Cooper v. Penske Truck Leasing
Filing
15
ORDER granting 12 Motion for Protective Order. Ordered by Magistrate Judge Cheryl R. Zwart. (BHC)
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF NEBRASKA
GREGORY COOPER,
PROTECTIVE ORDER
Plaintiff,
Case No. 8:14-CV-00271-RGK-CRZ
vs.
PENSKE TRUCK LEASING CO., LTD
PARTNERSHIP,
Defendants.
The Plaintiff, Gregory Cooper, and the Defendant, Penske Truck Leasing Co., Ltd.
Partnership, hereby stipulate and agree to and request the entry of this Protective Order
(“Protective Order”) concerning disclosure, use, and protection of confidential or proprietary
documents and information, including, but not limited to, commercial and/or financial
information that is not available in the public domain.
The parties hereby stipulate and IT IS ORDERED as follows:
Purpose and Scope
1.
Discovery in this action may involve disclosure of purported trade secrets and
other confidential and proprietary business, technical, and financial information. This Protective
Order (the “Order”) therefore is intended to protect against unauthorized disclosure of any such
information and to ensure that such information will be used only for the purposes of this action.
This Order shall govern all information (whether in writing, electronic, or other form),
interrogatory responses, responses to requests for admission, documents produced in response to
requests for production or voluntary production of documents, deposition testimony, including
429427.3
1
but not limited to all copies, excerpts, and summaries thereof or materials derived therefrom,
including all such materials which are used in the course of pretrial discovery and other
proceedings in this action and any motions, briefs, or other filings incorporating such
information (collectively, “Discovery Material”).
Applicability
2.
Provisions of this Order shall apply to (i) the parties presently named or later
joined in this action, including, in the case of parties other than individuals, their officers,
directors, employees, and agents and (ii) any other person or entity who produced Discovery
Material in this action and who agrees to be bound by the terms of this Order.
Designation of Materials
3.
The producing parties may designate any Discovery Materials as either
“Confidential” or “Attorney Eyes Only” (collectively, “Confidential Discovery Material”) when
a party, third party, or their counsel in good faith believes that such Confidential Discovery
Material constitutes or reveals a trade secret or other confidential or proprietary business,
technical or financial information. For purposes of this Order, information considered to be
Confidential Discovery Material includes, but is not limited to, all non-public materials
containing information related to the following: research; market studies; trade secrets;
proprietary technical information; submissions of information to regulatory agencies and
designated or requested for confidential treatment; proprietary policies and procedures;
proprietary business strategies and marketing plans, transactions and strategies, and analysis of
same; financial or tax data; proprietary contracts; customer lists and information; competitive
analyses; costs; pricing; current personnel; employment compensation information; personnel
files and documents contained in personnel files of Defendant’s current and former employees;
429427.3
2
product and market development and planning; financial results, plans, and projections; or the
financial affairs of any individual subject to discovery in this action;
4.
It shall be the duty of the party or a third party who seeks to invoke protection
under this Order to give notice, in the manner set forth herein, of the Confidential Discovery
Material to be covered hereby, and the level of confidentiality invoked. The duty of the other
parties and of all parties bound by this Order to maintain confidentiality hereunder shall
commence with such notice.
Disclosure
5.
Except with the prior consent of the producing party or upon prior order of a court
of competent jurisdiction, Confidential Discovery Material shall not be disclosed except in
accordance with the terms, conditions, and restrictions of this Order. A nonproducing party shall
not, except with the prior consent of the producing party or witness or by order of this Court, use
Discovery Material or Confidential Discovery Material for any purpose, including, without
limitation, any business or commercial purpose, other than for the purpose of preparing for and
conducting the litigation of this action and any appellate proceedings in this action, and the use
and disclosure of any Confidential Discovery Material shall be limited to the extent reasonably
necessary for the prosecution, defense, and/or appeal of this action. The mere designation of a
document as “Confidential” pursuant to this Order does not mean that the document is a trade
secret or that the producing party has otherwise protected the document from disclosure and the
nonproducing party reserves all objections to the same.
Discovery Material Designated “Confidential”
6.
Except with the prior consent of the producing party or upon prior order of this
Court, Discovery Material designed “Confidential” shall not be disclosed directly or indirectly
by the person receiving such material to persons other than the following persons, as to whom
429427.3
3
disclosure shall be limited to the extent reasonably necessary for the prosecution, defense, and/or
appeal of this action:
(a)
The Court, persons employed by the Court, and stenographers transcribing the
testimony or argument at a hearing, trial, or deposition in this action or any appeal
therefrom;
(b)
Counsel for the parties in this action, associates, legal assistants, paralegals,
secretarial and clerical employees, and outside copy services, litigation consulting
services, document management services, and graphic services that are assisting
counsel in the prosecution, defense, and/or appeal of this action;
(c)
Independent and party experts, consultants and/or investigators retained,
employed, or informally consulted by counsel in connection with the prosecution,
defense, and/or appeal of this action, including their secretarial and clerical
employees who are assisting in the prosecution, defense, and/or appeal of this
action;
(d)
The parties and the officers and employees of any party solely for the purpose of
prosecuting, defending, and/or appealing this lawsuit;
(e)
Actual witnesses during the trial or any hearing in this lawsuit or actual deponents
during a deposition in this lawsuit and their respective attorneys, subject to their
signing the “Undertaking” (described below); and
(f)
Independent auditors of a party, subject to their signing the “Undertaking.”
Discovery Material Designated “Attorneys’ Eyes Only”
7.
The parties may designate certain highly sensitive confidential Discovery
Material as “Attorneys’ Eyes Only.” Except with the prior consent of the producing party or
upon prior order of this Court, Discovery Material designated “Attorneys’ Eyes Only” shall be
treated the same as documents labeled “Confidential,” but shall not be disclosed directly or
indirectly by the person receiving such material to persons other than the following persons, as to
whom disclosure shall be limited to the extent reasonably necessary for the prosecution, defense,
and/or appeal of this action:
(a)
429427.3
The Court, persons employed by the Court, and stenographers transcribing the
testimony or argument at a hearing, trial, or deposition in this action or any appeal
therefrom;
4
(b)
Counsel for the parties in this action, associates, legal assistants, paralegals,
secretarial and clerical employees, and outside copy services, litigation consulting
services, document management services, and graphic services that are assisting
counsel in the prosecution, defense and/or appeal of this action;
(c)
Independent non-party experts, consultants and/or investigators retained,
employed, or informally consulted by counsel in connection with the prosecution,
defense, and/or appeal of this action, including their secretarial and clerical
employees who are assisting in the prosecution, defense, and/or appeal of this
action, provided that such persons have no affiliation with the opposing party and
all communications regarding the materials are made solely with outside counsel;
(d)
Actual witnesses during the trial or any hearing in this lawsuit or actual deponents
during a deposition in this lawsuit and their respective attorneys, subject to their
signing the “Undertaking” (described below).
8.
To the extent that any party identifies documents which they believe need more
protection than provided herein, they shall seek protection from the Court.
Statements
9.
Any person who is given access to Confidential Discovery Material shall, prior to
being given any such material, be informed of the provisions of this Order, read this Order, and
execute an Undertaking, in the form annexed hereto as Exhibit A, indicating that he/she has read
this Order and will abide by its terms. The original of any such Undertaking shall be retained by
counsel for each party who intends to or does provide such persons any such material, until the
conclusion of this action, including all appeals. The parties agree not to use these statements for
any purpose other than monitoring and enforcing compliance with this Order.
Non-Disclosure
10.
Any person receiving Confidential Discovery Material shall not disclose such
information to any person who is not entitled to receive such information under this Order. If
Confidential Discovery Material is disclosed to any person other than in the manner authorized
by this Order, the person responsible for the disclosure must immediately bring all pertinent facts
429427.3
5
relating to such disclosure to the attention of counsel for all parties and, without prejudice to
other rights and remedies of any party, make a reasonable good faith effort to retrieve such
material and to prevent further disclosure by it or by the person who received such information.
Designation of Written Discovery Material by Party or Witness
11.
Any producing party or witness shall designate Confidential Discovery Material
at the time of its production by marking any originals or copies of the documents or other
tangible materials with the legend “Confidential” or “Attorneys’ Eyes Only” at the time of their
production. If any document or other material is used as an exhibit at trial or otherwise displayed
to the Jury, all markings indicating that the document or material had previously been designate
by the party pursuant to this Order as “Confidential” or “Attorneys’ Eyes Only” shall be
removed prior to offering the document or material into evidence or displaying same, and no
mention shall be made of the previous designation of confidentiality. Such removal shall not
alter the confidential nature and treatment of the document or material or the obligations of any
party or third party under this Order.
Designation of Testimony by Party or Witness
12.
Any party or non-party witness shall have thirty (30) days from the date of receipt
of a copy of a deposition or other transcript in which to designate all or portions of the testimony
as “Confidential” or “Attorneys’ Eyes Only.” Notwithstanding paragraph 4 of this Order, from
the time the testimony is given through such 30-day period, all information disclosed in the
testimony shall be deemed “Attorneys’ Eyes Only” Discovery Material subject to the terms of
this Order. After such thirty (30) days have expired, any testimony not designated shall not
longer be deemed Confidential Discovery Material, subject, however, to the terms of paragraph
21 below.
Such designation shall be made after transcription by sending written notice
identifying the information to be so designated by page and line numbers to counsel of record,
429427.3
6
the reporters, and the witness within the 30-day time period. The reporter shall stamp each page
so designated as either “confidential” or “attorneys eyes only – confidential.”
Deposition Procedures
13.
At any deposition session, when counsel for a party or witness deems that the
answer to a question will result in the disclosure of Attorneys' Eyes Only Confidential Discovery
Material, counsel shall have the option, in lieu of taking other steps available under the Federal
Rules of Civil Procedure, to request that all persons who are not permitted to receive such
Confidential Discovery Material pursuant to the terms of this Order leave the deposition room
during the confidential portion of the deposition. The failure of such other persons to comply
with such requests shall constitute substantial justification for counsel to advise the witness that
he need not answer the question.
Nonconfidential Information
14.
Discovery material may not be designated Confidential Discovery Material if the
content or substance thereof:
(a)
Is already in the public domain at the time of disclosure;
(b)
Becomes part of the public domain at any time, unless as a result of (i) action or
failure to act, where there is a public duty to act, on the part of the recipient; or (ii)
any malefaction or breach of duty by a recipient or any third party;
(c)
Is already in the possession of the recipient party at the time of disclosure and was
not acquired under assurance of confidentiality directly or indirectly from the
disclosing party; or
(d)
Is made available to the recipient party by a third party who obtained the same by
legal means and without any obligation of confidence to the disclosing party.
15.
In the event any Discovery Material originally designated as “Confidential” or
“Attorneys’ Eyes Only” is later discovered to not be confidential by the terms of paragraph 15,
such designation shall be honored by the parties until amended by agreement among the parties
429427.3
7
or until otherwise ordered by this Court in accordance with the provisions of this Order or until
the conclusion of the litigation.
Disputes
16.
Any party may object to the designation of particular Discovery Material as
“Confidential” or “Attorneys’ Eyes Only” by giving written notice to the party or witness
making the designation and to all other parties. Such notice shall identify with specificity the
Discovery Material to which the objection is directed and the basis of the objection. If any party
disputes the challenge to the designation of the Discovery Material and such dispute cannot be
resolved, it shall be the obligation of the party objecting to the designation to file a motion with
the Court to request an in camera review of the disputed Discovery Material and a determination
by the Court that this material be de-designated as “Confidential” or “Attorneys’ Eyes Only.”
The disputed Discovery Material shall be treated as originally designed pending a ruling from the
Court. In any proceeding under this paragraph, the witness or party making the designation shall
have the burden of proof that the challenged Discovery Material is entitled to the protection of
the particular designation of “Confidential” or “Attorneys’ Eyes Only.”
Court Filing
17.
All transcripts of any nature or portions thereof, exhibits, answers to
interrogatories, responses to requests for admissions, and other documents filed or used in
hearing or trial in this action which have previous thereto been designated as comprising or
containing Confidential Discovery Material, or any pleading or memorandum purporting to
reproduce or paraphrase such information, shall be filed or submitted to the Court via the
CM/ECF system in accordance with NECivRs 5.3 and 7.5.
18.
In the event that any Confidential Discovery is used in any court proceeding in
this action or any appeal therefrom, it shall not lose its status as Confidential Discovery Material.
429427.3
8
Counsel shall confer on such procedures as are necessary to protect the confidentiality of
information used in the course of any court proceedings or appeal, prior to using Confidential
Discovery Materials in such proceedings in any manner other than is explicitly provided for in
this Order and shall before using such material prepare and make such filings as are necessary
under the Federal Rules of Discovery and Evidence for the material to be used.
Return of Discovery Material
19.
All provisions of this Order restricting the use of information obtained during
discovery shall continue to be binding after the conclusion of this action, including all appeals,
until further reorder of the Court, unless the parties agree otherwise in writing. Any and all
originals and copies of documents or other information produced in this litigation, whether or not
designated as “Confidential” or “Attorneys’ Eyes Only” shall, at the request and expense of the
producing party, be returned to the party within sixty (60) days after a final, non-appealable
judgment herein or settlement of this action. In the event that documents are returned at the
request of the producing party, the other party or its outside counsel shall certify in writing that
all such documents have been returned. Sixty (60) days after a final, non-appealable judgment
has been entered, the receiving party, may unilaterally chose to destroy all originals and copies
of documents or other information.
No Waiver
20. Neither the taking of any action in accordance with the provisions of this Order, nor
the failure to object hereto, shall be construed as a waiver of any claim or defense in this action.
This Order shall not be construed as a waiver of any right to object to the furnishing of
information in response to discovery and, except as expressly provided, shall not relieve any
party or witness of the obligation to produce information properly sought in the course of
discovery. Nothing herein shall be construed to affect in any way the admissibility of any
429427.3
9
document, testimony, or other evidence at trial of this action. Nothing contained in this Order or
any declaration of confidentiality or restriction hereunder shall be used or characterized by any
party as an “admission” by a party opponent. The failure of a party to object to or to challenge
a designation by another party of Discovery Material as “Confidential” or “Attorneys’ Eyes
Only” shall not constitute an admission that the materials so designated are in fact trade secrets,
or other confidential or proprietary business, technical or financial information, or are entitled to
any legal protection. The failure of a party to object or to challenge a designation by another
party of Discovery Material as “Confidential” or “Attorneys’ Eyes Only” upon initial receipt of
this material shall not constitute or be construed as a waiver of that party’s right to subsequently
object to or to challenge such designations at any later time.
Inadvertent Failure to Designate
21.
Inadvertent failure to designate materials as Confidential Discovery Material at
the time of production or the designation of such materials at a lower level of confidentiality than
warranted pursuant to this Order may be remedied by supplemental written notice given by the
producing party. Upon receipt of such notification, all documents, materials, or testimony so
designated or redesignated shall be fully subject to this Order as if it has been initially so
designated and shall be re-marked by the receiving party; provided, however, that the receiving
party shall incur no liability for any previous treatment of such information in conformance with
its original designation. The party receiving such notice shall make a reasonable good faith
effort to ensure that any analyses, memoranda, or notes which were internally generated based
upon such information shall immediately be treated in conformance with any such designation or
redesignation. Notwithstanding the foregoing, no party may designate or redesignate materials
under the Order later than 90 days after the materials were produced to an opposing party
pursuant to this Order.
429427.3
10
Inadvertent Production
22.
The inadvertent production of any document or other information during
discovery in this action shall be without prejudice to any claim that such material is privileged
under the attorney-client privilege, or protected from discovery as work product within the
meaning of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, and no party or entity shall be held to have
waived any rights by such inadvertent production. Upon written request by the inadvertently
producing party or entity, the receiving party shall (i) return the original and all copies of such
documents within ten (10) days of receiving the request, and (ii) shall not use such information
for any purpose until further order of the Court. Any analyses, memoranda, or notes which were
internally generated based upon such information shall be destroyed. Upon written request by the
receiving party, the advertently producing party shall make the document available for in camera
inspection by the Court in connection with any challenge to the claim of privilege or work
product protection.
23.
Noting herein will restrict the party from whom the return of the documents is
requested from filing a motion with the Court contesting the designation of the material as
privileged or protected by the work product doctrine or from referring to the fact that the material
has been produced; provided, however, the party filing the motion cannot refer to the content of
the document nor contend that any privilege has been waived.
Inconsistent Designations
24.
In the event of a party produces two or more identical copies of a document any
such copy is designated with a lesser degree of confidentiality than any other copy, all such
identical documents shall be treated in accordance with the most restrictive designation on any
copy once the inconsistent designation is known. The producing party shall be responsible for
informing the party receiving the inconsistently designated information of the inconsistent
429427.3
11
designation; however, if any person subject to this Order receives such inconsistently designated
information, and has actual knowledge of the inconsistent designation, the person shall treat all
copies in accordance with the most restrictive designation.
Further Motions Not Precluded
25.
Entry of this Order shall be without prejudice to any motion for relief from the
provisions hereof or to any motion for further restriction on the production, exchange, or use of
any document or to any motion for further restriction on the production, exchange, or use of any
document or other information in the course of this action; provided, however, that no such
motion shall be made after the entry of a final judgment or settlement.
No Restrictions on Admissibility or Use
26.
Nothing herein shall impose any restriction on the use or disclosure by a party of
its own documents or information, including the deposition testimony of its employees or
experts, except to the extent such deposition testimony involves the disclosure of information
designed by another party as Confidential Discovery Material pursuant to the terms of this Order.
DATED this 22nd day of December, 2014.
So ordered.
BY THE COURT:
s/Cheryl R. Zwart
Hon. Cheryl R. Zwart
United States Magistrate Judge
429427.3
12
DATED: December 22, 2014
By: /s/ Ryan M. Kunhart
Ryan M. Kunhart, #24692
Jeffrey J. Blumel, #19011
Abrahams Kaslow & Cassman LLP
8712 West Dodge Road, Suite 300
Omaha, NE 68114
rkunhart@akclaw.com
jblumel@akclaw.com
Telephone: (402) 392-1250
Attorneys for Defendant
PENSKE TRUCK LEASING CO., LTD
PARTNERSHIP
DATED: December 22, 2014
/s/ Mark Iezza
JONATHAN ALLAN KLEIN
(admitted pro hac vice)
MICHAEL D. EARLY
(admitted pro hac vice)
MARK P. IEZZA
(admitted pro hac vice)
Attorneys for Defendant
PENSKE TRUCK LEASING CO., LTD
PARTNERSHIP
DATED: December 22, 2014
/s/ Terry A. White
Terry A. White, NE #18282
CARLSON & BURNETT, LLP
816 S. 169th Street
Omaha, NE 68118
Direct: (402) 934-5500, x120
Fax: (402) 934-5920
terry@carlsonburnett.com
Attorney for Plaintiff GREGORY COOPER
429427.3
13
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT AND AGREEMENT TO BE BOUND
I, _______________________, of _____________________, declare under penalty of
perjury that I have read in its entirety the Protective Order or have had the Protective Order
explained to me by Counsel for a party and understand the Protective Order that was issued by
the United States District Court for the District of Nebraska, on ______________, 2014, in the
case of Gregory Cooper, Plaintiff, v. Penske Truck Leasing Co., Ltd Partnership, Defendant,
Case No. 8:14-CV-00271-RGK-CRZ. I agree to comply with and to be bound by all the terms of
the Protective Order and I understand and acknowledge that failure to so comply could expose
me to sanctions and punishment in the nature of contempt. I promise that I will not disclose in
any manner any information or item that is subject to the Protective Order to any person or entity
except in strict compliance with the provisions of the Protective Order.
I further agree to submit to the jurisdiction of the United States District Court for the
District of Nebraska, for the purpose of enforcing the terms of the Protective Order, even if such
enforcement proceedings occur after termination of this action.
Printed Name:
Signature:
Address:
Dated:
429427.3
14
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?