Blades v. Countrywide Home Loans, Inc. et al

Filing 277

ORDER granting 243 defendants' Motion to Dismiss for Lack of Jurisdiction; denying as moot defendants' separate motions for summary judgment 245 , 247 , 249 and 251 . Signed by District Judge Halil S. Ozerden on 11/5/2009. (avm)

% & & % & &% '( ) ) ) % 5 * :" " ( & 6) ! 25578 # & ) ./ & ( ! "" # " 7! 74 87 567 ,% 4 " * 985 ) ) * +

!# "

"""

$

%

*

8

& & 6" ) 0 1

:;

) ' ./ 6:0 1 ./ 0+( & 1 "

./ 4 0 1 ./ & ( " 0' 1 )
2

6:

,$

1

& 2' & " " *

! "" (& * +3 ) "

#

"

$% (&

"

"

4 5

# , 2"

" & *" ++, ' ( & ) ./ 0! 1 2" 3 (& " & " +, # +%

& " 3'

(< &

) <

,

(&

"

, "

4

$+ ' 2

'2

8 & ! "" ) ' * " & & $ "' * & !" " " " & " " < B ( <" ; ; " " -2" & & < < A " A " " * (& & ) ' " '(< 6: ' * @ 6: ' 6: ; 6 & *" #
42

* * " 59 2: 2(* -8 " '

7*982: 6 ) 5 8= ! # > ./ ' 0 1

6: " & ? ; +, > -

> & & " < 6: (& <

2

"'

< (&

"

" < * '

" + < " & "" < , < "" + 8 1+1 .. $ & '5 " < " "') ,% " '

&

'

C

+ A

3 < " & C " " " '6&<

'* " 4 " " ) ' *) 9!!) ( ) ! 2 8

" < < '

"

" A , C $ 4' / A, + 4' '

" 4 ' 8'

8

+ . 1+1 . " " ' ; " A " '0 &< ;C ;

A "

< -' + . 1+1 5 ' .' ;

, , ,+ .$ & ; %3 % + .$ -

' + 3+1 D '

"

' + 3+1 D '

-3-

A E ,"< $ 4' ,+%' ) "

/

"

< " & " '0 " < 0 "; ! ; 8 + . 1+1" . & "' / "

"

A

" +% 4' A E '0 # ' 2 < " '0 .& ' % 31' 5 1 " $ ' / # E % " < )) ) 9 !< $ $++ .$

' ' + 3 1 /2 F '

" ' 9'!' (!5' H $$% 4'% ( " +% %

A )) G ) & +$.$ ! $%% 4'% ' $3 31 ,.$ ' +' / !

'0 # ' .& " " "& % / F " 4 '% $ 1/ '5 F & '0 # ' .& F " %( " " ! $ 4'% $+ < $ $ .$ & ; ' 31' 2 1

%(

I %$

-4-

+

" %*

< ,

" "' 33,4'
) :78 :

" $

" 3.$

<

'0 %

' + 3 1.&
-78 47*782:

+% -82 " -

628:7! 2:2( D8) 6 5 285698 8' >
5) 7 2( * -8 ) 7*987 G $ %'% %%

7*D28* 6 '

.% +,% "

'

31' 1 / "

+ " ' & +,% " < / "& < " " " " &

3

&

* " * 8 & & &
% '0

E" ' ')

*

"

''''0 &

"'

!

' @ " <

'+ ' ! ""

" & <

< & &

/ " <

&

3

" ') ; "

C < + " / < & " '0 ) ' + 3+1 ' " < < ! ; " " 3 " +,% " ' " " " +,%

< " / &

"

" ; 0

" ' '5

'

" 4' & + % / " " " 0' " " +, " -' 5A ' < + , .$

* <

#

$+

< & +,% " < ''

'0 # ' %%

'+ ' 5 " * & #' + 4' + +3$.$ .$ ' '+ '+

< " 1,% ,1

"' % 4'% + ""

* 5 5 2 & +,% $ " ++, H 7 &* @ 7 E / +J '+ K3+,' %' -' 8 ! & ( <" 5 2 C * :& 5 C & " $ & ' +,% '!" ' ' ,' 5 "; ' &

'5

& " " " 6: 7E / J '+ -' 8 * ' ' " & ' " '

4 E2 ' 7E / +J '+ " ' %H " 7 K+,% ' I < K+,% ' &*

' + +' &

'!" ' & 2 " + ' "

' + + ' 5& @ '5 K 3+,' %' /

K@ ,$' &

" &4 4

" : '0 *

&

5

-6-

', & & "

7E / @ 0 ' 2

*

' &

'

*" "

++, ' '5 &

&

5 * !5

&

<

@ < /

"' " " & ' '+ ' 5 '! '!" ' : 4 E2 ' 7E / +J '+ -' " 7E ' " * & "

4 : 5 " &

) '0 # ' 5 "

" :

:

" 8J / + * ' ' ++, H 7 * & ' & & < & & " E $ +! ' 5 < & + + +. " '0 '+ $1 ' < " *. < &* 5

'" +' 2 + 7 < "

" &

<

' 2/ & / " * &' " "

-7-

" ' " , % " < A '0H 1 &+ $ M .!'*' % < . '# ' " << " " ) '0
!!" '

" & " "H ,,4' A & $ + $ % .$ " " A A ' + 3+1.

'

" ; < ' / /C < < A " <3 " 8 A " " & < < " '+ $1 H " < " I " < D: " 0 ;0

% 1.

! 8 "

( ' %L + . 1+1" . 4 "

3

A

"

&

"

'/ E 9

*+
*7 2( ( '

1

% 4'% +% & "

+%,+ .$ " ""

G++@ @ $./ + )

" & '0' 1 ' 0+ +" < /& & 3%,! ' -8& $ < "

"

< . ' %1 '

"

< & / " 7 " < & $ A < / " A " " A &" " & < "" & &'
)

"

" "

'2

" A !

& ; % A " " A '

&

< &' 4 8 <

< "<
) ' -' N

&

" " &'0 47*' 8' $.15 '

&'

& " A " "" A "

" ') A < " *

" A &

)' ) < " " , % * 8 & & " " "

( :9 !) ( " " " ) " '

*" 6" : -9)'

:; &

# 4

( & " & " "

)

"

(&

) ) ) ! "" # "

" '

" , (& $+

6" :

)' ,

,$ ( &

) & '4

)

$

( <"

'

6
2:) !9:7= 2( O78*7( : 9 ( ) 7* !5257! * ) 58) 5 #9 * >7 5 !

-10-