Rowell v. Giannone et al

Filing 94

ORDER Granting 92 Motion to Extend Prison Copywork Limit. Signed by Judge Robert C. Jones on 5/6/10. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - EDS)

1
2

j
.

J. . .

.

.!

'
.

.. ' .. .

.

r

r.. . ' .

;
3 4
5

f
'
.

.
) f.., : -j 1' 7 .
'

/
j

ë

1
)

.

1

' 7

6 7

UN I E D STAT ES D I TR I T C O U R T T S C DISTRICT O F N EV A D A

.

8 LAM ARR ROW ELL, 9 1 0 11

1 2 1 3
1 4
15

) ) Pl i t an? ) ) vs . ) ) DET.GJ NN OUE ( #6 25 , A P 2 ) OFFI ER M . ' C ) SEED ( #6 2 ) OFFI ER J HI DEM A P 74; C .D ) ( #8 08 ; CER W . P 6 ) OFFI YOUNG (#9636 ' nd ) P )a , EW I G BROS. N TOW I G CO. N , ) )

2: 7 c - ll 9- CJ RJ 0 -v 0 6 R - J ORDER

Dee da t. f n ns

) )
I T R O D U C T IO N N

1 6

Bcor t cCo r i Pli tf' M oto t Extnd Prs n Coppvo k Lï i ( 92 .Pli tf f e h u t s an ifs in o e io r m t # ) an if

17 seeks t have hi copywor lm i ext nded f rt e narow pum os s oft e i santhabeas cor us o s ki t e oh r c h nt p 1 pr ceedi gs. Def ndant J.G i nnoue,O fi erM .Seed,Of i e J.Hi dem a and O fi erW . oung 8 o n e s a fc fc r d tc Y

1 (ole tveyt - M pD Dce da t' tldaNon- pposto t Plitf s oto ./93) Dee da t 9 c lci l tv t fn ns' ie ) o iin o anif M in (/ . fn n
20 Ew i g Br s. n o Tow i g Co. nottl d an r s onsve pl adi g. n has ie ep i en

21

I I HEREBY ORDERED ta plitf sMotont Extndprs nCo lvor Li i ( 92 TS h t an if i o e io p q k m t # )

22 i G RA N TED . s 23 DISC U SSI N O

24

Pe ii ne i a i d g ntpr s ne ,a de o sr t d b t e M oton f rLe ve t Pr c e l tto r s n n i e i o r s m n ta e y h i o a o o ed n

25 For a Pa pei. ( 1. Nc a a De at e tofCore tons(i DOC' Admiitaie Rul m u rs # ) v d p rm n rci i N ' ) nsrtv e
1

1 722.2( )al wsPeii n rt a c uea$1 0d bt gans hi a c unt o a dslga c pywor whih, 1 4 lo tto e o c r 0 e a i t s c o tw r e l o kc
2 once r ached,pr hi is hi fom accum ul tng any f rheri de t dnes f rs ch copya or . The e o bt m r ai ut n b e so u vk

3 Rul alwsf re cptonssaigiexc pto st t ir l wo l beac uror e rc ie drcty e lo o x e i ,ttn ç l e in o hs ue ud g o t d re ev d ie l
4 fom t e cours...' A . .722. 2. rh t'R 1 5 Pettonerhasr ached orexceededt e$100. 0 lm i oft cadm i i tatvem l .Accor i gl , ii e h 0it h n sr i e dn y

6 N D O C has pr hi ied hi att i tm e fom r cei i g any f r her l galcoppvor i t e i stnt o bt m hs i r e vn ut e knh n a 7 pr ceedi g unl sst eCour is esan or cralow i g hi t do s . Pettone cl i st athe needs o n eh t su d l n mo o ii r a m h

8 a dii na c pp v r s r i e i or e t ltga ehi i s a t tton. Spe ii a l , n a dii n t h s d to l o o k e v c s n d r o ii t s n t n pe ii c tc ly i d to o i
9 or gi al ofa1 pl a i gs, otonsand ot erdoc m ent i t i cas , i n s 1 ed n m i h u s n h s e hecl i st needcopi st s r e am o e o ev

10 upon Res ondent perFeder lRul ofCi i Pr cedur 5,and LocalRul s 5-1and 7- . TheN i t p s a e vl o e e 2 nh

ll Cicui hasdet r i ed t atgi i g aprs neracces t copi sr quied t fl ,ser eopponent ,and rt em n h vn io so c e r o ie v s 1 m ai t i a copy oft e i m at ' r cor s,i r as nabl . See,e. . Gl t v.Kangas,951 F. d 1504, 2 n an h n es e d s e o e g , uh 2

1 1 1 (( Ci.1 91 (plolig a ij ncinrquiigtepio t alw aprs n ra c s t 3 5 0 9h r 9 ) u l dn n nu to e rn h rs n o lo ie e c c s o
1 c p v r a dic scda ove . 4 o p o k s su s b )
l5 Deni lof Pe ii ner' r ques ,woul notr s l i Pe ii ner bci g com pl t l unabl t a tto s e t d e u t n tto n ee y eo

16 f rherpurs et i ltgaton.H ecoul copyby hand t eneces ar pl adi gs Butasone courthas ut u h s ii i d h sy e n . 17 sat d,i woul be tneedl s l dr coni n' t r quic i m at s t copy al docum e t by hand. te t d t e sy a a ' o e r n e o l ns

1 John o v Pare,642 F.d 377,380 ( 0t Ci.1 1 (uoe i Glt,951 F.d a 1 1 ) 8 sn . k 2 1 h r 98 ) q td n uh 2 t 5 0.
19 Accor i gl ,i i r asonabl t per i Pettonert m aket e copi snecess l i t e f rher nceof dn y t s e e o m t ii o h e a' n h u t a y

2 t i ltga i n, ri ul ry i lght De e da t 'no - p os ton t t e m oton.Butt i i no a 0 h s ii to pa tc a l n i of f n n s n o p ii o h i hs s t n
2l open ended gr ntr gar i g Pettoner' copyw or prvieges;i i lm ied t copi sneccss z t flt a e dn ii s k il ts i t o e a y o ic 22 m otons ser e opponent ,and m ai t i a copy f rpcttoner' r cor s i t i ltgaton al ne. i,v s n an o ii s c d n h s ii i o 23 C O N C L U SI N O

24

I I HEREBY ORDERED t a Pl itf sM oto t ExtndPrs nCo ywo kLi i ( 92 TS h t an if in o e io p r m t # )

25 i GRANTED.Pe Ne a aDe a t en ofCore tonsAdmi itai eRul 72 .2( ) t eNe a a s r v d p rm t r ci n sr tv e 2 1 4 ,h v d
Page 2 of 3

1 D eparm ent of Cor ectons s al alow Pettoner t e copywor neccss r t m akc copi s of t ri hll ii h k ay o e 2 Pettoners m otons t ser eD ef ndant ,a d f rPettoner' r cor s ast ey r l t t t e i sant ii ' i ,o v e sn o ii se d h eae o h n t 3 ltgaton pendi g bef r t i Cour . ii i n o e hs t 4
5 6 7 8
9

D at d t i e hs

day ofM ay,2010.

R os U N I ED ST T

T c . Jo x p; s ES D I TR I T JUD G E S C

10
11 1 2

13 14 15
16

17 1 8 1 9 20 21 22 23 24 25 Page 3 of 3