Davis v. Clark County Detention Center et al
Filing
14
ORDER that the Clerk of Court shall file the Complaint. Plaintiff's Complaint is DISMISSED without prejudice for failure to state a claim upon which relief may be granted. Amended Complaint to be filed within 30 days of this Order. Plaintiffs motion 12 for a temporary restraining order and his motion 13 for a preliminary injunction both are DENIED. Signed by Judge Robert C. Jones on 8/3/10. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - ECS, forms to plaintiff)
- . .-- . --. -
E
.
..
)
'
.
-.
t(y . 2
: â
.. ., e
F..... ... ' . ..
3 !' . .: -
.L J
.
.. ,
,
..
1
2 3
4
5
:
.
.
'i ' '. . .
f :
'
6 7
U N IT ED STA TE S D ISTR IC T CO U R T D ISTR IC T O F N EV A D A
8 KEVI SCOTT D A V I , N S
9
10 11 vs.
Pl i t. an ;ï j
2: 9- v 021 6- CJLRL 0 c- 9 R ORDER
C LA RK COUN TY D ETEN TIO N CENTER, 12 etal, .
1 3
14
Dee da t. f n ns
Thi prsonercii rght acton comes bef r t e Cour f ri ialr vi w under28 si vl i s i oe h t o nt e e i
1 5
1 U. . .j 1 1 A a wel o plitf mo in ( 1 )f ra t mpor r r s r iig or era d 6 S C 9 5 s las n an i s t # 2 o e f o a y e ta nn d n 1 mo in ( 1 ) o a pr l iar ij ncin. 7 to # 3 f r e i n y nu t m o
1 8
Davis v. Clark County Detention Center et al
Scr eni g en W hen a ' rsonerseek r dr ss f om a gover m ent l iy orofi erorem pl yee of 'i p se e r n a entt fc o
Doc. 14
1 9
20 a gover m ent lentt , t e c ur m ust'dentf c gni abl cl i s ordi m i s t e com pl i t n a iy ' h o t ' ' i iy o z e a m ssh an ,
21 oranyporinoft e c mpl itit ecomplit ( )i fiol us,mal ius,orf i t stt a t o h o an ,f h an : 1 s rv o io c al o ae s 22 cli uponwhih r le maybegr nt d;or( )seek monet r r leffom a def ndantwho am c e if ae 2 s a y ei r e
2 i i m u efom s c r l f' 28 U, . , 1 1 A( ) 3 s m n r u h ei , e SC j 9 5 b.
24 I consi erng whet er t e pl i tf has st t d a cl i upon w hi h r l f can be n di hh an i f ae am c ei e
25 gr nt d,aI mat ralf ct alal gatons i t e com pl i tar accept d as tue f rpur oses ae I ei a u li e nh an e e ro p 26 ofi ii lr vi w and ar t be c nstued i t e I htmostf vor bl t t e pl i t#, See, . . n ta e e eo or nh i g a a e o h an i eg ,
2 Ru s lv. an r u, F.d 1 37, 03 ( t Ci. 9 0) Ho e er mer Ig l on lson 7 s el L d i 621 2 0 1 9 9h r 1 8 . w v , e e a c cu i s e
28 uns ppoded by any act alal gatons off ctar notassumed t be tue i r vi w ig t e u u li e a e o r nee n h
Dockets.Justia.com
1 c m pl i t A s cr f v, qbal o a n . h ot I t
U, . S
,129 S. t 1937,1949- 1 & 1 54,1 3 L. d. d 868 C. 5 9 7 E2
2 ( 00 ) Th ti,ba e,n k d an c n ls r a s rin t a me ey c n tu e f r uli 2 9 . a s r a e d o cu o y s e t s h t r l o si t o m a c o t
3 r ciatons of t e el m ent of a cause of ac i n and t at ar devoi off rher f ct al e ti h e s to h e d ut au 4 enhancementar notaccept d as tue and do n ts at a cf i f rr l f I . e e r o t e a m o ei . d e
5 Fur her t e f ct al l gatons m ust at a pl us bl cl i f rr l f m eani g t att e t , h a u al ei st e a i e am o e i e nhh
6 wel- l adedf c smustper it ecour t i f rmor t ant e mer possi ii ofmi c nduct lp e at m th to n e eh h e b ly t so :
7
8 9
1 0 11
(J c mplit mu t c q an s fce t f c u l mat r A o ao n s o t i j f in a t q n i tj ç a da tuyj c oat a.cyxlomtjreIefth ij uIe nt s re t st e s l m ol I ,; as as lO , j fc pBelAta c yp. acot l l ae e ce L j ,5 gS y ,5; jg yS y . . 4b 1
.
p uil ,hnt6 lEipe92cu,Acntaalil SCs951e ,ep .d d9d(0tacnathtfcs lt15 w94h 7Lnf l sa7/oti slF . . iy 7 1 a t2 2 f0) lm a a a bi t if q e o
t e c ur t dr w t e r asonabI I f r nce t att e def ndantI h o to q h e e nee hh e s I bl f qt e ml c nduct l ged.d.at i e q h so a al e / , 556,1 7 S. t 1955.The 2 C. gl usi lt s andar i notakl t a d gbabii r quiem ent'but a bly t l ds no ' pr ly e r t '
I a k f rmoe tq a s e rpo sblt tatadee d n h s t s s o r h n h e s l ly h i fn a i a
jce una f l .bl .W he e a c mplltpla sf cst a a e t d lw jl I d y r o qn e d a t h t r
1 2
1 3
1 4
m er l c nslt ntwihnM def ndants I bit ,i N t ps shod of çy o se t e ' l ly t s o ai t : Ipe bet een possi lt and pl us bit of jenttem entt hl w bly i a i ly i ll o
1 5
r l f' l. a 5 7 1 7 S, t 1 5 ( r c e somie ) el ,H d , t 5 , 2 C . 9 5 b a k t t d . e t ( qer t ewel- ladedf qt donotger it ecour W h eh lpe p? m th ' t t if l mor tan t e rer posslll of mlconduc te o ne eh h pe bly t s th
,. ..
1 6
l 8
IetlhsljF-.u CvPo. n(w thp dr 9mpltorlfeebRtaitsojj-tatelae s ntnt el.dduI solhwa2. e o ldaae, tl n rc8 ') ii ae e e h. h
Al gatons ofa pr se I i antar hel t I s sti gen s andar s t an ar f r al li e o ig t e d o e s rn t t dh e om
1 I bal 1 9 S. t at1949- 0. 7 q ,2 C. 5 1 pl adigs by lw yer . Hai es v Ker er 4O4 U. .519,520,92 S. t 594,596,30 L. d. d 9 en a s n . n, S C. E2
2 65 ( 9 2) 0 2 17 .
21 I t e compl i t pl i tf Kevi Scot Davi seek compensat r damages agai s nh a n , a n if n t s s oy nt
22 m uli l def n ant i t ei i di i ual tp e e d s n h r n v d and ofi i l fc a capaciy on m uli l c ai s arsi g f om hi t tp e l m in r s
2 crm i alpr secuton i LasVegas and hi det nton att e Cl r Count Det n i n Cent r 3 in o in s ei h ak y e to e. 24 The Cour addr s es each counti t r , t es n un
25 CountI
26
I Count1 pl i tf seek damages fom assst ntpubl def nderJason Tr ut , he n , a n if s r ia ie c a ht
2 Cl r Count PublcDef ndersOfie, Assit n Cl r Count Manager e#W el bas d 7 ak y ie ' f and c sa t a k y l le s
28 on al gat ns t at pl i tf was deni d efectve assi t nce of c unseli hi r centst t li eo h a n if e fi sa o n se ae
-
2-
1 crmi alpr ceedi g. The c m pl i t aleges t at pl i tl ent r d a pl a and has been in o n o an l h a ni ee e
2 s nt nc d. The com pl i tdoes notalege t att e convi ton has been overur ed . eee an l hh ci tn
3
Count 1does not pr s nt a cogni abl cl i under Sec i n 1983 under Hec v. ee z e am to k
4 Hu phry, 2U. , 77, 4S. t23 4, 29L. d.d 3 3( 9 4) Un e Hec , cai t at m e 51 S 4 11 C . 6 1 E 2 8 1 9 . d r k a l m h
5 neces arl i ples t e i val iy ofa s at cour convi ton m ay notbe cons der d i a ci i s i m i h n it y d te t ci ien vl
6 r hs a t n u ls an u t t ejdgme to c nvc in i ivaia e , ih pan i d e i t ci ne s d n i h u g o l n f o it s n l t d whc lit f o s o d f
7 notal ge and appar nty cannotal ge hasoccured wih r gar t t e r centc nviton. l e el l e r t e doh e o ci
8 Bec use t e cl i i not cogni abl i t e fr t i s ance,t e Cour has no occasi n t a h am s z e n h is n t h t oo 9 consi erw het erst t acton can be est blshed on t e cl i agai s t e assi t ntpubl d h ae i ai h am n th sa i c 1 def nderwho r pr sent d pl i tf and/ rw het er pl i t fhas al ged a sufi i ntf c ual 0 e ee e a n if o h an i f l e fc e a t
11 basi f rI biiy agai stt e r m ai i g def ndan s on Count1 so i l at n h e nn e t . 1 2 1 3 Count1 1 Count1spansei ht ensi gl - paced pagesandas ersa muliudeof l ged Ei ht 1 ge n es st tt al e gh
1 Amendmentcai sas ocit dwi pl itf sdet ntonat he Cl r Count Det ntonCent r 4 lm s a e t a n ir h ei t ak y ei e,
1 The counti cl des cl i s t atpl i tf w as deni d bai ort atexcessi e bai was r quied' 5 nu am h a n if e lh v l e r,
1 t athe was denid emer ency car f l w i g hi arest t athi pr scrpton m ediatons, 6h e g e o l n s r 'h o , s e ii ci 1 i cl di goxycodone, 7 nun Soma, ndXanax, econfscat ddurng i t k ' hathewasnot ven a wer ie i n a e, t gi
1 t e pr per m edi aton durng hi det xfcaton and w ihdr w alf om opi t s't at he w as 8h o ci i s o ii i ta r ae ,h
1 r quied t make up hi bed, and i a f od Ine and eatata di i g t bl whi under oi g 9ero s st no i nn a e l e gn 20 wihdr w alt athe was pl ced i puniie confnem enteven bef r r cei i g a wrt up' hat t a 'h , a n tv i o e e vn ie , t 21 he was moved t a di er ntuni t cr at space i t e medi aluni; hathe was onl gi en o #e to e e nh c tt yv
22 an EKG when he com pl i ed ofches pai ,headaches,passi g outand backII g and hi an tn n e p
23 pai ;t at hi s iur swer not agnosed and he was notpr vi ed pr perm ediaton' hat nh s ez e e di od o ci, t 24 pr perchannel wer noti pl ce f rr questng teat ent t athewasnoti f r ed ofx r y o se na oe i r m ;h no m -a 25 r suls;t at he agai was moved t a dif r n uni;t at t er was a l ck of pr per eth n o fe e t t h h e a o 26 adm i itaton ofmedi als r ies and gener ldi or aniaton't athe was notpr t c ed nsr i c e vc a s g z i ,h oe t
2 fom ij rn hms ld r gs iu e 'ha h wa mo edt as iiewa c c l t a h wa 7 r nu ig i ef u i ez r s, t e s v o ucd t h el h t e s n t ; 28 notpr vied a r commended CT scan't ata kt r gar ig awrstij r was n tpr pery od e ,h ie e d n i nu y ool
-
3-
1 r sponded t ; hathe was i pr pery deni d m et adone' hathe was notpr vi ed a pr per e ot mol e h , t od o
2 splntf rhi wrstij r ;hathewasdenidopit pai mediaton'hatt er wasno pol y i o s i nu y t e ae n ci, he t i c
3 i pl ce t pr t ctdet i ees fom abuse, n a o oe an r negl c and r ckl s ness' hat her w as no f low et e es , tte ol 4 t r ugh as t a spoti hi I ng s ow n on an x- ay; hatTyl nol3, hi h i cl des an opi t , ho o n su h rt e -w c nu ae 5 was notavai bl orwas notpr vi ed t hi atvarous pi cal ; hatbl od pr s ur checks le a od o m i l lt ls o es e 6 wer notpr vi ed as fequenty as or er d aferhe w as di gnosed w ih hyperensi n' hat e od r l de t a t t o, t 7 t er was no pol y i pl ce t ensur t at one doct rs or er c ul not be over i den he ina c o eh o' d s o d rd
8 wi outj s c use;t att e medialuniwast o col ;t att e shower wer to col;tat t h ut a hh c t o dh h s eo dh
9 bl od was dr w n f om i m at s on t e sam e t bl s fom whi h t ey at ; hatno exer i e w as o a rne h aer ch et cs
1 pr vi ed ; hatpl i tf w as unabl t go t chur h,s hool al ohol s anonym ous m eetngs 0 od t a n if eo o cc ,c i c i l ornar otcs anonym ous m eetngs,and t att e m edi aluni w as uns niar because si k 1 ci i hh c t a ty c 1 i m at s wer vom ii g and urnatng aI overt e uni. 2ne e tn ii I h t
1 3
1 4
Cou t1 i s be tt mutpede ii n is n 1s u j c o l l fce ce . i
Fis ,puti g t e bai cl i t one si e f rt e m om ent t e Ei ht Am endm entdoes rt tn h l am o doh ,h gh
1 notappl t cl i s br ughtby pr t i l ai ees r gar i g condii ns ofconfnem ent The 5 y o am o e ra det n e dn to i . 1 c ns iu i nalpr t ctons avai bl t det i ees r gar i g t ei condii ns ofconfnem ent 6 o tt to oe i l eo a an e dn h r to i 1 i s ead arse undert e Due Pr cess Cl use oft e Foureent Am endm ent al ough t e 7 nt i h o a h t h ,t h h 1 Foudeent Am endm ent pr vi es no I ss pr t cton t an t e Ei ht Am endm ent i t i 8 h od e oe i h h gh n hs
1 c nt x. See, . , Or gonAdv c c Centrt Mik,322 F.d 11 1, 12O ( t ci.2003) 9 o et eg, e oay et n 3 O1 9h r .
20 Sec nd,under LocalRul LS R 2- jpl i t; m ust use t e C our' r quied Secton o e 1 an i h ts e r i 21 1983 f r t s at hi cl i s,and he m ustf l w t e i s r ctons f rt atf r i doi g so. o m o t e s am o l h n tu i o o h om n n 22 The i st uc i ns cl ary st t , w ih t e f l w i g em phas s: H O U MAY ALLEG E THE n r to e l ae t h ol n o iY 23 V I LA TI N O F O N LY O N E CI I RI H T PER C O U N T . Pl i tf m ay not as he has done O O VL G ' a n if ' , 24 i Count I,asser m uli l c vi rght vi l tons underone count even i t ey al gedl al n I t tp e i l i s o a i , fh l e yl 25 arse under one cons iutonal am endm ent He i s ead m us ass r one c nstt tonal i tt i . nt t et o iu i 26 vi l ton per c unt o ai o, 27 Thid, r Count1 con ai s m uli l r f r nces diec i g t e r ader o ' ee'varous i t ke 1 tn tp e e e e r tn h e t s ' i na 28 r cor s, edi al ecor s, ies orot erm at ral .Pl i tf m ust at hi cons iutonal ai s e d m c r d kt h e i s a n if st e s tt i cl m
-
4-
1 w ihi t e body oft e c m pl i tis l w ihoutsuch gener lr f r nces t ot erdocum ent . tnh h o an tef t a eee oh s 2 The alegatons w ihi t e body of t e c m pl i t m ust s at a cl i . I t ey do not li tn h h o an te am f h ,
3 gener l ed r f r nces t ot erdocument wi notsave t e compl itfom di m isal ai z eee oh sl l h an r ss .
4 Fourh, ai tf m ust ak specii alegatonsast t e i vol em ent each def ndan t pl n if me fc l i oh n v of e t 5 wihi t e body oft e com pl i ton eac cl i . Repeat dl ,pl i t# r f r t a num berof tn h h an h am e y an i e e s o
6 def ndant wih r spec t a pariul rdat and t en i cl des specii al gatons as t an e ste to tc a e h nu fc l i e o
7 act orom i si n by onl one or possi l t o oft e def ndant . O n each cl i ,as t each so y by w h e s am o
8 def ndantsued on t atcl i ,pl i t; mustal ge speciialy whateach def ndantdi or e h am ani l e fc l e d
9 f i d t do t atcaused hi har wih r gar t t atcl i . al o e h m m t e doh am 1 0 Fit ,t e Cl r Count Det nton Cen eri nota vi bl def ndant The C l r Count fh h ak y ei ts ae e . ak y
1l Det nton Cent ri a bui ig.Plit; c nsuea nat r lperon oraj rdialper onsuch ei es ln d an i a ua s ui c s
1 as a cor or ton or a m uni i al y. He m ay notsue,however a bui i g ora c r ectonal 2 p ai cp i t , ln d or i
1 f ciiy,whih i notaj rdialperonsubectt sui. 3 al t cs ui c s jot
1 4 Si t ,t e bai cl i under Count 1 - whi h i assered agai st t e C l r Count xh h l am 1 cs t nh ak y
1 Det nton Cen er- t us i notassered agai s a vi bl def ndant Baii any eventi set 5 ei t hs t nt a e e . ln s
1 by a cour , by t e det nton cent r 6 t not h ei e. 1 7 Seven h,on pl i tf s m uliudi ous dif r nt cl i s r gar i g hi m edi alcar i t a n ir tn t fe e am e dn s c en 1 Count I,t e al gatons pr sent d f i t s at a cl i upon whi h r l f m ay be gr nt d , 8 Ih l i e e e al o t e am c ei e ae 1 Count 1 i pr sent d as a near dai di l of t e m edi alc r pr vi ed t pl i tf at t e 9 1s e e l a' y y h c ae o d o a n if h 20 f cit . Atvarous poi t i t e r c t l pl i tl assers sundr varatons oft e concl sor a ly i i n s n h e ia , a n i t y ii h uy
21 i cant ton:' elber t i di er nc t aserousmedi al n ai d i a e n # e e o D i c need and pai and suferng. Such n fi ' ' 2 t lsm ani r ciatonsoft eel m ent ofa cause ofactonf it st t a cl i f rr l f I bal 2 ai ce ti he s i a lo a e a m o e i . q , e 23 supr .Rat er i or ert st t acl i f rr leff r el er t i dif r nce t serousmedi al a h ,n d o a e a m o e i o d i a e n fe e b oi c 24 needs, ai tf m ust esentact al l gatonst ndi gt es ablsht at hedef ndantoii i l pl n if pr f u al e i e no t i ht e ca 2 knew ofand di r gar ed an exc s i e rskt i m at healh orsaf t . See, , . Si m ons F, 5 se d e sv i o n e t ey e g, m
26 Nav j Count, iona, ao y Arz
F.d 3
, 2010W L2509181, * (une23, at 4 J 2010) Theofiil . fca
27 b0t mustbe awar oft e f c sfom whi ht e if r nce ofan excessi e rskt i m at healh h e h at r c h nee v i on e t
28 orsaf t coul be dr w n, ey d a and he al o m us dr w t e i f r nce. I . I ot erwor s, pl i t; s t a h ne e dnh d a a ni
-
5-
1 mus s o tat h ofcal s 'a)s becieyawa e o t e s r usmedia n ed a d ( ) t h w h t e fii wa ( u j t l v r f h ei o cl e n b 2 f ied adequat l t r s ond. I . ( uotng proraut ort ,wih emphasi i orgi al. al ey o e p ' d , q i i ' h iy t s n in )
3 M edialmidi gnosi ,dif r nces i m edialopi i n,medi almal r c i e, c sa s fe e n c no c p a tc and negl ence i g
4 do notam oun t delber t i dif r nce. Seey . . M cG ucki ? Sm i , t o i a e n fe e e g, n , t 974 F. d 1050,1 59 h 2 0
5 ( t Ci.992) r v' on oter gr unds,W MX Tec . l c.v.Mier 1O4 F.d 11 3 ( t 9 h r1 , e d h o h,n l, l 3 3 9h 6 Ci.9 7)e ? nc ' nc e v W/, F.d24 , 4142 ( t Ci.98 ) r1 9 (r ba j Sa h z . d 891 2 0 2 - 9 h r1 9 . ,
7 The alegatons i Count 1 f i t s at a cl i i t i r gar . For ex m pl , li n 1 al o t e a m n hs e d ae
8 confscatng pr scrpton m edi aton, ii e ii c i especi l opi t s, r m a det i ee on bei g pl ced i t a l a e fo y an na no
9 a ji cea l do s n tvilt t e Co si t n. Nord e t e mer f c tata h al c r al l ry e o o ae h n t u i to osh e ath e t ae h
1 pr vi erdeni s opit st a det i ee who, 0 od e ae o an underpl i tf' own al gatons, cl aropi t a n ifs l i has e e ae
1l dependence i sues c nstt t del er t i dif r nce t a serous m edi al s o iu e i a e n fe e b o i c need - r gar l s - e de s 1 ofw het er anot er healh car pr vi er i si e orout i e of t e i stt ton pr s rbed t e 2 h h t e od nd sd h n iu i e ci h 1 opi t s. 3 ae 1 4 l t i sam e vei , any of he m edi alssues aleged i C ount1 ar l r el unr l t d. n hs nm t ci l n 1 e a g y e ae 15 Forexam pl , he f i r t pr vi e opi t m edi aton i unr l t d t a f i r t f low t r ugh e t al e o o d u ae c i s eae o a l e o ol h o u 1 wih a r c m m endaton t peror a CT s an as t a spoton pl i t fs I ng, Pl i tf shoul 6 t eo i o ïm c o an i u f a n if d
1 s tf rh t e s par t cl i s as t separ t aleged deni l of me i alc r i separ t 7 e o t h e a e am o ae l as dc a e n ae
1 count wihf ct al l gatonsfom whih t e above- escrbed i f r nc s c n be dr w n, 8 s t a u ale i r ch d i ne e e a a as 1 t each def ndantnamed i each count Pl i tf s oul f c son s atng a cl i ast each 9o e n . a n if h d o u ti am o 20 dif r ntmedialssue ast whi hhe seeksr l fr t ert an pr vi ig a mer chr nolgial fe e ci oc ei a h h e o dn e o oc
21 dai s m m ar o hi m edi alcar att e C l r C oun y D e enton C ent r lu y yf s c eh ak t ti e. 22 Countll I
23
CountIIcombi es t r e dif r ntc t gores ofcl i s. Pl i tf,agai ,mus asser 1 n h e fe e a e i am a n if n t t
24 one cons iutonalvi l ton percountand he may n tas er mulpl ci i rght vi l tons tt i oai o s t t e vl i s oa i i
25 underone count .
26
Fist pl i tfalegest atr m Nov m ber1 , r , a n if l h fo e 6 2007,hr ughM ar h 3O, to c 2009,t o J hn wo
27 Doe def ndant and def ndantAssst ntCl r Count ManagerJef W el vi l t d hi rght e s e ia ak y f l oae s i s 28 t due pr ces .He al gest att eydi so ever day t atpl i tf coul notI ave LasVegas o os l e hh d y h a n if d e
-
6-
1 due t a cour or er or erng hi t check i f r pr t i lsupew i i n once a week as a o td di mo n o e ra so
2 condii n ofhi r l ase fom cust dy due t t e al gedl wr ngl -i d char es i t e st t to s ee r o oh l e y o y fl e g n h ae 3 crm i alpr s cuton. Alegatons onl t at pl i tf had t r por t pr ti lsuper ii n in oe i li yh a n if o e t o e ra vs o
4 pur uantt a cour or er as a c ndii n of r l as do notst t a vi bl cl i as t t ese s o td o to ee e ae a e am oh 5 def ndant .Pl i t f l ges no per onal nvol em entbyW elsor he ot erdef ndant gi i g e s an i a l fe s iv lt h e s vn
6 rs t I biiy. Furher underHeck,pl i tf may notseekdamagesf ra cust di l estait ie o i l at t, a n if o o ar rn
7 pur uantt a st t c ur or ert athas notpr vi usl been setasi e. s o ae o t d h eo y d
8
Second,pl i tf i t e mai r ppat t e al gatons fom Count 1chal ngi g t e a n if n h ne sh l i e r l nh e
9 c m pet nc ofhi r pr sent ton by t e count publ def nders ofi e i hi st t crm i al o ey se e ai h y ie c ' fc n s a e i n 1 pr secuton. Fort e r asons di cussed as t Count 1 t es al gatons f i t s at a 0 o i he s o ,h e l i e al o t e 11 c gniabl cl i and ar bared by Heck. o z e am er 1 2 Thid,pl i t# seeks t r asser t e muliudi ous al gatons ofCoun 1 i gl bo r an i oe th tt n li e t 1n o 1 i st ad alo asa vi l ton oft e Due Pr cessCl use oft e Foureent Amendment W hi 3 ne s oa i h o a h th . l e
1 pl i tf t us seeks t pr pery i voke t e Foudeent Am endm ent r t er t an t e Ei ht 4 a n if h o o ln h h ah h h gh 1 Am endm ent t e i c r or t d alegatons f i t s at a cl i f r r l f f r t e r m ai i g 5 ,h n o p ae l i alo t e am o ei o h e n n e 1 r asons di cussed underCount I. 6e s I l 7 Accor i gl , he f r goi g c nsi er d as t t e C ount I hr ugh 11 t e c m pl i t i dn y t o e n o d e oh sto 1, h o a n w l l
1 b dimis d wi ou p eu ie,s bec t a op orunt t fl a amen e c mpa n 8 e s s e t t rj dc u j t o n p t i o i n h y e d d o lit
1 corec i g t e defci nci s i t e orgi al 9 r tn h ie e n h i n com pl i t t t e ext ntpos i l , a n ,o h e sbe
20 Moton f rTempor r and Pr lm i ar Ij nctve Relef io ay ei n y n u i i 21 l temot n( 1 )o at m p r r r sr iigor er n mot n( 1 )o ap ei ia y nh i # 2 f r e o a y e tann d a d i # 3 f r r l n r o o m 22 ijncin,pl itf seeks wie-angig t mpor r and pr lm iar ij nctve r l fas t nu to a n i f dr n e ay ei n y nu i e i e o
23 c ndii ns ofconfnem entnotatCl r Count D et nton Cen erbu i s ead atHi h Desed o to i ak y ei t tn t g
2 St t Pr on (Hih Des r'. He s ek a or er ltrai, r c ig ' DSP't p y frhs 4 ae i ' g s e t) ' e s n d ,h e l di t ' a en H oa o i
25 pos age and cop wor char es i chal ngi g al gedl iegal sci lnar char es agai st t yk gn lnl e e yl l di p i y g n
26 hi ;bari g t e i posii n ofany f rherdi ci l ar sanctons agai s pl i tf untlt e m rn h m to ut s pi y n i n t a n if i h
27 prson' dici lnar pr cedur sar decl r dI galr s r i i g ' DSP' r m char i g pl i tf i s s pi y o ee a e e ' e ta n n H , fo g n a n if 28 i anywayf rc pywor orpost ge asa r suloft ealegedl il gal sci lnar pr cedur s; n oo k a eth l y le di p i y o e
-
7-
1 r stai i g ' D S P'fom feezi g hi i m at account or erng f rherdi gnostc t s i g by e r nn ' H 'r r n sn e , ' d i ut a i e tn 2 m edi al per onnelout i e of t e prs n'or erng an i m edi t r fl of t e m edi atons c s sd h io , d i m a e e il h ci 3 pr scrbed pror t hi ar es ,i cl di g t e opi t s'or erng t athe be tanspored t t e ei i o s rtnu n h ae , d i h r t oh
4 out ie pai managementdoct rt atpr scrbed t e opi t s prort hi arest or erng t at sd n oh ei h ae i o s r ; d i h 5 hi pr scrptons be fl d by an ou si e phar acy untlarangem ent ar made f ra prson s e ii il e td m ir se o i 6 phar ac 'or eran appoi t entwih Cl r Count Soci lSer ies r gar i g hi medial m y, d nm t ak y a vc e d n s c
7 bil ;or erng an i m edi t tans erof pl i tf t a dif r ntcl ssii aton l veland t en, ls d i m ae r f a n if o fe e a fc i e h 8 afer hi m edi alt eat ent i sues ar r sol ed,t Sout er Deser Cor ectonalC en er t s crm s ee v o hn t ri t' ,
9 or erng t e r pl c m entoft o bl e shit t atpl itf had t ' odiy'due t t er bei g no d i h e ae wu rs h a n if o' f ' m oh e n 1 t i t paper and r i bur em ent of pl i t f f r t e char es f r t e shit ; or erng 0 ol e em s an i o h f g oh rs d i 11 r i bur em entofpl i tf f rt e t i tpapert athe had t buy att e prson s or ;or erng em s a n if o h o l e h o hi te d i 1 t atpl i tf be gi en diec physialaccess t t e prson I w Ibr r f rI galr sear h' 2h a n if v rt c oh i a i ay o e e c, 1 r s r i i g any t pe of ' ar ss ent't r ugh iegalcel sear hes or v r alor physial 3 e ta n n y h a m ' ho l l l c eb c
1 t r at 'r stai i g Corec i nalOfi erEverstfom ver al t r at ni g pl i tf orcom i g 4 h e s e r nn r to fc ir b l h e e n a n if y n 1 i t any t pe of cont ct w ih hi ;and r s r i i g ' D S P ' f om t y n t ' n l ence' t e 5 no y a tm e ta n n ' H 'r r i g o ' fu i 'h 1 m edi al r at entt atpl i tf r c i es wih s at m ent such as ' e' f ki g i, dnm at s ar 6 c te m h a n if e e v t te s h s a n t' ' 'i ee
1 notal wed t ese t pes ofmedi atons, and/ r' e' a dr g addit' 7 l o h y ci ' ' o hs u c. '
l 8 Plitfasserst at hasmovedf rem por r andpr l iar ij ncier l f' ow an if t h he ot ay ei n y nu tv ei n m e 1 onl becauseanoteri mat ( otaIw cer)t l pl it he mihtgethel t i way.#12, 9 y h n e n a l k od a ni ; g p hs '
20 at3,l es 9- 0, i n 1
21 2 2
The moton wilbe deni d f rs ver lr asons. i l e o e ae Fis ,t e c m pl itpr sen s cl i s agai stdef ndant i Cl r Count r gar i g rt h o a n e t a m n e s n ak y e dn
2 pl i tf' s at crm i alpr secuton i Cl r Count and t e c ndii ns ofhi confnem entat 3 an i s t e i n f o i n ak y h o to s i 24 Cl r Count Det nton Cent r The pl adi gs pr sent no cl i s r gar i g pl i tf s ak y ei e. en e am e dn a n ir 25 i car er ton atHi h Deser St t Prson, he hasnamed no def ndant i any capaciy n c ai g t a e i and e sn t
26 w ih r gar t t atf cit . The m er flng ofa c m pl i t pr s ntng som e cl i s agai st t e d o h a ly i e ii o an e e i am n
27 some def ndant as ofsome poiti tm e doesnotmak t i I wsui a cl arnghouse f ral e s n ni e hs a t ei ol
28
-
8-
l of aitfsdiput statmayars ter afer Plitlmaynotpurueamotonf rij ncie pl n ir s e h ie h e t . a ni s i o nu tv
2 r lefas t cl i s t atar notpr s nt d by t e pl adigs. ei o am h e ee e hen
3
4
Second,t ecompl iti anyeventseek monet r damages,notij nctve r l f h an n s ay nu i ei . e
Thid ,pl i tf has f ied t pr vi e t e verfcaton and cerii aton r quied under r a n if al o o d h ii i tc i e r f
5 Rue6 ( )1 o t eFed r l lso CiiPrc d r f rs ua c o at mp r r r sr iig l 5 b () fh e a Rue f vl o e u e o is n e f e o a y e tann
6 or erw ihoutbot notce t t e adv r e pary and an opporuniy t be hear . d t h i oh es t t to d 7 Fourh,pl i tf does notev n nam e a vi bl adver e paly i t e m otons t whom a t a n if e ae s ' nh t i o
8 t mpor r r sr iig or erand/ rpr l iar ijncin coul be dieced. Hih Deser e a y e tann d o ei n y nu to m d rt g t 9 St t Prs n i a corectonalfciiy,notavi bl def ndantt whom an ijncin may be ae io s ri al t ae e o nu to
1 diect d. 0 re
1l Fit ,plitf hasnotsat da col r bl cli ofir par bl ij r ast manyofhi fh an if te o a e a m re a e nu y o s 1 r quest f rij nctver l f Finga motonf rt mpor r ij ncie r l fbec useanot er 2e s o nu i ei . l ei i oe a y nu tv e i ea h 1 im ae toughtt atiwoul be agood ieadoesnotesabl h ir par bl ijr . 3 n th ht d d t i re a e nu y s 1 4 Sit ,heunderyigc mpl itcurentyi subec t dimisaloraiur t sat upon xh t l n o a n r l s j to s s f f l e o t e
1 w hi h r l fm ay be gr nt d. 5 c ei e ae 1 6 I TH ER EFO R E I O R D E R E D t att e Cl r ofC our shal fl t e com pl i t T S h h ek t li h e a n and t at h
1 t e compliti DI MI SED wihoutpr jdie f rf i r t st t a cli uponwhih r l f 7h an s S S t eu c o al e o a e am u c ei e 1 ma b gr ned,s bec t Ia e t a en wi i t it ( 0)d y o e ty o t i or e t 8 y e a t u j t o e v o m d t n hry 3 a s f n r f hs d r o h
1 c rectt e defci nces i t e compl it i pos i l . 9 or h ie i n h a n ,f s b e 20 I FURTHER I ORDERED t at on any such amended compl i tfl d,pl i tf shal T S h, an i e a n if l
21 c eary tte t e am ended c m pl i t as an am ended c m pl i t by pl ci g t e wor l l il h o an o an an h d 22 ' M E N D E D 'i m edi t l abov ' i i Ri ht Com pl i t on page 1 i t e cap i n and shal A 'm ae y e ' vl g s C a n' ' nh to l 23 pl ce t e dock t ah e num ber 2: 9- v- 2 1 6- C J- R L, , O c 0 9 R L above t e wor ' M EN D E D ' n t e space h d' A ih
2 f r' ase No. UnderLocal e LR 1 - anyamended c m pl i t ied mustbe compl t i 4 oC ' ' Rul 51 o a n fl ee n
25 isel w ihoutr f r nce t prorflngs. Thus,any alegatons,pari s,or r quest f r r l f tft eee o i ii li te e s o ei e
26 fom prorpaper t atar notc ri d f r ar i t e amended com pl i tno I ngerwilbe r i sh e a re o w d n h an o l 27 bef r t e Coud. oe h
28
-
9-
1 I FURTHER I ORDERED t atplitf smoton (/ 2)f rat m por f r sr iig T S h an ir i /1 o e ay e tann 2 or erand hi moton( 13)f ra pr lmiar ijncton bot ar DENI D. d s i# o e i n y nu i he E
3
5
The Cl r ofCoud shalpr vi e pl i tf wiha copyoft e compl itt get erw iht o ek l o d a n if t h an o h tw
I an am ended com pl i ti fl d i r sponse t t i or er,t e Cour wilscr en t e f a n s ie n e o hs d h tl e h
4 copi s ofa Sec i n 1983 c m pl i tf r and one copy oft e i stuc i ns f rsame. e to o an o m h n r to o 6 amended pl adi g bef r or erng any f rheracton i t i case. en oe d i ut i n hs
7 I pl i tf does not tm el m ai an am ended com pl i tt t e C l r f rfl g,a fnal f a n if iy l an o h e k o ii n i
8 jdgm entdimisigt i acton wilbe ener d.Ite amended complitdoes notc rect u s s n hs i l t e fh an or
9 t e defci nci s i en ii d i t i or erandot er ie does notst t acl i uponwhi h r lef h i e e d tfe n h s d h ws a e am c ei
1 may be gr nt d,asnaludgmentdimisig t i acin wilbe ent r d. 0 ae j s s n hs to l ee
1 1
12 l3 14 .
DATED:Thi 32 day ofAugust 2010. s ,
1 5
16
1 7 18 19 20
Unied St t t a
i t i tJudge s rc
22 23 24 25 26
28
-
10-
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?