Chudacoff, MD v. University Medical Center Of Southern Nevada et al

Filing 177

STIPULATION AND ORDER of Dismissal with prejudice, each party to bear their own fees and costs incurred herein. Signed by Judge Miranda M. Du on 3/6/2015. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - DKJ)

Case 2:08-cv-00863-MMD-GWF Document 730 Filed 03/06/15 Page 1 of 6

ScoTT R. Coox,ESQ.
Nevada Bar No. 005265
RYAN S. PETERSF,N, ESQ.

Nevada Bar No. 10715
KOLESAR & LEATNAM

D
7

400 South Rampart Boulevard, Suite 400
Las Vegas, Nevada 89145
Telephone: [phone]
Facsimile: [phone]
E-Mail: [e-mail]
[e-mail]
Attorneys for Defendant
University Medical Centerfor Southern Nevada

9

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

]0

DISTRICT OF NEVADA

ll

***

N

o

r

~;
o e IZ
'
Q y
x~~e~
~~
~a~ l3
moor
~ W„
a a ue
y
° m7 ~. l4
~

RICHARD M. CHUDACOFF, M.D.,

CASE NO. 2:08-cv-00863-RCJ-GWF

Plaintiff,

Q

CONSOLIDATED W1TH:
CASE NO. 2:09-cv-01679-RCJ-GWF

vs.

-o

~/

15
""'
w~ W
~ ~~ 16
O 0 =`~
17
F
L4 L

pp
w R r
vC

a
~ E > ~

18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28

UNIVERS[TY MEDICAL CF,NTER OF
SOUTHERN NEVADA. a political subdivision
of Clark County, State of Nevada; STEVE
SISOLAK, BRUCE L. WOODBURY;TOM
COLLINS; LARRY BROWN; CHIP
MAXFIELD; LAWRENCE WEEKLY; CHRIS
GIUNCHIGLIANI; SUSAN BRAGER; and
RORY REID, Clark County Commissioners,
ex-officio, the Board of Trustees of
UNIVERSITY MEDICAL CENTER OF
SOUTHERN NEVADA;KATHLEEN
SILVER, an individual; THE MEDICAL AND
DENTAL STAFF OF THE UNIVERSITY
MEDICAL CENTER OF SOUTHERN
NEVADA,an independent subdivision of
University Medical Center of Southern Nevada;
JOHN ELLERTON, M.D., an individual;
MARVIN J. BERNSTEIN, M.D., an individual;
DALE GARRISON, M.D., an individual;
DONALD ROBERTS, M.D., an individual;
PAUL D. BANDT,M.D., an individual; JIM
CHRISTENSEN, M.D., an individual; JOHN
FILDES, an individual; CHARLES BLOOM,
M.D., an individual; MARIETTA NELSON,
M.D., an individual; KSHAMA DAPHTARY,
M.D., an individual; JOHN ONYEMA, M.D.,
an individual; BEVERLY NEYLAND, M.D.,
an individual; ALBERT CAPANNA,M.D., an

Page 1 of 4

STIPULATION AND ORDER FOR
DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE

Case 2:08-cv-00863-MMD-GWF Document 730 Filed 03/06/15 Page 2 of 6
CASE NO. 2:08-cv-00863-RCJ-GWF
CONSOLIDATED WITH:
CASE NO. 2:09-cv-01679-RCJ-GWF

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

individual; LAURA BILODEAU M.D., an
individual; STEVEN BECKER, M.D., an
individual; THOMAS HUNT, M.D., an
individual; CRAIG IWAMOTO, M.D., an
individual; DANIEL KIRGAN, M.D., an
individual; DEBORAH KUHLS, M.D., an
individual; TERRY LEWIS, M.D., an
individual; FREDERICK LIPPMANN, M.D.,
an individual; DIANNE MAZZU, M.D., an
individual; JOHN MCCOURT, M.D., an
individual; PAUL STEWART, M.D., an
individual; THOMAS VATER, D.O., an
individual; MEENA VOHRA, M.D., an
individual; CRAIG VOSS, M.D., an individual;
DOE Defendants I through X,inclusive; and
ROE CORPORATIONS A through Z,
inclusive,
Defendants.

11
N

~ ~ ~ 12
Q d
F= ~~,o 13
Q ~=
9~`.

STIPULATION AND ORDER FOR DISNIISSAL WITH PREJUDICE

~T „' V, M

L Q
R ...

..

~ v ~
~ ~ LL

14

~j °z~
~'

Provided all terms of the Settlement Agreement have been met, Plaintiff, RICHARD M.

1

CHUDACOFF, M.D., by and through his counsel of record, JACOB L. HAFTER, ESQ., of

~ G

~ w ~~ 15

Q a °'
~ E~ ~
a~
W a "7 c
~

~6

O `~
~' F ]7
d

Hafter Law, LLC; and Defendants UNIVERSITY MEDICAL CENTER OF SOUTHERN
NEVADA, BRUCE L. WOODBURY, TOM COLLINS, CHIP MAXFIELD, LAWRENCE
WEEKLY, CHRIS GIUNCHIGLIANI, SUSAN BRAGER, and RORY REID, Clark County

18

Commissioners, ex-officio; STEVE SISOLAK, TOM

19

LAWRENCE WEEKLY, CHRIS GIUNCHIGLIANI, SUSAN BRACER, and RORY REID, in

20

their ex officio capacity as the Board of Trustees of LTNIVERSTTY MEDICAL CENTER OF

21

SOUTHERN NEVADA; THE BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF UNIVERS]TY MEDICAL

22

CENTER OF SOUTHERN NEVADA, and KATNLEEN SILVER, by and through their counsel

23

of record, LYNN M. HANSEN,ESQ. of Jimmerson Hansen; Defendants THE MEDICAL AND

24

DENTAL STAFF OF UNIVERSITY MEDICAL CENTER OF SOUTHERN NEVADA, JOHN

25

ELLERTON, M.D., MARVIN J. BERNSTEIN, M.D.. DALE GARRISON, D.O., and DONALD

26

ROBERTS, M.D., by and through their counsel of record, KIM IRENE MANDELBAUM,ESQ.

27

of Mandelbaum Ellerton & Associates; and Defendants PAUL BANDT, M.D.; JIM

28
Page 2 of 4

COLLINS, LARRY BROWN,

Case 2:08-cv-00863-MMD-GWF Document 730 Filed 03/06/15 Page 3 of 6
CASE NO. 2:08-cv-00863-RCJ-G WF
CONSOLIDATED WITH:
CASE NO. 2:09-cv-01679-RCJ-GWF

1

CHRISTENSEN, M.D.; JOHN FILDES, M.D.; CHARLES BLOOM, M.D.; MARIETTA

2

NELSON, M.D.; KSHAMA DAPHTARY, M.D.; JOHN ONYEMA, M.D.; BEVERLY

3

NEYLAND, M.D.; ALBERT CAPANNA, M.D.; VICTOR GRIGORIEV, M.D.; LAURA

4

BILODEAU, M.D.; MICHAEL CASEY, M.D.; STEVEN BECKER, M.D.; THOMAS HUNT,

5

M.D.; CRAIG 1WAMOTO, M.D.; DANIEL KIRGAN, M.D.; DEBORAH KUHLS, M.D.;

6

TERRY LEWIS, M.D.; FREDERICK LIPPMANN, M.D.; DIANNE MAZZU, M.D.; JOHN

7

McCOURT, M.D.; PAUL STEWART, M.D.; THOMAS VATER, M.D.; MEENA VOHRA,

8

M.D. and CRAIG VOSS, M.D. by and through their counsel of record; WALTER CANNON,

~'] ESQ. of Olson Cannon Gormley Angulo & Stoberski, and Defendant ITNIVERSITY MEDICAL
CENTER OF SOUTHERN NEVADA,by and through Counsel SCOTT R. COOK, ESQ., of the
ll

law firm Kolesar & Leatham, hereby stipulate and agree to Dismiss the above-entitled action,

~2

with Prejudice, each party to bear their own fees and costs incurred herein.

N

r
~

~

Q'~,
-~' -oxr l3
~ ~
Q

~ R v
R .~ ..

DATED this 3~

day of December, 2014.

7

~ ~ S
~ ~ ~
~y o u s
`'
C) ~
~c

14

a C
G
a ~ ~
E ~ ~

RAFTER LAW

~5

Q
(~

Wz
l
1--I
O ~

~~

R

"' 16

~ C
...~

911 N Buffalo Drive, Suite 209
Las V gas, Nevada 89128
Attorn ys for Plaintiff

~ l7
18

19 ~ DATED this
20

day of December, 2014

DATED this

day of December, 2014.

MANDELBAUM ELLERTON &ASSOCIATES

JIMMERSON HANSEN

By

By

21
~~~
23
24
25
26

KIM I. MANDELBAUM,ESQ.
Nevada Bar No. 000318
2012 Hamilton Lane
Las Vegas, Nevada 89106
Attorneys for Defendants
The Medzcal and Dental Staffof University
Medical Center, John. Ellerton, M.D.;
Marvin J. Bernstein, M.D., Dale Garrison,
D.U., and Donald Roberts, M.D.
-

27
28
Page 3 of 4

LYNN M.HANSEN,ESQ.
Nevada Bar No. 000244
415 S. Sixth St., Suite 100
Las Vegas, Nevada 89101
Attorneys for Defendants
University Medical Center of
Southern Nevada; The Board of Trustees of
University Medical Center ofSouthern
Nevada and Kathleen Silver

Case 2:08-cv-00863-MMD-GWF Document 730 Filed 03/06/15 Page 4 of 6

CASE NO. 2:08-cv-OQ863-RC1-GWF
CON50LlDAT£D WITI-I:
CASE NQ. 2;09-cv-41G79-RCJ-GWP'

l

CHRISTENSEN, M.D.; JOHN FILDES; M.D.; CHARLES BLOOM, M.D.: MARIETTA
NELSON, M.D.; KSHAMA DAPHTARY, M.D.; ]OI~N ONYEMA, M.D.; BEVCRLY

3

NEYLAND, M.D.; ALBERT CAPANNA, M.D.; VICTOR GRIGOR]EV, M.D.; LAURA

4

BILODEAU, M.D.; MICHAEL CASEY, M.D.; STEVEN BECKER, M.D.; THOMAS HUNT,

5

M:D.; CRAIG IWAMOTO, M.D.; DAN[CL KIRGAN, M.D.; D~BORAN KUHLS, M.D.;

6

TERRY LEW1S, M.D.; FREDERICK LIPPMANN, M.D.: DIANNC MAZZU, M.D.; JINN

7

McCOURT, M.D.; PAUL STEWART, M.D.; THOMAS VATER, M.D.: MEENA VOHRA,

8

M.D. and CRAIG V05S, M.D. by and through their counsel of record, WALTER CANNON,

9

ESQ. of Olson Cannon Gormley Angula & Stoberski, and Defendant UNIVERS]TY MEDICAL

10

CENTER OF SOUTHERN NEVADA,by and through Counsel SCOTT .R. COOK,ESQ., of tf~e

11

law firm Kolesar & Leatham, hereby stipulate and agree to Dismiss the above-entitled action,

1Z

with Prejudice, each party to bear their own fees and costs incurred I~erein.

13

DATED this ~~day ofDecember,2014.

N

r
c

x ~~h
9C M1

a o u tr. l4 ~ RAFTER LAW
~>
°23 mz~
~~~G l5
~m``
4 ~d
- ~--~n E
'
By
w~ G
JACO HAFT~R, CSQ.
a ,~ 16
o ~ ~.
a
9l 1 N Buffalo Drive, Suite 209
o
v
~7
F
Las V gas, Nevada 89128
Attom ys for Plaintiff
18

.fin

19

DATED this ~3

20

MANDELBAUM ELLER

,aoc5

day of

DATED this

day ofDecember,2034.

JIMMERsQN H.ANSEN

&ASSOCIATES

21
By

B
22
23
24
?~
26

1. M NDELB
,ESQ.
Nevada Bar No. 000318
2012 Hamilton Lane
Las Vegas, Nevada 89106
Attorneys Far Defendants
The Meclica! and De»lal Slaffof U~~iversity
Aledical Ce~Tle1•, JohrT Ellerto~r, ADD.;
A~arvi» J. Bey»stein, AID.; Dale Car~~iso~~,
D.O.; nlzd Da~aulc~ Roberts, h1D.

27
28
Page 3 of4

LYNN M.HANSCT~I,ESQ.
Nevada Bar No. X00244
415 S. Sixth St., Suite l00
Las Vegas, Nevada 89101
Attorneys for Defendants
U►Tiversiry 11~Iedica! Center of
Sotriliern Ne~7nda; Tl~e Board of Trirslees of
U~ti>>ersity ll~ledical Ce~71er ofSoutherly
Nevada arrd Kathleen Silver•

Case 2:08-cv-00863-MMD-GWF Document 730 Filed 03/06/15 Page 5 of 6

CASE NO. 2:08-cv-008b3-RCJ-GWP
CONSOLIDATED WITH:
CASE NO. 2:09-cv-O 1 G79-RCJ-GWP

1

CHRISTCNSEN, M.D.; JO1HN F1LDE5; M.D.; CHARLES BLOOM, M.D., MARIETTA
NELSON, M.D.; KS~-IAMA DAPHTARY, M.D.; JOl-iN ONYEMA, M.D.; BEVCRLY

3

NEYLAND, M.D.; ALBERT CAPANNA, M.D.; VICTOR GRIGOR]EV, M.D.; LAURA
BIL~DEAU, M.D.; MICHAEL CASEY, M.D.; STGVCN BECICER, M.D.; THOMAS HUNT,

5
6

McCOURT, M.D.; PAUL STEWART, M.D.; THOMAS VATER, M.D., MLENA VOHRA,

8

M.D. and CRAG VOSS, M.D. by and througI~ their counsel of record, WALTER CANNON,

9

ESQ. of Olson Cannon Gormley Angulo & Staberski, and Defendant UN]VERS]TY MEDICAL

10

CENTER OF 50UTHERN NEVADA,6y and through Counsel SCOTT R. COOK,L-SQ., of the

11
C
Q Y

TERRY LEWIS, M.D.; FREDERICK LIPPMANN, M.D.: DIANNC MAZZU, M.D.; .IOI-~N

7

N
n
'7
C
M

M.D.; CRAIG IWAMOTO, M.D.; DANIEL KIRGAN, M.D.; DCBORAN ~UHLS, M.D.;

law firm Kaiesar & Leatham, hereby stipulate and agree to Dismiss tl~e above-entitled action,

~ •~

with Prejudice, each party to bear their awn fees and costs incurred herein.

-ir,n

~~~~ 13

¢ —°~=
i _

DATED this ~~day ofDecember, 20]4.

C

y ~~ =
Gi

e u
,
„ oz
o
_o

]4

=~
Q ~u ~ 15
~ ~s
ac.;~ 16
O ~'

xT

~ 17
F
18

HA~"TER LAW

JACO RAFTER, CSQ.
9]I N Buffalo Drive, Suite 209
Las V gas, Nevada 8912$
Aitorn vs for Plaintiff

~~,.~ ~IS

19

DATED this

?p

MANDELBAUM ELLERTON &ASSOCIATES

JIMMERSON HANSEN

~y_

By

day of December,20I 4

DATED this~day of~~ ~~',
;

?~
22
23
24
25
26

KIM 1. MANDELBAUM,ESQ.
Nevada Bar No. OOd3]8
2Q12 Hamilton Lane
Las Vegas, Nevada 89106
Attorneys for Defendants
The Nledicol a~td De~1ta1 S(affof U~7nlelsity
Aledical Ce~7te1•, Jal~~1 Ellerto►r, A~I.D.;
ll~n1-vi» J. Bel•1Tstein, A~I.D.; Dale Carriso~~,
D.O.; and Do»ald Roberts, h~I.D.

27
?g
Pale 3 of4

LYNN M.HANSCN,ESQ. ~~~1
_
Nevada Bar No.000244
T
415 S. Sixth St., Suite l00
Las Vegas, Nevada 89101
Attorneys for Defendants
U~rive~•sit~~ A~Iedical Ce1~le~• of
Sottlhern Ne~rada; Tl~e Board of Ti•iislees of
U~titi~er-siey lYledical Custer ofSo2rt/7err~
Nevada a~ad Aatl~lee~~ Sih~er•

Case 2:08-cv-00863-MMD-GWF Document 730 Filed 03/06/15 Page 6 of 6

CASE X10. 2:Q8-cv-008G3-RCJ-GWF
CONSOLIDATED WITH:
CASE NO. 2;Q9-cv-01679-RG-GWF

3~k~~'
I~A7'LL3 this

~ ~,,,G,, da}~ c~i'~

[JA'J'L-:L7 this 15 day of p~ee~~ber; 2014.
~

R]
UL~~N CAN?VON GOR]VI~EY t~,NGULC18t

~.

K~L1~SAR & X.,EA

Dy:

I3y:
SC~T'T R. COOK,ESQ.
Nevada l~arNa. QQS265
4D0 S. Kampart ~Ivd., ~uiie COQ
Las Vegas, NV $914

ALTER R..
ON,FSQ.
ev~da [far N . ~1Q1 OS
7
8

AM

N~:vada f3ar N 00 72
Avenue
9950 W. Choy ~
~,as Vedas, N 891?9

Attorneys far 17efenciant
1~1~fi~er.sil~~ ~R~I~dier~f Cc~ialer
a/'Sor.rthe~-ry IVevarla
(E~cess Carrier)

Attorneys fc~r Doctor Da;fendants
I'nul ~arTdl, .lint Ch1'islensen, ,Iti1t~t Tildes,
Chai•!es Bbanr, ~l~lnrieltn Nelso~~, Kslia~~u~
Orryemn, Beverl}~
Dapl~ra~}~, Jo1m
Neyland,
Albert
Co~~m~nn,
Dicta•
Grr~vrieu, Lniu~n Diludenar, ~Ylichnel
Case~~, Steven Decker, Tholl~as fltu~~,
C1•ai~ ha~rn~rot~, Daniel h'irgcm, Deborah
Ktrhls, Tc~•i~r Lc~~vis, F~~edet-ick Liprin~ni~r~,
Dicmt7e Mn.~r, Jcl~r~ h~IcCc~u1~1, Faar!
Sletivrn•t, TJtUl~rrrs f~n~er~ Aleenir Jtollra af~rl
~rarg= t%oss

zT ~s so oxuEu~n.
DATE17: March 6, 2015
f9
20

UNITEA STATES DISTRICT JUDGE

21
22
23
24
25
26
?~
?g
Pugs 4 of4