H&R Block Tax Services LLC v. Acevedo-Lopez
ORDER denying 151 defendant's motion requesting stay due to notice of appeal and granting 152 and 153 motions to withdraw as attorney. Attorneys Marie E. Lopez Adames and John J Miller terminated as counsel of record. Defendant will be e xpected to proceed pro se in this matter, to the extent any further proceedings are necessary in this Court. Clerk ordered to send a copy of this order via regular and certified mail to defendant. Signed on 12/8/14 by District Judge Fernando J. Gaitan, Jr. (Enss, Rhonda) Order sent to Lutgardo Acevedo-Lopez, MDC Guaynabo, Metorpolitan Detention Center, PO Box 2005, Catano, PR 00963 via regular and Certified Mail rcpt.# 7001 0360 0003 3497 9567 on 12/8/2014 (Martin, Jan).
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE
WESTERN DISTRICT OF MISSOURI
H&R BLOCK TAX SERVICES LLC,
Pending before the Court are (1) Defendant’s Pro Se Motion Requesting Stay
Due to Filling [sic] of Notice of Appeal (Doc. No. 151); (2) Swanson Midgley, LLC’s
Motion for Leave to Withdraw as Counsel for Defendant, With Suggestions in Support
(Doc. No. 152); and (3) Marie Elsie Lopez Adames’ Motion to Withdraw as Counsel
(Doc. No. 153).
All will be considered, below.
Motion to Stay (Doc. No. 151)
On October 30, 2014, defendant filed a pro se notice of appeal, as well as his
motion to stay post judgment proceedings pending the appeal.
In particular, defendant
seeks a stay of procedures such as duces tecum subpoenas made by plaintiffs.
Besides the fact that a notice of appeal has been filed, defendant gives no reason for the
Court to grant this motion.
In their response (Doc. No. 154), defendants note that the monetary portion of the
judgment of the Court exceeds $1,870,000 plus interest, and under Fed. R. Civ. P.
62(d),defendant could obtain a stay of that portion of the judgment by filing a
supersedeas bond with the Court.
He has not done so, however.
With respect to the
injunctive portion of the judgment, the Court may suspend such judgment “on terms for
bond or other terms that secure the opposing party’s rights.”
Fed. R. Civ. P. 62(c).
Defendant has not proposed a bond, or any other terms that would secure plaintiffs’
rights, and as noted by plaintiffs, the injunctive portion of the Court’s Judgment refers to
plaintiffs’ right to be free of competition from Acevedo and those acting in concert with
him. Plaintiffs also assert that defendant’s family members are continuing an ongoing
operation of tax preparation offices at the same locations where defendant was enjoined
from operating directly, and the subpoenas duces tecum referenced in defendant’s
motion were actually served on those family members (not on defendant directly).
After consideration of defendant’s motion and plaintiffs’ response, the Court finds
that for the reasons stated by plaintiffs, the motion to stay (Doc. No. 151) will be
Motions to Withdraw as Counsel (Doc. Nos. 152 and 153)
Shortly after the filing of defendant’s pro se notice of appeal and motion to stay,
defendant’s attorneys filed motions to withdraw as counsel (Doc. Nos. 152 and 153).
The indicate that defendant is presently incarcerated in Puerto Rico, has not been
responsive to counsel for much of the time since his incarceration, and is past-due on
obligations owed counsel. Counsel also note that pro se defendant filed the notice of
appeal and the motion to stay without any input from counsel.
Pro se defendant was
advised by counsel that any objection to the motion to withdraw must be filed with the
Court no later than November 20, 2014; despite that caution, pro se defendant has not
filed any response to the motions to withdraw.
Therefore, the Court will GRANT the motions to withdraw as counsel (Doc. Nos.
152 and 153). Swanson Midgley, LLC, attorney John J. Miller, and Marie Elsie Lopez
Adames will be withdrawn as counsel of record. Defendant will be expected to proceed
pro se in this matter, to the extent any further proceedings are necessary in this Court.
The Clerk of Court is further ordered to send a copy of this order via regular and
certified mail to:
Lutgardo Acevedo-Lopez, MDC Guaynabo, Metropolitan Detention
Center, P.O. Box 2005, Catano, PR
IT IS SO ORDERED.
Date: December 8, 2014
Kansas City, Missouri
S/ FERNANDO J. GAITAN, JR.
Fernando J. Gaitan, Jr.
United States District Judge
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?