Students for Fair Admissions, Inc. v. President and Fellows of Harvard College et al

Filing 419

DECLARATION re 417 MOTION for Summary Judgment by President and Fellows of Harvard College. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 1, # 2 Exhibit 2, # 3 Exhibit 3, # 4 Exhibit 4, # 5 Exhibit 5, # 6 Exhibit 6, # 7 Exhibit 7, # 8 Exhibit 8, # 9 Exhibit 9, # 10 Exhibit 10, # 11 Exhibit 11, # 12 Exhibit 12, # 13 Exhibit 13, # 14 Exhibit 14, # 15 Exhibit 15, # 16 Exhibit 16, # 17 Exhibit 17, # 18 Exhibit 18, # 19 Exhibit 19, # 20 Exhibit 20, # 21 Exhibit 21, # 22 Exhibit 22, # 23 Exhibit 23, # 24 Exhibit 24, # 25 Exhibit 25, # 26 Exhibit 26, # 27 Exhibit 27, # 28 Exhibit 28, # 29 Exhibit 29, # 30 Exhibit 30, # 31 Exhibit 31, # 32 Exhibit 32, # 33 Exhibit 33, # 34 Exhibit 34, # 35 Exhibit 35, # 36 Exhibit 36, # 37 Exhibit 37, # 38 Exhibit 38, # 39 Exhibit 39, # 40 Exhibit 40, # 41 Exhibit 41, # 42 Exhibit 42, # 43 Exhibit 43, # 44 Exhibit 44, # 45 Exhibit 45, # 46 Exhibit 46, # 47 Exhibit 47, # 48 Exhibit 48, # 49 Exhibit 49, # 50 Exhibit 50, # 51 Exhibit 51, # 52 Exhibit 52, # 53 Exhibit 53, # 54 Exhibit 54, # 55 Exhibit 55, # 56 Exhibit 56, # 57 Exhibit 57, # 58 Exhibit 58, # 59 Exhibit 59, # 60 Exhibit 60, # 61 Exhibit 61, # 62 Exhibit 62, # 63 Exhibit 63, # 64 Exhibit 64, # 65 Exhibit 65, # 66 Exhibit 66, # 67 Exhibit 67, # 68 Exhibit 68, # 69 Exhibit 69, # 70 Exhibit 70, # 71 Exhibit 71, # 72 Exhibit 72, # 73 Exhibit 73, # 74 Exhibit 74, # 75 Exhibit 75, # 76 Exhibit 76, # 77 Exhibit 77, # 78 Exhibit 78, # 79 Exhibit 79, # 80 Exhibit 80, # 81 Exhibit 81, # 82 Exhibit 82, # 83 Exhibit 83, # 84 Exhibit 84, # 85 Exhibit 85, # 86 Exhibit 86, # 87 Exhibit 87, # 88 Exhibit 88, # 89 Exhibit 89, # 90 Exhibit 90, # 91 Exhibit 91, # 92 Exhibit 92, # 93 Exhibit 93, # 94 Exhibit 94, # 95 Exhibit 95, # 96 Exhibit 96, # 97 Exhibit 97)(Ellsworth, Felicia)

Download PDF
EXHIBIT 70 02 13 5 134 2 679             7 !  8 7  9   9     7    ‚ …†‡ ˆ ‰ ‹Œ‚ ‰Ž‰‡ „ …ŒŠ ‰ŒŠ ‡ …„ ’“ ”‚ “ Š ‚ ƒ„ ‡ … ‚ Š „ ‚ † „ „ ‘‚ …Ž ƒ„‚ Š Œ Š •–† ‚ …‘‰ „ ‰† Œ ˜ TVX^ U^ WXb cdefWeY UWYY ]_`a ]`a Yc] Z\] Z g^eaZ hd ijlm op tuvlqwx zn sr}tum t~ lp  |€tom np qrs y {rq|p vm rto uwpq|  tp ( ™ )* *.0 2*4 6890 :-.5 <=>;* 7 5 > 78-51- <2*-6++>+* 205 +,- 13 572 1 2 ; 6* 6. ; ;+0 .9 *1>+* 3 > 0 2 ; 2 <?-*.7 * 2 0 95 2*-+0 28+*2; A7.5B0>@2 * < -*5-C -.C 02; >*. 2<; , < 23 > ;39 *>@ *< 9?2; 0 ; 0. *027 C ->@ -655 <*3 >C75>+5 2*D08@E 5>8; 2;6 8-8 23 8 * . * A3 -C -B **0 * , 5. 816896++>2*> F; 59G J ->*5* K5?-LM0 @ * *02<?8C< 9 +58572 0 2* ; 5 7 - HIB*2-2. -5<. 8; N 3 8 5 <02*C*.<?* 3 22<; , < <?->9 ;8<; -65<?->9 .*.;>80 *< ; 1NO -.* >P25 .7 * 2 0 9 >*.2Q>67 >@ 5>8 >*.2Q> .* 252 0 -C< @@68 ,*2?.5 <>.>7>; 8 .>;S 7 *50>50 R6>* ; ;2220 5+>.0 E  1   $ 7 13 04%&8 ' '  ' 1 #$ 8 814 2 111 9   9   " 1   8 7 25 1 02 13 5 134 2 679             7 !  8 7  9   9     7    [ Z () , .0231 .5* 7)09-3: <.6-=> 8?0768-0?> 1- 1*@>3:82/* * -/1 4* 4 6 8 :-; -* * ;> - /1 0 8? ) 1) 8*61 66 > * * 8*-A 4-1 0 1) > 5B:4 C6- D :.>6/ * 1- 581;1 1*E40?F 8 ;B 1* 0?0 / 1 4 8 1* / * < 8>C5*8- 1;>6 ; 1* 4 ) 0 *,0 2 ) 0 58 * * - 1D<85-8*-14 ?4 =G:H.4 , 8I*:6>-8> 1*07688.:* 124 ) 0 7)0 >8-<: 13 .8> :/ 4*1 > -: =** 114 J) - /16 /:>0 > 4; 8 * 1*K =* E4 :) -6-658 :.6J 8) :3@>3:824 (*- - C/1> <:-6.> 15* ) / :5* /1 *: 8 0 -*,6* F 8*61 < L6 1 68J4 *4 ; 8 F M *;3:821- 7** H2) : - 9-3: 1; 28> 18 065*)> 1- 7*.08-* () 8*61 ) 1 >4 ** 1 :-; 4 - 6 4 65=2 4 18? ) 1 /131N7* ; NB 14 18?1- ) 6* :* 78)1*> 7;54:= 864 1*@>1;K-*J 4 / 65*)> ) 1 - 5*?; 1 ) * * ?- ). <) 8* 116O E4 --8*I*88>=4*6:P8> QF S68 - 1*5*1> J; 8?1- 9-3: ) 65= :13 0 4 :<64 - - R. -; 1) *8?- ;> ) 1 :-; ? M*= >881O1 * ?? 78);3:828 - ;4 1 < >-- * ..>*1 :64 6B02 4 > -* 1 8*61 > > / 4 - .;58 4 1LF 8 M:-0<*1- 188-3: 6? 88- 1 5* 1 > 4 *- 7). 9-3:U38*F63: T*0 *0) 1)66 *2 8><.> 54 > - ; > 1 8) :-;6 4.F8 *2 2 F 8 41>JR. 68F 5= :- 1O S -; () 86*4 =4 1> ;3:82- > / ;::; -* .>8/;8 1*, .0266B*/> *6/ < :548? 8*61 54 ? > *?- / 16 4 1> * > ) -/1U / 6A * 1 ;6/64 4 -=4 4-1 .*1 -H81 6.=4:5B1 * 9-3: - ;1*> -B V*S* 8.68> < := 604 :-* 4> 5/8 :?- *7*> :-; > ) *:2 :0* E40? 4 W/8F ;0;-1:1**81> E40? - ;X* ?- ;E4 6:-42; -;?* 0 * < 6.W4 ** <* ) L68? 0 * > 7R> 0> >*31: / 0 *:* * * =4:5J) =4 4* V*S* .0 B :14 74 0 * - 06/ * 11 = :/ -<<)2- 5-1:6 :?- 1* := 6; :0* 40 4-8> /; > B* 1;>64 /6* 81 *: 6*U ;?* 8 ?4 -HYJ8 .:> J> 5/8B 6> 6J>- ;14 1 4) :4<:> 6> 1 *:*> 0B 0-Y<0 48?- ; 6. /8*68 ; 88> 4 1* <*8? 4 56 * ) 6Y;8 1*9-3:D :?5= -8* > ) :-;XRE=4:5F  1   $ 7 13 04%&8 ' '  ' 1 #$ 8 814 2 111 9   9   " 1   8 7 45 1 02 13 5 134 2 ‰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` d _`bcd efeghijk ^ _l_d n( ?34)5 0 +) 4; @2)5+ ` d ch gm = 2+? 0 = :,- ) -5)A ˆ o rtuwy{| v€y uƒ}~vp|{†y„ ˆ p s v xzv}~y{~ ‚y „{u ‡uz …  1   $ 7 13 04%&8 ' '  ' 1 #$ 8 814 2 111 9   9   " 1   8 7 %5 1 02 13 5 134 2 679             7 !  8 7  9   9     7    HM<@7E?==6IC <<?<WWI6W@b< =Ra> <E>Y@ C = @Y Q L<C U fhi?lg= ophqgqhg 9c7C?M= ? > deg j m oh rjs n kn rf mh jqhufemhvl tx jt e n sh m e w x fs yfkyh w mhywqoze n qxfgr ve qsj mh tx l ktmhywqovq h w xh e qsj w kl mx ty qoh mgw qh vq w xfs hjm xjklrrw {h |tkhf3 x qtm é W>Y V6=VEE6GE 6IC 7?< 7B=Y Q J876Y @U VE7M <\Ib< 9 7R6 b< UaWC7 @ 9= II< W>Y 5<7 M<R@ 6IC 6U 7?R Q }@V76@<cEY< ? _<6YEM @O< b< >7B=W> 7^6C U C7R@;<< 9 @ <E?S6IC = CE I= Q ?7 =6 GE 9VE W H7=<H E\b< AH C<==MEC @ Ukhm6=Cm@yyqhjxhu 9G7@?gnj w ? E ~x e i k h jl ywqof {h hj|t kmw zg qsj x x qg ljfx jg rl h muf kw r {h |t mtxr g e wh x g klrrvw e rohqoyt w qh qomh j zhj h wvqx rjkqfsm €hxw mh vhfszkwtx w j ve i kgnw qrj t‚fxh jlm v m x kh kr ƒfe h€3 ofe kjg ‚ m3 )*+ ./ , 01 ê 25687 ;<>@= >B6>=E AC <=G< HI<CD7 =<<L< = 3 769 =?9A><C@<D7 F6C @ C9@=E JK>@ M< NA9 =?@ ;6<6;<E9FOA>E=8 F6ISC@E9LP 3 M? E= C=C >7 E 7=PQ <R<H6D7S G = TH6UEE >VEWQ7 6?R5687 69H6<F8Y@<C6?@S679DE 6 5<5<9 3C7 >@M?= 7D7<W>@ 769 @ CCX<<P8=? C =Z7< 7MFK 6= RE [H7?\<?RG\ FD 7 F6 3C6RC@@ < <C 9 <@ O6 ]^\ P @CIB7P<CQVY?= Q 7 3 Q _E`HBEC9@? E?>A@ME< C C „ …†‡†‰…Š‹Œ  …Ž … “” —˜”—•š ˜›– •– “” šœ “ Ÿ¡ —ž£¡¢¥– š£¤¨ Ÿ   ªŸ« ˜ž ŸªŸ–« ›§ ­ ž  ¢¤Ÿ¦§ žŸ ž © ž § Ÿ ¢£ž § ¡ª ¬­ ® ¯ ±³°µ±·´¶ º»¸² ½´² º¾¾·¿À° ´¶Á¶·¸¼¸º¾°²°´±³¸°²´± ²°¶¾ ¸´Ã °²´ ¶°¸² ¶ ¼ ³º° ± °°¼ »°Á± ±°²´ ± ±´À°°´ ±°¶Á ± ³²¹ ¹ + *’+ 1 ‘ *./ – —•Å” Ĕ ˜Æ˜Çŗǖ ÇÈǘśɘÊƘÇËË”Ì Î ” ÍÏ + *’+ 1 ‘ *./ – —ž Ð«   Ÿ ÇÑ«ª ɡЫ ҝ ¡Ÿ¤”¬Õ¢ž ®Ÿª ž¤Çž © ¤¤Ç›žÊÖ ­ « § ª ¡¡ª « ¡¤ ­ ¡¨¨ ®Ó« ԝ Ÿ­ «›   Ÿ ª ­Ÿ¡  ¤ Æ®Ó ® ›°µ±¾˜º¾³º²¢¢´¥‘´Á´»»°ØÙÚÛÜ°׼´¾Ý¿º¾¶Á³±¾°´´¾³º²º½¾°»¶º×º´¸À´Á´»»°Ü°½Á±¶°¸¼³²²±¾¶Á ­¢®´´Õ ž 0׺Ÿ¸ ¼ º ¬« ¤­ ¤Ó® ¢ , °Á ° ¾  ² ¿¸° ± Áº ° º ½ ¾ ¼ º ´ ¼ ¸ ¸º ± ³ ¾´´¾ º°×¼Þº¾¸º° ¶×¶ ºÁ¼ ºº¾°½Ã ± °Áº³² ´ ± ´¸² ² ¿ß¿³ ¶±°  – Ҙš ʕà˜Ç•Å› —Åš Ĕ ˛ – Ê Ä­ à®¬¬«ž¤“¢¢ž« ª–¬ž ®Ð ›Õ¡Ÿ¤–  ¡¨ŸÉ ¬ Ñʞ ­á§ ¢â ¤­ ž § ­­ ¥  «« § ¨Ö­ § «á , °1¶¶ ² ä¼ ±²0¶ ² å æ¼ ¾1¼ç°¿  Áã¹° »»³ ¶ »¸¼ 1¼ ¼ Ü ¿ ¹ è + *’+ 1 ‘ *./  1   $ 7 13 04%&8 ' '  ' 1 #$ 8 814 2 111 9   9   " 1   8 7 (5 1 02 13 5 134 2 679             7 !  8 7  9   9     7    123456 57 38:< ?:A<3:BC D B< F= GA :H3C8 = @ 6 KLCMNE OF 9;= @ B:=58@E< @ <=B IJ8 @C = FK = 8 PQ TT V UZ[\Q]T * `T Q^aQb[d.f ^ ghY eV Q[jQRUhVZRUY [YU kT ]T S T[ V S bhV^ RSUV XY Y TQ^ _ QU Y T ce V UZQ^^ Yi Qi V V UY U^ V UUl `Ti T V Zhm Y V * ,-* 0 + ,./ * ,-* 0 + ,./ n G5o 7q452qrp sro N6 3p n 7 r<:O2t 7=8o@C E8 4M; 3:FFBw8x<E8yF IM<:O38 < K6 C F= LC = @= t ; =FK ;B <u FCv@M 8@F C 6 <E @= = = Jt ?8:O J8 z^QQ[jRiZihUXV V[VV_ihfVUYiQl^i [TQhU[UhQYY QjTiRiQXV[U `UZb[ V URQc Uc ^lQY V f l { Qh Y [ l i Y c l f k f f Q U^ZZUXf]hbZbVZii|QQ[URU_fY[ b[ QRQfY UT[j hV[ fi T]^Z ZT i Y if Qf Q i V Y Y iiQXQQ` TXRU YT Ui ]T `UiQUi Uh[ m V Y `i }  1   $ 7 13 04%&8 ' '  ' 1 #$ 8 814 2 111 9   9   " 1   8 7 ~ (5 1 02 13 5 134 2 ()**+ . ()**/,01 ,n ,P † E+ )**+ 679             7 !  8 7  9   9     7    + ; 789: 5 , 4 2)30 7):<1=+ - . J 9 K   8 2>?@ CD AB@ >E7@ ?AFGB@ 7IF7 L CDH@ 7  OP+ M4 77  0 */.   Q R SUW YWV[V]Y_` Vc_VVVXf YWVf ^ VX ZVY \ \^^ab d UWe V ZV_Z e ^VV[_Ze \e Vhgf ijVd e Y jVjY ^^e g W Vf fX f _Y i f jjg ^ f _^ kVf jVd e Y ^V jY ^^ekVf Y ajVd e Y l f jjg ^g X f _^ Y lf f j jg ^ me \ m` a\ VjVkVfm Y ^ f ^ f V ^V Y jV g `a e f _ d Y e me e Y ZWg g W\ Vm Ya_ Wb f 4 ˆ " 7 MN M  ‡ A9 1o):0 M4 77  ,n :.   Q R pV Vme ^Vr s\Xe SWmY at_fV ` Y _ `\ k[W qg Y`^ q ^ f sV sm f fke mX WYqW a^VWskk_kV ^eYaUWVm` V ^ e X Vq_kV g _ e ^ f ^ _Vm ^af [ a b ue q fX^V g aYs` jg ^aUWV kVf Y ag j j_e \ g X Y \V Y v_Vmv Y m f e ^ e ^_ _b e [Yf ^ 4 ‰ " 7 MN M  ‡ (9 /9 ><. :+ M4 77  . w +O :   Q R x]We Y\[\ U ^Y ybb Wsf YV` Y \^ a Vmf \ V_ V g ^ t SkV_Y m W f [V e e X V m [s`V` le l g ]e \e ^g W _ e Wf ^e e VY ml g mkV` l V]V ` ^VVf ` Y_f a f^ YVkY mY a ` l [\ U ^Y e WV`Y_f\ V e zg U ] f l g x V_ V g ^ ` a s^e _ V d ms Y _ t `gSq_YY a ` lg xY lUWjg W \ V `g mf e ^ Ws f l g ^V W{ VVX VV_ d ms Ylf l [\ U ^Y ^V me \l` V`Y_f `g mY a x V_ V g ^g X g `a e W a s^e V eV g W _ ^Vybbg `ag \ ^Vybb` lW` l UW VVf g t me \ V] g tl g el g me \ g \ t `gSq_YY ame \ g \ ^VxY Y a^V g `a V] e ^ Ws f g `a V] g W{ f g SmY s` ^_mm jVj_ [ Y \^ [ _ ` e Wq^Wb _f e fWVle \ V [V e `\ ] ` ``V \ a r We Ws_ Wf e ` g\ V b a 2 " 7 MN M  ‡ *9. -.9-} !79  M4 77  w90|0 7~   Q €V\Ya \m_ R " 7 MN M  ‡ =)<M4 77   Q R ‚g g Y \ VvY`^ yf fke mX„f em t` V ^ V Va_ ƒr s\X Y _ `\ a WV ^af f …_Vm^v UW_X  1   $ 7 13 04%&8 ' '  ' 1 #$ 8 814 2 111 9   9   " 1   8 7 05 1 02 13 5 134 2 679             7 !  8 7  9   9     7    +, ., 12-344 7-:. ;< <=> ?1@< >? - .0 03 568 931 - 5 :3 4 20 1 A0>:5<B> 5D. E0CF>53:.9 +-2>?IJ ?3.> C< > 0 G 9-H ?50 252F J K, 5L-M7 02 9? B-N2FJ931-0?: << - 4O-0 2-4?-:. 2 .< 5D < 2NP 2 " 7 )* )  ‰ Q S UVWXS)4 77  RTQ Y   Z [ K,?, ?O9=0- 0-> C 35-920.0?- < 5 - 0> < 2 J >593>29< ? => D . 3 0-?5 > 29: .1\, 2 55-9<0.>?0\, 9< 5 23 < : > <2 00.? > .?. 0 > O ?1.0\>44N251.0=>.5 ? - , 2 50?. , ?.=0P A0J5=5D4N2515? ND 055=0<< 3?P -J2 < 50?. ? > -: .? - 5D0? 2 " 7 )* )  ‰ ]^ `aUb _^ 4 77  _^ ]^ `   Z R Vc) Š [ 7 =O2 > .08 931> e2?- 4G5<0 d0 0? J, -:. J . < 90 9? : - 5 :32-J2 4.02 < <=> ?1 0J5=0 , 5 9==5=0 .>-4N20?: 0 . > 1- .02=> .3 > . < . 50? .4< O 4 ., 5 <,1 =0.< K:?-f 05D 04 1 N.< . 0 4 20-2C 2?C >.< 29-- 40, 5 >5D > < >? 0>.: C 25D -53< .<9 C:-5=- .0 323 ., ? g>3DP 3 07 0 h?2-=ijklmpq o tov ?2-=i -9? o okkrs uhw-9? 2 " 7 )* )  ‰ aUaUR 4 77  TUaU)   Z -5< < 0 < . C 3x D. y >-J21: ?- ? 04 > - C1 \0 > - : . > > z 2 ‹ [ " 7 )* )  ‰ {|R R |{c^|)4 77  TSQ X   Z ;< <=> ?N.?-0?P.4 6z - 5 : >0 2 >P51} P [ " 7 )* )  ‰ ~Y _Y€R 4 77  US XUW)   Z [ ‚0, C , 4- 3-. < J931=0 0 N.4--<., 2- ? - .0?> 0-:. =O2 >0 D5?.0 2C 2J2.0?M > 4N251> > 55< - < .0 0>.> , -0 J 50?. J C<> ? => D , J931P -:.P P ƒ50?. 4 0 < . „?f >=-.2> 0?7-530, 57 N251 >? > 05.< .0 < F 29-w.<9 O 9D> < f 1:4 < . -0-?D 55- . : 0 > -M2: 4 5 > > > , N 5<J9< < =O2 J J ?: 0 .J> > 259=0J=50P - C20 .D > .4<?2=3\0 <> - 3 ?+, . 09<-0 J 5 ?: 0 .- B-N2 9=0J> - 3 ?5 .03\0 … ‡ .4<? . 2-4 > 2=J=50 < , > 2 † 5 59=0O-M. <> 290 ˆ e?J2e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v ,  77 Z[ ^[`ac f g9  O4 77  \] b\d    * e PIUJ E 6REC989;E TEK 4 9 I 4 7 4J : ; 6 Eh;C 45 6@ 8 Ii UBR;4 K I : H; E ?;HC RU 88J E;7EU: 6: F 5C ; 4 H4 C ; IEC QC U;C EC UJ6 Q J 6 4 5 7N " 7 O1 O  v n c \t b c o jklcm]l[ u pqqrnskcb \k]cn[pqqrnskcpqq x w   ("  6  79 )7 7 * + "   , -   6 . ,. 9   , *   9   .8 . /9 0*7  7    0     07 0 8  8 120  *   ! 8 7 !8    7 .8  9    " 0 .8   9     " 34 68: => AB: DEF7 37HIJ LM 5 79 ; ?@ C 7EG 8 4 KJN  1   $ 7 13 04%&8 ' '  ' 1 #$ 8 814 2 111 9   9   " 1   8 7 55 1

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.

Why Is My Information Online?