Smith et al v. Mississippi Security Police, Inc. et al

Filing 88

ORDER denying Defendant's Motion for Summary Judgment 56 . Signed by District Judge Halil S. Ozerden on 7/6/2010. (YSM)

Download PDF
Smith et al v. Mississippi Security Police, Inc. et al Doc. 88 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF MISSISSIPPI SOUTHERN DIVISION v. MISSISSIPPI SECURITY POLICE, INC., et al. WENDY JANE SMITH, individually and as Mother and Natural Guardian of JM NMB, JM NMB PLAINTIFFS Civil Action No. 1:08cv DEFENDANTS !" " # $ " '( !%' & .' " (( /( ) *( ' +, .0 ' +( ! ' - !" " 12 ' " .3 - / ", "* " " * 6 / 78 9 ' ( + + " 4' " ( " ' !5 "+ ) #+ ! /%' $ & 9 ' ": "+ ( '4 '( " " " "" +> >" ' ? @@6 6 ) 6A ; *" ! "' " "( 9 '4 "* " ) / ' *"* ( ) "" 2== ' <<' 4 ( 4 4 4 " *!/ " " !"-5 ( " - '4 - 3: ' -1- Dockets.Justia.com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

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?