Johnny v. Bornowski et al

Filing 180

ORDER ruling parties' objections to the deposition designations of Murray Underwood and Brandon Wade. Signed on 9/20/12 by Chief District Judge Fernando J. Gaitan, Jr. (Enss, Rhonda)

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
WESTERN DISTRICT OF MISSOURI
CENTRAL DIVISION
OSCAR L. JOHNNY, JR.,
Plaintiff,
v.
LARRY BORNOWSKI and
STAMPEDE CARRIERS, LLC,
et al.,
Defendants.

)
)
)
)
) Case No. 10-04008-CV-FJG
)
)
)
)
)

ORDER
Currently pending before the Court are the parties’ objections to the deposition
designations of Murray Underwood and Brandon Wade. The Court hereby rules as
follows:
Defendants’ Objections to Plaintiff’s Designations
(Doc. No. 132)
MURRAY UNDERWOOD
PAGE REFERENCE
Page 43, lines 3-7

OBJECTION
Foundation, calls for
speculation, ultimate issue,
invades the province of the
jury (whether Bornowski
was going too fast)

RULING

SUSTAINED

Plaintiff’s Objections to Defendants’ Designations
(Doc. No. 133)
MURRAY UNDERWOOD
PAGE REFERENCE
P. 5; lines 4-8

OBJECTION
Not a question

RULING

SUSTAINED

P. 5; line 17 to P. 6; line 5

Non-responsive

SUSTAINED

P. 6; lines 6-14

Foundation

OVERRULED

P. 6; lines 6-18

Not a question; NonResponsive; Relevance;
Vague and ambiguous

SUSTAINED

P. 6; line 25 to P. 7; line 2

Not a question; NonResponsive

SUSTAINED

P. 7; lines 3-12

Foundation

SUSTAINED

P. 7; line 17 to P. 8; line 15

Foundation

SUSTAINED

P. 8; lines 12-15

Not a question; NonResponsive; Foundation

SUSTAINED

P. 8; line 20 to P. 9; line 1

Foundation

SUSTAINED

P. 9; lines 4-10

Foundation

SUSTAINED

P. 9; lines 11-18

Hearsay; Foundation

OVERRULED

P. 9; lines 18-21

Foundation

OVERRULED

P. 9; line 22 to P. 10; line
14
P. 10; lines 15-19

Foundation

SUSTAINED

Foundation

OVERRULED

P. 12; lines 16-20

Relevance

OVERRULED

P. 13; lines 2-9

Relevance

SUSTAINED

P. 14; line 21 to P. 15; line
23
P. 15; line 25 to P. 16; line
24
P. 17; lines 2-4

Foundation; Relevance

OVERRULED

Foundation; Relevance

OVERRULED

Foundation

SUSTAINED

P. 17; line 7 to P. 18

Foundation; Relevance;
Form

SUSTAINED

P. 18; line 15 to P. 20 line
25

Foundation; Relevance;
Form

OVERRULED

2

P. 21; lines 3-13

Foundation; Relevance;
Form

OVERRULED

P. 21; line 17 to P. 22; line
24
P. 22; lines 21-24

Relevance

OVERRULED

Relevance

OVERRULED

P. 23; line 2 to P. 24; line
13
P. 25; line 5 to P. 26; line
18

Relevance

OVERRULED

Foundation; Relevance;
Form

OVERRULED

P. 26; line 18 to P. 29; line
23
P. 30; line 3 to P. 32; line
18
P. 32; line 23 to P. 33; line
12

Foundation; Relevance

OVERRULED

Foundation; Relevance

OVERRULED

Foundation; Relevance

OVERRULED

BRANDON WADE
PAGE REFERENCE

OBJECTION

RULING

P. 5; lines 8-15

Relevance

OVERRULED

P. 5; line 24 to P. 6; line 3

Relevance; Foundation

SUSTAINED

P. 6; lines 11-21

Relevance

SUSTAINED

P. 6; line 25 to P. 7; line 2

Relevance

OVERRULED

P. 7; line 21 to P. 8; line 21

Relevance; Foundation

OVERRULED

P. 9; lines 6-24

Relevance; Foundation;
Speculation

SUSTAINED

P. 10; lines 3-25

Relevance

OVERRULED

P. 11; lines 12-25

Foundation; Relevance

OVERRULED

P. 13; line 1 to P. 14

Relevance

OVERRULED

P. 14; line 24 to P. 16; line
25
P. 17; lines 1-25

Relevance

SUSTAINED

Relevance

OVERRULED
3

P. 18; line 1 to P. 19; line
24
P. 20; lines 10-13

Foundation; Relevance

SUSTAINED

Not a question

SUSTAINED

P. 24; lines 2-5

Foundation

SUSTAINED

P. 24: lines 8 - 18

“It” Non-Responsive

OVERRULED

P. 24: lines 12-25

Form; Leading; Foundation

SUSTAINED

P. 25: lines 4-8

Foundation

SUSTAINED

P. 26: lines 7-12

Leading; Foundation

OVERRULED

P. 26: lines 15-19

Leading; Foundation;
Relevance

SUSTAINED

P. 27: lines 3-11

Leading; Foundation;
Relevance

SUSTAINED

Date: September 20, 2012
Kansas City, Missouri

S/ FERNANDO J. GAITAN, JR.
Fernando J. Gaitan, Jr.
Chief United States District Judge

4