Davis v. State of Mississippi

Filing 11

REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS re 7 MOTION to Dismiss filed by Margaret Bingham, 10 MOTION for Expansion of the Record filed by Gregory Davis. Objections to R&R due by 2/12/2009. Signed by Magistrate Judge Linda R. Anderson on 1/29/09 (CC)

!

! #' "" " ( (

!" )

# *

$% +! " * 3' 3 2

& " )

,- + + + . ,,//0 1 # ) * " ) * ' ' '

,$# ,% - ! " %+ ' ' " * "' 3# +

3 $4 5 0 4 *1

)

'

36

( $4 - ' -# '

)3 + '

'

)' " "

'" " ' )'

7

,$#

3 7 ' ,,#

+

"$# #%

& & # 588 "' 3

+, :

-/ 0 5 ' " " "

+ $4 81 4

$4 8+) 9 49 '

$4 $4 # 4# '

'

+0&

!" '

; " "

+1 ? $ " * :

" "

' '

' +

*' ? ')

) 9' ,$# ,% % 0 %+ '

)' 3

!

0* ! 1 3 '

$8# $4 4 3 ' 4# & ) ) " # )' C A C 3 @ " " &

1 + 3 ;' $* A 3 @ D ' B ;

" "

" *! + 2 " ,$#

"9 # ,% -, ' %+ " )" ) '3 ) ' "" " 'C ' ''

"

$5# ,% %# 3 ')

; " ' ' " C "

) ' '3 C

'3

"' )3 ' 3 C 3 ' ' )C 0$=1 ' ' 3 ) C E' @& ' # ' " ' ' * ) 'C "

3

D ' #3 A C 'C

"'

! "

$

3
;

# +

&

&

) & # " ( " ' '' + (' " # )* + $ , % + $- < = =4 # /% # +(# /+ $ $4 < = $,8408 5+ 4 4# 41 # 8,4 + + $% # $,% + 8 + $85/# $/5 > + + , /5 0,% % %1 + 0 - & $ '# "+ $/4< = + = /# , 5: -08 ( #) ) $# + = = $4 - + 41

,

+

') E

" " 3C A ' "

E ; "' C ) E " 3 ) 2 ' ' ' "

' " ' 3 C ) "1 + '

C 3 C ' 3 ")

3 '

@" " C 3 E )

C E' * C +

# 0 *

'

* ' " + + . ,,//0 1 + + ' ' )' 0 1$1 0 @' F

E' * F# '

")

: '

') ,-

. ,,//0 1 # ' '

" )' 3 0$1 36 "' " " "

+A ,- + + + . ,,//0 1 ) " 3 $: E " ' G " + " " " '

01

' ' B

3' ' '

E )3 ) 3C " )

' & "

01

' 3 3 ")

3' '

"' " )# ' ' C 3 " " # ' ) 3C # "' "

01

'3' ' 3 H ' ' H ) "' "

'

=

01' & ' 0,1 " )' ' 3 E " "

3' '

' ) '+

"

' ')

'

3' '

"" ' "

"' " )3 3 '

" "' ' +

:

,- + + + .,,//0 1$1 # 0 " E " "" + . /+ # &! $ / # ' )' ' " : '

0,1 + .,,// 0 1$10 : 1 " # 0 " " # )'
+

3&" ' 3

; 3

E' " $4 - # ' 41
+

" '

+ +

+ 8 ( + ( # $5, < = ,4 08 , %+

# $$4 +

0$4 4 C ( + ' # 41 + $0

( + ( # $5$ < = 4 $# 4 / 08 , %+ + / /
+

$4 - C )+ 1" 41 " " + ( + # $5% ('

( + ( # $8/ < = $4 # +$+ 08 , %+ + 5
+

$4 - C 41

( 10 # 1( '

" < = $,,=# $,,5 0$% + ' ! / "" " " " 3 : ) ;E : ' 3 +

$4 - 0. ,,// 0 1,1 D 41 0 : ' )' 2 "! " 0=% 1 #* B" " 3 : ' " " * ' D +1

"

' E 3( ' 5 7 6 # &4 0 6 5 6 # 0=% 1 # #

) 3+ ! " ?) + $- $4 # 4# #! " '

' '" " "

,- + + + . ,,//0 1 * #

/

)3 3

D ?) :

"' " $- $4 4 # 4+ " 3 ' "

"

: '

)' " : '

3 )' 3

#

#

9 ' "

$8# $4 4 4# '

" : !)' ' ". , 8 # ,% % + $ %1 ,,// 0 1,1 0 ); " # 3 ' '

(' 40 5 #* ' 7 * /% / 3 + 09 ' $8# $4 4: ) 4? '' 4 0 3* ' 7 3

( '9 " :( + ' 00* ' ,% %# 3 " " + " 'B

( ' 4 0 7 6 ; ( ' 4 0 7 6 6 -. = => 9 ? #* ' 5 5 6 # * ' 5 5 6 < )% "% '# ') 3 ,# 55,# ,5 =# 3) # " " ,$# ,% - = %# " $5# !" * :

" $ $+ ' : . ,,//0 1 " 6 * )

#* 3

;

" " " D

'

6

E # ' " +

' )' & " ,- + + +

) & # " ( " ' '' + (' " # )* + $ , % + $- < = =4 # /% # +(# /+ $ $4 < = $,8408 5+ 4 4# 41 # 8,4 + + $% # $,% + 8 + $85/# $/5 > + + , /5 0,% % %1 + 0 - & $ '# "+ $/4< = + = /# 8 5: -08 ( #) ) $# + = = $4 - + 41

=

+

$ * E '+ D 3&# (& '

) ) ' ' , C # ' - " + + . ,,8= ' + + D ' ' " '' 3 ,,8/ "' " " "' ,,// 0 1$1 1 00+ D2 D @ " &" ' @
+

3

"+ # A' '

&

)

' &" ' ,% % + %1

3 ''

D ' +A

( + ( # ,, <= ,5% ,5= 08 , %+ + $ #

+ $ 1%" > ( 3. $+ >+ + + ) %( %
3 # !" # ) ' ' " 3 3 # "' " ' # 3 "' "

;' '

? + ) ? ' ) ) ; " ,$# ,% % * ! %# # , 3) # * $- $4 # 4# 0=% 1 E' '

+*

;E 3 : 3 + '

' '"

"

: ) 0=81 " # 3

" ,$# ,% - < %+ ; "

- + '+ + .,,//0 1 + 7 * ' "3 2 !" " ; 3 ' 10 + ' 7 " &> "E ' ,- + + + .,,//0 1 +

5

! ' " " "' " E '' ' # &" ' : "" #' ' 3 " ' # 0$% 1 '+ '"

*

; $% '"

& "

3 ' ' ) " # ' ( 1)% # . "% ' 3 'B 3

E' " '" " " '' " %@ # %+ 4

+ ,- + + + . 5=5#

+ & > ' #3 % . ( $ ' 0 $' &

<= $/$8# $/,- ,408 + : ,4

+ $4 51 4+ 7 # ,% 4 %+ ? I > ! + ( ! 7(

'