Wachovia Bank, N.A. v. Charter Bank et al

Filing 210

ORDER denying 169 Wachovia Bank's Motion for Partial Summary Judgment. Signed by District Judge Halil S. Ozerden on 9/16/2010. (YSM)

Wachovia Bank, N.A. v. Charter Bank et al

Doc. 210

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF MISSISSIPPI SOUTHERN DIVISION WACHOVIA BANK N.A. v. CHARTER BANK, GREGORY E. CRONIN and JAMES ROBERT FAVRE PLAINTIFF Civil Action No. 1:08cv267 DEFENDANTS

!"#" $% 2 . .* ( + .( ( (( * / 8/ . 1( ./ ( (, 11 3* ( !"#" $% * ) 0 > + ( &" # *' .1( , ( .( , 7 0 / ( (. . ( 0 ( =* ( . ) * ( 0 + .- + (. / " ( * 0( . / .0 &( ' ( )*+ + ( -*./ , + $% 1 *0+ * 6 *( ( ( ' 3( / ( " & , 45 . ( ( . *. +* 0 . /* ." ( 0* . * 0 1 .- + 5"# ( + ( . *" 0( ( / (

((

" 9 :;;< + ( ( 3( / ( " / , ( *

* , > ( . () * 6

/(( 1

11 3*

-1-

Dockets.Justia.com

. 6 ( ( )1 *" . , +1 , (( ( 1 1( *. / *. / ( 2 1 (+ ! + 0 (:;;4 ( . -* + :5 :;;4 ( 1 ( . . % * (> * , (& " 2 . .* ( .* , " (* (( ( ( ,* ( + + 1 " BB < :<C . $% ( . ( + (' &" .*

> . / ( (

+1 , . ( . ( .. ( (+ ( ( " 1*( 1 -* , ? :;;4 ( " ( ( ( .* . ( /

. ( .* , ( 0/ 8 11

(

, , >( , />

. .

( (( 1 /

(+ ( > 1( 8( 11 > .

0( ( :: :;;4 *, >0 . / .1 ( . (( .

(( ( 6/ ( (>

#11

*+ ( . (0*

>0 :;;5"

(

.

((

(>( . ( ,> (+ ( ( ( /> +( (( / +1 , .* . ( * (( " A

( + :;;@* ( , ( / ." ( *( ( ( " (( .. ( ( (&

#1( : :;;4 , , ( ( 0 +

.

(1 , . 0, (.

(( 6

./ 8( (

,% . . ( (( . 6 0*

>* ,( B ??"

+1 . ( 11 (( > -20* ( / ( +

-* +

:

:;;5 / , # ( , 9 )" ) .
2

(0(

(. ) ( . +1 , +

D 4@7 7 :

1( ,
# E ./ *+

.* 0(

( +1 .*

" +/

>+ 2

(1 ( . "

*+ + ( ,

( .* , ,

" * / (

)*+ + ( -*./ , + * @$'

) .(

.( . * 1 / ( .*( E ./ *+ >( . . 2" " 9 " G *
"

0 ( . (. ( > ( . .+ /* E ./ *+ * + (

. / .1 (> (

(/ .( *

, + /1 (, 1*( 1 +

>

,+ >" .. 1

@"

+ + ( E ./ ,* + . " + 5<: ":. 5 @ 5 (F E ./ *+ % + + 1/ ( *.
1

, * *11 ( . 5' C

(

<44 ")" ? 4 ?:<$ $@ ( " 55' " * . *.

. 1* . +* 0 / *

( +* 0 + " . 1* ' "

*+ + ( , (" (/ ( . > >> "$

"

. 1*

4@ " )*11" :. @< @<?$)"2" ( ,& * +1 ( + " ( + +0 ( > * * .( $ ! , / ( "

/ *0 #

*+ + ( E ./ ,* +

9* 11 ( ( + 0, . , 0( * ( .* , ,( +" + + ( > .

1( *+ + ( E ./ ,* + +" > ( + ( .*+ 4 + *+ + ( E ./ ,* + 0( F *+ + ( E ./ ,* + , > . E ./ *+ > 0. . + >" -3-

5 : 0":. : @ :4: $@ F + ++ 54'" ' ( "& ( 0* 1 ( , + * 1( * ( . + $ ' (0 " + ( ( 0( 4 ( ( * 1 (,& " () ( ' "$ (

( "

54'" '

(% +

*+ + ( E ./ ,* + 1 6 * :@ *

. . ( ( . (. ?5$@ ( "

> """" %

( #

.

@< ":.

1( 1 (, *11 ( . + / . 1( 0 (/ %& ( )) / <44 ")" ( ?5 .

( *+ + ( E ./ ,* + % + ( *

11 ((

/

/1 (, ( E ( *,

( *(

"?. <: < 7 ; $@ @ 5 '" 9 '

( :;;<' " .

" <44 ")" :<: :< $ , 1( 0 :< " / *

1( , . 1( 1( . @

*+ + ( E ./ ,* + + 1 # +, ./ +, (, +(

* >(

( ( *+ / &

( / + + ( ." $)"2" *( 6 E ( . * " :;;5' "

?< " )*11" :. * 8 % #. ' " * 0 . ) 1

1( + *0 / )) >"

. *1 -

.

(,

*( + *

11 , ?5' $ C

?;< ")" < 4 7 ; $ 5 (

"?. 4? 4? $@

( "

>

0+ > H 2(6 > 0 11 . 0, .( *( , 0( F 1> + (0 ( *( / ( . 0, * # / ( (, ( -4-

>

/ "

> .( 0

.+ ++

> >"

(*( ( ,

1

( *+

0,

;? ":. ;?; ;?: $@ 6( .* ( 2* , ,

( " +

;' "

( . * (1 1 >( 1(

11 .. (

. D5 7 7 ;@. @ (" % 1 /. ( (0 .. ( """ .> *" . ( .

.( .

(

11

0 . (

0

0. +. ( / .* ( E ./ *+
2 D5

(( , 1 .. . *0 I

./ 9 )" )

.

$:' &

7 7 ;@$ ' )*0 @ "

(( . (( ( 0 """ 0 /1 ( """ (+ (.+ / * , / ( , // + ("" ( / / . " ( (. ( / ( ( . .* , ( * .* ( 0( ++ (( > 1 " / 9 )" ) ( + *
2

.1 ( ,0 .( (( ( . .* > .+ ( /( // * .* , , ,(

" D 5 7 7 ;@$:' @ " > / ( ( (F 1
: "&

+ . ( ( 0+
2

+ *+ %( 0 . . 0, (
D5

*1 0 . (/ ( . ( *0

,* . ( ( 0 . ( * 1( ( (0

*

// /

. .

./ 0 >

+1 , ( . ( . ( *+

.( .
9 )" )

0,

* .(

7 7 ;@$@' @ "

(

*/ ( 0* 0 / ( ( ( (( 1 > (

2

. 1* D5 7 7 ;@/ ( @ . (> ,> ( ( > (0( / % .F* >/ (

.( . " (

/

( 1( * .

-5-

+ 1 21 * 1" . > 1

( (

(

. 6

(

. 1( 1(

( ,

( " "C 11 ( (

( (> (

0

+

11 3* . F< " > " F :; " (

( + () ( 7

. / ( ( . ( . (* .>(

) .

( (#11 , * . 1* . ++* + > ( . 1 ( + . 0" :;;4 7 + ( (+ ( ( , . + 2 1"

+1 , . ( . ( 0 ( + +0 ( , . 0* ( "C ( /

* . .

+( F % <J ":

>0

" 1" @

F 11" 47 " ( (> "

4 75 4 ( ,> (

( 2 1" . ( .

+1 , . . 1 "C 0" : " / 1( :;;4 "

0 ( + +0 ( > ( . . .> > > ( ( ( (( " , 2 1" 2 1" . ( +* (6 . F @K " F % ?J " ( ( (

1,0

+

( >(

. 1* * , .0, ( (+ L F @: " F%& "2 * . + 1( 1 ( ( ( 1"

(

( . .

. ( .

*

+1 ,

(

:: :;;4 7 + . . ,

, "

F :? "

1 "CL ( "C9

11" ?: <:7 ? < 11" ?: ?5 .* / ( * //

. F%& " (( .> ( (

.*

(+

0

,

.(

(

.

(

(0-

""""&

9 )" )

2

D5

7 7 ;@$<' @ "

6-

=* 1 $. ( (+ /%

( E( *, 0# =*

( '

( . ( / *+ + ( E ./ ,* + : : "?. @ < ( . ( #) 0+ ( + */ > 0( AA * .0 / ! " :I : ; $ */ .+/ . ( .( M ?$@ .

11( 1(

"

( :;;;' " 11( 1( "

*+ + ( E ./ ,* + " " #11" :;;;'$%> "" // ( (/ """ 1 * .( (, M .( !# ( #

&C/ ' (

44<) " :. <@ < < $ + ( =*

( , (. (( 11 (

E ( &" * ,' ( > . .( . ( .* 0 ( .* , " .* ( .* , , 1 .

> / ,1 ( -

5 :;;? ")" 2 * ( (. . +

" A N9 : 4 : ) 2 F / & * . (+ ( " =* + (, (( * 5 )"

5:7 < $!"2" 5 :. 4 ( 5 7 :< $ 5 ( . . 1* .

" 2 " :? :;;?'$ " ( @ '" '

.( / . ( + ( (> * (+ ( 6 / ( " ( * (

F ( ( * .0 (/ ( . 11( 1( . "

. >

0

((

*+ + ( E ./ ,* +

( (> * . 0

*1

(

( .

. ."

(

> 1(

*+ + ( E ./ ,* +

(

* .0 . . +( *, (

( !"#" -7-

( (

( ( 0,

)*+ + ( -*./ , + "

. 1*( *

2" " 9 " G

"

@

* .0

.

.,

) 1 + 0 ( :; ;"

#
A9 ) A O #! P 2 ! A !9 2 ) # ) 2 9 ) 9 - 23

-8-