Halo Electronics, Inc. v. Bel Fuse Inc. et al

Filing 529

PERMANENT INJUNCTION against Defendants Pulse Electronics, Inc. and Pulse Electronics Corp. The terms of this injunction shall remain in effect until 8/10/15, after which this injunction will be dissolved without further order of the court. Signed by Judge Philip M. Pro on 6/17/2013. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - EDS)

Download PDF

1 2 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 3 DISTRICT OF NEVADA 4 5 HALO ELECTRONICS, INC., 6 Plaintiff, 7 v. 8 9 PULSE ELECTRONICS, INC. and PULSE ELECTRONICS CORPORATION, 10 Defendants. 11 *** ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) 2:07-cv-00331-PMP-PAL PERMANENT INJUNCTION 12 Having considered the arguments and evidence submitted by both parties, and having 13 found that (1) Plaintiff Halo Electronics, Inc. will suffer irreparable harm if an injunction is 14 not entered; (2) Plaintiff has no adequate remedy at law for Defendants’ continued patent 15 infringement; (3) the balance of hardships between Plaintiff and Defendants tips in favor of 16 Plaintiff in entering an injunction; (4) the public interest will not be disserved by entry of 17 the injunction, the Court hereby enters the following injunction, consistent with Federal 18 Rule of Civil Procedure 65: Definitions 19 20 1. “Pulse” means Pulse Electronics, Inc., Pulse Electronics Corp., any of their 21 subsidiaries or affiliates, and their officers, agents, servants, employees, and 22 attorneys, and those persons in active concert or participation with any or all of 23 them who receive actual notice of this Permanent Injunction. 24 2. “Infringing Product” means one or more of the products listed in Appendix A to 25 this Permanent Injunction or any product not more than colorably different from 26 one of the products listed in Appendix A to this Permanent Injunction. Prohibited Acts 1 2 3. Pulse is prohibited from making, using, offering to sell, or selling any Infringing 3 Product within the United States or importing into the United States any 4 Infringing Product. 5 4. Pulse is prohibited from actively inducing infringement of Halo Electronics Inc.’s 6 patents by assisting others in making, using, importing, selling or offering to sell 7 in the United States any Infringing Product. 8 5. UL-certification for any Infringing Product. 9 10 11 12 13 Pulse is prohibited from seeking a new or renewed United States specific 6. Pulse is required to include a copy of this Permanent Injunction with any Infringing Product that it delivers outside of the United States. The above terms of this injunction shall remain in effect until August 10, 2015, after which this injunction will be dissolved without further order of the Court. 14 15 16 17 DATED: June 17, 2013 _______________________________ PHILIP M. PRO United States District Judge 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 2 APPENDIX A TO THE COURT’S PERMANENT INJUNCTION LIST OF PULSE INFRINGING PRODUCTS REPRESENTATIVE PART: H0022 H0005 H0005T H0006 H0006T H0013.01 H0013.01T H0020 H0020NL H0020NLT H0020T H0022 H0022B H0022BNL H0022BNLT H0022BT H0022NL H0022NLT H0022T H0023 H0023NL H0023NLT H0023RL H0023RLT H0023T H0029 H0029L H0029LT H0029T H0037 H0037NL H0037NLT H0037RL H0037RLT H0037T H0041 H0041NL H0041NLT H0041RL H0041RLT H0041T H0042 H0042NL H0042NLT H0042RL H0042RLT H0042T H0042T.PK3000 H0042T.PK3000NL H0042T.PK3000NLT H0042T.PK3000T H0055 H0055A H0055AT H0055NL H0055NLT H0055T H0056 H0056NL H0056NLT H0056RL H0056RLT H0056T H0062 H0062RL H0062RLT H0062T H0064 H0064NL H0064NLT H0064T H0067 H0067T H0069 H0069T H0072 H0072T H0082 H0082NL H0082NLT H0082T H5019 H5019H H5019HM H5019HMNL H5019HMNLT H5019HMT H5019HNL H5019HNLT H5019HT H5019M H5019MT H5019NL H5019NLT H5019T H5055 H5055NL H5055NLT H5055RL H5055RLT H5055T H5069 H5069T H5074 H5074T H5091 H5091NL H5091NLT H5091T H5108NL H5108NLT QUADPAK SMD QUADPAK SMDT 1 Halo Electronics, Inc. v. Pulse Electronics, Inc., et al., Case No: 2:07-cv-00331-PMP (PAL) (D. Nevada) APPENDIX A TO THE COURT’S PERMANENT INJUNCTION LIST OF PULSE INFRINGING PRODUCTS (CONTINUED) REPRESENTATIVE PART: H0009 H0008 H0008T H0009 H0009.01NL H0009.01NLT H0009.02 H0009.02NL H0009.02NLT H0009.02T H0009.90 H0009.90NL H0009.90NLT H0009.90T H0009NL H0009NLS H0009NLST H0009NLT H0009RL H0009RLT H0009T H0009T.01 H0009T.01NL H0009T.01NLT H0009T.01T H0009T.02 H0009T.02NL H0009T.02NLT H0009T.02T H0010 H0010T H0011 H0011.90 H0011.90T H0011NL H0011NLT H0011T H0014 H0014T H0018 H0018NL H0018NLT H0018T REPRESENTATIVE PART: H1260 23Z108SMNL 23Z108SMNLT 23Z114SMNL 23Z114SMNL-T 23Z356SMQNL 23Z356SMQNLT 23Z435SMNL 23Z435SMNLT 23Z467SMNL 23Z467SMNLS 23Z467SMNLST 23Z467SMNLT 23Z90SMNL 23Z90SMNLT 23Z91SMNL 23Z91SMNL-T B8124 B8124T E2023 E2023.01 E2023.01T E2023NL E2023NLT E2023T E2031NL E2031NLT E2032NL EX2033 EX2033NL EX2033NLT EX2033T H0034 H0034NL H0034NLT H0034T H0135NL H0135NLT H1015NL H1015NLT H1015QNL H1015QNLT H1081QNL H1081QNLT H1100 H1100NL H1100NLT H1100T H1101 H1101NL H1101NLT H1101T H1102 H1102HL H1102HLT E2032NLT E2035NL E2035NLT E2081NL E2081NLT E2082NL E2082NLT E2452NL E2452NLT E2453NL E2453NLT E2454NL E2454NLT E2457NL E2457NLT E2458NL E2458NLT E2466NL E2466NLS E2466NLST E2466NLT E2467NL E2467NLT EX2024 EX2024NL EX2024NLT EX2024T 2 Halo Electronics, Inc. v. Pulse Electronics, Inc., et al., Case No: 2:07-cv-00331-PMP (PAL) (D. Nevada) APPENDIX A TO THE COURT’S PERMANENT INJUNCTION LIST OF PULSE INFRINGING PRODUCTS (CONTINUED) H1102NL H1102NLS H1102NLST H1102NLT H1102RL H1102RLT H1102T H1120 H1120T H1121 H1121NL H1121NLS H1121NLST H1121NLT H1121T H1122 H1122T H1137 H1137T H1138 H1138NL H1138NLT H1138T H1141 H1141NL H1141NLT H1141T H1146 H1146NL H1146NLT H1146T H1173 H1173T H1183 H1183NL H1183NLS H1183NLST H1183NLT H1183T H1197 H1197NL H1197NLT H1197T H1199 H1199NL H1199NLT H1199T H1202 H1202T H1205 H1205NL H1205NLT H1205T H1209 H1209NL H1209NLT H1209T H1235 H1235NL H1235NLT H1235T H1238 H1238NL H1238NLT H1238T H1245 H1245NL H1245NLT H1245T H1249 H1249NL H1249NLT H1249T H1251 H1251NL H1251NLT H1251T H1253 H1253T H1255 H1255T H1259 H1259NL H1259NLT H1259T H1260 H1260A H1260ANL H1260ANLT H1260AT H1260NL H1260NLS H1260NLST H1260NLT H1260RL H1260RLT H1260T H1261 H1261NL H1261NLT H1261T H1265 H1265NL H1265NLT H1265T H1266 H1266T H1275 H1275NL H1275NLT H1275T H1276 H1276T H1278 H1278NL H1278NLT H1278T H1279 H1279T H1281 H1281NL H1281NLT H1281T H1285 H1285NL H1285NLT H1285T H1286 H1286NL H1286NLT H1286T H1287 H1287T H1290 H1290T 3 Halo Electronics, Inc. v. Pulse Electronics, Inc., et al., Case No: 2:07-cv-00331-PMP (PAL) (D. Nevada) APPENDIX A TO THE COURT’S PERMANENT INJUNCTION LIST OF PULSE INFRINGING PRODUCTS (CONTINUED) H1292 H1292T H1300 H1300NL H1300NLT H1300T H1302 H1302NL H1302NLT H1302T H1303 H1303T H1308 H1308T H1313 H1313NL H1313NLT H1313T H1315 H1315T H1316 H1316T H1321NL H1321NLT H1338 H1338NL H1338NLT H1338T H1343 H1343NL H1343NLT H1343T H1364NL H1364NLT H1395NL H1395NLT H2019 H2019A H2019ANL H2019ANLT H2019AT H2019BNL H2019BNLT H2019NL H2019NLS H2019NLST H2019NLT H2019T H2041 H2041NL H2041NLT H2041T H2054 H2054T H2055 H2055NL H2055NLT H2055T H2059NL H2059NLT H2060NL H2060NLT H2073NL H2073NLT H2260 H2260NL H2260NLT H2260T H2309 H2309NL H2309NLT H2309T H5007CNL H5007CNLT H5007ENL H5007ENLT H5008 H5008NL H5008NLT H5008P H5008PNL H5008PNLT H5008PT H5008T H5009 H5009NL H5009NLT H5009T H5010 H5010NL H5010NLT H5010T H5012 H5012NL H5012NLS H5012NLST H5012NLT H5012S H5012SNL H5012SNLT H5012ST H5012T H5014 H5014NL H5014NLT H5014T H5015 H5015BNL H5015BNLT H5015CNL H5015CNLT H5015NL H5015NLT H5015T H5020 H5020NL H5020NLS H5020NLST H5020NLT H5020T H5025NL H5025NLT H5028 H5028T H5043 H5043E H5043ET H5043NL H5043NLT H5043T H5050NL H5050NLT H5051NL H5051NLT H5053 4 Halo Electronics, Inc. v. Pulse Electronics, Inc., et al., Case No: 2:07-cv-00331-PMP (PAL) (D. Nevada) APPENDIX A TO THE COURT’S PERMANENT INJUNCTION LIST OF PULSE INFRINGING PRODUCTS (CONTINUED) H5053T H5054 H5054NL H5054NLT H5054T H5062 H5062NL H5062NLT H5062T H5064 H5064NL H5064NLS H5064NLST H5064NLT H5064T H5067 H5067NL H5067NLT H5067T H5072 H5072T H5084 H5084NL H5084NLS H5084NLST H5084NLT H5084T H5089 H5089NL H5089NLT H5089T H5100NL H5100NLT H5107NL H5107NLT H5109NL H5109NLT H5111NL H5111NLT H5115NL H5115NLT H5118NL H5118NLT H5127 H5127T H5135NL H5135NLT H5140NL H5140NLT H5143ANL H5143ANLT H5143NL H5143NLT H5178HL H5178HLT H5178NL H5178NLT H6062 H6062NL H6062NLS H6062NLST H6062NLT H6062T H6072NL H6072NLT H6080 H6080NL H6080NLS H6080NLST H6080NLT H6080T H6084NL H6084NLT H6096NL H6096NLT H6101NL H6101NLT H6103NL H6103NLT HM1198 HM1198T HX0060 HX0060NL HX0060NLT HX0060T HX1141NL HX1141NLT HX1188 HX1188NL HX1188NLS HX1188NLST HX1188NLT HX1188T HX1198 HX1198NL HX1198NLS HX1198NLST HX1198NLT HX1198T HX1241 HX1241T HX1252 HX1252T HX1259 HX1259NL HX1259NLT HX1259T HX1260 HX1260NL HX1260NLT HX1260T HX1294 HX1294NL HX1294NLT HX1294T HX1300NL HX1300NLT HX1302 HX1302NL HX1302NLT HX1302T HX1323NL HX1323NLT HX1324NL HX1324NLT HX1393NL HX1393NLT HX2019 HX2019NL HX2019NLT HX2019T HX2045 HX2045T HX2088NL HX2088NLT 5 Halo Electronics, Inc. v. Pulse Electronics, Inc., et al., Case No: 2:07-cv-00331-PMP (PAL) (D. Nevada) APPENDIX A TO THE COURT’S PERMANENT INJUNCTION LIST OF PULSE INFRINGING PRODUCTS (CONTINUED) HX2260 HX2260NL HX2260NLT HX2260T HX5009 HX5009NL HX5009NLT HX5009T HX5012 HX5012NL HX5012NLS HX5012NLST HX5012NLT HX5012T HX5014 HX5014NL HX5014NLT HX5014T HX5018 HX5018NL HX5018NLT HX5018T HX5020 HX5020NL HX5020NLS HX5020NLST HX5020NLT HX5020T HX5049 HX5049NL HX5049NLT HX5049T HX5062 HX5062NL HX5062NLT HX5062T HX5084NL HX5084NLT HX5092 HX5092T HX5103NL HX5103NLT HX5104NL HX5104NLT HX5118NL HX5118NLT HX6002NL HX6002NLT HX6015NL HX6015NLS HX6015NLST HX6015NLT HX6017NL HX6017NLT HX6062 HX6062NL HX6062NLT HX6062T HX6080 HX6080NL HX6080NLT HX6080T HX6083NL HX6083NLT HX6095NL HX6095NLT HX6096NL HX6096NLS HX6096NLST HX6096NLT HX6510NL HX6510NLT JM-18506 JM-18506T ML102 ML102T PE-68515QNL PE-68515QNLT PE-68517QNL PE-68517QNLT ST4152NL ST4152NLT ST4152QNL ST4152QNLT ST4202TNL ST4202TNL-R ST4202TNL-RT ST4202TNLT ST4242QNL ST4242QNLT ST6114QNL ST6114QNLT ST6118QNL ST6118QNLT ST6160QNL ST6160QNLT ST6167QNL ST6167QNLT ST7010QNL ST7010QNLT ST7011QNL ST7011QNLT ST7032QNL ST7032QNLT ST7033QNL ST7033QNLT T1096QNL T1096QNLT T1144QNL T1144QNLT T1233QNL T1233QNLT T1235 T1235NL T1235NLT T1235T T1339QNL T1339QNLT T1347QNL T1347QNLT T1539QNL T1539QNLT T1589NL T1589NLT T8008QNL T8008QNLT TX1089QNL TX1089QNLT TX1267QNL TX1267QNLT TX1456 TX1456NL TX1456NLT TX1456T TX1516QNL 6 Halo Electronics, Inc. v. Pulse Electronics, Inc., et al., Case No: 2:07-cv-00331-PMP (PAL) (D. Nevada) APPENDIX A TO THE COURT’S PERMANENT INJUNCTION LIST OF PULSE INFRINGING PRODUCTS (CONTINUED) TX1516QNLT TX1520NL TX1520NLT TX3125NL TX3125NLT TX7016 TX7016T T1064QNL T1064QNLT T1065QNL T1065QNLT T1073QNL T1073QNLT T1712QNL T1712QNLT TX1261MNL TX1261MNLT TX1535QNL TX1535QNLT TX1542NL TX1542NLT TX1544NL TX1544NLT H1664NL H1664NLT H5019BNL H5019BNLT H5038NL H5038NLT H6080ANL H6080ANLT HX1225NL HX1225NLT HX1323NLS HX1323NLST HX5009NLS HX5009NLST HX5019BNL HX5019BNLT HX6014NL HX6014NLT T1136QNL T1136QNLT T1146QNL T1146QNLT C2267NL C2267NLT C2268NL C2268NLT REPRESENTATIVE PART: 23Z110SMNL 23Z110SMNL 23Z110SMNL-T B2013.90NL B2013.90NLT B2013NL B2013NLT H1190NL H1190NLT PA2401NL PA2401NLT PE-65558MNL PE-65558MNLT PE-65812NL PE-65812NL-900 PE-65812NL-900T PE-65812NLT PE-65848NL PE-65848NLT PE-8271QNL PE-8271QNLT PA2932NL PA2932NLT REPRESENTATIVE PART: H1305 H1170NL H1170NLT H1271 H1271T H1272 H1272T H1305 H1305NL H1305NLT H1305T H2005B H2005BT H2009 H2053A H2053ANL H2053ANLT H2053AT H2053BNL H2053BNLT H2075NL H2075NLT H2305 H2305NL H2305NLT H2305T H2310NL H2009ANL H2009ANLT H2009NL H2009NLT H2009RL H2009RLT H2009T H2039 H2039ANL H2039ANLT H2039NL H2039NLT H2039T 7 Halo Electronics, Inc. v. Pulse Electronics, Inc., et al., Case No: 2:07-cv-00331-PMP (PAL) (D. Nevada) APPENDIX A TO THE COURT’S PERMANENT INJUNCTION LIST OF PULSE INFRINGING PRODUCTS (CONTINUED) H2310NLT H2312NL H2312NLT H2318ANL H2318ANLT H2318NL H2318NLT H5047 H5047T H7001 H7001NL H7001NLT H7001T H7007 H7007NL H7007NLT H7007T H7008 H7008NL H7008NLT H7008T H7009NL H7009NLT H7011NL H7011NLT H7012NL H7012NLT H7018NL H7018NLT H7019NL H7019NLT HX1294NLS HX1294NLST HX1305 HX1305NL HX1305NLT HX1305T HX2305 HX2305NL HX2305NLT HX2305T HX5008 HX5008NL HX5008NLS HX5008NLST HX5008NLT HX5008T HX5030NL HX5030NLT HX5132 HX5132NL HX5132NLT HX5132T HX1291NL HX1291NLT H2354NL H2354NLT H7028NL H7028NLT H7029NL H7029NLT H7030NL H7030NLT H7037NL H7037NLT H7136NL H7136NLT H7137NL H7137NLT REPRESENTATIVE PART: H1174 H1174 H1174NL H1174NLS H1174NLST H1174NLT H1174T H1195 H1195NL H1195NLT H1195RL H1195RLT H1195T H1244 H1244NL H1244NLT H1244T H1256 H1256T H1270 H1270NL H1270NLS H1270NLST H1270NLT H1270T REPRESENTATIVE PART: H0026 H0026 H0026NL H0026NLT H0026T H5041 H5041T REPRESENTATIVE PART: H0019 1000B-5001 1000B-5001T 1000B-5001X 1000B-5001XNL 1000B-5001XNLT 1000B-5001XT 1000B-5002NL 1000B-5002NLT 1000B-5002XNL 8 Halo Electronics, Inc. v. Pulse Electronics, Inc., et al., Case No: 2:07-cv-00331-PMP (PAL) (D. Nevada) APPENDIX A TO THE COURT’S PERMANENT INJUNCTION LIST OF PULSE INFRINGING PRODUCTS (CONTINUED) 1000B-5002XNLT 1000B-5003 1000B-5003T 1000B-5003NL 1000B-5003NLT 1000B-5003X 1000B-5003XNL 1000B-5003XNLT 1000B-5003XT 1000B-5009 1000B-5009T 1000B-5009X 1000B-5009XT 100B-1007 100B-1007T 100B-1011 100B-1011T 100B-1011X 100B-1011XT 100B-2002 100B-2002T 100B-2002X 100B-2002XNL 100B-2002XNLT 100B-2002XT E0001 E0001T E0005 E0005T H0007 H0007T H0013 H0013NL H0013NLS H0013NLST H0013NLT H0013T H0019 H0019NL H0019NLT H0019T H0025 H0025NL H0025NLT H0025T H0028 H0028T H0031 H0031T H0032 H0032T H0059 H0059T H5019D H5019DNL H5019DNLT H5019DT R0007 R0007T R7003 R7003T R7004 R7004T T1101 T1101T T1143 T1143T X-1590 X-1590T 9 Halo Electronics, Inc. v. Pulse Electronics, Inc., et al., Case No: 2:07-cv-00331-PMP (PAL) (D. Nevada)

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.

Why Is My Information Online?