Slaughter et al v. Uponor, Inc. et al

Filing 476

ORDER Granting in Part and Denying in Part 354 Motion for Attorney Fees. The Court awards Defendant Interstate Plumbing & Air Condition, LLC twenty percent (20%) of its requested attorneys' fees and non-taxable costs, including experts& #039; fees, in the amount of $53,831.25. The Court awards Defendant Interstate Plumbing & Air Conditioning, LLC taxable costs in the amount of $15,469.00. As such, the Court award Defendant Interstate Plumbing & Air Conditioning, LLC its attorneys' fees and costs in the total amount of $69,300.25. Signed by Judge Robert C. Jones on 11/29/10. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - ASB)

1

2
3

U N I E D STA T E S DI T R I T CO U R T T S C DI TR I T O F N EVAD A S C

4

5 EDW I K .SLAUGHTEK REBECCA FLI N , Ca eNo. N N s :
6

2: 8 CV- 1 23- CJ GW F O- 02 R -

a d SI L a d CAR OL HLAT Y , nd vi ua l nEn T i i d ly a d on be al ofal ot e ss m iary sitat do n hf 1 h r i l l tz e Pi a ntfs i if ,
v s.

7
8

9
10

U PO N O R , N C . a M i nes t co or ton; 1, n o a m ai

OR D E R ON DE FE N D A G I TE K ST A I E N '

U PON OR NORTH AM ERI A m C.a C ,

PLUM BI G & AI CONII I M NG, N R IT O

Slaughter et al v. Uponor, Inc. et al

11 M i e ou c r o a i n; R CR PLUNI m G A' D I,, S M O T I N FOR ATTO R N EY S' rs m o p r to B N IC S O M BC H A N I A L,I C . a Ca io n a c r o a i n; FEES A N C O ST S C N, lf r i o p r to m 1 m TER STA IE PLUM BING & AI 2 ' I R 1 C ON D I I N W G , 3 TO LLC,a N e a a l ie v d i td m la iiy o m pa y; TED PLLM BW G,LLC, i b lt o n UNI F 1 a Ne a a lm ie la iiy co pa l ; 4 v d i t d i b it m ry FER G U SO N EN TER PP SE S,m C . aV igi i J , r na 1 cor orato ;H U GH E S W A T ER & SEW E R L P, 5 in p 1 aFl zdalm ie pa t e s i a d s c es o by 6 oi i td rn rh p n u c s r m e ge t STAN D AR D W H O LE SM . r ro E 1 SUPPLY COO A I , d s ol e N e a a 7 W a is v d v d c p o a i n;1 D SI PPLY CON STR U CTI N o r to 1 J O 1 stp ptv LI ITED PARTNERSHI , orda 8 NI P aFl i . l lm ie pa t e s i , D O E S 1 30, 9 i t d rn r h p' - ROE C O R PO R A TI N S I XA- . O -' X
Doc. 476

20
21

D ef ndant . e s

22

23

Thi c s i ac a sa to lw s i a ans De e da t , s a e s l s c in a u t g i t f n n s who ae al ge t ha en a uf c u e , r le d o v a n a t r d

sr b l d n o n t le le l f tv u n o n n s c an i f 24 m ar et d, dit i u e ,a d/ ri s a l d a l ged y de ec i epl m bi g c m po e t ,wbj b Pi i tf s kc r 25 alege caused ha m . o a e lke j t c us h l li t e f tle t t e rr sde c sl ca e i Cl r l r r r i l'o a e am n h ut . o h i e i n e o t d n ak
26 Count'Ne ad .Theca ehasbe n d s és e Mrh pr j die.Be or t eCou i Defnd a l. v a s e in s d i qu r t f el a n s e mt

27 I TERS ATE P LM BI G & .J CONDI I NI G. .' M oîn f r - z e s F e a dCo t. I N T LI N XR T O -N Ll ' to o Aton y ' e s n ss Cs t
2 j J5 .AEsae h ri .i àt to?i Gru e .l p r. F I ?4 p :td ezn t t i: s a td i aL wo k I
I
Dockets.Justia.com

1

TheCo r a a dsDe e da tI TERSTA TE PLL BW G & AI CONDI I N I Q LLC u tw r fn n N M R TO N

2
4

e1)pec nt(0O )ofisr quetdatr e s'fe a dnon-a a l c ss icudnge pet'fe 1 : re 2 A t e se ton y e s n 1 tx be o t,n l i x rs e s
The Cour a a dsD e e da tI TER STA TE PLI M B I G & AI COND I I O tw r fn n N J N R TO G, LLC

3 a d t a e e pe s s i t et t la o m to $53, 31. 5. n rv l x n e , n h o a m t f 82

5 txa l cossi t ea o ntof$1 , 6 . 0. a be t n h m u 54 9 0
6 A ss c ,t e t t la a d o f esa d o ss t De e da tI TE R STA TE PLU M B L G & A I u h h oa w r f e n o t o fn n N N R

7 CON D I I N L G , T O N LLC i $69 300. 5. s,2

8

TheCour a a dsDe e d ntW TER STATE PLUM BI G & AI CONDI I NI G, tw r fn a N R T O N LLC

9 osju sne titrs a tl fdea j dgme trt.Thewe kl a ea eoftl ly a co sa t t d n n ee t tle e rlu n ae e y v rg lc -e r n tn
1 m a u ij Tr w tt yi l f rt ew e k be o e J nu r 27. 0 i . 1 . da l r t f rpos0 t rtr e sty e d o h ' e f r a a y 201 s 3 % The iy a e o t

11 'dm e titrs i .00 08 931 ( .031365 .Pos-udgme titr s wila c mult a $.81% u n n ee ts 0 0 4 5 $0 / ) tj n ne et l c u ae t 5 / 1 t tlstsid (000008 9 15*$69300.5 . 2 m i aife . 43 , 2)
11 3.
1 4

FI D I G S O F FA C T NN
1.

( n J l 28, ) u y 2008, a ntf sEdw i K . a ght r Re ec a Flnn,M e H e l y a d Pl i if n Sl u e , b c i 1 ae n

15 Ca o H ea e fl d t e pr s n a to o be a foft e s l e a d a 1o he s sm ia st a e , n t e . r l ly ie h e e t c i m n h l h m e v s n 1 t r i lr iu t d i h
16 Ei ht Judi i lD itrctCourti Ci r Cot t ,N eva a.Pl i tff alege t atD ef nda t Uponor, gh ca s i n ak m y d an i s l h e ns

un c n c l I . n e sae u n r n totn , Unie 17 l c., RCR Pl m bi g & M e hn ia , nc,i tr tt Plm bi g & Ai Co dii ri g LLC, t d n ro e p ie , n , n ' h s tr n w r l r n gd n h 18 Pl m bi g, LLC,Fe gus n Ent r rs s l c.a dIug c W ae a d Se e LP aee ga e i t e un
1 busne s o de i n ng, ve o i g, a uf c ui g, s rbu i g, a ke i g, e lug,a d i s a lng t e 9 i s f s g i de l p n m n a t ln diti tn m r tn s li n n t li h 20 w îs o PEX pl m bi g s s e , nc ud ng W i s o b a sf ti gs a pa toft epot bl w a e s ppl rb u n y tm i l i r b r s itn , s r h a e tr u y

21 s se sofr sde ta d eli gsi Clr Co mt , vad . y tm e i n i l w ln n a k t y Ne a
22 2.

Pl itfsal get a 'y lo br s 'W is o fti gsi sal d a pad o W is o an if le h t çel w a s' rb itn n t le s f rb

23 pl m bi g s s e s i r s de ta dw e lngs i Cl r Count , e a a, r de e tve d et a p oc s u n y t m n e i n i l li u a k y N v d a e f ci u o r e s 2 r f r e t a de i c f c ton. Pl i tf ss e t eD e e da s i c ud ng I TE R STA TE PLI V BI G 4 e e r d o s z n ii a i a n if u d h fn m ,n l i N JN '
25 ( A . CON- T I NT G, tJ R D T O -N LLC.unde t ef lowi gt e re ofla iil:( J oduc la iiy;( ) r h o i n h o i s ib lt' 1 pr t ib lt 2
. .

26 src ia iiy;( ) ea h ofe p e swal np' ï ) e c o 'm ple wa r nt t( )b e c ofwa r nt ti: l b lt 3 br c x r s r- ' 4 br a h 1i id ra y 5 r a b a: ra y
o
-

7 Ifme ha tbiiy a dt . n gi n e Panis og : zea adsci dmae i ecs o' o a ni lt; n 6 el ec. i tf suh gnr!u pca a gsn xes f )g if l
.

I

j
1
1
!

-E I )?ttt.ll. ? '' S (.l h- o 0(. L è tt l I
n - . .. .

j(L t(.y, . ); j.k . 1s n

'

3.

On Se t m be 1 ,2 08 D e e da tUpo o , nc r m ove t e l w s i fom Cl r p e r 5 0 , fn n n rl .e d h a ut r ak

2 Comt DititCo r t Fe ea Co rpu s a t oteCls AcinFam esAc (t AF '.# 1 t y src u to d r l u t ru n t h a s t o i s tt A ' ( ) C )
3
5
6

4.

OnAprl20,2009, antfsfldaM oin frCls Cetfo ton.g 11 J''e i Pli if ie to o a s ri ai # 0 fh

4 Cou tt e e û e pe nit d ape i d ofdi c ve y a d t r ugh v r o s e t nsons s tahea i g f r r h r a r n te ro s o r n ho aiu xe i , e rn o

li tfs M oton f rCls Ce tic ton o J nua y 25 2010. an if ' i o a s rii ai n a r ,
5. A s bsanta pa toft e di c ve y co duc ed by D e e da t t da e i c ud ng u t il r h so r n t f n n s o t, n l i

7

e e da tW TEI S A TE PLUM BI G & AI . fn n LT N R CONDI I NI G, T O N LLC,hasbe n t de e d a ang e o fn g i t

8 Pl i tfs M oton f rCl s Ce tfc to . nn if ' i o a s riiai n 9 l 0 6. Thr ugbo tt edic ve r ro ,De e da t,i cl d n De e da tI TFR STA ' o u h s o o pe i d f n n s n u i g f n n N I Y

LIM BI G & M R CONDI I N I G,LLC,a tnde a d pa tcpaediln m e o sde ostox, J N TO N te d n ri i t l u r u p iirs

l1 icudnga etm ae nie()o tofsaede ostons rviweda dive tgae t ola dsofpa c n l i n si td n 9 u tt p ii ,e e n n si td h ts n gs
1 ofdoc m e t ton di c os d by t e Pl i tf s r t i ed e pe t ,a tnde de tuc i et s i g a c o 2 u nai sl e h a n if , e n n x rs t e d s r tv e tn n l r /

1 viualm pe tonsofatlm t:ve( )ho e ,a d atnde mealr iale tngofpl mbig 3 s i ci e s i 5 m s n te d tlu gc tsi un
1 c m pone t s lc e by Pli tfsa Se lLa o aoresi ElSe u do,Caio ni .Thi die ve ywa 4o n s ee td an if t a b r t i n gn if r a s so r s
l a lprm a iy ge r d t w a dsde e tng Pl i tf s M o i n f rCl s Ce tfca i n. 5 l i rl a e o r fai a n if ? to o a s r ii to 1 6 7. Si c t e i ii to ofttsca e, beD e e d nt ha e c ga e i nu e ousm oto n e h n ta i n li s t fn a s v n g d n m r in

1 flngs a d a gu e t prm a i y r l tng t di c ve y a d co c nl ofc a sce tf c ton. The e 7 ii n r m n s i z l e a i o s o ! n n e s l s r ii a i s

1 M oinsicude aMoto f rPr lmi aylj ncina do Te poayRe tanigOr e fl. b) 8 to n l d in o ei n r nu to n /r m rr sri n d r e , d 1 Dee da t Fegu o Entr rss l c. ndUnie Plmbig, ( 20 ) whihDee da t 9 fn n s r s n ep ie ,n a td u n LLC # 9 , c fn n
20 PWERSTATB PLUM BI ' & A. CONDI I NI G, j ie ,a dPlitfs Moto frLe ve NG I R T O N LLC on d n an if' in o a

21 t FieaSe o dAme de Complit( 21 1 whiht eDce da t,n l digI TERSTA' ol cn nd an # 9 , c h fn n s icu n N I Y
22 PLL M BI G & . I CON D I I M N G , TN /R t TO LLC,op os d. pe

23

8.

On De e ber3, cm 2009, ai tfsûl d aNotceofW ihd a alo M oton f rCl s Pi n if c i t rw f i o as

24 Cetfc lon.f 27 JPlitfs(i no! e klaz ofteCo r ê fl i ame de s mplitt riiai # 8 an if ld s e e lc h u t o ie m n d o an o
25 w ih r w t e cl s a l ga i ns f o t c rpl a i g . t d a h a s lc to r m h i e d n s
26 9. On Deccm ber7-3009.Pl i tf s fl d a M oton t V olm triy Di m i st i ltgaton a n i f ie io t a l s s h s ii i

27 i ise trt .t 28 j OnJ nua ' 7.2O1 ti Coutc tr da Or e p'ntngPiitfk'Moin n t niey ' 5 # a o2 0,h s r n ee n d r a i anlf to
n8 f rR- lz t l D in i s l i pa .a d di n i s x t i l v/u tvi h pr i di e. nzl di g a 1 le a i nsi o o tn ap s l s a - n n n s l s t l h s a s i t e u c i u l l a i g to n l :
.

;-

.

+

I

1 teCo plitg 34% TheCo r ex r sl r a e lu s itont c nsde M otonsf rAtom e s h m an .# u t p esy m m e u dci o o i r i o l y '
2 Fe sa l Cossfldby t eDe e da t,i cudi gI TER STATE PLLT BI G & AI e rd t ie h fn ns n l u N MN R
3 CO N D I I N I G , T O N LLC.

4

1. 0

W TER STA TE PLU. B I C & AI CONDI I M NG , MN R TO LLC fl disM oto f r ie t in o

5 Atorlls Fec a dCo t o Fe r ay l , 0.( 35 1 OnM ac 11 2009 I TERSTATE t rer' s n ss n b u r 0 201 # 4 rh , , N
6 LUM BI G & AI CONDI I NI G , N R T O N LLC fld isRe i t Pli éfs Oppo iin t isM oto f r ie t p y o a n f ' sto o t in o
7 A tor e s Fe s a d Cos s i w h c I TER ST A 'E PLU M B I G & A I CON D I I N W G , tny' e n t, n i h N I N R TO LLC

8 spplme tdisM otonw11a diina fe a dcossi c re snc ilngisorbna M oin,a d u e n e t i t1 d to l e s n t n u rd i e ii t i l to n .
9 i cud da Af da i fom Eie nMulia Maks Es .i c mplalewihLR 54- 6.g 36 ) n l e n f vt r le lg n r , q,n o irc t 1#9
1 0 1. 1 I T ERSTA '' PLUAI I G & .. CONDT I NT G,LLC r que td a a a d o NT TE BN AI R TO N r se u w r f 11 a t r e s'f e a dnon-a a l c ss i cudnge pe t'f e a d ta elc ssf ratndngnmne ol to n y e s u tx b e o t ,n l i x rs e s n r v o t o te i r ts 1 outofsaede osto sno iedbyPli tfs i t ea o mto $269, 56.6.I TER STA TE 2 t t p ii n tc an if , n h m l f 12 N
1 PLUNI I G & A I COND I I M N G , 3 BN R TO LLC a s r que t d t a l o ssi t e a ou to lo e s e U b e o t n h m n f

1 $ 7, 78.4.l al,I TERSTA TE PLI M BI G & AI CONDI I NI G , 4 1 1 4 n lN J N R T O N LLC r qu se is e e td t 1 a tr e s f e , n-a a l coss a dt xa l c ssi t et tla ou tof$ 8633 . 0. 5 to n y ' e s no tx b e t, n a b e o t n h o a m n 2 , 47
1 6 1. 2 A tt ehe r ng o M a 1 , 0a h s Coa ta a de I T ER STA TE PLU M B I G & h a i n y 0 201 t i r w r dN N

1 A.k COND I I M N G , 7' I l TO LLC 20 ofisa t r e s f e a d non-a a l c s s a d or e e t er % t to n y ' e s n tx b e o t , n d r d h e

l t xi g ofc sst c nf n t a no a ou tofatr e s f e a d no -u a l c sswe ei cude il 8 an ot o o m h t m n to n y ' e s n n t b e o t r n l d r
1 heo i illtxai n ofcoss 9 rg ra a to t.
20 1. 3 On M a 25, 0,I U R STA TE PLU M B W G & A I CON D I I N W G , y 201 N R TO LLC f ld te

21 isa e de bilofcossc nGr igistxa l c ssi tettla o ntof$1 ,78.4(422 a d tmn d l t o m n t a b e o t n h oa m u 71 . / ) n 4
22 fu t crconfr i g t att ose eos sdo noti cl de am 'a t r e s'tr e orany ott rm ate notpr pery rh im n h h t nu to n y in te tr ol

2 txa l und rLR 54- tr ughLR 54- 5a d28U. . .j19 0- 924. 3 a be e 1 ho 1n SC 21

2 4

1 . OnJ ne4,2010 Plitfsflda Ob e to a da M oint Re-a Coss(W3 ) 4 u , anif ie n j ein n to o -r x t # 2 .

2 ITT R T PL IIG&.RC N IINN ,L fe a eltPatfOjcoadl 5lN EL W E LABN z O DTO LGL C id Rp o lnf'bei n 1 S t l l y iis tn
2 k4 î nt Refa o J n .l J 1 443 2al Plilf fldaRe l o J n 2 - O O(4 63 , 6 s oï o - x n u e2 .2 0 / 8 . r an i s ie o 0 d f pl n u e 8 2 1 t 4 .4 1 4
27 ii a' g u'siel ol Aug s 13.2(1 a d t eOou-is e af r a Or c on Se tm bc 2(. 1O r l e ln a l d ) u t -i 1O n h l su d o m l d r t p e r .2t1 e ,

j
I

'

O ), S.
..

l
ci0, u .. , , . ... .

i ,

1 t xi g I RY R STA TE PLU M B I G & Am COM X T I N I G ,LLC ' c s si t ea o ntof anN N ON S ot n h m u

2 $15469.0.* 53 , 0 (W )
3 H. C O N C L U SIO N S O F LA W

4
5

1 .
2.

TheCo r e prsl rtie j rs itont rzeupo t eDee da t'M oinsfr u t x e sy ean d u idci o tl n h fn ns to o
Loc lRul 5 -1 ou lne t e f low i g f c o st co s de whe a a d ng a t r e s a e 4 6 ti s h o l n a t r o n i r n w r i to n y '

torreys'Fees and Coss. tt t

6

7 fe :()ter s lsobaneda dtea omti vove ;()t eno et a ddifcut ofteque to s e s 1 h e ut ti n h m t n l d 2 h v l. n f ly h sin y

8 h ov d ()tes il e u st t p rom t elg l e r e p o el ;4 tep e lso o oh r w le ; 3 h k lrq iie o efr h e a s ni s r p ry () h rcu in f te c
9 e ply e tbyteatr e d et tea c ptnc oft eca e ( )whzhe tefei fxedor m o m n h to n y u o h c e a e h s ; 5 t rh e sl 1 c ntng nt ()tetmelmiainsi pos dbyt ecinto tecr u sales ()t ee peinc , 0 o i e ;6 h i i tto m e h le r h ic m ttc ; 7 h x re e 11 e utEon,a da iiyo teatr e s ()tl l de ia iiyo teca e i al;( )t enaur a d pa n blt f h to n y ; 8 le m srblt f h s ,f ry 9 h t e u
1 lngt oftt p oe so a rlto s i wihtecintaz ( 0 a adsi sria c s s 2 e h le r fs in l eain hp t h le ; ld 1 ) w r n in lr a e .
1 3
1 4

3.

ETF KSTA TE PLI AI I G & Am CONDI I N I G,LLC s b it d Afi a iso E J BN TO N u m te fd v t f

ie n M uli an M a ks Es . ih isM o i n f rAtor e s'Fee ard Cos s a d Re l t Pl i tf s le lg r , qwt t to o t n y sl t, n p y o an if '

1 O p osto t isM oto f rAto ne s Fee a d Cos s whi h m e t er quie e t o Loc lRul 5 p ii n o t i n o tr y ' s n t, c th e rm ns f a c
1 54-16. 6

1 7 1 8

4.

I Afi aviss bm itdwih I TER STATE PLUM B I G & Al CONDI I M N G, n ld t u te t N N R TO

LC' M o i g a d Re l Pa e s co ns lf rI TERSTA TE PLIM BW G & M R CONDI I N W G, s vn n py p r, u e o N J TO

1 LLC al sst a t elw f n i iilybild f riswor a ar t of$1 0.0pe ho rf rpa te tm e 9 te t h t h a m n ta l le o t k t ae 4 0 r u o rn r i ,

20 $1 3.0pe ho rf ras oc aetm e a d $80.0 pe ho rf rpa ae a tm e Durngtt c m s o t i 2 0 r u o s it i n n 0 r u o r lg l i . i le o e f h s 21 ltg to , hef ewasi c ea e t S16 .0pe ho rf rpa m c tm ea d $1 5.0pe hou f r ii a in t e n r s d o 0O r u o z r i n 3 0 r r o
22 m s c aetm c Co ms lf rI C R STATE PLUM BI G & AB? CONDI I NVNG . s o it i . t e o N E N TO LLC a s atss lo te t 23 t t enu be ofhou st elw fnn s e ton I TER STATE PLLM BI G & AJ CONDI I N L G, oh m r r h a i pn N N R TO N
24 LLC' def ns i tksacton. S e e n li i

2 5

5.

Pii tfsha eha t eop c- niyt r v e a dr s o dt t ee i e c an if v d h p qt t o e i w n e p n o h v d n e u

26 I TER STA TE PLUAI I G & ..R CON D I I N-N G , -- s bm it d i s ppo tofisM oto f r N BN AI T O L ItC u te - u r t l z in o 27 At o n ys Fe s a d Cos s i c udi g t e Af i a 't ofc uns la é i vo cc f rt xa l a d nontr r ' e n t - n i n h f d Ais o e n n i s o a b e n
2E , 1

1 txa l c ssicur d.Plitfsdi notob ett tehotl bli grt o c unslnort entmbe of a be o t n re an if d j o o h try iln ae f o e, h t r
2 hou sbil di dee dng I TER STA TE PLI M BI G & AI CONDI J NTNG,LLC. r le n fn i N JN R TO 3 6. TheCour ge e a l fndst a t ebul oft ea tm e s f e a d no -a a l c ss t n r ly h th k h to y ' c s n n t x b e o t

4 i c re b t eDe e d nt,i cud ngI TERSTA TE PLUM BI G & A. CONDI I N I G , n u rd y h fn a s n l i N N I R T O N LLC,

5 wilhav v leils bsque tpr c e i gsa dma no betes bec o alatr e s'fe a adi l e au r u e n o e dn n y t h u j t f r to n y e s w r n
6 t i lt gaton. h s ii i

7

7.

A r a a d ofs m e pori n o tl r q e t d a t m e s f e a t no - a a l c ss lw r o to f le e u s e t o y ' e s rd n t x b e o t p

8 i cl di g e pe t 'f e a d t a e e pe s sf r al ndi g num e ous o tofs a e dc osto sno i e by n u n x r s e s n r v l x n e o te u r u t t p ii n tc d 9 Pl i tf s i r a o a l a d a pr pra e i t i m a t rbe a s oft e r s t a t eD e e da t s a n i f , s e s n b e n p o i t n h s te c u e h i k h t h fn ns 1 i c udi g I T ER STA TE PLUM Bm G & AI . 0 nl n N R CON D I I N I G ,LLC,w il nc rd plc tve TO N l i u u i ai

a tr ey 'fesi de e di g i e tc lis e itf t r pr c e i gs i cudi g, notlm ie t ,a to n s e n f n n d n i a s u s r u u e o e d n ,n l n but i t d o
1 2 ot nta r que tf rcl s c r i c ton. M or i pora ty dl a t r e s'f e we e i c r e asa r s l e i l e s o a s e tf a i e m tn l , e to n y e s r n u r d eut

1 ofPll tf s own de i i n t s e c a s c ri i a i n, y t l t ri t e c s w i d a t e.M o i n 3 r n ir ' i c so o e k l s e tfc to onl o a e n h a e t r w h i to h r 1 f r Cl s Ce tfc to a d fl aM oto t D i m i s 4 o a s rii a i n n ie in o s s.

1 5

8.

TheCo tindst a r que tng adei eain off e i lneby lne d t - y- ae m i h t e si ln to e s n i - i . a eb d t

1 f r a ,a d/ rr quii g m TER STA T. PLUM B I G & A' CON D I I N I G , 6 o m t n o e rn E N x T O N LLC t p od c o r ue

1 e a td bilngi v ùc s wo l r quieI TER STA TE PLUM BL G & AI CONDI I NW G, 7 d c e li n c e , u d e r N N R TO LLC
l8 t ur ecess rl i ctrm or ator e r'f es. om aiy n t e t n ls e

1 9

9. A sa r s l oft e f c t a s ve a D e e da t a e r q e tng a t m e s f e a d c s s e u t h a t h t e r l f n n s r e u si to y ' e s n o t ,

20 t eCour fndst a a i - r s nzi gawa di g at r e s f esa dnon-a a l cossi a pr prae h t i h t n n g o s ln r n to n y ' e n t x b e t s p o it

21 a dfndsta a a adoft e t pec nt(0%)oft eatm e s'fe a dno -n a l e ssic re n i h t n w r ' ny re 2 w h to y e s n n t b e o t n urd
22 by e cloft eM tv ngDe e da t,i c u i g J T FR STA TE PLUM BI G & altCONDI I M N G, a i h li f n n s n l d n NT N il k TO 23 LLC, sar as na l a a d ofa tm e s f esa dno -a a l c ss i e udi g e pe t'f e al ta e i e o be w r to y ' e n n tx b e o t ,n l n x rs e s rd r v l

2 epnetaedhnmeudpsi sn ne osMie toDenatpnrn. l 4 xessotnteu r seoio iMi a l, l saf fdnUoo,cs t o tn n p i m o e i'
25 per ol elnotced by t e Pl i tfs. sm î b a n if

2 txabl lt iTcioigeunlofsatieeeaomisnennabone-sldj'.or ! ( 0 hMcieDfdtivruetdtryifsno-xolot.(l.) 1 ) o. o s nea shhc'mortantnlioe. awtd fcttn n nnlg lqsh Sùe'.x arae sfa 27 a ecss nac lctv m'o 7 4 ' i:
f

78 l veav pf c n:f 0% ) o-a t r e ''f esa d nop-a a l cossi c r e b3 I TER ST A TE ' ll' r t . e . r t o o ls e u v 2 :x b e l n u r d .N ' -

k

,

i

1 LUM BI G & AlkCONDF I M NG, N l FO LLC, nd e c oft eot e M o it De e d nt,i r a ona l a a h h h r v rg fn a s s e s b e
2 unde t e c r um sa ce an f di gsass tf r h a ove a r duc ng t ef e r que t d by e c s c r h ic t n s d m n e o t b , s e i b c s e se ah u b

3 De e da tpr vi esf rar a o a l c le tvef e a a d o a pr xi aey $2 0, 00.Thi a ad of fn n o d o e s n b e o lc i e w r f p o m tl 0 0 sw r 4 a t m e s'f e an non-axa l c ssi s e ii aly e tr da ai s t ena e Pl i tfs andnot to y e s d t b e o t s p c lc l n e e g n t h m d an if ,
5 co m s lf rt ePli tf s t e o h an if . 6 1. 1 Tle Co r fndst a i i r a o a l a d a pr p i t t a a d I T R STA TE z u ti h t t s e s n b e n p o ra e o w r N E

7 PLUM BI G & AI CONDI I N W G, N ! R TO LLC t xa l c ssi t ea o m tof$15469. 0 a be o t n h m t , 0. 8 1. 2 T TERSTATE PLLI BW G & .m CONDI I NW G,LLC i note tte t pr N M A TO s n ild o e

9 ' d m e ti tr s. Howe e ,I TERSTA TE PLUM BW G & M R CONDI I M N G , u g n neet vr N TO LLC i e tte s n itd

1 t po t ud m e titr s fo tedaeofe ty o t efna J dgme tofDi lslwihPrj die 0 o sj g n n ee t rm h t n ! f b i l u n m ' a t eu c , s
l1 Jam a y 2 ,201 , i t e a a d i s ts e i f l. tr7 0 untl h w r s a if d n u l 1 H1 2 . 1 3 O R DER The Cou ta a dsD e e da tI T ER STA TE PLU M B W G & . R CON D I I O rwr fn n N M TO G, LLC

1 t e t pece ( 0 )ofisrquetdatm e s fe a dnon-a a l c ss i oudnge pe t'fe,n 4 w ny r m 2 % t e se to y ' e s n tx b e o-,n l i x rs e si t
1 t ea ountof$5 , 31. 5. 5hm 38 2 1 6 The Cour a a dsDe e da tI T ERSTA TE PLUM BW G & AI CONDI I M NG , tw r f n n NT R TO LLC

1 t a l c ss i t e a o ntof $1 , 69. 0. 7 r be o t n h m u 54 0 1 8 A s s c ,t e Cou ta a dsD e e da tI T ER STA T E PLI NI I G & AI CON D I I N I G , uh h r wr fn n N J BN R TO N

19 LLC is a t rt ys f esa d c s si t et t la o m tof$69 30 . 5. t to re ' e n o t n h o a m t , 02
20 .// /

21 /// 22 1// 1
23 //. / 24. '/, '/ 25 ''7

26
. , ,
'

.

28
I
i l

! 1

l

'

!

1

The Co r a a dsD e e dmz I TER STA TE PLU M B I G & A I COND I I N W G , u tw r fn t N N R TO LLC

2 os-udgme titrs a t efdea j dgme trt.Thewe kl a ea eoft elye rc rsa t tj n n ee t th e rlu n ae e y v rg h - a olt' a
3 m a urt Tr a l y y e d f rt e w e k bef r J nu ! 27, 0 i . IA . The da l r t f rpos t iy e su i l o h e o e a ay 201 s 3 O iy a e o t

4 'dgm e ti t r s i . 0 008 931 ( . 0 1365) Pos-ud ne ti trs wilac lntlt a $.8da u n n e e t s 0 0 4 5 $ 0 3 / . tj g n ne et l cu zae t 5 / y
.

5 untlstsid (000008 9 1 *$69,00.5 . i aife . 435 3 2)
6

7 Dae Novem bqr29t ,2010 td h
6
9

-

-

uO oa j po n 1yC

Untd S t s ' 'tCC A ie u e ) U
.

u y ua os

10

11 Re pe t a l Subm it d: s c f ly te
12 T 1 M zu x s LA / ,GR o l' ,s p H .s ; p 13

14 By:

1 sl u t A . ! 5tm > EsQ. 16 1l 0 Town Cent rD rve,Sui e 200 2 ei t
asV eg% ,N evada 89144

EI EEN L

, ESQ. 005708 /

17 Ator e sf rD e e da tI TE R STA TE t n y o fn n N PLLM BW G & AI CONDI I NI G , T R T O N LLC 18
19
20

21
22 23 24 25 26

(
2% I i