Atlantic Sounding Co., Inc. v. Vickers

Filing 84

ORDER denying 74 Motion for Summary Judgment.Signed by District Judge Halil S. Ozerden on 9/7/2010. (Brown, T.)

JMR Atlantic Sounding Co., Inc. v. Vickers

Doc. 84

$ % $

!"

# $ &

! "# & # 4 # $ #% 45. / / ,). ! ( &5 1 0' # 8 & # " 4 & *+(+ #& % && &% *++< # = & & 0 / / 5 5 # / # "/ 4 / "# $ #% 7& & % *< *++< % 0 $ = & # & % #8 '/ &(3 *+(+ 4 $ (3 *+(+0 (* / 8 " '9 #& 2 $ # 0 # 0 &% & # "# $ #% ': 7 (( *+(+ )3. ! 7 ( & $ / 1 " ; 4$ # #& 4 & '#% # () *+(+ ,-. ! /# # ( # 0 2& '& 4# "# & 6+. !0 ' ( # 4 &7 0 % 0 0 1 0 20 3) / $ '& !

Dockets.Justia.com

4 # $ < *+(+ "# 8$ # % % # # / &/ $ 5 #% 0 # >+. ! 7 ( $ #4 ?# && $

#% #

#

&& #

2 (( *+(+ )-. !0 ( # 7 & 0

&

@ #/ #0

7

&7 % & 7& 0

'#% # (< *+(+ % & & $

'#% # () *+(+ "# & "/ 4 $ *(

& 2

*+(+ 2 (A + /0 0 >

4

## 7 % %0 & & # & &5 & /

& #& = / 0 0 1 0 20 )B C*C 4B 0 ?# 4& 03

5 &2 # $

#

)B C*C 7 4B % $ & 7 # 000 = 4 # #

$

#

/

= # 4& = # 4&

+, 0"0 >6+ ><3B <<>C ( 0 # // D # 7 # % 0 % %8 &# #& &/ 4& 0 '& #% # %/ # % $ BC E* % EB C > & 5 # 7 5 E % / &% 8

#

# # &$ &$ B C7 #& & & # % AB C (

/

% & / 7

/D #

75

F = # 4&

# # &$ & #& )B C 4

F= # 4& 8 % & F& /8

-2-

&5 0

& $ 0 & ><*0

# = # 4&

4$ % & & $

# / # ()B C/ 5 4 %

4$ 4 4$ /& &

& #&& 0 #& % 0 >660

4 D # %8 % % / # = 3 *,3 *,6B # # & 0

#& $4

5 &2

#

&7 $

#

7

7

0 0 1 0 20 ()B C 40 # AB C ( ?# # # /D # =& / EB C/ > 0

&7 % # & & # &/ D # E BC (++ = #& % 7 / &C E 0 (<<,C 0 7 0 (<<+C 0 = / # % 4 % & $ % & 7 # & &% 0 %& 5 # & %4 $ 0 $ & & EB C * 5 &4& $ 0 '//8 =

0 *++-C # B = / ! 5 8 7 "! 7 4

((+ 0> *3> *3, B 3

<(< 0* *,> *,3 B 3 & 7

/ / 0 (<<-C 0 %7 # 4 $ "# $ #% # 0 % # 5 &0 & #$ &

*( 0> ((+6 ((+< B 3 # 5 /

&# $ = # 4& 8#

/ 5 #& $ & / 2 &

)3. ! ( # /

$%

7 #& 4 / D #

-3-

4$ /

$# & $ % # &

&$

/ 01 #

% 4&

4$

&% 7%

# %

#

& $

&% &0 #. . / # #& % &5 # = # 4& $ #% 7 & %& 5 # % & D # # & # #// % # / 5 #& $

# / %0 ' # =/ 7 / &% %

0 '& /D #

4D 7& & %

& / & 5 #%

"# & 09

0

& #

% 8 8

4 #& 4 0 $ "# $ #% 4$ ,
$

7

&

#

/ ## 0 0 1 0 20 3)

,-. ! (

& '#% # () *+(+

$ #& 4

"/

4

*+(+0

'
:1 " : ; '9 G : 91 "' " 1 "1 9 H

-4-