North Atlantic Operating Company, Inc., et al. v. Babenko, et al.

Filing 288

ENTRY OF DEFAULT JUDGMENT Following Orders Granting Plaintiffs' Motions for Default Judgment as to Certain Defendants. Default Judgment entered against Harvey Dan, Dhgate Seller CNGZSS, Dhgate Seller CNGZSS1, Dhgate Seller Jackyhu, Dhgate Selle r Kathy0577, Ebay Seller Anlpa91, Ebay Seller Auctionlegends, Ebay Seller Bestdealmontreal, Ebay Seller Dollarplusdiscount1, Ebay Seller Harda-Enlhui, Ebay Seller Honestfisherman2015, Ebay Seller Honestvalues1, Ebay Seller Hookupdealsforyou, Ebay Sel ler Huapur_6233, Ebay Seller Kal Tek_Shop, Ebay Seller Kyystore, Ebay Seller Mimifbabyy, Ebay Seller Ryan0201168, Francis Ferland, Alice Huang, JingJing Huang, Kal Huang, Kale Huang, Narek Nazaryan, Mimi Nguyen, Jaime Ortiz, Anle Pan, Ryan Pan, Zhangqi Pan, Andrew Russell, Speedzone, Super Home Variety Store. Signed by District Judge Terrence G. Berg. (AChu)

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
EASTERN DISTRICT OF MICHIGAN
SOUTHERN DIVISION

NORTH ATLANTIC
OPERATING COMPANY,
INC.; NATIONAL TOBACCO
COMPANY, L.P.,
Plaintiff,
Case No. 15-14013
Hon. Terrence G. Berg

v.
JINGJING JUANG, et al.,
Defendants.

ENTRY OF DEFAULT JUDGMENT FOLLOWING ORDERS
GRANTING PLAINTIFFS’ MOTIONS FOR DEFAULT
JUDGMENT AS TO CERTAIN DEFENDANTS
This matter is before the Court on Plaintiff North Atlantic
Operating Company, Inc. and Plaintiff National Tobacco Company,
L.P.’s Application for Entry of Default Judgment. Dkt. 286. On May
9, 2017, the Court granted in part Plaintiffs’ Motion for Default
Judgment. Dkt. 276. That order also awarded statutory damages in
the amount of $200,000 per group of defendants and ordered
Plaintiffs to submit an accounting of its attorneys’ fees, costs, and
investigative fees. Id. at Pg ID 2416-17. Plaintiffs submitted the
requested information, Dkt. 277, 278, and the Court issued an order
awarding fees and costs in the amount of $333,519.59. Dkt. 284 at
1

Pg ID 2529. Divided among the fourteen defendants against whom
the Court granted default judgment, the fees and costs award
amounts to $23,822.83 per group. In total, the statutory damages
and fees and costs awarded to Plaintiffs are $3,133,519.59, or
$223,822.83 per group of defendants. Plaintiffs now seek entry of
default judgment in the amounts previously awarded, set forth in a
separate document pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 58
and Local Rule 58.1.
Accordingly, it is ORDERED AND ADJUDGED that judgment
be entered in favor Plaintiffs against the following groups of
defendants, jointly and severally, in the amount of $223,822.83 per
group:
(a)

Francis Ferland and eBay Seller bestdealmontreal;

(b)

Kale Huang, Kal Huang, and eBay Sellers Kyystore and
Kaltek-Shop;

(c)

Mimi

Nguyen

and

eBay

Sellers

mimifbabyy,

honestfisherman2015, and honestvalues1;
(d)

Narek Nazaryan and eBay Seller hookupdealsforyou;

(e)

Harvey Dan, Speedzone, and eBay Seller harda-enlhui;

(f)

Jaime Ortiz and eBay Seller auctionlegends;

(g)

Andrew Russell and eBay Seller dollarplusdiscount1;

(h)

DHGate Seller jackyhu;

(i)

DHGate Seller cngzss;
2

(j)

DHGate Seller cngzss1;

(k)

DHGate Seller kathy0577;

(l)

JingJing

Huang,

Alice

Huang,

and

eBay

Seller

HUAPUR_6233;
(m)

Anle Pan, Super Home Variety Store, Inc., and eBay Seller
ANLPA91; and

(n)

Zhangqi Pan, Ryan Pan, and eBay Seller RYAN0201168.
This case remains open and pending as to the remaining

defendants.
SO ORDERED.
s/Terrence G. Berg
HON. TERRENCE G. BERG
UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE 
Dated: September 10, 2018.

Certificate of Service
I hereby certify that this Order was electronically filed,
and the parties and/or counsel of record were served on
September 10, 2018.
s/A. Chubb
Case Manager

3