Santana International Corporation et al v. Tax Services of America, Inc.

Filing 13

ORDER that this matter be ADMINISTRATIVELY CLOSED, to be reopened upon motion from counsel if necessary. Signed by Judge Roger L. Hunt on 9/6/2011. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - SLR)

@
1

@

LiaSlpio rRe es(nPr Se
s e cf y 1 o )
1
0365Tal ngTKe Avt.
ki
LasVegas N V.89129

,

uu.
'

2 72 5 10 2
0- 6 -7 0
wnewe a 1ç
r
om
3 P AN T F:sl s
L I i mo E
4

'

'.'!
' ,
'

UNI
TED STA TE S DISTR I T CO U R T
C

5

DIST R I T O F N EV A D A
C

6

i LSSEIOFEE, iidl lc sN,:--37 -WH
l I LP FRYSa nvu, ) AE o21vl - C
A CPl
n dia
:1c06Km
9
at
ii
nf
f
l
pA ryxRso s
lm'F' EpNE
- ll
s
v.
s

10

BAC HOM E LOANS SERW CI , LP;
NG
RECONTRUST COM P
ANY, A.MERSCORP,
N. ;

11 l
NC aW gi aCor a
ni
por éonsM ORTGAGE
.
y
12 ELECTROM C REGI
STRATI SYSTEM S,
ON
I a s ilal ofM ERSCORP,I ,a
NC. ubsti y
nc.
la Delwve cor
a
pomton;FEDERAL NATI
i
ONAL
M ORTGAGE ASSX I ON ;AND X ES
ATI
14 Zdi dua s 1t 1 l usve;and ROES
vi l o 00, ncl i
Col a im 1t 3G,I l i
por to
o
ncusve;

OPPOSW I TO D EFEND AN TS'
ON
M OTI TO DI I
ON
SM SS

15
16

Ekf nl.
enda

18

20

Pli i LiaSe io y sI Pr & , t u s mitn t t uidito o t sCo a
antl s lpc fRe e n o wiho t ub tig o hejrs cin fhi mt s

21 Pl i tf sa s tl d a ' o in t Re n ' t t em a trh r i al a c di g y he e y a s ll s
a n ifha lo ie M to o m nd' o h te e e n x c or n l r b lo ie
d
ton o le ' i o s s '
ed
t , 01 y h fn a ts;
2 r pons i opposii t tl 'M oton t D tmis'asfl on Augus 31 2 1b teDee d n l) Ban
2 es e n

23 o rc , e aIThe Plitf leenrs n lgma sau v ra oj ci t ec a de ey
fAmeta NA. t .
anif lri epo di ke niesl beton o ah n v r
l
24

ar e oft De e an ' De ur r aswel ast De r rasa whol , on t basst t
gum nt he f nd ts m re ,
l he mure
e
be i hat he

De re inot n &Iani o rate ( tr et ve/ o h c- (h f /o h ale df cs
murr s hig / mprpe tmpto zpl he ra fte t te m/lfte lge a t
25 i riul )r he JXa t J ce ,p ft e ig .ThePlit fh spo ie se i çpe dn a
npa t ar at r J? he o jnc o kepladn s
c
ani a rvd d p c' la ig s
f
s
26 r q ie u e t er l so t e c u t Th sr s o ei s p re b t Po nt a Aut o i s S a a d
e u r d nd r h u e f h o r. i e p ns s u po td y he i s nd h rée / t nd r
2 o Re e h r i ,t c mp eefl a r c d o t sa to a d up n t e a gt n sd1 ma l
7 f viw e en he o l t e nd e or s f hi c il n o h r t t * y )
me
e
pr e e a tz hearngofDefnda ' m oton.
es nt d t le
i
e nts i
28

PLAI FF RESPONSE I OPPOS TI TO DEFENDANT' M OTI TO DI SS COM PLAI
NTI
N
I ON
S
ON
SV
NT

l

pj a j xxux STATEM ENT
t w

2

The de endaly e
f tts ngagementizttsm a t a eilIa antvi aton ofacç ed r esat
l li ter r l l gr
ol i
ept eal t e

3 r cor ton a due pr gofFe ala s a or l , and i t pr cie r on t thasl t t
e da i nd
oces
der nd t mt y aws
s he e s eas ha
ead o he

4 iii f n o ti lws tThePlitf a dietys ee ijr ' tf 'teDee Y t na d
ataldig f bs a ui.
anifh s rol e rd nuy ' or'h fn ' me
bu
s
5 he ei pari pa i ofwho,what whenphom a why ofwhata ol st a cons r cy t c mi
r ns tci ton
,
nd
m mt o
pia o om t
6

H IIa d c nv rinu t s j c pr mryo t Plitf.
I n o e so pon he ube t o t f he an ir
I
n ed s v rb e' ie ( ri ie 'iv v me i Pli ilsmo t gei t evain eo
ico e a l ' r d o ndrdl'n ole ntn antf' rga n h ra c f
d

7 degr by a oft def antpa tesi notr quied t s
ees
nd he end
ri s
e r o upportac i f c pi cy, muc l s t
ton or ons ra
h es , o
8 al geca est asc aned i Pl i s 'VERI ED COM PLAI ' De e nt ave wihout
le
us o onti n ane '
FI
NT' f nda s r t
.
9 ve fcaton t al cats ofa i conti wibi tl Pl ntl sfl co pl i .Def nt' aroga
rti t o l les cton
aned t n le ai i ied m ant enda s r nce
10 a s l rglt u e egi conductsmpl lnowsno boundstîbl antvevi wihi 11 r centv
nd ef-i leels gr ous
i yt
z at l dent t n /, e l
11
12

fldS I #p$ Ne al a fr e Ge r l
le /C he v fzll n p ne a.
o

Se ST OF NEV v B o e aI
e ATE
ADA . fA t .
i ( S Ditit wr o v a Cf: nu e :3: 1 0,0 3 AI -A' .
n Z src Ct /fNe ad zc mb r 1 - - 01 5 LJI I
V)

13

Def nt i ttsc e movet court'o dimis'asi ANY i
enda s n li as
he
' s s' f
t
nnuende ofanotceplndi does
i e ng
14 notappl a consde ed t be a ur . Def ndant a e a s e t y esopped i t refort t do s as
y nd
i r o bs d
e
s r l o quiabl t
n bei
so
o

1 t alw aprj iilajdcdo a t ydam t c mplitd n algeaywrng oigb t m
5 o lo
eudca du ia n she i he o an œs ot le n o d n y he
1 a t ti s u d ledim is d. l i tl a s rst tl c mp antc nt i s œ c e tf c sa d a lga i
6 nd ha t ho l ) s s e P an i s e t h1 l o l i o ans u i n a t n le t
e
o
he e
s en
ope i
he li gans hem
17 t putt def ndo t her i onpr rnotçcoft ca msa i tt . n etz i e i e r t by t
le nt ntonz f ors h
def tts rvcer a t i ac
endal e i s nd her oomplce t f c peopl i o de a t al f e ur sl de diguie of
i s o or e
e nt f uls rd or dos e m r s s
18

' otou t D t s 'a e i
M i o smis' r ndeed becomi ' aq i pr e e' a a s h tt De endatq z ous
ng ' sc œ dur ' nd s uc le f tt 'xal
cl
19 conduc s at f is fasva i ton oft al tonsoft Compl nt fl t t ac i her n.
t pe ls or tel
lda i
he legai
he
ai ied o he ton ei
20

Furhe mor , tl Pli i spendi m otonst r m a a enow be or tz cour and t decson
t r e le antF
ng i o e nd r
f e le
l
he ii

a ofuidcina a toiyt nl o a ya do t t matrh ri i no beoet c u ta sld a d
l jrsito l uh rt o ze n n c n o he te een s w fr he o r s e n
22 t courts d r e on is ofr
he
houl ul
s ues emand andf t ' av' ocee ngsl ndi de er naton of al
urher ' 'pr di
st
ng t mi i
l
23

sc ise c n enngFe ea ç u tuidi ont pmfc t b0htec r J //l Pl nt r n
u h su s o c rl d rl o rj rs di o e /he t h out nt / ai i ei
e
lhe

fom lanece m rptm eJa# epe wih r w clt defndt ' ym vr/e# av me si tvojfnz t / e
r f
x
i
x nse t el
o e mts
ji er nt n z t/ he m
24 tsue Jl vll'.îoft cz' atbar
s s W tzl he tâe
/
.
25

Them f nda s ar m e tl tlslw s ti am igui , a tmptoft Pl ntf oavoi
e nt' gu nt iat li a ui s s ded te
he ai irt
d
26 f nci oblgatonsf l t r ogni et thom e
ma al i i ais o ec z ha
owne sha no r coure. By f ii t a i good f iha
r ve e s
nlng o d n
at
21 t De e
he f ndant l t Pl ne wi. no et ropton t n t e
s eA he ai
t
h
he i ha o ngageltga f pr rr ol t t
ii don or ope es ve o he

a c nrves bdwe nt pateshes j c po rya teo lgailsu de tlde do tut
a o to ry
e he rist ubet rpet nd l bi tot n r i e f rs.
z
e
2

PLAI FF RESN NSE I OPPOSW I TO DEFENDANT' M OTI TO DI M I COM P NT
NTI
N
ON
S
ON
S SS
LAI

r
l

1
2

3

STANDARD O F REVI
EW

4
5

1 TH E M O TI TO DISM I SH OULD BE DKNIED UNTI
.
ON
SS
L
DISCOV ERY Cn Tm
PLACE

6
Rue1 6 mo nsaeWe dw11dga rGil anv J mc De .D rl1 F.d
l 2*)() Eo r we t1 ifvo. li . a o v / 08 3
.
g
7 24 ,2 ( lCi.1 97 . s sa wiho tla t a ndi p o ronyi ' xrori r ' a e .
6 49 9d r 9 ) Dimis l t u e ve o me s r pe l n ' ta dnay'c s s
e
8 Untdst e v Ci o dwo t 64 F. 9 , 6(t Ci.1 l. e rln o al()( moil
ie ats . t fRe oi 0 2d 63 96 91 r 98 ) Wh n uig n 2b 6) to
y
1
be
an
t
tu d n l i
t a b t o l ax f. h k
e
l
9 t complitm us beçonsr e i tw lgbtm os fvora l t ti plikif Par Sc 0/#=. n .
f c v,
S n o 51F. 1 0 18 ( hCi.1 . c ut s ac pt sml all tra alg t si
ymtgtn
3d 48 , 4 4 9t r 05)The o rmut ce a e l naeil le ai n
on
.

10

t compl ,aswel asany r as
he
int
l
e onabl i e e
e nf r ncest bedr lf om t . Par o v.FDIC,139 F.
o
awz r hem
et
3d

z 69 6 ( d Ci.1 98 .
l
6, 99 9 z r 9 )
12

i

Pl m tf ma sv ld ca msa aas t s De e a . f d nt i h s t e o c R sw i
n' i ke a i l i g i t he e f nd - De O a s nt e e yp s f a
l
l

1

1 d a tiz t r le ei oft o lga ns i udi bltnotlm ie t t flng ofa ' oton t
3 o nvhn o eiv t is bi do . ncl ng, z
i td o, he zi
u i o

l
1

1 Dimi 'â pr a y A c e. ha zke pl et a'e t tepr c ur z l rl e b t evz4 s s ' e e n ov r s t n ac o l rWa h o ed - l #er k a y h yy
s
p
z
c
z

I

-

1 dq' n f t %mWt t s pr c ealla.@ t 'l lf t n f br ct andx lt
5
t nda t a hL l ok t o ur zt f ' he izfy he /y e l
e
n
l
.
ue
elhe
. uâ
1 Pll T'ho â , u nfauâ npfo,r ses ee a aa a tnAn ,w o tt
6
anh s me ee po
d
y tc tanf r,
ndsa g
u ye
1 oi nal -, ndY p et Pl l c s w 1 zt il :cam o ne- h dfe nt
7 rgî n@ a
r he ial - ho At he ee li fltr y e nda s
F
/
18

waspr ed â t r do,nterr H . b W/* @ y flw.
ocur y.f> rf k ey * y l a o a

1,

Untlt pe esar alowed t pr d tlough dic y,1 1 t pa i havet e ieat '
i he
e l
o ogee lr
s over m11 he rtes
he ntr rue '

20

fl t ed c me t d fn a t rvd dma o ma n t etemlr d c met)complt a i oft
e t ou ns ee d n po ie y r y o b h t e o u ns,
b
i
e e ud t he
voair adtedtr nt lo terme ise ec voai aepeu iil x nwm ' eeoe
ilt t a l eemiait fl e de fr ah ilt r rjdcal mk o I rfr,
os l
o t
y
h

.

1
i

21 def
endant ar notdi r nta e i t Co an a o no beo ed s o e y t c u tsu a r o
s e
fe e it d n he mplit s f w, fr ic v r ,he o r i n wa e f

!

22

I
!

t f nt s es msbl or t
Wha de enda i r pt i ef wha , D I m ii alg di Plitc sc mp e t(e g nea
I q t s le e n ani o l s e e rl
V
2a alg do ) t t de endant act i conce t
le a ns, hat he f
s ed n
r.
14
41

p,
1

'h r f r De e a s M ot t Dim isj l p e ntd s o bl ve iia i n f rt be t
r e e o e f nd nt
i o s s rwi r ve ic vma e rfc to o he ne
on
l

25 o a1 risc n ene a ac rigl tebe eio Ne a acs lw pee nsa sauoy
f 1pat o cr d nd c odn y h n ft f v d a e a rcdet nd tttr
e
26 de opm e c
vel
nt oncem i t e mat r a t s dnotbeal d t sandw11 pr rr
ag hes te s nd hus houl
lowe o t
t1 ope emandt t
o he
27 St t CoursofNe
ae
t
vada.
26
1
3

PLAI FF RESPONSE I OPPOSI ON TO DEFENDAU ' M OTI TO DI I COM PLAI
NTI
N
TI
S
ON
SM SS
NT

I

I .NO TI PLEADI I REO UIRED AND PI I FF HA S
I
CE
NG S
A NTI
ADEOUATELY PLED FACTS FOR u cj cArsE O F ACTI
j
ON

1

2

I i awel d 1w çtl o yis ivov di ad mu rrhe nngi whel rt eç mp antm i
t s l s a ithe nl sue n le n e re x ' s tl l o li s
e z

3

salts.l
t tt mcom lct wih exta l m a t s sat a cale o ac i '
e ed t rneols ter , t es ls f ton.'

S . Fa nsv Su rorCt l( 98 )1 3Ca. p.d90 , 5. No i ad mu rrtea prprat
A
'F r t . pe i wr 1 4 5 l 3 2 90
Ap
r s e re l p o i e
z
5 pr dur f dder ni t % t1ofdiput f dsorwha i e e
oce e or
mi ng he .
1
s ed a
t nf r ncess dbe(I - Iwhe e
houl
I'
a
r

s c mp t if rn e aep sbl. Crm Takf'W?c/atI . , a n s n( 99 )65Ca. p. h631
o ei n ee c s r esi e' t l r z/t nc v J c b o 1 8
ng
'
t p
1 4t ,
Ap
7 63 Too romeade r r aplitf e on pla fc sta s o h ma bee ildt s me
5. vec
mure , an ifne d % e d a t h t h w e y nt e o o
t
rle Gt nb r v Aenall.Co (97)9CaI d56 ,57
eif w eg . t l . 1 3
s
. 6 2. Ft e mo e i t plitf ssae a
3
t r r ,f he an ifha ttd
e
8
ca eofac undvranypossbl l.llflprp i i e r r o tetilcmr t s s n t Jenl r
us
don
x
î e e le - ,t s ro f r h ra t lo u mi he zz .
#
ve
9 Fredman v
t
:
,
.
Me kt C% ( 00 I Ca, p.t 45 4 3. I aç mpan lb r l rme fe jç t
nt o
2 3) W l 4h 4, 6 f o lik le al t rd ai
Ap
y
.

10 sat aca e ofa i ori i i r as
t e us
otonm f t s e onabl pos i e tl t pl r can o e t compl i by
y sbl lat he aidls
ur he
ant
11 a e
m ndment t t1 o ts d nots ai a tezz r e?wihoutl vet a
, he 1a1 our houl
ust n / zl r ' t
z
ea o mend.' Dalonv.Eastsm '
' t

1 M u U/àt Dtt( 9 3)1 Ca. 4t 1 66,l o.Emp ssa d d.
2
n. j y s. 1 9 8 l
App. h 5 s7 l ha i d e )

l Moe e,Rue()6 mus b ra ila de wihRue8 whihrq ie :
a
rovr l b() t e ed ltn m t l , o e urs
14

Feder lRul ofCi lPr dur Rul 8 s aest ge r r eofpladi t a
a e
vi oce e e t t he ne al ul
e ng hat

15 Compl ntnee cont n:
ai
d
si

1
6
1
7

( )as o ta paxsae nto tego nd f rtec r s u idcinm ls teco r
1 h r nd lil ttme f h u s o h ou f j rs ito une s h u t
ara yha jrsito a t csm n e sn ne uidc na spp r;
led suidoin nd he li e d o wj rsiuo l u ot

1
8

( )as o ta pans e nt tecam s wi ta t pla ri e tde t r le;
2 h r nd li ktme of h li ho ng h the e de s n i d o eif

19

( )ade ndf rt r le s ug , c ma icu rle i tl atr a i o di r n
3 ms o he eif o htwhih y n lde eif n i len tve r Fee t
e

a
nd

t
ypesofr i
elef
20

' tc p e f ng'i a l h ti r q r d u l s pla ng a s c a m a tra dei ae i FRCP
' i e l a l ' s l t a s e uie n e s e di
No
i
pe i l te s lne t d n
21

R

ue9. vSe (00 )5 7F.d 1 6 1 3 1 4 ctdt c s rle um n v r he vl b d fnd n
l Doe e 2 9 5 3 06 . 07 - 07 . ie he a e eid
ey a iy y ee a
22 i t ca a bar Bel lni Cor A T mbv 55 U. 5 ,1 S. . 9 , 9 -5 1 L. 2d
n he se t , lAt t
a c p.z wo l, 0 S. 44 27 G 155 1 646 , 67 Ed.
.
2 9 ( 0 .Il Co r i Do vS ctdT' mbyf rt p o sto t tnohn mo ei r q r doh
3 29 20 7) 'le u tn e ee ie wo l o be r po iin ha tig r s e uie te
'
a4 t n as tand pl i saementunl sas cilmateri al
ba hor
an t t
es pe a
t s leged:

Un rn kep e dng r l s wer q r on y ' s r a p a n sa e n 'oftl gr und f
de ot l a i ue , e uie l a ho t nd l i t t me t' le o s or

2
5
26

j iddins dt ça11o rle Fe KCi P.8a () ( ) s eas BelAta i Co p.
ulsi o n he l11fr eif d. V. ()l, 2 ; e lo l lnt r v.
c
Two y, 0U. 5 .l 7 S. .1 5 1 6 65 1 7L. .d92 ( 0 7)W edono i s a
mbl 55 S. 44 2 G 9 5,9 4- , 6 Ed2 9 2 0 .
t mpo e

27

hei mz pl ng sa d i t abs e of' explctr r nti a sa e orf a
ght ed endi t ndar n he enc '
an
ii equieme n t mt
eder l
'SkA . e M i n NorhAmerc Beve y H il, fa , 6F,d8 2 8 (t Ci.00 )
' a M r e
t
ia
rl ls ac'
rl,
ue
f 50 3 3 , 41 9h r2 7;

.

28
4

PLM NTI RES
FF
PONS I OPPOSF
E N
HON TO DEFENDAN F' M OTI TO DI I COM P NT
S
ON
SM SS
LAI

p
E

l
2

t ti cour t dl w ar ona ei er nc tmttltt def
he ral t o '
a
eas bl nf e e l la he endanti labl f tl m iconduc ale
s i e or le s
t lged.
3 I t cas atbar Pli i ha pl d b sca d s ct f c sf ro u e o a to a p e t s e ii
n he e
F s e a i n pe ik a t o a s s f o i n, nd l d he p c fc
, ant
4 mater ,wher neededsw11 tz r st pa tcul iy.
ts
e
t1 le equiie r i art
5 FURTHER'
;

6

(

Levet a n aCo antc l e tlrq ie ns(9 a tmsalwe at cr ay
a o me d mpli , me tle e urme t o sl lo d o ue n
m
dee t s utc rq ie, rso v Fietn (9 6)7 F.d1 0 ,1 9.
fc a j sie e ursFietne . rso e 19 6 3 2 5 20

7

8

Def nfs' oton t D imts'f l ast t pl ng r r m e sand wihi t
endn ' i o s s ' ais o he eadi equie nt
M
t n he

9
10

r onabl dicr ton oft cout asr cogni d ly t pr dent he ei and ass i t
ems
e s ei
he t e
ze ) he eœ
s rn
uch s o
bedeni
ed.

11

12

I . PLM NTI
H FFS H AS VESTED W TEREST TO PURSUE CAUSES OF ACTI D ENTI
ON
FIED

13

I TI E COM PLM NT AGM NST DEFENDANTS
N I

14

-

- - -

.

W 1e1r asawhol and i cont a Pl ntl' c pl ntsat s cintf tl
: 1 ead
e
n
ext ni ils om ai t es um e ac tal

15 ale ton t def atDe e ntsn oton To Di s ' Def nt m oton i r cty ar
l ga i o e
f ndn ' M i
smis ' enda s i ncor e l gues
.

1 tttPli i H1 n itrs ( cam ivodn teS jc Prpet a is i timatra
6 la antf 1 e neet) li n l g h ube t o ry tsue n bs te nd
%
r
1 tztmatr ha b e aj dige a teis sofwh te o n t, n wh n,Plie wa
7 la tes ve en du c td sh sue
eh r r o a d e an
s
pr v d d w11 t p o rd s l s r s asi m e t/ubsi o o tuse , ,nz ,be kir
o i e 11 he r pe ic o u e , sgn n s tt n f r te t e nef a y
.
mi
ze
sandi a notc ,a sa u or rght of duepr si a is off cta cn
t ng, nd ies ad t t t y i s
oces s n s ue a nd nnotbe
19 dimi s wihouta l ng Pl ntf t c
s s ed t
lowi ai i o ondud di c l
s ovey
20

21

Def nt 'a gum e f l on isf a i ir l
enda s r
nt ais t ace nd s r eevantittz i i ' f 't ac i
r lat t s ' or' he tons
but

2 t k n a a v rfe b De e n so e l isa pr v de t t ec u t b t n f c t
2 a e nd s e i d y f nd nt wn xl b t s o i d o h o r t a i a t he
i
23

;
;

I teveyrc n Unie Stt Su e Co r CaeoAs cot Ib .Ma 1 ,
n h l ee t td aes prme u t s f h rj v.q al( y 8
2 9 - S. .- ,2 W L 1 61 36 teCo r h l ta s dfcf csmus b pldt alw
00 ) Ct -- 0*
3 5 , h u t ed h t pe
a t t e e o lo

24

Plitfi aprn il o adwihnteraeilta scinsp ennngt teS bet
ax i s iope f n ti h n tra rn ato e ii o h u jc
l
Pr pet a a c r ngywa as sb e tt tl e e t wh na h te ha tk n pa e
o ry, nd c o di l s lo u j c o le v n s e nd ow h y ve a e lc
.
tr g t ted algsteç n uc o,a i ascainwil teSujc Prpet a
hou hoz h e ln ,h o d t f nd n so ito tn h be t o ry nd
t

25 concer ng t Def
ni he endantpadi t have tans r ast y have ladhl t dicover ea
es hat
r pied he
e go s
abl nd
26 flt vertabl vesed i e es on be l oftl Pl ntf asf edhe ei .
irher ii e t ntr t
ha f le ai ir l
rn
27
28

5

PLAI F RESPONSE I OPPOSI ON TO DEFENDANT' MOTI TO DI I COM PI N
NTI F
N
TI
S
ON
SM SS
A

l

1 1 PLAINTW FS HAS PENDI M O TI BEFO RE TH E CO URT
1.
NG
ON

2

No pe di b f r t eç ur i M o nt Re n a dM e int S a Pr e d.
w n ng e o e h o ts éo o ma d n
to o ty oc e mgs

3 pe dngDeemininToMoinToRe n t c s h ri Panifsld c n urnt pusa tt 28
n i tr n to
to
mn d he ae een litf e o c re l ru n o
y
4 USC j146, US j 1 7 p rnni t sbetmatrjrsiio fiueo dfndnt t t l
4 28 C 44 eti ng o u jc te uidc n;alr f ee n s o i y
me
s ji i t rmo lato i wrtng adt rma bae ona tnto grund stot wihi te
on n he e va cin n ii ; n o e nd sd bse in o s e frh t n h
6
7

8

M ouon t Remand.n eçour s d r l on is sofr m a and f tt ' f 'pr edi pendi
o
t houl u e s ue
e nd
urler ' w' oce ngs
yf
ng

dtr naino a1sc ise c n enngFe ea c utuidito t pr etteb t tec r Ji
eemi to f 1 u h su s o c ri d rl o rjzs çin o otc h 0h h out z
J
t Pl ndlhe ei f - unnece sarvtmetlt pens wth v pec/t deendantslnvcrfgt z vc .
he ai
rnm
s
i zzfex e t
o f
' / jl ftver n/
ç
i av i i z fl f e is e tr me i o t czeat r
n o d n / m s u s zW rt f he t ' M .
e
s
â

9

l
o

n ee o e ' o inToDiris'sir lv nt m n tu a u tcbeds o r a da j diain
rf r ,' to
M
sns 'i ree a u r e ndj siil ic vey n du c to

1 o t m at r p ra ni g t a o t rg sa d o i to o t epa te a o r e b vit eo t e
1 f he te s e ti n o nd f he i ht n blgai ns f h ris s ha g d y r u f h

l de do tu t
a e f rs

' 'gt t s j d p o ryl ri
o he ube r pet l en.
e

l
a

I C O NC LUSI N
n
O

14

( h Plitf z Co lita e uaeysae csmsf rrle a ans Dee a pate ( 1 o
Tl e an ifs mpan d q tl tt s li o eif g i t fnd nt ris a1 f
1 t m)a alg d The ef eDef na ntsG OTI TO DJ /JS's ul bed ne s t alw f r
5 he s le e
ON
D J ' ho d e id o o lo o
'
r or
e a 'M
.

1 po e aj dct no te ic v l a dt meis ftecs a b rPani sa e u tl md de
6 r pr du iai n h dso ey n âe r o l ae t a. lit d q aey
o
t l
T
l
1 b d n u de FRCP 8 o K ot 'pl e n Ale nai e y, hou d t e c u t md a y de i inc e i t
7 ur e n r
f ' ke' e g. tr tv l s l h o r f n fc e i s n he
n
1 Co a n Pli i e ue t l a et a e e t Co aitpu sx t Fe r lRul o Ci l
8
mpl i t antf q ss e v o m nd d he mpl n r lmt o de a e f vi
rr
s
'
19

Pr c d r 1 ()2 .
o e u e 5 a( )

20 Th Pli c r s e tul rq s t tti c ur d n t Dee d
e ant e p c f l e uet ha h s o t e y he f n
y

a e ' ot t Dimisp/ n#
nts' i o s s lj/.
M on
p

2l Compl nv'
ai .
22

23

zo/
k

DATED :hi & ' ' dayof Sept
ts
ember 2011
,

24

BY:

2
5

L' sei# Ree ve,r S)
s lpo y nPo e
a kl ee
1
0365 Tal ng Tr

26

Lasvegas NV.891
29
,
702-561 720
4

27

wne r@ao.o
wea a lc m

28

PLM NTI I PRO PER
FF: N
6

PLAI FF RESPONS I OPPOSI ON TO DEFENDANT' M OTI TO DI M I COM P
NTI
E N
TI
S
ON
S SS
LAN

1

CERTI CATE OF SERVI
FI
CE

2

3
4

Ihe e y
rb

' t a s r i, o t e f r go n de u n de c i d a :
b t e vc f h o e i g c me t s rG s
e

'PIAI I SRESPONS I OPPOSI
'
NT FF'
E N
TION TO DEFENDANTS' OTION TO DI I '
M
SM SS '

h a f etmbr 2 1 y eoin oy o in z tls mal
t
i r
wa maeo te Jh' dyo S pe e ,0l b dp sigacp frmal p fscas i,
s d nh
.

5 pos p e a d a La Ve a , e a t t e f lo ng:
lge r p i t s g s N v da o h o l wi
6
7

8
s

lo

11

Ariel E . Stern
Akerman Senterfitt , LLP
400 South Fourth Street
Su:te 450
L
La: Veqas , NV 89101
702-634-5000
Fax : [phone]
Email: ariel.
[e-mail]
ATTORNEY 20 BE NOTICED
*

l2

1
3
14
15
.

l6

M làson lchmidt
Akerman Senterf itt
4 00 So . Fourth Street
Suite 450
Las Vegas , NV 8 9101
702-634-5000
Fax : [phone]
Email: aschmldt@piteduncan .
com
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTTCSD

17
18

19
20

2
1

BY

2

g'

z

Ini t se pa t oft ma t he en.
J ntw td ry he tc r i

23
24
25
26
27
28
7

PLM NTI RESPONSE I OPPOSI ON TO DEFENDANT' M OTI TO DI I COM P N T
FF
N
TI
S
ON
SM SS
LAI