Pacific Northwest Solar v. Northwestern Corporation, A Delaware Corporation

Filing 280

ORDERED: 1. Admission at trial of the following exhibits, designated as "Will Offer" by Defendant: 508, 548, and 605, is DENIED. 2. Admission at trial of the following exhibits, designated as "Will Offer" by Plaintiff: 14, 15, 16 , and 17, is provisionally DENIED. 3. Admission at trial of the following exhibits, designated as "Will Offer" by Defendant: 543,564,566,589,596,609,618,619,620, and 629, is provisionally DENIED. (see order for complete information and details.) Signed by Judge Sam E Haddon on 9/17/2019. (HEG)

9/17/2019

IN THE UNITED ST ATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF MONTANA
HELENA DIVISION
PACIFIC NORTHWEST SOLAR,
LLC,
No. CV-16-114-H-SEH
Plaintiff,
vs.

ORDER

NORTHWESTERN CORPORATION,
A DELA WARE CORPORATION
DBA NORTHWESTERN ENERGY,
Defendant.

The Court conducted a hearing on September 11 , 2019, to address issues of
admissibility at trial of Plaintiffs "Will Offer" Exhibits 14, 15, 16, and 17, and
Defendant's "Will Offer" Exhibits 508, 541, 543, 548, 553, 564, 566, 570, 589,
592,596,597,598,599,605,609,618,619,620,629,630,644,645,646,647,
and 648.

ORDERED:
1.

Admission at trial of the following exhibits, designated as "Will

Offer" by Defendant: 508, 548, and 605, is DENIED for one or more of the
reasons stated as objections to the particular exhibit in the Joint Proposed Final
Pretrial Order.'
2.

Admission at trial of the following exhibits, designated as "Will

Offer" by Plaintiff: 14, 15, 16, and 17, is provisionally DENIED for one or more
of the reasons stated as objections to the particular exhibit in the Joint Proposed
Final Pretrial Order. 2
3.

Admission at trial of the following exhibits, designated as "Will

Offer" by Defendant: 543,564,566,589,596,609,618,619,620, and 629, is
provisionally DENIED for one or more of the reasons stated as objections to the
particular exhibit in the Joint Proposed Final Pretrial Order. 3

'Doc. 182.
Doc. 182.
3
Doc. 182.
2

-2-

4.

Determination of admissibility at trial of the exhibits designated as

"Will Offer" by Defendant: 541,553,570,592,597,598,599,630,644,645,646,
647, and 648, is RESERVED unless and until offered for admission at trial.
5.

Each party shall have until 4:45 p.m. on September 30, 2019, to

renew any objection or objections previously stated in the Joint Proposed Final
Pretrial Order4 for any exhibit for which a detennination of admissibility at trial
has been RESERVED.
6.

Each party shall have until 4:45 p.m. on September 30, 2019, to

renew any objection or objections previously stated in the Joint Proposed Final
Pretrial Order for any exhibit for which admission was denoted as provisionally
DENIED.

+J,. of September, 2019.
DATED this f'/ day

United States District Judge

4
5

Doc. 182.
Doc. 182.
-3-