Slaughter et al v. Uponor, Inc. et al

Filing 472

ORDER Granting in Part and Denying in Part 352 Motion for Attorney Fees. Hughes is awarded $52,672.38, which represents twenty percent (20%) of its requested attorneys' fees and non-taxable costs. Signed by Judge Robert C. Jones on 11/29/10. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - ASB)

1 2 3
4 5 6

7 8 r a .1 .) ï UN I E D STATE S DI T R I T C O U R T T S C

9 D I T R I T O F N EV A D A S C 1 EDW I K . S AUGHTER, ta, 0 N L el Ca eNo. s:

2:8 CV- l 2 - J -GW F 0 - 0 2 3R C ( )

# *5 Z x' E pp
.

i: $ '

1 )
l 2 &s ,.

pani s lits

,
) ORDER GIAxaax c Ix PA R T AxI I DENYI G I PART HUGIES NN I

rrt% :nc 7
'

c. ,o : ' X z -. 1 V N- 2 4 5 *' 1

J. y 1 UPONOR,NC.e a. j 3 I ,t l
De e d n s f n a t.

j

V' TER & SEw ER I ' M o Tl x A oes o

x . z' @a
'

f Sgg l 5 rw J a / 16 crtë !z
-

- .-

k i l 1 '

FOR FEESAND COS S13 21 T #5

Y)' $îl
t .

uj ;
@

1 7
1 8
1 9
20 :l 1 !
22 .

T ics iacasat npoutlblylwsirgrigal el dfciepu bn hs ae s ls ci rd csi it a uteadn lgdy eet lm ig o ai e v
k d t l e l n fcu e , r ee , itiu e , n /r n tle l e l e e com ponent . oefn mzsalg dyma ua trd mak td dsrb td a do isald alg dy s
Doc. 472

Slaughter et al v. Uponor, Inc. et al

Y

de e tve pi m bi g c m po e t . Dee da t a e Upo o ,l c (l po o ' ;RCR Pl nbi g a d f ci u n o n n s fn ns r n r n . û n r' u ) mnn

l c a ia,nc (4 CR' .nesaePlmbig& Ai Condiinig(tnesae'aUnie Plmbig Me h nc ll .: R ', trtt u n )I r to n d trtte ' td u n , l l
'

LLC (' nie '; Feg s n Entr rs s Ic.(''r u on'' a d Hu he ' ae & Se e LP $U td' ru o ) ep ie , n 'leg s ', n çl l g s W tr wr

23 (C UGH ES-) ( l d fnda t .c le tvey,t l f nda t ' . Edwi K.Slugh e ,Re e c Fln , KH '; al e e n s o lci l s ee n se l ) n a t r b c a in

2 / 1Hely a d Cao Hell (olciey ' litf- alg ta te d fdie pu bn 4 Me ae . n rl ae' clet l. T ani s' lee h t h ee v lm ig v f)
ei ) o e r nh u e o h r ei ot n 25 ' com ponent caus d ha m . or ar lkel t caus harn i t e fut r .t t ei r s dcnces l ca ed i j s er
:

1 ' .

26 C l .k Count..N m ,ada. m )
-

/
:

Nou bror teCour i HUGIES'sltonfrAtone s Fc? a dCoss (?5',Assac a ch f ts I oi o tr y ' k n s t.:F -j ttd
hcran.la'A;'i .i G r nl d.i)pan anc D e i - 1lpan. zi it (Top s a e . r ) l n zJ r ' .

ny

Dockets.Justia.com

11
,

nx lc opA T ox s lFC
Th Co r fn sa fl ws e utid s ol : o
O n J l 28,2008,Pl i tf sGl d t e pr s ntacton,on behal oft e s l es a d al uy a n it e h e e i r h m ev n l

2I j
3l

4 o he ssm ia st ae , nt eDititCou tf rClr Cot t ,Nc a a. Pe . rRe ova ( 1 ,Ex. t r i lr iu t d i h src r o a k m y v d ( t Fo m l # )
5 1 . Dee da t a e ale e l e g g d i t e b sn s of de i ni g,de co i g,ma uf c rng, ) fn n s r l g d y n a e n h u ie s sg n v lp n n am i
6 di ti utng, m ar etng, seli g, and i sali g t e W is o PEX pl m bi g s s em , W i s o bras s rb i ki ln n t ln h rb u n yt rb s

7 ftig , ndohe plt bigmaeil Jd.a l 5 l ) itn s a t r tm n tras t r - 1, . T .
# o
'l . ..

2.

Pi i tfs a l ge t a t e W is o br s fti gs i sa ld i c ra n r s d nc s a n if le d h t h rb a s itn n t le n e ti e i e e

9 t r ug outCl r Coun y,N e ada we e d f c i e.The ' is o fti g a l g dl r a t d w1. t e ho h ak t v , r e e tv W r b itn s le e y e c e t1 h 1
l 0

) ï kV ' l ( '' :t Q: 5 z' J 81 roe T r. r. # .= , y ' l gj
.

wae i Clr Cou t i s c ama ne a t c us ac e ia ra to knownasde icfc ton. tr n ak ny n u h n r s o a e h m c l e cin zn iiai l Asars l o d zn iiain Pl i tfs f rt er aleged t a zi c l ached out of t e W-r bo br ss l e ut f e icfc to , a n if u h l ht n e h is a
1 ftig , ihi pardrsde c s plmbigs se sa dh me .(d. t! 2 - 3.Plitfstld 2 itn s whc m ie ei n e ' u n y tm n o s 1 a 5 2 3 ) anif ie

1 s i unde tef lo igt e resofla iiy:()prduc la iiy'()src la iiy,()b e c of 3 ut r h olw n h oi iblt 1 o t iblt, 2 tit iblt 3 r ah jx 9:) 4 x r s ra t 4 e c f m id ra t 5 e c f ra y rh na lt. n 6 .n z 4 1 e pes warny;()bra ho i ple warny;()bra ho warnt ofmec a tbiiy'a d() ey* k > I . ,@ .2 -)
.

a

% a:> .a . . q( )g 16

f' Rj 1 neign e (d aI 3 -3, x S y 5 gie c . I t T 49 ) '
On Sept m be l5,2008,Def ndant Uponor l c.rem oved t e l w sui f om s at er e ,n ha lr te

g!a j (' /?
4' ( A ? ' ' Q ë
.

l c u tofd rl o r p ru n t teCls AcinFare sAc (CAFA'. q 7 o r t e ea c u t u s a t o h as to in s t ' ' ' /l ' ), 1 8 OnAprl20,2 09, anif fldaM oinf rCis Cetfc ton./1 0)TheCour i 0 Plitfs ie to o a s riiai 1 t
1 t e e fe pem it d a pero of dic v r , a d t r ug va i us e tnso s s t a h ai g f r 9 h r a tr r te id s o e y n h o h ro x e i n , e e rn o
20 Pl i tf s M o i n f rCl s Ce t i a i n on J nu r 25,2 l , a n i f ' to o a s ri c to f a ay 0 0. 2l
.

V

h s bsa ta pa t of t e di c v r c n uc e by Def nda t t da e ha be n t u tn i l r h s o e y o d td e ns o t s e o

22 dcf nd agai s Pl i tf s' oton f rCt ssCertfc ton; c n t a n if M i o a ii a i

23

Thr ughoutt e di cover pcrod.D cf nda t at nded a d pari i at d i num e ous o hs yi e n s tc n tc p e n r I depostons i cud ng a e tm ae ni e ( )ou o sa e d posto s r viw e a d ive tg td ii . n l i n si td n 9 t f tt e ii n , e e d n n siae 24 1 25 'hous nds of pages of docul enl ton di cl s d b) t e Pl i tf s. r t i ed expens. atended ta n ai s oc 'h a n if e a n t

26 k d s r c î e t si g a d/ r Niua i s e to s o1a l a t fNe ( 'hom e .a d a l nd d m e a l r i a ! e tu tv e tn n o ' l n p c i n ' t e s i ' 5p s s n te e t lu g c l
,i

2 t tn -7 'esi g of pl m bi g com ponent sei ct d un s cc

li i tr' al Seal Labor t res 'a n it s aof

Segundo.

.d

. '

'

l Cerii aton' tfc i ,

2

Si c t ei iiton oft i c s , f n a t ha ee g ge i nu e ou motonflngs n e h n ta i h s a e De e d n s v n a d n m r s i ii

3 and ar um e t prm arl r l tng t di cover and concer sofcl s ce-iic ton; g n s i iy e a i o s y n a s ltt a i 4 8. On Decem ber 3,.009,Pl i tf s fl d a N otce of W ihdr w alo$ M oton f r Cl s 2 a n i f ie i ta ' i o as

5 Celfc to /278 . On De e be 7,20 9,Plitfsfld aM oin t Volmtr Dimiste riiain 4 cm r 0 anif ie to o t ay s s h 6 e tr acin.g285 . Al d fnd nse c p Upono ,lc.opposdt emoto a drquetdt a nie to # j l ce a t x e t rn eh in n e se h t
7 t i Co r dim istematrwih peudie a d alw t ed fnda t t mov f rfe a d c ss h s u t s s h te t rj c n lo h ee ns o e o e s n o t 8 (eenatrt e' o igDee da t' g31 , 1 , l 31 , a d3 1. h ri fe ,h ' vn fn n s' # 4 3 6 3 8, 9 320 n 2 1 M ) ,
u
Q <

9

On J nuar 5,2010,t i Cour hel a hearng on Pl i tf s'M oton t Vol nt riy a y hs td i a n if io u al

j
-

1 Dsi Wiotrui,hs orstdhtt ololds i wtpe d en tate 0 i s t uPe dc tiC uttetaiw ud ny i s i rui adhth ms h j e a ms h jc
1 is eofatr e ' fe a dc sswoul b rs re f rfrhe he rng(3 4, 3 51 1 su ton y s e s n o t d e e ev d o u t r ai # 4 4 . , 1 2 1 . OnJnuay27 201 ,hi Cour e trda ode g a tn teMoto t Volnaiy O a r , 0 t s t nee n r r rn ig h in o u trl

'' -

V

rë x; ê ; z >r * s 3. r # (' , g gy1 V tz j4 ) ' Nz 2 g *1 x . ,' iR l S jg j
,

1 DimisWIH PREJ DI E.g3 9.Th Co r rtie jrs ito t alw tedfn at t 3 ss T U C # 4 ) e utean d uidcin o lo h ee dns o 1 mo efrfe a dc ss 4 v o es n ot; 1 5 Dee d n HUGHEStldaM oinfrF e a dCo t /3 2 o F b u r 1 , 0 0 fn a t ie to o e s n ss 5 1 n e ray 0 2 1
1 (, eM oton,) TheFe M oi n rq etd fesi te a ou to $229,6193 a d c ssi t e 6 :Fe i ,. e to e u se e n h m n f 2 . n ot n h 1 a ot to $1 ,4149,icudig aBilo Co t d c me tng 558 8,5 i txa l c ssr/5 J 7 m m f 29 . n l n l f ss o u ni ,9 0 n a be o t /3 2 .
1 The Bilo Cosspr vi e an atda i at si g t a s c c sswe e r a ona l a d ne es aiy 8 l f t o d s fi v t te tn h t u h o t r e s b e n c s rl
l9 Ii c r ed, and pr vi ed i voi es f r t e t xabl coss, On M a ch 1, 2010, Pi i tf s fl d a nur od n c o h a c t r a n if ie ;

-

.

'1; : - I' i $7
z,

w mw

jya j ?l l
t' kJ k' 1K 3'
$
:
.

: g

R j ' -

20 Re p ns t M oto s f r Ator e s Fe s ( 363 , a dr s i g e c of t e M ovi g De e da t' so c o in o t n y ' c * 1 d e sn a h h n fn ns
211r que tf r fe a d c ss. On M a c 11 201 ,HUGHES fid a Re l i Su por o M o in f r e s o k s n ot rh , 0 ie p y n p t f to o
I 22 i sa d cos s (3 2 : ! Fee n t. / 7 1 / 23 I i

l

On Aprl 29.201 , HUGHES fld a Supptme t t is Fe Moto (/99 i 0 ie e n ot e in 1 1 3

2 j(' upplm c t'.pr vi i g e i e c of a d lona f e a d c ss i c n'd by HUGIES i t i 4t s e n' o dn vd n e ) d ii l e s n o t n u c I n hs
25 la to an r que tngagr ndt l lo $255- 7 . 0i l e a d $l 057.9 i c ss : cin d e si a oa f 5 8 9 n b s n 3. 3 n o t:
.

a6 i i I

Thi Jas pr scnt exceptonalcicum s a ces givn Pl i tfk. i iilon and pur ui s ce s i r tn Ae an it n ta i st

27 I of t e casc and cl s ac i n ferii aton pror l n't dr nrlot t e m ol on ï r cl s ceri-caton h a s t o z tfc l i i o ih a a . h l o a s tl i i
28 ! and dinnisalof t e case. ss 'h

1 lii a in i sa ec u t ltg to n tt o r;

l

2jl beforcedAengaeofscahe efonancnatsaatffssesivo Dmedhs nwr feptt Mvt DfdneiwrniatcMoi enat a g n ei i oi e e s y rne h n sfs n d oe g x d g 3l l wi t o a i du l tv f r d e p ns s b Pli t 'de i on t di ist e a
4 pr sentacton butcontnue t pur ue t ei cl ssacton i s at cout; e i i o s hra i nte 5 W hie t e bul of f es i cured by def ndant have val e i subs quent lh k e nr e s un e 6 pr ceedi gs, s m e s gnii ant porton of t e f es i cur ed w il be dupica i e. The M ovi g o n o i fc i he nr l i tv n

7 De e d nt s o l notbe f r e t i cu t e s m e f e whee t e f e ha e be n c us d by fn a s h ud ocd o n r h a es r h es v e a e
8 Pl i tfs de i i n t a s r c a s a ton s a u i t i ltg to a d l t r w ihdr w t e r m oton a n if ' c s o o s e t l s c i f t s n h s ii a i n n a e t a h i i
u
< <-

9 based on t ei deci i n t ptr uet e s m e cl s i a dif r ntf r m ; br s o o ls h a asn fe e o u
1 0 1 6. Local Rul 54-16 outi es t e f low i g f c or t consder w hen a a di g e ln h ol n a t s o i wrn

jV
'' -

c '' :*

1 atr e ' fe : 1 ter s lso tie a dt ea o n iv le ;()ten v l a ddfiut o 1 t n ys e s () h e ut ban d n h m u t n ov d 2 h o et n iic l f o y y
1 t e que to s i vol e ;( ) t e s il r qu st t pe f r t e l g l s r ies pr pe l ; ( ) t e 2h si n n v d 3 h k l e iie o ro m h e a e v c o ry 4 h

xJ E g5 1 1
>% *

;- V , % 1 p el so o oh re p o me t yteatr e d et a c pa c o t ec s ;5 wheh rt efe Jj 1a # 3 r cu in f te m l y n b h t n y u o c e tn e f h a e ( ) t e h e o ' x 0( r ,k , , jz ï 1 i txe orc ntn e t ()te tme lmiainsi po e by te cin or crumsa c s ()t e . ;* c j 4 s i d o ig n ; 6 h i i tto m s d b le t ic tn e; 6 h > x . u' @. a . ,s rw- 1 e pe inc ,r putto , nd a iiy oft eat r e s ( )t etnde ia iiyoft ec s ,i a y;( )t e . $ :o 5 x re e e a in a b lt h to n y ' 7 h l sr b lt h a e f n 8 h pt , E q N)' $
' ;ls. - :* J
S p I(v 1 ntradl g o te rfsoarli siwi te ln'n ()w rsns irae' gj 6 aue n e t fh poes nleao hp t h cetad 9 a ad i i l css nb i tn h i, ma 5

u: z
t m S '

1 7
j j l; 8 Coul

HUGHES h sa dc s d te fco ssae i LR 5 - 6 t te stsa t n o ti a d rse h a tr ttd n 4 1 o h aifci f hs o
l 8
.

V) q

1 9

I t e Fe M o i n, e e s c uns la t ss t a t e l w tr bil d a h ury r t of n h e to D f n e o e te t h t h a i m le n o l a e

20 $305.0 f r c u s ls tm e a d a ho ry rt of$1 0.0 f rpa aeg ltm e. De e s c un e 0 o o n e ' i n n u l ae 5 0 o rl a i fn e o s l
21 f rt er a-est t t e num bcr of hour t e l w tnn s em i dcf ndi g I U GH ES i t i acton. uh t soh t sh a ' ip n en' I n hs i

2 I an if di no o j c t eihe t ehou l r t sort enumbe sofh ur bild; 2 Pl itfs d t b c t o t r h ry ae h r o s le

j
J
1

'

23 g

Th s Cou ti f m ii r w ih t e c s o a l b li g r t s f r l ga s nrc s i sm ia i r s a la t h u t m r ' iln a e o e l e i e n i l r

2 ' a esa d fnd t a t es hou l r t sa e r as na l f rt e l g ls n ' e r nde e : 4 c s n i s h : h e ry a e r e o b c o h e a e i s e r d c 25 p j ! .
p I

.e Thi Cour i f ii r wih t i ac i n and t e ef or r quied b) def nse t def nd s t s . la t b s to am h f te r oc

26 #ag i s t e cls c riiato moto a d fndst a t e n m b r o hou s e p nde b) IUGHES I an t h a s e tfc in i n n i h t h u e f r x e d ' I E
J w asr asonabl : e e
*

u1ss11 n.-'C. h 1 sa -s1 . w.

1 w hi h aut entcat d t e i f r aton cont i ed i t e pl adi gs and contr i g t a s bm it d f es c h i e h n om i an n h e n - m n h t u te e i 2 and cos swer r vi w ed and t att e f esand cos schar ed w er reas nabl ,neces ar and act al t ee e h he t g e o e sy u;

3

22.

HU G H ES pr v d d a iem i a i n a d des rp i n of l g l s r i e pr vi e a d o i e n t z to n c i to e a evc s o d d n

4 t e tm e e pe de ,a wel a s p o tn a fda is o c uns l The ma o iy of t e M o i g h i x n d s l s u p ri g fi v t f o e . j rt h vn
5 Def ndant i cl ded af i avis of counselcat gorzi g a d s m m arzi g t e br akdow n of f es, e sn u fd t e in n u in h e e
6 cos s and t s s r l tve t t e f es r quesed. Thi Couz fnds t atr qui i g a delneaton off es t a k e ai o h e e t s ' i h e rn t ii e

7 i lne by-i e,d t - y da e f nna ,w o l r quie bo h pa i s t i c r m o c f e a d e f r a d n i - ln a e b - t o t u d e r t d e o n u r e s n fo t n
8 t att e Courti s ts i d wi. t e afi avis ofcounsel hh s a ife t h ld t h ; () .
a Q-

9

A sa r s l oft e num e ous def ndant requestng f es,t e bur en ofpr pa i g and eut h r e s ieh d e rn

%

10 r vi w i g r dac ed ine- y-i e iem i a i n, t e Cour fnds tït an i - r s r lng of f es i e e n e t i b ln t z to h t' i la ng o s ui es

i% s
'

.s., '

l a p o raea dtn sta a a ado 15o oe ic re b e c d fnd n i arao a l a ad l p r p it n ' d l t n w r ï ? f s n urd y a h ee a t s e s n be w r ia
1 otoes 2-;

ë 'z 5
>oe *

p: k

:- rC# l -= = % 3 5 1z $ A1 h h aigo Ma 1 , 01 ,hsCo r a ad dHUGHES 1 0 o i tx be t e e rn n y 0 2 0 t i u t w r e 0% ft aal s . m., + 1 coss and 20% of al a t r eys.f es and non-axabl cos s and order d t e r -axi g of coss t o p) e s.t 4 ee t 1 to n e t et e h et n to x ' m.1 > î u' >Q J a . ,
.

=-

G ) jra fl j

%p> $

i < X w; oU

.

S 9 o 1 c nfnn t a no a o ntofat m e sf e we ei cude i t eo i i a txa i nofc ss 4 5 o i ht m u to y e s r n l d n h rgn l a to o t.

ë* ( g
1

1 6

1 txa l c ssi t ea o ntot$5-8 8.5a d rrh rc nsr ig ta tos c ssdi n ticude 7 a be o t n h m u - 9 0 n u te o m n h t h e o t d o n l
1 1a y at r e s f e o ot e ma tr not p ope l t xa l unde t e Loc l Ruls Al ot e 8 , n to n y ' e s r h r te s r ry a b e rh a e. 1 hr

2. O Ma 2,00HU H SGe i a eddBlo C s ./ 11oimigi 5 n y 421, G E l t m ne i f ot (49 cnr n t ds l s/ is

m $
.

h *

1 jDee dnse cp Up n rtlda e d dBil f ss 9 l fn a t x e t o o 'e m n e lo Cot; i
l p r $

2; 0j 1
'

21'Ta (431,a d tee fe fld aM oinf 1Re- axain ofCossonJ ne 9.201 g : x # 1 n h ralr ie . to o T to t u 0
j ) '1 . -

2. O Jn 421,lnf fea Ojco tBl oCs adMoo tR6 nue ,00Patf idn b tno isf ot n yyyaj e iis l ei l s tno i
.

on

22 j u e 7, 0, ie p l o an if ' e to n to o -- n n l a tJ n l 201 HUGHES fld Re l't Pli tfs Objc in a d M o i n t Re - xsa d a

23 !Ame d d Or e Gr ntng i PM HUGHES M o i n f r Fe s a d Coss (/ 3 - 3 4 1 : ne dr a i n to o e n t /4 5 4 6 . he
24 'Am ended Or er atem pt d t addr ss t e er or se f rh i Pl i tf s M oton t Re-ia and i d t eo e h r s t o t n a n if ' io -x I 25 !r duc d t et xa l c s st $5.304. 7.consst ntu'h Pl i tf s'pl adi g: e e h a be o t o 3 i e i a n if e n t
1

. .

I i

26

On A ugus 13. 201(, a hea i g Mzs hell on Pl i tfs' N'oton t Re-lax. On t ) rn a s a n if l i o --

Sc t m bc 20. 1 .t i C ou tis ed a f r a O r e r -a i g 1 LJ H E F'co t f on $ . C8.i t p e r 20 0 h s ' r s u o m l d r et x n I G s s r l 5 8 ) (5 o . ' $5 3( (1 77 4

1

28.

To t e ext ntt i Cour ' tndi gs off c shoul be m or a pr prat l s tf rt as h e hs ts i n at d e p o i ey e o h

2 ac nc us o , ts a lbe d e e s c . o l in i h l em d uh
3 4 CON C L U SIO N S OF LA W The Cour concl desasf low s: t u ol

5
6

Thi Co r r t i e j rs ito t r l upont er q es f rat r e sf e a d c ss s u t ean d u id ci n o u e h e u t o to n y e s n o t;
The Fee M oton and Suppl m ent adequa el a dr ss d t e r quiem ent of Local i e ty d e e h e r s

7 Rul 54-16 and w astm el ; e iy 8 u
il . a
-

n e boury bilng r t ofcouns land t e ntm berofhour bil d t Hughes W at r l li a e e hl s le o e,

9 wasr as nabl f rt e com m uniy and f rtl s rvi espr vi ed and s i r t s wer notopposed as eo eo h t o le c c od ad ae e l0 excessve orotl r i e i appr prat ' i le w s n o i e,

%

i: ' s . .5 .q s'

l l

uucucss b tnil c mpidwi uerq ie e t o-- 5 -6a dr q iiga i u sa t l o l t , e urm ns ftR 4 1 n e urn ay eh

l' E !1 >oe X

1 l eb -ieadd t-yd t bek o no fe a dc sswo l n tb po utv a dcudcue 2 i -yl n aeb -ae ra d w fe s n ot ud o e rd cie n o l a s n n

r.r, ï 1 tep ris oic ra dto a fe a dc ss l = ë y 3 h at t n u d i n l e s n o t; d. e i < , fc tb 'm : = yZ'g 1 4 Thefe a dno -a a l cossic rc byHUGHESwer at al a dne es rl e s n n tx be t n urd e cu ly n c saiy >,G s I , 1, 1 ic re byde.l a t . -$ 5 n u rd Kn t t n; ed .. .$ = , %;R >w i d :L e$
Gg 'j

1 6

The t xa l c ss s bm it d by HU GI ES a e s ppore by t e a p o ra e a b e o t u te I ru td h p r p il

j,a ' u'
t
'

1 doc m e ttona rquie und rLR 54 1b)a dha ebe nacual a dne e srl pr vie a d 7 u nai s e rd e - ( n v c L ly n c saiy o d d n

I

@
g

1 ma e 8 d;
1 9 7
.

V

As ar s l o t e f c t a va i usde e da t a e r que tng a t r e s f e a d c s s e u t f h a t h t ro f n n s r e si to n y ' e s n o t ,

20 t i Co r tn st a a i - r s r ln a a di g a t r e s f e an no -a a i c s si a pr pra e h s u t i d h t n n g o s u i g w r n to n y ' e s d n t x b e o t s p o i t

21 a d tnds t a a a a d of t cny pe c nt ( 0z) of t e a tr e s f e a d no -a a i c ss n i ht n w r w t r e 2 OC ) h to n y ' e s n n tx b e o t

2 jnurdb,ahote v g f dnsic d gH G E .s raoala adoaony, 2 l cr ) c fh moi Dee at nl i U H Siaesnbe w r ft res jee i n n , un t
f 21esatdnsn-aal css ili epr'c adtvlxes taedt nmrs 31 e ïi no txbe ot nun xesfsn rec nsotn h ueu I no cdg t e a p e t e o 1 1
.

2 Ide o 4 g ps
i
I

,

icudig svca ou ofsae d postons 'hc Nf sng Dec da t ha e rqa se n l n e rl 1 tt e ii . F or i fn ns v e e td

25 at r e s f e ,non-a a l c ss a dt xa l e ssi ac le tv a ou tofsi h l'mo e ta $l to n y ' e s tx b e o t . n a be o t n o ic ie m n lg tl r h n
26 ln ilon. A n a a d of on -it ( ' ) or t en ) pe c ntr 0t ) o1 a t r e ''f es a d no -a a l j li wr e t fh l 5 . w t r e 2 t . - to n ls e n . t ntx bc 27 lc ss i e r e t Hti I E S a d e c of t r ot e n' h ng D e e da t . i r a ona l unda t e o t n u rd n ) GI n ah h hr l' oi f n n s s e s be rh
28 cicul salces and tnti gs r utl i in i nh b l duci g t e f es r quesec b) ' e n h e a tl

'

1 De e da tpr vi e f ra r a o a l c le tve f e a a d; f n n o d s o e s n b e o lc i e w r

2

8.

Thca a d o al r e s f e a d n n-a a l c ssi s e ii al e tr d a ans t e w r f to n y ' e s n o t x b e o t s p ctc ly n e e g i t h

3 na e Pl i tf s a d notc u s lf rt e Pl i tfs m d a n if s n o n e o h a n if ;
4 Thi Cour fnds t at i i r as nabl and appr prit t awar HU G H ES t xabl s ti h ts e o e o ae o d ae

5 c ss i t e a ot tof$ ,04. 7 a d t e e o e a a d d s c a oun i hs S ptm be 20 201 , ot n h m m 53 3 , n h rfr w re u h m t n ee r , 0

6 Or e /4 31 dr 5 , . 7 l 0. Dee da t ae n t e tte t pr-udg e titr s.Ho e e,Dee da t ae fn ns r o nild o ej m n neet w v r fn ns r 8 e tte t p s-u g e titrs fo te d t o e ty ofte fna J d me tofDimis lwih nild o o tj d m n neet rm h ae f nr h i l ug n s sa t
u
%
< a-

9 Prj die J nu y 27 201 untltea adi stsidi fl; eu c , a m , 0, i h w r s aife n ul
10 To t e e t ntt i Cour s Concl si nsofLa s oul be m or appr prit l se f rh h xe hs f uo wh d e o a ey t o t

ZV

t *' : Z. :
-

1 a at dn o fc, i s al be deem ed ass ch. 1 s i ig f a t t h l n u
l 2 ORDER

z' J p1 Joe *

7 4aï .j 1 p; % ' ,. lâ 1x ) 5 yz g q ) x . e' z ra t r g.p r % x/ G; j )t j
.

1 3

I I HEREBY ORDERED ta HUGHES, otonfrAtone sFe sa dCoss/35 1i TS ht M i b tr y , e n t 2s

1 GRANTED i p r a d DE I D i p r. HUGHES i a ad d $ 26 2.8 whc rp ee t 4 n at n N E n at s w r e 5 ,7 3 , ih e rsns , 1 t e t p re t2 %)o i rq e tdatne sfe a dn n tx bec ss Co bn dwi tec s 5 w ny ec n (0 ft e u se t ay e s n o -a a l o t. m ic t h o t s o . h
1 a a d o $5,0437,hi Cour a a dsHUGHES at t lmuou tof$ 7,76.5 f rf e a d c ss 6 w r f 3 . ts tw r oa n 5 9 7 o e s n o t.

;:a o
t $
'

l 7

.s u t Rhi Co rFURTHBR OIDERSa a ado pos-udg e titrs a t efd r lu g e t L n w r f tj m n neet t h e ea j d m n

1 r t t t e mov n De e da t.The we kl a eageoft e 1 y a c nsa tmaurt Tr as r yii 8 ae o h ig fn ns e y vr h - e r o tu t iy e u y ed

i '

V

1 lfrtewekbfr Jnay2,21 i 03%. Tedi rt frpsjdmetitrsi 9 o h e eoe aur 7 00 s .1 h al ae b otug n neets y 20 .00 08 931 ( .031365) Po t u g e titr s wil c mult at$ .9 da un i s tsid. 0 0 4 5 00 / . s- d m n n e e t l ac u a e 04 / y tl aife j
21
22

II TS

D
.

-RJ, D

V NORABLE . VVI Y D ON ES W

2l 31
24 l l
25 CI rj td h): jSuhn se , j

LN I E S A F-DI TRI T J DGL TTD T SCU
DA TED :Qovem be.rg apqz . yy
,

i

:i . 6! !

I ..-'t'...z.s':.--. 2-- ..c:E --. ?. -; -:---. .-. iRos m a h Nzl ssi n.Esq, e r ' ls i a -' l , -7 V. NBERG.V ) EI HEELER.H UDGI S.GUNN & D C L.LLC. N A f''z' ï)'. clnft'J. 'b.(. J (/;'&..t''-' -? t?Ft' (. D c /pl J ? r :à r ?fJ ' -t(.Jf ?l' k i? b ' 'ï ! k E- J . 1 .

.

.-

n8 D .'Eb ' i Fttda.o1S' tmbe. )C. t1 t s .l l - e e r2619 k- h è t p