Pulsipher v. Clark County et al

Filing 89

ORDER that the Motion for Reconsideration 79 is DENIED. The Motion in Limine 84 is GRANTED in part and DENIED in part. See Order for details. Signed by Judge Robert C. Jones on 12/27/10. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - ECS)

.

1

!

F l. .

Ftg ln . -- ENTERED .. -.

(ICE/ATE C RC R III LFFIZ F EO C IIC

qE EV ; c IE S RVED ON E

:

j
2

1

-. . . ' f gEg 2 7 21 00 : k ,,
-

..
; nE uw e

,

3

1 l

. (: ? : w

iGEKUIDSuITCAR LR RSIT'C DUY E . DITSTCRS AQ . S ' 'V t

l

E i !
;

4
5
6

j- . UNI E S ATESDlzP ( COURT TD T s. k2 T
DI TY C T ( F NEV A D A S )

ALAN PULS PHER, I

7
i i Pli tf, an if

8 9

) ) ) )

2:8c - 1 74RCJLRL 0 -v 0 3 - -

j
'

v. s
CLA R.K COUNTY e a . t l,

)
) )

.

-. u .
O RPER

4

1 0
De da t. sn ns

)
) )
Thi c s a iesouto al g d r c - r lgin- a dgi de - a e e plym e t s a e rs f le e a e , e i o , n n rb s d m o n

11
1 2

!

1 dici iain.TbeCoutb sd nidDefnda t'motonfrs mmayj d me t Beoete 3 srm n to z a ee e ns i o u z u g n. fr h
1 Cou t r De e da t'M oto t Re o sde ( CF No. 9)a d De e d nt 'M oton i Li i e 4 r ae fn ns in o c n i r E 7 n fn a s i n mn
'

' j )

1 ( CFNo 8 ) Fort er a onsgi e he en,heCou t(inistemoinfre o sdrto a d 5E 4. h es v n ri t r e e h to o r c n ieain n
.

'

'
f

l gr nt t e m oton i lm i e i pa ta d d ni si i pa t 6 a sh i n i n n r n e e t n r.
17 1.
Pulsipher v. Clark County et al

FA C T S A ND PRO C E D IR AL H I T O R Y J S
Doc. 89

1 8

Pl i tf A l n Pul i he i aw hie m a e m e be oft e Ch r h ofJ s sChrs ofLate a n if a sp r s t, l m r h uc eu it tr

1 d ySant, mmonl kno na te' or onCh r h. ( m . mpl! 1 ) Heha be n 9 a i s co y w sh t m M u c ' A Co . 3 . ' se
2 e pl y d byClr Cou t , va ai t eDi ii n ofJ ve ieJ sieSe vc s($ J S')f r 0 m oe ak n y Ne d n h v so u n l u tc r ie ç J ' o D

2l ov rade a ea di c re tyclsiida M a a e e tAnay tL C- 9 (d.M 1 ,1 ) e c d n s urn l asfe s n g m n ls I 2 .l 2 5.
2 2 I t el t l 90s Clr Count e tbls edt eDJ S Pr b tonOfi e Ac de y(he n h ae 9 , a k y sa ih h J o a i tc r a m t

23 S c de y' wihi DJ Sbe a s saelw rquie aIu e iepr bainofiest ate da t a m ' t n J c u e tt a e rd 1j v n l o to fc r o tn A )

l

2 bs l efre etcdmyadsni te onys rbtnotesote oi 4 ai a nocm naae ,n edn h C ut'poai fcrt h ple cw g oi c
25 a a e yi Cas nCi woul h vebe npr hiiiel e pe sv .(#.l 1 1 ) Thefrtc dc c d m n ro t y d a e o btv y x n ie / l &.8. j is a t

l

Dockets.Justia.com

1

. ' j
I 1 c cea tea a e yb ga i teSp igof1 99.1 .j 1 ) Plitf sr e a teExe utve y l th cd m e n n h rn 9 (d l 9 . anif ev d s h ci
2 Of i erf rt e fr tf urcycl s,aftrwhi h hew asassgned asCom m ander begi ni g w ih t e fc o h is o e e c i , nn th

3 S rng20 1c cl.1 .I 1-20.Plitf s reda Comma d rtr u bJ ne20 6, p i 0 y e (d ! 9 ) an if ev s ! n e ho g u 0

4 a mi itrngattlofM ev rgulra ds e ilc d tc ce .(d.5 22 24) d nsei oa le e a n p ca a e y ls 1 . - . 1
5 On oraboutApr l26,2006,D J S r or ani ed,r suli g i t e cr aton oft e i J eg z e tn n h e i h

6 Pr fsin lDe eopme tUni (tDU'.(#.!29.Dee d ntLar Catrwa a sgne aste o eso a v l n tt P ' f 1 ) fn a ry re s si d h )
7 As i t nt ie t ri c a ge oft e PD U ,whi h orgi a l c nss e o l ofDef n a tShe on ss a D r c o n b r h c i n ly o i t d n y edn r

8 Ha e a dPlitf.(d. 3 ) Ha esrpore t Dee da tChei Townsnddti gti tme y s n anif 1 ! 0 . y e td o fn n re e u n hs i 9 perod.f .i ) l tepesntmoton, fnda t cli ta Ha e i fc rpo tdt Catr i (# j31 . n h r e i Dee ns am h t y s n a t e re o re
l att e PD U ,notTownsend. Soon t er aûer Hayesw ascl ssii d as a Prnci alM anagem ent 0 b he , a fe ip

l

11 Anays C- 1a dwa ma ePlitf' die ts pe ior ((.( 2) l teprs ntmoin, l t 3 n s d anifs rc u w s ./f. 3 . n h e e j to
' 12 Def ndant cont nd t atH ayes had been a Prnci alM anagem entAnal stsnce2002 butwas e s eh ip yi 13 fr tappoi t d asPl i tf ' s pew i ori 2006. is ne a n ifs u sn 1 4 Pl i tf alegest atH ayesbegan t tea bi dif r nty fom ot erDJJS em pl yeeswho a n ir l h o r t m fe e l r h o

1 wer n tme besofterlva tpr tce clse .Sp ciial, alg s ( )ono a out 5 e o m r h ee n oe td as s e fc ly he le e : l rb
1 N o e be 1 , 06, y se t r d acl s Pl i tf w a t a hi g w ihoutp i rnotc a d 6 v m r 7 20 Ha e n e e a s a n if s e c n t ro ie n

l s lcie c nfde tale aiatonsofPli tf'( )Ha e be a gii g Pl i tf ltl ornonotc 7 o i td o i n i v u i an if 2 y s g n vn an if it , e ie

l ofsafme tngs atou hote e ply e rc ie notce ()Ha esr utneys h due 8 tf ei , lh g h r m o e s e ev d i '3 y o i l c e ld ,
19 m eetngsbased on ot erem pl yees'avaiabiiy and t en m anda ed Pl i tf ' atendance i b o l lt h t a n if s t

20 wihout e ha igiquie ast hsa albiiy;()o J nu r l 20 7, y sa dBrnda t ev r vn n rd o i v ia lt 4 n a ay 8, 0 Ha e n e
21 M ari ez,a DJ S empl yee i t e PDU ,confs at d f urA cadem y I gbooksf'm Pl i tf ' ln J o nh ic e o o yo a n i fs 22 of i e whie he wason vacaton t atwer notneeded f rw or pum os s butwhih cont i ed fc l ih e o k e c an

23 d c me ttonofHa e ' h rsme tofPlitf'()Ha esdie tdMatn zt ke ptee o u nai y ss aa s n anif 5 y rce rie o e h s ,
24 l gbooks whi h wer crtcalt Pl i tf ' per orm ance,ataI caton aw ay f om t e Academ y, o ,c e ii o a n ifs f oi rh

25 ma i gpe f r a c ofhi d te mor difc l;( )onJ n 8, 07 Ha esde id Pl itf k n ro m n e s u is e fiu t 6 u e 20 , y n e a n if
Page 2 of l8

'

l pe m i son t a t nd t e f ne alo a c - o ke wihouta pl i g f rl a e w h l pe nitng r s i o te h u r f o w r r t p y n o e v > ie n ti

2 oh r (ncldnghes l t atndwiho ttkngla e'7 ono a o tJ ne26,20 7, y s tes i u i reg o te t u a i ev , ) r b u u ( 0 Ha e
3 be a de a di g a v nc notc f o Pl i tf a y tm e he woul l a et e c m pus w h l no g n m n n d a e i e r m a n if n i d ev h a , ie t

4 rq iigtes meofote e po e s ()d rngteFal200 Ac de y, e mantie e urn h a h r m ly e ' 8 u i h l 6 a m Hay s i an d ,
5 cont ctw ih one orm or ofPl i tt spr bl m sm dent ,e cour gi g m i conducti bi cl s es a t e a n ir oe sn an s n s as

6 i a ate ptt bathi it awo k vi lton'( )Ha e ma edc o aor sae e t a o t n n tm o i m n o r o a i , 9 y s d r g t y t tm n s b u 7 Pl i tf' r c a dr lgin; nd(1 Ha esfe ue tyde id Pl i tf' r q e t t l a e an ifs a e n ei o a 0) y r q n l n e a n ifs e u ss o e v :

8 c mpus e enf rwor -eltdmatr,e uiighi t tkepai lav t dos .I . 33 .9, a , v o k r ae tes rq rn m o a d e e o o (d M -4

9 5)Plaintiffdescribestheallegeddisparatetreatm entastteath by athousand cuts.''This 2 d
.

1
'

10 teat entalegedl caus d Pl i tf t alerhi wor i g condii ns i a tm e- onsum i g and rm l y e a n if o t s k n to n i c n 1l diruptve way,r quii g hi t docum e tever i t r cton and ever sm aton t atcoul be si e rn m o n y nea i yi i h d

1 mic nsre byHa e ,nore t deen hi s l.f . !5 -51.las alge l rs le i 2 s d tu d y s i d r o f d m ef(# ' I 0 ) t lo le dy eutd n j

1 Plitf'b igpasdo e fr po oinfr ihh wa oh r ieq aiid (d !5 ) 3 anifs en se vr o a rm t o whc e s tew s u lfe .1 . 3. o
1 4 I oraboutJ ne 2006,Pl i tf subm it d an applcaton f rr cl s ii aton t Prnci al n u a n if te i i o e a s fc i o i p

I

1 V a a e e t ayt(d !5 ) Be a s o Plitf' rc , e d ra drl in hsa piain 5 n g m n An ls.1 . 4 . c u e f an ifs a e g n e, n ei o , i p l t g co
l was nevereven pr ces ed,des ie hi qualfcatons f rt e poston and hi dii ence i 6 os pt s ii i oh ii s lg n

1 mo io igtesausofhi a plc ton./ .l 55 57 . 7 ntrn h tt s p iai (# ll - ) !
l 8 Pl i tf s e Cl r Count , J , a n if u d a k y DJ S Tow n e d, re , H a e i t i Cou t or s n Ca t r and y s n h s rf

1 vilton offdea a dsaea t-ici iainlws ivokigt eCour' j rs itont de 9 oai s e rl n tt n id srm n to a ,n n h ts u idci m r

20 42U. . .j 1 83.Se Compla !2) Th Ame de Complit(t C' omitdDJ Sa a SC ' 9 ( e .t . e n d an t ' te J s A) 21 dee da ta die tte tej rs itona ba i oftec mplita 4 U.. .j200 e2.(e fn n n d niid h u idci l ss h o an s 2 SC ' 0 - S e
22 Am.Compla l2) Eih rsatt s p orsfdcaj rs iton, ndteCour teeor as ha . tf . te t u e u p t c rlu idci a h th rf e lo s 23 j rs itonove tesat lw cai spus a tt 28U.. .9 1 67.TheAC lssf u ca ssof u idci r h t e a l m ru n o SC 3 it o r u e
2 a ton:( )Vi ltonof4 U. . .j20 0e 2( lr Coun y ;( )Ho tl W or plc Envion e t 4 ci 1 o a i 2 SC 0 - C ak t) 2 si e k ae rmh

25 ( lr Count) ( )ViltonofteEqua Pr tcinClus ofteFoure nt Ame dme t C ak y ;3 oai h l oe to a e h te h nn
Page 3 of l8

i

1 p ru n t 4 U... 1 8 t a e, ne,n To ne d; n ()vilt no Ne a a usa to 2 sc j 9 3 ' y sca ra d w sn la d 4 oai f v d H o
2 Re ie Stmts(: , j61 330( lDee d nt) Dee da t move frs mmay vs d a e $ , 3 NRS ) A l fn a s. fn ns do u r
.

I

3 j d me ta dteCou t nidtemoin.Dee d nt h venow move f rteCourt u g n,n h r de e h to fn a s a do b to
4 gr reconsj e .

!

5 I. I
I

LEGAL STANDARDS
A. Rul s ( ) e 9e

6

i

! '

7

A motont ale o a e daj dgme tmus bema ewihi M e t eg t( 8 da so i o tr r m n u n t d t n np ih 2 ) y f
.

8 e tyof udg e tFe .R. v. 59e.Hee, de wa e trdo Se tmbe 20, 0, nr .j m n. d Ci P. () r or r s nee n p e r 201
9 a dt ep e e t to wa fldtnd y ltr nS pe b r3 , 01 .Th rfr te n h rs n moin s i e a s ae o e tm e 0 2 0 eeoe h e

1 moint rc n ie i tmeyunde Rul 59e a ds o l b c n iee unde ta r l as 0 to o e o sd r s i l r e () n h ud e o sd rd r h t ue 1 o posdt Rul 60 )Am.r nwo kît Ercor, nc v N. Ctal.Cor .2 8F.d89 , 1 p e o e 1 . Io r t e t s I . . Am. l r p , 4 3 2
1 8 8 99( t Ci. 01 (1A )d oton f rr c nsde ai n'i te t da amotont at rora e d 2 9 - 9 h r 20 ) t( m i o e o i r to s rae s i o le m n

: . 6 1 '

.

1 j d me tt d rFe ea Rul ofCiiPrc du eRul 5 ()ii i fldwihi tnd ysofe ty 3 u g n m e d rl e vl o e r e 9e f ts ie t n e a nr 1 of ud me t'. 4 j g n .ll '
15 B. M otonsi Li i e l n mn

'

1 6

A m oton i lm i e i a pr c d r lde i e t o t i a e ry an pr lm i a y r lng o t e i n i n s o e u a v c o b a n n a l d ei n r ui n h

i

1 a misbiiyofe ie c .Blc ' La Dito aydei e i a '()prtilrquetta ceti 7 d si lt vd n e a ks w cin r tn s t s &a era e s h t ran
1 i a m i sbl e i e c no be r f re t o of e e a t i l Typi a l ,a pa t m a e t i m oton 8 n d s i e v d n e t e e r d o r f r d t ra . c ly ry k s b s i

1 whe ibeive ta meeme to ofteevie c du igtilwo l behihl prj diila d 9 n t le s h t r n in h d n e rn ra ud g y eu ca n
2 c ul n tberme idbya isr cint dirgad.Blc 'fcw Dito ar 11 9(t e . 0 o d o e de n n tu to o se r ' a ks ' cin v 0 9h d
21 2 09 .Alho gh t eFe e a RulsofEvi e cedo no e plctya t o i eamoto i lm i e 0 ) t u h d rl e dn t x iil u b rz in n i n ,
'

2 teSu rmeCou t shedta tilud e aea torz dt r l onmotonsi lm iepurua t 2 h pe r ha l h t ra j g s r uh ie o ue i ni n s n
23 t t e rauhort t ma a etil. cl U?lc St ts, 9 U. .38 41n. ( 9 4) o h i t iy o n g ras fuc ? ;/# a e 46 S , 4 l 8 . .'
24

' n De e b rl 2 09, h tm et fl aRue 5 ( )mo in wa c a ge fom t nt O c m e , 0 t e i o ie l 9 e to s h n d r e o
25 rvenr ei htdays. Co lu'Fe . Ci. 59() 2 0 ) fi Fe . Ci. 59()(0) . kpg np l d R. v P. e ( 0 9 ,vt d R. v P. e 2 0) e h
Page4 of l 8

1

A m oton i lm i e i a r ques f rt ecour ' gui ance concer i g an evi entar i ni n s e to h ts d nn d iy

'

(

2 q e ton. e Wis nv Wilams 1 2F.d56 ,57 (t Ci.1 ) J dge ha ebr a u si Se lo . li , 8 3 2 0 7h r 999 . u s v o d
3 dic e i n w h n r lng on m o i ns i lm i e Se Jc /W. v Ch y l rM ot r Cor . 3l F. d s r to e ui to n i n . e n c î . r s e l os p, 6 3
4 663 66 ( t Ci. 2 .Ho e e , mot ni l i es o l not usdt rs lefcu l 4 7h r 200 ) w v r a i n i n h ud be e o eov a ta o m ,

! 4 j j

5 diputsorweihe ie c . eCI - e v.f a,v As lnd I c, 9F.S pp.2 31 , 3 se g vd n e Se M S r s, n . ha , n .53 u d 6 32
6 ( . . . 008 .To e cud e i e c onamoton i lm i eXt ee i e c mus be ia m isbl DDC 2 ) x l e vd n e i n i n tb v d n e t n d s i e

7 ona1potnta gr t ds'E..ld.n .Co v Gc . e .Co.3 6F. pp.2 8 4,8 6( . . l e il om . g ,n Is . . n Elc , 2 Su d 4 4 N D '
8 Ohi 200 ) t nls e i e c me t t i hi h sa da d, vi e ta yr lngss oul bede e r d o 4 . t e s v d n e es h s g tn r e d n ir u i h d u f re 9 untlti ls t a qu si nsoff un a i n, ee a c a d p tnta prj diem a b rs l e i i ra o b t e to o d to r lv n y n o e i l eu c y e e o v d n
.

1

1 prpe c ntxt'Hawtor eParnesv AT&T T c .I c,831F.Sup .1 98,1 00( . .1. 0 o ro e . ' hn tr . e h, n p 3 4 N D 11
1 1 93) Thi i be a s atoughr lngso moto si l i ema s vet i e, ss e f r an 1 9 . s s c u e lh u i n i n n i n y a tm co t, fo t d m t
1 pr par ton,a cour i al ostal aysbete st at d duri g t eact alti lt ass sst e val e and 2 e ai ts m w t r iu e nh u za o e h u

j
: '

'
i

1 utlt o e i e c . Wikisv Kmar Cop.487F. p. t 1 1 ,1 1 ( . n. 07) 3 iiy f v d n e' l n . ' t r, Sup 2 1 2 6 2 9 D Ka 20 .

1 4

I lmier lngsaeprviina.Suc tulngsaenotbidigontetiludg ( ho), n i n ui r o so l h l i r r nn h ra j e w

1 m a al a s c an e hi m i d du i g t eco r e ofa t i l' Ohl rv Unie St ts, 9 U . . 5 y w y h g s n rn h u s ra .' e . t d a e 52 S 753,

1 758n. ( 00 ) ac or Luc , 9U.. 41(otn ta i lmier lngsaeawa ss be to 6 3 2 0 * c d e 46 S at n ig h tn i n ui r l y u jc t ,
1 c a ge epe ilyi tee ie ceunflsi a una tcpae ma n r.t e ilo amotoni 7 h n , s cal fh vd n od n n nii td n e) l na f D in
1 lm i e do s not ce s rl m e n t a a 1e i e c c n e pl t d b t em o i n w ilbe a m it d 8 in e ne s a iy a h t 1 v d n e o t m a e y h to l d te
19 t t i l D eni lm er l m eanst atwihoutt e cont xtofti l t e cour i unabl t det nni e o ra . a ey h t h e ra ,h ts eo e n 20 whet ert e evi ence i queston s oul be excl ded.'lt ..?. Co. 326 F.Supp.2d at846. hh d n ihd u ' 'd f .. , ?5 2 1 1 1. 1
22

AN A L Y SIS
A. M oton t Reconsi er io d

23

Dee d nt ls sxfcua a dfurlga poit ofc ntntonwihtes mmayj d me t fn a s it i a t l n o e l n s o e i t h u r u g n

24 o de (th Or e ') Asapr lm i a yma tr man ofDe e da t 'a g m e t i t epr s n r r tte d r'. ei n r te , y fn ns ru ns n h e e t
25 m oton ar bas d on t c Coun havi g tr led on' ortcr died' cenai evi ence Pl i tf i ce h n le i ' le t ' nd a n if Page 5 of l8

1

:

1 prduc di opposto t Dee da t' infrs rm ayj d me tn tbl,hi ownafda i. o en iin o fn n s moto o un r u g n, oa y s fi vt
2 The Co r no e t a i ha m a e no tndi gsoff c , d t a Pl i tf nee no pr v a y f c sat u t ts h tt s d 'n i a t an h t a n if d t o e n a t

3 tes mmayj dg e tsa e.Hene do t pr duc a misbl e ie c whihi beive b h u r u m n tg e ny o e d si e vd n e c f le d y 4 tefcttnde a tilwoul s pp r aj d me ti hi fvo .Dee d nt'miundesa digo h a -i r tra d u o t u g n n s a r fn a s s rtn n f

5 tes mmayj dgme tsa dadi ilsrtdbytefrtt osntn e o tec ncuso h u r u n tn r s lu tae h is w e e c s f h o l in
6 paa rpho isprs nt in.Se Mot 111 -1 Se t3 , 0, No.7 (t eCoul rg a f t e e moto ( e . :6 8, p. 0 201 ECF 9t n ' t
7 a pe r t ha er le e c u i e y on Pi i tf ' A m e de Compl i t A fi a i a d t s m e p a s o v e id x l sv l a n ifs nd an , fd v t n o o
8 ext nt hi Res onset t e M oton f rSum m ar Judgm ent Pl i tf hasno f cm alsuppor f r e,s p oh io y . a n if a to

9 tealgainsi te eGlng .l.Ofc ureteCou trle o Plitf' a da i.The h le to n b s i s'l ' osh r eid n anifs m vt
10 alegatonsi a pl i tf saf i avi are t em sel es f c uals ppor,r gar l s ofwhet ert ey lin a n ir fd t h v at u t e de s hh ll m er l m i i t e alegatonspr vi usl m ade i an unverted com pl i t n ati t e dif r nce ey m c h l i eo y n ii an. s h fe e 1 bet een an af i avi and an unverfed com pl i t n e f r eri evi encebecause i i s onz 2 w fd t ii an . om s d ts w . 13 The l teri notevi encebecaus i i uns or .U nl s and untli st as af ct tnderatti l i at s d e ts w n es i t is a -i ra , t 1 4 i notf ra cour i iscapaciy asan a bieroft e l w t di cr di orwei b adm i sbl evi ence s o tn t t rt h a o set g si e d

1 pr duc d> buton y t no e whe he s c e i e c ha i f c be n pr du e . eAnd r on v 5 oe lo t t r u h v d n e s n a t e o c d Se es .

1 fie t Lobb ,nc, U. . 2, 9( 98 ) ' heh radeen a toracou t le e a 6 b ry y I 477 S 24 24 1 6 .W te f d n r beiv s
17 pl i tf ' am davi i tsel- er i g' w hi h i neces arl w ilbe unl s a pl i tf sa ot geshi a n ifs t s t fs v n ' ct s iy l e s a n if b a s

l c s vahso nafd vt i irlv n t as mmayj d me t n lss A pani so n 8 a e i i w f a i s ree a to u r u g n a ay i. litr w t
1 af i avi,i noti adm i sbl f rs m er ason,i com pet ntevi ence t atshoul be suf i i nt:1 9 fd t f n si e o o e s e d h d fc e -

20 a dofisl t me ttes itdbur e ofpr ducinats mmayj dgme t n - -tefo e h hfe d n o to u r u n.
21 2 2 1. Fac ua C halenge tl ls

Fis , e e da t a gu t a Ha e be a e a Prnci a M a a e e tA na y ti 20 2,n t r tD f n n s r e h t y s c m i p l n gm n ls n 0 o

23 i 20 6,a a l ge i t e AC an r c t d b t e Coun i t e Or e . Tbe e a pe r t be a diput n 0 s le d n h d e ie y h nh dr r p as o se 24 ov rt i f c , e e a s m i g De e d nt a e c r e t Pl i tf c m pl i snott a H a e wa e h s a t but v n s u n f n a s r o r c , a n if o a n h t ys s 25 pr m o c t t a pos ton i s e d ofhi i 2 06, tt athi a pic ton f rr c a s fc ton of o t d o h t ii n t a m n 0 bu h s p i a i o e l s ii a i
Page 6 of 1 8

i

1 hsownposto wa ete rjce ornotprpel pr c se an ta Ha e wr ngl ifue ce i iin s ih r ee td o ry o es d d h t y s o y n n d
2 t ede ii n. b c so
3 Second,Def ndant ar ue t att er i no evi ence Pl i tf w assri ped ofwor dutes e s g h h es d a n if tp ki

i

4 beca s ofH a es,notng t att e CourtScr died' i a f om ot Pl i tt salegaton t att e ue y ihh t e t 'n o e a n ir l i b h

5 Count ha apolc ofta s e rng r t e t a t r i atng poore pl y e who t r a e r c ys iy rn fri ah r h n e m n i m o es h e tn a e
6 di crm i aton s is. The Courtneihercr died nordi cr died t i alegaton,butsi pl not d s i n i ut t et s e t hs l i my e

7 i a d s a e t a whie s c a polc m i hts pp r a dipa at-m pa t a m i s m e t n t td h t l u h i y g u o t s r e i c cl i n o 8 cic m s a c s i di no s p or t e ki d ofdipa a e te t e tc ai Pl i tf ha br u h . I r u tn e , t d t u p tb n s r t -r a m n l m a n if s o g t n
9 any case,Pl i tf pr duced afi avi t stm ony t atsom eofhi super ior wor duteswer a n if o fd t e i h s vs y ki e

1 gie t Ha esu onhe ta se .Se Pulihe Af. !51 54, .1 20l ECFNo.50. 0 vn o y p r rn fr ( e sp r f! , Apr 4, 0, )
1l Thid,Def ndant ar ue t atPl i tf ' r cl s ii a i n applcaton was i f ctpr cess d, r e sg h a n if s e a s fc to ii na o e

1 butt e Cour r c t d Pl i tf ' a lga i n i t e f c ua ba kg o nd s c i n oft e O r e t a i 2 b t e ie a n if s le to n h a t l c r u e to h d r h tt
1 wasnot D ef ndant ar uet att e Si t r alr vi w ' t atconcl ded ar cl s ii aton was not 3 .e s g h h tn e n e e ' h u e a s fc i 1 w arant d consiut d t e pr ces i g ofPl i tf ' applcaton. D ef ndmzs ciet e depos ton of 4 re tt e h o s n a n if s ii e t tb ii 15 Cheryn Townsend,who t s ii d : don' r cal whet ert e i waseve advanced ornot ldo l e tfe 7 te l hh t r .

1 r c l t a t e a s s m e tby t e h m a r s u ce m a a e di no s p or r c a s tca i n. 6 e al h t b s e s n h u n e o r s n g r d t u p t e l s i to ' i '

l ( owns n De . :3 25, b.1 201 ECFNo. 3) De e da t t ennot t a Pli tf 7T e d p 412 - Fe 7, 0, 79- . f n n s h e h t an if
l a m il d at s d po ii n t a he h d r c i e a e a li 20 6 i di a i g t a t e hum a 8 d te hi e s to h t a e e v d n m i n 0 n c tn h t h n

1 r s u c sd pa t e tha f nv r edhi r cls iiai n r qu s t t efn nc de a t e t ( e 9 e o r e e rm n d o a d s e a sfc to e e t o h ia e p rm n .S e

20 Pulih rDe . 2-1 , 23,200 ,ECFNo. 1 .n i e ie c doe tndt s ow ta te sp e p 21 4 Nov. 9 79-) s vd n e s e o h h th
2 1 r qu s wa pr c s e t s m e e t nta d wasn ts m m a iy di m is d. Y e Pl i tf m a nt i s e e t s o e sd o o xe n ou rl s s e t a n if i a n

22 hi a plc tonwa n tf lypr c se .Se i. 78(tha ene e rc ie af nna a c ptnc s p iai s o ul o e sd ( e d ! t v v r e ev d o l c e a e 1

2 orrj cino myRe ls iiainRe uet') Thi fc rmaisdipue . 3 ee to f ca sfc to q s.l. s a t e n s td '
24 FourhrDef ndant ar ue t er i no evi ence Hayesw asper it d t opi e on Pl i tf s t e s g h es d m te o n a n if

25 a plc ton afc he 5l d hi ho tl w o k e vionm e tc m pl i ta a ns he :a Pl i tf alc e , p ia i tr e s s ie r n r n o a n g i t r s a n if l g s
Page 7 of l8

j

'

l

1 b t nyb fr h fldta c mplit Dee d nsn t ta Plit ffldh sc mp an wi u o l eoe e i h t o an. fn a t oe h t ani i i o lit t e fe h
m r 6 n h th ne l e e a n ifs 2 t e O f c ofDi e s t i N ove be 200 a d t a t e i t m a r vi w ofPl i tf ' h fe v r i,y n 3 r c a sfc to r q e toc ur e be o e Oct be 20 6. Pl i tf diput s t etm i gz t e e l s ii a i n e u s c r d f r or0 a n if s e b i n but h l

4 e hii b agu ss p ot hi cai ta W itake frHa e ' iputi Jnua.of2007i not x bt e r e u p rs s l m h t t s d o y ss n n a r y s
5 atached t hi r s onse.As um i g Def ndant a e cor e t Pl i tm scl i ofi pr per t o s ep sn e sr rc , an i am mo

6 ifue cewo l silbes ppore , r gar l s oft e tm i g ofhi com pl i tagai stH ayes The nl n ud tl u td e d e s h i n s an n .
i
! 7 ques i n i wbet ers m eone i tuenced t er vi w oft er cl s ii aton r questwih i pr per to s ho nl b ee h e a s fc i e tm o 8 m otvatons notwhct erany hostl w or envionm entcom pl i thad been pr vi usy fl d ii, b ie k r an e o l ie
.

(

9 a a ns t a pe s n. Thi tm i g i n tdi p s tve oft e di c i i a i n cl i . g i tb t ro s i n s o s o ii h s rm n to a m

l I

1 0

Ff Defendantsarguethatdiscrim inatorycom m entsm adeafteranallegedincident i t h
,

I
.

1l c nn tbe us d t s o dic i i a or m otve a t t e i ci e t De e da t t e e or a k t e ao e o h w s rm n t y i s o h n d n . f n n s b r f e s h 1 Cou tt r c nsde t e e i e c ofHa e ' ale e dic i i a or m o i e whie dico ntng 2 r o e o i r h vd n e y s s l g d s r m n t y tv l sui
13 r m ar sshe alegedl m ade t El nda Poteri 2008 or2009. ek l y oo tn 1 4 I i f rf om cl art atafert e- actr m ar sar neces arl ir l vant Forexa pl ,i a ts a r eh t -h f e k e s iy re e . m ef

l s pe viorco m e t i 2009 t a he al a sgi e w hie e pi y e t e b nettoft e do bti 5 u rs m ns n ht w y v s t m o es h e i h u n l m i c ndu ti v s i a i ns butt a he c ns de sbl c e pl ye st be gu ly untlpr ve 6 s o c n e tg to , h t o i r a k m o e o it i o n 1 i noc nt cou d i hone ty be s i t a s c a c m m e tw oul be ir l va tt t a s pe v s r s 7 n e, lt sl ad h t u b o n d ree n o h t u r io '
18 pas Grng ofa blck em pl yee f rm iconducti 2006? The com m entwoul n' be r ck- old ti a o os n d t o si

:

1 pr ofofdic i i a or m otve i 2 06, i w ou d c ra nl b r l v ntu de Rul 401 9 o s rm n t y i n 0 but t l e ti y e e e a n r e
20 because i woul t nd t m ake i m or pr babl t att e s per iorhad a dicr m i at r m otve t de o t eo e h h u vs s i n oy i

'

21 i 2 06ta i heha notma etec mme ta de ie c - eihigi f rtej r .Bute e n 0 hn f d d h o n , n vd n ew g n s o h uy vn
22 as um i g f rt e s keofar um enlt atafer t e-actr m ar sar nece sa iy ir l vant H a es s n ob a g h t -h f e k e s rl ree , y

23 alo alegedl m a e dicrm i at r com m ent t J r m e Si on and Pat i k Bl ck,and sl y d s i n oy s o eo m rc a
24 D e endant do notar ue t att es com m ent wer m ade afert e alegcd dicrm i at r event . f s g h he se th l s i n oy s

!
.

25

Si t , e cn a t cl rf t a Ha e r po e die ty t Ca t r nott To ns nd,f o x h D f d n s a iy h t y s e n d r c l o re , o w e rm Pa e 8 of 1k g t

$

I

l t etm e s e w a a s gn d t t e PDU i 200 . bi h s si e o h n6

E
! 2 2 t-e alc halenges g l

3

Fis,Dee da t agu ta tet a' pa 'te r ofla iiyi ia plc bl i ti ca e rt fn ns r e h th t ts w 'b oy ib lt s n p ia e n hs s . c

i
i

4 Tb yag eta b c ueJn t twa n t d cso - a e wi rsetoPlitrs e ru ht ea s a e wit s o a eiinm k r t ep c t ani h t
5 rca sfc to rqu s, Pl i tf ' wr ngf ly m otvat d i fuence on W it i any,i ir l vant e lsiiain e e t a n if s o u l i e n l t, f s ree .
6 Def ndant poi tt W itst stm ony t ata çr cl s iicaton' i dif r ntt an a pr m oton. A e s n o t ei h de a s t i ' s fe e b oi

)
.

;

1

7 rcasfc to i wh na e it gposto i u grde ,euligi tee ply ebengete e lsiiain s e n xsi n iin s p a d rs tn n h m o e i ih r
8 pr m ot d ordem ot d i accor ance w ih t e new cl s ii aton oft e posii n he occupi s. A oe en d th a s fc i h to e

.
!

9 pr m oto i whe ape s n mo esi t adif r ntposto t a i ca sfe hi he t a t e o in s n r o v n o fe e iin b t s ls iid g r b n h
I
'

!

1 p sto hec re tyh ls t itDe .1 1 :-1 :, c l1 200 ,ECFNo.794)2 W it 0 o iin urnl od .' t p 3:39 42 De . , 9 W -. t ll tsiidta To nsndake h rdopefr a çnfr a j ba di'onPlitf i tes mme e tfe h t w e s d e ro m n ' om l o u t' anifn h u r i 1 of2 06i rs ons t hi r q e tfrrca sfc ton.1 .l :8 24) W itsae ta s ema e 2 0 n e p e o s e u s o e ls iiai (d 4 1 - . t ttd h t h d
1 no detr i aton as t r cl s ii aton,because Towns nd had enl t l bert do an i f r al 3 em n i o e a s fc i e y od o n om

1

'

7

1 r viw .1 .1 l -1 3) Pli tf st si ony h weve , onka it W its Pli tf tsiid 4 e e (d 6: 6 7: . an if e tm , o r c d cs t'. an if e tfe
1 t atW itand/ rTow ns nd m ade a det nni aton nott r cl s iy hi poston bas d on Hayes' 5b t o e e ni o e a s f s ii e s

.
.

1 alge wrngf liput( e Pulihe Af. !57 58, .1 ,201 , No. ) l i notf r 6 le d o u n .S e sp r f!I - Apr 4 0 ECF 50 . ts o

1 teCour t weghteco titngtsi onya tes mmayj dgme tsa e.Morove,he 7h to i h nlci e tm th u r u n tg e rt
l f iu e t e e m a e a f nna r c a stc to de e m i a i n i i f c a i t r al r of 8 a l r o v n k o l e l s ii a i n t r n to s n a t n n e pa t 1 Pl i tf ' t e r oft e c s . n i a pe r t bew h th m e ns whe hes yshi a plc to w a 9 a n if s b o y h a e s p as o at a n a s p ia in s 20 21

2 hedif r nce i pr babl ir l vantf rt e pur os s ofTil VI . The deni lofan T fe e so y ree oh pe te I a upw ar r cl ssii aton r ques coul cons iut an tadver e em pl ym e tacton' undert e d e a fc i e t d tt e t s on i' h

2: Count' s se .T'attnn i br a l dei e .Se Rc)v He,es n,2l F.d 1 3 ,1 40(t , ! ys y tm h e s o dy tn d e ? . l ro 7 3 2 4 2 9h d Ci. ) l icldes fre a pl,sis miainofa adv rej brfrnc , e e wh r r2000 . t n u ,o x m e Sdse n to n es o eee e' v n ee ' 23 ta r fr nc doe no a f c ahii gde iin. d.a 1 4l( ii gHa hm ot w Dalon,l 8F. d h t e e e e s t fe t rn c so I t 2 ctn s i o . t 1 3 67l 6 6( t Ci.l ) 'k fs lt prmot'a dtolrtono haa s e tbyote , 7 9h r 997). t e u a o o e' n ' eai f rsm n l t hr 2 emply e 'as ft tedeiiin.#.(uotng bv t! Cibt Bo t',35F.d l l-l ( s 4 o e s' lo i h fnto f q i V at? (;? so' s . f 3 3, 5 6 lt Ci.1 ) An a v rer c m m e da in i r s on et ar ca sfcai n rque tc ud t e e or r 994). d e s e o n to n e p s o e ls ii to e s o l h r f e
25 s tsf t e defnii n of'adver e cm pl ym entacton.' ai y h i to ' s o i'

Pag 9 of l e 8

I

k

1 n tpr c s ed. Def nda t c nnota gue b t t a t e a plc ton f rr c a sfca i n w a o oes c ns a r o h h t h p i a i o e l s ii to s

2 pr c se (e a s iwa snt&o tehu anrs ure de at e tt tefna c de at e t, o e sd b c u e t s e m h m eo c s p rm n o h i n e p rm n)
5
;

3 butt en att e sam e tm e ar ue t att ey ar of t ehook f rany aleged adver e det nni aton h h i ghh e fb o l s e ni 4 becaus no tf nnal'det r i aton wasm ade,onl an %i f nnalr vi w .' Com plancew ih Til e to ' em n i y çn o ee ' i t te

@

5 ' li t i c nt x w o l s e t r quie p oc s i g a a plc ton f ly, e ni g a t a l Vl n h s o e t u d e m o e r r e sn n p i a i u l m a n c u ly
6 m aki g a decii n w ihouti pr peri t nt notpi eon- olng an applcaton. I ot erwor s n so t m o ne , g hi ii nh d,
i

i 1
i

7 pieo -oln a a plcainwihdici iaor motveij s a wrngf la tomal' g n h ig n p i to t srm n t y i s u t s o ' sx r ly' uf
8 denyi g one w ih dicrm i at r m otve. n t s i n oy i 9 Tber r m ai s a key nua ce i t i cas . l l ayesonl wr ngl i fuenced W it a d i ee n n n hs e f l y o y nl t, n t

1 was notW it butTowns nd,who m ade t e deci i n t pi eon- ol Pl i tf ' r cl s ii aton 0 t, e h so o g h e a n if s e a s fc i

1 rquetbyore igW itt c nd c onl a Xnf nnalo a dt'a dnott ma eatfr a' 1es d rn t o o u t y n ' o j b u i ' n i o k to m l'
12 det nni aton on t e r cl ss fcaton r ques,t er m ay be no lnk bet een t e wrongf l e ni h e a ii i e th q i w hr u l m otvaton and t e adver e em pl ym entacton. n e f ct on t i poi tar notentr l cl ar 3 ii h s o i a s hs n e ie y e .
I

J Pl i tf a pe r t a l ge t a Hay salo i fu nc d To ns nd,a l a ti die ty t r ug W it 4 a n if p a s o le h t e s n l e e w e t e s n r c l h o h t.

1 .

l ( e i.1 (sheyl Town e da dJne W itteDJSM a a e rs onsbl f rpes nne, 5 S e d !57 t r n c s n n a t t,h J n g r ep i e o ro l

1 rquetdta ShaonHa e rviw a de auaemyj bdute , ltc tonsa dtte sfrte 6 e se h t r yse e n vl t o is quai ai n in s o b i
1 Re ls ii a in. ) Theet e e or r m aisa fc u lq e to ont i poi t a dt ecli i not 7 ca stc to ' . r h r f e e n a t a u sin h s n , n b am s l I

1 a prpracf rs mmaya j diain. 8 p o it o u r du c to
1 9 Se on , f nda t a guet at e pl ye who wa s m ia l s m a e t Pl i tf i c d De e n s r h no m o e s i l r y i t d o a n if n

20 r l vantr s ect was teat d m or f vor bl t a he was.Lessf vor bl t cat enti one way i ee ep s re e a a y hn a a er m s n

21 whi h a pl i tf m a s ow dic i i aton. e eg. Ccr wc/ ! El c t C.Cr d tUnï) , c a n if y h s rm n i Se , . , ln / ' e r a . ei (l 439 7

2 F.d 1 8 1 ( t Ci. ) A s ow ig ofIs fvor bl te t e tc e t sar buta l 2 3 01 , 028 9 h r 2006 . h n e s a a e r am n r a e e tb e
23 pr sum pton ofdi crm i aton.l . Thepr sum pton,butnott e cl i isel,i def at d i a e i sini d e i h am t f s e e f

2 de e da tc n s ow a l gii a e n ndic i i a o y r a on f rt e a ve s e pl y e ta ton. 4 fn n a h e tm t , o s rm n t r c s o h d r e m o m n c i
25 f . Butapl i tf need nots ow t athe i entted t a pr sum pton ofdicri i aton i or ert # a n if h h s il o e i s mn i n d o Page l of l 0 8

i
i

:

I e tbls aprmatcedici iaincam A pl itr-may alo s ow dici i atont rough sa ih i k i srm n to li a n it sh s rm n i h
.

:

i
I I

2 die te ie c ta hewa s b e tt a ad es e ply e ta to be a s ofadici iaor rc vd n e h t s u jc o n v re m o m n cin c u e s rm n t y
3 m otve, r g r l s ofw he be ot e swer m or f vor bl te t d. l c m pa a i e m a te m l nt i e ade s ' t r hr e e a a y r a e f o r tv lr a e 4 w er t e onl w ay t show a Til VI vi l ton,an em pl yee w ho was m alr at d due t hi or eh y o te I o a i o te e os

5 he r c , nde , r lgi n w o l ne erha ea Til VI cl i i c s s whe e t e e pl y e i i r a e ge r or e i o ud v v te I a m n a e r l m oe sn l
6 a1 m at ralr spect i a uni ue posii n w ihi an or ani aton,and i i cl ary nott e case t a l ei e sn q to t n g zi ts e l h ht

7 t eM c o ne lD o gl s Co l i t nde t ba s c pl i tf sf om brngi g Til VH cl i s Se h D n l u a u - n e d o r u b a n if r t i n te am . e

J

8 Mc o nelDo glsCor.v Grc ,411U. . 2,802n.3( 97 )($hefcsne esaiywil D n l u a z . cn S 79 1 1 3 ç a t c srl l T

9 v r i TieVI c ss a dtes e i c t na o eofh p i afcep o f e urd&o ay n t I ae , n h p ct ai b v te rm a i r o rq ie m l io
1 rs onde ti notn c saiya plc bl i e eyrs e todifrngfcu lstains') 0 ep n s e es rl p ia e n v r ep c t fei a ta iu to . . ' '

I I

1 Moevrthe'çim ilarly-situated''languagehasbeen superim posed onto theM cD onnellD ougls 1 re s o a
,

i
!
1

1 rl due t t e f ct a st a i n t a t pi a l a c m pa i ss c c a m s t e c s is l d e not 2 te l o h a u l iu to h t y c ly c o n e u h l i ; h a e t e f o s
13 i cl de t i r quiem ent 3ee i .at802. n e l nguage ofts m iary siuat d'appear nowher i n u hs e r . d a ti l l t e ' s en l4 t ecas .Seegeneraly i . Thc Supr m e Cour hasr ier t d t att e M c onnel Dougl s f ct h e ld e t et a e h h D l aa 1 pater i not 5 tns

1 .

1 6
l7

T he i po t n e ofM c on el D ou l s le ,no i is s e i i a i n oft e di c e e m ra c D n l g a i s t n t p c fc to h s rt el m ent ofpr oft er r quied,buti is r cognii n oft e gener lprnci l t at e s o h ee r nt e to b a i pe h

teol men o etbihn api afcecs o idvda dsr iain . . h ny as f sal ig r ai ae fn iiul i i nt . . s m cm o
a yTil VI plitf mus c ryteiiilbude o ofeige ie c a e u t t n te I an if t ar h nta r n f frn vd n e d q ae o
c e t a i f r nc t a a e pl ym e tde ii n wa bas d o a di c i i a or r a e n n e e e h t n m o n c so s en s rm n t y crt ron il galundert e Act ie i le h .

1
' , 2

j

1 8
19
.

J; 'Bhd.o Te m se sv Unie S a e ,431U . . 3 8(l )( iigM c onn lDou ls ?// f a t r . td t ts S 324, 5 977 ctn D e l g a

20

Cop.41lU. . t80 n.3 .Plitf h spovie die tevdt c ofdici iao z tveby r, S a 2 l ) anif a r d d rc i n e srm n tn moi
21

wa oftsi onyc n er ig Ha e ' dic i i at r c mm e t.Se Cog/// v Am. q ood y e tm o c nn y ss s rm n o y o n s e ifi . Se f s ?
22

Co.41 F. d 1 0,1 95 ( t Ci.2 05)(r ie te i e cet pial c nsssofc e rys x s, , 3 3 09 0 9 h r 0 i r c vd n y c ly o it l al e it
23 .

r cs,orsm ia l dic i i aor satm e t oraci nsbyt ee pl y r' .Heha alopr vi e a it i lry s rm n t y t e n s to h m o e .) ' s s o dd
24
25

evi ence t alhi r cl s ii aton applcaton was eiherdeni d ornotf ly pr ces ed bccaus of d h s e a s fc i ii t e ul o s e

Page l1 of l 8

!

1 Ha essiput Su mayj dgme t ti cli i t eeor nota prplae. y 'n . m r u n on hs am s h rf e p o i t
2 Thid,Def ndant ar ue t atPl i tf w asnota s pel i or. A lhough ls ed as a l gal r e sg h a n if u ws t it e

3 isue,D ef ndant ar ue t i as a f ct alisue. Def ndant ar ue t atM anagem entA nal stI sdo s e s g hs au s e sg h yl

4 no h ve s pe v s r qua ii a i nsbec u e t e do no p r or s pe vio y t s s Butt i w a t a u r i o y lfc to a s hy t e f m u r s r ak . hs s
5 pr ciel Pl i tt s ar um e ti appl i g t ha e hi posii n r cl s ii d:t athi par iul r e s y a n ir g n n yn o v s to e a s fe h s tc a 6 poston i f ctr quied supe vior t s s,and t ati s oul i er f r be r cl s ii d upwar ii n a e r r s y ak h th d e o e e a s fe d 7 9om M anagem entA nal stt t Prnci alM anagem entAnal st D ef ndant aio ar ue t at y lo i p y. e ss g h

8 Pl i tf di noti f cth vca y s pe v s r dute i hi pos ton a t e Ac de y. The Co r a n if d n a a n u r io y i s n s ii t h am ut
9 tnds t att i i a ques i n off ct Pl i tf aleges,and D ef ndant do notappeart deny,t a i h hs s to a . a n if l e s o ht

l he wa r gu a l i c a ge ofc de sa t eA c de y a a i s r ct r O n t e ot e ha d, 0 s e lry n h r a t th a m s n n tu o . h hr n
11 D ef ndant ar ue,and Pl i tf does notappeart deny,t athe neve super i ed permanent e sg a n if o h r vs

1 A c de y pe s nne . n e c r di a r e e ta pe r t b ove whe he Pl i tf w a a 2 am ro l o e s g e m n p a s o e r t r a n if s
l ts pervior'i hi capaciy asan i sruct rofst dent att e academ y. A r asonabl f ctfnder 3 tu s 'n s t nt o ush e e a -i 14 coui tnd t att e s pew i ï n ofst dent atan academ y r quies sgnii antsupenrs r skil . di h h u so us e r i fc io y ls

1 Fore a pl , iia y p r on e a tndi g tai i g c ur e a ay f o t e rpe m a e tsato s 5 x m e m lt r e s n l te n r n n o s s w r m h i r n n t i n 1 a e s pe v s d i a 1 pe t by l c ls r e nt a d ofi e sw ho a m i i t rt e ta ni g c ur e 6 r u r i e n 1 as c s o a e g a s n ic r d n se h r i n o s
17 t e sm de ti pr s ntt atend,eve t ough t e s udenti pcr anenty as i ned t a dit ntbase. h n s ee o t nh ht sm l sg o sa 18 These st dtntper onnelhave no daiy s pervi i n by t ei penna entsupervi or whie att e u s lu so hr n ss l h

1 dit ntta ni g I c ton, nd s pe v son i l f t t e i s r ct r a t c ta ni g i s iu i n. n e 9 s a r i n o a i a u r i i s e t o h n tu o s t h r i n n tt to
20 pr s ntsiuaton appear t be si iar. Thati,a t pi alcadetatt e Academ y lkel has no ee t i so ml s yc h iy

21 diec s pe vi i n by hi pe na e ts pe v s r bu onl b Ac de y i s r ct r who a e r t u r so s n n n u r io , t y y a m n tu o s r
22 inm edi t l pr sent JustbecauseA c dem y per onne)pr sum abl cannotm ake e pl ym e t r a ey e . a s e y mo n

23 d ci i ns i t e s m e wa t a t e c de s'p nna e ts pe vior c n doe notm e n t a e so n h a y hth a t e n n u r s s a s a ht

2 Aca e yisr cor rquienos pe rs r s il t pcfr teij bs Be a s raona l fc4 d m n tu t s e r u n io y k ls o rom h r o . c u e e s be a t
25 Gnder coul diagr eon t i poi tbas d on t e evi ence cur cnty adduced,i i nots iabl f r s dse hs n e h d rl ts ut e o Page 1 of 18 2

;

'

l !

l s mmayj dgme t u ru n.

2
;

Fo rh, fnd nt ag eta Plitf ha fie t s o a yi pr pe moiainf r u t Dee a s ru b t an if s ald o h w n m o r tv to o

i ! '

3 H ayes' aleged poorteat entofPl i tff and t athi hos ie wor envionm entcl i t er f r sl rm an i , b s tl k r am h eo e 4 f is Def ndant ar ue t atPl i tf ' evi e ce ofHayes' di crm i at r com m ent f ls a l. e sg h an if s d n s s i n oy s al 5 outi e oft eei btw ee perod i t e Fal of2006 durng w hi h Pl i tf alegesHayes sd b g - k i nh l i c a n kf j

6 ha a s d hi w ih dic i i a o y m otva i n a d t at a ntf ne e c m pl i e of r s e m t s rm n t r i to n h Pl i if v r o a n d
.

7 di crm i at r teat ent9om Apr l2006 t O ct be 2006 when hew or ed f rHayes. s i n oy r m i o or ko 8 W het erPl i tf pr vi usl com pl i ed oft et eat enthe now alegest have suf er d h a n if e o y an hrm l o fe

!
;

9 i onl r l vantt Til VI sexhauston r quiem ent and Pl i tf s ow n cr di iiy. The s y ee o te I ier s a n ip e b lt

i

1 f r e is ei n l ng ri diput,a dt eCou t ynotc nsde t elte is ea t e 0 o m r su s o o e n s e n h r ma o i r b a tr s u t h

l1 s mmayj dgme tsa e.Alo, e ' c mm e t aeno ne e srl irlva tsmpl be a s u r u n tg s Hay ss o ns r t c saiy ree n i y c u e
1 t ey w er m ade out i e oft e tm eperod duri g whi h Pl i tf alegeshar s m entand 2h e sd hi i n c a n if l as ,

: .

1 dipa a e tea m e t Bef r -he- actand at rt e- actcom m ent w ilofen be t e 's oki g 3 s rt r t n . b et f u -h f slt h çm n

. 1
.

1

1 gn'ti r iao vametsc cmmetaeeeatoIn ate aepoaieo4 u-o- s i nte et n. uh o nsrrlvns og shy r rbt f d cm v
1 t e a to s c m pl i e of l wilb t e i pos i l r r s t a i n whe e ade e da t a esa 5 h c i n o a n d . t l e h m sb y a e iu to r fn n m k
l6 di crm i at r com m entcont m pom neousl w ih t edicrm i at r actsuch t attl entr s i n oy e y t h s i n oy h le ie
l7 evi ence neces ar t s ppon a Til VH ver i ti encaps l t d i a si gl s aps ot N o one d syou te dc s u ae n n e n h .

I

:

1 s y , t' r co m e di g de y n y urr que tbec u e y u a e bl c ,a d 1 m goi g t ha a s 8 a s t m e m n n n ig o e s a s o r a k n ' l n o rs 1 y u a d e c ur g y urc w o ke st i no e y u f rt e s m er as n. Eve u a ol g tc r c s s 9 o n n o ae o o r r o g r o o h a e o ' ' n n p o e i a it
20 ar cl ver rt an t at.A f ct fnderw ilofen havet pi ce t get erconfi tng and am bi uous ee eh h a -i lt oe oh lc i g 21 evi ence t det nni e whet eran actw asdone w ih dicri i at r i t nt Furher or ,asnot d d oen h t s m n oy ne . t m e e

22 il ',Ha essc m m e t t El nd Pote we ema edu i g t epe id t a Pli tf alge l a y ' o n s o o a tr r d rn h ro h t an if le s h
23 ha a s c t And, Pl i tf not s i hi r s on e, he Cl r Cou t Of i e ofD i e st is l rsm n . as a n if e n s e p s t ak n y fc v ri tef y
24 f und t at'D urng t i tm e pcrod ofM ar h-lul 2005 She on Ti dal --ayesdi m ake o h t i hs i i c y r s el l d

25 ia pr praer c a d r lgi u bas d c mm e t t J r m eSi o !'c ?' erit / Al l n p o it a e n ei o s e o n s o e o m n t?? lf l l ( aï /q g?

(
.

Page 1 of l 3 8

'

'

I !
.

!

'

1 Pullhe ... Suc comme t mus bepr s rb da lf u c e ke c ul ce t lg lla iiy sp r . h ns t o cie s ct n h c d o d rae e a iblt
2 f rt eor a iai n. ( fieofDi e st M e .t Che l nTo ns n , a . 2007, No. o h g n z to ' O fc ' v riy m o ry w e d M r 6, ECF
.

3 5 - (mph ssa de l. 57 e ai d d)

j I
!

' 4 Defnda t agueta Ha e ' dici iatr c mme t aetsry'a amae oflw. e ns r h t y ss srm n oy o n s r sta ' s tr a 5 t ta 'c mme t aeto eta aema eo tieo tec nc t fe po me t e iin . e t ry' o ns r h s h t r d usd f h o tx o m ly n d cso s S e s

6 Merc vFa mesIs Gr.8 2F.d13 , 4 8(t Ci. 9 0.Fo e a pe iasp rio rik . r r n . p, 9 2 4 4 1 3 9h r l 9 ) r x m l,f u evsr
7 ma esar cs c r m e tt ac le guet a h snot i gt dowib e plym e tde iins t e k a it on n o o la h t a hn o t m o n cso ,h n
I

!

8 t e atiudesil stat d by t e comm e tca notbe i put d t an adver e empl ym entdeci i n, h tt lu r e h nn m eo s o so

I

I

9 buti as p r io ma e ac m m e ti t ec ntxtofa emplym e tde iin, t e atiudes f u evs r k s o n n h o e n o n cso h tt
'
1 il s r t d by t e c m m e tc n be c nsde e m m otva i g t e d ci i n. I ot erwor s,i i not 0 lu ta e bo na o i r d s i tn b e s o n h d ts
11 enough f ra pl i tf t s ow t att e s per iordilkespeopl ofhi orherbackgr und as a o an if o h h h u v s si e s o

1 g nea ma tr Thec mm ents mu ti diaetttt es pe vs ri a tt tea me be soft e 2 e r l te . o t) s n c t ia h u r io s p o r t m r h
13 pl i tf ' backgr und unf il i empl p nentdeci i ns ort att e supenzs rhas teat d or a n ifs o a ry n o so , h h io re 1 i t nds t teatt epl i tf unf il i a pari ul rcicum st nce. A lhougb r m ar sspecii aly 4 ne o r h a n if a ry n tc a r a t ck fc l 1 r l t d t a pl i tf' ow n empl ym entdecii n ar t e m osty cl ary r l vantki dsofr m a ks, 5 eae o a n ifs o so e h l e l ee n er

1 t e N i t Cic i ha alo h l t a r m a ksr l t d t ge e a e pl y e tpr c i esora tt de 6 h n h r u t s s e d h t e r e a e o n r l m o m n a tc tiu s 1 c n be r l v ntt s ow di c i i a i n i pa t ul ri s a c sev n i notdie t d s e ii aly t 7a ee a o h s rm n to n r i a n t n e e f c r c e p c fc l o
18 t os i st nces,so l ng ast e com m ent ar m adebyt edeci i n m aker See .. ?,'/ v.Cal b ena o h se h so . &f 7 ( # J g? .

1 Pu .Utl. nr ', F.d 1 70,1 7 77(t Ci.1 8 ) 9 b is Cor ? , 67 3 4 4 * 9h r 9 5 . ;7
2 0 Atl a ts m e ofHa es sc m m e t i t i c s we e m a c i t e e pl y e tc nt x . es o -y'o ns n hs a e r d n h m o m n o e t

21 El nd Pote t s ii d a h rde os t n t atHa e ha s v r l i espoi t d t t e b c ofh r o a t r e tfe t e p ii h o y s d e e a tm ne o h a k e
22 hand t i di at hers i col r i a cont xtt ati pled t atA fi a - m eri anss oul si k on c e kn o n ehmih rc n A c h d tc 23 t get er a d Hayesdi t i s ecii aly i t e cont xtoft c Hayes pul i herconti t ie. o h ,n d h s p fc l n b e h - sp lc , . ,

24 Ha e ha t l Po trnott s e k wi Pulihe an wa up e wih Pote t a s eha . S e y s d o d te o p a t sp r d s s t t tr h t h d ( e h
25

Page l of 18 4

. 1

:
!

1 Pote De . 39, c 1 20 9, No. - )3 Ha e aloo c a c sdJ rmeSi o of tr p 34- De . 7, 0 ECF 532 . y s s n e c u e eo mn 2 benglya t tewhie . ( i o De . 0:0-11 De .1 2009, No. 1.Si on i o lo h ts S m n p 3 1 , c 5, ECF 53-) m 3 tsiidt a Ha essa e t hi ( twor lt a wbie a d M o nonssikt c te , s bl cks e tfe h t v tt d o m a k h t t s n n tc o eh r o a
' ' ' ' ' ' '

1
!

-

4 s oul as siktgete .S e1.32 33) Alho ghSi ondi notb le eHa eswa r fni g h d lo tc o h r (e * - . t u m # d eiv y s ee n
5 s ecii aly t Pl i tf ,butt ot erwbie,M or on,m al empl yees,t es cor m ent w er p fc l o a n if oh t m e o he n se
1
(

i

6 m ade i t e e pl ym entcont xtbecaus t ey had t do w ih cooper tng w ih ot erem pl yees nh m o e eh o t ai th o

7 a wor a d c o s ng s d si diput sat o k,whi h g r l v ntt t c ho tl wo k e vionm e t t k n h o i ie n s e w r c s e e a o h s ie r n r n

8 cam.Se i. -3 ) Th c mme t Ha e ma et Parc Blc ,u lk to ema et Potr li ( e d 32 6 . e o ns y s d o tik a k n ie h s d o te
! 7 1

i :

9 a dSmo ,r moel eysry b cuete smpyidct Ha e'dsiefr ie n i n ae r i l ta , ea s h y i l n iae y ss il o wht k k
1 c w or e sa a ge er lmate i 2 01or2 02,wihouta y i diaton t ats e i t n e t te t 0 o kr s n a tr n 0 0 t n n c i h h n e d d o ra 11 t e dif r nty t a non- hie c w or e sort a s e e pe t d he s bo di a e t f low s i. h m fe e l h n w t o kr b t h x ce r u r n ts o o l u t

) ' :

1 ( e Blc De .11 1 2:2, b.2 ,201 , No.5 ) Ag i ,t eCou tdi nott r di't i 2 S e a k p :0-1 1 Fe 3 0 ECF 3 . an h r d ' e t' h s c
1 evi e c ,a D e e da t ar ue a d i ne d notdo s . I f u d o l t a a m i s b eev d nc ha 3 d n e s fn ns g , n t e o t o n ny b t d sil ie e d
.

I

,
. 1

1 been pr duced t atwoul be s fi i ntt s pporta t ndi g ofdicr m i at r m otve i a f ct 4 o h d u fc e o u in s i n oy i f a!

1 t dr i ceii 5 i edd rdtt n .
.

1

1 6 17

Bendantstnnii dentiaryrequests. First,theyasktheCourttoexcludeany . M lkiL n ooeseven evi me Def ma

j '
k

18 evi ence t atCl r Count t ansf red orpr m ot d poorpedbr i g empl yeesw ho t r at ned d b ak y r er oe mn o he e 1 r ce dicrm i aton l wsuis,sucl asHayes AsD ef ndant not ,t e Cour basruld t at 9a si n i a t l . e s eh t eh

20 Pl i tf ha notbr ugbta dipa a e i pa tc a m , nd h h snotna e Cl r Coun y a a a n if s o s r t -m c l i a e a m d ak ts

2l Dee d ntwihrs e tt te(1 8 cam .Se Or e 7:7 8:3,Se t20, 0, No.7 ) fn a t ep c o h ' 9 3 li ( e d r 1- l p . 201 ECF 8.
2 Def n a ta ks t e Cour l e cl de s c e i e c be au e i i notr l v ntt a y ofPl i tf s 2 edn s h tt x u u h vd n e c s ts l ee a o n a n if

23 camsa di lk l t con uetej r . eFe .R. d. -40 .Th Cour grnstemoton li n s iey o f s h uy Se d Evi 401 3 e t at h i
24 3nci ent ly, t i deposii n t s i ony put i t di put D ef ndant 'cl i t atH ayes l d al hs to e tm s no s e e s am h 25 neverm ade alegcdl di crm i ar r com m enr t Potcrdurng t e r l vant(m e fam e. l y s i n oy so t i h cc ir Page !5 of l8

1 i t i r gar butw ilnotcat gorcaly excl de al evi ence ofHayes' aleged poorperor ance n hs e d l e il u ld sl fm

2 i Pl i tf c n s ow i i r lva tt hi ot e c ai s f a n if a h t s e e n o s h r l m . 3
4

S c n ,De e d nt a k t e Co r t e c ud t si ony by Pa rc Bl c a d Ca h rne e o d fn a s s h u t o x l e e tm ti k a k n tei
Hal r gar i g aleged di crm i at r comm ent by Hayes. Def nda t ar ue t esecom m ent e e dn l s i n oy s e ns g h s

5 ar t o r m ot i tm e t be r l vant Thecomm ent ar notir l vant A dicrm i at r eo e en i o ee . se ree . s i n oy 6 com m entm ade i 2001i r l vantt aleged dicrm i at r actonst ken i 2006,beca se n s ee ol s i n oy i a n u 7 evi e ce ofa pas di crm i at r atiude afect t e pr babiiy t ata acton t ken l t rwas dn t s i n o y tt f sh o lt h n i a ae

8 m otva e b dic i i at r i t nt af c w hi h i ofc ns q e c t a d s rm i a i n c a m . e i t d y s r m n o y n e , a t c s o e u n e o i c i n to l i Se

9 Fe . Evi . (sRee a te i e c 'me nse ie c ha ig a ytnde c t ma e t e d R. d 401 çt lv n v d n e a v d n e v n n e n y o k h
1 e it nc ofa y f c t a i ofcon e ue c t t e de e m i aton oft e a ton m or pr b bl or 0 x se e n a t h t s s q n e o h tr n i h ci e oa e

ll ls pr ba l ta iwo l bewiho ttee ie c '.Dee da t ma cetil agu t te es o b e h n t ud t u h vd n e) fn ns y rany r e o h 1 j r ta telps i tmema estee ie c we k Plitf mus ofc ureprveitnta d 2 u y h th a e n i k h vd n e a anif t o s o ne , n
13 al ot erel m ent ofhi cl i s by a pr ponde ance oft eevi ence butr l vance underRul Ib e s s am , e r h d ee e 14 401i a eiher- rconcept nota s i i g s al . The Cour asksonl whet erevi ence i s n t -o , ld n c e t y h d s

l r lv n . ei . tkl'e de c '( mph ssad e l .I i f rt ef c -i de t de em i ebow 5 e e a t Se d ttrytn n y ' e a i d d ) t s o h a tfn r o t r n t.

1 pes a ieapa t ulrpic ofe ie cei.l ore t a oi a yposil err tej r c nbe 6 ru sv ri a e e vd n s n d r o v d n sbe ro,h u y a c
1 i sr c e t a t e c nnotc n i e s r y c r m e t , nd t i c n be de i e f rt e . The Co r 7 n tu td h t h y a o s d r ta o n n s a h s a fn d o h m ut 1 de i st e r que tt c t gorc ly e cl de t e c m m e t . 8 n e h e s o ae ial x u h o ns 1 9 Th r ,De e da t a k t e Co r t e c ude e i e c ofH a es se pl ym e thi t r id f n n s s h u to x l vd n e y ' m o n so y

20 bef r s e ani ed atDJJS as ir l vantt Pl i tf ' cl i s. The Courtcannotsay att i poi t oe h v re e o a n if s a m hs n 21 t atany s ch evi c ce woul be ir l vantf ral pur oses Ata m i i um ,t er m ay be h u dn d ree olp . nm he 22 evi ence r l vantt i peachm ent d ee om .

23

Fou t ,De e d n s a k t e Cou tt e c ud e i e c by El nda Pote r ga di g a l g d rh f n a t s h r o x l e vd n e o t r e r n le e

24 dicrm i al r comm e t b) Hayesbecaus Potcrdi notwor wih Hayesunrlaf ert e aleged s i n oy ns ' etd kt ith l

25 dicrm iaoyte t c t Dee d ntagu sta 'glsi on fo wine sswh ween ti s i n tr ram n. fn a r e h tlte tm y rm t se o r o n
Page l6 of l8

.
i
i

* '

l teworplc d rngtea plc bl peidc nnotpo sbly)bepr baieofPlitt shosie h k a e u i b p ia e ro a si l o tv anir tl
2 wor e vion e tcli . (eeM o. mie7: 1 1 , k n r m n am ' S ' tLi n 1 - 3 Nov.1 , 0, No. 4) Thi i not 5 201 ECF 8 . s s
!

3 per uasve. ' lati H ayeshad s i t Poter t1can' sand whie,M or on guyslke Pul i her ' s i Wl f a d o t ,t tt t m i sp .

4 1m e s d wih bi a wor whe e e 1co l l ? Ofc ur e t e e i n e i e c i t er c r se t m t k n v r ud ' ' o s,h r s o vd n e n h e o d
5 H ayes eversai anyt i g lke t i,buti w oul be r l vantt bot a hosiew or envionm ent d hn i h s t d ee oh tl k r

6 cl i a d a di c i i a i n c a m i s e ha . The e i e i t c s e m a e c r m e t i di a i g am n s rm n to l i f h d r s vd n e b d o n n s n c tn 7 h rm otv sa d i t ntt te tpe s ns o Pl i tf s pr t c e cl s e dif r n l . Evi e ce o e i e n n e o r a r o f an if ' o e t d a s s f e e ty dn f
8 i t ntdoes notbecom e ir l vantsi pl because i i r veal d afert e acton occur . l f ct an ne ree my ts e e t h i s na, 9 afert e-actadm i si n m i htbe consi er d pari ul ry power ule i ence by a f ct fnder t -h f so g de tc a l f vd a -i ,

'

1 be a s a pe s n who be a e t i wa ha a sr ng m otva i n t h d he m otva i nsa t rt e 0 cue ro h v s h s y s to i to o i e r i to f e h

ll da a ei done n ej r c nde ie wiha popit isr cins whebe Ha e ' c mme t mg s . u y a cd , t p r rae n tu to , t r y ss o ns
1 t Pote s p or t ecl i s The Cou de i st i r q e t 2 o tr u p t b am . n n e h s e u s.
13 Fit ,Def ndant as t e Courtt excl de evi ence ofunr l t d diclm i aton suis fh e s kh o u d ea e s i n i t .

14 agai s Cl r Count . TheCour excl des s ch evi ence asir l vant See Fed.R.Ci .P. n t ak y tu u d ree . v
l5 401 402. -

1 6

Si t , e e da t a k t e Cour t e cl de t si o y t a H a esus d t e t r t or on x h D fn n s s h t o x u e tm n h t y e h em t m M .

1 M ata. Def nda t a gue t a Ca e r n H a e' t s i on o t i poi ti va ue D e e d nt 7 i' ' e ns r h t t h i e l s e tm y n b s n s g . f n a s

l c nagu t i t tej r itetsi o yi a du e .l Haetke tesa d,he ma cos 8 a r e hs o h uy fb etm n s d c d f l a s b tn t y y r s

! '

1 e a iehe.Dee da t aloagu ta tec mme t aemor prj diilta pobaie But 9 x m n r fn ns s r e h tb o ns r e eu ca h n r tv .
20 t e c m m e t a e i f c onl i fa m a or pr c s l be a s oft e rp obiy.Th e i e c w il ho n s r n a t y n lm t y e iey c u e h i r t e vd n e l

2l no bee cude .Agai,tej r ma beisnltdontesryco me t d ctie. t xl d n h u y y n t ce h ta - m ns o rn
22 Sevent ,Def ndant as t e Cour t excl de Jer m e Si on' t s i ony aboutcom m ent h e s kh lo u o m s e tm s

23 H ayesm adet Si on. D ef ndant ar ue t ats ch com m ent do nots pportahar ss ent om e sg h u s u am

2 t e r ,be a s t e w e enotm a e i Pli tf' pr s nc . Buts c c m m e t a e r l va tt 4 h oy cue h y r d n a n ifs e e e uh o n s r ee n o 25 i t nt whi h i a e e e toft e dic i i a i n c a m . The Coun dc i s t i r qu s. ne , c s n lm n h s rm n to l i ne hs e e t
Page 17 of l8

i
I

1

CO N C L U SI N O

2

I I HEREBY ORDERED t a t eM o in f rRe onsde ai n ( CF No. )i TS h tb to o c i r to E 79 s

3 DENI D . E

4

I I FURTHER ORDERED ta teMotoni Linie( CFNo. 4)i GRANTED i TS h tb i n rn E 8s n

5 pa1 and DEN I D i par . 4 Ent
6 I I SO ORDERED. TS

7
8 9

Dat d t i 27t day ofDec m ber 201 . e hs h e ,0

.

-

RO B E U nied St t

.JON ES Di ti tJudge sz c

1 3

Page 1 of 18 8