Slaughter et al v. Uponor, Inc. et al

Filing 468

ORDER Granting in Part and Denying in Part 350 Motion for Attorney Fees and Costs. Ferguson is awarded 100% of its taxable costs in the amount of $14,554.77; one-fifth (20%) of its attorneys fees and other costs in the amount of $66,731.67 for a total award of $81,286.44. Signed by Judge Robert C. Jones on 11/29/10. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - ASB)

Download PDF
1 2 3 4 5 6 UNI E D STATES DI TR I T COUR T T SC DI TR I T OF NEVADA S C 7 EDW I K.SLAUGHTER, .a. N et 1 ) ) 2: 8 c -1 2 - CJ GW F 0 -v 2 3 R ORDER ) 8 ) vs . ) 9 ) UPONOR,I C. M im e o aCor o ai n;e.a. ) N a l s t p rto t l l 0 ) De e da t , fn n s ) l1 Plitfs an if, 1 2 Pe di g be o et eCo r a e De e d n sUniedPll bi g LLC a d Fe gu o Entr rs s n n fr h u t r fn a t t t n, m n r s n e p ie , 1 I c' Moto frAto e ' Fee a dCoss(/50 ,PlitfsOpposto (/63, ndDee d nt' 3 n .s in o tm y s s n t 83 ) anif iin /3 )a fn a s 1 Re l (/7 ) Dee da t'Moinwa fldbaedu o teCour' Or e ds isngtecae 4 py /3 0 . fn ns to s ie s p n h ts d r im si h s 1 (/ 49)a di snttngt eprte t fl b if o t cis e o fesa dcc t.A h ai gwa hed 5 /3 n n t c i h is o ie re s n h s u s f e n s s e rn s l 1 on M a 1 , 01 r g r i g t em oto sfl d,a t g o c us a pe rngt e e or . Fort er a o s 6 y 0 2 0 e adn h i n ie r o d a e p ai h r f e d b esn 1 gi e he e n, he M oton i Gr n e i pa ta d De i d i pa t 7 v n ri t i s a td n r n n e n r. 1 8 Slaughter et al v. Uponor, Inc. et al 1 FI D I G S OF FACT .NN 11 9. On J l 28, uy 2008 PiitfsEd i K. a g tr Re e c Flnn, e He l ya d Ca o) , an if w n Slu h e , b c a i M l a e n r Doc. 468 20 21 2: 1 He l y f l d t epr s n ca s o a to ,o b ha fo t e s l e a d a l he ssm ia l a e ie h c c t u e f c i n n e l f h m e v s n 1 ot r i l ry st a e , n t e D iti tCour f r Cl r Cot t , r a a De e d nt Upo o , nc ; iu t d i h s fc t o ak m y N v d . fn a s n ri . Upono N o t A m e i a, nc. U p no Co . RCR Pl m bi g & M e ha lc l l c. r rh rc I ' o r p ; , un c zi a , n ; 23 24 l trtt Plm bi g & Ai Cond tonig,LLC;Unie Pi r bi g, n e sae u n r ii n t d u n n LLC; r u o Fe g s n Enl r rs s,l c, HughesB? t r& SewerLP'ars HD Suppl Cons r clon Suppl e p ie n ; ae S ll y tu i y 2 5 Li ie Pa L e s i a e a l ge t b e ga e i t ebusne sofd sgni g. ve opi g, m t d rn r h p r le d o e n g d l h is e i n de i n 26 ma ufcu ig diriutng, rl ig slig a disalngteBrrboPEX pimbig , n a trn . srb i mal n . eln . n n tli h is m un J ' Pg 1f5 ac ot l 1 1 i . 1 Dockets.Justia.com s sc ,W is obr s fti gs a d o h rplm bi gmae il a pa t -hepo a l wa e y tm r b a s itn , n t e u n t ras s r oit t b e tr s p l s se sofrsdc tald elngsi Clr Co ny,Ne a a. u p y y tm e i n i w li n ak u t vd Pl i tfk a l g d t a a 1oft e W is o b a sfti gsi sa l d aspa t t tpo a l wa e a n ii le e h t 1 h r b r s it n n t le r of h t b e t r s s e soft e r s de ta dweli g i Cl r Cu nt , e a aa e de ec i e a t er s l of y tm h e i n il ln s n a k u y N v d r f tv s h e u t ac e ia r a tc l own a d zicfc to .Plitfsa es ig t d rt ef lo i g h m c l e cim m s e n iia in an if r u n m e h o l w n te resofla iiy: 1 podu tla iiy;()src la iiy;()b e c ofc prs h oi iblt () r c iblt 2 titiblt 3 r ah x es warny;()be c ofi pie warnt;5)bra hofwarnt o mec a tbiiy; nd ra t 4 ra h m id ra y ( e c ra y f rh na lt a ( )ne lge c . 6 gi n e O n Se t m be 1 ,200 , f uda t r m o ed t el w s i fom s a e c u tt f d r lc ur pe r 5 8 De e n s e v h a u t r t t o r o e e a o t pt s a tt t eCls Aci nFar es Ac (t A.A ' o t e g o ndst a t ea o nti l u n o h a s to in s t ' F ' n h r u h t b m u n r C ) co tove s e c e s$5, 0 ,00,he ei di est ofctze s i bew e n Pli tfsa d nr ry x e d 0 0 0 t r s v r iy ii n hp t e an if n m or t a o e prm a y De e da t a d t e e a e c am ed t b m o e t = 1 0 cl s e h n n i r fn n , n h r r li o e r h 0 as m em ber . s OnOco e 1 , 08 PlitfsfldaMoint Re a d( 1 )t d rte a daoy tb r 4 20 , an if ie to o m n # 7 m e h c n tr m ho esae'tlc lc nto es 'a dt iceinay'e c pinst CAFA jtidcin. m -tt' to a o rv ry' n t srto r ' x e to o , d trs ito OnMac 5 200 ,Plitfsmoint rm a dwa de id(/4) rh , 9 anif to o e n s ne /9 . OnAprl2 ,20 9, anif mo e t cri teca s( 11 ) Dee d nt rsond d i O 0 Plitfs v d o e tf h ls # 0 . fn a s ep e y w ih mo insf rla et c nd c dic ve r#1 8a d/1 9)whihwe era t da d t e t to o e v o o u t s o o ( 1 n / 1 c r ne n h h aigo cascriiainwa stfrNove be 23,2009( l 4) Att erqueto e rn n ls etfcto s e o mr #4 . h e s f D e e da t U po or l c. nd RCR Pl m bi g & M e ha i a ,I c tlshe rng w a fn n s n ,n a un c nc l n ,l i ai s 21 c niue t M ac 29, 1 (/27 a dte move u b teCo rt Jnuay25 201 o tn d o rh 20 0 /2 ) n h n d p y h u to a r , 0 (27 ) # 2. The prm a y go lml f c soft e dico e y c ndu t d b ' f nda t w a i r s o s t i r a d ou h s v r o c e ) De e n s s n e p n e o Pl i tf sm ozon f rCl s Cerii aton. a n if i o a s tic i 7* D - D c e d nt a t nd ! de o ii nsof e s nsm os i o l dg a l -a lofD e e d n s f n a s te 5 p s to p ro tm w e e b e l fn a t; s he ul : nun c o scc u ii nsofw i e s s i cl di g t ena e pl i tfs i s ec e 5 c d el z r u l p s to t s e n u n h m d an if : n p t d n Pagc 2 of6 ; ho e viu la d 3ho esd sr c iey;atnda redu ont si g o mae il i m s sa n m e tu tv l te g e p e tn f tra s n Caior i ;s ug tdic veyoft ee pe t lf n a o h s o r h x r whos a fda i wa s bm i e i s p o t e fi v t s u u d n u p r of Pi l tf sm oton t Ce tf Cl s i c u i g a pca i g t e M a it a e' Or e t t e a n if i o riy a s n l d n p ln h g sr t s d r o h D iti tCo r a d tl d a M o i n f raTe po m' Resr i i g Or e a d/ rPr lm i a ' src u q n ie to o m r y ta n n d r n o ei n t y Ij ncino tl c ntmporme u Cha tr40pr-iiainpr cedngsbengfld nu to n le o e l o s p e cl g to o e i t i ie duri g t e cl ssdieovc y perod. nh a sr i 0nNo e b r23 200 , antfs c t s lee td a e uia l r m ed pr vi e b t e v m e , 9 Pli if' om e lce n q tb e e y o d d y h Cour a da r e t S p - ut ali dii uaswhofi dac a tr40notc ( 3 8 . t n g e d o t to ' l n v d l o ' ie h p e ie # 4 ) 0n De e be 3, c m r 2009 Pl i tf s wihou notc t t epu a i e c a sm e be s w i dr w , an if , t t i e o h t tv l s m r , t e h t erM otont Ce tf Cls (/ 7 ) h f i o rty a s /2 8 . ' O n De e be 7, 9, a n ir fl d a M oton f rV o ur a ' Di m i s lo t e e tr c m r 200 Pl i tf s ie i o l l z s s a f h n ie ty a to (285 .A1Dee da t e cptUpon ro po e ti volnt y dimis l e kn cin # ) 1 fn ns x e o p s d hs u m s sa s e ig 13 tedimis lobewihprj dc a df ral wado teral rzysfe a dc ss h s sa t t eu ie n o ra r f h i tore e s n ot (/ 1 , 6 31 ,319 3 0, nd321 . /3 4 31 , 8 , 2 a ) O n J nua y 5, 0, he r n w a he d o Pl i tf sm o i n t vo u t rl di m i s a r 201 a a i g s l n a n if to o l n a iy s s 15 wihou prj diewh ri teCo r saedta iwo l o l dimiswihprj dc a d t t eu c een h u t tt h tt ud ny s s t eu ie n ta ti is eo atre sfe a dc sswoudbers re frfrle he rng(344l d h t hs su f ton y es n ot l e cv d o lt r ai # m n 18 19 3 5 .OnJnua' 27, 0,hsmatrwa dimisdwihpcudie(.49 . 4) a l 201 ti te s s se t rj c #3 ) y OnFe ray1 , 01 , RGUS N ildamoinf ra of y fe a dc ss/3 0 b u r 0 2 0 FE O ic to o t ri s e s n ot 5 ) le s edng.293202.0i a tr e sf e sa a l c ssund rLR 54- t r ug 5 - 5 i t e e l $ , 0 n to n y e s tx b e o t e 1ho h 4 1 n h 21 a omt$ 1551.6a d ohe c sst de LR 5 - 6 i t ea om tof$41,56.3. m t 2 , 1 n t r ot m r 41 n h m t 43 FERGU SON ie tfe t a isbilngrt swe e$1 pe hourf rpa te s $1 pe d n i d h t t li ae r 60 r o rn r ; 40 r 7* J - ho rf ras o it sl d $ 5pe h urf rpaalg l whih wasi c e s d du i g ltgai n u o s c ae m 7 r o o r e as c n r a e rn ii to t $1 5 pe ho rf rp nne s $1 0 pe ho t f ra s c aesa d $ 5 pe ho rf r o 8 r u o a r ; 6 r tr o s o i t n 9 r u o p z l g l. Plitfsfld ar s o s o M i c 1 20l (/ 6 )a dFERGUSON tld a a a e as an if e e p n e n z h , 0 /3 3 n r ie r pl' M a c 11 20l0( 3 0 e lon r h , #7 . Page 3 of6 Att ehe rng o M a 1 ,201 ,t i Co r a a d dFERGUSON 1 0 o istxa l h ai n y 0 0 hs u t w rc 0 % f t a be c ssa d20% ofala tr e sf e a dote c ssal o de e t er -a i gofc sst ot n l to n y e s n h r o t rd r r d h e tx n ot o c nfr t a no a o ntofa o ne sf e we e i cude i t e o i i a t xa i n o c ss o im h t m u t r y c s r n l d n h r g n l a to f o t . O n M a 21 201 , y , 0 FERGU SON fl d isn e d d bilofco t c ntr i g ist x bl ie t m n e l s s o im n t a a e c ssi t et t ln o n o $21551 1 (W1 a df rhe c nfr i gt a t os c ssdo o t n h o a m u t f , .6 # 8) n ' t r o im n h t h e o t u noti cl de any ator eystm e orany ot err ate notpr pe l t xabl underLR 54-1 nu tn i h n tr o ry a e t r u hLR 5 - 5 a d 22U. . .j 1 20 1 24. lo g z 41 n SC 9 - 9 OnJ ne4,201 ,PlitfsfldaM oinfrReTa ainofCoss(432 .FERGUSON u 0 anif it to o - x to t# ) flda Oppostoro Jme22, 0(/4 )a dPlitfsfldaRe l ( 4 7)o J l 1, ie n ii l n t 201 /4 3 n anif ie py # 4 n uy 201 . A H e r ng w a he d on Aug s 1 , 1 a l t e Co -i s e a f r a Or e o 0 ai sl u t 3 20 0 rd h m tsu d om l d r n Se t m b r20, 0r -a i gFERGUSON' c ssfom $ l5 1l t $1 , 5 . 7. pe e 201 e tx n S o t r 2 ,5 ,6 o 4 5 4 7 (/ 5 ) /4 3 . 1 3 I . CO N C L U SI N S OF LAW l O Tli Cou teane jtidito o e tedeemiainofatr e sfe a dc ss ls r rti d trs cin v r h tr n to to n y e s n o t. FER G U SO N ' M o i n f rAtor e sFe sa d Co t wa tm e y a d c m pled wih t e S to o t n y e n ss s i l n o i th 1 6 r quie ent ofLR 54- 6. e rm s 1 Thehoury b li grt sc a g db FERGUSON' c t s lm' r a ona l f rt e l iln ae h r e y S om e e e s be o h c r m u kt a d f rt es r i e pr vi e a d s i r t sw e e uo o pos d a e c s i e or o n riy n o h e v c s o d d n a d a e r t p e s x e sv o he w ie i a pr pr a e t r s n p o it . Thet xa i a d ot e co t s b i td by FERGU SON a e s ppo t d by t e a p o ra e a b e n h r s s u m te r u re h p r p it d c me tto a r q ie und rLR 5 -@)ai h veben a tai a dne es rl o u nain s e urd e 4 1 rd a e cu ly n c saiy pr d ded and m adc, o F RGU SON i c relal r e sf e i t ea ou to $ 92, 0 . 0. a a l co t i t e E n u r : to n y c s n h m n f 2 2 2 0 , x b e ss n h t a o ntof$1 , 54. 7 a d o he c s si t e a o ntofT 1456.3. mu 45 7 n t r o t n h m u 4. 3 - Ar a a d o a t r e s f e a d c ss i r a o a l i t i c s i ig to t e du lc tvc . w r f to n y e s n o t s c s n b e n h s a e n i h f h p i a i 1 na-reoftz ef ol expenced i tzscaszand bcexpcndcd ilf t r ltgaton Pl i tfl. tu ie f l l n ii o r u u e ii i a n ii s P g 4o ( ac : ' - 1 1 1 2 3 4 5 7. 6 c u s l vesae t bepe di gr g r i gt es m eis e s tf rh i ttsma tr o n e ha tt d o n n e a d n h a s u s e o t n ii te r g r i g t e W is o fti g i a d f e e tf r m . Spe ii a l ,t e ne d f rFERGUSON e a dn h r b itn s n i f r n o u c fc ly h e o t i ve tg t a d dc e d a c a sa to i t i m a t ra d i s bs que tpe di g a d t be o n si a e n f n l s c i n n h s tc n n u e n n n n o fl d ltga i n. ie ii to FEROU SO N ha s b t n i ly co ple w ih t e r quie e t ofLR 54 1 a d r q ii g s u s a ta l m i d t h e r m n s - 6 n e u rn a lne- y-i e and da e- y- at br at ow n off es a d coss woul notbe pr ductve and i b ln t b d e e ld en t d oi 7 8 8. 9 wo l c us t epa te t i c raddto a f e a dc ss u d a e h ris o n u ii n l e s n o t . The Co r Gnd t a a l w a d o 1 0% oft xa l c s spu s a tt LR 5 - t r u h LR u t s h t ra r f 0 a be o t ru n o 4 1ho g 5 - 5 i r a on bl al a pr pra e. 4 1 s e s a e ld p o i t 10 9. 11 TheCo r Indst a a i- rs a adof)5(0%)o al me sfe a dohe c ss u ti h t n n go s w r / 2 f to y e s n t r o t . s ugh p r ua tt LR 54- 6i a pr p it a dr a on bl . o tus n o 1 s p o ra e n e s a e 1l 2 0. TheCo r indst a peudgme titrs i nota ade bu pos-udg e titrs u t' h t rj i n neets w r d t tj m n ncet 1 3 14 l5 16 s oul bca ade fo tl daeo t ee tyo tej dgme ta t efdca rt . h d w r d rm le t f h nr fh u n t h e rl ae 1 7 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 // // 26 // // Jpge 5 ol6 '- I 1 l , 1 IH . O R D E R 2 I I H EREB Y ORDERED,ADJUD G ED , nd DECREED t a FER G U SO N ' M o i n TS a ht S to 3 frAtone ' Fe sa dCoss(/50)i GRANTED i pala dDENI D i pat FERGUSON i o tr ys e n t/ 3s n ln E n r. s 4 a ade 1 0 ofistxa l c ssi tea o ntu $1 ,5 ,7;o effh( 0 )ofisatre s w r d 0 % t a be o t n h m u f 45 47 n -it 2 % t to n y 5 f e al ot e c ssi t ea ot tof$ 6,316 f rat t la a dof$812864 e s rd h r o t n h m m 6 7 .7 o o a w r , .4 6 I I FURTHER ORDERED,ADJUDGED ,ard D ECRE ED t att e M oton f r TS z hh io 7 Atore ' Fe san Cossi GRANTED a t pos-udg e titr s a t efdea j d me trt t nys e d t s s o tj m n ncet t h e rlu g n ae 8 (hewe l ya e a eo t e ly a co sa tmaurt Tr a ur yil f rt ewe k beor J n a y t ed v r g f h -e r n tn t iy e s y ed o h e f e a u r 9 27 201 ,s.1 . Thedal lt f rpos-ud me titrs i .00 02 9315( .031dvd dby , 0i 3 % 1 iy 'e o tj g n neet s 0 0 4 a $0 iie 1 3 5tm e t et t la a d)o $0.907pe da ) u tl i ; 0 6 i s h oa w r r 6 r y , n ipad 11 12 13 D A TED : Novem ber29,2010 14 15 16 RE SPECTFU LLY SUBM I TED BY T 17 ' H onor bl Rob u .J nes ae -o Unied St t s ' 'tJudge t ae c O LSO N , CANNON ,GORM LEY 18 & D ESRU I SEA I X S J 19 By:s) '* ..Ctpe // ,6 zsy s 20 Phii S. r on, q. lp Ge s Es 9950 W .Cheyenne Avenue 21 LasVegas,N evada 89129 A tonz y f rDe c d n s t e o fn a t 22 Un t d Pl m bi g, ie u n LLC a d n Fer us n Ent r rses l c. go ep i ,n 23 . 24 25 l I 2 6 't :Tww'e c' ls rr.ozee ss l 5 0i 01 5 ht lhssfd r ' cv g N' iae . l / 0 2 / p/ . i e e , / r r oQ ' Pa c6of6 g ' ) j l 1 I l 1 @ ( l

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?