Slaughter et al v. Uponor, Inc. et al

Filing 468

ORDER Granting in Part and Denying in Part 350 Motion for Attorney Fees and Costs. Ferguson is awarded 100% of its taxable costs in the amount of $14,554.77; one-fifth (20%) of its attorneys fees and other costs in the amount of $66,731.67 for a total award of $81,286.44. Signed by Judge Robert C. Jones on 11/29/10. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - ASB)

1

2
3

4 5
6

UNI E D STATES DI TR I T COUR T T SC DI TR I T OF NEVADA S C

7

EDW I K.SLAUGHTER, .a. N et 1

) )

2: 8 c -1 2 - CJ GW F 0 -v 2 3 R ORDER

) 8 ) vs . ) 9 ) UPONOR,I C. M im e o aCor o ai n;e.a. ) N a l s t p rto t l l 0 ) De e da t , fn n s )
l1

Plitfs an if,

1 2

Pe di g be o et eCo r a e De e d n sUniedPll bi g LLC a d Fe gu o Entr rs s n n fr h u t r fn a t t t n, m n r s n e p ie ,

1 I c' Moto frAto e ' Fee a dCoss(/50 ,PlitfsOpposto (/63, ndDee d nt' 3 n .s in o tm y s s n t 83 ) anif iin /3 )a fn a s
1 Re l (/7 ) Dee da t'Moinwa fldbaedu o teCour' Or e ds isngtecae 4 py /3 0 . fn ns to s ie s p n h ts d r im si h s
1 (/ 49)a di snttngt eprte t fl b if o t cis e o fesa dcc t.A h ai gwa hed 5 /3 n n t c i h is o ie re s n h s u s f e n s s e rn s l
1 on M a 1 , 01 r g r i g t em oto sfl d,a t g o c us a pe rngt e e or . Fort er a o s 6 y 0 2 0 e adn h i n ie r o d a e p ai h r f e d b esn 1 gi e he e n, he M oton i Gr n e i pa ta d De i d i pa t 7 v n ri t i s a td n r n n e n r. 1 8
Slaughter et al v. Uponor, Inc. et al

1 FI D I G S OF FACT .NN

11 9.

On J l 28, uy 2008 PiitfsEd i K. a g tr Re e c Flnn, e He l ya d Ca o) , an if w n Slu h e , b c a i M l a e n r
Doc. 468

20 21 2: 1

He l y f l d t epr s n ca s o a to ,o b ha fo t e s l e a d a l he ssm ia l a e ie h c c t u e f c i n n e l f h m e v s n 1 ot r i l ry st a e , n t e D iti tCour f r Cl r Cot t , r a a De e d nt Upo o , nc ; iu t d i h s fc t o ak m y N v d . fn a s n ri . Upono N o t A m e i a, nc. U p no Co . RCR Pl m bi g & M e ha lc l l c. r rh rc I ' o r p ; , un c zi a , n ;

23
24

l trtt Plm bi g & Ai Cond tonig,LLC;Unie Pi r bi g, n e sae u n r ii n t d u n n LLC; r u o Fe g s n
Enl r rs s,l c, HughesB? t r& SewerLP'ars HD Suppl Cons r clon Suppl e p ie n ; ae S ll y tu i y

2 5

Li ie Pa L e s i a e a l ge t b e ga e i t ebusne sofd sgni g. ve opi g, m t d rn r h p r le d o e n g d l h è is e i n de i n

26

ma ufcu ig diriutng, rl ig slig a disalngteBrrboPEX pimbig , n a trn . srb i mal n . eln . n n tli h is m un

J
'

Pg 1f5 ac ot

l 1
1

i
.

1

Dockets.Justia.com

s sc ,W is obr s fti gs a d o h rplm bi gmae il a pa t -hepo a l wa e y tm r b a s itn , n t e u n t ras s r oit t b e tr s p l s se sofrsdc tald elngsi Clr Co ny,Ne a a. u p y y tm e i n i w li n ak u t vd
Pl i tfk a l g d t a a 1oft e W is o b a sfti gsi sa l d aspa t t tpo a l wa e a n ii le e h t 1 h r b r s it n n t le r of h t b e t r s s e soft e r s de ta dweli g i Cl r Cu nt , e a aa e de ec i e a t er s l of y tm h e i n il ln s n a k u y N v d r f tv s h e u t

ac e ia r a tc l own a d zicfc to .Plitfsa es ig t d rt ef lo i g h m c l e cim m s e n iia in an if r u n m e h o l w n

te resofla iiy: 1 podu tla iiy;()src la iiy;()b e c ofc prs h oi iblt () r c iblt 2 titiblt 3 r ah x es warny;()be c ofi pie warnt;5)bra hofwarnt o mec a tbiiy; nd ra t 4 ra h m id ra y ( e c ra y f rh na lt a
( )ne lge c . 6 gi n e
O n Se t m be 1 ,200 , f uda t r m o ed t el w s i fom s a e c u tt f d r lc ur pe r 5 8 De e n s e v h a u t r t t o r o e e a o t

pt s a tt t eCls Aci nFar es Ac (t A.A ' o t e g o ndst a t ea o nti l u n o h a s to in s t ' F ' n h r u h t b m u n r C )
co tove s e c e s$5, 0 ,00,he ei di est ofctze s i bew e n Pli tfsa d nr ry x e d 0 0 0 t r s v r iy ii n hp t e an if n
m or t a o e prm a y De e da t a d t e e a e c am ed t b m o e t = 1 0 cl s e h n n i r fn n , n h r r li o e r h 0 as
m em ber . s

OnOco e 1 , 08 PlitfsfldaMoint Re a d( 1 )t d rteç a daoy tb r 4 20 , an if ie to o m n # 7 m e h c n tr m ho esae'tlc lc nto es 'a dt iceinay'e c pinst CAFA jtidcin. m -tt' to a o rv ry' n t srto r ' x e to o , d trs ito OnMac 5 200 ,Plitfsmoint rm a dwa de id(/4) rh , 9 anif to o e n s ne /9 . OnAprl2 ,20 9, anif mo e t cri teca s( 11 ) Dee d nt rsond d i O 0 Plitfs v d o e tf h ls # 0 . fn a s ep e y
w ih mo insf rla et c nd c dic ve r#1 8a d/1 9)whihwe era t da d t e t to o e v o o u t s o o ( 1 n / 1 c r ne n h

h aigo cascriiainwa stfrNove be 23,2009( l 4) Att erqueto e rn n ls etfcto s e o mr #4 . h e s f
D e e da t U po or l c. nd RCR Pl m bi g & M e ha i a ,I c tlshe rng w a fn n s n ,n a un c nc l n ,l i ai s
21

c niue t M ac 29, 1 (/27 a dte move u b teCo rt Jnuay25 201 o tn d o rh 20 0 /2 ) n h n d p y h u to a r , 0 (27 ) # 2.
The prm a y go lml f c soft e dico e y c ndu t d b ' f nda t w a i r s o s t i r a d ou h s v r o c e ) De e n s s n e p n e o
Pl i tf sm ozon f rCl s Cerii aton. a n if i o a s tic i

7* D
-

D c e d nt a t nd ! de o ii nsof e s nsm os i o l dg a l -a lofD e e d n s f n a s te 5 p s to p ro tm w e e b e l fn a t; s he ul : nun c o scc u ii nsofw i e s s i cl di g t ena e pl i tfs i s ec e 5 c d el z r u l p s to t s e n u n h m d an if : n p t d n
Pagc 2 of6 ;

ho e viu la d 3ho esd sr c iey;atnda redu ont si g o mae il i m s sa n m e tu tv l te g e p e tn f tra s n Caior i ;s ug tdic veyoft ee pe t lf n a o h s o r h x r whos a fda i wa s bm i e i s p o t e fi v t s u u d n u p r of
Pi l tf sm oton t Ce tf Cl s i c u i g a pca i g t e M a it a e' Or e t t e a n if i o riy a s n l d n p ln h g sr t s d r o h D iti tCo r a d tl d a M o i n f raTe po m' Resr i i g Or e a d/ rPr lm i a ' src u q n ie to o m r y ta n n d r n o ei n t y

Ij ncino tl c ntmporme u Cha tr40pr-iiainpr cedngsbengfld nu to n le o e l o s p e cl g to o e i t i ie
duri g t e cl ssdieovc y perod. nh a sr i

0nNo e b r23 200 , antfs c t s lee td a e uia l r m ed pr vi e b t e v m e , 9 Pli if' om e lce n q tb e e y o d d y h

Cour a da r e t S p - ut ali dii uaswhofi dac a tr40notc ( 3 8 . t n g e d o t to ' l n v d l o ' ie h p e ie # 4 )
0n De e be 3, c m r 2009 Pl i tf s wihou notc t t epu a i e c a sm e be s w i dr w , an if , t t i e o h t tv l s m r , t e h

t erM otont Ce tf Cls (/ 7 ) h f i o rty a s /2 8 . '
O n De e be 7, 9, a n ir fl d a M oton f rV o ur a ' Di m i s lo t e e tr c m r 200 Pl i tf s ie i o l l z s s a f h n ie ty

a to (285 .A1Dee da t e cptUpon ro po e ti volnt y dimis l e kn cin # ) 1 fn ns x e o p s d hs u m s sa s e ig
13

tedimis lobewihprj dc a df ral wado teral rzysfe a dc ss h s sa t t eu ie n o ra r f h i tore e s n ot
(/ 1 , 6 31 ,319 3 0, nd321 . /3 4 31 , 8 , 2 a )
O n J nua y 5, 0, he r n w a he d o Pl i tf sm o i n t vo u t rl di m i s a r 201 a a i g s l n a n if to o l n a iy s s

15

wihou prj diewh ri teCo r saedta iwo l o l dimiswihprj dc a d t t eu c een h u t tt h tt ud ny s s t eu ie n ta ti is eo atre sfe a dc sswoudbers re frfrle he rng(344l d h t hs su f ton y es n ot l e cv d o lt r ai # m n
18 19

3 5 .OnJnua' 27, 0,hsmatrwa dimisdwihpcudie(.49 . 4) a l 201 ti te s s se t rj c #3 ) y

OnFe ray1 , 01 , RGUS N ildamoinf ra of y fe a dc ss/3 0 b u r 0 2 0 FE O ic to o t ri s e s n ot 5 ) le
s edng.293202.0i a tr e sf e sa a l c ssund rLR 54- t r ug 5 - 5 i t e e l $ , 0 n to n y e s tx b e o t e 1ho h 4 1 n h

21

a omt$ 1551.6a d ohe c sst de LR 5 - 6 i t ea om tof$41,56.3. m t 2 , 1 n t r ot m r 41 n h m t 43
FERGU SON ie tfe t a isbilngrt swe e$1 pe hourf rpa te s $1 pe d n i d h t t li ae r 60 r o rn r ; 40 r

7* J
-

ho rf ras o it sl d $ 5pe h urf rpaalg l whih wasi c e s d du i g ltgai n u o s c ae m 7 r o o r e as c n r a e rn ii to
t $1 5 pe ho rf rp nne s $1 0 pe ho t f ra s c aesa d $ 5 pe ho rf r o 8 r u o a r ; 6 r tr o s o i t n 9 r u o

p z l g l. Plitfsfld ar s o s o M i c 1 20l (/ 6 )a dFERGUSON tld a a a e as an if e e p n e n z h , 0 /3 3 n r ie

r pl' M a c 11 20l0( 3 0à e lon r h , #7 .
Page 3 of6

Att ehe rng o M a 1 ,201 ,t i Co r a a d dFERGUSON 1 0 o istxa l h ai n y 0 0 hs u t w rc 0 % f t a be c ssa d20% ofala tr e sf e a dote c ssal o de e t er -a i gofc sst ot n l to n y e s n h r o t rd r r d h e tx n ot o
c nfr t a no a o ntofa o ne sf e we e i cude i t e o i i a t xa i n o c ss o im h t m u t r y c s r n l d n h r g n l a to f o t . O n M a 21 201 , y , 0 FERGU SON fl d isn e d d bilofco t c ntr i g ist x bl ie t m n e l s s o im n t a a e

c ssi t et t ln o n o $21551 1 (W1 a df rhe c nfr i gt a t os c ssdo o t n h o a m u t f , .6 # 8) n ' t r o im n h t h e o t u
noti cl de any ator eystm e orany ot err ate notpr pe l t xabl underLR 54-1 nu tn i h n tr o ry a e

t r u hLR 5 - 5 a d 22U. . .j 1 20 1 24. lo g z 41 n SC 9 - 9

OnJ ne4,201 ,PlitfsfldaM oinfrReTa ainofCoss(432 .FERGUSON u 0 anif it to o - x to t# ) flda Oppostoro Jme22, 0(/4 )a dPlitfsfldaRe l ( 4 7)o J l 1, ie n ii l n t 201 /4 3 n anif ie py # 4 n uy
201 . A H e r ng w a he d on Aug s 1 , 1 a l t e Co -i s e a f r a Or e o 0 ai sl u t 3 20 0 rd h m tsu d om l d r n

Se t m b r20, 0r -a i gFERGUSON' c ssfom $ l5 1l t $1 , 5 . 7. pe e 201 e tx n S o t r 2 ,5 ,6 o 4 5 4 7

(/ 5 ) /4 3 .
1 3

I . CO N C L U SI N S OF LAW l O

Tli Cou teane jtidito o e tedeemiainofatr e sfe a dc ss ls r rti d trs cin v r h tr n to to n y e s n o t.
FER G U SO N ' M o i n f rAtor e sFe sa d Co t wa tm e y a d c m pled wih t e S to o t n y e n ss s i l n o i th
1 6 r quie ent ofLR 54- 6. e rm s 1

Thehoury b li grt sc a g db FERGUSON' c t s lm' r a ona l f rt e l iln ae h r e y S om e e e s be o h
c r m u kt a d f rt es r i e pr vi e a d s i r t sw e e uo o pos d a e c s i e or o n riy n o h e v c s o d d n a d a e r t p e s x e sv o he w ie i a pr pr a e t r s n p o it . Thet xa i a d ot e co t s b i td by FERGU SON a e s ppo t d by t e a p o ra e a b e n h r s s u m te r u re h p r p it

d c me tto a r q ie und rLR 5 -@)ai h veben a tai a dne es rl o u nain s e urd e 4 1 rd a e cu ly n c saiy
pr d ded and m adc, o

F RGU SON i c relal r e sf e i t ea ou to $ 92, 0 . 0. a a l co t i t e E n u r : to n y c s n h m n f 2 2 2 0 , x b e ss n h t
a o ntof$1 , 54. 7 a d o he c s si t e a o ntofT 1456.3. mu 45 7 n t r o t n h m u 4. 3
-

Ar a a d o a t r e s f e a d c ss i r a o a l i t i c s i ig to t e du lc tvc . w r f to n y e s n o t s c s n b e n h s a e n i h f h p i a i 1

na-reoftz ef ol expenced i tzscaszand î bcexpcndcd ilf t r ltgaton Pl i tfl. tu ie f l l n ii o r u u e ii i a n ii s

P g 4o ( ac : ' -

1
1

1
2 3 4 5 7.
6

c u s l vesae t bepe di gr g r i gt es m eis e s tf rh i ttsma tr o n e ha tt d o n n e a d n h a s u s e o t n ii te
r g r i g t e W is o fti g i a d f e e tf r m . Spe ii a l ,t e ne d f rFERGUSON e a dn h r b itn s n i f r n o u c fc ly h e o t i ve tg t a d dc e d a c a sa to i t i m a t ra d i s bs que tpe di g a d t be o n si a e n f n l s c i n n h s tc n n u e n n n n o fl d ltga i n. ie ii to FEROU SO N ha s b t n i ly co ple w ih t e r quie e t ofLR 54 1 a d r q ii g s u s a ta l m i d t h e r m n s - 6 n e u rn
a lne- y-i e and da e- y- at br at ow n off es a d coss woul notbe pr ductve and i b ln t b d e e ld en t d oi

7
8 8. 9

wo l c us t epa te t i c raddto a f e a dc ss u d a e h ris o n u ii n l e s n o t .
The Co r Gnd t a a l w a d o 1 0% oft xa l c s spu s a tt LR 5 - t r u h LR u t s h t ra r f 0 a be o t ru n o 4 1ho g 5 - 5 i r a on bl al a pr pra e. 4 1 s e s a e ld p o i t

10 9.
11

TheCo r Indst a a i- rs a adof)5(0%)o al me sfe a dohe c ss u ti h t n n go s w r / 2 f to y e s n t r o t .
s ugh p r ua tt LR 54- 6i a pr p it a dr a on bl . o tus n o 1 s p o ra e n e s a e

1l 2 0. TheCo r indst a peudgme titrs i nota ade bu pos-udg e titrs u t' h t rj i n neets w r d t tj m n ncet 1 3
14 l5 16

s oul bca ade fo tl daeo t ee tyo tej dgme ta t efdca rt . h d w r d rm le t f h nr fh u n t h e rl ae

1 7 18
19

20
21

22
23

24 25 // // 26 // //
Jpge 5 ol6 '-

I
1

l

,

1

IH . O R D E R

2

I I H EREB Y ORDERED,ADJUD G ED , nd DECREED t a FER G U SO N ' M o i n TS a ht S to

3 frAtone ' Fe sa dCoss(/50)i GRANTED i pala dDENI D i pat FERGUSON i o tr ys e n t/ 3s n ln E n r. s 4 a ade 1 0 ofistxa l c ssi tea o ntu $1 ,5 ,7;o effh( 0 )ofisatre s w r d 0 % t a be o t n h m u f 45 47 n -it 2 % t to n y
5 f e al ot e c ssi t ea ot tof$ 6,316 f rat t la a dof$812864 e s rd h r o t n h m m 6 7 .7 o o a w r , .4
6 I I FURTHER ORDERED,ADJUDGED ,ard D ECRE ED t att e M oton f r TS z hh io

7 Atore ' Fe san Cossi GRANTED a t pos-udg e titr s a t efdea j d me trt t nys e d t s s o tj m n ncet t h e rlu g n ae
8 (hewe l ya e a eo t e ly a co sa tmaurt Tr a ur yil f rt ewe k beor J n a y t ed v r g f h -e r n tn t iy e s y ed o h e f e a u r

9 27 201 ,s.1 . Thedal lt f rpos-ud me titrs i .00 02 9315( .031dvd dby , 0i 3 % 1 iy 'e o tj g n neet s 0 0 4 a $0 iie
1 3 5tm e t et t la a d)o $0.907pe da ) u tl i ; 0 6 i s h oa w r r 6 r y , n ipad
11
12 13

D A TED :

Novem ber29,2010

14 15 16
RE SPECTFU LLY SUBM I TED BY T 17

' H onor bl Rob u .J nes ae -o Unied St t s ' 'tJudge t ae c

O LSO N , CANNON ,GORM LEY 18 & D ESRU I SEA I X S J
19

By:s) '* ..Ctpe // ,6 zsy s

20 Phii S. r on, q. lp Ge s Es 9950 W .Cheyenne Avenue 21 LasVegas,N evada 89129 A tonz y f rDe c d n s t e o fn a t 22 Un t d Pl m bi g, ie u n LLC a d n Fer us n Ent r rses l c. go ep i ,n 23
.

24

25 l I

2 6

't :Tww'e c' ls rr.ozee ss l 5 0i 01 5 ht lhssfd r ' cv g N' iae . l / 0 2 / p/ . i e e , / r r oQ '
Pa c6of6 g '

) j
l

1 I
l 1

@
(

l