Wachovia Bank, N.A. v. Charter Bank et al

Filing 216

ORDER granting in part and denying in part Defendants' Motions 160 , 162 for Summary Judgment. Signed by District Judge Halil S. Ozerden on 9/22/2010. (YSM)

achovia Bank, N.A. v. Charter Bank et al

Doc. 216

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF MISSISSIPPI SOUTHERN DIVISION WACHOVIA BANK N.A. v. CHARTER BANK, GREGORY E. CRONIN and JAMES ROBERT FAVRE PLAINTIFF Civil Action No. 1:08cv267 DEFENDANTS

! " ,-(( % '- $ ( " " 1 1 7+! " . )

# $%& )* ./ () * . " / * 1* -1 ) $

'( . - & 01 56! )

) 2. * & .

* "

+! "

3 &4& 1 . * 2 - )( / & 2 $ . $ 9" * W 3&4& ") ,< .* /* )" /

7!4 &

1$ 1 /

"

-1 1 $*

*. " % )

1% . 18 $ & : + 6" 2 . * ( $ "# $ % & ,-1-

1) .1 .; *.

$

.

// #-1 ( &4

,'(

)

/ * -1< %

- ").( 0

Dockets.Justia.com

$" 2

/ . * 1" %

2. *= <1 (/1 % ." 1$ 1 . & " 0( /- / & .

// #-1 *" -. %* $ )$ 9 // . / .1 $ = < <) . + 7& ( + ?1 % & $ . $ 9 . & 1 %

$

& %* 1

2. * . -.

-. * =

1 % 1% < 0( < .< / $ 9 " // .* . $<

& 2 . . 1% 2 . * ,/ 1" / . / $ .1 3 / $ ( * () ' +7" + 5" )% " $ + 5" * / < / . * 1" < % 0( ** * " .* (/1 % 0( "

) - % ++" + 5" <) " *"1 -( )-

'-1 > " + 5" % . .&

4//1.

2. * . *1 1 @ $ " (/1 % "

14/ 1+" + 5" % * ).( =

0 (/1 %

.&2. * " . 2 . * = )1% 1 !

" 1 $< 2. * 1 < -1% &1 2 %. (

(2 . * (/1 AA 6" +6B &

- 1 < -1% 1 A >>& ! *" // -2.

.* . %-

1"

(/1 "

'$. ( 1 (

+ " + 7" $ ) ,. . 1 % 1% 4. " : ,& ,

"* 1

C 5?8 8 " + .* 1. 1 4 /

&" ." % $

. (/ (&

.< &

)<

(/1 % ( -((

1

"

%D $ -(

1. ( 1

& -

,-((

% '- $ (

, 1 -1 < * 10 . /1 1" ( 1 $ $" < 1. & & : & 0& ? & E . - 1% - -// 1 / " *" < % " % < D$ -(

1? . 1) 1 " 1 $D$ -( %D $ &-( (

$$

%( 1 <& /

( * $/ /- / .( 1

(( "

" 655 &,& > 5" >+6 F7 B 76+ &+(7 ?" 7 G ? . & F77 & /" .- 1 . (- ) ( & FFF & 2 /$ -) # %D $ -( . "$ * . . 1 -(( 1 & $ .< . * 1< < 1 1 7+ )1 G %

D$ -( ( ( $ / .1

&

/-

(- ) $ -

" 5? & ,-//& + ?6 " ?6> ,& & 1% " . -(( (/ - .( %D $ -( & ( () 1< - ! 1 % $* " -(( /1

&+ + ?" +5+ ?

&1 F75 & 2 1(

=. -

-3-

(

1 <" & & & & 1 1 %) #

. " F?6 &+ ( * * %& ( )) $ .

+?"

. >7 ? -((

(( & F75 & %D $ -( " % D% -

1 &

&

/ / 1 -// % $ -. . * % & () /) .

//

$ 1 -

/

% (- /

* $

."

. ( * $/

-* 1 . ( / ' 1 .1 %

/

>7F &>

6+" 6F8 ? ? &:

&+ 6 * .

&" 655 &,& +6+" +6F F7 1/ ) % +6F& 1$ 1 &* # * " -(( (*

)1 " &'

%D $ -( (% /1 +, 1 % $ & ( $( ?>6

/1 /

" 655 &,& ) ." 1

(

-< 1 $ 1( (

& ,-//& + . . 9 /"

F5" FF ,& & - =D - (F>7 B$

& + 7& . -) / )) " . /( * 1 <& -/ * % "

//1 %

%# . & FFF &

> 6 &,& 6" 5F8 .7

&> 5> " 5>F ?

/ &

< ) .( < H . = ) 1 * 1< ) //1 )% 1. %. ) , G/< <" . ( ) .$* " 4. $ " % " 1 <" ( .1 < .- % " / . 1. . ( 1. (( 1 <& 0 . " F > &+ -. ( >" >+ ? & FF &

)% 1 . " )%

% -% 1 ( -$ 1 % . -4- = , / () "

+ ) .

" .

+! -. -(( // 2. * ( ,. . / 1) / / ! <** -1 $ / ( /

% $2 . * = 1;* ,. 4. 1 1 : ,& ,

0

1,-(( . ( /

% '- $ ( 1 (- ) &

% - % . (" ( 1 %D $ -( (

1 (" &

1( /- C

.($ 1 4. ,4 " *

// ;&" 1 $ $ 1 I

5?8 8 " +

( 1. - 1 - 19 % 2. * ) *1 ( ,. 4. " & C 5?8 8 " + ;&&&& < 1 -1% 11 ( 1. - 1 . / % ($ (1 * -. % (/1 % 2. * // / . (2 . * *1 ( ,. 4. &&&& .

* < 1 -1% 11 1 (

(/1 A 6 & & * G ) % : ,& 1,
C

2. * <1 %<

. (1 (/1 % 2. *" 1 . . * )

,4 .( 1 /

. (/ $
&

7 8 8 ?" < . / * ? . -/

G 1 * 1< $ * .&&&& : ,& , .

1 )1 % -? 6 & (( * ") %D $ -( . ( #) & ' & ?" + < * & )-

C 7 88 ?

." 2 . *

,4 . (& 1 .. ( #) . -5. . . ( )% (/ / // / ( & 1% J 3& & > " =

,4 .

&" 3 & +I 5. F" + * -

2@ +>6FF " 4. (

/ .1 . "

$

(-1 " / I

" . (/ 1

" / $ ("

*. " (

"

.

;-

* / . ( .* 1 " . - 1 / $$ 1% 1 < " )$ 1 % /( ( / )% " / < . ) : .1 -" . .( : ,& , ( / / $
C

)

1 " . .

( )1 )% ( .* 1 -

-)D . . ( & :/ / ( . 1. . 4. " < (

)1 . .& % .1 ) ( *1 I * . . )% / < .; < < )% (/ / & . : ,& , ") ) % " -%
C

5?8 8 +> ") -$ "-

-. (

( 5?8 8 +> &

. ." %

// /

4. ; ( .B ( 1/1 . & . + & 4 -

> &

. < -G / )% / <I (/ / ( .; <1 $ B ( .1 -" < < <1 $ .<I ( & * ( -$ / < - 19 // ( .; B ( 4. )& ; . .( . $* $ -% . .. % 1( -B / & * ( -$ / < < -% $1 ( .. % 1( B ( <1 .$ / " < < < . 1$ ) .; )% . . ( &

: ,& ,

C

5?8 8 ) & +> -6-

( //K / > ) . . LI 4I LI 4I < $ /&

" . *= / 1 " ( G6 & &&&( 1 ( < 1 // / :. = / 2 )3" & /& 5" & &

* &

-)(

* $ /&

. /& 5" 1 -1 . . G> &

*

$2 . * = " * $> ) K *= & & *"

* 10 . * %

/& //& ?>8 " 58 7" +?8 +7" $1 * % )% & "& 1<I 1 <1 $ " &

&

<1 $ % 2. * / 1 *M

%. <1 $

.

G> &

K

*=

&2. *=G /

( 1 1I % LI 4I / %< % 1 . - 1/ / % 1 " . . &* & (2 . * 2 "- * < $ / 1. / . - ( -1 :. -1 . % & /& $1 &3 < 2 . * " )- 1 . K / /1. < (= *= "< . < -)D . ;& & 1% 1" (1 (1 ( $ -// ( 2. * " /& /& +6" . G5 & * -1 / ( * / //& +F" ++ . (/1 % */ -. " < . . G> & 1 (/1 % " )K *= . & ( .. = $ ( . M

< ( (

/. 1 . . / . % -7-

* /&

. /& ?F8 " 2. * .

//1. .

<

1. G >N & /

2 . * = /-)1. K *= &

(

&

$

* /& % 2 . * =.

% 1 $" -

. ( < . -. 1

12 . * < $ 1. ( $ -1% 1& %

.( (& * ( ( 1

< ,-//& ." * //1.

(

/& F& 2 . * * . & 1. &2. * &3 = . . . . ( (

.

1 2. * . . & * .

-< ,-(( . / / . ( &3 // / < . % -. -1 ? . * 2. *= 1$ 1 " . / * % '- $ ( )% %* . .

. -// $ /

2. *= ( -( 5 !) " = . - 1% ( 1 /. . . %D $ -( -

F!

0 <.

1

"2 . * % .(< 1 . -$ . &+ > . && -. % -% (

// / <. *

2. * " 1 $< . &: . (/

-(( -% *

.& (/ -/ / <!

) " >?> &> >F>" 6 ? ? . .-% -(( 1% 1 * -8-$ %D $ -( ) .

-//

% // =

. - 1% ( 1

2. * / & : /& / // .. . 2 < . ) .- -// 1. ( 1( % .1 - -) -) & ) & .1 # &

.

<

*1

$

-.

%-

D % ;-

&

$ -((

%D $ -(

"

< * " 2 . * (- . ( 1 &

< &

<

<$$$ -// $( ( ( ( $*

.- 1

& & : & 0& ? E . * . . 2. *" "

." 2 . * ).$ * * . *1 " (/ ) )1 (/1 % (

.( 1

2. * . // /

* ,4& ." ;1 %

2. * 1" / . 1 " 1$ 1

11$ 1

. $( 1 %* & & + +& .1 . ( 1 . &3 & . 1 . ..

/. . . 2 &" +5

<$$&> 5?6" 5?F ? / . / ( /

. // / 1( < .(( & 4//& + & FF7 & : < & & $. &

- " -(( -: ). . 2 % " ! /

%D $ -( .< .< .<

! . -

#

&" F6F , & + ?+" ??

" 5 7, & + 66" 67 .< )( /1 -9<% 1 ( &&& . .

-1 < -1% * 1 // . (1

/.* . "

= )-

(- / * I

< / 1 . -

1

< 1 -1 + 1B 1 < -1)B> -

.<

. 1-1 . .< < )1 . -

.-

($ - 1 < -1/- / / 1 -1 & &

$ <( $ ..

1 "< -

$

D -

( 1. B 4# +5

6 .- 1 ( $ !' .+

. !'" F

, &+

F>" G / " (

F7

&- ? & + .< . ." .& ! . . (" 1 . /1 (. < -1 % 1 *) )1

. )-

. )1 . 1$ 1 & FF7 &

5 7, & 1 66" 67 + /( / <1 & & , && " "? . 1 (" 1 $( )- % % (/ & F7 .< , & + F?6" F?5 $ 1. & &

< 1 -1 1 . 1-1 . /1 . .- 1 $ & " < G . 62 2 & $ 1 $ D ( 1 -1 )1 & F7 & 2. * 2. * < (% / /#

;/. . ;. . )

<$ /* & 2

" ?F & ,-//& +5 " +7 . $ &

// !

* (/1 % . & *) 1.

. (

-// .. <

.*% 2. *

(/1 %

-10-

< -

<

8 1 (/1 % <1 / . $ & -. "

<

< 1% 1

.

< $( 0

(

%< *. %

&2. *" ) ". * (/1 % .( 1 $ ( % - %. ( 1 ( $ . ..

// '- $ . ( ) $(

%. ( 1 -. # % && & & 1 /& -

1,-(( 1. (/ .<

(/1 % = & . $ 2 . .

-((

%D $ -(

. ( " 2 . * (1 1) & -/ . -. ( %$

/. . . *

.

).- " G1 * .%< (

1 <" 2 . * = ) * 2. *& $ 1 = -) -( %D $ -( 1 . ))% ): ,& ,

/

.

$< . 1

(/1 %

C

78

?8 ? 6 / * . . - <. -. & 0 1( 2& . .* $

G 1 * 1< $ * .) &&& & 4 % . ( ) 1 * .( $$<

1 )1 % *=

-

$

2. * -(( 2. * .

2. * (%1 /. . . . -1 %

)%

. 2. * . / = ( )%

%

.

*

. 1$ 1 0(

/

-// ($ " ) < 1

. (&3 1 . . 1( <

*=

$ -11-

&

.

%2 . * "

(G1 *1 . % . /1 % < ( $ -1 D$ -( ( .1 % /( //$ ) // (( * ! / % 2// = ) < . 1 . .* $( . ). ./ &

= /& (/1 % /&

* =. .1 1

-. < 1

%< *

12 . * 1 1. 2. * 1. 1 < -(( %

<1

. $% 1"

2. *"

/ * 1 $ & 4. . 2. *= 1 . 1 % .< . ;% . (& 2 =1 1* " * . * ) . . -

.<

)-

1 $1 % '- $ ( . F! " -

. (& & 1

-$ 2 . * = ) 0 -. )-$ .G / / / 1) % &+ > & FF7 & . & 1 & ,-(( & . (/ .( 1 %D $ -( 1,-((

% - % . (" 1 1 . -(( . (& 1 . * . .

%D $ -( ( . . - &&&& % (/ * "> . &>

(* %D $ -( *

) " >?> &> >F>" 6 ? ? "> &> 6??" 6?7 ? -% -(( -$ %D $ -( . 1 . ;1

-1 ? . -

-/ -// 6?7 & / .

-((

%D $ -( -

// /

1(&

-12-

& / -- /

*1

/

. 1( % // 1 <" . / . % . () / - 1 < -1% 1& & ( 1 1 1 , & @ O: + 5F+" , .( 1 1. " < 1" 1 !# J +8 6 3& & 77 & 2 ( 1 "

. (/1 . /

$

- 1 < -1/- / > ?" > ? .-.

1 < -1/- / & FF6

" >7, & +

67 , &1 +65" +?? + D (( # 2 . * =) (

& F7? & .

$-

% - %. ( 1 (

- .-

1 . ;(- ) &

%D $ -(

-

" @@ " 3 & +I +. 7" + > &,& * & . +>" + > & & (/ . (/ 2. * !1 . /1 (( # & " (/$ /< 2. * -13, /- ! .) 1( %D $ -( )-(( / . " " / 1( 2. * -. * ( * "

*. . . -//

1$ % &:

. 1$ 1 / . (& 1 !) &+ 1 ( & $ "

. (/ ?

!. ( ) % 1 5 &" 6 1 ( /

!. (/1

&> ?76" ?77 & %) ( ( $

. (< 1 &3 . (& 1 . (& 1

2. * . $ $

- < 1$ 1

%D $ -(

.

-((

%D $ -(

)G / D " '& &

;<&

($ & <* " % .

/

. ($ = / $ -

/ -

2. *= /(6! . -1 G1 .-

( .- " / $% & 01 -

. 1 1 $* % =G / '& &

<" < .

/ '- $ ( /- & " <1 1 . (/

. / // . (" 1 -.

1* " ( .< -1 )

1 <" / ,. . ( . / 4. " . &

=

,-((

%

-1 ) $

& 2 . * =. ( 1 & ). C 5?8 8 " + 1 < 1/ . 1 " . (" 1 1

2 . * =) ( -1% 1 '- $ (

.

% -%

.. (& %1

"

! & && : & 0& ? " E -1 ) )%

"

,-((

%

" 1 /- -

( ' ( -1 ) 2 . * = . ( /- 1 // -14( ) -1% 1 * " )% " ,-(( +! % '- $ (

" # $%& " 1 /- & & : & 0& ? " E & " 01 ,. 4. " &

) -

C 5?8 8 " + 1

&" . (" 1

<1 1 &

. (/

.< . (" 1

. -1 )

. )%

"

++

%

, / () " +

&

4
@: , @ P 43 Q @ 3: ,4 , : ,: 3 ' #

-15-