Beasley v. Sutton et al

Filing 25

MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER granting 14 Motion to Remand to State Court. A certified copy of this order shall be immediately mailed by the Clerk of this Court to the clerk of the state court pursuant to 28 U.S.C. 1447(c). Signed by Chief District Judge Louis Guirola, Jr. on 4/10/2012 (wld)

!"
#

$

!"
$

"

!

#

!

$&

%

$
'

( ) *

)!

+

*

+

!

,)

.! $//0 1+
7
$6
: 3

$! 2+3 4

+
7

!

-

1-

!) 9

7

! 28 +

+

$/! $//;!

5, 6

1+

<

+
)

! 2+3 4
&! 2+3 4

$,
5, 6

#

!)
! 28

!

1! 2+3 4

$,
$6

+

!
7

)
= >

>$

7

=

)

1+

5, 6

&! 2+3 4

?
>&
1

"

, @ ) ( !
56

#
6A

>5

4

C

!
1

7
>B//!///

9

(

*)
!

!

* D

1

E# 7

! 28 #, 2+3
$!

*

)

1# 7

! 28 #, 2+3 4
$!

$,
$6

> //!///

*
8
7

: :
+

!

(
(

&! 2+3 4

5! $/ !
!

>5

1

6

*

!

1+

5, 6
)

*

+

) *

+

1-

7

*
6
,
$,

@

*

7
>$

( *
7
7) )

,
1

*

56

$,
$6

*(

*

!
1

(

!

!
>
! 28 ! 2+3 4
,

!

)
(
$,
$6

"

!

#

* *

F

!

!

!

*

!

!

8

+

!

!*

*

G

?

(

* *

*
!

*

, (

!

A
(

G

!)

G

)

% &'
(&)' (*
!")'
A

) )

*

G

G

!
*

C 6
1

1$6
, (

! & 3 & &/&! &/;15

D
+

$//56 <

*)

*
+

, (

!

C
)
(

& 3&

*

,

D

!

&/;

A
(

(

G
*

!

( *
D

(
*

*
!)

)

)

(
7

)
!

(

!) C
(
(
*

(

<
(

9

*
&/;,
/01?

*

! ..&3 $ 5 5! 5 015

0; 6 C
6 A

(
,
&,

!

+

D
1?

! 5/03 & ..5! ..015

*

!&

3&

*
3&

5;! . 15
G

+

H

+

$//B6

$//&6 C
6 A
(

7
D

! 5/0

..0
A

)

)!

(

*

$1 6 ,
1.6

*

!C 9 *

)
) *

,

! &;53 & 5.;! 5B&15

+

D

$// 6 @ ) ( !

)

)

G

*
3&

5B&,
B

C

?

,

D

7

! &;53 &
!

(

+

!
(

(
!

*

?

+

+
A

(

5B&,
B
?

(

+

! &;5

?
)

)

)

?

+,* ./ 0 (&&)/
- ) A
2?

+

8
*

F
C

*

)
!

,,

!

)

)
*

#

!)
G )
) D!
$///6

)
! BB;

$
?

)

$

)
1I561

&!

"
C
A
)
D

)
!0 $

$ 0B;! 0;$1I $61

?

$//56

C

4

!

8
!

**
!

!

D
%

' ! 0&;

&&
?

$ ;00! 0/&, 1
/

?
E1$6

+

$//.6 C
A

1 6

*

E

G

*
!; B

!

D

$ 5B;! 5;&1I 561

!

$//$6

C
2?

)
)
(

1&6

)

)

(

9

)

!H

*

(
*

)
! 00.

$
&

!

0

$

7 (
D

B.! ; 1I $&61

$ $/ ! $/B1

+

8

(

9
!

)*

*

*
C

*

0; 6
6
!

?

$//;61

(

!
*

*

*

D 1)

7
?

,
5,

$/! 2+3 4

(

$$6 @ ) ( !
!

)

!

*

3

!

7
C

+

9

*

!

*

D

( !

>B//!///!

> //!///!
)

!

!

*

)

8

!
*
*
J

* *
!
A

+

* J

?

8

@ ) ( !
(

(

+

*

*

*
C

H
!

(
(

(

*

7A

(
(

(
A

!

(

D

! BB3 & &$/15

# +
#

+

+

$//B6

(

+

G

G

*
(

! 5&&3 & &$ ! &$B15

-

)
+

,

*

$//;6

!

*

+

(
,
.,

?

!

+

)

)

G

*
$
?
$;'

B1 6

+ K

7

*

+

G

( *

+

!

7

.

3

*

+

?

! 5 .'

!

*

'

&$!

1$//56

7

*
#

#
A

#
$;'

+ K
#

9

(

#

#

B1 6
#
+
$;'

+ K

9

+

B1 6
/

! $/ $

s/
!%
+
,
B,

'

(

-

% *