Lansing, Charter Township of et al v. Lansing Board of Water and Light

Filing 43

OPINION; Order to issue; signed by Judge Janet T. Neff (Judge Janet T. Neff, rmw)

81,7(' 67$7(6 ',675,&7 &2857
:(67(51 ',675,&7 2) 0,&+,*$1
6287+(51 ',9,6,21
&+$57(5 72:16+,3 2) /$16,1*
DQG /$16,1* 72:16+,3
'2:172:1 '(9(/230(17
$87+25,7< individually and on behalf of
all others similarly situated
3ODLQWLIIV

&DVH 1R FY

Y

+21 -$1(7 7 1())

/$16,1* %2$5' 2) :$7(5
$1' /,*+7
'HIHQGDQW
BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB
23,1,21
7KLV SXWDWLYH FODVV DFWLRQ ODZVXLW VWHPV IURP D GHFDGHVORQJ HIIRUW WR UHVROYH ZDWHU UXQRII
SUREOHPV LQ /DQVLQJ 7RZQVKLS DQG LV WKH FXOPLQDWLRQ RI D ORQJUXQQLQJ GLVDJUHHPHQW RYHU
DSSRUWLRQHG FRVWV IRU D  PLOOLRQ GUDLQ SURMHFW DPRQJ WKH DIIHFWHG JRYHUQPHQWDO HQWLWLHV DQG
ODQGRZQHUV 3ODLQWLIIV /DQVLQJ &KDUWHU 7RZQVKLS DQG /DQVLQJ 7RZQVKLS 'RZQWRZQ 'HYHORSPHQW
$XWKRULW\ FRQWHQG WKDW D ODUJH SRUWLRQ RI WKH PXOWLPLOOLRQ SURMHFW FRVW LV DWWULEXWDEOH WR 'HIHQGDQW
/DQVLQJ %RDUG RI :DWHU DQG /LJKW¶V DFWLRQV WR UHPHG\ HQYLURQPHQWDO FRQWDPLQDWLRQ RQ WKHLU
SURSHUW\ ZKLFK QHFHVVLWDWHG WKH H[WHQVLYH GUDLQ SURMHFW $IWHU IDLOLQJ WR REWDLQ VDWLVIDFWRU\ UHOLHI
LQ WKH DGPLQLVWUDWLYH SURFHVV DQG VWDWH FRXUW DSSHDOV UHODWHG WR WKH GUDLQ SURMHFW DVVHVVPHQW
3ODLQWLIIV ILOHG WKLV VXLW VHHNLQJ VHSDUDWH UHFRYHU\ RI HQYLURQPHQWDO UHVSRQVH FRVWV XQGHU WKH
&RPSUHKHQVLYH (QYLURQPHQWDO 5HVSRQVH &RPSHQVDWLRQ DQG /LDELOLW\ $FW ³&(5&/$´  86&
† D DQG WKH 0LFKLJDQ 1DWXUDO 5HVRXUFHV DQG (QYLURQPHQWDO 3URWHFWLRQ $FW ³15(3$´

0,&+ &203 /$:6 †  et seq 'HIHQGDQW /DQVLQJ %RDUG RI :DWHU DQG /LJKW ³/%:/´ RU
³%:/´ KDV ILOHG D PRWLRQ WR GLVPLVV RU LQ WKH DOWHUQDWLYH IRU VXPPDU\ MXGJPHQW 'NW 
3ODLQWLIIV KDYH ILOHG D 5HVSRQVH LQ RSSRVLWLRQ 'NW  'HIHQGDQW KDV ILOHG D 5HSO\ 'NW 
+DYLQJ IXOO\ FRQVLGHUHG WKH SDUWLHV¶ VXEPLVVLRQV WKH &RXUW FRQFOXGHV WKDW RUDO DUJXPHQW ZRXOG QRW
DVVLVW LQ WKH GLVSRVLWLRQ RI WKH LVVXHV SUHVHQWHG See :' 0LFK /&LY5 G 'HIHQGDQW¶V 0RWLRQ
LV GHQLHG
, %DFNJURXQG
7KLV FDVH KDV LWV JHQHVLV LQ JURXQGZDWHU FRQWDPLQDWLRQ OLQNHG WR 'HIHQGDQW¶V 1RUWK /DQVLQJ
/DQGILOO  1// EHJLQQLQJ LQ  DQG SODQV IRU D VWRUP GUDLQ LQ WKH *URHVEHFN 'UDLQ 'LVWULFW
HQFRPSDVVLQJ WKH ODQGILOO ZKLFK HYROYHG IURP D  SODQ LQ  WR D  SODQ DW DQ
HVWLPDWHG FRVW RI  PLOOLRQ 7KH ,QJKDP &RXQW\ 'UDLQ &RPPLVVLRQHU ³,&'&´ DSSRUWLRQHG
WKH FRVW RI WKH  GUDLQ SURMHFW SXUVXDQW WR 0LFKLJDQ VWDWXWRU\ SURYLVLRQV DVVHVVLQJ  SHUFHQW
RI WKH FRVW WR WKH 7RZQVKLS DQG  SHUFHQW WR 'HIHQGDQW 3ODLQWLIIV DOOHJH WKDW WKH LQFUHDVH
LQ FRVWV IURP WKH  'UDLQ ZDV FDXVHG SULPDULO\ E\ WKH UHOHDVHV DQG WKUHDW RI UHOHDVHV RI
FRQWDPLQDQWV DW WKH 1// VLWH DQG E\ 'HIHQGDQW¶V FRQVWUXFWLRQ RI D VOXUU\ ZDOO RQ WKH VLWH WR FRQWDLQ
FRQWDPLQDWLRQ 3ODLQWLIIV FRQWHQG WKDW LI WKRVH FRQWDPLQDQWV KDG QRW EHHQ UHOHDVHG WKH JURXQGZDWHU
FRXOG GUDLQ QDWXUDOO\ DQG WKH H[WHQVLYH QHZ GUDLQ V\VWHP ZRXOG EH XQQHFHVVDU\ 3ODLQWLIIV VHHN
FODVV DFWLRQ VWDWXV WR UHFRYHU GDPDJHV DQG REWDLQ LQMXQFWLYH UHOLHI RQ EHKDOI RI UHDO SURSHUW\ RZQHUV



7KH 'UDLQ &RPPLVVLRQHU KDV DOVR DVVHVVHG FRVWV RI DSSUR[LPDWHO\  PLOOLRQ UHODWLQJ WR
HQJLQHHULQJ IRU WKH  GUDLQ SURMHFW


ZKR KDYH LQFXUUHG RU ZLOO EH FRPSHOOHG WR LQFXU 'UDLQ $VVHVVPHQW &RVWV DV D UHVXOW RI
'HIHQGDQW¶V UHOHDVH RU WKUHDW RI UHOHDVH RI KD]DUGRXV VXEVWDQFHV RU FRQWDPLQDWLRQ
3XUVXDQW WR WKLV &RXUW¶V GLVSRVLWLYH PRWLRQ SURFHGXUHV WKH SDUWLHV KDYH VWLSXODWHG WR WKH
IROORZLQJ -RLQW 6WDWHPHQW RI 0DWHULDO )DFWV -60) 'NW  IRU SXUSRVHV RI WKH PRWLRQ
$ %DFNJURXQG RI WKH *URHVEHFN 'UDLQ


7KH *URHVEHFN 'UDLQ WKH ³'UDLQ´ LV D GUDLQ GLVWULFW LQLWLDOO\ ODLG RXW E\ WKH ,QJKDP

&RXQW\ 'UDLQ &RPPLVVLRQHU LQ 


$ SHWLWLRQ WR HVWDEOLVK WKH 'UDLQ ZDV ILOHG LQ  $ %RDUG RI 'HWHUPLQDWLRQ ZDV

FRQYHQHG DQG XOWLPDWHO\ GHWHUPLQHG WKDW WKH 'UDLQ ZDV QHFHVVDU\


2Q 0D\   WKH ,QJKDP &RXQW\ 5RDG &RPPLVVLRQ ILOHG D SHWLWLRQ ZLWK WKH

,QJKDP &RXQW\ 'UDLQ &RPPLVVLRQHU WR ³FOHDQ RXW ZLGHQ GHHSHQ VWUDLJKWHQ RU H[WHQG´ WKH
'UDLQ LQ DFFRUGDQFH ZLWK WKH 'UDLQ &RGH


,VVXHV SHUWDLQLQJ WR WKH GHFLVLRQV RI WKH %RDUG RI 'HWHUPLQDWLRQ DQG RI QHFHVVLW\ ZHUH

UHVROYHG E\ WKH 0LFKLJDQ &RXUW RI $SSHDOV LQ DQ XQSXEOLVKHG per curiam RSLQLRQ GDWHG 0D\
  Standard Aggregates, Inc. et al. v. Ingham County Drain Commissioner et al.
0LFKLJDQ &RXUW RI $SSHDOV 1R  lv. to appeal den.  0LFK   $W WKH
FRQFOXVLRQ RI WKRVH MXGLFLDO SURFHHGLQJV D ³)LQDO 2UGHU RI 'HWHUPLQDWLRQ´ ZDV LVVXHG DQG



3ODLQWLIIV KDYH VLQFH ILOHG D 1RWLFH 'NW  DGYLVLQJ WKH &RXUW WKDW WKH LVVXH ZKHWKHU
UHVSRQVH FRVWV DUH LQFXUUHG DW WKH WLPH SD\PHQW LV PDGH RU ZKHQ D SDUW\ EHFRPHV OHJDOO\ UHVSRQVLEOH
WR SD\ WKHP LV QRZ PRRW EHFDXVH 3ODLQWLIIV ZHUH DVVHVVHG FRVWV IRU WKH UHPHGLDWLRQ IRU WKH
LPSURYHPHQWV DQG KDYH EHJXQ SD\LQJ WKHP ³,Q 0DUFK  /DQVLQJ 7RZQVKLS SDLG 
WR WKH ,QJKDP &RXQW\ 'UDLQ 2IILFH DV WKH ILUVW LQVWDOOPHQW RI WKLUW\ DQQXDO SD\PHQWV WRWDOLQJ
 $IIHFWHG KRPHRZQHUV DQG EXVLQHVVHV KDYH DOVR EHJXQ SD\LQJ WKH DVVHVVHG FRVWV´ Id.
DW 3DJH,'


WKH 'UDLQ &RPPLVVLRQHU ILQDOL]HG D SODQ IRU WKH FRQVWUXFWLRQ ILQDQFLQJ DQG DSSRUWLRQPHQW
RI FRVWV IRU WKH 'UDLQ
%

%DFNJURXQG RI WKH 1RUWK /DQVLQJ /DQGILOO WKH ³1//´



,Q  WKH %:/ DFTXLUHG IHH RZQHUVKLS RI  DFUHV RI ODQG LQ /DQVLQJ 7RZQVKLS

WKDW KDV VLQFH EHFRPH NQRZQ DV WKH 1//


,Q  WKH %:/ DSSOLHG IRU DQG DFTXLUHG D OLFHQVH IURP WKH 0LFKLJDQ 'HSDUWPHQW

RI 1DWXUDO 5HVRXUFHV ³0'15´ WR RSHUDWH D 7\SH ,,, ODQGILOO IRU GLVSRVDO RI FRDO DVK
UHVXOWLQJ IURP WKH %:/¶V VWHDP HOHFWULF RSHUDWLRQV LQ /DQVLQJ


2Q -XO\   WKH 0LFKLJDQ 'HSDUWPHQW RI (QYLURQPHQWDO 4XDOLW\ ³0'(4´

DGYLVHG WKH %:/ WKDW  DQG  JURXQGZDWHU VDPSOLQJ VKRZHG HOHYDWHG OHYHOV RI
VHOHQLXP FRQVLVWHQW ZLWK WKH GLVSRVDO RI DVK DW WKH 1// 7KH 0'(4 IXUWKHU VWDWHG WKDW
³>G@XULQJ WKH ILUVW TXDUWHU  VDPSOLQJ ERURQ ZDV DOVR GHWHFWHG LQ IRXU GLIIHUHQW
PRQLWRULQJ ZHOOV´


2Q 0DUFK   0'(4 GHQLHG WKH /%:/¶V DSSOLFDWLRQ IRU D UHQHZDO RI D OLFHQVH

WR GLVSRVH RI DVK DW WKH 1//


%HWZHHQ  DQG  WKH 1// ZDV WKH VXEMHFW RI VLJQLILFDQW HQYLURQPHQWDO UHYLHZ

LQFOXGLQJ VRLO DQG JURXQGZDWHU WHVWLQJ DQG YDULRXV SURSRVHG SODQV WR DGGUHVV FRQWDPLQDWLRQ
DW WKH VLWH 7KH %:/ SURYLGHG UHPHGLDO DFWLRQ SODQV DQG SURSRVDOV IRU UHPHGLDWLRQ RI
JURXQGZDWHUUHODWHG LVVXHV DW WKH 1// WR WKH 0'(4


,Q  QHZ FRQVWUXFWLRQ SODQV IRU WKH GUDLQ ZHUH FUHDWHG ³ 3ODQ´

 ,Q  WKH %:/ EHJDQ FRQVWUXFWLRQ RI D VOXUU\ ZDOO V\VWHP WKDW FRQVROLGDWHG WKH
FRQWDPLQDWHG VRLO DQG IO\ DVK DW WKH VLWH DQG HQFDSVXODWHG LW ZLWKLQ D FOD\ EDUULHU





$W WKH VDPH WLPH WKH %:/ LQVWDOOHG D SXPSLQJ V\VWHP WR SXPS JURXQGZDWHU IURP WKH

FRQWDLQHG DUHD WR D &LW\ RI /DQVLQJ ZDWHU WUHDWPHQW IDFLOLW\


$V D SDUW RI LWV FRQVWUXFWLRQ RI WKH UHPHGLDWLRQ V\VWHP WKH %:/ DOVR HVWDEOLVKHG D

JUDGLHQW FRQWURO V\VWHP


&RQVWUXFWLRQ RI WKH VOXUU\ ZDOO EHJDQ LQ 0D\ 



&RQVWUXFWLRQ RI WKH JUDGLHQW FRQWURO V\VWHP EHJDQ LQ 6HSWHPEHU 



7KH VOXUU\ ZDOO V\VWHP ZDV IXOO\ DSSURYHG DQG LV PRQLWRUHG E\ WKH 0'(4

&

7KH $SSRUWLRQPHQW RI &RVW IRU WKH 'UDLQ



8QGHU †  RI WKH 0LFKLJDQ 'UDLQ &RGH 0&/ †  D &RXQW\ 'UDLQ

&RPPLVVLRQHU LV FKDUJHG ZLWK FDOFXODWLQJ WKH FRVW RI LPSURYHPHQWV WR D GUDLQ DQG ZLWK
DSSRUWLRQLQJ WKRVH FRVWV DPRQJ WKH RZQHUV RI SURSHUW\ ZLWKLQ D GUDLQDJH GLVWULFW


7KH &RPPLVVLRQHU GHWHUPLQHG WKH FRVW RI WKH GUDLQ LPSURYHPHQW SURMHFW WR EH

DSSUR[LPDWHO\  7KH /%:/ KDV EHHQ DVVHVVHG 

RI WKH FRVWV 3ODLQWLIIV KDYH

EHHQ DVVHVVHG WKH PDMRULW\ RI WKH FRVWV


7KH FRVW DSSRUWLRQPHQW ZDV OLWLJDWHG WKURXJK DGPLQLVWUDWLYH DQG DSSHOODWH SURFHHGLQJV

³6WDWH &RXUW 3URFHHGLQJV´


3ODLQWLIIV ILOHG WKLV DFWLRQ RQ 0D\  >@ SULRU WR WKH FRQFOXVLRQ RI WKH 6WDWH &RXUW

SURFHHGLQJV 2Q 2FWREHU   WKLV &RXUW VWD\HG WKH FDVH SHQGLQJ ILQDO UHVROXWLRQ LQ WKH
0LFKLJDQ &RXUW RI $SSHDOV DQG WKH 0LFKLJDQ 6XSUHPH &RXUW 7KLV FDVH ZDV UHRSHQHG RQ
RU DERXW 0DUFK  
3ODLQWLIIV¶ &RPSODLQW DOOHJHV QLQH FRXQWV



7KH FDVH ZDV LQ IDFW ILOHG 0D\   'NW 


&RXQW ,

&(5&/$ †  &RVW 5HFRYHU\ $OO 3ODLQWLIIV Y /%:/

&RXQW ,,

&(5&/$ 'HFODUDWRU\ -XGJPHQW $OO 3ODLQWLIIV Y /%:/

&RXQW ,,,

&RVW 5HFRYHU\ ± 0LFKLJDQ 1DWXUDO 5HVRXUFHV DQG (QYLURQPHQWDO 3URWHFWLRQ
$FW $OO 3ODLQWLIIV Y /%:/

&RXQW ,9

'HFODUDWRU\ 5HOLHI ± 15(3$ $OO 3ODLQWLIIV Y /%:/

&RXQW 9

3XEOLF 1XLVDQFH /DQVLQJ 7RZQVKLS Y /%:/

&RXQW 9,

3ULYDWH 1XLVDQFH $OO 3ODLQWLIIV Y /%:/

&RXQW 9,,

)(' 5 &,9 3 E ''$ DQG &ODVV Y /%:/

&RXQW 9,,,

%UHDFK RI &RQWUDFWXDO (DVHPHQW DQG 3UHVFULSWLYH (DVHPHQW ''$ DQG &ODVV
Y /%:/

&RXQW ,;

,QWHUIHUHQFH :LWK 1DWXUDO )ORZ $OO 3ODLQWLIIV Y /%:/

'HIHQGDQW VHHNV GLVPLVVDO DQGRU VXPPDU\ MXGJPHQW RI DOO FRXQWV
,, /HJDO 6WDQGDUGV
$ 0RWLRQ WR 'LVPLVV
'HIHQGDQW PRYHV WR GLVPLVV 3ODLQWLIIV¶ &RPSODLQW XQGHU )HGHUDO 5XOH RI &LYLO 3URFHGXUH
5XOH E RU F
5XOH E DXWKRUL]HV WKH FRXUW WR GLVPLVV D FRPSODLQW LI LW ³IDLO>V@ WR VWDWH D FODLP XSRQ
ZKLFK UHOLHI FDQ EH JUDQWHG´ ,Q GHFLGLQJ D PRWLRQ WR GLVPLVV IRU IDLOXUH WR VWDWH D FODLP WKH FRXUW
PXVW FRQVWUXH WKH FRPSODLQW LQ WKH OLJKW PRVW IDYRUDEOH WR WKH SODLQWLII DQG DFFHSW DOO ZHOOSOHDGHG
IDFWXDO DOOHJDWLRQV LQ WKH FRPSODLQW DV WUXH Thompson v. Bank of Am., N.A.  )G   WK
&LU  +RZHYHU D FRXUW ³QHHG QRW  DFFHSW DV WUXH OHJDO FRQFOXVLRQV RU XQZDUUDQWHG IDFWXDO
LQIHUHQFHV´ Kottmyer v. Maas  )G   WK &LU  7KH FRPSODLQW PXVW SUHVHQW
³HQRXJK IDFWV WR VWDWH D FODLP WR UHOLHI WKDW LV SODXVLEOH RQ LWV IDFH´ Bell Atlantic Corp. v. Twombly



 86    see also Zaluski v. United Am. Healthcare Corp.  )G   WK
&LU 
³7KH FRPSODLQW VKRXOG JLYH WKH GHIHQGDQW IDLU QRWLFH RI ZKDW WKH SODLQWLII¶V FODLP LV DQG WKH
JURXQGV XSRQ ZKLFK LW UHVWV´ German Free State of Bavaria v. Toyobo Co, Ltd.,  ) 6XSS G
  :' 0LFK  see also Twombly,  86 DW  FLWLQJ )(' 5 &,9 3 D
$FFRUGLQJO\ WKH ³µFRPSODLQW PXVW FRQWDLQ HLWKHU GLUHFW RU LQIHUHQWLDO DOOHJDWLRQV UHVSHFWLQJ DOO WKH
PDWHULDO HOHPHQWV WR VXVWDLQ D UHFRYHU\ XQGHU VRPH YLDEOH OHJDO WKHRU\¶´ Bavaria  ) 6XSS G
DW  TXRWLQJ Lillard v. Shelby Cty. Bd. of Educ.,  ) G   WK &LU  FLWDWLRQ DQG
TXRWDWLRQV RPLWWHG )XUWKHU ³D SODLQWLII¶V REOLJDWLRQ WR SURYLGH WKH µJURXQGV¶ RI KLV µHQWLWOH>PHQW@
WR UHOLHI¶ UHTXLUHV PRUH WKDQ ODEHOV DQG FRQFOXVLRQV DQG D IRUPXODLF UHFLWDWLRQ RI WKH HOHPHQWV RI
D FDXVH RI DFWLRQ ZLOO QRW GR «´ Twombly  86 DW 
$ 5XOH F PRWLRQ PD\ EH EURXJKW ³>D@IWHU WKH SOHDGLQJV DUH FORVHG²EXW HDUO\ HQRXJK QRW
WR GHOD\ WULDO´ )(' 5 &,9 3 F 7KH VWDQGDUGV DSSOLFDEOH WR D 5XOH F PRWLRQ DUH WKH VDPH
DV WKRVH IRU 5XOH E Heinrich v. Waiting Angels Adoption Servs., Inc  )G   WK
&LU  Lindsay v. Yates  )G   WK &LU 
% 0RWLRQ IRU 6XPPDU\ -XGJPHQW
'HIHQGDQW PRYHV LQ WKH DOWHUQDWLYH IRU VXPPDU\ MXGJPHQW 6XPPDU\ MXGJPHQW LV SURSHU
³LI WKH PRYDQW VKRZV WKDW WKHUH LV QR JHQXLQH GLVSXWH DV WR DQ\ PDWHULDO IDFW DQG WKH PRYDQW LV
HQWLWOHG WR MXGJPHQW DV D PDWWHU RI ODZ´ )(' 5 &,9 3 D see also Anderson v. Liberty Lobby,
Inc.  86    7KH FRXUW PXVW FRQVLGHU WKH HYLGHQFH DQG DOO UHDVRQDEOH
LQIHUHQFHV LQ IDYRU RI WKH QRQPRYLQJ SDUW\ Burgess v. Fischer  )G   WK &LU 
U.S. S.E.C. v. Sierra Brokerage Servs., Inc.  )G   WK &LU  FLWDWLRQ RPLWWHG



7KH PRYLQJ SDUW\ KDV WKH LQLWLDO EXUGHQ RI VKRZLQJ WKH DEVHQFH RI D JHQXLQH LVVXH RI
PDWHULDO IDFW Jakubowski v. Christ Hosp., Inc.  )G   WK &LU  7KH EXUGHQ WKHQ
³VKLIWV WR WKH QRQPRYLQJ SDUW\ ZKR PXVW SUHVHQW VRPH µVSHFLILF IDFWV VKRZLQJ WKDW WKHUH LV D
JHQXLQH LVVXH IRU WULDO¶´ Id. TXRWLQJ Anderson,  86 DW 
³$ GLVSXWH LV JHQXLQH LI WKHUH LV HYLGHQFH µXSRQ ZKLFK D UHDVRQDEOH MXU\ FRXOG UHWXUQ D
YHUGLFW LQ IDYRU RI WKH QRQPRYLQJ SDUW\¶ $ IDFWXDO GLVSXWH LV PDWHULDO RQO\ LI LW FRXOG DIIHFW WKH
RXWFRPH RI WKH VXLW XQGHU WKH JRYHUQLQJ ODZ´ Smith v. Erie Cty. Sheriff’s Dep’t  ) $SS¶[ 
 WK &LU  TXRWLQJ Tysinger v. Police Dep’t of City of Zanesville  )G   WK
&LU  ³7KH XOWLPDWH TXHVWLRQ LV µZKHWKHU WKH HYLGHQFH SUHVHQWV D VXIILFLHQW GLVDJUHHPHQW WR
UHTXLUH VXEPLVVLRQ WR D MXU\ RU ZKHWKHU LW LV VR RQHVLGHG WKDW RQH SDUW\ PXVW SUHYDLO DV D PDWWHU RI
ODZ¶´ Back v. Nestlé USA, Inc.  )G   WK &LU  TXRWLQJ Anderson  86 DW

,,, $QDO\VLV
'HIHQGDQW¶V PRWLRQ DGYDQFHV IRXU DUJXPHQWV


3ODLQWLIIV¶ &RPSODLQW IDLOV WR VWDWH D FODLP XQGHU &(5&/$ RU 15(3$ &RXQWV ,±,9

EHFDXVH 3ODLQWLIIV KDYH QRW LQFXUUHG DQ\ ³QHFHVVDU\ FRVWV RI UHVSRQVH´ XQGHU &(5&/$ 
86& † D% RU 15(3$ 0,&+ &203 /$:6 † DE


3ODLQWLIIV¶ FODLPV DUH EDUUHG E\ UHV MXGLFDWD RU FROODWHUDO HVWRSSHO EHFDXVH WKHVH VDPH

LVVXHV KDYH EHHQ OLWLJDWHG DOUHDG\ DQG UHVROYHG LQ WKH %:/¶V IDYRU LQ WKH 6WDWH &RXUW
3URFHHGLQJV


3ODLQWLIIV¶ WRUW FODLPV &RXQWV 9 9, DQG ,; IDLO EHFDXVH WKH %:/ LV D JRYHUQPHQWDO

HQWLW\ HQWLWOHG WR LPPXQLW\ XQGHU 0,&+ &203 /$:6 † 





3ODLQWLIIV¶ VWDWHODZ QXLVDQFH FODLPV &RXQWV 9 DQG 9, DUH WLPHEDUUHG DQG EDUUHG

E\ UHV MXGLFDWD DQGRU FROODWHUDO HVWRSSHO
7KH &RXUW KDV FRQVLGHUHG WKH DUJXPHQWV SUHVHQWHG DQG ILQGV QR JURXQGV RQ ZKLFK WR JUDQW
GLVPLVVDO RU VXPPDU\ MXGJPHQW
$ &(5&/$ DQG 15(3$ ³1HFHVVDU\ &RVWV RI 5HVSRQVH´
'HIHQGDQW DVVHUWV WKDW 3ODLQWLIIV¶ SXUSRUWHG FODLPV XQGHU &(5&/$ DQG 15(3$ ³UHVW HQWLUHO\
RQ WKH IDXOW\ SUHPLVH´ WKDW VRPH XQVSHFLILHG SRUWLRQ RI 3ODLQWLIIV¶ DSSRUWLRQPHQW IRU WKH GUDLQ
SURMHFW FRVW FRQVWLWXWHV ³5HVSRQVH &RVW´ 'HI 0RW %U 'NW  DW 3DJH,' 'HIHQGDQW DUJXHV
WKDW EHFDXVH 3ODLQWLIIV  GLG QRW HQJDJH LQ DQ\ UHVSRQVH DFWLYLW\ RU  LQFXU DQ\ ³5HVSRQVH
&RVWV´²ERWK RI ZKLFK DUH SUHUHTXLVLWHV EHIRUH ILOLQJ D FRVW UHFRYHU\ DFWLRQ²3ODLQWLIIV¶ FODLPV
XQGHU &(5&/$ DQG 15(3$ IDLO id. DW 3DJH,'
³&(5&/$ DV DPHQGHG E\ WKH 6XSHUIXQG $PHQGPHQWV DQG 5HDXWKRUL]DWLRQ $FW RI 
³6$5$´ LV D FRPSUHKHQVLYH HQYLURQPHQWDO VWDWXWH SULQFLSDOO\ GHVLJQHG WR HIIHFWXDWH WZR JRDOV
 WKH FOHDQXS RI WR[LF ZDVWH VLWHV DQG  WKH FRPSHQVDWLRQ RI WKRVH ZKR KDYH DWWHQGHG WR WKH
UHPHGLDWLRQ RI HQYLURQPHQWDO KD]DUGV´ Franklin Cty. Convention Facilities Auth. v. Am. Premier
Underwriters, Inc.  )G   WK &LU  FLWLQJ Meghrig v. KFC Western, Inc. 
86    &(5&/$ SURYLGHV IRU UHFRYHU\ IURP OLDEOH SHUVRQV RI ³QHFHVVDU\ FRVWV RI
UHVSRQVH « FRQVLVWHQW ZLWK WKH QDWLRQDO FRQWLQJHQF\ SODQ´  86& † D%



3ODLQWLIIV QRWH WKDW 3DUW  RI WKH 15(3$ ZDV PRGHOHG DIWHU &(5&/$ 3OV 5HVS 'NW 
DW 3DJH,' ³%RWK SDUW  DQG WKH &(5&/$ FUHDWH D SULYDWH FDXVH RI DFWLRQ WR HVWDEOLVK
OLDELOLW\ IRU FRVWV RI LQYHVWLJDWLRQ DQG UHPHGLDWLRQ RI FRQWDPLQDWHG VLWHV´ Genesco, Inc. v. Mich.
Dep’t of Envtl. Quality  1:G   0LFK  7KH SDUWLHV GR QRW GLVWLQJXLVK WKHLU
DUJXPHQWV XQGHU &(5&/$ DQG 15(3$ DQG WKH &RXUW ZLOO SURFHHG DFFRUGLQJO\ ZLWK DQDO\VLV RQO\
XQGHU &(5&/$

7R HVWDEOLVK D SULPD IDFLH FDVH IRU FRVW UHFRYHU\ XQGHU &(5&/$ D SODLQWLII PXVW SURYH WKDW
³ D SROOXWLQJ VLWH LV D µIDFLOLW\¶ ZLWKLQ WKH VWDWXWH¶V GHILQLWLRQ  WKH IDFLOLW\ UHOHDVHG RU
WKUHDWHQHG WR UHOHDVH D KD]DUGRXV VXEVWDQFH  WKH UHOHDVH FDXVHG WKH SODLQWLII WR LQFXU QHFHVVDU\
FRVWV RI UHVSRQVH DQG  WKH GHIHQGDQW IDOOV ZLWKLQ RQH RI IRXU FDWHJRULHV RI SRWHQWLDOO\ UHVSRQVLEOH
SDUWLHV Village of Milford v. K-H Holding Corp.  )G   WK &LU  7KXV D
SODLQWLII PXVW SURYH ³µWKDW WKH GHIHQGDQW¶V KD]DUGRXV VXEVWDQFHV ZHUH GHSRVLWHG DW WKH VLWH IURP
ZKLFK WKHUH ZDV D UHOHDVH DQG WKDW WKH release FDXVHG WKH LQFXUUHQFH RI UHVSRQVH FRVWV¶´ Kalamazoo
River Study Grp. v. Menasha Corp.  )G   WK &LU  TXRWLQJ United States v.
Alcan Aluminum Corp  )G   G &LU  ³5HVSRQVH FRVWV DUH FRQVLGHUHG
QHFHVVDU\ ZKHQ µDQ DFWXDO DQG UHDO WKUHDW WR KXPDQ KHDOWK RU WKH HQYLURQPHQW H[LVW>V@¶ DQG DUH
FRQVLGHUHG FRQVLVWHQW ZLWK WKH >QDWLRQDO FRQWLQJHQF\ SODQ@ µLI WKH DFWLRQ ZKHQ HYDOXDWHG DV D ZKROH
LV LQ VXEVWDQWLDO FRPSOLDQFH¶ ZLWK LW´ City of Colton v. Am. Promotional Events, Inc.-W.  )G
  WK &LU  FLWDWLRQV RPLWWHG see also  86& † D% Pierson Sand &
Gravel, Inc. v. Pierson Twp.  ) 6XSS   :' 0LFK  aff’d  )G  WK &LU

'HIHQGDQW DUJXHV WKDW 3ODLQWLIIV KDYH QRW LQFXUUHG ³QHFHVVDU\ UHVSRQVH FRVWV´ WR PDLQWDLQ
DQ DFWLRQ IRU FRVW UHFRYHU\ XQGHU &(5&/$ EHFDXVH ³3ODLQWLIIV¶ VRFDOOHG UHVSRQVH FRVWV DUH QRW
5HVSRQVH &RVWV DW DOO´ 'NW  DW 3DJH,' 'HIHQGDQW DVVHUWV WKDW ³5HVSRQVH &RVWV´ LV D WHUP
RI DUW DQG WKHUH DUH VHYHUDO FDVHV DQDO\]LQJ ZKDW H[SHQVHV GR RU GR QRW TXDOLI\ DV ³5HVSRQVH &RVWV´
id. 'HIHQGDQW FRQWHQGV WKDW WKH ³GUDLQ DVVHVVPHQW FRVWV´ DUH QRW ³5HVSRQVH &RVWV´ DV WKDW WHUP
LV GHILQHG DQG WKH\ DUH WKHUHIRUH QRW UHLPEXUVDEOH &(5&/$ FRVWV 7KXV EHFDXVH WKH FODLPHG FRVWV
DUH QRW 5HVSRQVH &RVWV LQ WKH ILUVW LQVWDQFH WKH &RXUW QHHG QRW HQJDJH LQ WKH ³QHFHVVDU\´ DQDO\VLV



RU FRQVLGHU ZKHWKHU WKH FRVWV DUH ³FRQVLVWHQW ZLWK WKH QDWLRQDO FRQWLQJHQF\ SODQ´ RU ZKHWKHU
3ODLQWLII KDV HVWDEOLVKHG FDXVDWLRQ LH ZKHWKHU WKH ³UHOHDVH´ RU WKUHDWHQHG UHOHDVH RI KD]DUGRXV
VXEVWDQFHV IURP WKH 1// FDXVHG 3ODLQWLIIV WR LQFXU WKH FRVWV
$V DQ LQLWLDO PDWWHU 'HIHQGDQW FLWHV VHYHUDO FDVHV DQG WKH VWDWXWH IRU WKH SURSRVLWLRQ WKDW WR
VHHN UHLPEXUVHPHQW XQGHU &(5&/$ D SDUW\ PXVW ³ILUVW KDYH HQJDJHG LQ VRPH UHVSRQVH DFWLYLW\´
'NW  DW 3DJH,' Q +RZHYHU WKH &RXUW ILQGV WKH FLWHG DXWKRULW\ LQDSSRVLWH ,Q WKH
&RXUW¶V YLHZ WKH SHUWLQHQW TXHVWLRQ KHUH LV QRW ZKHWKHU 3ODLQWLII LV VHHNLQJ FRVWV LQFXUUHG DV
RSSRVHG WR IXWXUH FRVWV id. See, e.g. Krygoski Const. Co. v. City of Menominee 1R FY
 :/  DW
 :' 0LFK -XO\   ³6HFWLRQ  GRHV QRW FRQWHPSODWH UHFRYHU\
IRU IXWXUH FRVWV LW SURYLGHV UHFRYHU\ IRU FRVWV DOUHDG\ H[SHQGHG´ Jones v. Inmont Corp.  )
6XSS   6' 2KLR  ³VRPH FRVWV PXVW EH LQFXUUHG SULRU WR WKH ILOLQJ RI D VXLW´ 
86& † J DXWKRUL]LQJ D VXLW IRU UHFRYHU\ RI FRVWV SXUVXDQW WR †  ³DW DQ\ WLPH DIWHU
VXFK FRVWV KDYH EHHQ LQFXUUHG´ +HUH WKH VHSDUDWH 3ODLQWLIIV KDYH OLDELOLW\ IRU WKH GUDLQ DVVHVVPHQW
FRVWV SXUVXDQW WR WKH 'UDLQ &RPPLVVLRQHU¶V DSSRUWLRQPHQW ZKLFK KDV UHFHLYHG D ILQDO DGMXGLFDWLRQ
LQ WKH 0LFKLJDQ FRXUWV DQG ZDV XSKHOG 7KXV 'HIHQGDQW¶V UHOLDQFH RQ FDVHV UHMHFWLQJ FODLPV IRU
IXWXUH FRVWV LV PLVSODFHG ,Q DQ\ HYHQW SXUVXDQW WR WKH 1RWLFH ILOHG E\ 3ODLQWLIIV 'NW  3ODLQWLIIV
KDYH EHJXQ SD\LQJ WKH DVVHVVHG FRVWV DQG WKH LVVXH ZKHWKHU FRVWV KDYH EHHQ WHFKQLFDOO\ LQFXUUHG
RU H[SHQGHG LV PRRW
7KH NH\ TXHVWLRQ LV ZKHWKHU WKH FRVWV RI WKH GUDLQ SURMHFW FRQVWLWXWH ³5HVSRQVH &RVWV´ IRU
SXUSRVHV RI UHFRYHU\ XQGHU &(5&/$ ³%HFDXVH &(5&/$ GRHV QRW GHILQH µQHFHVVDU\ FRVWV RI
UHVSRQVH¶ DQG GHILQHV µUHVSRQVH¶ LQ DQ LQGLUHFW DQG DPELJXRXV PDQQHU FRXUWV KDYH UHDFKHG YDU\LQJ
UHVXOWV LQ GHWHUPLQLQJ ZKHWKHU WKH FRVWV RI YDULRXV DOOHJHG UHVSRQVH DFWLRQV ZHUH FRJQL]DEOH DV



UHVSRQVH FRVWV SXUVXDQW WR † D%´ :LOOLDP % -RKQVRQ $QQRWDWLRQ What are “necessary
costs of response” within meaning of § 107(a)(4)(b) of Comprehensive Environmental Response,
Compensation, and Liability Act (CERCLA) (42 U.S.C.A. § 9607(a)(4)(b))  $/5 )HG  † >D@
 QRWLQJ WKDW FRXUWV KDYH VSOLW RYHU ZKHWKHU PHGLFDOO\ PRQLWRULQJ WKH HIIHFWV RI D UHOHDVH RI
KD]DUGRXV VXEVWDQFHV DWWRUQH\V¶ IHHV DQG RWKHU FRVWV RI OLWLJDWLQJ SULYDWH FRVW UHFRYHU\ DFWLRQV DQG
WKH FRVWV RI LQYHVWLJDWLQJ DQG DVVHVVLQJ FRQWDPLQDWLRQ VLWHV RU IDFLOLWLHV DUH UHVSRQVH FRVWV &RXUWV
KDYH UHDFKHG YDU\LQJ UHVXOWV LQ GHWHUPLQLQJ ZKHWKHU UHVSRQVH FRVWV LQFXUUHG E\ SRWHQWLDOO\
UHVSRQVLEOH SDUWLHV ZHUH QHFHVVDU\ XQGHU WKH FLUFXPVWDQFHV FRXUWV KDYH DOVR UHDFKHG YDU\LQJ UHVXOWV
DV WR WKH QHFHVVLW\ RI FRVWV DOOHJHGO\ LQFXUUHG E\ QHLJKERUV RI KD]DUGRXV ZDVWH VLWHV RU IDFLOLWLHV
Id.
1HLWKHU VLGH LQ WKLV FRQWURYHUV\ FLWHV DQ\ FDVH RU RWKHU DXWKRULW\ WKDW DGGUHVVHV FRVWV VLPLODU
WR WKRVH DW LVVXH KHUH DQG WKH &RXUW KDV IRXQG QRQH &RQVHTXHQWO\ ZKHWKHU WKH GUDLQ DVVHVVPHQW
FRVWV DW LVVXH TXDOLI\ DV ³5HVSRQVH &RVWV´ LV DQ RSHQ TXHVWLRQ &DVHV FLWHG E\ 'HIHQGDQW WKDW
FRQVLGHU UHVSRQVH FRVWV LQ RWKHU OLPLWHG IDFWXDO RU OHJDO FRQWH[WV GLVVLPLODU WR WKRVH SUHVHQWHG KHUH
DUH XQKHOSIXO ,QVWHDG WKH &RXUW PXVW UHO\ RQ WKH JHQHUDO OHJDO IUDPHZRUN DSSOLHG WR &(5&/$ FRVW
UHFRYHU\ DFWLRQV DV 3ODLQWLIIV DSSURSULDWHO\ REVHUYH 3OV 5HVS 'NW  DW 3DJH,'
,Q Ford Motor Co. v. Michigan Consolidated Gas Co. 1R ±&9±±'7  :/
 DW
± (' 0LFK $XJ   WKH FRXUW VHW IRUWK WKH IUDPHZRUN IRU GHFLGLQJ WKH
LVVXH RI QHFHVVDU\ 5HVSRQVH &RVWV
8QGHU &(5&/$ ³UHVSRQVH´ LV GHILQHG DV ³UHPRYH UHPRYDO UHPHG\ DQG
UHPHGLDO DFWLRQ´ LQFOXGLQJ ³HQIRUFHPHQW DFWLYLWLHV UHODWHG WKHUHWR´  86&
†  7KXV WKH GHILQLWLRQ RI ³UHVSRQVH´ UHOLHV RQ WKH GHILQLWLRQV RI ³UHPRYH´
RU ³UHPRYDO´ DQG ³UHPHG\´ RU ³UHPHGLDO DFWLRQ´
&(5&/$ GHILQHV WKH WHUPV ³UHPRYH´ RU ³UHPRYDO´ DV


³WKH FOHDQXS RU UHPRYDO RI UHOHDVHG KD]DUGRXV VXEVWDQFHV IURP WKH HQYLURQPHQW
VXFK DFWLRQV DV PD\ EH QHFHVVDU\ WDNHQ LQ WKH HYHQW RI WKH WKUHDW RI UHOHDVH RI
KD]DUGRXV VXEVWDQFHV LQWR WKH HQYLURQPHQW VXFK DFWLRQV DV PD\ EH QHFHVVDU\ WR
PRQLWRU DVVHVV DQG HYDOXDWH WKH UHOHDVH RU WKUHDW RI UHOHDVH RI KD]DUGRXV VXEVWDQFHV
WKH GLVSRVDO RI UHPRYHG PDWHULDO RU WKH WDNLQJ RI VXFK RWKHU DFWLRQV DV PD\ EH
QHFHVVDU\ WR SUHYHQW PLQLPL]H RU PLWLJDWH GDPDJH WR WKH SXEOLF KHDOWK RU ZHOIDUH
RU WR WKH HQYLURQPHQW ZKLFK PD\ RWKHUZLVH UHVXOW IURP D UHOHDVH RU WKUHDW RI UHOHDVH
´
 86& †  >HPSKDVLV RPLWWHG@ ³>5@HPHG\´ RU ³UHPHGLDO DFWLRQ´ PHDQV
³WKRVH actions consistent with permanent remedy taken instead of or in addition to
removal actions in the event of a release or threatened release of a hazardous
substance into the environment, to prevent or minimize the release of hazardous
substances so that they do not migrate to cause substantial danger to present or
future public health or welfare or the environment 7KH WHUP LQFOXGHV EXW LV QRW
OLPLWHG WR VXFK DFWLRQV DW WKH ORFDWLRQ RI WKH UHOHDVH DV VWRUDJH FRQILQHPHQW
SHULPHWHU SURWHFWLRQ XVLQJ GLNHV WUHQFKHV RU GLWFKHV FOD\ FRYHU QHXWUDOL]DWLRQ
FOHDQXS RI UHOHDVHG KD]DUGRXV VXEVWDQFHV DQG DVVRFLDWHG FRQWDPLQDWHG PDWHULDOV
UHF\FOLQJ RU UHXVH GLYHUVLRQ GHVWUXFWLRQ VHJUHJDWLRQ RI UHDFWLYH ZDVWHV GUHGJLQJ
RU H[FDYDWLRQV UHSDLU RU UHSODFHPHQW RI OHDNLQJ FRQWDLQHUV FROOHFWLRQ RI OHDFKDWH
DQG UXQRII RQVLWH WUHDWPHQW RU LQFLQHUDWLRQ SURYLVLRQ RI DOWHUQDWLYH ZDWHU VXSSOLHV
DQG DQ\ PRQLWRULQJ UHDVRQDEO\ UHTXLUHG WR DVVXUH WKDW VXFK DFWLRQV SURWHFW WKH SXEOLF
KHDOWK DQG ZHOIDUH DQG WKH HQYLURQPHQW «´
 86& †  >HPSKDVLV DGGHG@ 3XUVXDQW WR WKHVH GHILQLWLRQV LQ RUGHU WR
VXVWDLQ D FODLP IRU FRVW UHFRYHU\ XQGHU &(5&/$ >D SODLQWLII@ PXVW KDYH LQFXUUHG
³QHFHVVDU\ FRVWV RI UHVSRQVH´ LQFOXGLQJ FRVWV RI UHPRYDO RU UHPHGLDO DFWLRQ
'HIHQGDQW VWDWHV WKDW 3ODLQWLIIV¶ &RPSODLQW LQFOXGHV RQO\ D VLQJOH FRQFOXVRU\ DOOHJDWLRQ WKDW
3ODLQWLIIV¶ 'UDLQ $VVHVVPHQW &RVWV FRQVWLWXWH ³5HFRYHU\ &RVWV´ XQGHU &(5&/$ DQGRU 15(3$
ZKLFK LV LQVXIILFLHQW WR ZLWKVWDQG GLVPLVVDO XQGHU WKH VWDQGDUGV RI Twombly DQG Iqbal 'NW  DW
3DJH,' 3ODLQWLIIV DVVHUW KRZHYHU WKDW WKH GUDLQ LV EHLQJ EXLOW EHFDXVH RI WKH UHOHDVH DQG
WKUHDWHQHG UHOHDVHV DQG WKH\ FLWH WR QXPHURXV SDUDJUDSKV LQ WKHLU &RPSODLQW VR DOOHJLQJ



'HIHQGDQW GRHV QRW FLWH WKH VSHFLILF DOOHJDWLRQ UHIHUHQFHG


 )O\ DVK DQG RWKHU FRDO FRPEXVWLRQ UHVLGXHV DUH NQRZQ WR SROOXWH ZDWHU )O\ DVK
DQG RWKHU FRDO FRPEXVWLRQ UHVLGXHV FRQWDLQ DUVHQLF VHOHQLXP FDGPLXP OHDG DQG
PHUFXU\ DOO RI ZKLFK SRVH SXEOLF KHDOWK ULVNV WR KXPDQV DQG ZLOGOLIH

 $IWHU WKH VOXUU\ ZDOO ZDV LQVWDOOHG WKH *URHVEHFN 3DUN 'UDLQDJH 'LVWULFW EHJDQ
WR IORRG EHFDXVH WKHUH ZDV QR RXWOHW IRU WKH ZDWHU WKDW QDWXUDOO\ IORZHG WRZDUG WKH
1//
 %HFDXVH WKH UHOHDVHV DQG WKUHDWV RI UHOHDVHV FDXVHG WKH  3ODQ WR EH
XQZRUNDEOH WKH GUDLQ SURMHFW ZDV RQFH DJDLQ VLJQLILFDQWO\ UHGHVLJQHG
 %HFDXVH RI WKH UHOHDVHV WKUHDWHQHG UHOHDVHV DQG FRQVWUXFWLRQ RI WKH VOXUU\ ZDOO
WKH WKUHH DQG D KDOI DFUHV RI VWRUPZDWHU GHWHQWLRQ DQG ZHWODQG PLWLJDWLRQ WKDW ZRXOG
KDYH EHHQ RQ WKH /%:/ SURSHUW\ KDG WR EH UHORFDWHG 7KH VOXUU\ ZDOO LQ HIIHFW
PHDQW WKDW VWRUPZDWHU FRXOG QRW EH VWRUHG DW WKH 6LWH DV SUHYLRXVO\ SODQQHG DQG DV
ZRXOG QDWXUDOO\ RFFXU
 7KH UHORFDWHG GHWHQWLRQ DUHD FDQQRW VHUYH LWV SXUSRVH RI SUHYHQWLQJ IORRGLQJ
XQOHVV WKH ZDWHU GLUHFWHG WKHUH LV GUDLQHG WR WKH *UDQG 5LYHU 7KXV WKH DPHQGHG
GUDLQ SODQ WKH ³ 3ODQ´ FDOOV IRU D  SLSH WR FDUU\ WKH ZDWHU WKURXJK D
GHWHQWLRQ DUHD DQG WKHQ WR WKH 5LYHU

 8QGHU WKH  3ODQ QXPHURXV SLSHV ZLOO EH ODLG WR GLUHFW WKH ZDWHU WR D
GHWHQWLRQ DUHD EHIRUH WUDYHUVLQJ WKURXJK WKH  SLSH LQWR WKH *UDQG 5LYHU

 7KH LQFUHDVH LQ FRVWV IURP WKH  'UDLQ ZDV FDXVHG SULPDULO\ E\ WKH UHOHDVHV
DQG WKUHDW RI UHOHDVHV RI FRQWDPLQDQWV DW WKH 6LWH DQG E\ WKH UHVXOWDQW FRQVWUXFWLRQ
RI WKH VOXUU\ ZDOO
 7KH 'UDLQ &RPPLVVLRQHU¶V DOORFDWLRQ RI DVVHVVHG FRVWV IRU WKH DPHQGHG GUDLQ
SURMHFW QHFHVVLWDWHG E\ /%:/¶V UHOHDVHV DQG WKUHDW RI UHOHDVHV ZLOO UHVXOW LQ /%:/
SD\LQJ RQO\  RI WKH FRVW RI WKLV UHPHGLDO PHDVXUH ZLWK 3ODLQWLIIV EHDULQJ QHDUO\
DOO RI WKH EDODQFH RI WKHVH 5HVSRQVH &RVWV



 /%:/¶V UHOHDVHV DQG WKUHDWHQHG UHOHDVHV RI KD]DUGRXV VXEVWDQFHV KDYH DQG ZLOO
FDXVH 3ODLQWLIIV WR LQFXU UHVSRQVH FRVWV VSHFLILFDOO\ 'UDLQ $VVHVVPHQW &RVWV IRU
ZKLFK /%:/ LV OLDEOH SXUVXDQW WR &(5&/$ †   86& † 
&RPSO 'NW 
3ODLQWLIIV¶ FRQWHQWLRQ EDVHG RQ WKHVH DOOHJDWLRQV LV WKDW WKH GUDLQ LV QHFHVVDU\ DV SDUW RI WKH
UHPHGLDWLRQ WR SUHYHQW WKH WKUHDWHQHG IXWXUH UHOHDVH WKDW ZLOO RFFXU LI WKH GUDLQ LV QRW EXLOW DQG ZDWHU
LV QRW GLYHUWHG DZD\ IURP WKH 1// DQG WKDW WKH GUDLQ LV DQ HVVHQWLDO FRPSRQHQW RI 'HIHQGDQW¶V
UHPHGLDWLRQ SODQ DW WKH 6LWH :LWKRXW WKH GUDLQ 'HIHQGDQW¶V FXUUHQW UHPHGLDWLRQ SODQV DW WKH 6LWH
ZLOO IDLO 3ODLQWLIIV QRWH WKDW 'HIHQGDQW PD\ GLVDJUHH ZLWK WKDW DVVHUWLRQ EXW WKDW GLVDJUHHPHQW LV
QRW RQH WKDW FDQ EH UHVROYHG WKURXJK D PRWLRQ WR GLVPLVV ,QVWHDG OD\ ZLWQHVV DQG H[SHUW GLVFRYHU\
ZLOO EH QHFHVVDU\ WR UHVROYH WKLV GLVSXWH ³7KH TXHVWLRQ RI µ>Z@KHWKHU VSHFLILF UHVSRQVH FRVWV ZHUH
µQHFHVVDU\¶ XVXDOO\ UHTXLUHV D IDFWXDO GHWHUPLQDWLRQ DQG FDQQRW EH VHWWOHG RQ D PRWLRQ WR GLVPLVV¶´
'NW  DW 3DJH,' TXRWLQJ  $/5 )HG  † >D@
&RQWUDU\ WR 'HIHQGDQW¶V DUJXPHQWV 3ODLQWLIIV KDYH VXIILFLHQWO\ DOOHJHG WKDW WKH\ KDYH
LQFXUUHG ³5HVSRQVH &RVWV´ DV WKDW WHUP LV GHILQHG LQ &(5&/$ DV SDUW RI WKH UHPHGLDWLRQ RI WKH VLWH
ZKHUH WKH UHOHDVH RFFXUUHG 8SRQ FORVH UHYLHZ WKH &RXUW ILQGV WKDW 'HIHQGDQW¶V DUJXPHQWV UHO\ RQ
VHOHFWLYH H[FHUSWV IURP FDVH DQDO\VHV ZKLFK DUH UHPRYHG IURP WKHLU DQDO\WLFDO FRQWH[W DQG
FRQVHTXHQWO\ DUH RI OLWWOH VXEVWDQWLYH YDOXH LQ HYDOXDWLQJ ZKHWKHU WKH FRVWV VRXJKW E\ 3ODLQWLIIV DUH
QHFHVVDU\ UHVSRQVH FRVWV
)RU LQVWDQFH 'HIHQGDQW FLWHV Ellis v. Gallatin Steel Co.  )G   WK &LU 
IRU WKH SULQFLSOH WKDW ³µRQO\ ZRUN WKDW LV FORVHO\ WLHG WR WKH DFWXDO FOHDQXS « PD\ FRQVWLWXWH D
QHFHVVDU\ FRVW RI UHVSRQVH¶´ 'NW  DW 3DJH,' Q  'HIHQGDQW WKHQ DUJXHV WKDW ³3ODLQWLIIV
GR QRW DOOHJH QRU FDQ WKH\ WKDW WKH\ VSHQW DQ\ PRQH\ FOHDQLQJ XS WKH 1// 7KLV DORQH LV IDWDO WR



3ODLQWLIIV¶ &(5&/$ DQG 15(3$ FODLPV EHFDXVH µRQO\ ZRUN WKDW LV FORVHO\ WLHG WR WKH DFWXDO FOHDQXS
   PD\ FRQVWLWXWH D QHFHVVDU\ FRVW RI UHVSRQVH¶ Ellis  )G DW    ´ 'NW  DW 3DJH,'
'HIHQGDQW¶V TXRWH IURP Ellis SHUWDLQHG WR D FODLP IRU FRPSHQVDWLRQ WR WKH SODLQWLIIV 5LFKDUG
DQG 7KRPDV (OOLV IRU WKH WLPH WKH\ VSHQW REVHUYLQJ DQG YLGHRWDSLQJ WKH RSHUDWLRQV RI WKH ³SROOXWLQJ
FRPSDQLHV´ IURP -DQXDU\  WKURXJK 'HFHPEHU   )G DW  7KH GLVWULFW FRXUW
UHMHFWHG WKH FODLP QRWLQJ WKDW ³WR UHFRYHU DQ\ FRVWV WKH µFLWL]HQV PXVW SURYH¶ WKDW WKH FRVWV ZHUH QRW
µSULPDULO\ IRU OLWLJDWLRQ¶ ZKLFK >WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW@ FRQFOXGHG >WKH SODLQWLIIV@ KDG IDLOHG WR GR´ Id.
DW  FLWDWLRQV RPLWWHG
7KH 6L[WK &LUFXLW DJUHHG WKDW DQ\ FRVWV ³LQFXUUHG´ E\ WKH (OOLVHV ZHUH QRW ³QHFHVVDU\
UHVSRQVH FRVWV´ H[SODLQLQJ
&(5&/$ SURYLGHV IRU UHFRYHU\ IURP OLDEOH SHUVRQV RI DQ\ ³QHFHVVDU\ FRVWV RI
UHVSRQVH LQFXUUHG E\ DQ\ RWKHU SHUVRQ FRQVLVWHQW ZLWK WKH QDWLRQDO FRQWLQJHQF\
SODQ´  86& † D% *HQHUDOO\ VSHDNLQJ OHJDO IHHV DQG
OLWLJDWLRQUHODWHG FRVWV ³DUH QRW UHFRYHUDEOH´ RQO\ ³ZRUN WKDW LV FORVHO\ WLHG WR WKH
DFWXDO FOHDQXS  PD\ FRQVWLWXWH D QHFHVVDU\ FRVW RI UHVSRQVH´ Franklin County
Convention Facilities Auth. v. Am. Premier Underwriters, Inc.  )G  
WK &LU  « (YHQ LI WKH PRQLWRULQJ WLPH VSHQW E\ WKH (OOLVHV FRQVWLWXWHV
SURSHU FRVWV LQFXUUHG XQGHU WKH VWDWXWH ZKLFK *DOODWLQ DQG +DUVFR GLVSXWH WKHVH
FRVWV ZHUH QRW FORVHO\ WLHG WR DQ DFWXDO FOHDQXS EXW LQ WKH HQG ZHUH XQUHODWHG WR DQ\
FOHDQXS DW DOO
Id. DW  $ IXUWKHU ORRN DW Franklin County Convention Facilities Authority  )G  WKH
FDVH UHOLHG RQ IRU WKH TXRWHG UXOH ³RQO\ µZRUN WKDW LV FORVHO\ WLHG WR WKH DFWXDO FOHDQXS  PD\
FRQVWLWXWH D QHFHVVDU\ FRVW RI UHVSRQVH¶´ GLVFORVHV WKDW WKH VWDWHPHQW UHODWHG WR DQ DZDUG RI DWWRUQH\
IHHV ZKLFK WKH FRXUW XOWLPDWHO\ IRXQG ZHUH D QHFHVVDU\ FRVW RI UHVSRQVH 7KH FRXUW¶V DQDO\VLV LV
LQVWUXFWLYH



*DOODWLQ 6WHHO &RPSDQ\ D VWHHO PDQXIDFWXUHU DQG +DUVFR &RUSRUDWLRQ D SURFHVVRU RI VODJ
D VWHHO E\SURGXFW Ellis  )G DW 


$38 DUJXHV WKDW WKH  DZDUG IRU DWWRUQH\ IHHV LQFXUUHG E\ 6WHYHQ
*HQWU\ &)$¶V LQGHSHQGHQW DWWRUQH\ ZDV QRW D ³QHFHVVDU\´ UHVSRQVH FRVW $V VWDWHG
DERYH &(5&/$ SHUPLWV UHFRYHU\ RI ³DQ\  QHFHVVDU\ FRVWV RI UHVSRQVH LQFXUUHG
 FRQVLVWHQW ZLWK WKH QDWLRQDO FRQWLQJHQF\ SODQ´  86& † D%
/LWLJDWLRQUHODWHG IHHV DUH QRW UHFRYHUDEOH EXW OHJDO ZRUN WKDW LV FORVHO\ WLHG WR WKH
DFWXDO FOHDQXS´ ZRUN WKDW EHQHILWV WKH HQWLUH FOHDQXS DQG VHUYHV D VWDWXWRU\ SXUSRVH
RWKHU WKDQ FRVW UHDOORFDWLRQ´ PD\ FRQVWLWXWH D QHFHVVDU\ FRVW RI UHVSRQVH See Key
Tronic Corp. v. United States  86    6 &W   / (G G
  )RU H[DPSOH ZRUN SHUIRUPHG LQ LGHQWLI\LQJ SRWHQWLDOO\ UHVSRQVLEOH
SDUWLHV LV UHFRYHUDEOH See id.
$38 FRQWHQGV WKDW WKH SRUWLRQ RI WKH DWWRUQH\ IHHV DZDUGHG WR &)$ IRU ZRUN
SHUIRUPHG LQ SUHSDULQJ ZDVWH PDQLIHVWV LV QRW D QHFHVVDU\ UHVSRQVH FRVW 0RUHRYHU
$38 DVVHUWV WKDW &)$ VKRXOG QRW KDYH EHHQ DZDUGHG IHHV IRU ZRUN SHUIRUPHG LQ
LGHQWLI\LQJ SRWHQWLDOO\ UHVSRQVLEOH SDUWLHV EHFDXVH *HQWU\ GLG QRW LGHQWLI\ $38 DV
D SRWHQWLDOO\ UHVSRQVLEOH SDUW\ 7KH GLVWULFW FRXUW FRQFOXGHG WKDW *HQWU\¶V IHHV ZHUH
QRW OLWLJDWLRQUHODWHG EXW ZHUH FORVHO\ WLHG WR WKH DFWXDO FOHDQXS DQG WKHUHIRUH
UHFRYHUDEOH E\ &)$ :H DJUHH *HQWU\¶V ZRUN ZLWK WKH ZDVWH PDQLIHVWV DQG
LGHQWLI\LQJ SRWHQWLDOO\ UHVSRQVLEOH SDUWLHV ZDV D QHFHVVDU\ FRVW RI UHVSRQVH EHFDXVH
LW DURVH GXULQJ WKH FOHDQXS SURFHVV KDG QRWKLQJ WR GR ZLWK DQ\ OLWLJDWLRQ and
benefitted the cleanup as a whole by increasing the probability that the cleanup
would be effective 0RUHRYHU Key Tronic Corp. H[SUHVVO\ DSSURYHV RI DWWRUQH\ IHHV
LQ FRQQHFWLRQ ZLWK LGHQWLI\LQJ SRWHQWLDOO\ UHVSRQVLEOH SDUWLHV DQG ZH DUH
XQSHUVXDGHG E\ $38¶V DVVHUWLRQ WKDW DQ DWWRUQH\ VHHNLQJ WR LGHQWLI\ VXFK SDUWLHV
PXVW DFWXDOO\ LGHQWLI\ WKRVH ZKR ZLOO XOWLPDWHO\ EH UHVSRQVLEOH IRU SD\PHQW 5DWKHU
DV LQGLFDWHG LQ Key Tronic Corp. it is enough that CFA’s actions increased the
probability of an effective cleanup  86 DW   6 &W  7KXV ZH
DIILUP WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW RQ WKLV LVVXH
Franklin Cty. Convention Facilities Auth.  )G DW  HPSKDVLV DGGHG $V LQ Franklin
County 3ODLQWLIIV LQ HVVHQFH FRQWHQG WKDW WKH GUDLQ SURMHFW LV QHFHVVDU\ WR UHQGHU 'HIHQGDQW¶V
UHPHGLDWLRQ effective
,Q WKLV FDVH 3ODLQWLIIV KDYH VXIILFLHQWO\ DOOHJHG WKDW WKH GUDLQ LV QHFHVVDU\ DV SDUW RI WKH
UHPHGLDWLRQ WR SUHYHQW WKH WKUHDWHQHG IXWXUH UHOHDVH WKDW ZLOO RFFXU LI WKH GUDLQ LV QRW EXLOW DQG ZDWHU
LV QRW GLYHUWHG DZD\ IURP WKH 1// DQG WKDW WKH GUDLQ LV DQ HVVHQWLDO FRPSRQHQW RI 'HIHQGDQW¶V
UHPHGLDWLRQ SODQ DW WKH 6LWH $V 3ODLQWLIIV QRWH 'HIHQGDQW PD\ GLVDJUHH ZLWK WKDW DVVHUWLRQ EXW WKDW
GLVDJUHHPHQW LV QRW RQH WKDW FDQ EH UHVROYHG RQ D PRWLRQ WR GLVPLVV See Village of Milford 


)G DW  ZKHWKHU UHVSRQVH FRVWV ZHUH QHFHVVDU\ LV D PL[HG TXHVWLRQ RI ODZ DQG IDFW
'HIHQGDQWV DUH QRW HQWLWOHG WR WKH GLVPLVVDO RI 3ODLQWLIIV¶ &RPSODLQW RQ WKH JURXQG WKDW 3ODLQWLIIV¶
FODLPHG FRVWV ZHUH QRW ³QHFHVVDU\ FRVWV RI UHVSRQVH´
% 5HV -XGLFDWD RU &ROODWHUDO (VWRSSHO %DU
'HIHQGDQW DUJXHV WKDW 3ODLQWLIIV¶ FODLPV DUH EDUUHG E\ UHV MXGLFDWD RU FROODWHUDO HVWRSSHO
EHFDXVH WKH LVVXHV LQ WKLV FDVH KDYH EHHQ OLWLJDWHG DOUHDG\ DQG UHVROYHG LQ 'HIHQGDQW¶V IDYRU LQ WKH
6WDWH &RXUW 3URFHHGLQJV 'HIHQGDQW DVVHUWV WKDW WKLV FDVH LV PHUHO\ DQ DWWHPSW E\ 3ODLQWLIIV WR
UHSKUDVH DQG UHOLWLJDWH WKHVH LVVXHV \HW DJDLQ ZKLFK WKLV &RXUW ³VKRXOG QRW FRXQWHQDQFH´ 'NW 
DW 3DJH,'
5HV MXGLFDWD FODLP SUHFOXVLRQ LV D MXGLFLDOO\ FUHDWHG GRFWULQH WR ³µUHOLHYH SDUWLHV RI WKH FRVW
DQG YH[DWLRQ RI PXOWLSOH ODZVXLWV «¶´ Adair v. Michigan  1:G   Q 0LFK 
FLWDWLRQV DQG TXRWDWLRQV RPLWWHG ³7KH GRFWULQH RI UHV MXGLFDWD EDUV D VXFFHVVLYH DFWLRQ LQ
0LFKLJDQ LI µ WKH SULRU DFWLRQ ZDV GHFLGHG RQ WKH PHULWV  ERWK DFWLRQV LQYROYH WKH VDPH SDUWLHV
RU WKHLU SULYLHV DQG  WKH PDWWHU LQ WKH VHFRQG FDVH ZDV RU FRXOG KDYH EHHQ UHVROYHG LQ WKH ILUVW¶´
Young v. Twp. of Green Oak  )G   WK &LU  TXRWLQJ Adair  1:G DW 
0LFKLJDQ FRXUWV WDNH D EURDG YLHZ RI WKH UHV MXGLFDWD GRFWULQH ³KROGLQJ WKDW LW EDUV QRW RQO\ FODLPV
DOUHDG\ OLWLJDWHG EXW DOVR HYHU\ FODLP DULVLQJ IURP WKH VDPH WUDQVDFWLRQ WKDW WKH SDUWLHV H[HUFLVLQJ
UHDVRQDEOH GLOLJHQFH FRXOG KDYH UDLVHG EXW GLG QRW´ Adair  1:G DW  'HIHQGDQW EHDUV
WKH EXUGHQ RI SURYLQJ WKH DSSOLFDELOLW\ RI WKH GRFWULQH RI UHV MXGLFDWD See McCoy v. Michigan 
) $SS¶[   WK &LU 
7KH &RXUW LV QRW SHUVXDGHG WKDW UHV MXGLFDWD EDUV WKH LQVWDQW DFWLRQ XQGHU WKH FLUFXPVWDQFHV
SUHVHQWHG 7KH SDUWLHV LQ WKLV VXLW DUH QRW WKH VDPH DV WKRVH LQ WKH 6WDWH &RXUW 3URFHHGLQJV :KLOH



'HIHQGDQW FRUUHFWO\ QRWHV WKDW WKH SULYLW\ HOHPHQW GRHV QRW UHTXLUH WKDW WKH SDUWLHV EH LGHQWLFDO LQ WKH
WZR DFWLRQV WKHUH PXVW EH D ³VXEVWDQWLDO LGHQWLW\ RI LQWHUHVWV´ DQG D ³ZRUNLQJ IXQFWLRQDO
UHODWLRQVKLS´ VXFK WKDW WKH LQWHUHVWV RI WKH QRQSDUW\ DUH SUHVHQWHG DQG SURWHFWHG E\ WKH SDUW\ LQ WKH
HDUOLHU OLWLJDWLRQ See Adair  1:G DW  ³7R EH LQ SULYLW\ LV WR EH VR LGHQWLILHG LQ LQWHUHVW
ZLWK DQRWKHU SDUW\ WKDW WKH ILUVW OLWLJDQW UHSUHVHQWV WKH VDPH OHJDO ULJKW WKDW WKH ODWHU OLWLJDQW LV WU\LQJ
WR DVVHUW´ Id.
'HIHQGDQW DUJXHV WKDW WKH 7RZQVKLS DQG WKH ''$ VDWLVI\ WKLV WHVW EHFDXVH WKH\ DUH
HVVHQWLDOO\ RQH LQ WKH VDPH WKH 7RZQVKLS FUHDWHG WKH ''$ DQG FRPSOHWHO\ FRQWUROV LW DQG WKH\
KDYH WKH VDPH LQWHUHVWV LQ UHOLWLJDWLQJ WKH PHULWV RI WKH 6WDWH &RXUW 3URFHHGLQJV 'HIHQGDQW
HPSKDVL]HV WKDW WKH ''$¶V ([HFXWLYH 'LUHFWRU ZDV WKH 7RZQVKLS¶V FKLHI ZLWQHVV LQ WKH %RDUG RI
5HYLHZ SURFHHGLQJV +RZHYHU 3ODLQWLIIV SRLQW RXW WKDW WKH ''$ LV D VHSDUDWH ³SXEOLF ERG\
FRUSRUDWH´ ZKLFK LV QRW FRQWUROOHG E\ WKH PXQLFLSDOLW\ 0RUHRYHU WKH 7RZQVKLS WKH ''$ DQG WKH
SXWDWLYH FODVV PHPEHUV GR QRW VKDUH LQWHUHVWV LGHQWLFDO WR WKRVH OLWLJDWHG LQ WKH VWDWH SURFHHGLQJV
*LYHQ WKH GLVWLQFW QDWXUH RI WKH VWDWH DGPLQLVWUDWLYH SURFHHGLQJV DQG WKH YDU\LQJ LQWHUHVWV DQG
DSSRUWLRQPHQW RI WKH GUDLQ SURMHFW FRVWV DPRQJ WKH FODVVSODLQWLIIV WKH &RXUW FDQQRW FRQFOXGH WKDW
WKH 7RZQVKLS¶V LQWHUHVW LQ WKH HDUOLHU SURFHHGLQJV LV LGHQWLFDO WR WKH YDULRXV QXPHURXV SDUWLHV LQ WKLV
VXLW
%XW HYHQ LI WKH SULYLW\ HOHPHQW ZHUH VDWLVILHG WKH &RXUW ZRXOG ILQG WKH WKLUG UHV MXGLFDWD
HOHPHQW ODFNLQJ 7KH LVVXHV LQ WKLV ODZVXLW ZHUH QRW DQG FRXOG QRW KDYH EHHQ UDLVHG LQ WKH SULRU
SURFHHGLQJV 'HIHQGDQW HPSKDVL]HV WKDW WKH 7RZQVKLS UDLVHV WKH VDPH LVVXHV LQ ERWK DFWLRQV LH
WKDW 'HIHQGDQW DOWHUHG WKH QDWXUDO IORZ RI VWRUP ZDWHU DQG FDXVHG WKH QHHG IRU WKH 'UDLQ
LPSURYHPHQWV ERWK RI ZKLFK ZHUH UHVROYHG LQ WKH VWDWH SURFHHGLQJV +RZHYHU WKH &RXUW ILQGV WKLV



DVVHUWLRQ HYHQ LI DFFXUDWH RI OLWWOH LPSRUW LQ WKH UHV MXGLFDWD DQDO\VLV EHFDXVH WKH SULRU FRQVLGHUDWLRQ
RI WKRVH LVVXHV ZDV FRQILQHG WR WKH OLPLWHG QDWXUH RI WKH GUDLQ DSSRUWLRQPHQW SURFHHGLQJV DQG
DSSHDOV DQG WKH QDUURZ OHJDO VWDQGDUGV DSSOLFDEOH WKHUHWR
3ODLQWLIIV SRLQW RXW WKDW WKH VWDWH SURFHHGLQJV RULJLQDWHG DV DQ DGPLQLVWUDWLYH GHFLVLRQ
UHQGHUHG E\ WKH *URHVEHFN 3DUN 'UDLQ %RDUG RI 5HYLHZ DQG ZHUH OLPLWHG WR DSSRUWLRQPHQW RI WKH
FRVWV IRU WKH *URHVEHFN 3DUN 'UDLQ 7KH 'UDLQ &RPPLVVLRQHU¶V DSSRUWLRQPHQW PXVW EH EDVHG RQ
³WKH EHQHILW WR WKH SXEOLF KHDOWK FRQYHQLHQFH RU ZHOIDUH RU DV WKH PHDQV RI LPSURYLQJ DQ\ KLJKZD\
XQGHU WKH FRQWURO RI VXFK WRZQVKLS FLW\ RU YLOODJH´ 0,&+ &203 /$:6 †  3ODLQWLIIV
DVVHUW DQG 'HIHQGDQW GRHV QRW GLVSXWH WKDW WKH %RDUG RI 5HYLHZ ³PD\ RQO\ GHWHUPLQH ZKHWKHU
µWKHUH LV D PDQLIHVW HUURU RU LQHTXDOLW\ LQ WKH DSSRUWLRQPHQWV¶ DQG µRUGHU DQG PDNH WKH FKDQJHV LQ
WKH DSSRUWLRQPHQW DV WKH\ PD\ FRQVLGHU MXVW DQG HTXLWDEOH¶´ 'NW  DW 3DJH,' 3ODLQWLIIV VWDWH
WKDW LQ IDFW WKH VWDWH FRXUWV UHEXIIHG WKH 7RZQVKLS¶V DWWHPSW WR LQWURGXFH HYLGHQFH UHODWLQJ WR WKH
UHOHDVH DQG HYLGHQFH WKDW WKH GUDLQ ZDV EHLQJ FRQVWUXFWHG WR UHPHGLDWH WKH UHOHDVH HVVHQWLDOO\ DV
³LPPDWHULDO FRQVLGHUDWLRQV´ LQ WKH QDUURZ FRQWH[W RI WKH GUDLQ DSSRUWLRQPHQW DSSHDOV )XUWKHU WKH
VWDWH FRXUW DSSHDOV ZHUH OLPLWHG WR FRQVLGHULQJ ZKHWKHU WKH %RDUG RI 5HYLHZ DSSRUWLRQPHQW GHFLVLRQ
ZDV FRQVWLWXWLRQDO DQG VXSSRUWHG E\ VXEVWDQWLDO HYLGHQFH
*LYHQ WKHVH FLUFXPVWDQFHV WKH &RXUW FDQQRW FRQFOXGH WKDW WKH GLVWLQFW FODLPV 3ODLQWLIIV QRZ
UDLVH ZHUH RU FRXOG KDYH EHHQ UDLVHG DQG UHVROYHG LQ WKH VWDWH SURFHHGLQJV $FFRUGLQJO\ WKH
GRFWULQH RI UHV MXGLFDWD GRHV QRW DSSO\
'HIHQGDQW¶V UHODWHG FROODWHUDO HVWRSSHO DUJXPHQW IDLOV IRU WKH VDPH UHDVRQV ³&ROODWHUDO
HVWRSSHO RU LVVXH SUHFOXVLRQ SUHFOXGHV UHOLWLJDWLRQ RI DQ LVVXH LQ D VXEVHTXHQW GLIIHUHQW FDXVH RI
DFWLRQ EHWZHHQ WKH VDPH SDUWLHV RU WKHLU SULYLHV ZKHQ WKH SULRU SURFHHGLQJ FXOPLQDWHG LQ D YDOLG ILQDO



MXGJPHQW DQG WKH LVVXH ZDV DFWXDOO\ DQG QHFHVVDULO\ GHWHUPLQHG LQ WKH SULRU SURFHHGLQJ´ Ditmore
v. Michalik  1:G   0LFK &W $SS  &RQWUDU\ WR 'HIHQGDQW¶V DUJXPHQWV WKLV
ODZVXLW LV QRW VLPSO\ D UHOLWLJDWLRQ RI WKH DERYH WZR HVVHQWLDO TXHVWLRQV RI IDFW  'HIHQGDQW GLG
QRW LQWHUIHUH ZLWK WKH QDWXUDO IORZ RI VWRUP ZDWHU DQG  'HIHQGDQW LV QRW FRQWUDFWXDOO\ ERXQG WR
DFFHSW VWRUP ZDWHU IURP DGMRLQLQJ SURSHUWLHV 7KH QDWXUH RI WKH SURFHHGLQJV LV VXEVWDQWLYHO\
GLIIHUHQW DQG WKH FRQVLGHUDWLRQ RI WKH HYLGHQFH DV ZHOO DV WKH LVVXHV DQG RXWFRPH KLQJH RQ GLIIHUHQW
OHJDO VWDQGDUGV
& 7RUW &ODLPV &RXQWV 9 9, DQG ,;
'HIHQGDQW EULHIO\ DUJXHV WKDW 3ODLQWLIIV¶ WRUW FODLPV &RXQWV 9 9, DQG ,; IDLO EHFDXVH
'HIHQGDQW LV D JRYHUQPHQWDO HQWLW\ HQWLWOHG WR LPPXQLW\ XQGHU 0,&+ &203 /$:6 † 
See, e.g., Siddock v. Grand Trunk Western R.R. Inc.  ) 6XSS G   :' 0LFK 
'HIHQGDQW DVVHUWV WKDW ZKLOH &RXQWV 9 DQG 9, RVWHQVLEO\ VHHN DEDWHPHQW RQO\ WKH 0LFKLJDQ &RXUW
RI $SSHDOV KDV KHOG WKDW WKH JRYHUQPHQWDO LPPXQLW\ VWDWXWH PXVW EH EURDGO\ FRQVWUXHG DQG WKXV
LW GRHV QRW LQFOXGH D ORRSKROH IRU FDVHV VHHNLQJ HTXLWDEOH UHOLHI RQO\ FLWLQJ Jackson C. Drain
Comm’r v. Village of Stockbridge  1:G   0LFK &W $SS  +RZHYHU DV
3ODLQWLIIV SRLQW RXW DQG 'HIHQGDQW QRWHV 'NW  DW 3DJH,' Q WKH 0LFKLJDQ FRXUWV KDYH
VLQFH REVHUYHG WKDW WKH KROGLQJ LQ Jackson ZDV LPSOLFLWO\ RYHUUXOHG LQ Lash v. Traverse City 
1:G  0LFK  See Gaskin v. City of Jackson 1R   :/  DW

0LFK &W $SS  ³>*@RYHUQPHQWDO LPPXQLW\ GRHV QRW DSSO\ WR FODLPV WKDW UHTXHVW GHFODUDWRU\



'HIHQGDQW¶V DGGLWLRQDO DUJXPHQW WKDW WKH VWDWH WRUW FODLPV DUH EDUUHG E\ UHV MXGLFDWD RU
FROODWHUDO HVWRSSHO IDLOV IRU WKH UHDVRQV VWDWHG DERYH ZLWK UHVSHFW WR WKH IHGHUDO FODLPV


RU LQMXQFWLYH UHOLHI´ Id. $FFRUGLQJO\ 'HIHQGDQW LV QRW HQWLWOHG WR GLVPLVVDO RI WKH WRUW FODLPV RQ
JURXQGV RI JRYHUQPHQWDO LPPXQLW\
' 1XLVDQFH &ODLPV
)LQDOO\ 'HIHQGDQW DUJXHV WKDW 3ODLQWLIIV¶ VWDWHODZ QXLVDQFH FODLPV &RXQWV 9 DQG 9, DUH
WLPHEDUUHG 'HIHQGDQW VWDWHV WKDW WKH VWDWXWH RI OLPLWDWLRQV IRU QXLVDQFH FODLPV LQ 0LFKLJDQ LV WKUHH
\HDUV 0,&+ &203 /$:6 †  See Marilyn Froling Revocable Living Trust v.
Bloomfield Hills Country Club  1:G   0LFK &W $SS  'HIHQGDQW DUJXHV WKDW
DFFRUGLQJ WR 3ODLQWLIIV¶ RZQ DOOHJDWLRQV WKH FRQVWUXFWLRQ RI WKH VOXUU\ ZDOO FDXVHG WKH LQWHUIHUHQFH
ZLWK WKH QDWXUDO GUDLQDJH RI ZDWHU 7KXV EHFDXVH WKH FRQVWUXFWLRQ RI WKH VOXUU\ ZDOO ZDV ³FRPSOHWHG
LQ ´ &RPSO DW ˆ  DQG WKLV DFWLRQ ZDV QRW ILOHG XQWLO 0D\   LW LV WLPHEDUUHG
3ODLQWLIIV UHVSRQG WKDW ZKLOH D WKUHH\HDU OLPLWDWLRQV SHULRG DSSOLHV WR SULYDWH QXLVDQFH FODLPV
DQG WKH FRQVWUXFWLRQ RI WKH VOXUU\ ZDOO RFFXUUHG PRUH WKDQ WKUHH \HDUV SULRU WR WKH ILOLQJ RI WKH
&RPSODLQW WKH FRVWV WR FRQVWUXFW WKH GUDLQ DV D UHVXOW RI 'HIHQGDQW¶V UHOHDVH DW WKH 6LWH DOVR LQWHUIHUH
ZLWK 3ODLQWLIIV¶ SURSHUW\ ULJKWV SULYLOHJHV DQG XVH DQG HQMR\PHQW RI WKHLU SURSHUWLHV 7KXV EHFDXVH
WKH GUDLQ DVVHVVPHQW ZDV LQFXUUHG DIWHU DOO VWDWH FRXUW UHPHGLHV ZHUH H[KDXVWHG RQO\ UHFHQWO\
3ODLQWLII¶V SULYDWH QXLVDQFH FODLP LV QRW EDUUHG E\ WKH VWDWXWH RI OLPLWDWLRQV
%HFDXVH 3ODLQWLIIV¶ &RPSODLQW DOOHJHV D WRUW EDVHG RQ WKH RFFXUUHQFH RI LQWHUIHUHQFH ZLWKLQ
WKUHH \HDUV RI ILOLQJ WKH &RXUW ILQGV WKDW WKH SULYDWH QXLVDQFH FODLP LV QRW VXEMHFW WR GLVPLVVDO DW WKLV
VWDJH RI WKH SURFHHGLQJV +RZHYHU VKRXOG GHYHORSPHQW RI WKH UHFRUG ZDUUDQW IXUWKHU FRQVLGHUDWLRQ
RI WKH VWDWXWH RI OLPLWDWLRQV LVVXHV 'HIHQGDQW PD\ UHTXHVW WKDW WKH &RXUW UHYLVLW WKH LVVXH XSRQ D
SURSHU VKRZLQJ WKDW IXUWKHU FRQVLGHUDWLRQ LV ZDUUDQWHG



3ODLQWLIIV DVVHUW WKDW ZLWK UHJDUG WR WKHLU SXEOLF QXLVDQFH FODLP WKH UHOHDVH DQG WKH
VXEVHTXHQW EXLOGLQJ RI WKH VOXUU\ ZDOO LQWHUIHUHG ZLWK WKH SXEOLF¶V KHDOWK VDIHW\ SHDFH FRPIRUW RU
FRQYHQLHQFH DQG FRQVWLWXWHG DQ XQUHDVRQDEOH LQWHUIHUHQFH ZLWK D FRPPRQ ULJKW HQMR\HG E\ WKH
JHQHUDO SXEOLF 3ODLQWLIIV FRQWHQG WKDW WKH VWDWXWH RI OLPLWDWLRQV IRU WKHLU SXEOLF QXLVDQFH FODLP LV VL[
\HDUV VLQFH WKH\ DUH VHHNLQJ LQMXQFWLYH UHOLHI See Dep’t of Envtl. Quality v. Waterous Co. 
1:G   0LFK &W $SS  REVHUYLQJ WKDW EHFDXVH WKH QXLVDQFH FODLP VRXJKW
LQMXQFWLYH UHOLHI WKH SHULRG RI OLPLWDWLRQV ZDV VL[ \HDUV see 0,&+ &203 /$:6 † 
3ODLQWLIIV¶ SXEOLF QXLVDQFH FODLP VHHNV ³HQWU\ RI D -XGJPHQW RUGHULQJ /%:/ WR UHVWRUH WKH 6LWH WR
LWV SUHYLRXV VWDWH VR WKDW WKH 6LWH FDQ UHFHLYH VXUIDFH ZDWHU UXQRQ DQG VR WKDW QDWXUDO GUDLQDJH FDQ
RFFXU´ &RPSO 'NW  DW 3DJH,'
$OWKRXJK 'HIHQGDQW DSSHDUV WR GLVSXWH LQ D IRRWQRWH WKDW 3ODLQWLIIV¶ SXEOLF QXLVDQFH FODLP
LV VXEMHFW WR D VL[\HDU OLPLWDWLRQ SHULRG 'HIHQGDQW IDLOV WR SURYLGH DQ\ VXSSRUWLQJ DUJXPHQW DQG
SDUWLFXODUO\ IDLOV WR DGGUHVV WKDW 3ODLQWLIIV VHHN LQMXQFWLYH UHOLHI see 5HSO\ 'NW DW 3DJH,' Q
 $FFRUGLQJO\ 'HIHQGDQW LV QRW HQWLWOHG WR GLVPLVVDO RI WKLV FODLP +RZHYHU DV GLVFXVVHG DERYH
ZLWK UHVSHFW WR WKH SULYDWH QXLVDQFH FODLP VKRXOG GHYHORSPHQW RI WKH UHFRUG VXEVHTXHQWO\ HVWDEOLVK
WKDW WKLV FODLP PD\ EH WLPHEDUUHG 'HIHQGDQW PD\ UHTXHVW WKDW WKH &RXUW UHYLVLW WKLV LVVXH XSRQ D
SURSHU VKRZLQJ WKDW IXUWKHU FRQVLGHUDWLRQ LV ZDUUDQWHG
,9 &RQFOXVLRQ
2Q WKH UHFRUG SUHVHQWHG 'HIHQGDQW¶V PRWLRQ WR GLVPLVV RU LQ WKH DOWHUQDWLYH IRU VXPPDU\
MXGJPHQW 'NW  LV SURSHUO\ GHQLHG $Q 2UGHU ZLOO HQWHU FRQVLVWHQW ZLWK WKLV 2SLQLRQ
'DWHG -DQXDU\ 6 

/s/ Janet T. Neff
-$1(7 7 1())
8QLWHG 6WDWHV 'LVWULFW -XGJH