Slaughter et al v. Uponor, Inc. et al

Filing 474

ORDER Granting in Part and Denying in Part 353 Motion for Attorney Fees. RCR is awarded 100% of its taxable costs in the amount of $17,502.72, 20% of its attorneys fees in the amount of $19,312.890, and 20% of its non-taxable costs in the amount of $7,111.50. Signed by Judge Robert C. Jones on 11/29/10. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - ASB)

1

1 SCOTT RASM U SSEN . ESQ. N evada BarN o.6100 2 HAN SEN RASM U SSEN , LLC l835 V il ge Ce t rCicl la ne r e 3 LasV egas, N evada 89l34

Tee ho e:( 0 )38 - 53 lp n 7 2 5 5 3 4 Fa sm ie: 70 )382 8 91 ci l ( 2 -8
5 Ator eysf rDef ndant tn o e RC R PLUM BI G AN D M ECH A N I A L.I C. N C N
6

7
8

UN I ED STA TE S D I T R IC T CO U R T T S
DISTRICT OF N EV A D A

9 EDW I K . SLAUGHTER, N REBECCA FLI N , ) CASE NO. 2: 8 CV- 22 - CJ- W F N :0 1 3R G

a dM EL a d CAROL HEALEY,idi iual , n n n v d ly 1 a don be al ofaIo he sm ia l st ae 0n h f 1 t r i lry iu td

2ZF 1 7Fï 2 ji !ji D' 1 UP NOR,I C-aMin s t c r o ain ., 3 r: O N , n e oa op rt : o tïb z 1 up xol xol'l AMERI A, c.a T iz 4 o t t. rl Cm.
z: :y 1' 1h :

H : ù

11

ll i tfs, aa n if

) ) )

vs .

) )

!Jtj lt
-

M i ne ot c r o a i n;RcR PLI M B I G AN D n s a o p r to J N
w

) ) ) )

:> QI 1 I TERSTAxE PLUM BI G & Al E ' 5 coxol l Tm o N N R Evo I- , uuc,axe a a lm ie v a i td
<

MEC ANIAL I C.aCai ricroain ) ANDMEC ANI AL,NC. MOT ONF R H C ,N . lona oprt ; f o H C I' SIO
Iabiiy com pany'UN I ED PLUM B I G . i lt T N LLC. ) , aNe a aIm ie la iiy c m pa y; v d i t d ib l o n t ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) J
)

) O R D E R O N DEENDA N T RC R PLUM B I G N

16

) ATTORNEYS'FEES AND COSTS )

I

17 FERGU SO N EN TER PRI ES. I C. a Vigi i S N . r na 18 a Fl ri a Im ied pa- ers i and succes orby 'o d i t lt h p n s m e ge t STAN D A R D W H O LESA L E r ro 19 SUPPLY COM PA N Y . a di s l e N e ada so v d v eor or ton;H D SUPPLY CON ST R UC T I N p ai O 20 SUPPLY . LI I ED PA R TN ER SH I . Fl rda MT P a oi lm ied parner hi :DO ES l- 0.ROE it t sp 3 21 CO RPO R A T I N S IX X X O Doc. 474

c p or to ;HUGHES W ATER & SEW ER LP, ) o a in

Slaughter et al v. Uponor, Inc. et al

22

Def ndant . e s

23

Thi cas i a cl s acton l w sui agai s Def ndant .w ho ar aleged t have manuf ct r d. s e s as i a t nt e s el o a ue

24 m ar ct d. dit i ut d. and/ r i s aled alegedl def ctve pl m bi g com ponent .w hi h Pi i tf s ke s rb e o nt l l ) ei un s c a n if

25 alege caus d har . o! ar lkei t caus har i t e flur .t t ei r si ences l cat d i Ci r l e m ' ei )o e m n h tt e o h r e d o e n ak

26 Co lt .N erda. Th c s h s b e dim is d u ih pr idie. Beor t e Cotn i Defld ntrCR tn ) Na e a e a e n s se t eu c feh l s 'l a . e 1 .
27 PLIJ /B I G .. D NIEC I . ! l ' L.I C .s N/oti n f lA tor e)' Fees ald Ctss ( 53) . s sat d -NI N AN ', i C A N ' i o b ' t n s I: ' lt #3 . ' l e l %

2 1eit 'tt i('ldipr 8 ilrn h vll oil .2a. c.e li l' l t tn at e
l
'

-

ë. .

E
Dockets.Justia.com

!

1

The Courtawar s Def ndantRCR PLUM BI G AND M ECH A N I A L,I C .t ent per ent d e N C N wyc

2 ( 0% = $1 . 1 .9)of is r qu se at r e 's f e ( 96, 6 . 7)a d 1 0% of is t xa l c ss 2 93 2 8 t e e td to n l- e s $ 5 44 n 0 t a be o t.
3 i cldi ge pe t'f e a dta e e pe s si t et tla oun o $53048.6. n u n x rs e s n r v l x n e n h o a m t f . 8
4 As s ch- t e t t l awar of f es and cos s t Def ndant RCR PLU M B I G AN D u h oa d e to e N

5 M EC H A N I A L.I C .I $72, 61. 5. C N S 37

6
8

Th Cour as a adsprj dgme titrs i n ta ade ,b tpos-u gme titrs s oul e t lo w r eu n neet s o w r d u tj d n nee t h d
1 yearconsantm at rt Tr asur yi l f rt e w eek bef r Ja uar 27.2010 i . 110 The daiy r t t u iy e y e d o h oe n y s3 . l ae

7 bea ade fom tedaeoftee tyofteidgme ta t efdea rt,Thewe kl a eag o t e w r d r h t h nr h u n t h e rl ae e y vr e fh

9 f rpos-u gme titrs i .00 08 931 ( .0 1365. P s j d me titrs wila c mult a o tj d n neet s 0 0 4 5 $0 3 / ) o t u g n neet l c u ae t
1 $.7 ada un i s tsid. 0 3 y tl a ife k 1 1 1 . FI DI G S OF FACT NN 2z y 1 nj 2 OnJ l 28 20 8pPli tfsEd i K.Sl u ht r Re e c Finn.M e He ly a d c r lHe ly u y e 0 an if w n a g e, b c a i I ae n a o ae ;( . E j': 1zw 3 1 fld te prsn c u e o ato .on be afo te s le a d aIotessmi ry stae .i te LIï 7 3 ie h e e t a s f cin i h l f h m ev s n I h r i l l' iu td n h a . ii 5i' ' : Zq's 1 oititco r orclr cou t . xe ad . oekn a t upono .I c. upono xorh Am e ia l c. 'l s 4 r t src u t ak ny v a t d ns rn. , rt rc . n .
.

-

!aEiI @, q r> 1! 1 UponorCor . RCR Plmbig & Me ha ial Ic. ltrtt Pimbig & Ai Condiinig,LLC; J5 p; un c nc , n ; nesae u n r to n
jE t ;éj -7 16 Unied Pl m bi g-LLC) Fer us n Ent r rs s l c. Hughes W a er & Sewer LP; and HD Suppl t un go e p ie . n ; t y
z :

17 Consr cton Suppl Li ied Parner hi ar aleged t be engaged i t e busi es of desi ni g. tu i y mt t sp e l o nh ns gn

1 de el pi g m a uf c urng.diti u i g.m a k tng s li g.a d i s a ln t e W'r bo PEX pl m bi g 8 v o n - n at i sr b tn r e i . e ln n n t li g h is un 19 s s e . hrr b br s tti gs a d ot e pl m bi g m a e i l a pa t of t e pot bl wa e s ppl ' y tm is o a s i tn . n h r u n t ra s s r h a e tr u l
20 s s em sofresdentaldw eli gsi Cl r Count .N evada. yt ii ln n a k y

21 22

Pl i tf s aleged t at aI ort e qrr bo br s fti gs i saled as par of t e pot bl w at r a n if i h lh is a s itn n t l th ae e s s em soft e r si entaldurli gs i Ci r Count -Nevada ar def ctve as t e r sul ofa chem i al yt h ed i e ln n a k ) e ei het c

23 r a ton k own a de i ciia i n. Pi itfsa e s ig unde t e f lou' g t e re ofla iil:( ) e ci n s zn fc to an if r u n r h o i i h o is ib lt' 1 n

24 p tdu tia ii '( )src la iil:( jbra h oïex r s wa r nt' ( )br a h ofi ple n'ra t' rl c ib lt : 2 tit ib l ' 3 e c - p e s ra l: 4 c c l t m id a r n l:
25 ( )br ach ofu'ralt ofm er hant bii):and ( )neglgcnce. 5e ' a r :) c a it ' 6 i
26 O1 Sept m ber l5. 2C(8. Def ndant t7 ) e )) e .ponor l .r m okcd t e i u sui f om sat cotn t . nc e ha tk tc l o

27 f der lcotr pul ualtt t e C i ssAclon Fainess Act(' . l'.' 0: tl gr undstl tt' anA unti ea lt . l o h a s i 'r 'C , -A', 1 ic o k ia ie o l n 28
i

l

1 c n r ve s e c e s$5,00,00.0-t e e i di e st ofctze s i bew e n Pl itfsa dm or t a o to ry x e d 0 0 0 h r s v ri y ii n h p t e a n if n e hn
2 one prm ar Def ndant and t er ar cl i ed t be m or t an 100 cl s m em ber . iy e , h e e am o eh as s

3

On Ocob r 1 -2008 Plitfsfld aM oto t Re a d ( l und rt eb an a o y home te 4 . an if ie in o m n # 7) e h ' d t r m -

4 sa e'ioc lc n r ve s 'a d*dic e ina y'e ce to st CAFA i rs iton. tt ' û a o to r y' n ' s r to r ' x p in o ,l u id ci 5
6

OnM ac 5-2 09, antfsmoto t r m a d wa d nid(/4) r h 0 Pli if in o e n s e e /9 .
On Aprl20,2009.Plitfsmove t c riy t e cls ( II . De e da t r s onde wih i an if d o e tf h a s # 0) f n n s e p dt

7 motonsf rIa et c ndu tdic v r ( ll a d /1 9)whih we eg a td a dt ehe rng o ca s i o e v o o c so ey # 8 n /1 c r r n e n h a i n is
8 c riiai n wa s tf rNo e be 23,200 ( l . Att e r qu s ofDe e da t,Upono ,l c. nd e t c to f s e o vm r 9 # 44) h e et fn ns rn a

9 RCR Pl m bi ga d M e h nia,l c. hi he rn wa c ntnu d t M a c 29, 0 (/27)a d t e u nn c a c l n .t s a ig s o i e o r h 201 / 2 n hn 1 move up byt eCo r t J nua y25- 0 ( 27 ) 0 d h u t o a r 201 # 2 .
11
-

A lhough r nni g at t e s m e tm e. a subsantal par of t e dicover 'conduct d by t e t un ha i ti t hs y e h

t2 ;r 12 Def ndant w as i r s ons t Pl i tf sm oton f rCl s Certfi a i n. 7 e s n e p e o a n if i o as i c to
!ë'& ,z q2' i-

! 1. 8 3 L:i- 1 'q 7
o :j j. y
.

Dee d ns atn 1 d p st n o p ro s mo t k o ld e be aI o Dee d ns fn a t t d 5 e o ii s f esn e o s n w e g a l, l f fn a te

ï

ll- b 1 s he uld nu e ous de ostons of wine s s i cudi g t e na e pl itfs i s e td 5 ho es iZ z L 4 c d e m r p ii t s e n l n h m d a n if; n p ce m

-'

! c qt : të x. o
<
x

r-- 5 15 viua a d 3 home de tuc iel 'atnd a r ed u o t si g of mae il i Calf r i ;s ugh i1 > s ln s sr tv y, te g e p n e tn tra s n io n a o t I-j:c 2,
16 dicover oft e exper whos afi avi w assubm it d i s pportofPl i tf sm oton t Cer iy Cl ss s yh t e fd t te n u a n if i o tf a 17 i cl di g appealng t e M agitat ' O r ert t e D it itCour ;and fl d a M oton f r a Tem por r nun ih sr e s d o h src t ie io ay

1 Resr i i g Or e a d/ rPr lm i a y I i nci n on t e co tm por ne usCha t r40 pr -ii ai n 8 tan n d r n o e i n r nu to h ne ao pe e ltg to
19 pr ceedi gsbei g t1 d durng t e cl s dicover perod. o n n 5e i h as s yi 20 O n N ovem ber23-2009.Pl i tf s'counselel ct d an equiabl r m edl pr vi ed b) t e Cour a n if ee t ee 'od 'h t

21 a dagre t ' p - ut' li di iuaswhofld ac a tr40 Notc (/ 48) n e d o ' to -al n v d l o ie h p e ie /3 .
22 On Decem ber3.2009-Pl i tf s w ihoutnotce oft e ptt tve ci ssm em ber .w ihdr u t ei a n if . t i h la i a s t e hr

23 M oto t Ce tf Cis (/.8) in o ri) a s /27 .
24 ( n Decem ber 7.2009.Pl i tf sGl d a M oton f r V ol nt r D im i s loft e entr acton ) a n if e io u a ) s s a 'h ie i

25 ( ,85) A 1 Def ndant .exceptUponoropposed t i Nol nt r di m i s ls eki g t e dim isalt bc #- . 1 e > s hs u a) s sa e n h s s o

26 ' ih pr idiea d f ra a 'r o t ei at r e ' f e a d c ss( 1 .31 .3l .3l .3 0an 321 . Nt q u c n o n ua d f h r to l lh e s n o t /3 4 6 8 9 2 d b l
27 (#è.anuar 5.2(l a hcarng h as hel ol Pl i tf h l otol t'1oi lt r 1 dinnss u ilout l1 ) ) 0. i. h s d 1 a n if - i ' ( . ula i) s i n ï tl

28 ; r il ic h le e 1 tè'(' u : sa c t t i u (tl tl1 dinls l il pr il i z alit a t1s i s c of . p c t ic ' ' r i lu ) l r t l d h u t èlk l ) s ' s . th e td c lc i t ii s u ' c 'l 1 s t jl ih l
.

I :

3.

, ! !

1 at r e sf e a d c sswoul b r s r e f rf rhe he rn (/ 44 a d 3 5) On J nu r 27- 0, to n y e s n o t d e e e v d o u t r a ig /3 n 4 . a a y 201

2 t imatrwa dimisdwihprj die(/4 ) hs te s s se t eu c /3 9 .
3 On Febr ar 10.20 l RCR PLUM BI G AN D M EC H A N I A L.I C . fl d a m oton f r uy 0. N C N , ie io

4 at r e sf e a dc ss( 35 )s e i g $ 6.64. 7 i at r e ' f e a d $5 .4886.Pli tfsGld to n y e s n o t # 3 e k n 9 5 4 n to n y s e s n 3 0 . an if e

5 a Oppo iin a dRCR fld aRepl t t eOpposto o M a c 11 201 (/ 7 ) n sto n ie yo h iin n r h - 0 /3 3 .
6 At t e hearng on M a 1 2010. t i Cour awar ed RCR PLUM B I G AN D h i y 0. hs t d N

7 M EC H A N I A L,I C .100% of is t xabl cos s and 20% of al ator eys f es and ot er eos s and C ' N ta e t I tn e h t 8 or er d t e r -axi g of cos s t confim t a no am ount of ator eys f es w er i cl ded i t e d e h et n to r ht tn e enu nh
9 orgi alt xa i n ofcos s. i n a to t

10

On M ay 25.2010,RCR Gl d is Am ended Bilof Cos s confr i g is t xabl cos s i t e et l t im n t a e t n h

ù
-

11 t t la o ntof$1 5 2.4 a dnon-a abl co t i t ea oun of$7. l .0 ( 427) oa m u 7.0 7 n t x e ss n h m t 1 I5 # .
l. l CONCLUSI N S OF LAW O

1r 5 q (, y ! o. i . l ë2 1 z' 4 1 RCR' M oton f rAtor e sFe sa d Cosswa tmel an c mple wih t e r q ie en s S i o t ny e n t s i y d o id t h e u r m t txuFè è = rJ- g l o 1R- 4- 6. s s f- 5 1 t )i ' jè é l 1 6 Thehourl biln r t sc a g d b) RCR, c uns la er as n bl t rt e c m m uniy a d f r l' lig a e h r e S o e r e oa e - h o o tno
.

Zzrjj 12 r1' EE :I(31 1 1 .E 3 q

Thi Cou teaie j rs ito ove tedee miainofatr e sfe a dc ss s r rt n d u idcin r h tr n to to n y e s n ot.

.-

.

17 t eser i espr vi ed and s i r t swer notopposed asexcessve orot er ie i appr pra e. h vc od ad ae e i h ws n o it 18 The t xabl and ot ercoss s bm it d by RCR ar suppored b) t e appr prat docum ent ton ae h t u te e t 'h o ie ai

19 a r quie und rLR 5 -lb)a d h vebe n a t al ' nd n c sarl' r vi e a d ma e s e rd e 4( n a e cu l a e e s il p o d d n l d.
20 RCR a t al' nd r as n bl i c re ator eysf esi t ea oun of$ 6.64. 7 a d c ssi cu ll a e o a e n u r d t n e n h m t 9 5 4 n ot n

21 t eamou tof$ 3.4886. h n 50.
22 A n au ar ofator eysf es and coss i r as nabl i t i cas i ightoft e duplcatve nat r d tn e t se o c n hs e n i h ii ue

73 of t e ef or expended i t i cas and t be expended i f t r ltga i n Pl i tf s couns l have h ft n hs e o n u u e ii to a n if e 74 sat d t be pendi g r gar i g t e s m e i s es s tf rh i t i m aterr gar i g t e q'r bo tti gs i a te o n e dn h a s u e o t n h s t e d n h is ' tn n i
25 dif r ntf r l . Speciical).t e need f rRC R t i Nes i at and def nd a cl ss acton i t i m ater fe e o tm t1h o o n . tg e e a i n hs t

26 and i s bs quentpendi g and t be fied Itga i n. nu e n o l ii to
27

28 I '
'
.

I j
4.

j

1

RCR has s bsantaly com pled wih t e r quie ent ofLR 54-16 and r quii g a lne- y-i e u t il i t h e rm s e r n i b ln

2 and dat by dat br akdow n off es and cos swoul notbe pr duc i e and woul caus t e partest e ee e t d o tv d eh io 3 i curaddii nalf esand coss. n to e t
4 The Cour tnds t atan aw a d of 1 0% oft xabl cos spur uantt LR 54-l a d LR 54-1 i ti h r 0 aet s o n 5s

5 r asonabl and appr prat . e e o ie 6 The Cour Gnds t at an i - r s aw ar of 20% of ator eys f es and ot er cos s sought t h ng o s d tn e h t

7 pur uantt LR 54-16 i appr prat and r as nabl . s o s o ie eo e

8
10 u 11

Th Coutfn sta prj dgme titrs i no a ad dbu pos-udg e titrs s oul be e r id h t eu n neet s t w re t tj m n neet h d
1 1. 1 O R DER

9 a ad dfo tedaeoft ee tyoftej dgme ta t efd rlrt. w re rm h t h nr h u n t h e ea ae
I IS H ER EB Y OR D E R ED ,A D JU D E D and DECR EE D t atRCR' M oton f rAtor ey' T h S i o tn s

tzr 1 f e a d coss ( 353 i GRANTED i pa ta d DENI D i pa t RCR i a a de 1 0% of is zr 2 es n t # )s n rn E n r. swr d 0 t /j' EZ ë .- !I ' ? 3 a a l o t n h m u t f 75 27 . 0 f t t r e s e s n h m u t f 93 28 a d l'èF 1 tx bec ssi tea o n o $1 ,0 .4 2 % o i a o n y fe i tea o n o $1 , 1 .9, n nl sl :j; ë. k ' I-z 1 : -z 4 2 % o-t n ntx bec ssi t ea o n o- 7l lst. 0 fi o -a a l o t n h m u t fs .l ) s !a t r<j =r:kt j Eë s jj
.

-

-

)il éc
2 1 //// 6
17 //// 18 ////

19 I/// 20 ////
21 ''// //
:: ,''ï 22 // / :1

23
24

ê?: '1 (

.'y .

'//? '

25
26 '

''

2C
;8 ' !
,
.

! :

J

.

j

-

1

I IS FU R T H ER OR D ER E D ,ADJUD G ED and D EC R E ED t att e M oton f rA tor ey' T hh i o tn s

2 Fe sa dCossi GRANTED a t pos-udg e titrs a tefdea j dg en rt.Thedal rt en ts s o ti m n neet t h e rlu m t ae iy ae

3 frpos-udg e titrs i (0000 8 9 1 tme $4 .27.3)$ .7ada . o tj m n neet s . 0 4 3 5 i s 39 1 03 y
4
5
6 7 HON O RA B L U N I ED ST T O BER T C . JON ES S D I TR I T JUDG E S C

I IS SO O R D E R ED . T

D A TED : Novem ber29j2010
8

9 Subm it d: te 10 HAN SEN RASM U SSEN

ï 1 1 w 2z i 1 ?nk 2 ! E :l ' F 7 7 1;i 13 @ Jé' i' i ::p z 1 '< -z 4 5 ! =xt: ht ë

, a .scot arx lx- , z & t z- ls z e

r- '; 1 Fa smie:(02)38 -891 E è 5 ci i 7 ;. 28 i . 1 s ot- hr vlu. o r 6 c tsa n a c m i ;2 4.
.

s o'' R s uss x, o. c rr A v n Es xe a aBa xo. 00 v d r 61 uAx ssx RA su u sssx Iuc 1 35Vilg Ce trCici 8 l e ne r e a La ve a xevada 89134 s gs Tee h n :(0 )3 55 3 lp o e 7 2 8 -5 3
.

.

17 18

19 20 21 22 23 24
25 26 27

21 8
1 :
'
-

j,

l ;

)