Perez-Zarate v. Bravo Pro Maintenance, Inc. et al

Filing 64

ORDER Denying 63 Plaintiffs' Motion for Judgment Against Garnishee Defendants. Signed by Judge Roger L. Hunt on 7/18/12. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - EDS)

1
2
3
4
5

I
6

7

UM TED STA TES DISTRICT CO URT
;

8

;
!

9

1

1
0

I
i
!
I
:

11 ROSENDO PEREZ- RATE, b hafo
M
on e l f
hi s fa a 1ot r sm ia l st t d'
m el nd l he s i lry iua e ,
1
2
Pli if,
antfs
1
3
vs
.

)
)
)
)
)
)

!

1
4

)

!

i

I

DI H CT OF NEVAD A
STI

1

***

I

!

I
;

I
Cas No.2: c 01 e : 09-v- 567RLH- .I.
1R
o l El
tp t

( i f J
Moton or udgme Agans Gmmihee
nt i t
s
Dee nt -#63)
fnda s

I
!
.
;
.

BRAVO PRO M AI
NTENANCE,I C.a
N U..)
Ne
vadac por ton;
or ai ADRI RAM I
AN
REZ, n )
a
i vi l ALFONSO RAM X EZ,a
ndi dua )
n
)
-

1
5

1 i vi lGABRI RAM I
6 ndi dua;
EL
REZ,a
n
i i dua; LLERM O ALONSO:a
ndvi lGUI
n
1 i vi l DOES 1t oug 1 i l i
7 ndi dua ;
hr h 00, nc usve;
ROE CORPORATI
ONS 1t ough 1
hr
00,

)
)
)
)

1
9

)
)

Def nt .
enda s

20

21

Bef e t Cour i Pl ntf Cl s M oto f J
or he
t s ai if as '
i n or udgm e Aga ns t H a d Roc
nt
i t he r
k

22 Caéa t El
f nd he ephan Ba (i r s es' ( 3,tldM a 22, 2) Ganihee ha nottl a
t r E nihe ' e ie y 201 . r s s ve ied n
Ga
)
23

24

25

O pp ii
os ton.

BACK GROUND

Pl ntfscommenc t sac i a i tBr vo Pr M ant na (t av Pr ' t
ai if
ed hi ton gans a
o i e nce t o o') o
Br

26 rc unpadwage e r whiee oy dt r TheCour grntds
e over i
s aned l mpl e hee.
t a e ummayj
r udgme i
nt n
AO 72
( 8 82)
Rev. /

1

'

1

fv ro Plitfso No e e 2 2 0( 4 ) a do d r dBrv Pr t p yaj d me t f
a o f anif n v mb r 3, 01 # 6 , n r ee a o o o a u g n o

2

$6111 74 ( .
,24. #47)

3

P an if n w s e t g r ihp rin o ta j d me fo Ganih e , c
litfs o e k o ans o t s f h t u g nt r m r s e s whih
o

4

alg dye o o e o e tej ni ra sr ie o Brv Pr Plitfscame t h v
le e l mply r mply d h a t il e vc s f a o o. anif li d o a e
o

5

s l d W rt ofGar s e a Ga nihm e l e r t re on Ga nihe , tGa nihe
ewe
is
nihm nt nd r s nt ntroga o is
r s es bu r s es

6

f i dt r s o d.P an if r q e tti Co r e trd fu t u me ta ans Gan s e u d r
al o e p n litfs e u s h s u t ne ea lj dg n g i t r ihe s n e
e

7

NRS 31320 f f l et r s
.
or aiur o e pond. Fort r as dic s d bel Pl ntfs M oton f
he e ons s us e
ow, ai if ' i or

g

J
udgmentAgans Ga nihe De e nt i de e
i t r s e f nda s s nid.

9

DI
SCUSSI
ON

1)
(

A m ong t e m yrad i s s f t lt Pl i if 'm oton, he Cou w ilonl a r s
h
i s ue a a o a ntf s
i t
rt l y dd e s

jj

t o,nam e y t ts r i e w a i pr rt derf de a r esa t t W rtofGa ni hm e i
w
l . ha e v c
s m ope m
e r l ul nd hat he i
r s nt s

12 ia e u t s ht th Co rc r te tru g n a antGanse s F dea rlsrq iea
: n d q ae uc ha te u t amo ne j d me t g is rih e . e rl ue c ur
,
1: c por ton be s r ed G de i rng (our doc e s t an ofl er am a i org r la nt
$ or a i
e v G lve i c t um ntl o
by
tc , nagng ene a ge ,
1
4

ort any ot rag a horze by a
o
he ent ut i d
ppoi m e orby l w t r c ve s l i e ofpr s ....' Fe
nt nt
a o e ei ew c
oce s
' d.

1 R. v. 4( .Pli if s tpr s bymalt Dee nt'outofsaebusnes a e sa
5
Ci P. h) antfs en oce s
i o fnda s
tt i s ddrs nd
1
6

i ntfe onl t t l r Roc Ca é'a t t e ntBa ' t r eve t d ume s l Lar en
de iid y he : a d
l
k f ' nd he t pha
El
r' o ec i he oc nt. n s

17
,

v M ayo M e c Ce er,s vc bym alwa i operwhe pr e swa no a es e t a
.
dial nt i er ie
i s mpr
n oc s s t ddr s d o n

j
g

a t i d a entbutt ç e c llega De rm e , a Clni ' Se ,eg. 21 F.3d 863,868
u horze g
o ç dia/- l pa t nt M yo i c.' e . , 8
M

1
9

( h Ci. 0) Pli if ha nots
8t r 2œ . antfs ve
hownt tt ys v da i vi la horze t rceve
ha he er e n ndi dua ut i d o e i

::
)

s r i e. n e e or s r c i i ld bec e Pl i if di notde i rpr es t a a ho i ed
e vc
r f e, e vi e s nva i
aus a ntf s d
lve oc s o n ut r z

21

a ntof t G a ni he ,b m er l a e s d t doc e s t t Ga nihe 'e ii s i g ne a .
ge
he r s es ut e y ddr s e he um nt o he r s es ntte n e r l

2:
2
,
23

l a ton,Pl ntf sdi nots ciy a a ountt be gmmi hed i t W r tof
n ddii
ai if d
pe f n m
o
s
n he i
G a nihm e .a r quie u rN e
r s nt s e r d nde vada rles N RS 31.
tl .
320. Pl ntf sm e e y s cii a pe c
ai if
r l pe fed
r ent

2 o a t ee mi ds m o g o swa e .n eeo e ti Com c u dn tg a t u g nt g is
4 f n md tr ne u f r s g s
rf r ,h s l o l o rn j d me a an t
25

Ga nihe ev i s r i e w a pr r
r s es en f e v c
s ope .

26

//
/

AO 72
( v.8/
Re 82)

2

# .
4

1

CONCLUSI
ON

J
,

A c or ngl a f goo c us a
c di y. nd or d a e ppea i
rng,

a

I I HEREBY ORD ERED t tPl ntf s M oton f J
T S
ha ai if ' i or udgm e A ga ns
nt
i t

4

5

Ganihe Dee nt ( 63)i DENDD .
r s e fnda s J s
#

Dt Jl1,02
adu 821.
e y

.
y
.

6

. ..
.

.

.
'
M

t b l'
Q f pm
.

K' '
'

,<
''

'
'''

Z

...
.

.. ;y
-

RO ed S tHUST ctJudge
U *
esDlt
sri

8
9
10
11
12

1
3
14
15

1
6
17

1
8
1
9
20
21
22
23
24
25

26
AO 72
( v. 82)
Re 8/

1.

'

3

'
.