Atlantic Sounding Co., Inc. v. Vickers
Filing
99
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW Signed by District Judge Halil S. Ozerden on 2/24/2011 (wld)
-JMR Atlantic Sounding Co., Inc. v. Vickers
Doc. 99
!" $ %
# $
& '( ! ' # " # # * ( " # $ % %& & # # / 0 $24 -60 -7 . / # # 0 %+ #
7
"# , %%&
)# * . 12$ !( 2 3
%+
$ )# * * 9!( 2 # < ; %; 8; ?; " " " " " " " " )
+ %&&5 7
( , 88% , # %+ "
)# * %%& , 888 *
1 5: ";
"
#* "
7 7 7 7
) ' # " # " " " > # " 7
= + %&&5= = "# ' # ) # # "
=
@; " "
Dockets.Justia.com
1 A
B7 $ )# + %&&5 7
7
%6 8 # 8- 0 7 C6 " < " ' # # * " " 6 *
# #
9!( 2 # #0 # * * #
1 5: "; " * # 3
" * " * " " " " " # " " > # " "" " #* " D# # 6 1 # " " " " # # * " " ' # > # " # " " " * * # " " # " " " " " # # # " * " " * # > # * # " # # # #
(
A 1
#
6 #
56 & 7 " * *7 " A ) " 7 $ # # % " " D# * %& & "
# 5?6 0 7 * $ $ # 7 A * 7
$
% %& & "
#
# # #
6# ' A "
" " "
*
# " "
" # #
(#
* "
" 6 %6
#
# # " " " * # *9 * # #
> "
"
#
" "
*" " * " " "
" " * "
"
# " 3 <
*
9
" 9 E( EF $9 9
*
#
"
#
# *
" " * * " " * " 1 E($2 7 * "#
#
3 #
$
+ %&&5 7 * " > G 1 E($2 7 &< && # ' # # F 7 # 7 " " 7 # # " > A * * A# " * " "
* * " 7
3 #
" 1 E($2 * " ' #
*"
#
- * .
/ " 0 + %&&5 7 # " * 1 # (# " # " " 1 E($2 6 86 " " # " " # * " " 7
*
" 1 E($2 "
"
# " 7 " * 7
" " D# " " " 7 "#
G
" D#
*
" * " " D# " " # 7 7
* * # "
"
"# *
# " " # "
D# > I > * " # 7 " G #* D# " I " " " " " "
" *# "7 " 7 F# * 7 A ' # # # D# " I #*
8
-7 / . 0 ' # " " !> 16 J
%
* #
# " *
I #* " " "
?
"
" G #*
7
" I #*
%
" " # # " A D# " 7 * " 6
> "
H F# * " " " " 6 ?6
*
8
" D# " I #* * # " # " " "# " " D# #*
" " * *
*
?
" " " "# - "# 8%0 * * "
7
* #" K "
" 7
* "
"
# + %&&5 >
* < && 7 I > # " # *
" * " 7 " * " D# * 7 * I > * # " " * # # * "
#*
#" 7 7 * #
K
"
" # "" # " " " " " I " > " "# # "# 7 @< 8& E " #* #* " " " # C< && " " " F#
* " "
" > 7
#*
" 7 * "# "
"
"
#
9 >
*" # " 7 * )# 9 2 A " #
" 7 "" + %&&5 I #* # J %&&5 " "
+ %&&5 7 "# 2 2 " #
#
)# 7
% %&&5 # 7
L
"
"
6 @6
#*
( )#
" J %&&5
* * (
$
#* # * * " # "
8 %&&5 * #*
#
*
# 1
"
7 #* " " # * " " " " " # #* # %C %&&5 7 A 7 * # #
"( #" ( # I
" 1 # #* # " 7
$ )#
#* #
%
%&&5
5 %&&5 "
"# A
%? %&&5 7 # A ' # # * # " " * * I * 2 #
"
( 7 " " " A 2 "# "#
* * ( 1
#
*
#* %+ %&&5 # #* J %&&5 " #* # * #" " K " #*
( *
1 " # #* 7 # 7 $
" 2 ( 1 7 A "# " " #*
# ( $ ( % %&&5 7 #
"
"
6 # + %&&5 # ( A "
* *2
1" 7
"
6 C6
" ## *
#
*
$
@ %&&5 7 # * " " " * *2 " < &G &5 +G " ( * # ## # * A " " D#
" "
# (
" 1 ) # ) - 07 *" # " 7 " #* " !> 16 %+ 7 * *" " " " # &G @G " &5 * " " " A !> " %+
"
"
#* 2 "
%& &
# : &G 8 M &G @; " *
> # "
#
*
# #"
7 # " )#
A ( * " ( * " # ( 3 * L K ##
" 555 ) " " # 7
" ' #
" " # #* # ' # # ' # *
L K
%&&8 " #*
" !> 16 8+ ) # !> 16 8+ 2 * %&&C &6 8 7 7
"
#
D# *
# 7
A
6 J6
" !> 16 M 16 7 5 " !> 16 5 " " * 3 .> * # 7 " # # D# * " " " " ' # " * " # 7 D# " " * * "/ A " " " # ) # *
D# ? %&&5 #*
" " < # #
"
!> 16 5 7 " "# 9 ( # @ %& & 7 " * " 6 * * %&&5 7 "# " "# !> 16 8 6 +6 " " # " " # D# ) # J %& & - 0> " # " # 6 # 7 ( 3 * 6 6 " # " " " ' # 6> * 6> ' # * + "# " A ) # J %& & 7 ( " " A * !> 16 8J " %&6 % " <
#" K ' # 7 * " "# # "
" "
"
( D#
# # 7 " " " # %+ %&&5 A " # # # . 7
" %? %& & " / # " *
"
" * (
!> 16 85
$ 7
(
7 # "E # 2
"
"
*
*
"
" " F# #
%@ %& & 7 I1 " $E $9 3
&N "
%@ %& & # $E 3 $)* + -. / , " " " + -12* /. .2, . + 1 " 9 " # !> # * " > N * " " # " ' # ' # " " "
# ' "
" " #
0
3 /. 2/3/-2 3/, )* /,2* ,4 * . 36 7 2 3 5 # . 0 # * *
:
; 8+9 8 J@@ J@J : " @ 55?;:
:# ;/ ; " "
6 56
' # " * # " # " > " # # #
* * #
"
D# " # " "
%+&9 8 ?C ?C+: " @ %&&%; " * A " # O? @&&&& # " $ " O J J+J ++ # " ) # * " > : " @ # %&& ; " " > # # " " " " J %& & O%C? J # # # " # " " > > # " " " %?+9 8 . " A / " 85 ?& # # " + %&&5 # K 7 " O% 5 J # " " # " * > > " 7 " "" " > + %&&5< ; O8 8 % 8 2 = 8; O885&J !> 16 8% " * * * ' # 7 E " " " I = # ?; * " " " #
= %; O?JJ +@
* *2
# "
6 &6
! " . > #
"
# $ % "
C&? 9 % 85C ?&&: " @ " # ( # # #
5J5; : " # # 7 " # # 7 "# " " "
;
# '
/
) # * 7 " A #
J %& & "#
"
" # " " " # 7 A # # # 5J@; = ' % " # * D# > # " # # "
" " " # ( # " " " " 7 .
" > / .# /
"
A #
# # " " " (
"
" #
*
# " % & % # * # * # * 6 6 $ #" " " " " 7 * # "# ! %+% 9 # @ 9 % J8@ J8J : " @ @J8 @J@ : ( 3 ! 5?+; 5C+; =
C59 % C C? : 8
* "
(
85C 9 % @?J @?5 : " @ # " " < ;" : 6 > @?+6 ?5 " " " D# # " " " # # -12* 8 29)2+ : * 3/-. /+ + . 7 D# # # " D# " < ; <= # " 7 # " " "
5C+;
"
=: " %; " " ' # " # " = : 8;
" " ""
A
"
#
#
"
7 "
!> J
" " + %&&5 # ) # # "
#
*
J %& & 9 *
" 7
A " # # 9!( 2
7
1
2#
2>* 2/. 2+ 3. /+ . . ?2 )* I . * " # * " 6 " " 6 * * * * * 6 6 # " " " N * D# # " # < * # 6 %6 # " #" * " =
;= #
; " (= > * * > ;= " # " ; " != . 9!( 2 2#
7
*
" * # * # " * " " # = #
> = #
*
*
# *
# "
1
:; :; D# # " 7 A * " A "# 7 $E 3 " " ' * # + %&&5 7 " " # " J %& & " " # 7 ' # " " # " # " " > " # " $E # " " " # " # " # " # " # 7 A D# " * 2# " :; " "
(#
* "
#
#
#
"
9 " " #
" "
#
$
%&&5 @
" ) #
#
@
"
" 6 86
"
>
#
) #
%& &
# "
* # #* " * " " # "# (
7
A *
>
" ' * #
# "
A * )# * 9
(
7
A 7
# A
6
A
2# $ " " ' * # " # ) " " 7
"
1 " # " 7 A 6
#
* #
' #
+ %&&5 $ " # 6 "
" # " # 6
' * # "#
7
A
$ "# ' * # # # " 9!( 2
7
" " #
7
A D#
1 @+ " " %? " 9 # %&
$
33 3!4 E $P!2(!E E !( ! ( 2 ) (F!
6 ?6
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?