Time Insurance Company v. White

Filing 85

ORDER granting 39 Time Insurance Company's Motion to Dismiss Third-Party Defendant Albert Small's Cross-claim. Signed by District Judge Halil S. Ozerden on 12/10/2008. (YSM)

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF MISSISSIPPI SOUTHERN DIVISION TIME INSURANCE COMPANY v. LARRYE J. WHITE LARRYE J.WHITE v. ALBERT W. SMALL § § § § § § § § § § PLAINTIFF Civil Action No. 1:08cv16 DEFENDANT THIRD-PARTY PLAINTIFF

THIRD-PARTY DEFENDANT

ORDER AND REASONS GRANTING TIME INSURANCE COMPANY'S MOTION TO DISMISS THIRD-PARTY DEFENDANT ALBERT SMALL'S CROSS-CLAIM
! "# + , + $& % *. ( ( & (+ 4 + > +. @ 4 4 A 14 ' ( @ 8 ( 3< . ! /?& 1220& ( 8& * ' /0& 1220& 56 () !' +3 ( & ( ( *9 *: ' - (3 != ( ' & ( *+ ( ( 3 , 4 () ) !' & ( ( & ( (4 ( *+

! 76 4 * . *9 , ( . ( + ' ( ;

(+ .

<.(

( 9 ! >4

16& 1220&

-1-

+

. ! 12& 1220& @ . ! . . (! C ( 4, (B &+ ( 3 = 3! 4&( & 4 8 (

. ( ( * ) 8 .

4 () +=

@ !

-*

8 .

( *+

4 @4, 4 & ()

+ +

> @

17& 1220& (

.

& .. (@ &8 ( . . & "+% . (C ! 33 &C (( .8

( . ( " %8 !& &" % & ( "(% !

&

,

) 4 A 14 <( () > ! 11& 122 & , $8 % 4 A 74 (( (3 3 <= ( 3 . , ( ( *. , *. . 3 @ & !' ( ( ! "# , D $& % ) -

. * . ( 3 C 3= , . *. 4 3( . ( ( "# . * 4-

+

( 4

/1"+%/% /1"+%1% "& "& AA ?) 6 4

(/1"+% % "

', # 8 = ( + + ! ( (3 ) !4$

,,

: .3 ( ( ( 8

-2-

: 4 E 0 3 2 0& 1220 @ 9 16 ?26/& 22 F ":4'4 ?1"7 ( ( 4,4 /& 8 12"/ 61%4 % ( ( ! "%( !H + ( , @ 3 ( C 3= ! 44 ! 8 , 4444$ , 4 8 4 /4 & (+ . *. . ( "5% ! ) # + .3 444 ( 3 ( *. +8 ( ! ( ( . (3 += ( # ! ( 444 4$ *. 4 (+! ( (( ( 4 ! $+ 8 ( . .3 ! ) 3 ( 3 8 & /1/ 4 ( ( ?14 *. ( ( (= ( 4 ?& !& +! (* + @4 4 . ( C #I 41 8 +8 8 3 . 4$ 4 + . ) ! C* 4 1/& 1220%" ) 8 +! "# $ !+ (8 ( 8 # . % E"/% ( +# ( 3 3( ( H ! 3( +G &'( ' ) . "1% H & /1/ 4 ( 7?& ( (+ +& 526

4 1227%4 * %

-3-

() . , +

!

&

8 !&

,

,

( &$ (

)

&

( ) 3 ( . (+ & 526 4,4 !& )

# 4

(

*.

= * # ( +$

8 ( # 3+ ( ! .

+ 4 4$

(8 ! & /1/ 4 )

( .

(

?1" ! 8

$ +

/6% , 4 (

(

4 /5" %1% "

( 8 3( &

(+ 3

+ ( 4 +! 8

( 3&, . ) 8 ( ! 4,4 707& 7 7 "/ ) + 4$ * +! ! F?",4'4 ,! C 4 ( /% 4 .

4

.! .) ( * ! "! 4 + . .3 " ) /?& 122?%H +4 % ( :4

& # +=

=( ! &5 .

4$ 8 3 &# ( *! /& 1220% F"( ?

) 6) 5 5& 1220 @ 9 2/50 & 2/ * !

4& : 4 27) 0 5> & 122? @ 9 5/52 ?& 5 ! +< %H ) < 5 8 + 4,4 7 5" +( ) & (.

< 41(

-4-

/126& /1/ " ( )

4/

/%"# (

!

3+ 0 3( ( + 4 ( . .&8 8

. 1

3 4& 3( (

3 ( !4$./! % C 122 % , 4 4 . 3

25 4 , * 4 1( 0 2& 0 5 ":4'4 +. ! /20& //?" 8 .. . &8 ! .4 4 122?%( " ( ( 1 8 +. .(

" 8% 4

& 51, 4 1( 3& (

+. & '! (

( 0 4, )

( &: 4 4 /0& 122?% 4 8 +4 ) ( (

5E 7 3 /5) ) & 122? @ 9 162//??& 2 /. ' ( . & 3 : + (+! ( 3 (8 $ E !( /1H "% ( ( ) . . & ( 3 (

F ) ":4'4 5

8

( (

/5" %1% "E () ! J # ()

!( "*% (

(

.

()

!

-

! /"% ( & ! !( ( ) !( ( () !( . -

() ! ! . / "+% ! ( / "+% ! ( ( / ". H % !( H(

.

.

"%

!

()

!

-5-

"' %

! .

. () !

+! = 4

. -

'4 4 L * /.

K4 4 /5" %1% "4 (. , & 8 8 ! . . ( (. & !& ! . += ( @ 3 8 8 (3 ( 4 () . . /5" %( . 4$ 2 &# L ! & 25 4

5" %1% " 4 5) 4 7 !(

83 & (

/5" %1%'% "" .

() !(

. (

()

! .

4

41(6/2& 4

F 41" 1

4/

2% H

' '

$! ( +38( ! !

. &? 6 4, , / ," % &, 8

4 6?7& 6??",4'4 : 4;4 / 00% , 4 8 ( '4 4 ( ! +4 (+ # ( 3( ( (! 4$ : (! ( ( @ 8& . ! 3 +

(

(/5" % % "4 (3 , 8 8

K4 4 /5" % % "4 . . ( + ( .3 ! . 8! )

3

+

8

(+ (

3(

-6-

+

! @ + 4, &

8 8

(+ ! &+ 8

3

(4 @

& )

.

+( & ( +( 4 1227% 4 + 4 033

+ #

. 3$ ! 4 .

) &

/1/ 4 ( 7?& ?1"7 ! + + .8 &+ F1" 4'4 9 4 > () ! ( (( 3. 1 8 = . ( @ 3 4 8 3( 4 4! ( 4 8 &

) , .+ & ( () ! & : 4 26) 3(

+8 575& 1220@ 9 1 776 2& ) ( (& : ( & ( .8

7& 1220%"( . % 4 )

+!

( 5" (

4& 5?5 4 , 8 = ( 3

4 1( 02?& 0// "@ 4'4 @ ) 8 ( . & 3= ( & = ( @

4 122?%"# * ( 3 ( ( 8

4$4 % (

38 @

8 (
1

(. 3+

( +=

4/

"

.

, ( 8 3( ( ( ( *8 , ) (: 3 + /0& 1220& (, . : * ( *84 * ( (* ( 3 + /0& 1220& ( += ) (4 & 3 . 38( (& 8 4, -.

) +! 4!C !( > 4 . ( 8 6& ( + 3 . 4

.

-7-

L

=

(4

(

@ :

8% 4

:9, + &+ 4 ( . . (+! ( +. ( ! "# + 3 & =( 4 $& % ' ( (, & () + ) !' ( *+ & ( += (4 ) 3

*. ( (+ & (& 8 ( 8 3 (+! -

& ! , (+ +! ( &
*

) (

&

( +!

*. .

/0& 1220&

(& 8

/2

(

!

'

+ & 12204

9 9 , 9 ; *: M : ' , * ,' ,

': > 'D

-8-