyre dias nierehw" noitatimil mialc eht .23535000 CTI-MA ,rehtruF ;57-56318000 CTI-MA ;657-31660010 CTI-MA ;143-60394800 CTI-MA ,.g.e eeS :negmA yb decudorp ro stnemucod gniwollof eht tsael ta ni tnedive a era stnemele esehT .reirrac tnavujda ,tneulid yllacituepareht elbatpecca yllacituecamrahp a dna niteioporhtyre namuh fo tnuoma evitceffe gnisirpmoc noitisopmoc lacituecamrahp a ecitcarp .rD ot decuder dna deviecnoc dah ressawdloG eneguE ,smialc eseht fo sa rettam tcejbus eht fo noitnevni degella s'negmA era erofeb ,ralucitrap nI .srehto morf devired 224' 0(201 § .C.S.U 53 rednu dilavni )"tnetap 339' eht"( 339,745,5 dna )"tnetap eht"( 224,559,5 ressawdloG .soN tnetaP .S.U fo smialc detressa ehT 0(201 noitceS rednU noitavireD .D .tius-ni -stnetap eht fo smialc detressa eht suoivbo sredner dna noitnevni roirp OPE eht fo a saw 4891 no yaM ni eneg ecitcarp ot noitcuder s'hcstirF ,gnitnetap elbuod epyt-ssensuoivbo snoitnetnoc ytidilavni 'stnadnefeD ot tcepser htiw evoba detats snosaer eht lla rof ,eroferehT .tius-ni-stnetap saw eht fo etad gnilif evitceffe tseilrae eht ,4891 rebmevoN erofeb shtnom lareves .6021-5021 ta d2.F 729 sihT ,negmAeeS saw .4891 yaM ni eneg OPE eht fo noitalosi eht ecitcarp ot decuder dah hctirF taht dehsilbatse .ssaM ti 31 ,)1991 .riC .deF( 0021 d2.F 729 ,trap tnaveler ni .v d'ffa ,)9891 .D( 7371 d2.Q.P.S.U ,.smrahP iaguhC .cnI ,negmA ni dna sgnideecorp ecnerefretni decnerefer evoba eht rednU hcstirF gnirud ,ylralimiS roirP 301/)g(201 yB pihsrotnevnI .dI .C a .nietorp evitca ecno yllacigoloib otni eneg taht sserpxe ot suoivbo neeb evah dluow ti ,detalosi saw eneg eht taht detats rehtar ton did tub ,eneg OPE eht gnitalosi sdrawot detcerid nI saw noitubirtnoc s'niL taht etupsid negmA ,niL .v ,sgnideecorp Page 7 of 22 esoht gnirud ,tcaf .)2991 .fretnI & .ppA .taP .dB( 7371 d2 .Q.P.S.U 12 LAIRETAM DN1/ALB REDRO EVITCETORP OT TNAUSRUP LAITNEDIFNOC SSECCA DETCIRTSER SNIATNOC Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-32 Filed 06/20/2007 18 90174413 ",erudecorP petS ruoF a .)2891( )072 tcartsbA( a68:)5(06 ,doolB yb niteioporhtyrE ytivitcA cificepS hgiH fo noitaraperP" ,.P.P eterceS tahT slleC" sekuD .)2891( 734-534 :)rebmeceD( ,SBIT ",snietorP ngieroF ,.la te namloC .)4891 yluJ( A573:)6(21 .lotameH .pxE ",)1KPCLL( eniL lleC elubuT lamixorP yendiK dehsilbatsE nA yB noitcudorP niteioporhtyrE" ,.J.A ,velsrE dna .J yekciH ,.J ,oraC "I-A nietorpopilopa namuH A .)2891( 5686-1686:97 ,ASU .icS dacA .ltaN .corP namuh rof senolc ANDc fo noitaziretcarahc dna noitalosI" ,.la te wolserB .)3891( 4311-2311 :)5(26 doolB ",eniL lleC mreG ralucitseT yB noitcudorP niteioporhtyrE" ,.la te .D ,nosnorB ,.F ,silyaG ,.L.J ,oasnecsA nispyrT .)3891( 2486-8386:08 ,ASU .icS .dacA .ltaN .corP ",eborP AND citehtnyS ecneuqeS-euqinU A gnisU yB rotibihnI citaercnaP enivoB roF enolC cimoneG A fO noitalosI" ,.B.I ,notsgniK dna ,.S ,nosrednA .snoitacilppa tnetap .3891 dna stnetap evoba eht ni deman srotnevni fo krow .oN gniylrednu llA ,9 rebmevoN dehsilbup ,916,390 noitacilppA tnetaP tnetaP naeporuE esenapaJ .9791 ,4 yaM dehsilbup ,09755-45 OHS rebmuN iakoK noitacilppA 600,757,4 .oN tnetaP setatS detinU .oN tnetaP setatS detinU .oN tnetaP setatS detinU .oN tnetaP setatS detinU .oN tnetaP setatS detinU 600,855,4 331,393,4 612,993,4 315,773,4 :snoitnetnoc evoba eht rof troppus edivorp ot dna ,suoivbo tius-ni-stnetap eht fo smialc eht eht tsael ta no gniredner sa ,noitanibmoc ni ro enola ,tra roirp gniwollof yler yam ehcoR .noitnevni eht fo emit eht ta tra eht ni lliks yranidro fo eno ot suoivbo neeb evah dluow yeht esuaceb 301 § .C.S.U 53 rednu dilavni era tius-ni-stnetap eht fo smialc ehT .E ssecorp 301 noitceS rednU ssensuoivbO .)".snoitatimil ro ecruos fo noitidda eht demialc a yb ylelos elbatnetap deredner eb tonnac tra roirp eht ni tneserp eb .riC ot nwohs tcudorp taht elur eht fo tnazingoc eb dluohs truoc tcirtsid .v eh]T["( )3002 .ecruos .deF( 02.n 4531 ,3131 d3.F 413 ,lessuoR noiraM tshceoH Document 534-32 .cnl negmA eeS tnereffid LAIRETAM DNI/ALB REDRO EVITCETORP OT TNAUSRUP LAITNEDIFNOC SSECCA DETCIRTSER SNIATNOC Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Filed 06/20/2007 Page 8 of 22 28 eht 90174413 fo slannA ",niteioporhtyrE fO noitacifiruP ehT nI amsalP .)8691( 35-94:941 .icS .dacA .Y.N ssergorP" .K.C ,gnuK dna .E ,ressawdloG .syhpoiB .hcoiB ",niteioporhtyrE peehS .)2691( 694-784:46 ATCA fo noitacifiruP rehtruF'" ,.la te .E ,ressawdloG .)6691( YN ,sserP cimedacA ,112-371 .pp ,anocsoN .A.A dna yornoM .A .de ,ygoloiB latnempoleveD ni scipoT tnerruC ni ",tnempoleveD diorhtyrE fo lortnoC lacimehcoiB" .E ressawdloG .)7891( 6797-2797:48 ASU .icS .dacA .ltaN .corP ",seniL lleC amotapeH namuH owT yB niteioporhtyrE fO noisserpxE detalugeR ehT" ,.la te .M.J mahgninnuC ,.A.G ,ssalG ,.A.M ,grebdloG .)2891( 6256-2256:97 ASU .icS .dacA .ltaN .corP ,slleC retsmaH derutluC ni seneG esatcudeR etalofordyhiD esuoM detaiverbbA fo noisserpxE" ,.la te .S.C ressaG .)1791( 806-595:)4(11 eiglotameH'd euveR ellevuoN esiacnarF niteioporhtyrE ",seitreporP citeiopomeH stI fO ydutS dnA doolB latnecalP morF fO noitcartxE" ,.la te .G.M ,ezdiletehkaK ,.Y.G ,grebnezoR ,.A.N ,vorodoeF .tpxE ",niteioporhtyrE fO noitalsnarT" siveaL ,101 tcartsbA )3891 yluJ( .41S :11 ygolotameH evitcA yllacigoloiB otni yendiK noobaB cimenA morF ANRm .meH .pxE .coS .tnI ,.D.E ,inajnaZ dna ,.M.N ,rebraF otnI .)3891( 967A:13 .seR .nilC ,setycoO suponeX otnI noitcejniorciM gniwolloF niteioporhtyrE evitcA yllacigoloiB syendiK namuH morF ANRm fO noitalsnarT" ,tcartsbA ,.D.E ,inajnaZ dna ,.M.N ,rebraF otnI )3891( 186 )4(201 .deM .nilC .baL .J'" ,setycoO siveaL suponeX otnI noitcejniorciM gniwolloF niteioporhtyrE evitcA yllacigoloiB syendiK namuH morF ANRm fO noitalsnarT" ,tcartsbA ,.D.E ,inajnaZ dna ,.M.N ,rebraF .)5791( 204-893:11 .v ,517UE 1W demoiB ,sgnideecorP noitaicossA tnalpsnarT dna sisylaiD naeporuE ",ycneiciffusnI laneR htiW stneitaP nI dnA neM lamroN nI niteioporhtyrE fO tceffE" ,.R ,ztnieH dna .W ,relluM ,.U ,sressE nov .)4791( 4261-8161:99 tfirhcsnehcoW ehcsinizideM ehcstueD ",zneiziffusninereiN tim netneitaP ieb niteoporhtyrE tiekmaskriW ruz negnuhcusretnU eretieW" ,.E ,rennurB dna .W ,relluM ,.U ,sressE .)1891( aimenA .W.J ,hcabhcsE )A875 tcartsbA( 96:)2(92 .seR .nilC ",peehS nI )FRC( eruliaF laneR cinorhC fO ehT fO yparehT )OPE( niteioporhtyrE yB noitcerroC" ,.W.J ,nosmadA dna .)4891 tsuguA( nI eruliaF laneR cinorhC fO aimenA ehT" 144-434:47 .tsevnI .nilC .J ",peehS ,.la te .F.J ,aicraG ,.J ,civonedalM ,.W.J ,hcabhcsE .)9791( 742-342:)2(66 .deM .J .mA ",aimehtycyloP nI niteioporhtyrE amsalP" ,.la te .E ,usnaK ,.J ,oraC ,.J.A ,velsrE LAIRETAM DNI/ALB REDRO EVITCETORP OT TNAUSRUP LAITNEDIFNOC SSECCA DETCIRTSER SNIATNOC Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-32 Filed 06/20/2007 Page 9 of 22 38 90174413 lleC dirbyH esuoM-namuH fO sesU dnA .)8691( 2021-9911:022 erutaN ",seniL seitreporP" ,.C ,ocilisaB dna .H ,neerG ,.Y ,ayustaM .)0891( 842-442:77 ASU .icS .dacA .ltaN .corP ",eneG nimublavO nekcihC larutaN eht htiw demrofsnarT slleC esuoM ni sisehtnyS si nimublavO" ,.la te iaL ,nottartS nhoitaraperP .)2691( kroY weN dna enurG 36-85 ,).de ,.P.L ,nosbocaJ( siseioporhtyrE nI ",niteioporhtyrE fO roF ecruoS A sA doolB namuH" ,.la te .B ,iksnipiL ,.E ,ikslawoK ,.Z ,akswoaruK .)3891( 2223-8123:08 ASU .icS .dacA .ltaN .eorP ",snitcenorbiF enivoB dna namuH rof senolC ANDc fo noitaziretcarahC dna noitalosI" ,.la te .R.A ,tthilbnroK .)0891( 994 -794:)5544( 902 ecneicS ",negitnA ecafruS B sititapeH dnA snietorP amsalP rojaM ehT eterceS seniL lleC amonicraC ralullecotapeH namuH ,.P.D ,nedA ,.C.C ,ewoH ,.B.B ,selwonK .)3891( 145-435:47 NNAG ",erutluC eussiT nI dnA eciM eduN nI degassaP slleC amonicraC laneR namuH nI noitcudorP niteioporhtyrE" ,.la te .B.A ,egeR ,.R ,elginoGcM ,.Y ,akoustaK namuh fo senolc ANDc dna .)5891( 01-608:)5006(313 erutaN .niteioporhtyre cimoneg fo noitaziretcarahc dna noitalosI ,.la te ",siseioporhtyrE ni sbocaJ .)7591( 436-336:971 erutaN yendiK eht fo eloR" .O.L ,nesbocaJ .)3891( 92-111 :)gniteeM 2891( .icsoiB .pmyS dnuoF .icS adekaT .corP ,.feD tsoH srotcaF laromuH ",ygolonhceT AND tnanibmoceR yb nietorP namuH detalysocylG a fo noitcudorP" ,namssieW dna .)2891( 456-056:792 erutaN senyaH ",senolC llec L esuoM ni norefretni-B namuH fo noitcudnI" ,.la te resuaH fO serutluC .)4891 rebotcO( 426-916:)2(451 .seR lleC .pxE ",slleC mreT-gnoL nI noitcudorP niteioporhtyrE" ,.W.J amonicraC laneR namuH rehsiF ,.L.I ,nehC ,.M ,arawigaH .)4891 lirpA( erutluC 538-828:)4(36 yramirP A doolB ",eciM eduN nI deniatniaM slleC amonicraC laneR namuH fo nI noitcudorP niteioporhtyrE" ,.la te .R ,elginoGcM ,.I ,nehC ,.M ,arawigaH namuH derutluC .)8182 tcartsbA( )3891 lirpA( ",slleC amonicraC laneR yB noitcudorP niteioporhtyrE" ,.la te .R ,elginoGcM ,nehC iL-I ,.M ,arawigaH .E ni ANDc norefretnI namuH fo :592 erutaN ",slleC yeknoM dna iloC .coS .corP .)2891( 805-305 noisserpxE" ,.la te yarG .loiB .tpxE ",ytivitcA citeioporhtyrE LAIRETAM DNI/ALB .)4591( 862-552:68 .deM htiw tcaartxE amsalP A" ,.la te .S.A ,nodroG REDRO EVITCETORP OT TNAUSRUP LAITNEDIFNOC SSECCA DETCIRTSER SNIATNOC Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-32 Filed 06/20/2007 Page 10 of 22 48 90174413 .)9791( 352-542:)1(45 doolB ",eciM eduN nI romuT sihT fO noitatnalpsnarT dnA amonicraC lleC laneR gnicudorP-niteioporhtyrE htiW tneitaP A FO esruoC ehT nI sleveL niteioporhtyrE" ,.la te .H ,ikuzuS ,.F ,oyotiroN ,.K ,amayoT .)1891( ,.dE ,nworB .D ,seneG deifiruP gnisU ygoloiB latnempoleveD ni ",secneuqeS AND denolC cificepS fo noitalosI eht rof seditoelcunobir-yxoedogilO citehtnyS fo esU" ,.la te .V.S ,sgguS .)1891( 7166-3166 :87 ASU .icS .dacA .ltaN .corP ",nilubolgorcim-2B namuH rof secneuqeS ANDc denolC fo noitalosI :seborP noitazidirbyH sa seditoelcunogilO citehtnyS fo esU" ,.la te .V.S ,sgguS .)3891( 55-1563:)21(08 ASU .icS .dacA .ltaN .corP ",noigeR lanimreT-2HN ehT drawoT detceriD niteioporhtyrE namuH oT seidobitnA cificepS-etiS" ,.J.A ,ikswoktyS dna ,.M.J ,euS nI scipoT ",sessecorP .)1891( kroY weN ,dnalloH -htroN/reiveslE 335-115 ).sde resiepS .P dna remierB .D.D( secneicS lacituecamrahP noitcudorP lacituecamrahP nI serutluC lleC laminA fO esU ehT" ,.R ,reipS .)6891( 961-561:38 ASU .icS .dacA .ltaN .corP ",eniL lleC ehT fO tnempoleveD :eniL lleC amonicraC laneR namuH dehsilbatsE nA yB niteioporhtyrE fO noitcudorP suounitnoC" ,.D lavuohS dna .B.J doowrehS amonicraC laneR namuH .)6791( 015-405:)2(99 ygolonircodnE ",erutluC nI slleC yB noitcudorP niteioporhtyrE" ,.E ,ressawdloG dna .B.J doowrehS .seR .nilC ",eniL lleC amonicraC laneR gnicudorP tnemhsilbatsE" .D ,lavuohS dna .E ,smuB ,.B.J ,doowrehS .)3891( A323:)2( 13 -niteioporhtyrE namuH A fO odnE K2-H .)8791( ",syendiK lamroN morf 078-668:301 .B.J niteioporhtyrE fo noitcartxE" .E ,ressawdloG dna ,doowrehS .)3891( 557-057:3 .loiB .lleC negitnA noitatnalpsnarT .loM ",seditoelcunogilO citehtnyS htiw noitazidirbyH yb eniruM eht roF eneG denolc eht fo noitacifitnedI" .la te ezluhcS .)5891( 82-32:31 .lotameH .pxE ",niteioporhtyrE fO seitreporP lacigoloiB ehT htiW tcudorP A otnI romuT laneR A morF ANR regnesseM fO noitalsnarT" ,.la te .D tnerT ,.K otiaS ,.T ,otiaS .pxE ",sANRnr-niteioporhtyrE namuH A nI noitcudorP namuH fO noitalsnarT" .)3891( )904 tcartsbA( 822:)41(11 .lotameH ,.la te .J.D tnerT ,.K ,otiaS ,.T ,otiaS .)5891( )915 tcartsbA( a851:66 doolB ",eniL lleC amotsalbotapeH niteioporhtyrE" ,.la te .J ,oraC ,.J.S ,retsuhcS ,.J.O ,nesleiN .)7791( ",niteioporhtyrE namuH fo noitacifiruP" 4655-8555:252 .mehC .loiB .J ateB namuH ,.la te .T ,ekayiM .)4891( 271-661:)1(4 LoiB lleC .loM ",slleC OHC nI seneG norefretnI deifilpmA fO noisserpxE elbicudnI" ,.la te .M ,sinnI ,.M ,yeharT ,.F ,kcimroCcM REDRO EVITCETORP OT TNAUSRUP LAIRETAM DNI/ALB LAITNEDIFNOC SSECCA DETCIRTSER SNIATNOC Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-32 Filed 06/20/2007 Page 11 of 22 58 90174413 eht ni sllec ni diorhtyre ni esaercni na ,tnuoc roF etycoluciter .)6002 .riC ni esaercni na dewohs yduts 754 lacinilc eht gnitapicitrap stneitap .v eht ,elpmaxe .deF( 3031 ,3921 d3.F sa ,.cnI ,lessuoR namuh fo noiraM tshceoH tnuoma evitceffe .cnI ,negmA eeS .deurtsnoc ylreporp si mret taht "niteioporhtyre yllacituepareht" a desirpmoc noitisopmoc lacituecamrahp ,noitidda htiw nI .nimubla eht taht etartsnomed namuh deniatnoc yduts lacinilc s'ressawdloG fo stluser eht sihT .aimena a mures noitisopmoc lacituecamrahp fo citsalpa stneitap fo eniru eht morf deraperp OPE noitisopmoc lacituecamrahp desolcsid ressawdloG .stnetap 339' dna 224' eht fo smialc eht fo snoitatimil tnaveler eht fo lla steem yduts lacinilc ressawdloG eht ,elpmaxe roF .)E tra dna D snoitceS ni evoba detic dna eeS( .niteioporhtyre namuh fo tnuoma evitceffe sa yllacituepareht a gniyfirup gnitalosi rof ,stcejbus fo esu cimena morf eniru llew sa ,sllec gnisserpxe OPE gnidulcni ,OPE fo lareves fo a revoc eno secruos suoirav gnibircsed snoitacilbup era tra roirp yna yb detapicitna tcejbus sa 201 § .C.S.U 53 rednu dilavni )nietorpocylg sa dica onima 561 os dluow rettam demialc eht taht sdnetnoc ylreporpmi negmA raf ,tnetap 080' eht dna( stnetap 339' dna 224' eht fo smialc ehT 201 noitceS rednU noitapicitnA .F .etad noitnevni na hcus erofeb yna fo etad noitacilbup eht ot tnetxe eht ot negmA htiW srohtua eht yb detcudnoc krow gniylrednu yna ,snoitacilbup evoba eht fo roirp etad noitnevni na tius-ni-stnetap eht fo mialc yna rof sdnetnoc ,gnidulcni ,snoitacilbup hcus fo srohtua eht yb krow gniylrednu llA .)4891 hcraM( 01-7072 :)5(952 .mehC niteioporhtyrE namuH fO noitalosI" ,.la .loiB .J ",seidobitnA lanolconoM ,atonhO ,.K ,edariH ,.S ,awaganaY te .H ydobitnA .)2891( 9645-5645:97 ASU .icS .dacA LtaN .corP ",niteioporhtyrE namuH oT lanolconoM A fO noitaziretcarahC" ,.E ,ressawdloG dna ,.J.C ,yksnivaK ,.L.T noitazidirbyH sa ,ssieW sdicA cielcuN ",seborP .)1891( 598-978:9 .seR seditoelcunogilO citehtnyS fo esU ehT" ,.la te ecallaW ASU .icS .dacA .ltaN .corP ",ytivitcA esatcudeR lleC yravO retsmaH esenihC fo noitalosI" ,.la te bualrU .)0891( 0224-6124:77 etalofordyhiD ni tneicifeD stnatuM AND citehtnyS a gnisU .)4891 yraurbeF( 463-163:3 .J OBME ",eborP eneG I rotcaF htworG ekil-nilusnI namuH eht fo noitalosI" ,.la te hcirllU LAIRETAM DNI/ALB REDRO EVITCETORP OT TNAUSRUP LAITNEDIFNOC SSECCA DETCIRTSER SNIATNOC Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-32 Filed 06/20/2007 Page 12 of 22 68 ton seod 90174413 ,tius-ni-stnetap eht fo noitacificeps )GPB( a eht ot lacitnedi si hcihw ,erusolcsid tnetap naeporuE s'negmA taht 0002 rebmeceD ni dleh truoC tnetaP laredeF namreG ehT naht rehtar .yrarbil ANDc namuh OPE fo gnineercs ,AND cimoneg namuh ot selpmaxe yb detroppus ylno fo kcal dna morf era noitcudorp na eht ot detcerid smialc ot eruliaf s'negmA .tnemelbane era noitpircsed nettirw revoc etauqeda edivorp rof dilavni smialc esoht ,ANDc desserpxe snietorp AND tius-ni-stnetap eht taht sdnetnoc negmA taht tnetxe eht oT 211 noitceS rednU tnemelbanE dna noitpircseD smialC nettirW fo kcaL .H .smialc detressa sti fo epocs lluf dednetnoc sti ebircsed nihtiw yletauqeda rof ot deliaf sah eht fo negmA ,tluser a sA on .snoitacificeps tnetap si ereht taht era eht snietorp gnitalygep seuqinhcet noitpircsed nettirw detupsidnu eht si ti esuaceb tnemelbane dna fo smialc detressa ehT .eb ot MT noitpircsed nettirw fo kcal rof dilavni tius-ni-stnetap ARECRIM sdnetnoc negmA hcihw ,sdnuopmoc detalygep eht nekat sah mialc dna revoc tius-ni-stnetap eht fo smialc detressa eht taht noitisop negmA .G a sdnuopmoC detalygeP 211 noitceS rednU tnemelbanE dna noitpircseD nettirW fo kcaL .ecruos tnereffid morf detalosi niteioporhtyre 080' eht ni ro namuh revo stcudorp demialc esoht ot ytilibatnetap ro ecruos refnoc ton dluow smialc smialc 339' eht ni dnuof snoitatimil ssecorp yna ,ylralimiS .)3002 eeS .ecruos .riC .deF( a 02.n 4531 ,3131 d3.F 413 morf detalosi ,lessuoR namuh noiraM tshceoH revo .v .cnI negmA tnereffid niteioporhtyre tcudorp demialc eht ot ro ecruos a ytilibatnetap refnoc ton dluow detats tiucriC laredeF eht hcihw noitatimil ssecorp nailammam morf si "erutluc ni nworg sllec deifirup si niteioporhtyre ylreporp dias nierehw'" noitatimil mialc eht si ,rehtruF .deurtsnoc fo esarhp enob taht sa "sllec doolb der dna fo setycoluciter ni eht" noitcudorp esaercni ot sllec worram gnisuac ytivitca lacigoloib oviv dah osla ressawdloG yb desolcsid OPE eht eht taht ,ylgnidroccA .stceffe cituepareht dah na noitisopmoc dna worram lacituecamrahp Page 13 of 22 sngis era hcihw fo lla ,ssam llec der ni esaercni REDRO EVITCETORP OT TNAUSRUP LAIRETAM DNI/ALB LAITNEDIFNOC SSECCA DETCIRTSER SNIATNOC Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-32 Filed 06/20/2007 78 90174413 yb deriuqer sa )"U"( stinu niteioporhtyre erusaem tonnac enola yassaonummioidar sa ,etaruccani eb tonnac yllacifitneics esiwrehto si dna sa noitacificeps tnetap esarhp eht fo weiv ni denifed ylreporp ,etinifedni si smialc eht ni desu denimreted eb rep eht taht noitnetnoc s'ehcoR si tI .yassaonummioidar yb "niteioporhtyre fo U" taht eriuqer rehtruf 6-1 smialC .sruoh 84 ni sllec 000,001 a ,0001 ro ,005 ,001 rehtie ",niteioporhtyre fo U"fo rebmun deificeps smialc ehT ecudorp fo sllec demialc taht eriuqer .htworg rieht fo muidem eht ni niteioporhtyre gnicudorp elbapac sllec etarbetrev ot detcerid hcae ,6-1 smialc morf sdneped tnetap 943' eht fo 7 mialc detressA "yassaonummioidar yb denimreted sa sruoh 84 ni sllec 601 rep niteioporhtyre fo U 001 fo ssecxe ni htworg rieht fo muidem eht ni niteioporhtyre gnicudorp fo erutluc ni htworg nopu elbapac" 211 noitceS rednU ssenetinifeD fo kcaL .J .tnetap eht fo tnemegnirfni setutitsnoc tahw ot sa srehto ot gninraw raelc yrassecen eht edivorp fo ot deliaf sah dna demialc sah ti hcihw noitnevni eht fo sdnuob eht eht htiw tuo tes ot deliaf sah fo ytiralucitrap dna noisicerp fo eerged etisiuqer eht ehT negmA erofereht dna snietorpocylg ytienegoretehorcim a" thgil ni etimfedni dna eugav ro era stnairav sti dna "niteioporhtyre detalysocylg a egaugnal .senomroh fo noitidda eht tnereffid fo a ,noitartnecnoc noi muinomma tnereffid rednu derutluc nehw rucco ,noitartnecnoc esoculg sti gnidulcni ,snoitidnoc gnireffid yllaicepse ,stinu etardyhobrac nietorpocylg ralucitrap A erom ro eno fo erutcurts eht ni reffid taht smrof ni yam .snoitidnoc tnereffid rednu derutluc nehw llec tsoh elgnis a morf tsixe nac smrof noitalysocylg elpitlum eno taht gniredisnoc egaugnal sa mialc eht fo sdnuob eht .C.S.U 53 rednu dilavni dneherpmoc era ot elbanu si tra eht ni delliks esuaceb etinifedni 211 § ,stnairav ralimis dna ",nietorpocylg niteioporhtyre" ",niteioporhtyre niatnoc taht detalysocylg" smret eht tius-ni-stnetap eht fo smialc detressa ehT .I "niteioporhtyrE detalysocylG" 211 noitceS rednU ssenetinifeD fo kcaL .0002 ,41 rebmeceD detad ,noisiceD GPB eeS ".OPE erew namuh gnidocne ecneuqes ANDc na ]eht[ gnidulcxe" yeht taht gnitats esac taht ni smialc AND eht ni remialcsid sserpxe deriuqer dna OPE namuh gnidocne ANDc hcaet yletauqeda LAIRETAM DNI/ALB REDRO EVITCETORP OT TNAUSRUP LAITNEDIFNOC SSECCA DETCIRTSER SNIATNOC Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-32 Filed 06/20/2007 Page 14 of 22 88 90174413 :fo spets eht gnisirpmoc sllec doolb der dna setycoluciter fo noitcudorp esaercni ot sllec worram enob gnisuac fo ytreporp lacigoloib oviv ni eht gnivah editpepylop niteioporhtyre detalysocylg a fo noitcudorp eht rof ssecorp A .1 211§ .C.S.U 53 301§ .C.S.U 53 2o1§ .C.S.U 53 mialC 101§ C.S.U 53 gnitnetaP elbuoD .tneitap dias fo level tircotameh eht esaercni ot evitceffe tnuoma na ni 4 mialc fo noitisopmoc lacituecamrahp a gniretsinimda sesirpmoc hcihw tneitap sisylaid yendik a gnitaert rof dohtem A .6 3 na ro 2 ,1 mialc ot gnidrocca tcudorp nietorpocylg niteioporhtyre tnuoma evitceffe yllacituepareht a gnisirpmoc noitisopmoc lacituecamrahp A .4 .6 .GIF fo ecneuqes dica onima niteioporhtyre erutam eht sesirpmoc nietorpocylg niteioporhtyre dias nierehw ,sllec doolb der dna setycoluciter fo noitcudorp esaercni ot sllec worram enob gnisuac fo ytivitca lacigoloib oviv ni eht gnivah nietorpocylg niteioporhtyre gnirrucco yllarutan-non A .3 101 § .C.S.U 53 elbuoD 211§ .C.S.U 53 3o·§ .C.S.U 53 2o·§ .C.S.U 53 mialC gnitnetaP dilavnI eB ot ehcoR yb detressA smialC .sesnefed niatrec detressa eht fo hcihw yb dilavni era tius-ni-stnetap stnemelppus eht fo smialc gniwohs trahc gniwollof eht htiw esnopser siht ehcoR ESNOPSER LATNEMELPPUS .epocs eurt sti dnatsrednu ot tra eht ni delliks eno selbane taht rennam a ni rettam tcejbus eht mialc yltcnitsid ot gniliaf rof 211 § rednu etinifedni 7 mialc ot si flesti 7 mialc ,noitatimil siht sniatnoc hcihw fo hcae ,6-1 smialc morf sdneped esuaceB .denimreted eb tonnac noitatimil siht fo sdnuob dna setem reporp eht ,edivorp sliaf noitacificeps eht taht ecnadiug rehtruf tuohtiW ".niteioporhtyre fo U" gnirusaem ehT rof dohtem yna mialc eht esolcsid ti seod ron "niteioporhtyre fo U" enifed ton seod noitacificeps .esarhp LAIRETAM DNI/ALB REDRO EVITCETORP OT TNAUSRUP LAITNEDIFNOC SSECCA DETCIRTSER SNIATNOC Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-32 Filed 06/20/2007 Page 15 of 22 98 90174413 nierehw .sllec OHC era sllec tsoh dias mialc ot gnidrocca ssecorp ehT .2 ..morfereht dias niteioporhtyre detalysocylg editpepylop gnitalosi )b( dna ;niteioporhtyre namuh gnidocne ecneuqes AND detalosi na htiw detcefsnart ro demrofsnart sllec tsoh nailammam ,snoitidnoc tnedtun elbatius rednu ,gniworg )a( 101§ C.S.U 53 .C.S.U 53 3o1§ .C.S.U 53 201§ .C.S.U 53 mialC gnitnetaP elbuoD LAIRETAM DNI/ALB REDRO EVITCETORP OT TNAUSRUP LAITNEDIFNOC SSECCA DETCIRTSER SNIATNOC Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-32 Filed 06/20/2007 Page 16 of 22 09 90174413 sllac nailammam era sllec dias nierehw 6 dna 4 ,2 smialc ot gnidrocca ssecorp ehT .9 .AND eneg )RFHD( esatcuder etalofordyhiD si AND eneg rekram deifilpma dias nierehw 7 mialc fo ssecorp ehT .8 .AND eneg rekram deifilpma esirpmoc rehtruf sllec etarbetrev dias nierehw 6 mialc fo ssecorp ehT .7 .sllec dias yb desserpxe editpepylop dias gnitalosi )b niteioporhtyre detalysocylg dna ;6 .GIF fo ecneuqes dica onima niteioporhtyre erutam eht gnidocne AND deifilpma gnisirpmoc sllec etarbetrev ,snoitidnoc tneirtun elbatius rednu ,gniworg )a :fo spets eht gnisirpmoc sllec doolb der dna setycoluciter fo noitcudorp esaercni ot sllec worram enob gnisuac fo ytreporp lacigoloib oviv ni eht gnivah editpepylop niteioporhtyre detalysocylg a fo no·cudorp eht rof ssecorp A .6 .AND retomorp lariv si AND retomorp dias nierehw 4 mialc fo ssecorp ehT .5 .sllec dias yb desserpxe editpepylop niteioporhtyre detalysocylg dias gnitalosi )b dna ;6 .GIF fo ecneuqes dica onima niteioporhtyre erutam eht gnidocne AND ot deknil ylevitarepo ,AND retomorp niteioporhtyre namuh naht rehto ,AND retomorp gnisirpmoc sllec etarbetrev ,snoitidnoc tneirtun elbatius rednu ,gniworg )a :fo spets eht gnisirpmoc sllec doolb der dna setycoluciter fo noitcudorp esaercni ot sllec worram enob gnisuac fo ytreporp lacigoloib oviv ni eht gnivah editpepylop niteioporhtyre detalysocylg a fo noitcudorp eht rof ssecorp A .4 lo1§ gnitnetaP 211§ .C.S.U 53 3o1§ .C.S.U 53 2o1§ .C.S.U 53 mialC c.s.u s3 elbuoD LAIRETAM DNI/ALB REDRO EVITCETORP OT TNAUSRUP LAITNEDIFNOC SSECCA DETCIRTSER SNIATNOC Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-32 Filed 06/20/2007 Page 17 of 22 19 90174413 .erutluc ni nworg sllec nailammam morf deifirup si niteioporhtyre dias nierehw ,reirrac ro tnavujda ,tneulid elbatpecca yllacituecamrahp a dna niteioporhtyre namuh fo tnuoma evitceffe yllacituepareht a gnisirpmoc noitisopmoc lacituecamrahp A .1 101§ gnitnetaP 211§ .C.S.U 53 301§ .C.S.U 53 2o1§ .C.S.U 53 mialC C.S.U 53 elbuoD .6 ro 5 ,4 ,3 ,2 ,I mialc ot gnidrocca sllec etarbetrev ,snoitidnoc tneirtun elbatius rednu ,gnirutluc fo pets eht gnisirpmoc niteioporhtyre gnicudorp rof ssecorp A .7 101§ /gnitnetaP 301§ .C.S.U 53 .C.S.U 53 201§ .C.S.U 53 mialC C.S.U 53 elbuoD LAIRETAM DNI/ALB REDRO EVITCETORP OT TNAUSRUP LAITNEDIFNOC SSECCA DETCIRTSER SNIATNOC Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-32 Filed 06/20/2007 Page 18 of 22 29 90174413 .]?tneitap .cis[ tcudorp dias fo level tircotameh eht esaercni ot evitceffe tnuoma na ni 21 mialc fo noitisopmoc lacituecamrahp a gniretsinimda sesirpmoc hcihw tneitap sisylaid yendik a gnitaert rof dohtem A .41 .reirrac 7 mialc ot a ro tnavujda ,tneulid elbatpecca yllacituecamrahp a dna gnidrocca ypareht niteioporhtyre rof evitceffe tcudorp nietorpocylg fo tnuoma evitceffe na gnisirpmoc noitisopmoc lacituecamrahp A .21 .tneitap dias fo level tircotameh eht esaercni ot evitceffe tnuoma na ni 9 mialc fo noitisopmoc lacituecamrahp a gniretsinimda sesirpmoc hcihw tneitap sisylaid yendik a gnitaert rof dohtem A .11 .reirrac ro tnavujda ,tneulid elbatpecca yllacituecamrahp a dna 6 ro 5 ,4 ,3 ,2,1 mialc ot gnidrocca ypareht niteioporhtyre rof evitceffe tcudorp nietorpoclyg a ]fo .cis[ tnuoma evitceffe na gnisirpmoc noitisopmoc lacituecamrahp A .9 .llec OHC a si llec nailammam namuh-non eht nierehw 7 mialc ot gnidrocca tcudorp nietorpocylg ehT .8 .llec nailammam namuh-non a si llec tsoh eht nierehw 6 ro 5 ,4 ,3 mialc ot gnidrocca tcudorp nietorpocylg ehT .7 .sllec doolb der dna setycoluciter fo noitcudorp esaercni ot sllec worram enob gnisuac fo ytreporp lacigoloib oviv ni eht gnissessop tcudorp dias niteioporhtyre namuh gnidocne ecneuqes AND a gnisirpmoc ecneuqes AND suonegoxe na fo llec tsoh nailammam a ni noisserpxe eht fo tcudorp nietorpocylg gnirrucco yllarutan-non A .3 101§ gnitnetaP 3o § .C.S.U 53 .C.S.U 53 201§ .C.S.U 53 mialC C.S.U 53 elbuoD LAIRETAM DNI/ALB REDRO EVITCETORP OT TNAUSRUP LAITNEDIFNOC SSECCA DETCIRTSER SNIATNOC Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-32 Filed 06/20/2007 Page 19 of 22 39 90174413 DETCADER .evoba deifitnedi sa dilavni tius -ni-stnetap eht fo smialc detressa eht redner 800,307,4 .oN ehcoR tnetaP .S.U fo 72 dna ,62 ,52 ,42 ,32 ,8 ,7 ,6 ,5 ,4 ,2 ,1 smialc tsael Page 20 of 22 ta taht sdnetnoc ,gnitnetap elbuod ot tcepser htiW Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-32 LAIRETAM DNI/ALB REDRO EVITCETORP OT TNAUSRUP LAITNEDIFNOC SSECCA DETCIRTSER SNIATNOC Filed 06/20/2007 601 90174413 2929-344 )716( .leT 01120 AM ,notsoB teertS remmuS 521 PLL NIETSNUS & GREBMORB )963366 #OBB( smoT .E htieK )061265 #OBB( notsuH ailuJ )084850 #OBB( grebmorB lraC eeL dna 0008-638 )212( :leT 22001 YN ,kroY weN eunevA kraP 524 PLL RELOHCS EYAK )eciv cah orp( huS .S drawoH )eciv cah orp( gnimelF .F samohT )eciv cah orp( nosraC .A aicirtaP )eciv cah orp( imA-neB aroeL gnimelF .F samohT/s/ ,syenrotta sti yB .CNI EHCOR AL-NNAMFFOH dna ,HBMG SCITSONGAID EHCOR ,DTL EHCOR AL-NNAMFFOH .F 7002 ,2 LAIRETAM DNI/ALB lirpA :DETAD REDRO EVITCETORP OT TNAUSRUP LAITNEDIFNOC SSECCA DETCIRTSER SNIATNOC Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-32 Filed 06/20/2007 Page 21 of 22 701 9o174413 zepoL esineD zepoL esineD/s/ 8440-474 )213( :elimiscaF 0015-318 )056( :elimiscaF 0005-318 )056( :enohpeleT 40349 AC ,otlA olaP evirD retroP 0513 YREME & LLIW TTOMREDcM cah orp( III edeaG .G mailliW 0036-474 )213( :enohpeleT 60606 LI ogacihC rewoT sraeS 0036 evirD rekcaW htuoS 332 PLL NUROB & NIETSREG ,LLAHSRAM )eciv cah orp( ssoR .I samohT )eciv cah orp( srewolF .M niveK 1029-982 )716( :elimiscaF 0029-982 )716( :enohpeleT 01220 AM ,notsoB 005 etiuS ,eunevA citnaltA 074 PLL SIRROM ENAUD )eciv )875046 #OBB( hciR .R aicirtaP )651245#OBB( deirfttoG .R leahciM )115545#OBB( ittergellA sinneD .D rof drocer fo syenrotta eht nopu devres 0220-378 )804( :elimiscaF 0110-378 )804( :enohpeleT 41059 AC ,onitrepuC 004 etiuS ,draveluoB keerC snevetS 00302 PLL REDLEHCTAB & DIRDAM REEBESAC YAD .A adniL .A divaD .R dyolL )eciv cah orp( yelxaB-ikasaS )eciv cah orp( dirdaM )eciv cah orp( .rJ ,yaD .etad evoba eht no liame aiv )woleb detsil saw tnemucod siht fo ypoc a taht yfitrec sa( ffitnialp ybereh I eht ECIVRES FO ETACIFITREC REDRO EVITCETORP OT TNAUSRUP LAIRETAM DNI/ALB LAITNEDIFNOC SSECCA DETCIRTSER SNIATNOC Case 1:05-cv-12237-WGY Document 534-32 Filed 06/20/2007 Page 22 of 22

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?