Slaughter et al v. Uponor, Inc. et al

Filing 470

ORDER Granting in Part and Denying in Part 351 Motion for Attorney Fees. United Plumbing is awarded its taxable costs in the amount of $10,911.29; one-fifth (20%) of its attorneys fees and other costs in the amount of $33,679.87 for a total award of $49,591.16. Signed by Judge Robert C. Jones on 11/29/10. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - ASB)

1 2 3

4
5 6 7
8
V S.

UN I E D STATES DI T R I T CO U R T T SC
DI T R I T OF NEV A D A S C FD W I K . SLAUGH TER ,e a1, N t. Pl ai tf s, n if Cas N o. e: 2: 8- V - 1223- CJ- W F 0C 0 RG

9
10 11
1 2

U PON OK l C a M i nes t cor or ton;et N n o a p ai .,
al, . D ef ndant . e s

O RDER

Thi oas i acl s ac i nl w s i agai stDef ndant ,whom mm f ct r d, ar eed,di hibut d. s e s a s to a u t n e s a ue m k t s e
13

a d ori s a l d a l ge l de e tvepl m bi g c m po e t , c Pl i tf sa l g c us d ha n, a e n / n t le le d y f c i u n o n n s whi h an if le e a e n or r
1 4

lkel t caus har i t e f t r ,t t ei r si encesl cat d i Clr Count ,N e ada. The cas has i yo e m n h ' ue o h r e d u o e n ak yv e
15

16 17 18

b e dimisdw11prj dc .BeoeteCouri Dee da tINI ED PLUMBI G, SMoin e n s se t eu ie fr h . : ts fn n J T N LLC' to
f r t r e ' Fe sa dCoss ( 351 Assae heei,heM otoni GRANTED i pa'a dDENI D o Ato n y s e n t .# ) t td r n t is n ln t E
i par. nt

TheCou t wad Defnda t TEDPLUM BI G, t e t pec nt20 )oftrquetd r a rs e n UNI N LLC w ny re ( % is e se
19
Slaughter et al v. Uponor, Inc. et al

ator e ' f es a d non-a abl cos s i cl di g expe t 'f es and tavele pens s i t e am om A of t nys e n tx e t, n u n rs e r x e, n h t
20

Doc. 470

$33, 79. 7. 68 21

The Cour a a ds De e da tI N I ED PLUM B I G .LLC is t x bl c s s i t e a ot tof tw r fn n - T J N t aa e ot n h m m
22

$10, 11. 9 f ra t t lf es and c ssawar of$45, 91. 6. 9 2 o oa e ot d 51
23 24 1 2y

l

Th Cou t w adsDee da t TED PLUM BI G , pos-udg e tit rs,r m t edae e r a r fn n UNI N LLC t. m n n e e tfo h t j

' t e l- earm am r lTr as n , el f rt eweekbef r J nuar 37, 0i . 1% .Thsdail r t f rpos hy h ' e u yi d o h oe a y 201 s 3 l' a e o t

o e ty o t efna jdg e to J nua ' 2 1 , tt efde a j dg e t a e(hewe k la e a eof f n r f h i l u m n n a n 27, 0 0 a h e r l u m n r t t e l' v r g

26

!jdg e :ntr s i umit ea a di s tsi da adal'ato .(3i7 têr . 0 1di iedb ' 65tm e u m n i c c t s lh w r s aife t ilr tt f 0) 1 2? T 0 3 v é )3 i s z '
j '

1 ns 1
I
!ëàC iC: ,t ? ' ? '

1 '
I

Dockets.Justia.com

1 t et tla a dl,mtl i . h o a w r ) t ipad
2 3 1 1 I x p l c s o v FAC T .q x on Jul 2g, 200 , a n if Ed i K . a g t r Re e c Fln , e He l y a d y 8 pl i tfs w n Sl u h e , b c a i n M 1 a e n

4 Ca olHealy f ld t epr s ntc us ofac i n, o be al o t e s l e a d a lo he s m ia st a e i r e ie h e e a e to n h f f h m e v s n l t r i l r i t d n u

5 t eEi ht J di i lDit i tCou t n Cl r Co n y, Nevada. Pl i tfsalege t a Def ndant Uponor h g h u c a s rc r i ak u t a n if l h t e s ,
6 I c. RCR Pll bi g & M e ha ia,l c. l trtt Pl m bng & Ai Condto i g LLC,Unt d n tn m c n c l n , n e sae u i r iin n , ie

1 Plm bi g LLC, r us n Ent m rs s,nc.andHughesW aerandSe erlp ar engage i t ebusness u n, Fe g o e ie I s t w,e d nh i
F ofde i ni g.de e o i g, a u a t rn , srbu i g, a k tng s li g, n i sali gt eW is opEx sg n v l p n m n f c u i g diti tn m r e i , e ln a d n t ln h r b

9 7 um bi gs se , W is obr s fti gs a dot e pl m bi gm a e i l a pa t t ep t bl w a e s ppl l n y tm r b a s it , n h r u n n t ra s s r of h o a e t r u y 1 s se s o r sde ta dwe lngsi Cl r Coun y, Nevada. 0 y t m f e i n i l li n a k t
11 2 J ai tfs alege t atç elow br ss'W i s o fti gsi saled aspar ofW is o n n if l h t l y a ' r b itn n t l t rb

1 Plu bng s se si r sde ta dwelng i Clr Co ny, v d , w er def c i e due t a pr cess 2 tu i y tm n e i n il li s n a k u t Ne a a e e tv oo
1 r f r e t a d z nc fc to . Pl i tf ss ed t eD ef ndant ,i cl di g U N I ED PLUM BI G ,LLC, 3 e e r d o s e i ii a i n a n if u h e sn u n T N

1 4

de tef lowigte re o lablt:()Pr du t a iiy;2 Stit a iiy;()Bra hof rs rh oi n h ois fi iiy 1 o c Liblt () o Liblt 3 ec Exp es

1 w arny ()Bra h o I ple W arny;()Br a h ofW a 'nt ofMcc an biiy;a d ( ) 5 ra t; 4 e c f m id ra t 5 e c na y rh m lt n 6
16 N eglgenc . Pli tfss ugh ge ea a d s e ilda a e i e ce sof$1 ,00,000 . i e a n if o t n r l n p ca m g s n x s 0 0 0 .0

17

3

On Se t m be 15, 20 8 De e d nt m o ,l c. e o e t e l w s i f o Cl r pe r 0 , f n a Upc r n r m v d h a u t r m a k

1 Co nyDititCo rt Fe ea Co r puru ntoteCls AcinFanls Ac (* AFA'.( 1 2 u t sro u to d rl u t s a t h as to i e s ttC '#) )
19 4 on Oct ber 1 , 2 0 , anif ildaMoint Re a d( 1 )u d rh t atao ' o 4 0 8 Plitfs ie to o m n # 7 n e te G rd tn m 20 hom e-saerç c l o to es 'a dt icein r'e cp in t c-lwj rs it n tt,xl a c nrv ry' n v srto ay, x e to s o w h uidci . o d o 21 22 5 6 on M a oh j, 200 , ani s moint rma dwa de id(9 1 r 9 plitf ' to o e n s ne / 4 . f / on Apri 20, 2 0 , anif fIdaMot nfrCls Ce iiain.#l 0 'h l . 9 Plitfs ie . i o a s n fc to ( 1 )T e 0 o

23 cou t c e fe pe m it d a pe i d o dic v r ' nd t r ug va i us e t ns o s s t a he rn on n h r a t r r te ro f s o e l a h o h ro x e i n , e a ig 2 Pl i if 'M o i n f rCl s Ce tfe to o M a c 29, 201 (2 7 b t smove u byt eCo r t 4 a m fs to o a s rii a i n n r h 0 7 2 ) u wa / d p h u to
25 J nua y 2.5 2O1 g2 2 . a r . O #7 )

2 6
.

7.

A subsanlalpartoft e dicove s c nduct d b) t e Dei ndant was i r s onset ti h s ro e ' h è s n ep o

.

1

27 1pl i tfs-m o:on f rci sscenii aton. a n if ioa fc i

'l *q '; . i '
.. .. .

: : (
I

'

h : . ua v . de ale c v .oz 'xe s s' 'ï.(I' ' nt' v .f r r s r r g .r la e :. 2 ) () 25 a b c ,k :. ' (.

l
1 '

r !

J n .- !age- (: ' 5

j l

' I

'

1

8 .

Thr ugh ut t e dic v r pe i d De e da t, i c ud ng De e da t UNI ED oo h s o e y ro , f n n s n l i fn n T

2 PLUMBI G, N LLC, te de a dpatcp tdi numeousde o iin ,ncudnga etmae nie( ) atn d n riiae n r p sto s i l i n si td n 9
ou o sa e de osto s r vi w e a d i ve tga e t ou ml sofpa e o do u e t ton pr vi e by t f t t p ii n , e e d n n si t d h s d g s f c m n ai o dd

4 tePlitfs atnde detu tvetsiga do viua is e to so a latfve( )home,a d h anif, te d srci etn n /r s l n p cin f t e s i 5 sn
5 a tnde m e alu gi a t s i g of u bi g o m po e t s l c e b Pli tfsa Se lJa or t e i E1 te d t l r c l e tn pi m n o n n s e e t d y a n i f t a w b a o s n 6 Se t do,Ca ior i , nd s ug tdic v r oft e e pe' whos a f av tw m s bm it d i s p or of gm lf n a a o h s o e y h x l t e fk i s u te n u p t 7 Pl i tfs m o i n t c riy c a s a n if ' to o e tf l s . 8 9. Si c t ei iito oft i c s , heDe e d nt ha e e ga e i num e ou m o i n n e h n ta i n h s a e t fn a s v n g d n r s to

9 ûl g an a gum e t r l tn t d s o e y a d c n e nso c a sc rii a i n.The eM oto si c ud d is dr n n s e a i g o i c v r n o c r f l s e tfc to s in n l e

1 aMoinfrPrlmiayIj ncina do Te poajRetanigOr e fjdb Dee d nsFeg sn 0 to o ei n r nu to n /r m rrr sri n d r ie y fn a t ru o 11 Ene rs sIc. n UntdPl nbig, ( 2 9 , l Plitfs M oinf rLevet FieaSe on tm ie,n a d ie m n LLC # 0 4 az anif' to o a o l c d d 1. Ame de Co plit( 21 , c teDee d nt,ncudigUNI ED PLUMBI G, 2 n d m an # 9)whih h fn a s i l n T N LLC, os d. opp e
1 3 l 0. OnNove be 23 2 09, antfs Com s l loeda e uia l r m e yp o ie b t e m r , 0 Pli if ' l e ee t n q tb e e d r v d d y h

1 Com'a da re t Ko to t' 1 i di iuaswhofldaNRS Cha tr40Notc ( 3 8 . 4 t n g e d o Gp - u 'a1 n vd l ie pe ie # 4 q
1 5 On De e be 3, 009 Pl i tfsfl d a Notc ofW ihdr w a ofM oto f rCl s c m r 2 , a n if ie ie tal in o a s

1 Cetfcain ( 2 8 . Plstfsdi no se la eofteCo r t fl a a e d d c mpan t 6 rii to # 7 4 anif d t e k e v h u t o ie n m n e o lit o
1 wihdr w t e c a sa l ga i nsi t e rpl a i g . 7 t a h l s le to n h i e d n s 1 8 1. 2 On De e be 7, 9, ai tfsfl d aM oto t Volm t rl D im i st i ltga i n c m r 200 Pl n if ie i n o t a iy s s h s ii to

1 i ise trt ( 28 1 .1 Dee da t,e c p Upo o , 9 n t niey # 5 . * 1 fn ns x e t n r opposdti vountr dimislsekn te e h s l ay s sa e ig h

20 ds is lobewihprj diea da a adofteratme sfe an co t /31 ,3 6. 1 , 9 3 0 im sa t t eu c n n w r h i 'o y e s d ss 4 0 3 8 31 , 2 t
21 a d321. n j
22 l 3. On J r a y 27,201 , t i Co r e t r d a Or e gr n i g Pl i tf s M o i n f r am r 0 h s u t n e e n d r a tn a n if - to o

23 Vot t r Dim is l i pa t a d cim is d t i lws i wih pr i d c ,i cu i g Pli tfs c a s lm ay s s a, n r, n ls s e h s a ut t qu i e n l d n an if' l s

2 alg tonsi terCo pan.#3 9 TheCou txpe syrtie jrs ito t c nsde Motonsf r 4 le ai n h i m lit(t4 ) re rsl ean d u idcin o o i r i o
25 Atorl ys'Fees and Cost tl d b) t e Def ndant ,i el di g UN I ED PLUM B I G .LLC. l re s ie 'h e sn u n T N 26 On Febr ar l 20l0. N I ED PLUM BI G .LLC fl d isM oton f rAtor ey' Fees u y 0, UT N ie t i o tn 8

27 a dCoss( 3 1.Pli if fldars on eo Mac î 2 )1$36 ) ndonMao 5l 3 09 UNI ED n t # 5 J am fs ie ep s n rh . 0 ((1 3 a rh , 0 . T 2 t LtX BI G. LC f e isRe l t Pamii Rtp n et i l oirfrAto n lsFzta dCo t.' 8 P JI N L i d l p) o ii fs t o s o : ' tolo trc' t n ss i i s sv i s
1 :
!
i

q
Prgt 3 oï t' '

1

1 i whi h UNI ED PLUM BI O , LLC s ppl m e t d is M oto a d i c ud d a Af d vi f o n c T N u e ne t in n n l e n û a t r m

2 Stp a i A. e, q,i s bsa ta c mpla c wihLR 5 - 6.( 371 e h ne Le Es - n u tnil o in e t 41 # )
3 1. 5 Att eh a i g o M a 1) 201 , h sCou la a d d UN I ED PLI M BW G 1 0% ofis h e rn n y t, 0 t i t w rr T J 0 t 4 t xa l c ssa d 20 o a1a t r e sf e a d o he c s sa d or e e t er -a i gofc sst c nir a b e o t n % f l to n y e s n t r o t n d r d h e t x n o t o o im

5 ta noa o n ofa tr e sfe we eicud d i t eorgna txain ofc ss h t m u t to n y e s r n l e n h i i l a to o t.
6 1. 6 On M a 25,201 ,UNI ED PLU M BI G il d isam ended bilofcost confnni g is y 0 T N 'e t i l s int

7 txa l c ssi tettl mou tof$70,22. 1(425 a dfrhe c nfnnigta tos c ssd no a be o t n h oa a n 1 4 # ) n u t r o i n h th e o t o t
8 i cl deany ator eystm eoranyot erm a e notpr pe l t xa l underLR 54- t r ugh LR 54-15and nu tn i h ur o ry m b e 1ho

9 28U.. .j1 20-92 . SC 9 1 4 1 0 1 . On Jm e4, 0, antfsfld aM o in f rReTa ai n ofCo t L 4 2) UNI ED 7 t 201 Pl i if ie to o - x to ss # 3 . T 11 PLUM BI G ildonOppoiinonJ ne21 201 g441, ndPlitfsfidaRe l o J l 1 201 N ie sto u , 0 # )a anif ie py n uy , 0 1 E44 ) 2 # 7.
1 3 1 8. A h a i g wa he d on A u us 1 ,201 a d t e Cou ti s e a f r a Or e on e rn sl g t3 0n h r su d o m i d r

1 Se tmbe 20,201 r-a igLNI'D PLUMBI G' c ssfom $7 ,22.1t S1 ,1l29/453. 4 pe r 0 etxn T 'E I N S ot r 0 1 4 o 09 . )
1 5 I . CO N C L U SIO N S OF LAS I V

1 6
1 8

1 .
2.

TheCou t xprsl rtie j rs ito t r l u onteDee d nt'Motonsf r r e esy ean d u idcin o ue p h fn a s i o
Loc l e 5 - 6 o ti e t e f lo i g f c o st c nsd rwhe a rr i g a t r e s a Rul 4 1 u ln s h o l w n a t r o o i e n h a d n to n y '

l7 Atonl y' Feesard Coss. tes t t

1 fe :()t ers lsoban da dtea oun ivoled;()tenov lya ddifc l oftequ sins 9 e s 1 h eut tie n h m t n v 2 h et n fiut h e to y 20 iv le ;()te s ilrquiiet pefr telg lsrvcspopel;()teprcu in o ote n ov d 3 h kl e st o ro m h e a e ie r ry 4 h e lso f h r 21 e plyme t teatr e duet t ea c ptrc ofh c s'5) te tefei fx dorc ntng n; m o n by h ton y o h c e ale te ae ( wheh rh e s ie o i e t , 22 ()t etm elm iainsi posdbytecintortecrumsa c s ()t ee peino ,e utton, nd 6 h i i tto m e h le h ic tn e ; 7 h x re e rp ai a
23 a iiy o t e a tr e s ( )t e und sr biiy oft e c s ,i a y;( )t e naur a d lngt o t e b lt f h to n y ; S h e ia lt h ac f n 9 h t e n e h f h 2 pr f s i na r lton hi wih t eoint a d( 0) wa dsi sm ia c s s 4 o e so l e ai s p t h le ; n 1 -a r n i lr a e
25 LJ I ED PLUM BI G , LLC s bm it d Af i a is of St phani A. Lee, Es . and -T ' N N u te fd v t e e q
i

26 The do e Pa ke 11 Es .w ih is M o i n f r Ator e ' Fc s a . Cos s a d Re l,t Pli tf s o r r r 1, q t t to o t n y s e nd t, n p ) o a n if 27 !Res ons t is li ton f r Ator e 's Fees and Cos s whih s bs a tall compled wih t e ' p e o t vo i o t n l' t. c u t n i l' i th

2 4rxliens t o Lot l l 5 - 6. 8 ; t u rl n s f - l Rue 4 1 a
' .

1

I
1 : !

!Cgt u (: àtr': ' M

1

'

1

4.

l d c m e t s bm i e wihUNI ED PLUM Bm G , n o u ns u t d t l T LLC' M oviga dRe l Pa e s S n n py p r,

2 UNI ED PLUM BI GSLLC' i v ie pr vet a t elw $11 bilda h u l rt o $1 5pe hol T N S n o c s o h t h a 144 le n o ry ae f 3 r tr 3 f rp rne tm e $1 5 pe hou f ra s caetme, nd $ 0 pe hourf rpa aeg lt ne Cou s lf r o a t r i , 2 r r o so it i a 6 r o rl a h . n e o
4 U NI ED PLUM BI G ,LLC a s a t ss t t e n m be of hou s t e 1 w 511 s e t on I N I ED T N l o te t o h u r rh a 1: p n JT 5 PLUM BI G , N LLC' d f ns i t i a to . S e e e n h s cin 6 Pl i tf s h v ha t e op oruniy t r viw a d r s on t t e e i e c UNI ED a n lf a e d h p t t o e e n e p d o h v d n e T

7 PLUM BI G ,LLC s bm i e i s ppo to is M o i n f r Atom e ' Fe s a d Coss i c ud ng t e N u t d n u r f t to o t y s e n l t, n l i h

8 Afia isofc t slal ivoie f rtxa l a dn n-a a l c ssic re .Plitfsdi no o jc fd vt om e ld n c s o a be n o tx be o t n u rd anif d t bet
9 t t eho r ybilngr t of ns l n rt enunb rof ur b le i de en i gI N I ED PLUM BI G , o h u l li a e cou e , o h l e ho s ild n f d n J T N 1 LLC,n rt er m ona l ne sa d ne es iyoft ef e , t xa l c s s an t xa l c s si c r e by 0 o h e s b e s n c st h e s non-a b e o t , d a b e o t n u r d 11 L N I BD PLUM BI G , TT N LLC ,
12 6. The Courtgener ly fndst a t ebul oft e at r ey' f es a d non-axabl cos s al i h t h k h to n s e n t et

13 i c red by t e D ef ndant ,i cl di g LT I ED PLUM BI G ,LLC,wilhave val e i s bs quent n ur h e s n u n NT N l u nu e

1 pr c e igsa dma no betes beto a atre s fe a adi t i ltg to . 4 o e dn n y t h u jc f n ton y 'e s w r n hs iiain
1 5 An a a d ofs m epori n o t er que t d a t r e s f e a d non-a a l c s s wr o to f h e se to n y ' e s n tx b e o t , 1 i c ud n e pe t'f e a d ta e e pe s sf ral nd ng nu e ousouto s a ede osto sn tc d b 6 n i i g x rs e s n r v l x n e o te i mr f t t p ii n o i e y 1 Pl i tf s i r a on bl a d a pr pra ei t i m a trbe a s oft ers t a t e De e da t , nc u i g 7 a n if , s e s a e n p o i t n h s te c u e h ik h t h f n n s i l d n 1 UNI ED PLL M BI G , 8 T J N LLC, il nc rd plo tvea t r e s f e i de e di gi e tc l s u si f t r w l i u u i a i to n y ' e s n f n n d n i a i s e n u u e 1 pr c e i g i o udi g, utnot i ie t , po e ta r qu s f rc a sce t i a i n.M or i po tnty, 9 o e dn s n l n b lm t d o a t n i l e e t o l s ri c to f e m ra l 2 a t r e s f eswe ei c n'd b Pl i tf sour de i i n t s e c a sa to s a u ,on yt l t ri t e 0 to n y ' e r n u e y a n if n c so o e k l s c i n t t s l o a e n h
21 casew ihdr u't e rM oton f rCl ssCe ii aton. t a hi ioa d tc i

2 2

8.

The Cour t n st a r q e tng a de i e ton off e i lne by lne da e- y- a e t' d h t e u si i ln ai es n i - i , t b dt

23 f r a , n / r e uii gl l Y D PLU M BI G , t pr d c r da t dbilngi voi e a o m t a d o r q rn W l N LLC o o u e e c e li n c s woul r qu r d e ie
24 I N I ED PLU M BI G ,LLC t unncces a iy i curm or ator ey' f es. JT N o s rl n e tn se 25
l

9.

A sa r s l oft e f c:t a s ve alDef ndant ar r quesi g ator el- f esand cost, eut h a h t e r e s ee ln t n .s e s

26 tl Coul fndst atani - r s r lngaw a di gatona l' f esand non-axabl cos si appr prat and le -i h t n go s ui r n t e 's e t e ts o ie

27 f dst a a a ur of12 oft e at n e ' f e a d non î xa l c ssi c n'd b) e c oft e M o i g m h tn u d 5 h to R l' e s n s - a b e o t n u e ' a h hh vn 28 D z e d nt . nc ud n t N I -' PLU I BI G . . .i a r a o a i a a d o a t r r 'Ff r a d no . f n a s i l i g . '., T 1FD N N LIC s c s n b e w r f to n l' c s n n I .
i
!
!

t
l

l

i

Ja;t ' oJ ' .. z'

!
:
i

1 t xabl cos s i cl di g expe t' f es and tavelexpe ses t atend t e num er us de ostons of a e t, n u n rs e r n ot h o p ii

2 De e d ntUpo o ,l c.spe s nne no i e b t e Pl i tfsi M i n a ols M im e ot . fn a n r n ' r o l tc d y h a n if n n e p i , r s a
3 10. TheM ovi g Def ndant ha e r quest d ator ey' f es, t xabl coss,and n e sve e t n s e non-a e t

4

txa l c ssi ac lecie a o n ofsi h l mor t a $1milon. An a a d o 1 5 or2 % ,o a b e o t n o l tv m u t lg ty e h n li w r f /, 0 $ f

5 a t r e ' f e a d non t xa l c ss i c r e by I NI ED PLUM BI G ,LLC a d e c oft e o h r to n y s e s n -a b e o t n u r d J T N n ah h te
6 M ovi g Def ndant i r as nabi undert e cic m sancesand fndi gsass tf rh above,asr duoi g n e sse o e h ru t in e ot en

7 t e f e r qu se by e c D e e da tpr vi e f ra r a o a l c le tve f ea a d o a pr xi a e y h e s e e td a h fn n o d s o e s n b e o lci e w r f p o m tl

8 $ 000 0.Thi a adofat r e ' f e a dno - x bl c ssi s e iial e t r da al thename 2 ,0 swr to n y s e s n n i a e o t s p cfc ly n e e g is t t d
9 Pl i tfs,and notc unself rt e Pl i tfs. a n if o o h a n if 10 11. The Com' tndst ati i r as nabl a d appr prat t awar UNI ED PLUM Bm G , ti h t se o e n o ieo d T

11 LLC istxa l c ssi t ea ou to $1 , 112 , s tf rhi LNI ED PLUM BI G, t a b e o t n h m n f 09 .9 as e o t n T T N LLC' Bil S ls

1 o Cot ontl heena dteCou tsOre (453,Thi a adi alos e ikal e trda anst e 2 f ss ie ri n h r' d r # ) s w r s s p ci ly nee g i th
1 n m e Pl i tfs a d n tc l s l ort e Pl i tfs 3 a d a n if , n o o m e f h a n if .

1 4

1 . INI ED PLUM BI G, LC inotntte t pr-udgme tntrs.Ho e e, TED 2 JT N L s e ild o ej n i eet w v rUNI

1 PLUM BI G , i e tte t po tj d m e tit rs fo t edaeofe ty o t efn lJ dg e tof 5 N LLC s nild o s-u g n n e et r m h t n r f h ia u m n

1 DimislwihPrj die J nuay2 , 0, tltea adi stsidi fl. 6 s sa t eu c , a r 7 201 uni h w r s aite n ul
1 7 1 1. O R D E R 1

1 8

I I HEREBY ORDERED , ADJ D GED mz DECREED t a De e da t UNI ED TS U d h t fn n T

1 PLUMBI G, SM oinfrAtone ' Fe sa dCot g351 i CRANTED i p r a dDENI D 9 N LLC' to o l r y s e n ss # ) s J n at n E 20 i pa t L IY D PLUM BI G i a a d distxa l c ssi t ea o n of l s l129. e tfht o l n r. m ' I N s w r e ! a be o t n b m u t s og . , -ll z % on
21 o hsa tm e sf e a dot e c ssi t ea o n of$ 3,79.7 f rat t la ad ef$ 9.91 1 . f to y e s n h r o t n h m u t 3 6 8 o o a w r 4 5 .6
22 I I FURTHER ORDERED ,ADJ D G ED AN D DECREED t att e M oton f rAtor ey' TS U hh i o tn s

23 Fe sa dCossi GRANTED a t pos-udgme tm e e t fom t ed t o e tyo-hetna j dg e t en ts s o ti n i r s,r h a e f n r tt ' )u m n i

24 1o Jnuay2 , 0 a tefd rludg e trt thewe kl a ea eo tely a mauiyTraur . n a r 7 201 , th e ea j m n ae t e y v rg f h -e r trt e s y
.

2 lilfrh wekbfr Jna '72 l i.1à T edi rtfr otu g etneetsu t . yed o te e eoe aun 2-O Os3?. h al ae o p sc dm nitrsi ni 5 z y j l
2 itea a di s tsi ca acal r t o .0 8 2% (, 0 1d v d d b . 65 tm e t ett l w ad:. i 6 h w r s aifel t iiy ae f 0 3 7 5. 3 i i e ) 3 i s h o a a r )untl 0 17 Ipad. 1'i 1
' a
-.

8l !
' .

1

t
r !
l

Z np:'v ' .c ir lcs r '. ' rca z ' ! 2(lC''25 h ?'u v f ce a r eas goîr k s g l .' / 1t J hF :. k

FagS t i1 ' ' ' 7- ' ''

l
2

D a ed Novem ber29.2010 t

3 4
5 6 U nied St t s i 'tCour t ae c t

o orbl Ro , J ne n ae C.o s

RE SPECTFU LLY SUBM I TED BY T 7

PA RX ER NELSON & A SSO CI TES, A CHTD.
8 9

//t/tfr eakrH1 s flpàc rql t 1 THEODOessonaRKER 11ES . 1 2 6 Pr fV lP lCourq Suie 200 40 o A 1, Q t
10

LasVegas N V 89128 , 1 Co c o m s lf rD e e d z 2 - t e o fn m t U nied Pl m bi g,LLC. t un
13

14
15 1 6 1 7

1 s 1 9
20

21
22 23

24
25 26
n
-

71 1 , >
-

8t

Ja c' :L ' - h; '