Voggenthaler, et al., v. Maryland Square, LLC, et al.,

Filing 677

ORDER Granting in Part and Denying in Part #622 Motion for District Judge to Reconsider Order, Granting in Part and Denying in Part #633 Objection to Order Granting Motion to Compel, and Granting in Part and Denying in Part #665 Motion for More Definite Statement. Signed by Judge Robert C. Jones on 2/28/11. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - ASB)

!
1

. J .. .

'
., 1

6 12 0 X 66

Fl o fE .

ot sj?''sg aaa l E- ii r l a s .' 'f i rcg 2 g 2 y ' g:

-

-' '2fyg'Ly ' -s:161 ' s6 6b6 - y nt '

! i

2
: ;

; .
i

4
5
.

g .j-j y;; (;.gy gyp-gg (y. j j -s ; j
,

6Y ;

glrt ( y j s ij ) gvkj gr g ,
-' = = = ==
- - - .

- -

-

-

0F tT P7

6
'
E

UNI TED STATES DI STRI CO URT CT
D I RI T O F N EV A DA ST C

7

8 PETER J VOGGENTHALER, al, . et .
9

1 0

l l
E
k
:

1 2
1 3

1 4
I
'

l 5 1 6

l 7
,

l 8 1 9 2 0

) ) pl i if , a ntf s ) ) v. ) ) MARYLAND S QUARE, LLC, ta. e l , ) ) Deen ns f da t. ) ) ) MARYLAND SQUARE, LLC, ta. e 1, ) ) ThidPat Pl ntfs, r ry ai if ) ) v. ) ) GENERAL GROW TH M ANAGEMENT,l ,) NC. at egnc ori omorton,e a1 ai t . ) ) ThidPat Dee nt. r ry fnda s ) ) )
.
Doc. 677

1: - l - - F 08CV- 618RCJGW

ORDER

.
.

-GWF Voggenthaler, et al., v. Maryland Square, LLC, et al.,

i
@

Cu r nl b fr teCo r i a Eme g n yM oi f r ai c to ( 6 5 fldb teKihn r re ty eo e h u ts n r e c t o Clrt ai n # 6 ) ie y h s e on i

: E

e s' y . 21 oer ndant on yebruaz 1s, 2o 1 Alob r r teco r i so lv , M alt sobe to st t e 1 . s e o e h u ts u e ad l zc' j ci n o h , 2 M a itaeJ d esOr e ( 6 2 a d S a sRo b c & Co a ysOb e to t Ma srt,sOre 2 g sr t u g ' d r # 2 ) n e r e u k mp n , j cin o gitae d r 23 Gr tngM otont Compe ( ) ani i o l #633 .

24
E

OnJ r 1 20l1 M a srt J Ge geFol J,is d a Or r(/ on aMoton anuay 3, , gitae udge or ey, r sue n de /603) i

25 t Compe Com pla e wih a Sub o l i nc t poena. Tha or rpr ded t Kihne Def nd s t rg t t de ovi he s r e ant he i ht o ' 26 c duc s lga t si on t Se r pr ery,i l nga oxi el 5 s lga s m pl .Theo der on t oi s e tng he a s op t ncudi ppr mat y 5 oi s a es r 27 a s pr ded t Kil r Def ant t rghtt conduc s lgast s i on t Bo e r M al lo ovi he sme end s he i o t oi e tng he ulva d l
! 28 pr ery,i udi ap oxi a el 1 s lg s m pl s op t ncl ng pr m t y 09 oi as a e . O n J ar 21 2O11 t s Cour hel or a gum ç on a num be of m otons i l di Se s' anu y , , hi t d al r nt r i nc u ng ar

5
1
i

Dockets.Justia.com

'
.

1 ; ! '

r . :

.

K.

' l M oto t D i m i s t Ki l e D e e nt Fi s A m e d Thid Pa t Com pl i . Dtr n t he r n i n o s s he sm r f nda s' r t nde r ry a nt zi g he a i g . 2 on Se s M oton t Dim is t Cour addr s e t s ar ' i o s s , he t e s d he cope oft s lga t si g gr nt i t he oi s e tn a ed n he 3 M a sr t J git a e udge' or r an a s d t K il e D e e dan st ti w oul l m i t num bero s lga s de , d dvi e he sm r f n t ha t d i t he f oi s

!

i

i

4

s e t b t ent tr e( ont Seas prperya fve()ont BoulvadM alpr ry. ampls o e ak o h e 3) he r, o t nd i 5 he e r l opet l
.

5
i

Folwi g ta h aig,Bo e ad M al LLC a d S a sfld Obe to st te M a itae lo n h t e rn ulv r l, n e r ie j ci n o h g srt

I

6 J d esOr e .I t Bo lv r M al LLC' obe to s Bo lv r M alLLC sae t a d s iei u g ' d r n he ue a d l, S j cin , ue ad l, ttd h t e p t t s 7 o j cinst t eu d ry n M a itaeJ d eso d r içswiln t p o iea c s t isp ri o be to o h n eli g g srt u g ' re , tt l g o r vd c e s o t o t f i i on
8 t M a lf a s lga s udy' a r r d by t s Cour dur ng t J num' 21, 1 he r ng. Thu ,i he l or oi s t ' s equie hi t i he a y 20l a i s t

9 woul a l fve s lgm c i t be esa ihe on is pori oft M al pr ry. Sea s as d low i oi s orngs o tbls d t ton he l ope t r lo

;
i

1 obece t t s opeoft M a srt J 0 j td o he c he gitae udge' or r butr ogni dt t sCo tt eal lmie ' s de, ec ze hathi ur t ty i td' gr
11 t s o oft or r he c pe hat de .
1 2 0n Fe u r l 2011 t sKii De en nt fld an Em e ge M oton f Clrfc ton br a y 8, , hi smer f da s ie r ncy i or a iia i

i

j
i
!

1 ( 3 #665)rgar ng t M a sr e J dgesOr ra t sCou tsorlmodiiatons t t tor r e di he gitat u ' de nd hi r' a fc i o ha de.
1 Spe tca l t K i hne Def ndan s r quts 'c arfc i n f om t s Cour i t f r of a wr ten 4 cii ly, he s r e t e t t l ii ato r hi t n he o m it
'

1 or . ( .f Clrtcai (/ )at4) Ac or ngt t Kihne Deen s:t wrte or 5 der' Mot or aii ton /665 ' . c di o he s r f dant &A itn der
1 fom t Cour wil e l a ss t epa tesi confr ngt rr pec i rght r a di t s opeof 6 r he t lgr aty s it h ri n imi hei es tve i s eg r ng he c !
I
!

1 s lg t tng a l 7 oi as esi lowed a t Boul r M al a Se r pr tesand t tmi f c t he eva d l nd a s operi he i ng or ompltngt e i he
I s m e' I 8 a .' d 1 9 As not d i t f e ng, t Cour lmie durngor a gum e ,t s e n he or goi he t i td, i al r nt he copeoft M a sr t he gita e

!

20 J udge' or r Spe i i aly, he Cou tf s de . c fc l t r ound t co ctng 55 s lga t s i on t Sea s pr r y hat ndu i oi s e tngs he r ' ope t

21 a a oxi el 1 s lga t tn on t Boul r M al pr t wmst ra ed. Ra he ,t nd ppr mat y 09 oi s esi gs he eva d l opery mwa r nt t r he
22 Cour f t ound t talow i t e s l t s i on t Se r pr ery a fve on t Boul va d M al ha l ng hr e oi gas e tngs he a s' op t nd i he e r l ! 23 pr t wasap opra e. opery pr i t

24
25

I lne wih isor lr i ,t Cou tno hol t tt Kii Def nda s a e e il d t n i t t a ulngs he r w ds ha he smer e nt r ntte o

E
'

!

26 IS p cfcly teCo rsae t ttne de t<ga t e r,moint ds s, t udhod eiial,h utttd haiitn d o rn S as to o imisbu wo l l zy of onis ngt or rt alow t Kii rDe e nt t dot e s m plsont Se r pr m ie , nd f s ui he de o l he sme f nda s o hr e a e he a s e s s a no m or t n fve s m pl s on t Boul var M a le s a w es . The Cour expr s l di ag e w ih e ha i a e he e d l a t nd t' ' t e s y s r ed t

ag t M a sr eJ he gitat udge' Or (/ )alowi ffpfvetssont Se s pr ry.SeeTr s i of s der / 603 l ng it i e t he ar' ope t an crpt
J nua y 21 201l pr e ng a p.21 a r , oc edi t .

2
i

.

i

' l c onduc t ees l st t ont Se s pr rya tv s lga ts son t Boulva dM alpr ry. t hr oiga ess he ar ' ope t nd i e oi s e t he e r l ope t

!

2 Tot e e t M a srt J ge' Or r( he xtnt he gitae ud s de #603)al f mor tsi a lors mplst b tken, lows or e e tng nc a e o e a /
3 i i ove r l t s r u ed.

i

4

Concl i uson

5
!
i
'

I I HEREBY ORDERED ta teM o inf rDititJ d et Re o sd rOr e ( 6 2 i TS h th to o src u g o c n ie d r # 2 ) s
I I FURTHER ORDERED t tSe r Obe tont M a srt sOr rGrntngM otont T S ha as' j ci o gitae' de a i i o
I I FURTHER ORDERED t t heKihne De enda s. TS ha t s r f nt , Emer en M oton f Cl i c i g cy i or art aton i

6 GRANTED I PART and DENI I PART. N ED N

7
9

:

8 Compel( #633)i GRANTED I PART andDENI I PART, s N ED N
1 i GRANTED I PART a DEN I I PART. 0 s ' N nd ED N

i

;

11

TheK i h rD ef s ne endan sa eau horze t c t r t i d o onduc t ees l st s son t Se r pr t a t hr oi ga e t he a s' opery nd

1 fve s lgast s s on t Boul va d M a lpr ry. 2 i oi et he e r l ope t

1 3
1 4
.

Thetsi r nss j tt t f l ngc tons e tng emai ubec o he olowi ondii :
1 Thc s lg t s i i t be s dui d and c di t d w ih t Thid Pa t D e en s a . oi as e tng s o che e oor na e t he r ry f dant nd

1 ot erBoulva d M al Pr ryowner t m i mi t i e f e ewiht busne sope a i oft 5 h e r l ope t s o ni ze he ntrer nc t he i s r tons he
16 m al,t m al t l he l enant and t rcust er s hei om s;

i

l 7

2. Kihne Def nda sa t i c r t ss lus t s viesofa unde gr The s r e nt nd her ontacor hal e he er c n r ound u iiy tlt

I I a i s r cei t ede hoft c ehol pr e ar a onabl rs ofda et unde gr 8 oc tng e vi f h pt he or es es nt e s e ik mag o r oundutlt iiy
ë

1 lnesorot f ciii ; 9 i her a ltes and

(

'

2 0

3 Tb s itsigc nrco t) s b a e u tl isle f r rpe t d ma ea db dl iju . e ole t o ta trs mu t e d q aey n t d o p o ry a g n o i n t' n r y y

'

21 da est ma b ca edbyt s lg t tng.Thid Pa t De enda sSea s t Boul r M al, mag hat y e us he oi as esi r ry f nt r ,he eva d l 22 LLC a ot o nd her wner oft pr m ie onwhiht t si i conduc e s l a s beIseda a tonal s he e s s c he e tng s t d ha ! lo it s ddii
23 i s e on t e i t lng c t a t ' i ur e polc n ur ds h ns ali on r c or s ns anc i y.
!

24

2 5
1 ! 26

ot:otah ) st adfb ? d t e u z
UNI TED ST S DI STRI J CT UDGE

27
28

i

3 I

l
i