Vickers v. Astrue

Filing 15

REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS re 8 MOTION for Summary Judgment filed by Dena C. Vickers, and 10 MOTION to Affirm Decision of the Commissioner filed by Michael J. Astrue. Objections to R&R due by 3/13/2009. Signed by Magistrate Judge Linda R. Anderson on 2/27/09 (CC)

! "# $ %& ' # & # # # 0 12 / ! # % & (& ) ! +$ "$ ' "* % # # , % # '* # # # * * # ! #+ * # ,! +'% . / # / () % # !# '*

# # # 7 " # 2$ #5 < 5) 60 0 )

# 0 #

&

3

(4 5) 60 0) # # / 2 6(0 5) 6* ) 0&

# #

#*

# (8 5) 60 0 ) # = #

0

* ,* : ; 9 6: * #

2

1

# 2

/# ? % 5) # ) : # *'

(4 5) : 0 )0 !# . #* @ 2 /2 . 5) 5) : 0 )0 &, & $ "- + 5 2 )8 )0 0 $ $ 2 $B 0 # # *& # # 3 #/ # # 0 @

/ 12

, 1> 5) 5) : 0 )0

19 * &

*

13 2 *&

#

2 6) 5) : 0 )0 2 # $ *

&

# .& /$# " $ "' . + # 2 ; * #$ / ; #; * # 2 /# #$ / * ,* 9 0 0 2 $ , 68 #

(50 (4 (0 A

# # $ * (4 :*
3

0

/ 0 2

#

#

B

/ *

13

#

0& # # * ,8 (; ;

3

#

# /#

# 0 #

/ 0 0 / 0 # 0

/

0

# 2

# /

# # #

(4 * 4 # / # # 2 C # # * "# $ + 0 & *!*0 #

5) 6* , * (4 ; 4 - ! * + )9 A( 4

2

/ &

#%

0 ' /

2 D * , * (4 ; 4 - ! * + 9 :( * 2 # 0 & $0 % # # B B# # 0 #

#

23

02 # 2 02

,* 9

(4 # * D 0

!*

+

*' , * (4 - ! * + 9 * 2 ;/ # # 0 # 3 #/ # / 0 ## 0!* # 0 E 0 # # 2 ## # E# # E# . & # & 3 / 0 # #0 # # 0 ,9 '%@ & * , * 5) ; ) 9 )5 6 * # # 0 & *!*0 / 9 * , * (4 9 *

2

& 3 @# ##& 0

5) 60 & )

#

!*

# * , * 5(8 * 9 #2 3 ## 2 # 0

# #

#

# # #

2

#2 $ 0

* , * 5) ; ) - ! * 9 )5 ( * 0 # 2;

2

3

B #

E # / .

#/E #

0# #

#

2 $2 , * 5) -( 9 5*

$2

+$. * ! , # $2. .,& .# & + - 01 +- , / 3 %* $# /2 2 / # 0 . &0 B( , ) *@9 8 8(< , - # 8(< < 5 * * )* 5 08 * 5 ) # # # 1 ## 2$ # # 0# 2 0# . 0 # & 2 0 / ## $ 9 # # $ @# 0$ / $* 2 $ , * 56*9 * # 0 # / / / #0 ! # # 5) *@9 & ** 8 8( < A * )* 5 0!* # 02 88 )0 1 2 & 1 & * 2 1

, * (4 55-5 9 ;*
1

!# 3 & C# 64 ; 4 -# (6 5* ! * 3 () * ? B # 5) < )0 2 1 F # F$ 2

&

5) 8 & )0 0 !* 2 / B

3 2#

0!*& ; 0 / 3 / !*&

$0 0

# * ,9 * & + 0 *

2 #

0!* ! *? 0& / #* , & 2 *1 0& # # # $

$*

%# B 5) A # # # () 2$

# . E ****', *

# (4 * -

#

4

# & %1 .# * ' ,! , . 3 , 2 52 # # * (4 A 0 4# # # 1 # 0 * (4 < 0 4/2 / 13 # 2 / &./ # # # 2 #. 1I # G %, ( E 1, 0 &#

*J ( ! )/ "

** 8@6 : A : , 50 5 < (4 (# 4* @

6 << % ' & 0 4 8@5 58 0 58 , '/ + 8 * . / . # J 2# ## / E

# *J # * , / * #, +, ! 4/ % ' & 0 4 8@5 5 4 1+ '/ + < * . 0

& # 0 A @6 < 0 < 8, , :* < A< 54 , << * (4 54* / (4 < * 4# # B # # 3 % # # ##

/*

. '4 / 5#

1 , 0 A @6 &# :*

< 50 < < , < <<

*

2 #/ ***2 # (5 * (4 8 * 4# *' 8 5 #

#

* * * H8 6 5

, -(- - (! ' */ 1 ''0 6A@6 8 (0 8 <, , , E 3. . + &&& * 6 6< /; # 2

*6

3

#

# / E, -2 . 5 / 2$ E

G , -2 ( # # / E, -2 6 E, -2 8 / # 0 , -2 < / # # / * 5) *@95HH 8 8(< ) - 8 A4 ) ** )* 5 , 0 ( * 5 , *

# / ( ! # 0 ()@ 5 (54 0 (6) ; 5 , 3+ * A () < / # # 0 &#/ 2)* 5 << # )# 0 : :@ 5 (A 0 (A , "' * (4 6* 0 /2$ * $* & * (4 : * = # #

* B * # & &/ *

# $ (6) * 5 2

/

*

, , 2# , 0 1 - % &# + ! , # - # & 2 * G 1 "# $3 ## # # # # 0 ## . # #0 # /# #. B # < 2$ 32$ & / # # 0 $ # # &$ + B * # * 13 # / #

+*

/ 0 # # #1 3 / #* # # # 3 B

*

/

# 2 #/

;B # #. *

6 1 ,# ,# #1 1 7 . $. * , & ' . , 0 & -++ 1 , &+ . 0 + #0 2 ! % 5 , $ 8 % - & , ' ! & . +& /$# " 5 ! # 4 8 ,+ . & ", ! ' .+# .1 6 ! ) *,

6

& /## # 3

3

13

# 19 ## 2 # / # 0 # ## # # !* # # 0 0

# # #

& #/ 0 2 0

3

/

#0 ! * *# & # 0

#*

#0

# # 0 #

#/

0

# ## 0

#0 #& #

#* 0 2/ 0 # 3 9 "# # 19 ,- # # @# B * 2 # # # # 2$ # $* , & & # # 39 + # 0 *A * & ## 0& ## 39 3 + 0 * : * 1$ 2 # ## 1 0 # 0 # * # & 3 0 # 0 #0 "# 0 B # 0

,- # & #. /

D & # # #

2# / # *, &

7

#

2

/# & 3

B

3

# * / # # # 0# # #

/#

B

2

& . # # 0 0 13 # # 5(#* "# # * (5* # # 1# / 3 # # B % 2 90 @ 2 $B # # 2 $// # . + 0 ** (6* 0 0 / $ # "# ## # 2 & # 2 # / 2 # 0' B# 0 $% /# *, /# # #2 B / 2 !* # 0 2 &

13 2$ 0# 0 # 0 # 3 #. # 0 9 *, * @

0$ $* !* # 3

, * (4 559 ;* 3 # & 2 3 9 *, @ 0 # B 3+ B # 3 9 *1 @ & 0 3 0 0 # # & * (5* # 0 3

3+ 1

0

19 B 0 13

39 @ *' , # 3

8

# , ' 25 .2# , +& & +# !* * / # / %+' # * * / 1# (5*) 8 # 3 /2 # 13 # 0 19 !! # # 0 # & 2 # G / #0 3

#0 # 3 (5*) :

#

, 9 5(- , * * % 2 # ! *

# 2 / 12 , , & # " " +- ' +, & # * + 4 ! %, & " +, % -, 8 3#' % 5 , $ & $ , # # ! ## , '$ ! .# !# + '- 5 ! # + 1 0 + .# , , * # , .1 ! & 3#* , / 12 " +" !% . 0 $. * , & , # "&2 & ,. " 5 8 #! 5 0 2. * +. + + 1 , 1 '. + - & & ' 0 # ! + -2 5 # # # . / , - -! % - .# 3! ) .' 5 , .# & ) , + )' $ ' # 0# * 19 B 2 # 3 %# # 1 / $ $ # *' , * 5(9 * # # 2 $' , * 5(* 9 * 3 0 !* # # 0 & #0 # 3 # ## #* & 0 # # ## # 3 2 B

/

#

# +! # # 2 , # # #

0# #

9

#0 / 2

# $0 * # , &

# % $

2 2 $' 0

# %#

&

#

% $

*' ,9 5(0 8 < * :E 39 / $ 0 0 / ## # & # 3 # $* , 2 02 + 0 * <* #

3+ 2/ 0

0 &

* <* & 0

# .

#

E ##

#2 $ #

0 # 3+ 0 * ((* 13

2 # # # 3#

# # % # 0 # 0 * @ # # B 0 & 3 #*

% # # #

'/ &

$ 3

/

/ #2 / 3 ## 2 #

3 # #

****' , 2 /

3+

0

* < (6E9 5) ; ) 0 * )5 ( * 13 0

%

10

1 * / 2* 2 13 # 2 # 0 2/ & 0 2 * # # ( 4 ! 1 , & 9% - . + 5 , #. ' # , " ! / /2 02 # 13 2 # / 0 #2 $ / 13# 5) # # 0 # 0 # * # 2G #

'2

# # #

02

1 # *

#

"#

B

, 9 8 <* * :# ! #* #

0 2$ B # # # 0$ 0 # # 0 # 20 # # * +$.. % ' " + 5 0 2 -2 5 # /$ & & #! .' # # . / , - - " ++! 5 0 2 $# &'$ , - - ! 5 , .# & ) , & , #! ,. # &) 0 ' 3 $# &'$ . - % , +- > !' ! ,. # + , ". * ! # 0 # # / 2$ # K

2 /# 13 # / # .

/

*

# # * 1 * # >

# ## # ## !* #

# 0 2 # 3

&

3 # #0 2 2 0 # B # #

11

@ # @ 1 2*

#

2

#2

#/ 0

#

#

# # * (4 8 * 4# # 3 * # # 3 0& #. * 2 #

#. C #. # 0 0 2$ * 3# 0 / 1*'

%# (! ' * / 3. +

&&& 6A@ 6 8 (0 8 A, # '0 ' * 6 6< .# #

#

#

# # )# 0 "' @ B 1

&#/ 2% "#

: :@ 5 )* # #

(A 0 (A , 5 << 2 . # # 0'

* (4 6*

# # # # # 0 # * , &

3 3 9 + 0 # 2* & 3 D# 1 , < * 5) - , )* >

* (5*

#

# # # *

9# 0

0

@ # #

# # # B8 *( 2

2 # 1

(! $#! / '+ # / / /# # B #

- %05 (@ * ,# ## B 0 / /0 *** #

#. # %2 / 36 / *(! $#! 0 '+ 2 2 $' * $* 1 B 8 6* 5 $

12

2/ $

2 0 G % 2 0 % 0

%

5) 02 2

# # ; D2 # # 1 *' $* #

0 () *'

. $* #

0 12 # # 0 ;; 3 0 2

#

0

; ;2 # # 0 #

@ 0 # 2

2 ## #

#

'

# 2

*

$* 13 # & !* # 3 3

# &0 1 # 3 # * !# 3 2

# ## 0 2 0

# 2

*+ # #

'. , 0 &+ . 7 01 # #/ 0 # ;B #*

: 2 . & . + ! '. , 0 : # , & +, ! 0 &+ . 7 0- 5 & /# B * (! ' * 6A @6 3. 0 + #. #/ B @ # *9 # (! $ / 4 . # 1 # ;B *& 8 (0 6 3# #

5

2

#

;B

/#

# #0 564@6 A , ' * 4< # . / 2 #

* 5) (- & )0

#. (! $G 4

13

* * * ,-

(! ' * 3. + # #2 3# ## #

1 / . # # * / ;

# /# * $ ::# (0 ) !$ 4 # / 1# # # 3 / 0 @ # * / # # 2 $ B # # 1 0 3 @
/ 0 # & 0 3 # # #

(! ' * 6A@6 3. 0 + *

8A 6* # 0 2/ * 2 * $* / # / :: )* % ' # 0

#3 # # & 0

(! $ 2 4

*

$*

2/ #

0 # B

# B #

2 /

# # & ;B 3 3 2

B E &

0

$ 3 / E 0

/# $

2; & #

$E &

* , * 8 :8 9 : ;: * & 3 ## #*

0# #

$

/# #

0

#0

#

2

B #

14

#

2

*

*

#

=

0 # 0 B# # ## 2 0 ,) (0 ## * * * H A A ! * & -/ 6 E % ', < * (4 A * 45: @ 0 5) 4 )* +. $ , # # $ # # # # /

2 2 2 #

D#

D# ! - 7 0 : @6 -+ 4 * #

; *5

# /" - % ! .# ,

(8 < (8 ; 4 (0 55

? !

F 1

9 * L 9 !L

15