Robotic Vision Technologies LLC et al v. Shafi
ORDER Appointing Special Master. Signed by District Judge Victoria A. Roberts. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit, # 2 Exhibit) (LVer)
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
EASTERN DISTRICT OF MICHIGAN
ROBOTIC VISION TECHNOLOGIES LLC and
Case No. 11-12909
Hon. Victoria A. Roberts
Mag. Judge Laurie J. Michelson
ORDER APPOINTING SPECIAL MASTER
The Court convened telephone conferences with counsel for the parties and
communicated with counsel by email in January and February 2014. Pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P.
53(b)(1), the Court provided the parties and their respective counsel notice and an opportunity to
be heard on the proposed appointment of Lee A. Hollaar, Ph.D., as Special Master.
In accordance with Fed. R. Civ. P. 53(b)(3)(A), Dr. Hollaar provided an affidavit
disclosing whether there is any ground for disqualification under 28 U.S.C. § 455; his affidavit is
attached as Exhibit 1.
In an email dated January 30, 2014, T. Michael Doyle – counsel for Defendant Adil Shafi
(“Defendant”) – informed the Court and opposing counsel that “[Defendant] accepts the
recommendation of Judge Roberts as to a special master [i.e., Dr. Hollaar] … [but] proposes that
the losing party be responsible for the total fee of the special master.” Through emails dated
February 12 and 13, 2014, the Court sent the parties’ respective counsel a Proposed Order
Appointing Special Master, in which Plaintiffs bear 50% and Defendant bears 50% of Dr.
Hollaar’s fees and expenses; the Court asked if either party had objections to the order. In an
email dated February 14, 2014, Defendant objected to the entry of the order.
Notwithstanding Defendant’s objection, the Court ORDERS that:
Pursuant to Fed.R.Civ.P. 53(a), Lee A. Hollaar, Ph.D., is appointed as Special
Master in order to conduct a confidential and neutral comparison of any similarities,
duplications, and derivations of:
a) Defendant’s source code(s) for vision software sold to and/or installed at a
customer by him – personally or through any entity, including but not
limited to Aptura and Advenovation – during the periods of (i) November 25,
2008 to June 30, 2009, and (ii) December 1, 2012 to November 30, 2013,
To or From
b) The following source codes owned by Plaintiff Robotic VISION
Technologies LLC (“RVT”): (i) the Reliabot source code which Braintech,
Inc. acquired from Defendant, SHAFI, Inc., and SHAFI Innovation by
agreements dated August 12, 2008; and (ii) the source code(s) developed by
Braintech prior to November 24, 2008 for vision software and any iterations
thereof Plaintiff RVT chooses to submit.
In order for Dr. Hollaar to conduct his comparative analysis in accordance with
the authority conferred by Fed. R. Civ. P. 53(c), each party must produce its source code in its
native development environment with the tools necessary to generate the compiled object by
providing Dr. Hollaar with a portable laptop computer loaded with their respective systems,
development systems and source code repositories (with full meta data).
If tools whose
documentation is not readily available are used, a copy of documentation for such tools shall be
included. Proceeding in this manner ensures that each party’s source code remains separated
from the other’s source code.
By March 4, 2014, Dr. Hollaar must convene a telephone conference with the
parties and their respective counsel and experts to discuss appropriate procedures to facilitate and
enable Dr. Hollaar to conduct the comparison analysis of the source codes, including the tangible
items necessary for Dr. Hollaar to validate and authenticate that the source code(s) provided by
Defendant were in fact utilized in software products that were sold and installed at customer
The parties must deliver their laptops to Dr. Hollaar by March 14, 2014, via
overnight air courier, such as UPS or FedEx, return shipping pre-paid. Upon receipt, Dr. Hollaar
may circulate any inquiries regarding the nature of the materials provided.
After conducting a comparative analysis of the parties’ respective source codes,
Dr. Hollaar must prepare a preliminary report for review and comment by the parties. Dr.
Hollaar must deliver the preliminary report to counsel for the parties by electronic mail no later
than May 2, 2014.
Upon receipt of the Dr. Hollaar’s preliminary report, the parties have 20 days to
submit comments and objections to the preliminary report and then 10 additional days to
comment on or object to the submissions of the other party. Throughout the process, the parties
and Dr. Hollaar may convene telephone conferences, at the discretion of Dr. Hollaar, to discuss
comments, objections and submissions.
After conferring with the parties and reviewing their submissions, Dr. Hollaar
must file with the Court a final report under seal no later than June 24, 2014.
As required by Fed. R. Civ. P. 53(f), the parties have 20 days after the filing of Dr.
Hollaar’s final report to file formal objections with the Court. The filing of oppositions and
replies to any such objections is governed by the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure and the Local
Rules of this District.
Dr. Hollaar will not issue any orders. All communications, notices to the parties
and requests for information will be sent by electronic mail to the following addresses:
a. For Plaintiffs: Thomas G. McNeill; TMcNeill@dickinsonwright.com
b. For Defendant: T. Michael Doyle; firstname.lastname@example.org
c. Special Master: Lee A. Hollaar; email@example.com
Dr. Hollaar shall not engage in any ex parte communications with the parties or
their respective counsel or experts. All telephone calls shall be joint, and any emails or other
correspondence shall be copied to opposing counsel. Dr. Hollaar may communicate ex parte
with the Court about any matter regarding the scope and performance of his rights and duties
under this Order.
Dr. Hollaar’s fees are $300.00 per hour. Plaintiffs will bear 50% and Defendant
will bear 50% of Dr. Hollaar’s fees and expenses. In order to guarantee payment of those fees
and expenses, Plaintiff RVT and Defendant must each deliver to Dr. Hollaar a retainer in the
amount of $5,000 by February 28, 2014. Dr. Hollaar must submit monthly invoices for his
services to the parties’ respective counsel; those invoices will be billed against the deposited
funds. If the deposited funds fall below $2,000 in the aggregate, Dr. Hollaar may require the
parties to deliver additional funds, in an amount which he deems reasonable in light of the
remaining uncompleted work; the parties must deliver the additional funds to Dr. Hollaar within
five business days of his request. If a party fails to deliver the initial retainer of $5,000 or fails
to deliver additional funds as deemed necessary, Dr. Hollaar may inform the Court.
Upon the filing of his final report, Dr. Hollaar must submit his final invoice to the
parties’ respective counsel. After the final invoice has been paid in full, Dr. Hollaar must
disburse any remaining deposited funds; 50% must be disbursed to Plaintiffs and 50% must be
disbursed to Defendant.
The proprietary information and data produced during the course of Dr. Hollaar’s
analysis is deemed Highly Confidential pursuant to the Protective Order entered by the Court on
February 14, 2013. (See Doc. # 47). Dr. Hollaar reviewed the Protective Order and agrees to
comply with its terms; a copy of the Protective Order and Dr. Hollaar’s signed undertaking is
attached as Exhibit 2. In the event that Dr. Hollaar’s report, including any preliminary versions,
contains proprietary information of the parties, the same is also deemed Highly Confidential
under the Protective Order.
IT IS ORDERED.
S/Victoria A. Roberts
Victoria A. Roberts
United States District Judge
Dated: February 18, 2014
The undersigned certifies that a copy of this
document was served on the attorneys of
record by electronic means or U.S. Mail on
February 18, 2014.
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?