Davis v. Clark County Detention Center et al

Filing 14

ORDER that the Clerk of Court shall file the Complaint. Plaintiff's Complaint is DISMISSED without prejudice for failure to state a claim upon which relief may be granted. Amended Complaint to be filed within 30 days of this Order. Plaintiffs motion 12 for a temporary restraining order and his motion 13 for a preliminary injunction both are DENIED. Signed by Judge Robert C. Jones on 8/3/10. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - ECS, forms to plaintiff)

- . .-- . --. -

E

.

..

)
'
.

-.
t(y . 2
: â
.. ., e

F..... ... ' . ..
3 !' . .: -

.L J

.

.. ,

,

..

1
2 3
4
5

:

.

.
'i ' '. . .

f :
'

6 7

U N IT ED STA TE S D ISTR IC T CO U R T D ISTR IC T O F N EV A D A

8 KEVI SCOTT D A V I , N S

9
10 11 vs.

Pl i t. an ;ï j

2: 9- v 021 6- CJLRL 0 c- 9 R ORDER

C LA RK COUN TY D ETEN TIO N CENTER, 12 etal, .

1 3
14

Dee da t. f n ns
Thi prsonercii rght acton comes bef r t e Cour f ri ialr vi w under28 si vl i s i oe h t o nt e e i

1 5

1 U. . .j 1 1 A a wel o plitf mo in ( 1 )f ra t mpor r r s r iig or era d 6 S C 9 5 s las n an i s t # 2 o e f o a y e ta nn d n 1 mo in ( 1 ) o a pr l iar ij ncin. 7 to # 3 f r e i n y nu t m o
1 8
Davis v. Clark County Detention Center et al

Scr eni g en W hen a ' rsonerseek r dr ss f om a gover m ent l iy orofi erorem pl yee of 'i p se e r n a entt fc o
Doc. 14

1 9

20 a gover m ent lentt , t e c ur m ust'dentf c gni abl cl i s ordi m i s t e com pl i t n a iy ' h o t ' ' i iy o z e a m ssh an ,

21 oranyporinoft e c mpl itit ecomplit ( )i fiol us,mal ius,orf i t stt a t o h o an ,f h an : 1 s rv o io c al o ae s 22 cli uponwhih r le maybegr nt d;or( )seek monet r r leffom a def ndantwho am c e if ae 2 s a y ei r e

2 i i m u efom s c r l f' 28 U, . , 1 1 A( ) 3 s m n r u h ei , e SC j 9 5 b.
24 I consi erng whet er t e pl i tf has st t d a cl i upon w hi h r l f can be n di hh an i f ae am c ei e

25 gr nt d,aI mat ralf ct alal gatons i t e com pl i tar accept d as tue f rpur oses ae I ei a u li e nh an e e ro p 26 ofi ii lr vi w and ar t be c nstued i t e I htmostf vor bl t t e pl i t#, See, . . n ta e e eo or nh i g a a e o h an i eg ,

2 Ru s lv. an r u, F.d 1 37, 03 ( t Ci. 9 0) Ho e er mer Ig l on lson 7 s el L d i 621 2 0 1 9 9h r 1 8 . w v , e e a c cu i s e
28 uns ppoded by any act alal gatons off ctar notassumed t be tue i r vi w ig t e u u li e a e o r nee n h

Dockets.Justia.com

1 c m pl i t A s cr f v, qbal o a n . h ot I t

U, . S

,129 S. t 1937,1949- 1 & 1 54,1 3 L. d. d 868 C. 5 9 7 E2

2 ( 00 ) Th ti,ba e,n k d an c n ls r a s rin t a me ey c n tu e f r uli 2 9 . a s r a e d o cu o y s e t s h t r l o si t o m a c o t
3 r ciatons of t e el m ent of a cause of ac i n and t at ar devoi off rher f ct al e ti h e s to h e d ut au 4 enhancementar notaccept d as tue and do n ts at a cf i f rr l f I . e e r o t e a m o ei . d e
5 Fur her t e f ct al l gatons m ust at a pl us bl cl i f rr l f m eani g t att e t , h a u al ei st e a i e am o e i e nhh

6 wel- l adedf c smustper it ecour t i f rmor t ant e mer possi ii ofmi c nduct lp e at m th to n e eh h e b ly t so :
7

8 9
1 0 11

(J c mplit mu t c q an s fce t f c u l mat r A o ao n s o t i j f in a t q n i tj ç a da tuyj c oat a.cyxlomtjreIefth ij uIe nt s re t st e s l m ol I ,; as as lO , j fc pBelAta c yp. acot l l ae e ce L j ,5 gS y ,5; jg yS y . . 4b 1
.

p uil ,hnt6 lEipe92cu,Acntaalil SCs951e ,ep .d d9d(0tacnathtfcs lt15 w94h 7Lnf l sa7/oti slF . . iy 7 1 a t2 2 f0) lm a a a bi t if q e o
t e c ur t dr w t e r asonabI I f r nce t att e def ndantI h o to q h e e nee hh e s I bl f qt e ml c nduct l ged.d.at i e q h so a al e / , 556,1 7 S. t 1955.The 2 C. gl usi lt s andar i notakl t a d gbabii r quiem ent'but a bly t l ds no ' pr ly e r t '

I a k f rmoe tq a s e rpo sblt tatadee d n h s t s s o r h n h e s l ly h i fn a i a
jce una f l .bl .W he e a c mplltpla sf cst a a e t d lw jl I d y r o qn e d a t h t r

1 2
1 3
1 4

m er l c nslt ntwihnM def ndants I bit ,i N t ps shod of çy o se t e ' l ly t s o ai t : Ipe bet een possi lt and pl us bit of jenttem entt hl w bly i a i ly i ll o

1 5

r l f' l. a 5 7 1 7 S, t 1 5 ( r c e somie ) el ,H d , t 5 , 2 C . 9 5 b a k t t d . e t ( qer t ewel- ladedf qt donotger it ecour W h eh lpe p? m th ' t t if l mor tan t e rer posslll of mlconduc te o ne eh h pe bly t s th
,. ..

1 6
l 8

IetlhsljF-.u CvPo. n(w thp dr 9mpltorlfeebRtaitsojj-tatelae s ntnt el.dduI solhwa2. e o ldaae, tl n rc8 ') ii ae e e h. h
Al gatons ofa pr se I i antar hel t I s sti gen s andar s t an ar f r al li e o ig t e d o e s rn t t dh e om

1 I bal 1 9 S. t at1949- 0. 7 q ,2 C. 5 1 pl adigs by lw yer . Hai es v Ker er 4O4 U. .519,520,92 S. t 594,596,30 L. d. d 9 en a s n . n, S C. E2

2 65 ( 9 2) 0 2 17 .
21 I t e compl i t pl i tf Kevi Scot Davi seek compensat r damages agai s nh a n , a n if n t s s oy nt
22 m uli l def n ant i t ei i di i ual tp e e d s n h r n v d and ofi i l fc a capaciy on m uli l c ai s arsi g f om hi t tp e l m in r s

2 crm i alpr secuton i LasVegas and hi det nton att e Cl r Count Det n i n Cent r 3 in o in s ei h ak y e to e. 24 The Cour addr s es each counti t r , t es n un
25 CountI

26

I Count1 pl i tf seek damages fom assst ntpubl def nderJason Tr ut , he n , a n if s r ia ie c a ht

2 Cl r Count PublcDef ndersOfie, Assit n Cl r Count Manager e#W el bas d 7 ak y ie ' f and c sa t a k y l le s
28 on al gat ns t at pl i tf was deni d efectve assi t nce of c unseli hi r centst t li eo h a n if e fi sa o n se ae
-

2-

1 crmi alpr ceedi g. The c m pl i t aleges t at pl i tl ent r d a pl a and has been in o n o an l h a ni ee e
2 s nt nc d. The com pl i tdoes notalege t att e convi ton has been overur ed . eee an l hh ci tn

3

Count 1does not pr s nt a cogni abl cl i under Sec i n 1983 under Hec v. ee z e am to k

4 Hu phry, 2U. , 77, 4S. t23 4, 29L. d.d 3 3( 9 4) Un e Hec , cai t at m e 51 S 4 11 C . 6 1 E 2 8 1 9 . d r k a l m h
5 neces arl i ples t e i val iy ofa s at cour convi ton m ay notbe cons der d i a ci i s i m i h n it y d te t ci ien vl

6 r hs a t n u ls an u t t ejdgme to c nvc in i ivaia e , ih pan i d e i t ci ne s d n i h u g o l n f o it s n l t d whc lit f o s o d f
7 notal ge and appar nty cannotal ge hasoccured wih r gar t t e r centc nviton. l e el l e r t e doh e o ci
8 Bec use t e cl i i not cogni abl i t e fr t i s ance,t e Cour has no occasi n t a h am s z e n h is n t h t oo 9 consi erw het erst t acton can be est blshed on t e cl i agai s t e assi t ntpubl d h ae i ai h am n th sa i c 1 def nderwho r pr sent d pl i tf and/ rw het er pl i t fhas al ged a sufi i ntf c ual 0 e ee e a n if o h an i f l e fc e a t

11 basi f rI biiy agai stt e r m ai i g def ndan s on Count1 so i l at n h e nn e t . 1 2 1 3 Count1 1 Count1spansei ht ensi gl - paced pagesandas ersa muliudeof l ged Ei ht 1 ge n es st tt al e gh

1 Amendmentcai sas ocit dwi pl itf sdet ntonat he Cl r Count Det ntonCent r 4 lm s a e t a n ir h ei t ak y ei e,
1 The counti cl des cl i s t atpl i tf w as deni d bai ort atexcessi e bai was r quied' 5 nu am h a n if e lh v l e r,

1 t athe was denid emer ency car f l w i g hi arest t athi pr scrpton m ediatons, 6h e g e o l n s r 'h o , s e ii ci 1 i cl di goxycodone, 7 nun Soma, ndXanax, econfscat ddurng i t k ' hathewasnot ven a wer ie i n a e, t gi
1 t e pr per m edi aton durng hi det xfcaton and w ihdr w alf om opi t s't at he w as 8h o ci i s o ii i ta r ae ,h

1 r quied t make up hi bed, and i a f od Ine and eatata di i g t bl whi under oi g 9ero s st no i nn a e l e gn 20 wihdr w alt athe was pl ced i puniie confnem enteven bef r r cei i g a wrt up' hat t a 'h , a n tv i o e e vn ie , t 21 he was moved t a di er ntuni t cr at space i t e medi aluni; hathe was onl gi en o #e to e e nh c tt yv
22 an EKG when he com pl i ed ofches pai ,headaches,passi g outand backII g and hi an tn n e p

23 pai ;t at hi s iur swer not agnosed and he was notpr vi ed pr perm ediaton' hat nh s ez e e di od o ci, t 24 pr perchannel wer noti pl ce f rr questng teat ent t athewasnoti f r ed ofx r y o se na oe i r m ;h no m -a 25 r suls;t at he agai was moved t a dif r n uni;t at t er was a l ck of pr per eth n o fe e t t h h e a o 26 adm i itaton ofmedi als r ies and gener ldi or aniaton't athe was notpr t c ed nsr i c e vc a s g z i ,h oe t

2 fom ij rn hms ld r gs iu e 'ha h wa mo edt as iiewa c c l t a h wa 7 r nu ig i ef u i ez r s, t e s v o ucd t h el h t e s n t ; 28 notpr vied a r commended CT scan't ata kt r gar ig awrstij r was n tpr pery od e ,h ie e d n i nu y ool
-

3-

1 r sponded t ; hathe was i pr pery deni d m et adone' hathe was notpr vi ed a pr per e ot mol e h , t od o

2 splntf rhi wrstij r ;hathewasdenidopit pai mediaton'hatt er wasno pol y i o s i nu y t e ae n ci, he t i c
3 i pl ce t pr t ctdet i ees fom abuse, n a o oe an r negl c and r ckl s ness' hat her w as no f low et e es , tte ol 4 t r ugh as t a spoti hi I ng s ow n on an x- ay; hatTyl nol3, hi h i cl des an opi t , ho o n su h rt e -w c nu ae 5 was notavai bl orwas notpr vi ed t hi atvarous pi cal ; hatbl od pr s ur checks le a od o m i l lt ls o es e 6 wer notpr vi ed as fequenty as or er d aferhe w as di gnosed w ih hyperensi n' hat e od r l de t a t t o, t 7 t er was no pol y i pl ce t ensur t at one doct rs or er c ul not be over i den he ina c o eh o' d s o d rd

8 wi outj s c use;t att e medialuniwast o col ;t att e shower wer to col;tat t h ut a hh c t o dh h s eo dh
9 bl od was dr w n f om i m at s on t e sam e t bl s fom whi h t ey at ; hatno exer i e w as o a rne h aer ch et cs

1 pr vi ed ; hatpl i tf w as unabl t go t chur h,s hool al ohol s anonym ous m eetngs 0 od t a n if eo o cc ,c i c i l ornar otcs anonym ous m eetngs,and t att e m edi aluni w as uns niar because si k 1 ci i hh c t a ty c 1 i m at s wer vom ii g and urnatng aI overt e uni. 2ne e tn ii I h t

1 3
1 4

Cou t1 i s be tt mutpede ii n is n 1s u j c o l l fce ce . i
Fis ,puti g t e bai cl i t one si e f rt e m om ent t e Ei ht Am endm entdoes rt tn h l am o doh ,h gh

1 notappl t cl i s br ughtby pr t i l ai ees r gar i g condii ns ofconfnem ent The 5 y o am o e ra det n e dn to i . 1 c ns iu i nalpr t ctons avai bl t det i ees r gar i g t ei condii ns ofconfnem ent 6 o tt to oe i l eo a an e dn h r to i 1 i s ead arse undert e Due Pr cess Cl use oft e Foureent Am endm ent al ough t e 7 nt i h o a h t h ,t h h 1 Foudeent Am endm ent pr vi es no I ss pr t cton t an t e Ei ht Am endm ent i t i 8 h od e oe i h h gh n hs

1 c nt x. See, . , Or gonAdv c c Centrt Mik,322 F.d 11 1, 12O ( t ci.2003) 9 o et eg, e oay et n 3 O1 9h r .
20 Sec nd,under LocalRul LS R 2- jpl i t; m ust use t e C our' r quied Secton o e 1 an i h ts e r i 21 1983 f r t s at hi cl i s,and he m ustf l w t e i s r ctons f rt atf r i doi g so. o m o t e s am o l h n tu i o o h om n n 22 The i st uc i ns cl ary st t , w ih t e f l w i g em phas s: H O U MAY ALLEG E THE n r to e l ae t h ol n o iY 23 V I LA TI N O F O N LY O N E CI I RI H T PER C O U N T . Pl i tf m ay not as he has done O O VL G ' a n if ' , 24 i Count I,asser m uli l c vi rght vi l tons underone count even i t ey al gedl al n I t tp e i l i s o a i , fh l e yl 25 arse under one cons iutonal am endm ent He i s ead m us ass r one c nstt tonal i tt i . nt t et o iu i 26 vi l ton per c unt o ai o, 27 Thid, r Count1 con ai s m uli l r f r nces diec i g t e r ader o ' ee'varous i t ke 1 tn tp e e e e r tn h e t s ' i na 28 r cor s, edi al ecor s, ies orot erm at ral .Pl i tf m ust at hi cons iutonal ai s e d m c r d kt h e i s a n if st e s tt i cl m
-

4-

1 w ihi t e body oft e c m pl i tis l w ihoutsuch gener lr f r nces t ot erdocum ent . tnh h o an tef t a eee oh s 2 The alegatons w ihi t e body of t e c m pl i t m ust s at a cl i . I t ey do not li tn h h o an te am f h ,

3 gener l ed r f r nces t ot erdocument wi notsave t e compl itfom di m isal ai z eee oh sl l h an r ss .
4 Fourh, ai tf m ust ak specii alegatonsast t e i vol em ent each def ndan t pl n if me fc l i oh n v of e t 5 wihi t e body oft e com pl i ton eac cl i . Repeat dl ,pl i t# r f r t a num berof tn h h an h am e y an i e e s o

6 def ndant wih r spec t a pariul rdat and t en i cl des specii al gatons as t an e ste to tc a e h nu fc l i e o
7 act orom i si n by onl one or possi l t o oft e def ndant . O n each cl i ,as t each so y by w h e s am o

8 def ndantsued on t atcl i ,pl i t; mustal ge speciialy whateach def ndantdi or e h am ani l e fc l e d
9 f i d t do t atcaused hi har wih r gar t t atcl i . al o e h m m t e doh am 1 0 Fit ,t e Cl r Count Det nton Cen eri nota vi bl def ndant The C l r Count fh h ak y ei ts ae e . ak y

1l Det nton Cent ri a bui ig.Plit; c nsuea nat r lperon oraj rdialper onsuch ei es ln d an i a ua s ui c s
1 as a cor or ton or a m uni i al y. He m ay notsue,however a bui i g ora c r ectonal 2 p ai cp i t , ln d or i

1 f ciiy,whih i notaj rdialperonsubectt sui. 3 al t cs ui c s jot
1 4 Si t ,t e bai cl i under Count 1 - whi h i assered agai st t e C l r Count xh h l am 1 cs t nh ak y

1 Det nton Cen er- t us i notassered agai s a vi bl def ndant Baii any eventi set 5 ei t hs t nt a e e . ln s
1 by a cour , by t e det nton cent r 6 t not h ei e. 1 7 Seven h,on pl i tf s m uliudi ous dif r nt cl i s r gar i g hi m edi alcar i t a n ir tn t fe e am e dn s c en 1 Count I,t e al gatons pr sent d f i t s at a cl i upon whi h r l f m ay be gr nt d , 8 Ih l i e e e al o t e am c ei e ae 1 Count 1 i pr sent d as a near dai di l of t e m edi alc r pr vi ed t pl i tf at t e 9 1s e e l a' y y h c ae o d o a n if h 20 f cit . Atvarous poi t i t e r c t l pl i tl assers sundr varatons oft e concl sor a ly i i n s n h e ia , a n i t y ii h uy

21 i cant ton:' elber t i di er nc t aserousmedi al n ai d i a e n # e e o D i c need and pai and suferng. Such n fi ' ' 2 t lsm ani r ciatonsoft eel m ent ofa cause ofactonf it st t a cl i f rr l f I bal 2 ai ce ti he s i a lo a e a m o e i . q , e 23 supr .Rat er i or ert st t acl i f rr leff r el er t i dif r nce t serousmedi al a h ,n d o a e a m o e i o d i a e n fe e b oi c 24 needs, ai tf m ust esentact al l gatonst ndi gt es ablsht at hedef ndantoii i l pl n if pr f u al e i e no t i ht e ca 2 knew ofand di r gar ed an exc s i e rskt i m at healh orsaf t . See, , . Si m ons F, 5 se d e sv i o n e t ey e g, m

26 Nav j Count, iona, ao y Arz

F.d 3

, 2010W L2509181, * (une23, at 4 J 2010) Theofiil . fca

27 b0t mustbe awar oft e f c sfom whi ht e if r nce ofan excessi e rskt i m at healh h e h at r c h nee v i on e t
28 orsaf t coul be dr w n, ey d a and he al o m us dr w t e i f r nce. I . I ot erwor s, pl i t; s t a h ne e dnh d a a ni
-

5-

1 mus s o tat h ofcal s 'a)s becieyawa e o t e s r usmedia n ed a d ( ) t h w h t e fii wa ( u j t l v r f h ei o cl e n b 2 f ied adequat l t r s ond. I . ( uotng proraut ort ,wih emphasi i orgi al. al ey o e p ' d , q i i ' h iy t s n in )
3 M edialmidi gnosi ,dif r nces i m edialopi i n,medi almal r c i e, c sa s fe e n c no c p a tc and negl ence i g
4 do notam oun t delber t i dif r nce. Seey . . M cG ucki ? Sm i , t o i a e n fe e e g, n , t 974 F. d 1050,1 59 h 2 0

5 ( t Ci.992) r v' on oter gr unds,W MX Tec . l c.v.Mier 1O4 F.d 11 3 ( t 9 h r1 , e d h o h,n l, l 3 3 9h 6 Ci.9 7)e ? nc ' nc e v W/, F.d24 , 4142 ( t Ci.98 ) r1 9 (r ba j Sa h z . d 891 2 0 2 - 9 h r1 9 . ,
7 The alegatons i Count 1 f i t s at a cl i i t i r gar . For ex m pl , li n 1 al o t e a m n hs e d ae
8 confscatng pr scrpton m edi aton, ii e ii c i especi l opi t s, r m a det i ee on bei g pl ced i t a l a e fo y an na no

9 a ji cea l do s n tvilt t e Co si t n. Nord e t e mer f c tata h al c r al l ry e o o ae h n t u i to osh e ath e t ae h
1 pr vi erdeni s opit st a det i ee who, 0 od e ae o an underpl i tf' own al gatons, cl aropi t a n ifs l i has e e ae
1l dependence i sues c nstt t del er t i dif r nce t a serous m edi al s o iu e i a e n fe e b o i c need - r gar l s - e de s 1 ofw het er anot er healh car pr vi er i si e orout i e of t e i stt ton pr s rbed t e 2 h h t e od nd sd h n iu i e ci h 1 opi t s. 3 ae 1 4 l t i sam e vei , any of he m edi alssues aleged i C ount1 ar l r el unr l t d. n hs nm t ci l n 1 e a g y e ae 15 Forexam pl , he f i r t pr vi e opi t m edi aton i unr l t d t a f i r t f low t r ugh e t al e o o d u ae c i s eae o a l e o ol h o u 1 wih a r c m m endaton t peror a CT s an as t a spoton pl i t fs I ng, Pl i tf shoul 6 t eo i o ïm c o an i u f a n if d

1 s tf rh t e s par t cl i s as t separ t aleged deni l of me i alc r i separ t 7 e o t h e a e am o ae l as dc a e n ae
1 count wihf ct al l gatonsfom whih t e above- escrbed i f r nc s c n be dr w n, 8 s t a u ale i r ch d i ne e e a a as 1 t each def ndantnamed i each count Pl i tf s oul f c son s atng a cl i ast each 9o e n . a n if h d o u ti am o 20 dif r ntmedialssue ast whi hhe seeksr l fr t ert an pr vi ig a mer chr nolgial fe e ci oc ei a h h e o dn e o oc
21 dai s m m ar o hi m edi alcar att e C l r C oun y D e enton C ent r lu y yf s c eh ak t ti e. 22 Countll I

23

CountIIcombi es t r e dif r ntc t gores ofcl i s. Pl i tf,agai ,mus asser 1 n h e fe e a e i am a n if n t t

24 one cons iutonalvi l ton percountand he may n tas er mulpl ci i rght vi l tons tt i oai o s t t e vl i s oa i i
25 underone count .

26

Fist pl i tfalegest atr m Nov m ber1 , r , a n if l h fo e 6 2007,hr ughM ar h 3O, to c 2009,t o J hn wo

27 Doe def ndant and def ndantAssst ntCl r Count ManagerJef W el vi l t d hi rght e s e ia ak y f l oae s i s 28 t due pr ces .He al gest att eydi so ever day t atpl i tf coul notI ave LasVegas o os l e hh d y h a n if d e
-

6-

1 due t a cour or er or erng hi t check i f r pr t i lsupew i i n once a week as a o td di mo n o e ra so

2 condii n ofhi r l ase fom cust dy due t t e al gedl wr ngl -i d char es i t e st t to s ee r o oh l e y o y fl e g n h ae 3 crm i alpr s cuton. Alegatons onl t at pl i tf had t r por t pr ti lsuper ii n in oe i li yh a n if o e t o e ra vs o
4 pur uantt a cour or er as a c ndii n of r l as do notst t a vi bl cl i as t t ese s o td o to ee e ae a e am oh 5 def ndant .Pl i t f l ges no per onal nvol em entbyW elsor he ot erdef ndant gi i g e s an i a l fe s iv lt h e s vn

6 rs t I biiy. Furher underHeck,pl i tf may notseekdamagesf ra cust di l estait ie o i l at t, a n if o o ar rn
7 pur uantt a st t c ur or ert athas notpr vi usl been setasi e. s o ae o t d h eo y d

8

Second,pl i tf i t e mai r ppat t e al gatons fom Count 1chal ngi g t e a n if n h ne sh l i e r l nh e

9 c m pet nc ofhi r pr sent ton by t e count publ def nders ofi e i hi st t crm i al o ey se e ai h y ie c ' fc n s a e i n 1 pr secuton. Fort e r asons di cussed as t Count 1 t es al gatons f i t s at a 0 o i he s o ,h e l i e al o t e 11 c gniabl cl i and ar bared by Heck. o z e am er 1 2 Thid,pl i t# seeks t r asser t e muliudi ous al gatons ofCoun 1 i gl bo r an i oe th tt n li e t 1n o 1 i st ad alo asa vi l ton oft e Due Pr cessCl use oft e Foureent Amendment W hi 3 ne s oa i h o a h th . l e
1 pl i tf t us seeks t pr pery i voke t e Foudeent Am endm ent r t er t an t e Ei ht 4 a n if h o o ln h h ah h h gh 1 Am endm ent t e i c r or t d alegatons f i t s at a cl i f r r l f f r t e r m ai i g 5 ,h n o p ae l i alo t e am o ei o h e n n e 1 r asons di cussed underCount I. 6e s I l 7 Accor i gl , he f r goi g c nsi er d as t t e C ount I hr ugh 11 t e c m pl i t i dn y t o e n o d e oh sto 1, h o a n w l l

1 b dimis d wi ou p eu ie,s bec t a op orunt t fl a amen e c mpa n 8 e s s e t t rj dc u j t o n p t i o i n h y e d d o lit
1 corec i g t e defci nci s i t e orgi al 9 r tn h ie e n h i n com pl i t t t e ext ntpos i l , a n ,o h e sbe

20 Moton f rTempor r and Pr lm i ar Ij nctve Relef io ay ei n y n u i i 21 l temot n( 1 )o at m p r r r sr iigor er n mot n( 1 )o ap ei ia y nh i # 2 f r e o a y e tann d a d i # 3 f r r l n r o o m 22 ijncin,pl itf seeks wie-angig t mpor r and pr lm iar ij nctve r l fas t nu to a n i f dr n e ay ei n y nu i e i e o
23 c ndii ns ofconfnem entnotatCl r Count D et nton Cen erbu i s ead atHi h Desed o to i ak y ei t tn t g

2 St t Pr on (Hih Des r'. He s ek a or er ltrai, r c ig ' DSP't p y frhs 4 ae i ' g s e t) ' e s n d ,h e l di t ' a en H oa o i
25 pos age and cop wor char es i chal ngi g al gedl iegal sci lnar char es agai st t yk gn lnl e e yl l di p i y g n

26 hi ;bari g t e i posii n ofany f rherdi ci l ar sanctons agai s pl i tf untlt e m rn h m to ut s pi y n i n t a n if i h
27 prson' dici lnar pr cedur sar decl r dI galr s r i i g ' DSP' r m char i g pl i tf i s s pi y o ee a e e ' e ta n n H , fo g n a n if 28 i anywayf rc pywor orpost ge asa r suloft ealegedl il gal sci lnar pr cedur s; n oo k a eth l y le di p i y o e
-

7-

1 r stai i g ' D S P'fom feezi g hi i m at account or erng f rherdi gnostc t s i g by e r nn ' H 'r r n sn e , ' d i ut a i e tn 2 m edi al per onnelout i e of t e prs n'or erng an i m edi t r fl of t e m edi atons c s sd h io , d i m a e e il h ci 3 pr scrbed pror t hi ar es ,i cl di g t e opi t s'or erng t athe be tanspored t t e ei i o s rtnu n h ae , d i h r t oh

4 out ie pai managementdoct rt atpr scrbed t e opi t s prort hi arest or erng t at sd n oh ei h ae i o s r ; d i h 5 hi pr scrptons be fl d by an ou si e phar acy untlarangem ent ar made f ra prson s e ii il e td m ir se o i 6 phar ac 'or eran appoi t entwih Cl r Count Soci lSer ies r gar i g hi medial m y, d nm t ak y a vc e d n s c
7 bil ;or erng an i m edi t tans erof pl i tf t a dif r ntcl ssii aton l veland t en, ls d i m ae r f a n if o fe e a fc i e h 8 afer hi m edi alt eat ent i sues ar r sol ed,t Sout er Deser Cor ectonalC en er t s crm s ee v o hn t ri t' ,

9 or erng t e r pl c m entoft o bl e shit t atpl itf had t ' odiy'due t t er bei g no d i h e ae wu rs h a n if o' f ' m oh e n 1 t i t paper and r i bur em ent of pl i t f f r t e char es f r t e shit ; or erng 0 ol e em s an i o h f g oh rs d i 11 r i bur em entofpl i tf f rt e t i tpapert athe had t buy att e prson s or ;or erng em s a n if o h o l e h o hi te d i 1 t atpl i tf be gi en diec physialaccess t t e prson I w Ibr r f rI galr sear h' 2h a n if v rt c oh i a i ay o e e c, 1 r s r i i g any t pe of ' ar ss ent't r ugh iegalcel sear hes or v r alor physial 3 e ta n n y h a m ' ho l l l c eb c
1 t r at 'r stai i g Corec i nalOfi erEverstfom ver al t r at ni g pl i tf orcom i g 4 h e s e r nn r to fc ir b l h e e n a n if y n 1 i t any t pe of cont ct w ih hi ;and r s r i i g ' D S P ' f om t y n t ' n l ence' t e 5 no y a tm e ta n n ' H 'r r i g o ' fu i 'h 1 m edi al r at entt atpl i tf r c i es wih s at m ent such as ' e' f ki g i, dnm at s ar 6 c te m h a n if e e v t te s h s a n t' ' 'i ee

1 notal wed t ese t pes ofmedi atons, and/ r' e' a dr g addit' 7 l o h y ci ' ' o hs u c. '

l 8 Plitfasserst at hasmovedf rem por r andpr l iar ij ncier l f' ow an if t h he ot ay ei n y nu tv ei n m e 1 onl becauseanoteri mat ( otaIw cer)t l pl it he mihtgethel t i way.#12, 9 y h n e n a l k od a ni ; g p hs '
20 at3,l es 9- 0, i n 1

21 2 2

The moton wilbe deni d f rs ver lr asons. i l e o e ae Fis ,t e c m pl itpr sen s cl i s agai stdef ndant i Cl r Count r gar i g rt h o a n e t a m n e s n ak y e dn

2 pl i tf' s at crm i alpr secuton i Cl r Count and t e c ndii ns ofhi confnem entat 3 an i s t e i n f o i n ak y h o to s i 24 Cl r Count Det nton Cent r The pl adi gs pr sent no cl i s r gar i g pl i tf s ak y ei e. en e am e dn a n ir 25 i car er ton atHi h Deser St t Prson, he hasnamed no def ndant i any capaciy n c ai g t a e i and e sn t
26 w ih r gar t t atf cit . The m er flng ofa c m pl i t pr s ntng som e cl i s agai st t e d o h a ly i e ii o an e e i am n

27 some def ndant as ofsome poiti tm e doesnotmak t i I wsui a cl arnghouse f ral e s n ni e hs a t ei ol
28
-

8-

l of aitfsdiput statmayars ter afer Plitlmaynotpurueamotonf rij ncie pl n ir s e h ie h e t . a ni s i o nu tv
2 r lefas t cl i s t atar notpr s nt d by t e pl adigs. ei o am h e ee e hen

3
4

Second,t ecompl iti anyeventseek monet r damages,notij nctve r l f h an n s ay nu i ei . e
Thid ,pl i tf has f ied t pr vi e t e verfcaton and cerii aton r quied under r a n if al o o d h ii i tc i e r f

5 Rue6 ( )1 o t eFed r l lso CiiPrc d r f rs ua c o at mp r r r sr iig l 5 b () fh e a Rue f vl o e u e o is n e f e o a y e tann
6 or erw ihoutbot notce t t e adv r e pary and an opporuniy t be hear . d t h i oh es t t to d 7 Fourh,pl i tf does notev n nam e a vi bl adver e paly i t e m otons t whom a t a n if e ae s ' nh t i o

8 t mpor r r sr iig or erand/ rpr l iar ijncin coul be dieced. Hih Deser e a y e tann d o ei n y nu to m d rt g t 9 St t Prs n i a corectonalfciiy,notavi bl def ndantt whom an ijncin may be ae io s ri al t ae e o nu to
1 diect d. 0 re

1l Fit ,plitf hasnotsat da col r bl cli ofir par bl ij r ast manyofhi fh an if te o a e a m re a e nu y o s 1 r quest f rij nctver l f Finga motonf rt mpor r ij ncie r l fbec useanot er 2e s o nu i ei . l ei i oe a y nu tv e i ea h 1 im ae toughtt atiwoul be agood ieadoesnotesabl h ir par bl ijr . 3 n th ht d d t i re a e nu y s 1 4 Sit ,heunderyigc mpl itcurentyi subec t dimisaloraiur t sat upon xh t l n o a n r l s j to s s f f l e o t e
1 w hi h r l fm ay be gr nt d. 5 c ei e ae 1 6 I TH ER EFO R E I O R D E R E D t att e Cl r ofC our shal fl t e com pl i t T S h h ek t li h e a n and t at h

1 t e compliti DI MI SED wihoutpr jdie f rf i r t st t a cli uponwhih r l f 7h an s S S t eu c o al e o a e am u c ei e 1 ma b gr ned,s bec t Ia e t a en wi i t it ( 0)d y o e ty o t i or e t 8 y e a t u j t o e v o m d t n hry 3 a s f n r f hs d r o h
1 c rectt e defci nces i t e compl it i pos i l . 9 or h ie i n h a n ,f s b e 20 I FURTHER I ORDERED t at on any such amended compl i tfl d,pl i tf shal T S h, an i e a n if l
21 c eary tte t e am ended c m pl i t as an am ended c m pl i t by pl ci g t e wor l l il h o an o an an h d 22 ' M E N D E D 'i m edi t l abov ' i i Ri ht Com pl i t on page 1 i t e cap i n and shal A 'm ae y e ' vl g s C a n' ' nh to l 23 pl ce t e dock t ah e num ber 2: 9- v- 2 1 6- C J- R L, , O c 0 9 R L above t e wor ' M EN D E D ' n t e space h d' A ih

2 f r' ase No. UnderLocal e LR 1 - anyamended c m pl i t ied mustbe compl t i 4 oC ' ' Rul 51 o a n fl ee n
25 isel w ihoutr f r nce t prorflngs. Thus,any alegatons,pari s,or r quest f r r l f tft eee o i ii li te e s o ei e

26 fom prorpaper t atar notc ri d f r ar i t e amended com pl i tno I ngerwilbe r i sh e a re o w d n h an o l 27 bef r t e Coud. oe h
28
-

9-

1 I FURTHER I ORDERED t atplitf smoton (/ 2)f rat m por f r sr iig T S h an ir i /1 o e ay e tann 2 or erand hi moton( 13)f ra pr lmiar ijncton bot ar DENI D. d s i# o e i n y nu i he E
3
5

The Cl r ofCoud shalpr vi e pl i tf wiha copyoft e compl itt get erw iht o ek l o d a n if t h an o h tw
I an am ended com pl i ti fl d i r sponse t t i or er,t e Cour wilscr en t e f a n s ie n e o hs d h tl e h

4 copi s ofa Sec i n 1983 c m pl i tf r and one copy oft e i stuc i ns f rsame. e to o an o m h n r to o 6 amended pl adi g bef r or erng any f rheracton i t i case. en oe d i ut i n hs
7 I pl i tf does not tm el m ai an am ended com pl i tt t e C l r f rfl g,a fnal f a n if iy l an o h e k o ii n i

8 jdgm entdimisigt i acton wilbe ener d.Ite amended complitdoes notc rect u s s n hs i l t e fh an or
9 t e defci nci s i en ii d i t i or erandot er ie does notst t acl i uponwhi h r lef h i e e d tfe n h s d h ws a e am c ei

1 may be gr nt d,asnaludgmentdimisig t i acin wilbe ent r d. 0 ae j s s n hs to l ee
1 1
12 l3 14 .

DATED:Thi 32 day ofAugust 2010. s ,

1 5
16
1 7 18 19 20

Unied St t t a

i t i tJudge s rc

22 23 24 25 26

28
-

10-