Smith et al v. Mississippi Security Police, Inc. et al

Filing 88

ORDER denying Defendant's Motion for Summary Judgment 56 . Signed by District Judge Halil S. Ozerden on 7/6/2010. (YSM)

Smith et al v. Mississippi Security Police, Inc. et al

Doc. 88

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF MISSISSIPPI SOUTHERN DIVISION § § § § v. § § MISSISSIPPI SECURITY POLICE, INC., § et al. § WENDY JANE SMITH, individually and as Mother and Natural Guardian of JM NMB, JM NMB

PLAINTIFFS Civil Action No. 1:08cv DEFENDANTS

!" "

# $ " '(

!%' & .' "

(( /(

) *(

'

+, .0 ' +( ! '

- !" " 12 '

" .3 - / ", "* " " * 6 / 78 9 ' (

+

+ " 4' " ( " '

!5

"+

) #+ ! /%' $ &

9

' ": "+

(

'4 '( "

" " "" +> >" ' ? @@6 6 ) 6A ;

*" ! "' " "( 9 '4 "* " )

/ ' *"*

(

) "" 2== ' <<' 4 ( 4 4 4 " *!/

" " !"-5 ( " -

'4 - 3: '

-1-

Dockets.Justia.com

+

B$% -8 > -# , "+ $ +21' -

!"5 > %' 4 &

-

"* " !/

C 4 ) ! ( * "* " -% 8 * ' , 9 ( 5 * + ,

," " +" ( -

B$% -/ / "<<' 2== ' 4 5 (

!"-5 4 " "

8 !* / <=: 2' <

,"

! /'

($ , - <0' 22'D

-

B$% -/

!"-5 " '4

-

! "

+, / ' --"* " ((

"<0' 2== ' * ( !/

E ( ( + ( +"

( +" ( + -

( ----

/ ",

(> (

" " +"

FFF G * ," " "" ' 2== ' ! / 4 $% / , 9 , !"-5 5 C ," " !4 , , ! ! /* , "+ " ---" " " " 4 "

6

B$% -

!"-5 4

'4 - 2<: 2' 2 !/ ! ( ) + ! B -

) " <<' 2== 4 , "+ > (

)

9

5

C

-

-2-

!" ' / *" ! $ ( ' ;; ' "( ( )* (* " / " !" +* ( %' & " ' ) ' )

- 3H' .2' " (" 3=' 2==.' / )

B$% -/

!"-5

8 * " / ' ('

* "(

*

!'

( ' ;; ' ! <# 3: # 1$ *' "6 "

G 4/ $ %< & ' ( +

( ' ;; ' 8 " %' ) & 2# ' "6 " *"* I " " ) (, "( ) 4 " 2- / " >5 ( ' ;; ' ! G 4/ , !" !" ) - 29 5 5 4" C " (' 9 + ' !"5 '

*"* " " * 9 "

'

*"* ( , " (* ! '

<3' 2==.+ " B

( , "2(+ + 23' 2==H' * / " <H ' 2< 8" ( ' ;; ' ! ! " ,' -5 ! * 4

/

/ ;; "4 ( 4 *

( ' ;; ' " >5 ( , "+ +

*" !

> 4

* >- 6 , *

1

' ;;!' -

( " ' 4

> "

+

4, '

4 )

-3-

66 /* * (( " ) *( #& "+ " * C *( C *( ( " ' " 4' ( " 4 "' ( "

6

69

, "! " * " - - 6 - !G " " "( *' 4 ' ,' (,* 4

C *(

'

4 "

(( ' .02

011 - - 3<1' 320# H. & < A -2 .< ' .< # ( B C *( $ ( ( ( 212 # " % 4' - - - - " " + " ' H 0 -2 <<2 ' <<3.# " ( * + ( , , ' C *( " '% ( ( "4 # $ " (( 5 (( - <H.1&& (( C *( $ ' '( 1 +* -2 ' 0<' 03# - " *, ! C *( " , B "% * + !# +" ( -# $ , "4 4 " " - <H..& " ( +( - <HHH& I " " *

((

( (+

(* "

.<2 -2 2 '

"<H.1&- I & "(

* "

-4-

," ' () '" +" ' ' 011 - + ' 4 " * "( ( HH# - + 1 )) ' < + , " 4- 2==.& -% ( )) *

,

, %&

*

(,*

C - 2==0&# , ( ( " ( " "

3.H -3 <02'<0H: =#

-' 011 - - 202' 20H # H. &- 6 < & " + ,' (( ( " * , C %" . - <HHH& + (>4 "+ '( + / ' J " ' ( " * +, C *( " *( &

20H"* " -

(,

30 -

-2

H1'

"

' 3=0 - - 0' 1H: = # H3./ # .< 0

-3 13 ' 13H# 4

" , "4 + 4' B 4 ( 1 (( 2 9 *"* "4 " 4-

5 + *, ' ( + " 4' " '+ "

*

' "

' H=3 -2 <=3=' <=32 # " ( '4

- <HH=& -

*"* ( +" > "* " C C

' !"

(

4

$<& #

B

*

J

5# & + A2 A #& C 0 $

A

#& 3(

"" * -%

+4 ) ' =3

+

- 2 . ' .1= - #

- <HH2&#

*

-5-

+

" "

% ))' =.

- 2 <=12' <=10 # " "(

- <H.1&&

B * *"* 3 '

. 2 J $2 13.' 102 # ( )4 $( # I " ( * " " *

'.

- 2 <<30' <<03 #

- 2==0&#

- <HH && ( 4 "C * ( + ( B ," , C -% ' .0 +" ' K 5 2 )2 '1 , - 2 3H1' 3HH # C -% -

) '5 "# &$

- <HH<&& " 4' " "4 +

+ # ( - <HH=&$ & I B ( (+ + H &- $ # < & ' #( # H <&< & $ / -% 6 " " *

-

- 2 H 1' H12

+ 'J ( * " +" -5 % J C "# &$ * 6 ( 4

" 4

+

**+ " , ,

<<00: # 0$ " +" ,+ & +

(

# "

& C -% ' <2 -

' L03 " <<0

+" '7

- 2 2 .' 2 <

B

4 -' H =

> - 2 <=1 ' <=.=#

4 -/

( -

-6-

<==1& $ 2 <0 & / B" + + 4 , + & ( * '

B + + " (

+ (

-%

-# '

-

'.

-2

4 "

*

( +

, ,+ " 4+ (( , "* " 4 '

' ( ( 4 *#

+ (" " * " +"* + + 4 + ( 1

+"* (

( -6 "-

(

2 '. -2 <<0 # $ 11' 21H# - <H.=&& I 6' " . < <3 : 13 < 9 <31( , ", "+ ' , 4 / / ( $ + 4' 4B -% +" " C K * ( "4 "/ ' " 5 + * ( !4 *4 * " + '.

)

" " 7 ' 3H=

-2

((

C *( ( 5 ' +*" + "/ <<0." 4' " 5 ' C ( " +9 9 $ "E "/ 4 9 +"* + 4 " " " * 4 * (' * ' * (

- 2 <<30# >' 4 + ( 9 "% * 4

- 2==0& 6 -

( (' 4 " (

-7-

- #( *

& +4 "( , '4 4 " +, "$ I , > " " , , " ( E /* > M ( ' ( *" ! / " ' " /* " ( ( ! +"* ' !/ %#/* $ !/ B$% ( ( -% !"-5 ( %' & "

! / , ! $ " 6" ! -( " ' + " ' " ", $ " "

4 !4 " " -% I !

> *4 * 4 #& 2 ,

, -# (*

, 23& !* ( !

( " *

" , -# + +" ( ! /- # ( "( 4 2-&--B $% -) , " '4 " -5 -5 - 2A -6

*' 4 0A A 0 -I 2=-& ( * * * , 01-& !" " * (( " ! /' + " , ", " -#

-

(3 =# & & +# , (

! /6 ' !5 C +4 !5

"! " , "

" , "!

'

- 22: 3' 2 , 4 -. -

B$% -/ "'

!"-5 "'

- 64 "' " 4

!5 C + 4 + -

-8-

! B !" ( 4 "( ( ) '---5 % " .0 * , ! (" C " -% & '7 B + . " !' C '.

* (4 ( ) 9 -

( ' ( (4 C

4

4

-

*

+ - <<: 2- $ < C * ! * 4 ! - <04, ' " +" * ,+ * "# &$ + +" 6 ' +" "# &$ $+ "4 !" J (

!/

" "

)

-2

<<03# ( - <HH<&& 5 +" '% J -

- 2 3H1' 3HH # "( 4 ("' $ ' -2 "

4 "* "

"

C

<<0 # ( - 2 2 .' 2 < # H <&< &

) ' <2 9 + " -

5

C 4

4 + !4 !-

"

+"

" " B$% -/ ! /4

!/ !"-5 $ , -5 -A - 2==1&# 6 * , * - 2A '

4

- <<' !5

4 6 "! " 'H = '

"+

,

-%

(!"-5 -/

B$% - 2 <=1 ' <=.< #

-9-

4" 4 > " 4 "* " " $% ' 4 ! $ , !5 ! I " B ! ( " -5 -AI " , '4 , * " 5 + " ( * " +" ' ( &! ( ,

(5 " "4 * " " - 32: 3' 3 *( 4 -% I *' +4 $ * '

4 ' B"

,

," ( ( ' !4 4 (N

(4 4 " , - < : 1' < B$% 4 ( " * - 33' !4 " " -5 ! /' ) *%

B -/ !

B$% "* "

"-5 -

( ' (

, " , "+ B$% -5 ! >- 2.: H' 2 -

,

, /' 2.: H' 2 $% +5 +C " " B$% !"-5 ' A "" , -A6 +" B$% / -' ( -5

B -AI

B 4, ' !5

, !/ "! B$% " ' !"-5 -I ( B$% -

' /* !"-5

(

' -A !5

-10-

) 4 1 + '

9 K

B *

, "+ C 5 +"

>' ( ( - 2==.& ' "4 ' ( -

'4

'$ 4

" ! "-

(( ' H.H " '$ 6 *K "' " " '

- 2 0..#

(

-/ 6

++ "* ( 6 * 6 ( " ( " ,

> *" -

" ( 4 / +4 " ( + * 4 " 0H2"* " 4 ' * * (( C *( 4" " !5 ' !5 " 4 +

4

'(" : (' 44 + ,

'

*

-

+ 4

$ (

-% (5 , 8 , + ' K ' ( " 6 !, * * ) " " "+ , >5" > '$ "

-

* 4 , "+ , '4 4 * >-

" (

9

5

C "(

$ 4

+ -%

, -5 -

* - 2-

'

-11-

$

+

"4

"* 1

"

C ' 23 -3 011' 0H # * 4 - 2 <2 1' <21H: = # . +" ' " + " " 5C C (4 5 *"* - 2==.& +" -%

* , -# ( "

" -% 2 *+ 68 . , ' 4 + B -# $ * ! K7 " %& " + "! !" *"*, M (*L , +" (( (* " (* I 1 2 " * * 9

'H . K ( C 4 "

- 2==1&& K 4 (* +" +" A " " "

B * "> "4 ( 'H . -2 C

<21.: H& 1+" -' =3 , * 4 K - 2 .20' .3= # B 4 +" " , "* " !/ + 4 "+ " " + (4 4 C C -% -#

- <HH2& # &$ '

(

C *( "( ! " ( * B 4

$ " "4 4"' ) O.='===9

' '%

>" ' * K

"

!"-5 ( " ? @@G-

<<: : # & < , "( ,* (* , ( *, + 4

E 4 "( * "( " ' * * ,+ 4( , *"* '4 '

* 4 " "4 "'

>"

-12-

(( 6
-

"

K , " *, 4 4 " 4 " 4 , '*, " + (( C *( '

" <<: : # & L< ," "

" ( C -

((

C *(

66 6G4* ( " * ( # $ +& !%' " " (( ' ) *( '" " ' , ,' !5 "*

9; (

69 , +" ( "+ ' !" - - 6 - !G ' "+ !" "K ' "*" , "

' ) " ' 2=<=-

/
;6 ; 96 ; D /9 P / 6 6 9 ) 8

-13-