Voggenthaler, et al., v. Maryland Square, LLC, et al.,

Filing 592

PERMANENT INJUNCTION Governing the Clean Up of Hazardous Substances at and Emanating from Maryland Square Shopping Center. Signed by Judge Robert C. Jones on 12/27/10. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - ASB)

Download PDF
. . FL O IE pj g g 'qg r . . P t(l( . . E bD ' . gq gj g y g gy '1 ROBERT#ON & W CK, ' LLP Alxa d rRobeto ,I ( V Ba No' 42) e ne rs n V N r . 86 2 J n ie L. ylr( V Ba No. ) e n fr Ta o N r 5798 40lNorhBufaoDrve Suie20 t fl i , t 2 3 1 % V e a , e ad 891 5 . g sN v a 4 tdSt?hIs0r Eo; NE/&TE zcR 2EC 2 7 2 1 20 4 Fas ue(0) 4 -27 cm l:72 2762 5 i v o a r c lw .o o lr v da c m ' Tee h ne:702 247-661 l? q ( ) 4 ao eto @n c lw .o rb rs n da c m J nAda Grbe ( A BarNo.1 34 4 a m e nC 0 6) '' . CEjI DSR JS q L8 S I I f Iq Dzl( 0 N V Z lTtl F LA A lf . IE CY . I FJ T 8 :. Y 6 GREBEN & ASSOCI TtS A 7 AdmitdPr Hac Yie te o c 1 3 Ar ca aSe t Suie 11 32 m p e t0 8 Sa u B a b0 , n r CA 931 1 0 Telpho e: 8 5)963-090 e n (0 9 9 Fa smle (05)96 -998 c' ' : 8 tl 39 i nt zr be l w . om a a e na c 10 At mesfr an fs t y o Pliz f o UNI ED STATES DI TRI T COURT T SC i 1 1 2 13 ' DI TRI T OF NEVADA SC . e1 14 'ETER 2. VOGGENTHALERJ ta. P . 15 16 vs . Plitfs anifk 17 M ARYIAND SQUARE, , LLC; a. et l 18 -GWF Voggenthaler, et al., v. Maryland Square, LLC, et al., Dee da t. fn ns Doc. 592 ) CAS NO 2:8-y- 1 1 RCJ( W F) E 0 c 06 8 G ) 7 . ' ) ) PERMAW N . ) I JUNCTI N GOVERNI G THE N O N ) CLNAN UP OENAZARDOUS ) SW STANCESAT AND XM ANATI G N ) FROM MARYLAND SQUAQE ) SHOPVI G CENTER N j ' 1 9 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 3:. : Dockets.Justia.com ! 1 11 . I TR O D U C T I N N O 2 : ' . n eCo r h rb is e tef l wigIj n to Go e igt eCla u o te u t ee y su s h l n nu cin v m n h en p f h o ' . ' 3 Hnu r ol Subsa Co tm i a o a a d Km n nig fo t eM aylnd Squa eSho pig d ts tn e na u u n t n n tn r m h za r pn ' 4 Ce trren t cin'. ne ljm 'to ' l 5 U B T m ssy oRoElzo, ADJJ GBD Axo oEcasFo pulsum . p t ID . t 6 THAT; 5 ' To . . ; ! . 6 FEDERAL RU LE OF Cn ' PROCY D I K X 7 H. D E FI TI N S MO 8 . .. W h ne e tl flp igtr saeUS,i ti Ijmcin,ogehe wihal ume t e v r le olw n em r eIn hs nt to t t r t ldoc n s I : . ' 9 a pe de he e o,t ef lo i g m e nl gsK al a pl : ' p n d rt h o l w n n n b lp y . . I 1: 11 A. e o r ci eActon'm e nnage m a e tr m e yt pr ve taba a do ssisa o ' re tv C i'q r nn e d o e n z r u tb ti e o w a t f om posng at r a ( po e a t r a t pu lole lb ort e r se r i ,h e t i t n l h e t o b i a t r h ' 1 2 . e vio me t( e n nAdmiitaieCo e( AQ 445A.26 ) n rn n N v d n srtv d N 2 2. 1 3 1 4 1 5 B. ' ee d ns'h lme n( ) aya dS u ry D fn a t's al a l M rln q ae LLC;2 ' aya dS u r ( )M rln q ae Sho pigCe trLi ie LibiiyCompv y ( )Hema Kihne, Maya d p n ne m td a lt ; 3' r n s r dba rln Sq'aeSho pigCe tr a d()l' i Kihne , er Enge, ndBn kof ,r p n ne ; n 4 hw n q r J ry la n 1 6 ' Ameiam i ute frteHema Kil t Trs:5 Slor Brtms rc s ' ses o h r n sm r ut() l io oh . r i I ve t t tCo, n sm n 17 1 8 C. ' ei ea l 's alm t n,wihou lm iein, nywo k pl n, e o t pr p e s D lv r b e' h l a t t i tl o a t r a r p ra s . 19 r pot piw daa d c m e t i f r nin, s bm itl whih t eDe el a t ae e l a ta o u n n o m to or u ta, c h f td n s r 2 0 21 . D. rquie t s b i t teNev daDiiinofEnvio me tlPrtcin(T EP) e rd o u m to h a vso r n na oe to 'D . N t-a a d ts Su sa c ' s a lha e t es m em e ni gs a s tf rt e i tl z r o l b t n e ' h l v h a l a n se o h n 22 ' . ' Compr he sveEnvio m e t l s o s ,Compe s to a dLibiiyAo e ni r n n Re p n e n a in n a lt t . ( ERcLA)1 11 ) 42U., . ( 4 $ icutigwihou lmiain1 c 0 (4: sc 9601 1 ) u l ln t t i tto tta hlr eh lze( CE) tihlr ebye e( CE) cs lz-ihlr eh lne a d erc o o tyei P ,zs o o t ln T , '- , dc o o tye , n i 2 3 24 . 25 26 c lr ehe e( lorfre t a viy c lrde,a ds als e i o lyi cu eaJ ho o t n as eerd o s n l hoi ) n h l p cf al n ld I m at r al m eetng eibert e defnii n ofT laza dous W as e' ortsold W ast ' s t ei s ith i to l r t' t i e' e 27 7$ i frh i f d r lRe o r eCons r a in a dPe ove ' tt cp lsa uor, ot n e ea suc e v to n v c o Ac ' u x tt t ) R ei ii nsa 1 03( 1a ff 7' 42U. . '69f3( 'a f ( 7 r s eri ey.l fn to : 0 5 n . 2 ) : S C. J ' 1 n 2 1 e p v l n 5 l ; E i ! a d ton,xl z r ol Subsa c 'i cud s Wilutlm ia in,ha adouswas d ii a ad l l s t n e'n l e , tl i t to zr t t o a aRe ie Sa ts ' v d v sd tm e N c ntri a t o xnn n B )45 .30,apoltnt 94 ) lua 445 .00 a da A4 ) n 4 5 .25) 4A3 . ' n e i - c o Le e ' m e= ND BP' I t rm - c i n Le e o rpcB va op i ' t rm A u n v l' I S n e i A to v l pn O Sde ua i d orai, c sba i on a1 - i o e e t lrm pe u . . i n l n o r whii wa s d 0. n r m n a i rs F G. Envio me tlmotcinAg no ' 200 PrlmiayRe e idonGo l ( ROs. rn na to e y s 4 ei n r m da as P ) ' g . t aina Uo hnge c Pln'orC CP's almen40C. X .PM 300 . W to l n n y a ' W 'h l a F, . , E A C 'm e zst eN e a aA dr i l ta i e Code. W ' al h vd n n s r tv H. ' DEP's alme n t eNe a aDi sonofEnvionm e t lPr tc in oft e N 'h l a b v d G i r n a o e to h N e a aD e Rf e to Co s w a o a dNahl lRes u ce . vd p rm n f n e n n m or s 1 . J. . . w m s,,m e nstl N e a Re sdsttts a le v u vie aue' ' pe t's alme n t ep ope t a dl m to oft ef t e A1Philpst e ' M ry ' h l a h r ry n o in h o m r li h Cla e ( PTC)dr cenigbusne slctda 3661S. aylndPakwayi en r A y ln n i s o ae t M ra r n t e La V e as N e a a w hi h i oria b/ n o ne by t eD e e da t . h s g , v d y o s ls e w d h fn n s K. ' e e ito Stndad'zia stelv lo c n e tainotahnmr ou A m ain a r 're n h e c f o c nrto sd s bsanc ,ln - d usm ai ilo ar gu ae s bsa c i s i, nd ae o u t e l' r o z q tra r e ltd u tn e n o l pou w ti r s ra ewa e wh c Core veAc in i de i n d t a hive.Thef a u fc tr ih t c to s sg e o c e ml rm e it nsa d r sma b aj se b sdo st-p cscfcos t- cfc e dai tn ad y e du td ae n i s o i a tz, i s ii o e ew c lultdrs c tm ains ml ba kgrt d(..a bin)c idiins ac ae ik si to , d c om ie, m e t oz to . L. t ie's a lm e n t eTr pe t a d a y a e o m e i whe eH n nr ous t t ' h l a h 'o ry n n r a r d a s r ed j bpn c srla e a o fo t ePrp ryh vec m et belc td icu ig u fn e ec s d t r rm h o e t a o o o ae yn ldn a ya c wh r Ha adousSu sa c sr l a eda orfom t ePr pe t ha e n ra ee z r b tn e ee s t r l o ry v a c r ii gld wihHa a doz Su sa c sfo ot e st s om ln e t z r ls b tn e r m h r ie . M. t or ' s al m e n al a td te pr s rbe by,o r quie t bepe f r e s k ' h l a l ci is e o i d W r e rd o ro m d p rua rt ti ijmcin.- 1d cu e t rq iedt bes bmitd. NDEPa . u s n o h s nt to V o m ns e ur o u te t o s pa loft i W or , sw e lasa y r quiz r s ons by N D EP , ha lbe fl, wib r hs km l n e rd e p e sl rt d t e Cour . h t j ' 1 m. . . I JU N C TI N TO I N D ER T A K E M TI A T I N A N D CO D Q E C TM N O J G O A CTI N S O 2 .. . . n eDefnda t m'e ji e t a ds alj itya dsveal, ciaei ti e n s e non, o n h l,onl n e rly pe p t n h s d ' . , 3 Ij n t ng v r igt ep ro ma c o W oka t eSi , srqt e i t i lj n t n.No nu ci o enn i efr n e f r ti t a e trd n ls nu ci o l le i z o , 4 a uonss a l tke wiho tr viw a d a p o a byNDBP. . 'c h l be a.n t u e e n p r v l . 1 ; ' ' . . . ! 5 X. M I I ATI N OF I D OOR AltAl W ELL W A TBR.Atam i u t e TG O N lo nm m h ; :j ' . . 6 7 .: ' 9 . . flo igat n s l eM pe e tdj rl n t ti Ijmc o : olw n ci s Q b lm ne usl to hsnt n o a 1 . W okPlnlrW t aino I d o Ai a dW el ae .Wibnsxt r a ' i to f n o r r n tW tr Al i y b g ' ; ' (0 da softee e *vedaeo t i Ijmcin t eDee dx t s al 6) y h f c t f hs nt to ah fn n s h t s bm i aW ok Pln f rtl i plm e ton o a to sne e s r t c ntol ut z a o lo m e n a f o in s ay o o r , ' : . I . . 1 0 1 1 .1. 2 13 1 4 15 . ' . mip t da aetetrast ht a h at vatev p rituj n t ae n b t h het o t n elh i h a o nrso i m p twa .mpe et*o o V WokPlnsal gnn ltrh nti' ah y I lm na n f r a h lbe i o ae ta II ZT . . Ij I k' ' 1 I ; . . (0)dgys.tra pr va oft eW or PlnbyNDEP. 3 ate p o l h ka ' a. ' ' . To.r vi ei d o ars m plng,a la ta rl ly a dt 'ei i ae p o d n o r i a i t e s 'm nl n o b n td '' ' ' f lw i gt elm et l s e i e i ELA.. f rho e i t e o l n h i -p o ' c s d n p I, o m s n l z neg bor o dtlto e let ea e ofee adPCE c nc n rto s ih h o la v ri b r a lv t o e ta in 1 j ' j 16 17 1 8 . i gru tr a de e byte1 0rir grm spe ltr( #L) n o n wae, s e d h 0 nco a r ie p b tda yoft epl h e Re a plng s a l i ac or a c wih o!! r z h u z . s m i h l be n c d n e t . t es he ul a dwok plns& a p o e byNDEP. l ' d en lc r a s p r v, d . I ( . . 1 9 b. De i n i sala t t s t ee c c ofa diima s bsa sg , n t l rd e th l a y d to l u lb 2 0 21 22 de rsu zain( S )s se si i d o arsmplsc le td p e sd tp S D y tm f p o r i a e olce f o unm ii a e ho e t a a c f und t c nt i PCE va o s a rm tg t d m s h t r o o o an p! t c nc n a i nst a e ce d N D EP' I t rm - c i n Le e . o e t to b t x e S n e i A to v l ' '. 2 3 c. M anti a dm o io e itngSSD s se su li Re e ito i an n n tr x si y tm ttl m d ai n 2 4 25 d. Stndadsf rPCE i grundwatra didoo aiha eV e ze. aro no e n n r r v nnt D e netl downr a i nte t n oft e Sie gr t dw a erpl m e ' f ic d e x e t b t om tl z 26 27 c ati igmo et1 5pgl ofPCE,io th'nyd m etcwei o ann r .% ,.1 / d ni a o si ls wihi t i pi m e a d t ke a pr pza ea i n t a s r t a t e t n h s u , n a p o it m o o su s h :h 2 : ! t dilgw l sna f7 C .n i cgaao-rc ae j rfi ae : rsoP Sadr i rlrpour r zn ra . se i s I f - :. i . . ' . : . . . 1 2 . n t x e d di teewae slpywou. j t to bf o t o e c e e n h s tr t j j s i in w r p a t w a d de i e tng t e pl m e t 5 gg/ s al be i no l t rt a o r ln a i h u o , . h l g n L ae h n ! ' 3 ii i; ; j . t i t ( 0 da sa tra pr va o t eW or Plnby NDEP. b r y 3 ) y fe p o l f h ka B. REM ED I TI N OF sol cE AREA SOI S.TheDefnda t s als bm i t AO m L e ns h l u to . N DEP f rr viw andapprova : 1 o ee . . 4 5 ' . ' ' 6 7 . 1. .Coreci eAc in Pln ( APJf rSo r eAr aSoisl c t d a t ef r e r tv to C o uc e l o ae t h o m r . . . . M a ya d SquaeShop i g Ce t r n ecl-nu goa .o s u c a e s is r ln r pn ne. e p lf r o r e r o l q l ! i I ' .' 8 9 s albeba e o pr t c o o gr undwa e a dhu a he lk a hl sd n oe n f o t f n m n at s . de e mi e b h Ep. tr n d y r 1 0 . . C' . REM EDI U ON OF GROUNDW ATER. A 1: CAP f rGr und ae a di plm e tton s he ul d s rbi ga l o o w tr n m e n ai o d e e c i n l i I ! 11 j I 1 2 ' ' ' ' : . 1' 3 1 4 ' . a tvt sn c sayt c l jeetea ay i o at naic . rm e it ' ciii e es r o op it h n lss f lm tv st e dae ! e o qlwrnwt,oeo hl gp arnrra no od ei dt . ' ' . ddr s t e i doo arpa hw a y o be esb n r i t y t . 1' j ! s bm itd byt eDe e d nt f rmviw anda pr va byNDEp. u te b fh a s o e pol 'l :t l . 1 5 . . '. o o om w trn ' De e da t s al i pl m e tt ea pr ve cxp f rGr t d ae i fn n s h lm i n u p ' d a co - c wiht ea r ve s he u ef it eur l dwai r m e y. c r e t h x o d c d l o h ro m tr e d ' '' ' *. . * 1 6 17 2. Cor e tve Ac o Re o t D e e da t s a ls bnita(r . Corec i e rci n o r . f n n s h l u i 1a* r tv A c on R e o tf rr vi w i a c r a c wih t e p o e i pl m e t to f p r o e e n c o d n e t h p r v d m e n ain : 18 1 9 s le ul .The(.. Core tveAc o Re or s alpr vi et er s lso ' cl d e ha * rci u n p t h l o d h e ut f 20 :1 i 22 23 pio sudis be c -o l stdis a do ie tbiiyjudis(..d ti lt t e , n hs ae t e , n /r raa lt t e ie, eald z a ayssofrme ilatm a ve)co sse twibNAC 445 al NIS, ' n l i e da lr s n itn t A ld t a d t eN CP. nh 3. . Pr oo e Pl n. De e da t s a lp e a e a d s bm i t N D EP a d t e o sd a fn ns h l r p r n u t o I nh ' .' 2 4 2 5 26 Cou t aPr po e Plnno ltrt m1t i t ( 0 da sa tra pr va oft e r, o s d a a e h b ry 3 ) y fe p o l h RA S R e ol by I D EP a d t e Cour . Ti Pr pos d Pl n s a li cl de a p' N tT nh t m o e a hln u s a e e tofr a onss t hg f rb tl ba i f rt er m e i la to s ttm n es e d o t ie s s o h e d a c i n 27 sc t :a dt eRr s ito Slnd r sf rPCE i i d orarml t z ol n b m d ain a a d o nno i d 78 $ I gr u cu'lr o n i as . I - J I L- 4. R e o d o De ii n t O D ) N D EP s a lt 'l a ROD , hii s l pr s n ' c r f cso ' R . h l ka t w c ) ba l e e t t e s l c e r m e i la t r a i ef r p ou d a e a t e Sie Th sde ii n h e e t d e d a le n tv o n w t r t h t . i c so 3 szl beba e u on t eM m i ita ieRo o d NAC 44 A .271a d la l sd p b n sr tv c r , 52 n 4 44 A .227 , a d s albei a c r a cew11 q ie i lse i ' eNC' a 40 5 3 n h l n codn t1 rt ra it d n t h Pt c R 3 04 0:. v 0 .3 ( 5 Re edi io esi nm em edi lActon t o m . ).ooe auon and M ai t na ce. ma z ix A r ne u D e e da t s a l e a eRD/ A d c m e t a d s bm i t N D EP w ibi f n n s h l pr p r R o u ns n u to tn onehundr d t e t (20 da so a c ptn eoftePr posdPln,a e w ny 1 ) y f ce ac h o e a n Pe f r s c a totsi c nf r a c w ib tl r m e y s l c e a d s t r o m u h c i u n o o m n e t ie e d e e t d n e f rl i t eROD . o tl n h D. OUARTERLY GROUNDWATERMOVI ORX G AND RBPOITW G.n i T t s W or rII c ntnuea o r ig t t es he ul pr vi usy e tbls e i NDEP k J: I o i c o dn o h c d e e o l sa ih d n l ter . et s E. fn n s b l m r nt COM M UM TY RELATI N K PLAN D e e da t s a lpr a eaCommu iy O R ea irsP1n. Defnda t s a l r c o e a i ey wihNDEP a d Pli tG t ltol a e n s h l wo k o p r tv l t n an i o po ieifr ainu dtso V grs o rig to a dTme ito efrlt rvd nom to p ae n es fn ain n e dain fot o r sde t a d o he sa e ol e s i c o m to wih l c l r r e tof c as e i n s n t r t k h d r, n o p in t o a govc n n n f i l. F. STA TUS REPORTS. fnda ? s als bm i t t eCout NDEP a dt e De e n h l u t o h z nh Pl i tf s q a try r porsde c i i g s a'sofW or f rtt Sie. f nd n salp a n i , u re l e t s rb n t t u k o ie t Dt e a t s z0 21 s alpr qltyta A ite erp zsnotltrta l itz30 da satrtee d h l o pl rn m t h d e ot a h n h r.( ) y fe b n ! o teJsmo t o teq mlrbegim i g wih t ef % fb at nb fh u e, r n t h o fe ue c ofr pori g. rq n y e t n PER FO R M A N C E O F W O R K ca e f a q a trof l rd r u re 201 . D e e da t m a r qut t a d ' D E P m a c m s de , o i c to st t e 0 fn ns y e s, n N y t i r m d f ain o h A. M OD F I A TI N OF DELM RM LES. CO l Dee d n s dh' n meh do iiit ne a tvte frwhih f fn a t mo i a y to r ntae w ci i s o c i fn n s h l nc e s n ' r -e u e orplrsha eb e e tbis slt eDgc da : s a! a s a o o d r s' at v e n sa ih c)h DK Da C a acdt dtm l1f e a prw zd ' - n.'' n / Nlo-rm ' t: anc r n im t (n o W o ' -DJ . 3 * - Itsr ' 'as ' z . .. '. . . 1 . I . . j ' 1 ( 2 co me tbyNDEP.NDEP s alha eteo to ofa c ptng, e tng, mn h l v h p in c e i mjci orm od'm' ga yW or c m plt dlo r or fng una pr ve t f n k o ey o p ai pod l , 3 . ' m o i c tou orde ito s9o t ea p ov/ W or Plns d s a ils v ai n m h p r k a. Ifr 4 5 6 ' . ' 2 . EPd tr ie ta mo i o t nt t eW oks ei l i te ee m n s b t d ai o b r p cf d n b o ' . Ij nc o a d/ri ote Deiea lsde eo e ptrln tt te nu i n n o n h r lv rbe v lp d tsln o h Ij ncini nec say NDEPma r q iet a s c modi ctonbe nu to s es r, y e ur h t u b f ai i c r or t d i s c De i e a l s t t e e t ntt a i i c ns se tw i n o p a e n u h l# r b e o h x e h t t s o i t n t b 7' 8 , ' f1 1 ROD() t4 m s. 9 i 1 . 3. ' . I teDee da t orPlitFso jd t a ymodi c to deemie by fh fn ns an i be o n f ain tr n d c sr s n o h s rg a . y h kse NDF. t bene es aypuzua tt t i pa a rphz t e m ay see diput .o p . . 10 11 rs ltonbyt eCo r pus a tt Se o X m iput Reolto a d eoui h u t zu n o c n s e s uin n . i . ' I. 1 2 1 3 1 4 '' . Con iuigJ rs ito ofteCou t.Deieg lsq xl modfe i tn n uidcin h rl lv rb e b lbe iid n ' . a c r a c wib fnn r s l to oft ediput . ebe e d nt s al ' c o d n e t i l e ou in h s e n fn a s b l pr c e wih a l or no t es b e tofDi ut Re ol to . o e d t lW k th u jc o e s u in ' ' ' ' ' ' . ' ! j .. . 1 5 .' 4. . Nobn i t i p r g i al eo z tu dt l iNDE 'a to i t tlg n h s aa rpl h lb ou r e o i t PS uh rt o s m y !i ;j ' ' ' . 1' 6 rq iep romac o s-b rrmo s auo sa ob r iepo ie i e ur efr n e f e e n e c n s tew s rvdd n . ' . . . 1 7 18 tiIuco. hsn ntn ji ' . ' ' 1 j ' . 5. .' TheDee d m s alc ntnuet i plm e tteRe e ilAcint)at fn a h l o i o m e n h m da to s rd t l . 1 9 zo mananh memiiainsse su tl 'me iio Sa G d ae iti o tato ytm niRe dain tn s r ' ' ' ' ' . a hi ve ,ormsot er i e de ec i ed underN D EF' regul t z aut oriy ced h ws t mn S a oy h t 21 22 V. 23 . unde NA c 44 A . r 5 CO M PL I N C E MT TH A PPL I A B L E LAW S A I C TheW or j a lc m pl w ih a la pic bl s a e a d l c ll w s r gu a i nsa d k h l o y t 1 p i a e t t , n o a a , e l to n 2 gui ei e , a e d d:ncudi gbutnotlm ie t s S 4 5 , 4 d in s ms m n e i l n i td o NP. 4 A NRS 459a t notico sse t n n n itn 25 wib t e N C P. th 26 /// . 27 / / / 11 17? 1! 1'J j' . ' . . I L. ? ' . 1 Vl . REco M R ET E N TI N O ' ' 2 . Co iso al o u e t s al flbwi teCo r a dsbmitdt NDFp i b t h r pe f ld c m ns h lbe ie t h u t n u te o . r oh ad h ,t . 3 c p a deetol f1 frn t. nvzvlgdDeiea lsa dcgepo dnc wi b potd o y n lcrzc e orns No pjiee l rbe n o s n e e l e se i v l 4 o N D EP' we st a : ht :/ de . v.ov/ c / a v a d s u r . % . n S b ie t t /n o n z o e m r l n a a e h r . . j. 5 V1. EXTENSI N REQUESTS I O 6 ' . .' . . . F t eDe e da t a el a l t pe f r a ya tviyors b i ai do u e t t i t e h f n n s r m b e o ro m n o i t u m t ly c m p wih n h I l . 7 t erq ie u d rti Ijmciq t a Dee d t ma , ro t e pr t no ten t rq et i e urd n e h s nt to h t fn r s y p iro x iai f h ' , e u s m o m 8 mle t ns o oft e tm e i w rtrg t N D EP, i. a c py t t e Co t n e e t ns o r qu s x e i n h i n iil o wt o oh h m xq in e e t . 9 s alicudeaji c to frtedea . 1s clrquet s albei a va c oftz aeo hl nl u tf ain o h ly A1 u i e ss h l n d n e le t n ' 10 whi h t e actviy ordocm ne ti due. ch it ns 11 Vm . I COA OM TI N OFPLANS. TEDII, SANb REPORTS N O SRI T E 1 2 XIplns she ulsrpo t,s e i caim a iote doo m e t t a aes bmitdby I a , c d e, e rs p cs to nl h r u ns b t r u te . 1 Dee d nsp rt n t ti ljmcinaeic r o tdi ti Ij n t nu o fl gwihte 3 fn a t u sl to hs n t t r n op m e n h s n u ci p n in t h q o o i. 14 Cour a d t e a pr pra er vi w a d a pr va by N D EP. t n h p o it e e n p o l ' I 15 I . X ' 16 ' . CALENDAR OF TASKS AND SCNEDULES Thi Se to pr v de a IF i g a d s be ul ofke De i e a l sr q io byN D EP: s o i n o i s i tn n e d e y iv r b e e u r d . ' Ti e i e m ln '. . 1 D ei e a l 7 lv r b e 18 A, . W o k Pln f rM ii ai n o l dooyAi 1 r a o tg to f n r 19 ' ' a dW elW ae n l tr ' W ihi 60Da so ti hjmcin tn y f bs t to Se tm be l ,201 pe r 3 0 O o o e 1l. 0 tb r ' 201 . 20 B. . CAP f rSo ceAr aSo l 1 om ei ' 21 C . . ' 1 CH f rGr t d a e . o om w tr 2 c. . co r c i cAc in Ro o t 2 2 re tv to p r c: s 24 c. . Pr po e Pi n 3 ' o sd a ' ' ' . w ihi 18 da jofa pr ve tn o y pod Gr undw a e C A. o tr P W ihi 30 da sofa pr v l tn y p oa .. . 25 C.. ROD 4 26 C . . P. . A Re o t 5 ./ DR pr ' ( obeprpae byNDEP) T e rd T . W ih n l 0 da sofa pr v d ti 2 y p oe Pr pos d Pi n oea 27 2: lD 1 , . Qu reh' ou d ae hl niornga dPe orig atr Gr n w tr o t i n vp tn .ss he ul 2 cde k I ( t ' . . i . ' ' ! ; ' 1 E. o mz iyReair Pln m m t ltou a s 2 F. sau Re ot tts p zs W i i 6 d y o ti hjmcin f n 0 a s fhs t to h Qua try, giaigwih4 rei be n n t 1 Qua tr 201 re , 0 . 3 ! ' 4 IiiuonorviiainAc o s nta tg to u a 6 w ib' 3 da so a pove wok tl 0 y f p r d r n ol n a 5 ' ..' . .6 xo ieofw o k tc r . . . . . ' L No i i to wil' 5da sof tf a in tun y . know l dg ofdel y e a I ' y j g ooa i wok lyn r . ' Noltrkn5dy piroayl aeta as r t n ed o ' w or k . I I p 10 x. ' . pr rt l im r oLtrloN s ra s f coN G zt x m ce ox OF'- cotRT ms n r r . 11 TheUou ts alrti flj rs io ov rti Ijmc o f rpumo e ofc sd ng r h l ean ulu idc n e h s nt u n o s s n ln . . I' . 12 o mpla c w11iijr sa dprviinsa da j dcaiga yds ueaiighee nde. o in e t1t em n o so n du i tn n ip t rsn ru r . .43 A . I t eD e e dn t c Pl i tfs d s gr ew ih a y d oii n o.f iu' t m a e a fh f n n s ; a n if i a e t n e s o r a l r o k r e 1 4 ' . . . 15 1 6 17 ' . d ciinbyxoBppu s a tt ti Ij nc om te s al uf xoo a dte e so ru n o ls nu u z y h lno y z nh ' ltZ WltngO tedip ' (; tceofDiput, wjjy O U. 'gg;j p or Colr ii f h s ut ; i e No s e1 j . .V ( . )u uj . B. t ede ii n o f ilr . ma . ad cso . h cso r alzet ke e ii n o . n e'qouceofDiw t 's a ls tf rb t es ecfcpbi y oft ediput,t e r l s e' h l e o t l p i z ns b s e l l . . . ' ' . I . ? , 1 8 . . po ii n t ed s uant c al s o l bca opt da c n itntwih t e sto h ip t s l i h d d e s o sse th . . j. j ' j 1 9 zt l ri ie eto tiJjmcikte aifrh p s o ,z fcul1u, eurz ns fhsnt t h b s o te oi n ai ata( n o s y a a aysso o i in s ppor ng t a posuon,a y s ppo tngdoc m e tuo r le n l i r pn o u u ht i n u ri u n a n eid ; 2 1 2 2 2 3 24 2s . u o , and apyi f r atonnecessryf t eCo r' d tr ialn. pn s o n om i a or h u t eem n t . ' J C. NDEP a dtenon-ip tngpa t s alha etil ( 0 da so s c tmestby nh dsu i ry h l v h'y 3 ) y r u h i e l tCo r t r s o d TheCoul,sdecii n s ai bei com or td i t anjbecom e l u to e p n z l so h l n ab n o . a e fre bl ee c to ti Ij ncir an s albec nsdee tef a n n oc a e lm n f h s nu toq d h l o i rd h m l deci i n. so D. . . .. zE ' nypa t ma pe to t eco r f rrviw oft etr softlsIjmcieor e, ry y u in h u t o e e h em ii nt tv d r 7: i 28 ,?? o r vi s ofhsi pl m e t Eo . rs m' m c n ai n l l - (q. - U 1 M. PA R D C I A T' N O F PL A W IT FN P O 'F 2 3 K M 1 lve n l ss h nitdbyt eDeO da t t NDpp a d = yr p o s by Dei r h e u r te h f nso . e ne NDBP n nlbe512 wi t eCou tq nlas bes bm it dt tz Pli tfsa bl e *: r h l lo u te o i a nif s 4 5 6 B. s e i e i XI o ti Ij n u eOr e. ' c d n I f hs nu c v d r p Plit sma p vd 0 = * 1 o al j ea lst NDBP.NDEPc mmi ani y m ie 0 s n lDe v zb e o ot a t dic s a lmz: 0 1:= 1 w11 t ePli t o pr vi ea i f r n r s o s ; o s u s l c 011 t1 h an o r o d n n o m l e p n e 7 8 ho e e , w v r NDEP s al r pa eaf r a t o pons t Comm = t'docm = ton y h lp e r o m l' s o o R s' t t f rs lcedSlhm itk.Suc s l oo Sub itl i dudett M pos d *1n f r o ee t l tas h e e td m tas n le e ao . p 10 rmeif no go n wae, ywel sayniv j' ntasa a re t b b t e dai f ru d tra ja . ttr 'x i l, s ged o y o o u lt t epii e h an a dr U . n 11 0 . DELI EQ AR LE S V 1 2 ' . M Dei> b e a dnoi cEo fo Dee d ns epie b td Jj n inKx1be l ls n ts a n rm fn x t rz lr. y i s nu v o 1s1 v d 1 s n smula e usyt : 3 e t i tp o l o 1 ' A st t e s a eorN e a a: 4 o i tt z vd ' i M G A . ie Ph , Sd a r ND& , e u o Cone veAdims Bur a f t 901S. e a tSt,SR 4001 Stw r . Cms nCiy,V V 89701 o t: ' i j 1 WG = '< , rDe A AG 5 F S. P Ol c oft eAto ne r e xl e h tr y - r 16 1 0N. r o St 0 Ca s n . Ca s n Ciy ' V 897 1 r o ' ,N t 0 17 1 Ast F1it s S o an - : d . i 4 ; 1 9 M e a de Ro r son,V , q. x n r b r t 1 Bs J n Grbe o q. a e n Es 2 0 21 Rob rs n& Vik Emy e to c 8 0Ha ps ieRo Su t B 8 m b r < ie W eslktVil g ,CA 91 61 ta la e 3 DATE X eb n& Asocaas e s it . 1 32 Ann a aSte t Suiell 3 n p re y t o SR K BA G CA 93101 22 M TI EFFECTM . 2 3 Thi Ij cini eFecieatrii sgndhyt eCo elee bytl Clromz s nm to s tv te t s i o h < itrd le ek d 24 s r o onNoBp,hepli tfsa d t eDefnda t. . evd t an if n b e ns i I I s ORDERED. s Tso 26 17 D a e Dez m ber27. ! td e 20,0 2s . t z ', !' u . i Dii c J d e1 ? s :u g ' / , / -

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?