Schloemer

Filing 24

MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER AFFIRMING IN PART AND VACATING IN PART THE NOVEMBER 5, 2010, ORDER [1-4] AND JUDGMENT [1-5] OF THE UNITED STATES BANKRUPTCY COURT AND DISMISSING BANKRUPTCY APPEAL IN CIVIL NO. 1:10cv566. Signed by District Judge Halil S. Ozerden on 9/20/2011 (wld)

!

"

#
#
#

'

!" #
"(

$

$%

)$ ' ! ,
#' " %
&

)
#$

&'
"
!

'
*

+ "(

&$)

2"(

'
"

&"( '"
!,

!

( & *$

!

%

2' *
2)

) ' "(
!
* 0&*1
)

3

' * " '$
"-

*

* 0&*1
)
'
"

*

'
*

"(

&

*$

"-

" *
!

2 '
"

* "( '

+! "(

'
"!

(

) '

" * " "
(

!

/ 2"(

+

/ 2"(

5 6 78 9

4

! "( '

* 2 '"( '

' '- ./
*

(

&"( ' 3 "' " 2

$' 2 *

' ()

*

' '- ./
*

&' 2 '"(
"

%&
%
$
*

2 %
&
*'"
"

2"(

1

&' 2 * "( " "(
"

" * " "
* "( " "(

#' " %
&

)$ '
&'
"

* #" *
! ( & *$ * )

*

(

&' +
"

**'

"(

*" *

!

=!

'"
$

3

) $ ',,! ,

" '*

0&*1
)

) ' 1 $ "+
'

" 23

&'
"

( 0&*1
)
1 )
'

"8 1 )
? '

2 * 5 ""
*

*&

" +( "( '(

$ 1"

(

=! &' &
) "

2

) '"

&

2 ! "( % - ' /
+

' '- ./
*
"

'

*

. : 7:! ,
#' " %
&

&'
"

* 0&*1
)

) '
!

'
"

"(

(
&' ' " ( '
"
" 2 ' &'
2"(
!
. : 7:! ,

/
!

$%

" )$ '

%'

'" ' C )
% &*1
*

( ' *
1

%'
)

.!

7! "( $ #' " %
&

*

" ( *$

#'

"

1 " *
'

,

"&' 2

6= ! " D 8

"" )

*+

( ' $ & *'
1

*& " * "'

)$ ' ! ,

*!

1 )
'

%'
!

&1 " ,! ,
&

% ' &1
("

:

1 "(

*

'
"%

B =,=

%'

!

!*

A &" *

""

' - '/
+

;<.

"-

& "%
!

*3

5'

* $" & * ' #
"

*

*

"!

#' " %
&

& * '"( ,

"

(

* "" (

&' 2
"

$ 32 '
2

" '= 2"(

?
+( "( ' '
"

!

'
%

' ' " * $% ' 2 '

1 )
'
'
"

(

"@! +( ( $ "(
9

' ( =! ,
'

& +

"

*#

' >'
'

%

& *' (

( '
1
+

:! "(

' '
*

"
"

' 2
"

%)
!

"

! '

B ,:8 9 9@
8
3
!,

!,
!

*

9

" '* "

)$ ' ! ,
' ' "(
* !

#' " %
&

% "(

&' ( * "( " " +
"

'
"
2"( ( " ' 2"(
%
+( ( '
' ) ' *"
* ' *&' ( " ' 2"(
%
!
; < . 6= 8 #' 3
!,
9

,

&

' " *" '
%
)

*

( '
1

&' &

+( "( '

*

(

1 & * "( " ( '
'
'% $ 2 ' "(

:

.

3

1"

* 1

*+ '

" "+

2 '*
' '
* !

6= ! " D ,

*
F

(
5

(

"$

&

"( %

( ' *
1
"

*

2 ''

2'

3

4

"( '

&' *
'
,

+ 2"(

(

2

#' " %
&

) '
E
,89

" *2 )
'
A "

' * ) "" ' +( ( + '

" "(
&

" ( + "(

* $" + ' "( ' 2 ' *
*

&' '+ ' '
"!
'

%'
E "
' 'C
&*
,

&" * ) '"

""

= ,!

* '

;<.

* 1 ! &' &

"( 5

* $" + ' A

) '( *

&'
"

"

!

,

#' " %
&

0&*1
)

* ' ' '
%

(

!

&* * "( " "(

$ #' " %
&

'

&" * ) '"

" " B ,:8 9 9
8 !

% * $" + * ( '
&'
"

%*

5

"
'"

) '

+

+

' " ' ' 2 &1
%
("
"
2"( * "'

) '
2"(

''
+ 2
+ 2"(
G

%'
E "
2 '*
' " ' ' 2+
%
" $% " '
"+ *+ "(
"
2 ' '2 "
*H ' " ' ' " "
2 " "
&' ' ' 2
" *
* '
*H' ) % & '
!
" *)
"
! ) # 1 ' &"
" "
&'
"
' ' " & * '"(
* "' G
%'
E )
"' ' %
G
(
"( '

#' " %
&
&"
2

"+

' ) "&' !

&' ' *
" '
%'
E
"

,

"'

*

" % 1 "( " "
" )
"G

# 1

&'
"

"&

"

* 1

(
#' " % &'
&
"E ' '
*
*
* ( ) '
E
"
2 ' &) ) '
%
0&*1
) "! &' & " "
3
F 5
* 3
4 5 =
!
1 & * "( " "
'
+
"2 *
)
+ "(
2' <
)
& =
2"(
" * " "
#' " % &' 2 '"(
&
"
' '
"(
* &"( ' 3 "' " 2
" 2 "( '
&'
*
*
%'
E
"
" "'#
) " $ *&
"( *
2 ( ) '
E
"
! *
*
*(
"
2'
"
1 & * "( " ( 2 * "
'
) % + "(
3
4 5
7 89 9 9 (
8 8
'
& 1 '
" "
&
"(

:

(
(

#' " % &' ' * 2 * 1 "( "
&
" '
) '+ ' * ( ' * $ #' " %
1
&
G

% '+
) '
( ) '
G
=

(
"

6

) "" ' 2 +
* 1
G

(
#' " % &' ' *
&
" '
A "
2 %' $ 1"
E
* ( ' G
1

(
" "
'
,

( ' 1 ' "
1 &

* $ 1"

"

1 "( "

%'
E

'
&

#' " % &' ' * 2 * 1 "( "
&
" '
""
" $ ( "(
A "
2(
#' " % &' ' *
&
" '
&'
"
* 1
*
* 1G

&

%' " ")
E
$ 1"
"

%+
( ) '
G

1 ' &) " 2 ) ( ) '
1
'
E
1
" ( ' "(
" " 2* '

#' " % &' $& * " * ' "
&
"
I& "
1 ( ) '
&'
"
' 1"
*
1 E
&
% 2 '* " 1 ( 1
&
$ "+
B ,:8 9 9 * 8 9 9* $"
B
8
8
* "( '
& 1 "( "
( ) ' '
" *
*
2 &
' $ 1"
"
'- "
,/

! "(

&

&' +
"

**'

(

) '
E

"( ) " 1 "( '

"

"

2' '
'

* 2

'" %

!
(

&' C * "
"J &'

,6

'*

B

* * $% ,6

:

2"(

'
& 1 "( " ( ) '( * " '
"(
" ( '
' '" A ) " "( ) 2 )
*
'

(

"

'

"

#' " % &' ' * '
&
" '
& 1 "( " ( ) '$ ' "(
2 '
1 A "
2 ) * ( ' $% '
'
1
*'
"
2 '*
' " ' ' 22 * $%
%
%'
G

(
&2
2

'

+ *" *

#' " % &' ' *
&
" '
"
)
"
' '

(
$&'
*
*

7

'%

%' $ 1"
E

B

- ( * "' "
"/

6: ? (
;

68 9 '

*

&'
"

2"(

'

" *

"

&"( '"% " (

+ 1 $ #' " %
&

' &(

&' *
"E

"( "
" * " "

(

.

(

C * "
&'

" (

'

K'
"

'

* 1 * "' "
!E

* ' 2'
*

+1

!7 .

$
K

#

'

&$ "

'

*

,!

: . 8 "(

'1
(" '

* * $%

"&'

* 8 8* " 2 1
09
%

"(

! 6,

'
'

( ' $ "% 2 ' & '* $"
1
"

&' .
"

2' *
2)
'

%

'

"(

"(
* 1 "(
!

&*

* / '-/

*2

" *

E
@

' 76=9 3
9

"

"( " "( ) "" '

* 1 *" '
)

"!

"( "

" A 2 $ #' " %
"
&

* 1

* $C "

"(

* 1

#' " %
&

&'
"

'

'

,* 7 ! 7=8 "(

'

*
@ " ##

? '

"(

"' ' ! "(
%
" "&"

$

"

&'
"

&' - /
"

' 77,9

&* '

" "(

"(

&'
"E ' '+
*

2* '

"

) ' $C "
E
" *

"

' %

8 " 1
I&

=8 8 89
$9,9
*

"

* 1 "( " $% "
"

(

,*

&' 2 "
" &

*$%
"

B
B
2

( ' 9 (
1

* "(

) "" '

&' '
"

+ "(

'

' & " %
#'
'% $ 2 ' "(

#' " %
&

&'
"E

8 92 ) 2
'
C ) " ! ' ' ! ** ' G ,92 ) " ' &" ' ' '
&*1
*
8 '
% *
*
* '
& *& * ' "
, 8 2" "
*9
'
1 '' *& 1"( " )
' * ' 2 ' *"
'
"
, 2 & ( " " G *8 + "(
:9
2"(
&'
"!
2 ) "( ' " ' &" ' ' '
'
% *
** ' G *! + "(
2"(
&' 2 )
"! '
" ' &" ' ' '
% *
* * ' ! 2$ #' " % C
&
&*1
" '*
*
'
* 1 ' 2 ' *" "( $ #' " %C
'
&
&*1 & * ' "
= 2
"( " "
& * ' "(
&$ "
(
$ " #
% " "( * "' " &' 2 ' "(
"
C
&*
* "' " +( ( "( $ #' " % C
&
&*1
' 1
,6

B
.

68 9

(
&'
"
" ' & * * $% ( ) ' ' &) " "( " "( ) "" '
E 1
"
' '% $ 2 ' "(
&' $ * &
"
"(
+ 2"(
* "'
(
+ 2"(
* "'
$
%?
*&' 1 "(
* % 2
! *
'" "
2'
' A)
"
2* * * &
"( ' ' ) * '
&$ I& "
@
!
! 7:7 ,* , =! , . 8 "( ' 77 98 ) (
'1
9 (
&' 2 ' "(
" 2)
#' " % &' * " '
&
"E
)
"
"( " "( ' ) * 2"(
' E ' '
"
" "( " "
&'
"
'" * ' ' '
%
* 1
"$ * 1
"(
&'
" "(
!,
; < . 6= ! " D

2 * 1

22 " 2 '

' ' '
' !

:*,=.! ,=7 6 8 "(

&'
*

"

8
?

$% * $" '"
"&' 2

&

2 +

! ,.

9

25' 2

5' '"
" 2,

',

* "

)

*)

5 5 @!
9
2' '
)

)

" & * '"(

%)
!

#' " % $&
&

B ,:8 9 9 A
8
&

"

+( ( '
! ' &

5'

"

" *2 ) *
'

& *' *

( ' * $"
1

' * '

'
"

&) '
+ *

*+ '

!

"(

=! ,

'*
"(
&' 2 * "( " "(
"
* "' $ ' "(
2 ) "(
'
&' '
"E
+
(
* "'
"
%$ '
1 '
"%
" "
&'
"
2 )
'
# 1 +( " ) & " "
" '
+ 2 2
" "
&' C ) "
" &*1
2* '
* "' " &'
"
%
%
! :
:* =, ! =,78 "( '
,
9
( ) ' '&
1
% "( "
%' *
E
'" ' C ) " "
% &*1
" '
"+ *
+ "(
* 1 " "
&' '
"
* 1 " "( " (
!
# 1'
+ 2 2
" "
&'
"
C ) " ; ( "(
&*1
#' " % &'
&
"E ' '- ./*
*
" A
" % **'
( ) '
E
' &) "! "(
1
&' 2 '
" 2) " )
"*
2"(
' &) "
1
% "( &1
!
( ( ) ' ' & "( " "(
1
#' " % &' ' * $% " % 1
&
" '
"( " "
&' '
"
* 1 ! "(
#' " % &'
&
"E
)$ ' ! ,
! ' '- ./
*
"
"(
"
*
"(
&' ' &"
"E
2"(
= ! "(
&' 2 * "(
"
" 2 ' ') " " "( " )
'
5'

5 5 ! B ,:8 9 9 A
8

" *2 ) *
'

( '
1

* $" + *

"
& ! 2' '
)
& ! ' ( * 2"( * $" ' 2 ' ) % " ! )
!
2' ' &
!
' 2 &(
"
&
' ( *!
"
+ "(
1 ) "! * ' * ' ! ' ' '
'
"% "" ) " 1 ) "! $&"
'
A " "( ">
"

"
'"
" " "(

DDD
89

& ( * $"
&
' &
"
)
"

B ,:8 9 98
8 ,
B ,:8 9 9 '
8 !
1 "(

&*
$ "% *
&(
$ "%
! ' &
'
"
9 (
1 1
&

5 5
'

1 " *
"& %

)
"(

** * "( " ' ? )
) *
5 5 B ,:8 9 9
8

% )
!
"
"&' 2 ) )

"

&
&

'
%
!

' $ 1 " @"
"
!.
7 6!

;<

=,

! "D 8

* $" ') % 2
3

4

* $" A "

)
5 .

=8 9 "
!

A

. , 6. ! ,

6 ! 6 78
"

2 ) *
'

A "

2 * $"

' 2+( "( '"(
: =
+(
*

&' "( "
"
*'

"(

"(

2 ' 2
!

' * " '$
2"(

7,, 8 #' 3 ' ,
8 . 9' "
"(
2 ) %)
!
"
* 1 " * -/@
5 5 B ,:8 9 9
8

#' ; 3

*
'
"

'

!

+!

(

"(

# 1" (

A "

(

2 '

1

:,! :. 8

"(

"&' 2

2

:. ! :.=8

@
9

,!

K $"E9
* @G

#'

)

3

1 "(
%
!

" 1 "( $&'
*

2

"

" 2 '* 2 * "
2

' *" '

1 "( "

& * 'B ,:8 9 9 2 '
8

" 2 ' &'

! ,.:

" "' ! "(

8

! ,=

'
$&'
*

""

( ' & * 'B ,:
1

I& "

'
"9 " ) "" '

* 2 * "! "(

2 '

.98 ' * " '$ ' "( $&'
*

2' "
2)

" 6 7G
"

" *2 ) *
'

* "( " "( * $"

' *" '

' *" ' '

( ' $ "% 2 * $" &' &
1

,.7! " D
.

0,

"(

( ' $ ' "( $&'
1
*

'

A

( ' & * 'B ,:9
1
G

! ' &

"( '

' * " '+( $ ' "( $&'
*

;<

#' 3

76:98 ' * " '(

"

"( *

9 ;(

"(' ( * ) "" '"( " "( ' $

(

)

"(

"( "%

98B ,: ' I& '
?

: =

' ( ,7! ,

"" *" '
)

*"( " "
!

,

#' 3 F"

!

#' ; 3 ;
* $" A

&' 1
" '

) '$ ' "( $&'
*

77798
?

" *2 )
'

+ "( "(
2 '

#' " %
&

1 $%

2 * $" + *

" & " * "( "

% '( * ' *%

9

" 2 *)

% 2(

( *2 "
2? ) "
*
&
' $ 1" @
"
"
"
* 2 ' 'B ,:8 9 9 "( " * $" $ ? "(
)
8 !
! ' &
' ? "( &" ' 1 ' " +( "( ' & ( * $"
"!@ +
*
A'
"( ' ' ( '
"%
" " "(
#' " % &' '
&
"E
&

=

B
"&'
%
'

$ 1"

& * '"(

1 )
'

+ ' 2

*

&" * ) '"

*

(

2"'

(

) '* *
"
!

* $"

$ &"

#' " %
&

'"(

'1 ' "
*

!,
(

(*

;<.

) 'I& "

&" * ) '"

6= ! " D 7
*

) & "

%' " ")
E

&' 2 & * "( " "(
"

* $"

"

+ *! 2
% "(
!

* &)

% 2"( *
#' " %
&

"

&

% '*&' 1 "(

" " " 2 ! $&" &$) "" * 2 '
%
"% 1 8 * &)
(" .69

(

A "

"

"

7
"

"

( + *

&" * ) '"

*
"( '"(

* $"

; "(

&' 2 & * "( "
"

%' " ") %
E
' * $ % " $ ( * "( " 2 '
' "% 2'
!
( + & + ' 2 % $ 1"
"( " ' )
*" $
* ( ) '
' 1 ' 1"(
*
*
A
! "( F
3 $"! '"( ' * " '
*3 $"
'
' ( " " ) %* * " " $ ( "( A "
!
2 "&* " <
2 ' +( ( ( ) ' ' )
*'
$
"( '
" ' ' 2'
*!
A)
! "
"' %
$ "( " "( "&* " <
( *$
* 2' *
'
' 2'
1
$ &
2 ( ) ' ( "(
E
*"
%
!
%'
*) "" * "( " (
"
*
% 1 "( < 2
&'
3 $"! $&" "(
$ 1"
"
% A " * %
1
% '( * 2
$ 1"
"
( ) ' +( ( ( ) '2 * " '
!
( ' "(
"!
A "

2

#' " %
&

% 2"( *

&' 2 & * "( "
"

&" * ) '"

(

) '( *

* $"

" '

"(

"

%
? $ #' " %
&
&' (
"

K *2 "
"(

! ,.
,

2 '

"

* 2'
)

22 " ) % $ '
"

"( "

(

) ' '&
1

" $ ( "(
'
*

*

"

!

"( " "(

A "
* 1"

' *

) " # (

:* " ,=7 6 8 " 1
I&

79 ; (
9

( **

&' 2 * 1
"E

#' " %
&

2 * $"! ( *
( + "(
6

A "

% 2"( '
$

) * E
@

:* .=:! .6 8 "(
&' ' *
" '
"
2

" "(

+ 1

'

2 * 1 "( "
&' "
"

% * $" + * " ( '

%

*&

"(

"' ! "(

&'
"

) " # (

+
6

% "( " "

"

"

"

"( " "(

698

*'
!

) ' "

"( 2 ' 1

&" "

* +( "

"

*

"

*

!(

9

(

#' " %
&

"

&'
"

) '*

&' 2
"

*"

2 * $"

' 2"(
"

,!

* " ' ' &)
% 1

"

A "

' % ( '$&'
'
*

:*

"( $ #' " %
&

* "(

'*

"

&* "( " "(

*"

* '*
2

*

' 2( '
"

" $ ( * "(

&'
"
) '2

&

&

"( "

&' ( & * (
"

"+

(

&"( '"%

"

! :

"( ' A

*

" * "

* 2'
)

" "(

&* 1 "( "

' & '
"

1 "(
!
(

'

:* " ,=7 6

#' " %
&

' " * &"( '"%

% 1

2 * 1 "( "

*

1( '
!

* ' '( + " + & * (
!
(

"(

! ,.

+( ' ( '$' 2

" * " 2 +( "
%

+

* I& " $' 2 1

',

' 2 *"
&

!

2 + "( "( ? 2 "
"
*

" * $% I& "

* *& "
8 "(

'
"

) * @

) '
E

2' "
)

2"(
"

$

(

$

&$)

*&

#' " %
&
2 ( + 1 "(

&'
"

'% ' *
'

A "

2

%

* 1 * $"
;(

$% "(

'

'+ ' "
"(

"(

#' " %
&

*'

2"(

+ *! "
*

( ' *
1

&' * " '
"
)
*

"( "

* "( "
% 2"( *

&* * "( " "(
% ' $ #' " %
E
&

*

(

) '( *
&" * ) '"

&" * ) '"

"

" $ ( *

* $"

A " *

* $" + '
!,

;<.

6= !

; ( "(
#' " % &' ) * ' 2 '
&
"
"
" " ) " ) * $% ( ) '
' ' " "
&' '
"
* 1 "(
!
&'
"
" % "( "! $ *
"( ' ' "(
*!
#' " % &' ' * "( " " ) " ) # 1 " * " '
&
"
)
"

7

"D ,

( C * "
&'

' I& ' )

" 2"(

' % ' I& ' )
E

+ '
*

* $"

+ 1
!

#' 3

0&*1
)

"-

+ ' *

9

( ' *
1

"(

"( 2 ' 1

* 0&*1
)

"-

'
"

"( %

(

&* * "(

"( ''

/ 2"(

* "( I& "

2"( '

#' " %
&

&'
"E ' '- ./
*

&" * * $"

' '- ./
*

"

&

" "'
"-

/2

"

&' 2 * "( " "(
"

)$ ' ! ,

&' ( & * $
"

2' *
2)

* 0&*1
)

"-

" * " "(

/ '

( ' *
1

*

0&*1
)

*

' & '
"

" * $" + ' *

, 7! ,=7

( % '

!

' '
*

'
"!

*

A
"

" "( "

2' *
2)

"
#

%
)$ ' ! ,

!

' '- ./
*

* 0&*1
)

"( "!

"-

/ 2"(

#' " %
&

(

! "(

' '- ./
*

&' '
"
0&*1
)

( ' @
1

! ::

"(

'

&' 2 & * "( " "( '
"

#' " %
&

' '- ./
*

%
( '

" *

"( ! "( K

"

" "(

1 "(
!

A "

*!

&* "( " "( *

&' ) & " $
"

! B ,G

K $"E *
*
"

#' " %
&

% ' $ #' " % "(
E
&
!

*&

" *

A
"

/ & *$ ' * "

#' " %
&

- ./

2 '* " '
)
"(

"( ' A "

' %' )

'%
@

(. 6
!

* 1 &(

"(

"'

"'

:98 " 1

1

&
'

"'

,

,

$ ) "

" .,

( ' $ "% +
1

8

(

'
'
"

( ' $ "% '
1

"+

!: :

$

*

) " * $% "( ?

" "&"

. ! ., 8 3

,.! : 8 7=.9 ? /
9 "'

&'
"

" * " "

!: :

$

22 * '

"-

/ '

" *" "(

A
"

" "( % *

( ' "(
1

A "

" " *

"! *

*

&" *

) '"

* $" !

* 2' *
2)

"( ''

"

%

* #" *

#

"( "!

%

"

%

* 1

%

#

"( "! "(

'

!

!

( ' $%
#

! "(

"( ,

<<

"(

*% 2

< L
3

M
3

" )$ ' ,
!

3
0 3N