James v. Zych

Filing 4

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 9/10/2015. (slt) [Transferred from Virginia Western on 9/10/2015.]

I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT

VOR THE W ES
TERN DI
STRI OF W RGI A CL R OF #EUE DS OU T
CT
NI
E KS FC . IXC R
ROANOKE DI SI
VI ON

A R #< %
T W
Fkso
.
%
'
.'.

cAlw xz ss,
aM

) cws xo. l cva 4l
s
z:s e s
)
.
Peii r
ttone ,

v.

CHRI TOPHER ZYCH, ARDEN
S
W
Re ponde .
s
nt

sEF 10 2 1
05

)
s
v;
) M EM ORANDUM OPI
NI
)
)
) By:Ho Gln E. nr d
n. e Co a
) Ch e Un td S a e DititJ e
if ie t t s src udg
)

p
.
' -.

Cal n J m e ,an i t a t Unied Stt Pe t nta y i Lee Count Vigi a,fld
vi a s
nma e t he t
aes nie i r n
y, r ni ie

tlspr â peiin f awrtofha asc pus ptrua tt 28U. C.j2241.J me algest t
li o : tto or i
be or , ts n o
S.
a s le ha
he s d be r e t nc d,be a e hi f de a c i na s nt nc as i
houl
es n e e
c us s e r l rmi l e e e
mpos i lnlwft t r
ed s l a tl mde
J
ohns v. nied St t , U .
on U t
a es
S.
-

-

,

1 S Ct25 1tu e2 , 01 ) Up nrviw o terc r ,
35 . . 5 l n 6 2 5 . o e e f h e o d

t c tc l t thi cli f r ifunde j2241i tzsc tmus besl rl denid
he our oncudes ha s am or ele
r
n li our t lmmaiy e

wih u p eu ie Thec u t 1 h we e , o tu t es b sin a a moi n t v c t,s t
t o t rj dc .
o r * 1 o v r c nsr e h u miso s
,
to o a ae e
a i eo c re thes ne c t e 28U. C. 2 5 a dta fri t t es n e cngc u t
sd r o r c t e tn e md r
S. j 25 , n rnse t o h e tn i o r.
J m e wasc c e i t Unie Stt DititCour f t Diti tofM i s aon
n s
onvit d n he t d aes src
t or he src
nne ot
o co ofbn r
ne unt
nk obber a s nt nc t a t t lof21 mont i prs The Unied St t
y nd e e ed o o a
0
hs n ion.
t
aes

Cour ofAppe safr d hi co cin.Unie Sttsv.J me ,534F. 868( h Ci.2008)
t
al fime s nvito
td ae n s
3d
8t r
,

c r.d ne ,5 7 U. 91 ( 0 9 . J me 'moi n t v c t,s ta ie o c re tte s n e c
et e id 5 S. 5 2 0 ) a s to o a ae e sd r o r c h e tn e
t r28 U. C.j2255,fld i t s ntncng c wast ucc sf . J me now peiins
mde
S.
ie n he e e i omt
ms e sul n s
tto

t s c u tt e j2 41f rh be s c r u rle u d rt J l o d cso whc Vl t a
hi o r md r 2 o a a o p s eif n e he oms n e iin, ih d h t
,

'

i posng an i r as s nt nc unde t r i ua c a e oft Ar ed Ca e rCrm i Ac ,18
m i
nc e ed e e e
r he esd l l us
he m
r e i nal t

U. C. 9 4 e, iltst Co siuin' g aa teo d ep o e s
S. j 2 () vo ae he n ttto s u rn e f u r c s .

As sa e J mes cai c lng t l lt ofhi f de a s n e e a i
tt d, a ' l m hale es he egaiy
s e r l e t nc s mpos d. Such
e

camsmu tn r l b rie o a p a o i a j2 5moin i t sn e ig c u t I r
li
s o mal e as d n p e l r n
y
25 to n he e tncn o r. n e
J n s 2 6 F.d 3 ,3 2 (t Ci.2 0 ) Pei o e ' j2 41 p tto rii s c cams i
o e , 2 3 28 3 4h r 0 0 . tt n rs 2 eiin asng u h li s
i
bar d t e s i m e t t srnge sa r ma td t rt J s de i i 226 F. a
re mls t e s he ti nt t nda d ndae mde he one c son.
3d t

3 3 3 (idngta c le g t f d rlc n ito i b re fo r ve t e j2 41a e ta
3 -4 fn i h t haln e o e ea o v cin s ar d ' m e iw md r 2 bsn
r
s
howi t tt de apos- onviton c ngei t lw,pe ii rsofe e c
ng ha m r
tc c i ha
n he a
ttone ' f ns onduc i no l r
t s onge

ci n l; e as Uni dS ae v. u rt, F.d , 5W L 4 91 7 ( t Ci. uy31 201 )
rmia) s e lo t tts S rat- 3 - 201
e
5 6 7 4h rJ l , 5
(ppl ng I r J t ba j2241 sntncng rle unde rtoa tve a lae c tde iin
a yi n e ones o r
e e i eif
r er ci ppelt our cso
is a trpeii rs ilta j2255 moton,be a e peiine' ofe e c
sued fe ttone ' riil
i
c us tto rs fns onduc rmane
te i d

ci n l.
rmia)
The c r ntpe ii f ist sa e f t o whih J m e c d s ts y t J
ur e
tton al o tt acs n
c n s oul a if he onessa r
t nda d.
Be aus t J ms n de ii ha no e f c on t c i i lt ofJ mes ofe e c
c e he ol o c son d
fe t he rm na iy
n ' f ns onduc - bn
t - nk

rb r - he c n o p o e d wih l scamsun e j2 41 Th r f r ,te c u twild ny
o bey n n t r c e t l li
i
d r 2 . e eo e h o r l e
wih u p eu ieJ me 'cam t e j2 41frs ne igrle u e J l o .Thec u t l
t o t rj dc n s li md r 2 o e tncn eif nd r oms n
o r wi
l
as c t eJ s s si a a j2255 moton,howe r whih wilbeta fre t t
lo onsnz nme ' ubmison s
i
ve, c l rnser d o he
Unie St t Diti tCo tf t DititofM imes a A c r s
td aes src ur or he src
r ot . or e pondi or s l is t s
ng der hal s ue hi
da
y.

EN TER: Thi Ib da ofSe e be , 2015.
s
y
ptm r

Cli fUnied St t sD i ti tJ
le
t
a e s r c udge