Greenwood v. King et al
Filing
110
MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER denying 109 Motion for Judgment NOV; denying 109 Motion for New Trial. Signed by District Judge Keith Starrett on 4/12/11 (scp)
<![CDATA[
This case involves an inmate’s Section 1983 claim for use of excessive force. For the reasons
stated below, the Court denies Plaintiff’s Motion for Judgment Notwithstanding the Verdict or New
Trial [109].
!
"
(
#
(
$ %&
)
#
*
,
-
#
+
(
$ /&
)
#
.
*
#
2
'
1
+
'
)
+
)
0
"
1
(
*
)
-(
+
+ )
)
*
2
$ 3&
.
4
(
'(
)
35
6
)
)
7
)
)
(
*
)
7
+ ((
)
8
0
3 /
4
%:
%/ ;
<
:< :: ;
<
330= ;
>
33 = 2
=
(
)
:9
9
*
(
+
*
+
?
)
( +
+ @
$&
7
7 $
(
)
$
(
)
)
&
>
&
* +
;>
+
+)
+
A
(
*
7
:33
:0
)
%: ;
<
3/9= ;
=
=
62 ( )
A
+
A
)
(
+
)
+ A
+
;
<
<= ;
$ %
+
)
( (
+
?; =
7
$
"
8!
)
;
<
9 %0< %<
330=
=
(
@
4
(
7
(
+ ;=
;
9=
0
" #
9 <3% :
*
@
+
7
*
2
7
*
!
% "
"
)
#
$
%
# '
1 A
( *
5
B 7
(
7+
' 2
A(
$
30&
$
39&
+
'
#
6
7+
8'(
+
+
9<<
;
<
&
9 /:: /%/ ;
<
33:= 2
=
( (
+
9= ;
>
6
& ' ' %3
$
7
8
3%%=
C
(
+
:%3
6
(
%
&
" <<%
<90 <93 ;
<
(
%;
<
<03
(
7
D
*
9 3:9 3%0 ;
<
/= ;
>
3/<= 2
=
(
0%: 0/ ;
<
3/ =
7
)*
9 0 9 0 0
)
9
%%
+
+
7
+8
)
A
( (
+
( (
$
7
6
&
)
8E 4
+ :
(
7+
.
(
4
+
-
(
'
'(
9
3F
+
( (
+
)
(
?
( (
A
)
)
4
3
'(
)
+
+
2
2
+
7
A
>
2
*
)
+
'
$
7
(
7 *
#
(
) (
*
#
+
+
2
+
$
)
(
)
)
)
!
+
) +(
- ( )
+
7
(
7
( )
0
3/9
;=
;=
(
(
33 ;
<
+
33:=
%
,
(
(
*
(
(( +
09: G - :</ :3 3/ -
*
(
(
:
; 3%/= '
+ )
!
E4
+ )
!
(
(
2
$
3
3/9
4
4
%< 9
-
/ <: E ,
( )
) +(
+
!
+
( (
*
'
*
+
+
+
)
4
*
)
+
)
)
7
(
)
*
'
+F
+
F
)
)
*
*
2
) +
7
)
)
*
7 4
*
2
)
+
(
4
+
2
>
)
)
+
>
*
-
+
+
+
)
(
7
>
4
<
+
4
(
7+
2
*
4
>
2
*
2
+ )
2
)
+
)
7
*
)
2
+
+
)
7 )
(
B
)
*
) 7
)
)
*
+ )
B
+
4
A
=
(
+
(
+
&
)
E4
*
(
2
)
)
7
+
+7
*
@
+
)
4
7
)
7
)
*
7
+7 4
+
(
+
*
)
+
*
6@
(
8&
!
+
>
)
*
7
9/
$
(
+
'(( A 9%9 9/ ;
<
)
(
)
(
(
:
((
*
+
*
+ )
)
2
+
/
+
33%= ;
7
(
)
6
4
+8
*
A
= 2
+ 7
)
)
*
2
( )
+
*
(
>
F
) +
( +
*
)
*
)
7 )
1
"
-
, ,
+
4
2
7
9 90< 9< ;
<
'1
#
1
2
' #
G
$ 3&
H,
+
'(
s/ Keith Starrett
UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE
%
+
]]>
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?
