Ainsworth v. Cargotec USA Inc. et al

Filing 50

MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER denying 7 Motion to Dismiss for Lack of Jurisdiction. Counsel for all parties shall contact the Magistrate Judge within 3 days of the entry of this Order to schedule a Case Management Conference. Signed by District Judge Keith Starrett on 5/9/11 (scp)

!
" "# $%
&
# ( )
* $ $ ++
$'
'( ,
*
& &$
* ) &
.
"

'
,$
(
"
*
& & & &
"
*
"
*
+

#&

+

$87
7
+

&7
$87
&
9
&

& 02
/1 3

&

!"
$%&

)

#
# '

6

'

(

+
'

-

'

'
* '

#

'

&
(

34 3 3
/ 56

#
#

,'

## (
.

(

0

'

1
)

#

4

#

5 3) 1

,

'

23

#

#

.

6

#

-

5

#

#

-

3

1
5
(

0

3

#

'

!"

'
'
#

#

'

'

5

'
3

)

6#
'

5

3

0

)##
-

&
2*
7

#

#

#
-

7
(

-

'

7

#
8

'

- '4

'
'
!

/

% /!9 /9 $:

-

;;!&$0

!!/ /

9:

;/ $:

#

7

2
#

'

" % %
#

%

7

% 9>; 9 / $:

%%9 %=% $:

-

#

7
$:

#

$

/>>:&
&

#

4

#

4

/ / % / ! $:

#

/>>?&$

#

-

#

'

/>>/& *
&

'
2

-

#
==:

!

;9:& <
&

9;:

!

2

-

#

#
4

# $

#
!::

#

/

?/

?:

;9:&
&
)2

-

'

' 6

$ &
#

'

##
) '

7

@
.

:?=

#

A
)

% %9? %;9 $:

@

/>>;&

#

-

#

B
0

%

$/&
4

@
6

#

#

'

'#

'

#
'
#

'

-

'
##

'

7

7
133

)C C D %@ :! $/> >& .
%@

,

7

#

-

@

#

#

@
(

5

3

5

)##

-

##

#

7 '
##

0

=!/

&

A

7 '

% /?? /!>@ $:
!

## 3 #
#

'

/>>?&$

##

&

#

B

)"

'
#

#

-

#

#

3

#
3

'

#

3
'

1
#
(

@

#

%

7 '

##
0

B

7

/:/ 3

7
'

3

-

/ / / / ?$

;! & )

##

@
=

#
0

7 '
-

2(

'

@

#

0

#

#

#

BG &
$

' -

#

'

A

7

$/&

6

# '
:?=

%

%;9 $0

/>>9& A
&

'

$

#

? :

)

G

0

#

2G

=9> 5 3

'
4'

>/

>9@
>;

##

=!/

%
>! 3

!

%

#

>/? ;=

/ ;/ $ ;9!&
&

#

/> >&

(

#
#

7

E

B

F

7

'

/! $0

* " ? : % :!; :9= $:

#
#

/> >& 2(

#
%

.

%!= %!9 $:

4

4

% ?>/ ?>; $:

G
#

#

@

:/%

(#

'
3

#

%

7

'
'

'
:

(
0

6

-

F
#

' 2 "#

#

#

'

7

6

G

7

$

-

+

$ ;9:& '
A

#

*

$* $!
-

(

2 ##

=! 5 3 =?/ =!/

,
$
#

@

;:=

!
'

4#

>: 3
/

>?9

=!/

%

7

%

;;/&
&

#
A

4'

? :

$%&

%

:9: $

#
-

#

@ @

#

#

2 ##

#

#

7

(
#

-

7
17

#
##

7

-

) -

$
- #

:/9

/! &

.
*

/

B$ &

@
#

%!9

; $:

7

A$/&

6

%

/ != 9:

>?

#

? :

#
-

&)
##

'
6

?

##
#

.
7

- #
H % >
I

4

% %!= %9> $:

$

)

/>>/& (
&

*

B

2

#

'
#
-

" 7

#

6#

#

'

4
$0

% > %

)
#

#

#

#
2

' -

4

0

2#

-

4

% = : = ; $:

$

*

!

;;%& $#
&

2
#
3
#

=9> 5 3

0

#

'
;

#

@ @

#

#

#

#

#
#

#

'
!

#

>! 3

-

>/? $J
- '

4#
% %?= %!% $:

/

&(

#
)

? :

'

'4

#

-

'

@ @

2

(

& )

7

'

2 "

%9>&$

/> >&
!

&1
0

&

#

0

0
+

1

&

4

1
'

1

#

#
)

'

1

## 1
-

-

-

'

-

-

#

'

##

## 3
'

'

# '

# '

'
## 1

#
'

#

## 1

##

#

-

# '

#

#

##

'

'
'

#

#

3
#

'

#

'

##

#
#

5
#

3

6

#

#

)

'

5

'

#
#

#

.

'

'

#
@#

1

#

'

-

' #

#

'
)

-

3

#

'

#

'
'

9

#

#
#

'

3
5

' (

'

##
/>>>

-

K/:= >>> >>> >>

3 #

/> >

% >!%

/>%
##

'

6

/>>>
3

B

##

-

:: L

-

5

$#

!== /

/

(
3

' K% ;:> >>> >>
1

;9=& %

0
5

#

0

3

#

)##
(

E
)

@ ' #
,
6

>9/ (

+

*

#

+

#

'

'

'

' )-

J
'

>9 $:

3 #'

#

1
#

##

/

,

6

'

@
#

'

##
%

(
#

$:

0
! >! 3
;9;&

#
5
3
>/?A

##
3 #
2,

#

;

1/

#

'
9?=

0
# =9> 5 3
/ %9% %9:

@
#
#

'

E

@ ' #
,

E

@ ' #
,

-

7
E

@ ' #
,

'#

)

@
#

6

2

#

4

1

-

# '

#
-

E

@ ' #
,

#

>>>

: >>>

'

'

#

'

#
7

+
(
6

#
#

7

7

-

'
@ @

2
A
#

G

#
0

##

' #

4

??!

-

/ =9% =99 $:
0

0
E

;9/& 1
&
'

-

B 2 "'

4
@ ' #
,

2

#
#

-

>9%@ (
9:
-

G

$0

'

'

E

#

#

@ ' # 2
,

4

>9: (
'

>

4

2

4

#

#

#

2

"
/>

5

/? $!

3

4

$0

;9%& 1
&

#

'

@
#

#

! !

)

A

'

A

@
#

(

2

5

3

#

'#
'

'

E

4

/

#
@ ' #
,

2

'

#

0

-

4

>9%@
9:
1

#

'

#

M

N

5

3

#
%>$ &
$?& #

-

'

#

#
#

- #

#

#
#

-

##

-

/>%

' K% ;:> >>> >>
#

-

##
(

0
## +

@ @

'+

7

'

6

#

7
#

'

0
5

@

3

#

'

'
-

5

0
' *

1

7

## *
6

1

#

'

-

7

-

'

-

#
' 1

3

5

3
#

0
#

'

>9: 1
@
#

(
#

0
@
#

#
3
1

1
#

#

#
'

#

#

'

##
*

#
'

2

/

#

@
? :

'

%

:9: .

4

'
#

4

1

21

*

#

0

/
'

#

7
4

'

=!/

%

%

6

/! $

% > %

)

7

## )
##

7

'

6

%9/&

#

@ @

7

)

#

'

'

#

'

C 6

1
7

6

$ &

(

#

7
-

(

B

#

$=&

? :

-

7

A$%&

#

6

##

%

'
A

A$/&
A

#

$:&

-

#

%9! $

#
-

2(

%

=9> 5 3
0

% >! 3
#

>/?&
#

'

#

4

=9> 5 3

#
-

6

6

%

/%: /=: $:

7

-

>/? <

-

5

: !

>! 3

7

#
#

=

7

& $

#

,

/>>9& (

-

.

#
)

.
'

.

'

#

(

##
#

7

##

#

<

- -

-

2

#

7
5

'

3

4

8

1

##
8

(
*

- 6

#
#

##
1

2

-

#
#

4

3 #
#

#

5

=

3

#

1

#

##
#

'

1

'

#

-

' #

## (

'
# -

&

P 13 :??:/ $*
'

'

( 6 )

-

5

C

&

)@
>?@ )@
>;! O //>! 5 3

% />>!& (

#

3

,

'

-

#

#

.

- '

'

5

-

3

)##

'
-

'

7

#
6

#

7
8

#

'

##

.
7

(

&

+

!"
$%&

'

#
'

:

3, , E

E

)C

)

5

F

;

'

' />

s/ Keith Starrett
UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE

?