Everest Indemnity Insurance Company v. Aventine-Tramoni Homeowners Association, et al.,

Filing 228

ORDER that Pipes Paving's Motion to File Counterclaim 131 is DENIED. Plaintiff's Motion to Strike Pipes Paving's Motion to File Counterclaim 164 is GRANTED. Rising Sun Plumbing, LLC's Motion to File Counterclaim 150 is GRA NTED. Nevada Stairs, Inc.'s Motion to File Amended Answer and Counterclaim 152 is GRANTED. Plaintiff's Motion to Dismiss Counterclaim of Town Center Ventures, LLC 63 is GRANTED. Signed by Judge Robert C. Jones on 12/27/10. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - ECS)

. :

i ---. . f! I . 7.ë)
- - .- . .

EI'SE II ?O E

Ctsl ff s r ttp pa fs jï g acu r' t
1

--' FF EV D - Z /E S j gig jw j N

'

!E( 2 g g l )' gg
2

3

4 5
6

t Ey L : s j! .g g l rs I ) lygr t ; t Si, a/ ypj jgglgy s yg y jA B> t u UN I ED STATES DI T R I T CO- . T S C - - gs yp D I TR I T O F NEVAD A S C

EVEREST I DEM NI Y I SURANCE CO. N TN ,
7 Pli tf# an if 8 9 vs . '

AVEN TI E- RAM ON TIHOM EOW NERS NT 1 ASSOCI TI N e a. 0 A O t 1, 1I
l 2

Defnda t. e ns

) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) )

2: 9-v- 1 7 - CJRJ 0 c 0 6 2R - J ORDER

1 3

Thi i a itr la e a tonaiigoutofcams(ndpotnta cams by s s n n ep e d r ci rsn li a e il li )

1 a pr xi aeysxt Defnda t a ans Plitf Eveetlde niyJs rnc Co.(t v rs'. 4 p o m tl i y e ns g i t anif rs n m t n u a e ç ee t) E '
15 Fi e m otons ar pendi g bef r t e Court Pi es Pavi g' M oton .t FieCou tr li ( CF v i e n oe h :p ns i oi n ec am E
;

1 No.1 1* aitf' Motont StiePie Pa ig.sM otont FleCo ntrli ( CFNo. 6 3 )Pl n ifs i o rk p s vn , , i o l u ecam E 1 1 4) RiigSu Plmbig LLC' Motont FieCou trli ( CFNo.1 ) Ne a aStis 7 6 ; sn n u n , S i o l n ecam E 50 ; v d ar,
-RJJ Everest Indemnity Insurance Company v. Aventine-Tramoni Homeowners Association, et al., Doc. 228

1 I c' Motont FieAme d dAns e an Co ntrli ( CFNo.1 2 ; ndPlitf' Moto 8 n .s i o l ne w r d u ecam E 5 ) a anifs in 1 t DimisCo ntr li ofTownCentrVe trs LLC ( CFNo.1 3) 9 o s s u ecam e nue , E 6.
20 1 . FACTS A N D PRO C E D U R AL Y ST O R Y

21

l come tonwihac nsrcinprj c a For Apa heRo da dGicraeAve uei n r ci t o tu to oe t t t c a n l es n n

22 La Ve a , a a (het rjc' Plitf Ev rs is e a Owne Contole Is ln e s g s Nev d , t t oe t' anif ee ts u d n p ) r r ld n u- c a 23 Pr grm Poiy(het olc/'efcieMa l 2003tr ug May1 ,200 t Defnda tTown o a lc t t i ) fetv y 5, p ho h 5 6o e n
2 Ce trVe m r s LLC (ç CV') whih c v r d TCV a wel a co ta t r an s bc nta t r . 4 ne n e , 1 T ' c o ee s l s n r co s d u o r co s

25 ( omp.1 71 77) ThePolc povie $lmilo i cov rge:ube tt a$50,00tsef C lI , . ! iy r d s lin n ea s jc o 0 tl

Dockets.Justia.com

1 ls rdRee ton. (d. 7 ) Onora o tJ n ay l ,20 8,Dee d ntAv ntne-rmoni n u e tni ' 1 ! 3 . ' b u au r 5 0 fn a ei-a t f 2 Home wnesAsocato (bet socain' s e TCV a dDee da tCamsConsnlton o r s i in t ' s ito ' u d A ) n fn n t ci 3 (t a s'i saec ur f ralg dc nsr cindee t.f.!7 ) Plitf undeto te ç m ' n tt o t o le e o tu to fcs (# 8 . anif ro k h C )
4 d f n e ofisi s r dsTCV a d Ca sa d ha a r a y e pe de $1 0, 00 i t e rde e s a of ee s t nue n m n d le d x n d 5 0 n h i f n e s

5 ted t ofteprsntComplit( ugut2 , 09)la iga prxi aey$85 ,00av iabl h ae h ee an A s 8 20 ,e vn p o m tl 00 al e
6 u d rt ePolc .1 . 81 . SiceOcob r2007 t eAs oca in ha ma es v r lde a ds ne h iy (d ! ) n te , h s ito s d e e a m n

7 u d rtePolc a dh srjce bohPlitm sownp lc -i iss tlme tofra da n e h iy n a ee td t ani o iylm t ete n fe n
8 m edi t r' pr posalt ati cl ded paym entoft e polcy lm is,choosng i sead t pur ue a ao s o h nu b i it i nt o s

9 mulim ilon-ola j dgme ta an tPlitf sis rds (#.I -8 ,88.Plitf t- li d lr u n g is anif n u e .f ' 83 4 ) an if !
1 acknow l dgest att e c ver d contact r and s bcontact r ar notnam ed asdef ndant i t e 0 e hhoe r os u r os e e snh 11 st t cour ltgaton butaleges t att ey r m ai pot ntaly labl f rt e dam agessoughtt er i ae t ii i l h h e n e il i eo h h en

' 1

1 i tec re tltgaina dpotnta ftr ltg to .Se i.l ) 2 n h u rn ii to n e il uue iiain ( e d' 89. !
l3 Becaus Pl i tf coul pot ntaly f ce rvalcl i s fom isvarous i s r dsundert e e an if d e il a i am r t i nue h

1 Polc t a e c e t e $8 0, 0 i ism a i u la iiy unde t e polc ,i fl d t e pr s nt 4 i y h t x e d h 5 0 0 n t x m m i b lt rh i y t ie h e e

1 itr la e a ton.Se î. 90 .Plitf ha s e a pr xi aeysxt ofisis rdsu de te 5 nepe d r ci ( e '! ) an if s u d p o m tl i y t n ue n r h #
1 Polc ,a w e la t e As o i ton, 6 iy s l s h s c a i TCV , nd Ca s o hv c us sofac i n pur ua tt 28 a m ,n o a e to sno

1 U. . . 1 35a d 22 1: 1 I t m l a er a d ( )De lr t r Rele . Pl itf ha d postd 7 S C jj 3 n 0 ( ) n e e d ; n 2 c a ao y if a n if s e ie l $85 , 00wih t eCour.( e Ce iiae,Se t 1 20 9,ECF No.9 . 8 00 th t S e n fc t p . 7, 0 ) 1 9 Se e a De e da ? ha cfldco ntr li s ( )Ne a aGy s m Flor , nc, s e v r l f n n v ie u e ca m : 1 v d p u o s l .( e

20 Ans e & Countrl,ECFNo. ) ()TCV e a.(e Ans er& Countrl,ECFNo. ) ( ) wr ec. 44. 2 , t l,s e w ec. 46, 3 .
21 Ava tDoo Gr up,s eAns e & Countrl,ECFNo.75,a d()W etr Pieie n i r o (e wr ec. ) n 4 sen p ln . 2 Co sr cinCor .(e Ans e & Counecl ECFNo. 1.Pie Pa ig;RiigSu , ' 2 n tu to p,s e w r tr . , 8 ) p s vn sn n LLC,
2 a d Ne a a St is l c. veea h tl d s pa at m o i n f r la e t tl t ei o n 3n v d a r , n ha c i e e r e to s o e v o ie h r w
24 count r l i s. Ncvada St is al o s eksl ave t am end is answer Pl i tf hasm oved t s rke e ca m ar s e e o t . a n if o ti

25 Pi es Pavi g' m oton and t dim i st e exi tng TCV Count r l i f rf iur oft os partes p ns i o ssh si e ca m o a l e h e i Page 2 of 5

i t obt i couns l o an e.

2 l. 1
3 4

LEGA L STAN D A R D S
A. Leave t Am end an A nsw eror t Fie a C ount rcl i o ol e am

A pary m ay am end a pl adi g once asa m aterofcour ew ihi t e t one daysof t en t s t n w np

5 sr igii nors onsvepla igi rquie . eFe .R. v.P.l ()1( ) A dititc ur e vn tf e p i e dn s e rd Se d Ci 5a()A . src o t

6 ha diceint pe nia a e dme tt a a s e,Ge tl v Ci o Tu s n, 1 F.d 1 , s s rto o n t n m n n o n n w r naa . t f c o 2 3 3 055 y
7 1 ( t Ci. ) ort grntla et fl ac untrli , son- urn Co.v Be te,5 l 061 9h r 2000, o a e v o ie o ecam Ralt p ia . ri 4 8 F.d 1 6 ,1 6 (t Ci.1 7 ) Fe eal eofCiiPrc dur 1 ()i t bea ple lbe ly 2 3 3 3 7 9h r 9 6 . d r Rul vl o e e 5a s o p id i m l 9 i fvo ofa e dme t a d,nge ea,laves albefe l gie wh nj sies'rquie . e n a r m n ns n i n rl e h l rey v n e u tc o e rs Se 1 Janik Lo gig Co.v' ate , F.d561 5 6(t Ci,1 4) l c nsde igwhehe t grnt 0 ci g n M e r 42 3 , 6 9h r 99 . n o i rn t ro a 11 orde yamotons e igla et a e d, c ulma c nsde whebe teei ()ba fih,2) n i e kn e v o m n a o r y o i r t r h r s 1 d at ( 1 un uedea ,3)prj diet teo posngpary,()ftlt i tea e d e tan ()whehe 2d ly ( eu c o h p i t 4 uiiy n h m n m n, d 5 tr 1 temo a tha prviusya e de tepla ig. eAle v. t o Be e l Hil, 11F.d 3 h v n s e o l m n d h e dn Se ln Ci f v ry l 9 2 y s 1 3 7,3 3(t Ci.1 90) 4 6 7 9h r 9 .
1 5
l 6

'

B.

Rul 1 ( e 29

Sf e c u t a sr ke f o a pl a i g a i s f i i ntde e s o a y r du d nt ç ' o r m y ti r m -h e d n n n u fce fn e r n e n a ,

1 i maeili petne tors a dao smatr'Fe . Ci. 1 ( .A dititco r' r lngon 7 m tra,m ri n, c n lu te. d R. v P. 2 9 ' src u ts ui
1 a m oton t srke i r vi w e f ra a us o di c e i n. eH am bl t n Br s Lumbe Co.v 8 i o ti s e e d o n b e f s r to Se eo o . r .

1 Bali Entr.I c, F.d 1 l 1 24n. (t Ci.2 05) 9 kn es,n 397 3 2 7, 2 4 9h r 0 .
20 2l C. A ppear ncesofBus nessEnttes i FederalCour a i ii n t

A busi es entt m us be r pr s nt d by a lce s d ator ey i f der lcourt See n s iy t e ee e i ne t n n e a .

22 Rowl ndv CalM e?s C(/ l ,Uni 1 M e 'ztv- l Cotn i,506U. .l 2 2 ( 9 3) a . . ?' )(i ?y t 1 n s dï ïcr tc l çy S 94, 0 l 9

23 (iig28U. . .j 1 ) U?' #SttsIHihCtl &7Br ad Co.3F.d 1 44,l (t Ci. ctn SC 654 * 7/ ae t g ?/ ' o . , 3 2 245 9h r , sc n
24 1 3)(t c m o a in ma a pe ri f de a c un o l t r ugh lc ns dc uns l' ' ealo.7 99 1A o r to y p a n e r l o n y h o ie e o e .l se s / ', 1

25 r rec//ptt . /t( v,2 P.d 1 1200t ev 2001 (' eba eco sse tyhedt a alga e v ji ? % '?' ' 5 3 9 , ' . ) t ?f # N W v n itn l l h t e l
Page 3 of 5

.

*

1 e tt s c a ac r ortonc nnota p a e c ptt r ug c u s l....) n iy u h s o p a i a p er x e ho h o n e '. '
2 H I. 3
4

AN A LY SIS A. Pi esPavi g' M oton f r Leave t Fie Count rcl i and Pl i tf ' M oton p ns io ol e am a n if s i t St i e o rk

Pi esPavi g see s l ave t a end isAns ert add count r l i sf rbr ach of p n ke om t wo eca m o e
5

c n r c,u j s e rc m e t a dbr a h oft ec ve a to go d f ih a df i de lng. Se M ot o ta t n u t n i h n , n e c h o n n f o at n ar ai ( e . .
6

Ex.A, No.1 1.l rs ons , antf mo e t srketemotonbe au ePie pa igi ECF 3 ) n e p e Pli if v s o ti h i c s p s vn s
7
8

' notr pr sent d by couns l I deed,t er cor i di at st atpi es Pavi g hasnotbeen ee e e. n h e dn ce h p n r pr s nt d by counsels nceJul 13,2010. The Cour t er f r deni sism oton t am end and e ee e i y th eoe et io

9 gr nt t e m oton t srke i. a sh i o ti t 1 0

l

B.
11 1 2

m s ng Sun Pl m bi g' M ot on for Leavet Fie C ount rc ai i u ns i ol e lm

R i i g Sun Pl m bi g s eksI ave t fl count r l i s f rdecl r t r r lef br a h of sn u ne e o ie ec am o a ao y ei , e c

c nta ta dbra hoftec ve a to go dfiba dfi de lng.(ccM o.ECFNo.1 0 . o rc, n e c h o n n f o at n ar ai J t, 5)
l3

Pl i tf ha Gl d a notc cl rf i g t a ism oton t srke doe no a pl t Rii g St a n if s e i e a iy n h t t i o ti s t p y o sn m
1 4

Pl m bi g' m oton,and Pl i tf hasnotot er i eoppos d t em oton. The Cour t er f r u ns i a n if b ws eh i th eo e
15

grnt t emoto . eL. . v. a .7 2( ) a sh in Se R Ci Pr c - d .
1 6
C.
l7

Nevada St i s'M oton f rL eave t Fie Count rcl i ar io ol e am

N evada St is s eksl a et am end is ans ert tl count r l i s f rbr ac of ar e ev o t w o ie e cam o e h l8

c nta tu j s e rc m e ta dbe c oftec v na tofg odfiha dfide lng.S eMot o rc, nu t n ih n, n ra h h o e n o at n ar ai (e .
l9

Ex. ECFNo.1 2- ) Plitf ha no opposdtemoton.TheCo r teeor ga t te A, 5 1. anif s t eh i u th rf e rns b
20

moton.Se L. .Ci. a .72() i e R v Prc - d .
2l

D. 22
23

M oton t D i m i sCount r l i ofTCV i oss e ca m

Fi aly,Pl i tf hasm oved t dim is t e exi tng TCV Count r l i . Tha n l a n if o ssh si e c am t C ount r l i i br ughtby TCV ;Cams;Pageanty Com m unii s,l c. Pageanty Devel pm ent e cam s o r te n ; r o 24

C o p. Pa e nty Re ly,l c. Pa ea ty Re i e ta , r ' g a r a t n , g n r s d n i l LLC' d Pr m i rCons r c i n Co p. , ' , an e e tu to r
25 . .

Page4 of 5

.

.

*

1 (ole tvey,t ou trli a t')( e ECFNo. ) Ic ntisco ntrli sfrbra hof c lci l tc n ecam ns'.S e 46. t o an u ecam o e c
2 c n r c , d f ih br a h ofi s r n ec nta t a d sat t r unf i c a m spr ctc sun e o ta t ba a t e c n u a c o c , n t u o y ar li a ie d r

3 s cin68 A.1 ofteNe a aRe ie Sotts (e i..Plitf agu sta e to 6 3 0 h v d vs d ue .S e dj anif r e h t
4 Co n e c a m a t 'c u s lw ihd e o J l 1 ,201 ,a d Co nt r l i a t c nnot s e t e r u t r li n s o n e t r w n u y 3 0n u e ca m n s a pur u h i 5 cl i s i f de a c ur w ihou r pr s nt to . Pl i tf i c r e ton bot co nt . a m n e r l o t t t e e e a i n a n if s o r c h us

6 Cou trli a t ha enot jctd(hc ca notobe twih utc u s l. TleCour ga t te n ecam ns v obe e t y n j c to o n ell z t rns h
7 m oton. i

8

CO N C LU SIO N

9

I I HEREBY ORDERED tatPie Pa ig' Motont FieCo ntr li ( CFNo. TS h p s vn s i o l u ecam E

1 1 1 i DENI D. 0 3)s E
.

11

I I FU RTII R O RD ERED t a Pl i tf sM oton t Sti e Pi esPavi g' M oton t TS 'E h t a n if i o rk p ns io

1 FieCo ntrli ( CFNo.1 4 i GRANTED. 2 l u ecam E 6 )s
1 3 I I FU RT HE R O R D ER ED t atRii g Sun Pl m bi g,LLC' M otc l Fie TS h sn un S im ( l )

l Co ntr li ( CF No.1 )i GRANTED. 4 u e c am E 50 s
1 5 I I FI RT H ER O R D ERE D t a N e a a St is l c.sM o i n t Fie Am e de A ns e TS J h t v d a r , n ' to o l nd wr

ï

1 a dCo ntrli ( CFNo.1 2 i GRANTED. 6 n u ecam ' E 5 )s
1 7 I I FURTHER ORDERED t a Pl i tm s M oton t D im i sCoun e c a m ofTo n TS h t an i i o ss t r li w

1 Ce trVe trs LLC ( CFNo.1 3)i GRANTED. 8 ne nu e, E 6s
19 I I SO ORDERED . TS

20
2I

Da e * 1 27t day ofDecem ber 201 . td s h ,0
.

22 23

ROBE -.J N ES O U nied St e D it i tJ dge t a s rc u

24 l heAsocainha fldalmie o j cin,n tt op os dimis l teTCV ' r s ito s i i td be to o o p e s s a ofh e 25 cou tr li , t noeiso jcint c nai agume t Plitf ma e i ismoton necam buto t t be to o e n r ns an if k s n t i
concer i g t e m ert oft e cas . nn h is h e
Page 5 of 5